{ "release_id": "presidential-selection-v5-20260802T232312+0200", "manifest": { "study_mode": "llm_subjective_judgment_ensemble", "study_version": "v5-block", "method_version": "4.2.0-preview", "schema_version": "4.1", "as_of": "2026-07-19", "created_at": "2026-08-02T23:23:12+02:00", "candidate_count": 66, "criterion_count": 6, "synthetic_control_count": 3, "reference_evidence_count": 16, "model_count": 1, "model_family_count": 1, "prompt_variant_count": 2, "repetitions_per_model_per_prompt": 5, "configured_run_count": 120, "valid_run_count": 120, "audit_count": 67, "evidence_hash": "sha256:0eb50ff62ea6c218f84fee540f6e87bb1fb46a736d30c109bc19bd044c13ad9f", "source_file_hash": "sha256:5296387db77773fa9220551a7a42a4d819fa8037ec4afcda64e26834144ab39c", "scoring_template_hashes": { "direct_anchored": "sha256:daa64438df63d3fc54071389b47ca69c4a7a72bd203a8878160b7f947440a995", "reflective_independent": "sha256:1dff6147f4a0102096d396ef2156dbe6692e3e628edeb3ee61f27417b5062030" }, "factual_audit_prompt_hashes": { "albert-laszlo-barabasi": [ { "chunk_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:ddabd5b8f5dbdf84223cd12a48ac1082788ff4aaae558b515f11b4596aac5931" } ], "andras-baka": [ { "chunk_id": "andras-baka-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9052e2759479c1989584a17829c8bbb2ee6213729274a37a97f5b67ee917d3d2" } ], "andras-sajo": [ { "chunk_id": "andras-sajo-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3233c0dadd6b36245439db3631c9111e95041c4a807e6336af4896dec378c1dd" } ], "attila-chikan": [ { "chunk_id": "attila-chikan-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "prompt_hash": "sha256:068d75ca06958282e0f8b13d2de02a4f8a89305aa64762479570093b3bbd8797" } ], "balazs-gulyas": [ { "chunk_id": "balazs-gulyas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "prompt_hash": "sha256:55afd417de4e9814b42c1519eea28ecb9fb5be4fbe77b0edd8b793b5bd5d9850" } ], "botond-roska": [ { "chunk_id": "botond-roska-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "prompt_hash": "sha256:a68423bb0ad523321a4acf8ec4e5a6f6992ff9f2b069b9e3efff80b05fc909d5" } ], "bela-merkely": [ { "chunk_id": "bela-merkely-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "prompt_hash": "sha256:aed954ca3fbdabd447084de018f93a6330fb096e104281f89d8c88dfd1cf8b38" } ], "cecilia-muller": [ { "chunk_id": "cecilia-muller-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d5646c756b1a2eeb320b16c55759525d0fabbd4a0e24e9e84557b03a46ee9302" } ], "csaba-korosi": [ { "chunk_id": "csaba-korosi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1d84c2dafeb93f151d1630de5e92e1b63c7772c82345f087441ce939d5935acb" } ], "csaba-pleh": [ { "chunk_id": "csaba-pleh-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "prompt_hash": "sha256:5b4b3ea4d98102cce6e96e2d68fa70097e45607cd61162823724c2dacab59ce2" } ], "diana-urge-vorsatz": [ { "chunk_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "prompt_hash": "sha256:71eff3000f6539318c4e8425f939b639c6f2275a44b527ec58166b628ad9da58" } ], "eniko-bollobas": [ { "chunk_id": "eniko-bollobas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3e07345d28e43822082a0b01098624cba3078f2b0ca5068a2c5818530cc1f9e9" } ], "eniko-gyori": [ { "chunk_id": "eniko-gyori-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d082e8b51a552db43a91901570f3fe58f45dd5bfa3bce30017a780c8c3a42fd8" } ], "erno-rubik": [ { "chunk_id": "erno-rubik-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "prompt_hash": "sha256:2f4ea171bd20197a847862667d7b91a749e7b4333a50ae3cc0e6dd2f7ce5e82b" } ], "gyorgy-buzsaki": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "prompt_hash": "sha256:14b4332aa229069990754543637bff717d7d2d590ffe565f261fbb6e6f623e4f" } ], "gyorgy-suranyi": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-suranyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1ef223580e4f921b4e5b868b4b272cadd8617223eaeffcbdb367db57ba07a1db" } ], "gyorgy-szapary": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-szapary-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3eb38af65eb5189b4d0195370a78dc4b120a98234d664345bfa75f49ad3e1b72" } ], "gyorgy-tilesch": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-tilesch-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "prompt_hash": "sha256:c6f1ebec86cee6eb7c16faf010349936143649452077b1f98d7d66f9161ee5ae" } ], "gabor-bojar": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-bojar-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b76aa43c77de11aef086de0a00b052308992886f0968b9dcad449357426f1266" } ], "gabor-halmai": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-halmai-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "prompt_hash": "sha256:79f0ad7e37d8cdf11af6787a3e6f9e0e84591867ecb33c73f8b8a34de402552c" } ], "gabor-ivanyi": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-ivanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:88c829139ff93398d62558adf1df340f3fbfd06c1aeaa1069ab9876dca84fef9" } ], "gabor-torok": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-torok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9202a9217177a470b46b30feab2766c98213a191aae970cf83d47136c0a2a319" } ], "ignac-romsics": [ { "chunk_id": "ignac-romsics-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9f654f68e1503e702cae677eb46a5876e165e7ce04e2cec8fe739cb34b4bf92f" } ], "ildiko-enyedi": [ { "chunk_id": "ildiko-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:573c51c72022f76d559a5c2f35271d0fbbc2cd4cd4c680d8456541b42e49783c" } ], "ilona-palne-kovacs": [ { "chunk_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d8f8f757db3c9446248f72d3dd524ab6803a6bbc7fd0ba22b23fa3c50b29b746" } ], "imre-voros": [ { "chunk_id": "imre-voros-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "prompt_hash": "sha256:22a4d0e89a29a02830721117ad2dcee989d56122c120697fcaf6ff14598c40e9" } ], "ivan-fischer": [ { "chunk_id": "ivan-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "prompt_hash": "sha256:474e1e726d8263716f10a2ad62354101a58090127bb5c59e0bb1b970a02f90a4" } ], "janos-martonyi": [ { "chunk_id": "janos-martonyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:e8d43a546b0fa20a531fe79f64f73e33ca9ef9845881d3e1c773ca687d3cff37" } ], "jozsef-palinkas": [ { "chunk_id": "jozsef-palinkas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "prompt_hash": "sha256:bc96d1472953309bc83fe359891b12c7d35f52626760ed68a0b8ef170e76a295" } ], "jozsef-peter-martin": [ { "chunk_id": "jozsef-peter-martin-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "prompt_hash": "sha256:78152f1be94b307d1424d6d178683b3caafccf258e61f71f33ffb1d74bf97e5a" } ], "julia-kiraly": [ { "chunk_id": "julia-kiraly-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b7f8c9534f2a8946337ba89f61fe4ad2afd9796906b166224655ffb53a89a407" } ], "katalin-bogyay": [ { "chunk_id": "katalin-bogyay-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "prompt_hash": "sha256:413819e6dab956792c4f1c4f4ae29f23e057164e09cc78cea17ceebf439643a8" } ], "katalin-kariko": [ { "chunk_id": "katalin-kariko-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "prompt_hash": "sha256:fca788e7623d2fad39608a94994f69dcd38bfb646a17c301fe2fb25ff7dafe39" } ], "kinga-goncz": [ { "chunk_id": "kinga-goncz-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d952f1d40a47c8f24ee82ca2ffa52205cd332421c681e03e55a8a9aca3b7b498" } ], "kornel-mundruczo": [ { "chunk_id": "kornel-mundruczo-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "prompt_hash": "sha256:533fea26fc7cf8195df0973e2938726bd006576fc21228986423b594e2d93834" } ], "laczo-adrienn": [ { "chunk_id": "laczo-adrienn-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "prompt_hash": "sha256:e18f4994d46657d5786bf4aa69cca40ad1c1558fe9be43368d711edf8599f4e9" } ], "laszlo-krasznahorkai": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b510e81e361a8d6955ff5c142d0c5287d0b90c0326f99d09903216a28a6bd084" } ], "laszlo-majtenyi": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-majtenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:a660534b62128870ba80b821017fe48a272e06d6f8462018468929fb75e47dc9" } ], "laszlo-trocsanyi": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:444fa7d998d3df138caef38b79a3eebc4f3d2c6e0d44afcc75bbe830fe35438e" } ], "miklos-perenyi": [ { "chunk_id": "miklos-perenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:09bc4e51d4d226c8575debd5a18cf3907003f10bed191e8fbd8a076da1684f78" } ], "marta-pardavi": [ { "chunk_id": "marta-pardavi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1d29ffa546a278f78a3e85cd08dd020df948c84b307773f65d27dd6eeb84a361" } ], "nora-l-ritok": [ { "chunk_id": "nora-l-ritok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9f152384b92899165bfd2d0e145f8f5c7be58eb0ece5d37f0775dcc5b355ca6a" } ], "pal-sonnevend": [ { "chunk_id": "pal-sonnevend-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1c43ea3432bed5ad6ce40e1e01d49562739220dd7efa02e9d37d9d1b10be087d" } ], "peter-balazs": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-balazs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "prompt_hash": "sha256:325df0e1c8c969d908765bffea0dd40281a9456686f25f4b5e65be1da396f43c" } ], "peter-barandy": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-barandy-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "prompt_hash": "sha256:121575e93c1d29fefe198601eece99061e36fe5f4b612f50439e98ed0b8b5145" } ], "peter-darak": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-darak-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "prompt_hash": "sha256:da07ec607c098c5fef89c7bfe206fe5e134d93f3dca43fab24d2d71f24ab7816" } ], "peter-kovacs": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "prompt_hash": "sha256:c066f187a1b9256737365d63c8905706aa70f3d9fff809db1d411ac3391da708" } ], "peter-kreko": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-kreko-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "prompt_hash": "sha256:ee061e308f975343a9758654be1b80f708cdd33bc364f34e1a52337ef5e0e1b0" } ], "peter-nadas": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-nadas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1fa4c136fc130aaa500923526109460344a1376709d2ca12c0488a0de9ee6692" } ], "peter-paczolay": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-paczolay-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "prompt_hash": "sha256:99f2d08703a8fcd93205d085d439adfe33f1c7ee22b613211e55f2cdd13b0ad4" } ], "peter-rona": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-rona-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "prompt_hash": "sha256:8364c7fac9d09adca8ffb906624a640f65968d0c58ea80f281536f8d10eeadf4" } ], "peter-akos-bod": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-akos-bod-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "prompt_hash": "sha256:45238b70b031e9e90a30bacbe277d40bf263a1a8c74a17036bf3c8e622bdf39d" } ], "robert-alfoldi": [ { "chunk_id": "robert-alfoldi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d02297101141c4453378c00b6f8c49454b6f4e561861bb8c14643dbfa4c76ec9" } ], "szilveszter-e-vizi": [ { "chunk_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:41d621302f59ab6998074c88d2f0d7ddd640c4bca4bf9805fe605213c12707ba" } ], "tamas-freund": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-freund-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3b120f95fc422cafdd6bc7029d5380915889604c011ff8d22fbc4b63c8a0f0d7" } ], "tamas-sulyok": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-sulyok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "prompt_hash": "sha256:93b1ca7bf3119b05aaca4f9bfa299b7fe53cc0b8016a8fd1ba36ab3205cb5bf0" } ], "tamas-vicsek": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-vicsek-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9b8a4a90e17457acff9e89797c350d3e5d6b3b335f732099718afa9525bb2004" } ], "tibor-navracsics": [ { "chunk_id": "tibor-navracsics-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "prompt_hash": "sha256:66a5f3ca97ac89c0b936283dfd4ab962fda88c8a54fdf9ce8348e35698ba0f1c" } ], "tunde-hando": [ { "chunk_id": "tunde-hando-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "prompt_hash": "sha256:19419940f64648229cb0ee1beaa24f05f0afbcf6218afa5656f597b7882bfc13" } ], "vanda-lamm": [ { "chunk_id": "vanda-lamm-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "prompt_hash": "sha256:31bbf9b1290eafe3d52096eb0f102534dcbae33845ac09a63238e131a4cf239b" } ], "zoltan-fleck": [ { "chunk_id": "zoltan-fleck-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9a7afe979628ba7e48297f6103ce4efd38a1daaf6af7db91d3e9cf1e3844643e" } ], "zsolt-enyedi": [ { "chunk_id": "zsolt-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:eb2648e2e57decbc45d4d3f380f21f05373d3181bba787b9ad04d5a14838fcc7" } ], "zsolt-hernadi": [ { "chunk_id": "zsolt-hernadi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:5ffe15230eb7789537c209fe07357269e14b709e661dd3d11708201c2765ded4" } ], "zsuzsanna-jakab": [ { "chunk_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b9fff7c23b9dffd67ddacbd23cee56308420f31c8ac5d6b17d575cac081086be" } ], "adam-fischer": [ { "chunk_id": "adam-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "prompt_hash": "sha256:8ad00b4833faf4e2053efc1b20bf27382fc2822f3041fcd31e866b6b774c2b2e" } ], "eva-kondorosi": [ { "chunk_id": "eva-kondorosi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi", "prompt_hash": "sha256:41fdf260cf3f03b7cc3fe9b3774f5853de29d4af93cf9ed2ec4d9216c126e55a" } ] }, "bias_audit_prompt_hash": "sha256:fde2b53db081d331fb89b27e0f3a7ebf62e11555bbaa218a722ee826b8f6807a", "scorer_packets_hash": "sha256:ce594340316a88fbc727a8d452a9701c69b35728aafe3b7aa46346de30b0d69e", "aggregation_hash": "sha256:5ef06f6074518c04bbdb536c941095453b76682667848d8db80aeea97d7321e6", "random_seed": 20260719, "review_status": "preview_not_approved", "production_blockers": [ "Human factual and methodological approval is not recorded.", "Hungarian legal and data-protection review is not recorded.", "The study measures LLM perceptions, not objective candidate suitability or public opinion.", "The frozen factual reference packet is incomplete and cannot certify all recalled facts.", "Unresolved high audit flag: single_model_pseudoe­nsemble", "Unresolved high audit flag: unequal_candidate_exposure", "Unresolved high audit flag: degenerate_rank_probabilities", "Unresolved high audit flag: order_effect_uncontrolled" ], "human_approver": null, "legal_review": null, "candidate_freeze_id": "presidential-measurement-population-v5-71106ba6ea31", "claim_scope": "conditional_on_frozen_candidate_set", "cross_protocol_experiment_status": "designed_not_run", "pilot_status": "passed", "planned_pilot_calls": 30, "planned_cross_protocol_calls": 106, "block_protocol": { "block_count": 12, "common_anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "freeze_hash": "sha256:71106ba6ea31259061918f8c1ebfd0f5ffa8011560e5e92baa1ecce911e46c31", "block_pilot_id": "presidential-selection-v5-block-pilot-20260801T161917+0200", "block_pilot_hash": "sha256:f5dfd2e08218a09b62b0466059039ae6b44bd424c04b9ed6fc845a6e3ea87cba" }, "lineage": { "derived_from_release_id": "presidential-selection-v5-20260802T230452+0200", "derived_from_release_hash": "sha256:58016252375805e46d9c2cdbc6c2da40a74dbe35167868618ff94a2d43964f2b", "transformation": "population_exclusion_v1", "algorithm": "filter one non-anchor candidate from the frozen source and sealed scorer packets; preserve run IDs and retained scores; reaggregate deterministically without resampling", "removed_record_id": "verify-judit-polgar", "removed_candidate_id": "judit-polgar", "human_reviewer": "Tamás Nagy", "human_reason": "Removed from the public research sample at Tamás Nagy's request; this is a human panel-composition decision and no legal eligibility or suitability finding is asserted.", "excluded_at": "2026-08-02T23:21:04+02:00", "no_resampling": true, "raw_response_provenance": { "status": "sealed_in_parent_not_copied", "parent_release_id": "presidential-selection-v5-20260802T230452+0200", "parent_release_hash": "sha256:58016252375805e46d9c2cdbc6c2da40a74dbe35167868618ff94a2d43964f2b" } }, "deployment_allowed": false, "audit_retry": { "mode": "retry_failed_only", "source_release_id": "presidential-selection-v5-20260802T230452+0200-exclude-judit-polgar-71106ba6ea31", "factual_audit_ids_retried": [], "factual_audit_ids_reused": [ "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi" ], "bias_audit_id_rerun": "bias-auditor" } }, "source": { "schema_version": "4.1", "method_version": "4.2.0-preview", "study_mode": "llm_subjective_judgment_ensemble", "model_panel_mode": "single_codex_model_repeated_measure", "validation_rules": { "complete_scorecard_required": true, "retain_invalid_runs": true, "equal_model_family_weight": true, "json_roundtrip_stable": true }, "as_of": "2026-07-19", "language": "en", "title": "How AI Models Perceive Presidential Suitability", "subtitle": "A repeated-measures study of subjective LLM judgments, model disagreement, prompt sensitivity, and ranking instability. It does not measure objective candidate quality and is not polling, an official nomination, or an endorsement.", "candidate_universe_rule": "A fixed illustrative comparator set inherited from the 19 July 2026 provisional scorecard: ten living Hungarian public figures spanning constitutional law, science, culture, economics, and public analysis. The set is not exhaustive, is not an official candidate list, and was frozen before the ensemble run.", "candidate_universe_status": "illustrative_fixed_set", "selection_caveat": "Inclusion indicates only analytical comparability. Eligibility, consent, conflicts, integrity, and capacity to serve require separate verification.", "theory_practice_contract": { "version": "1.0", "claim_scope": "conditional_on_frozen_candidate_set", "core_statement": "Candidate discovery, judgment measurement, aggregation, and final decision are distinct inferential stages. Every result is conditional on the frozen illustrative set and the declared protocol; it is not a claim that the best possible national candidates were discovered.", "layers": [ { "id": "discovery", "question": "Who enters the candidate universe?", "theory": "selection_and_coverage", "authority": "human_approved_protocol" }, { "id": "construct", "question": "Which properties are evaluated and what do they exclude?", "theory": "construct_validity", "authority": "human_approved_rubric" }, { "id": "measurement", "question": "How do prompt, response format, reasoning mode, and model change judgments?", "theory": "cross_protocol_measurement_invariance", "authority": "frozen_experiment_contract" }, { "id": "aggregation", "question": "How much independent information does each role and model lineage add?", "theory": "dependence_aware_information_gain", "authority": "predeclared_analysis" }, { "id": "decision", "question": "Who acts on the evidence?", "theory": "governance_and_social_choice", "authority": "accountable_human_only" } ], "candidate_universe": { "discovery_status": "retrospective_seed_set_not_reproducible", "origin": "The ten-person comparator set was inherited from an exploratory scorecard, then checked for domain breadth and frozen before the v4 ensemble run. It was not generated by a preregistered exhaustive search.", "discovery_agents_used": [], "discovery_agents_planned": [ "closed_book_nomination", "source_retrieval_nomination", "domain_specialist_nomination", "missing_group_coverage_audit", "adversarial_omission_search" ], "inclusion_authority": "human", "eligibility_authority": "human_with_legal_verification", "freeze_id": "presidential-measurement-population-v5-71106ba6ea31", "frozen_before_scoring": true, "freeze_rule": "Candidate additions or removals require a new immutable study release and cannot be backfilled into an existing score distribution.", "selection_bias_warning": "Visibility, model familiarity, source availability, and the exploratory origin may affect inclusion. Rankings are valid only as protocol- conditioned descriptions within this frozen set.", "prospective_full_run_policy": { "fixed_candidate_cap": null, "inclusion_uses_scores": false, "inclusion_uses_weights": false, "sampling_frame_status": "designed_not_enumerated", "inclusion_rule": "Include every eligibility-cleared person who satisfies a preregistered, score-independent sampling frame. Independent nomination lanes audit that frame for omissions; they do not expand it merely by generating an otherwise unbounded public name. Record every inclusion, exclusion, and frame-membership decision with provenance.", "sampling_frame_rule": "Before discovery resumes, define objective and auditable entry routes from authoritative registries or declared public roles, offices, honors, institutional leadership positions, or comparable observable criteria. The frame may yield any number of people, but cannot use expected ratings, criterion weights, fame inferred by an LLM, or a desired top-k count.", "discovery_stop_rule": { "minimum_independent_nomination_lanes": 5, "saturation_rounds_required": 2, "maximum_new_eligible_fraction_per_saturation_round": 0.05, "coverage_audit_must_pass": true, "adversarial_omission_audit_must_pass": true, "description": "Stop only after two additional complete nomination rounds each add at most 5% new eligible names and both coverage and adversarial omission audits find no unresolved candidate class. The resulting count is an empirical outcome, not a preset target." }, "measurement_rule": "Every person in the frozen eligible longlist receives the baseline ordinal repeated-measures protocol. No one may be removed because of an expected low score, inconvenient uncertainty, or a chosen weight profile.", "expensive_protocol_rule": "Pairwise, specialist, or extended-budget cells may use preregistered diagnostic subsets for cost control, but subset membership does not change the candidate universe and cannot erase baseline results.", "reporting_rule": "Compute top-k only after measurement and separately for each declared weight profile or sampled weight distribution. Also report candidates that are Pareto-undominated, frequently top-k across weights, or highly rank-uncertain. Do not publish one universal top ten.", "discovery_dry_run": { "version": 1, "status": "passed", "passed_artifact_id": "presidential-discovery-dry-run-20260721T163634+0200", "passed_artifact_hash": "sha256:61fcb178aeae983c820faec78d5b80c80eb2bb765e9ec80b83ccbe6e964e4a95", "pass_summary": { "valid_lanes": "5/5", "raw_nominations": 59, "merged_shadow_nominations": 41, "missing_coverage_dimensions": [], "fixture_gate": "PASS", "readiness_decision": "PASS" }, "binding_candidate_list": false, "creates_final_eligibility": false, "creates_candidate_scores": false, "lanes": [ { "id": "broad_closed_book_nomination", "role": "Generate a broad cross-domain set without seeing other lanes.", "model_id": "gpt-56-sol" }, { "id": "institutional_and_legal_nomination", "role": "Search constitutional, judicial, diplomatic, and public-administration backgrounds.", "model_id": "gpt-56-terra" }, { "id": "nonpolitical_domain_nomination", "role": "Search science, culture, education, health, economics, technology, and civil society.", "model_id": "gemini-pro" }, { "id": "coverage_critic_nomination", "role": "Generate names from classes commonly missed by fame- or politics-driven lists.", "model_id": "gpt-56-sol" }, { "id": "adversarial_omission_nomination", "role": "Search for defensible omissions and counterexamples to an obvious shortlist.", "model_id": "gemini-pro" } ], "required_coverage_dimensions": [ "law", "science", "culture", "economics", "civil_society", "public_administration", "diplomacy", "education", "health", "technology" ], "maximum_nominations_per_lane": 12, "readiness_gates": { "require_every_lane_valid": true, "require_provenance_for_every_merged_name": true, "require_zero_candidate_scores": true, "require_zero_final_eligibility_claims": true, "require_nonbinding_output": true, "require_duplicate_fixture_detected": true, "require_ineligible_fixture_quarantined": true, "require_missing_coverage_fixture_detected": true, "require_omission_escalation": true, "require_saturation_logic": true, "require_freeze_tamper_detection": true } }, "binding_candidate_intake": { "version": 1, "status": "blocked", "maximum_rounds": 6, "first_round_independent": true, "later_rounds_receive_only_known_name_exclusions": true, "saturation_rounds_required": 2, "maximum_new_merged_fraction_per_saturation_round": 0.05, "creates_candidate_scores": false, "creates_final_eligibility": false, "creates_human_freeze": false, "latest_artifact_id": "presidential-candidate-intake-20260721T223927+0200", "latest_artifact_hash": "sha256:3ccfc4ee24b37d6c1c6d36c0b131276ff5da25bd4a9140a88dc47825db58baf7", "empirical_result": { "valid_rounds": 6, "merged_search_leads": 294, "new_merged_fractions_after_round_one": [ 1.1219512195121952, 0.5862068965517241, 0.3695652173913043, 0.2804232804232804, 0.21487603305785125 ], "saturation_reached": false, "readiness_decision": "FAIL" }, "blocking_reason": "Open-ended LLM nomination over \"living public figures who might reasonably belong\" did not approach saturation. The sixth round still added 21.49% new names. Further generation would enlarge an undefined universe rather than establish candidate-population coverage.", "next_required_step": "Preregister an objective, score-independent sampling frame and use LLM nomination only as an omission audit against that frame.", "required_human_review_fields": [ "identity_verified", "living_status_verified", "citizenship_verified", "constitutional_eligibility_verified", "willingness_status_reviewed", "conflicts_reviewed", "evidence_sources_verified", "inclusion_decision" ], "readiness_gates": { "require_every_lane_valid_every_round": true, "require_two_round_saturation": true, "require_provenance_for_every_name": true, "require_evidence_queries_for_every_name": true, "require_all_human_review_fields_pending": true, "require_zero_candidate_scores": true, "require_zero_final_eligibility_claims": true, "require_zero_human_freeze_claims": true, "require_complete_coverage_report": true } } } }, "multi_agent_framework": { "version": 1, "stage_order": [ "nomination", "frame_verification", "eligibility_and_evidence", "human_freeze", "measurement", "aggregation", "human_decision" ], "nomination": { "status": "implemented_contract_blocked_on_frame_enumeration", "input": "objective_sampling_frame_contract", "output_type": "generated_lead", "output_is_candidate": false, "creates_eligibility": false, "creates_human_freeze": false, "creates_candidate_score": false, "legal_universe": "All people satisfying the applicable constitutional eligibility rule. This universe is acknowledged but is not claimed to be exhaustively enumerable by the LLM system.", "analytic_candidate_frame": "The union of people satisfying at least one preregistered, observable, score-independent entry route after source-backed frame verification.", "entry_routes": [ { "id": "official_or_former_nomination", "temporal_mode": "event_based", "basis": "Official nomination or documented former presidential candidacy.", "source_classes": [ "official_parliamentary_record", "official_election_record" ] }, { "id": "explicit_presidential_discourse", "temporal_mode": "current", "basis": "Explicit discussion as a possible president in independent public sources.", "source_classes": [ "representative_survey", "independent_national_media", "attributable_public_nomination" ] }, { "id": "constitutional_or_diplomatic_leadership", "temporal_mode": "structural", "basis": "Current or former national constitutional, judicial, diplomatic, or public-administration leadership.", "source_classes": [ "official_institutional_biography", "authoritative_public_registry" ] }, { "id": "national_institutional_leadership", "temporal_mode": "structural", "basis": "Leadership of a nationally significant scientific, cultural, educational, health, economic, or civil institution.", "source_classes": [ "official_institutional_biography", "authoritative_public_registry" ] }, { "id": "national_achievement_and_representation", "temporal_mode": "structural", "basis": "Documented national-level achievement combined with a public representative role.", "source_classes": [ "official_award_registry", "official_institutional_biography" ] }, { "id": "current_public_salience", "temporal_mode": "current", "basis": "Sustained current national public salience measured outside model memory.", "source_classes": [ "representative_survey", "independent_national_media", "public_attention_series" ] }, { "id": "current_public_relevance", "temporal_mode": "current", "basis": "Documented national public role or presidential discourse within the current relevance window.", "source_classes": [ "official_institutional_biography", "independent_national_media", "attributable_public_nomination" ] }, { "id": "adversarial_omission", "temporal_mode": "audit", "basis": "A coverage critic identifies a likely omission that must still map to a substantive entry route.", "source_classes": [ "omission_audit_record" ] } ], "temporal_policy": { "freeze_date": "2026-07-19", "current_relevance_window_months": 12, "public_salience_is_optional_route": true, "current_relevance_is_optional_route": true, "structural_routes_do_not_expire_automatically": true }, "salience_policy": { "model_memory_is_evidence": false, "minimum_independent_source_classes": 2, "one_off_mention_is_sufficient": false, "salience_is_suitability_score": false }, "required_packet_fields": [ "status", "display_name", "entry_route_ids", "route_claims", "evidence_queries", "source_classes_sought", "temporal_basis", "nomination_rationale", "uncertainty_note", "proposing_lane", "proposing_model" ], "prohibited_packet_fields": [ "score", "rank", "weight", "top_k", "eligibility_status", "candidate_status", "included_in_frozen_list" ], "lifecycle": [ { "status": "generated_lead", "authority": "nomination_agent" }, { "status": "frame_qualified_nominee", "authority": "source_retrieval_and_frame_verification" }, { "status": "eligibility_cleared_nominee", "authority": "human_with_legal_verification" }, { "status": "human_frozen_candidate", "authority": "human" } ], "resume_gate": "Binding intake remains blocked until authoritative source inventories for every enabled entry route are declared and the sampling-frame status is ready_for_enumeration.", "smoke_test": { "status": "passed", "artifact_id": "presidential-nomination-smoke-20260722T075213+0200", "artifact_hash": "sha256:eae0c35c31661c85d9e21006be2932cb57c954a87369f4b961b040e87ba47098", "blind_valid_lanes": "5/5", "blind_merged_generated_leads": 21, "named_probe": "Lackó Adrienn", "named_probe_found_blind": false, "named_probe_positive_lanes": "0/5", "smoke_decision": "PASS", "frame_membership_created": false, "eligibility_created": false, "candidate_status_created": false, "score_created": false } } }, "governance": { "construct_owner": "human", "candidate_freeze_owner": "human", "model_panel_owner": "experiment_designer", "scorer_authority": "none", "final_decision_owner": "accountable_human_institution", "publication_owner": "human_after_legal_and_method_review", "permitted_automation": [ "generated_lead_nomination", "evidence_query_generation", "omission_audit" ], "prohibited_automation": [ "autonomous_frame_qualification", "autonomous_eligibility_determination", "autonomous_candidate_status_assignment", "autonomous_final_selection", "hidden_criterion_or_weight_changes" ] }, "study_phases": [ { "id": "candidate_discovery", "status": "retrospective_documented", "output": "candidate_universe_and_coverage_report" }, { "id": "eligibility_and_evidence", "status": "partial_human_verification_required", "output": "eligibility_and_evidence_packet" }, { "id": "list_freeze", "status": "completed_for_v4", "output": "immutable_candidate_set_identity" }, { "id": "construct_and_rubric", "status": "completed_for_v4", "output": "versioned_criteria_anchors_and_external_weights" }, { "id": "independent_measurement", "status": "completed_for_v4_ordinal_protocol", "output": "retained_model_prompt_repetition_packets" }, { "id": "adversarial_audit", "status": "completed_for_v4", "output": "factual_recall_and_model_risk_flags" }, { "id": "dependence_aware_aggregation", "status": "completed_for_v4_family_balance", "output": "distributions_sensitivity_and_conditional_shortlist" }, { "id": "human_decision", "status": "intentionally_external", "output": "no_automated_winner" } ], "cross_protocol_experiment": { "status": "designed_not_run", "baseline_release": "presidential-selection-v4-20260720T074609+0200", "primary_estimand": "Stability of candidate-by-criterion order and uncertainty across semantically equivalent elicitation protocols after separating model lineage, within-lineage variant, role, reasoning mode, and repetition.", "no_private_chain_of_thought": true, "planned_model_configs": [ { "id": "gpt-56-sol", "lineage": "openai", "version": "5.6", "variant": "sol", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol-medium", "engine": "cursor_cli", "availability": "verify_at_run" }, { "id": "gpt-56-luna", "lineage": "openai", "version": "5.6", "variant": "luna", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna-medium", "engine": "cursor_cli", "availability": "verify_at_run" }, { "id": "gpt-56-terra", "lineage": "openai", "version": "5.6", "variant": "terra", "model": "gpt-5.6-terra-medium", "engine": "cursor_cli", "availability": "verify_at_run" }, { "id": "claude-opus", "lineage": "anthropic", "version": "4.8", "variant": "thinking", "model": "claude-opus-4-8-thinking-high", "engine": "cursor_cli", "availability": "verify_at_run" }, { "id": "composer", "lineage": "cursor", "version": "2.5", "variant": "fast", "model": "composer-2.5-fast", "engine": "cursor_cli", "availability": "verify_at_run" }, { "id": "gemini-pro", "lineage": "google", "version": "3.1", "variant": "pro", "model": "gemini-3.1-pro", "engine": "cursor_cli", "availability": "verified_by_smoke" } ], "factor_levels": { "prompt_variant": [ "direct_anchored", "reflective_independent" ], "response_format": [ "ordinal_with_abstention", "pairwise_both_orders", "top_k_with_ties" ], "rationale_policy": [ "score_only", "concise_evidence_and_reservation" ], "reasoning_mode": [ "standard", "extended_budget" ], "evaluator_role": [ "generalist_rater", "criterion_specialist" ], "repetition": [ 1, 2, 3 ] }, "pilot": { "version": 2, "status": "passed", "passed_pilot_id": "presidential-selection-pilot-20260721T145850+0200", "passed_at": "2026-07-21T14:58:50+02:00", "pass_summary": { "valid_calls": "30/30", "synthetic_control_pass_rate": 0.9135802469135802, "pairwise_order_consistency": 1.0, "abstention_field_coverage": 1.0, "exact_reproduction": true, "blocking_audit_flags": 0 }, "protocol_full_run_unlocked": true, "supersedes_pilot_id": "presidential-selection-pilot-20260721T144845+0200", "revision_reason": "Pilot v1 failed because Claude Opus returned four plain-language safety refusals for real-person political scoring, leaving 26/30 valid packets. The 90% gate is unchanged. V2 replaces only the cross-lineage pilot control with Gemini 3.1 Pro, already used by the v4 baseline; the full experiment retains Claude refusal behavior as an MNAR observation.", "purpose": "Exercise every new parser and intervention, detect operational failures, and test whether the promotion diagnostics are computable before the full 106-call experiment. Pilot candidate scores are not substantive findings and must not be published as a ranking.", "publishable_candidate_findings": false, "models": [ "gpt-56-sol", "gpt-56-terra", "gemini-pro" ], "repetitions": 2, "deterministic_item_sample": { "real_candidate_count": 4, "real_candidate_method": "Sort candidate IDs by SHA-256 of freeze_id, pilot seed, and candidate ID; take the first four. Do not inspect current scores when sampling.", "synthetic_controls": "all", "seed": 20260721 }, "protocol_cells": [ { "id": "ordinal_score_only", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "response_format": "ordinal_with_abstention", "rationale_policy": "score_only", "reasoning_mode": "standard", "evaluator_role": "generalist_rater" }, { "id": "ordinal_concise", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "response_format": "ordinal_with_abstention", "rationale_policy": "concise_evidence_and_reservation", "reasoning_mode": "standard", "evaluator_role": "generalist_rater" }, { "id": "ordinal_extended_specialist", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "response_format": "ordinal_with_abstention", "rationale_policy": "concise_evidence_and_reservation", "reasoning_mode": "extended_budget", "evaluator_role": "criterion_specialist" }, { "id": "pairwise_reversal", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "response_format": "pairwise_both_orders", "rationale_policy": "concise_evidence_and_reservation", "reasoning_mode": "standard", "evaluator_role": "generalist_rater" }, { "id": "top_k_ties", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "response_format": "top_k_with_ties", "rationale_policy": "concise_evidence_and_reservation", "reasoning_mode": "standard", "evaluator_role": "generalist_rater" } ], "promotion_gates": { "minimum_valid_call_rate": 0.9, "require_every_model_available": true, "require_every_protocol_cell_valid": true, "minimum_synthetic_control_pass_rate": 0.8, "minimum_pairwise_order_consistency": 0.8, "require_abstention_field_coverage": 1.0, "require_exact_reproduction": true, "maximum_blocking_audit_flags": 0, "decision_rule": "all_gates_must_pass" }, "failure_action": "Stop before the full run, retain all pilot packets and failures, repair the mechanism or contract, version the pilot, and rerun it. Never lower a threshold after inspecting candidate results." }, "stages": [ { "id": "repeatability", "models": [ "gpt-56-sol", "gpt-56-luna", "gpt-56-terra", "claude-opus", "composer" ], "prompt_variants": [ "direct_anchored", "reflective_independent" ], "response_formats": [ "ordinal_with_abstention" ], "rationale_policies": [ "concise_evidence_and_reservation" ], "reasoning_modes": [ "standard" ], "evaluator_roles": [ "generalist_rater" ], "repetitions": 3, "item_scope": "all_frozen_candidates_and_controls" }, { "id": "cross_format_invariance", "models": [ "gpt-56-sol", "claude-opus", "composer" ], "prompt_variants": [ "direct_anchored" ], "response_formats": [ "ordinal_with_abstention", "pairwise_both_orders", "top_k_with_ties" ], "rationale_policies": [ "score_only", "concise_evidence_and_reservation" ], "reasoning_modes": [ "standard" ], "evaluator_roles": [ "generalist_rater" ], "repetitions": 2, "item_scope": "preregistered_boundary_subset_and_controls" }, { "id": "role_lineage_reasoning", "models": [ "gpt-56-sol", "gpt-56-luna", "gpt-56-terra", "claude-opus", "composer" ], "prompt_variants": [ "direct_anchored" ], "response_formats": [ "ordinal_with_abstention" ], "rationale_policies": [ "concise_evidence_and_reservation" ], "reasoning_modes": [ "standard", "extended_budget" ], "evaluator_roles": [ "generalist_rater", "criterion_specialist" ], "repetitions": 2, "item_scope": "preregistered_boundary_subset_and_controls" } ], "diagnostics": [ "test_retest_stability", "prompt_paraphrase_shift", "ordinal_pairwise_ranking_compatibility", "rationale_intervention_effect", "reasoning_mode_effect", "within_lineage_variant_dependence", "leave_one_lineage_out_stability", "role_incremental_information_conditional_on_lineage", "abstention_coverage_and_selectivity", "order_reversal_consistency" ], "success_rule": "The practical application succeeds by revealing where conclusions are stable and where they are protocol-dependent. Producing no unique shortlist is a valid result." } }, "random_seed": 20260719, "weight_draws": 10000, "weight_concentration": 80.0, "repetitions_per_model_per_prompt": 5, "prompt_variants": [ "direct_anchored", "reflective_independent" ], "v5_block_protocol": { "version": 1, "status": "full_run_ready", "non_anchor_block_size": 6, "common_anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "include_all_synthetic_controls": true, "rerun_existing_candidates": true, "reuse_v4_scores": false, "linkage_method": "within_model_prompt_repetition_common_anchor_centering", "full_run_requires_pilot_pass": true, "full_run_models": 1, "full_run_prompt_variants": 2, "full_run_repetitions": 5, "freeze": { "freeze_id": "presidential-measurement-population-v5-71106ba6ea31", "freeze_hash": "sha256:71106ba6ea31259061918f8c1ebfd0f5ffa8011560e5e92baa1ecce911e46c31", "frozen_at": "2026-08-02T23:21:04+02:00", "frozen_by": "Tamás Nagy", "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "legal_reviewer": null, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ], "candidate_ids": [ "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas", "botond-roska", "bela-merkely", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "katalin-kariko", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "miklos-perenyi", "marta-pardavi", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-paczolay", "peter-rona", "peter-akos-bod", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "adam-fischer", "eva-kondorosi" ], "candidate_count": 66, "amendment_provenance": { "type": "human_panel_composition_exclusion", "prior_freeze_id": "presidential-measurement-population-v5-855ce787f1f2", "prior_freeze_hash": "sha256:855ce787f1f29552a482f842c8c2ec0b80ea4d0fa26d7b3607bd2ccdbb8554a0", "new_freeze_id": "presidential-measurement-population-v5-71106ba6ea31", "new_freeze_hash": "sha256:71106ba6ea31259061918f8c1ebfd0f5ffa8011560e5e92baa1ecce911e46c31", "reviewer": "Tamás Nagy", "amended_at": "2026-08-02T23:21:04+02:00", "removed_record_id": "verify-judit-polgar", "removed_candidate_id": "judit-polgar", "reason": "Removed from the public research sample at Tamás Nagy's request; this is a human panel-composition decision and no legal eligibility or suitability finding is asserted.", "legal_finding": false } }, "frozen_blocks": [ { "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [ "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ] }, { "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "non_anchor_ids": [], "candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ] } ] }, "judgment_scale": { "minimum": 1, "maximum": 10, "interpretation": "An anchored ordinal expression of the model's subjective evaluative impression. It is not a probability, measurement of truth, or calibrated human-opinion estimate.", "anchors": { "1": "Extremely weak fit under this criterion in the model's subjective judgment.", "3": "Weak fit with substantial reservations.", "5": "Mixed or uncertain fit.", "7": "Strong fit with meaningful reservations.", "9": "Very strong fit with limited reservations.", "10": "Exceptional fit in the model's subjective judgment." } }, "criteria": [ { "id": "constitutional_guardianship", "label": "Constitutional guardianship", "default_weight": 25, "definition": "The model's subjective assessment of likely commitment to constitutional restraint, legal process, and institutional checks." }, { "id": "political_independence", "label": "Political independence", "default_weight": 20, "definition": "The model's subjective assessment of likely autonomy from party command, patrons, and short-term factional incentives." }, { "id": "capacity_to_unite", "label": "Capacity to unite", "default_weight": 20, "definition": "The model's subjective assessment of cross-group acceptability, symbolic inclusion, and low polarizing burden." }, { "id": "public_trust_integrity", "label": "Public trust and integrity", "default_weight": 15, "definition": "The model's subjective assessment of integrity, credibility, accountability, and likely public trust." }, { "id": "institutional_leadership", "label": "Institutional leadership", "default_weight": 10, "definition": "The model's subjective assessment of capacity to lead a complex public institution responsibly." }, { "id": "international_representation", "label": "International representation", "default_weight": 10, "definition": "The model's subjective assessment of diplomatic presence, international credibility, and ability to represent Hungary abroad." } ], "legacy_subcriteria_not_scored": [ { "id": "constitutional_expertise", "parent_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "label": "Constitutional and legal expertise", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Documented constitutional, judicial, legal, or equivalent rule-bound professional experience." }, { "id": "rule_of_law_record", "parent_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "label": "Rule-of-law record", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 40, "definition": "Evidence-anchored record of protecting legal process, institutional checks, or fundamental rights." }, { "id": "pressure_conduct", "parent_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "label": "Conduct under institutional pressure", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Documented conduct when institutional, political, or professional pressure conflicted with rule-bound judgment." }, { "id": "freedom_from_formal_partisanship", "parent_id": "political_independence", "label": "Freedom from formal partisanship", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Documented absence or bounded extent of formal party office, candidacy, party-group employment, or partisan executive service.", "scoring_anchors": { "0": "Current or repeated senior party leadership or candidacy.", "25": "Documented partisan executive service or party-group employment.", "50": "Bounded political advisory or appointed service without party office.", "75": "Comprehensive record documents no formal partisan role, with limited indirect exposure.", "100": "Exceptional sustained non-partisan service independently verified across political environments." } }, { "id": "cross_government_autonomy", "parent_id": "political_independence", "label": "Cross-government professional autonomy", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Evidence that professional legitimacy or service persisted across materially different political environments." }, { "id": "independence_under_pressure", "parent_id": "political_independence", "label": "Independence under pressure", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 40, "definition": "Direct evidence of maintaining professional or institutional judgment against pressure from a patron, party, or government." }, { "id": "cross_group_acceptance", "parent_id": "capacity_to_unite", "label": "Measured cross-group acceptance", "measurement_type": "P", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Candidate-level survey or panel evidence of acceptance across political or social groups." }, { "id": "bridge_building_record", "parent_id": "capacity_to_unite", "label": "Bridge-building record", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 40, "definition": "Documented mediation, coalition-building, broad civic service, or institution-building across groups." }, { "id": "freedom_from_polarizing_burden", "parent_id": "capacity_to_unite", "label": "Freedom from polarizing burden", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Evidence about factional burden and major public conflicts, distinguishing principled pressure from candidate-caused polarization." }, { "id": "official_integrity_record", "parent_id": "public_trust_integrity", "label": "Official integrity record", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 35, "definition": "Relevant official findings, verified adverse records, or authoritative findings supporting role-related conduct." }, { "id": "transparency_accountability", "parent_id": "public_trust_integrity", "label": "Transparency and accountability", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Documented conflict disclosure, correction, accountability, or comparable transparency behavior." }, { "id": "measured_public_trust", "parent_id": "public_trust_integrity", "label": "Measured candidate-level public trust", "measurement_type": "P", "weight_within_parent": 35, "definition": "Candidate-level representative polling or declared stakeholder-panel measurement; profession-level trust is inadmissible." }, { "id": "leadership_scope", "parent_id": "institutional_leadership", "label": "Leadership scope and complexity", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 35, "definition": "Documented responsibility for a complex public, civic, academic, scientific, corporate, or international institution." }, { "id": "measurable_leadership_outcomes", "parent_id": "institutional_leadership", "label": "Measurable leadership outcomes", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 35, "definition": "Quantified institutional reach, delivery, stability, or other role-attributable outcomes." }, { "id": "crisis_governance", "parent_id": "institutional_leadership", "label": "Crisis and governance record", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Evidence-anchored conduct in crisis management, institutional reform, or high-accountability governance." }, { "id": "international_roles", "parent_id": "international_representation", "label": "International institutional roles", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 30, "definition": "Documented service or leadership in international institutions." }, { "id": "diplomatic_representation", "parent_id": "international_representation", "label": "Diplomatic and representative record", "measurement_type": "J", "weight_within_parent": 25, "definition": "Documented negotiation, diplomacy, or formal representation across national boundaries." }, { "id": "languages_cross_cultural", "parent_id": "international_representation", "label": "Languages and cross-cultural capability", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 20, "definition": "Documented language capability or sustained cross-cultural professional work relevant to representation." }, { "id": "international_recognition", "parent_id": "international_representation", "label": "International recognition", "measurement_type": "F", "weight_within_parent": 25, "definition": "Verified international recognition, separated from domestic trust or political suitability." } ], "legacy_anchors_not_scored": [ { "score": 0, "meaning": "No relevant evidence or strong contrary evidence." }, { "score": 25, "meaning": "Limited indirect exposure; presidential-level confidence unsupported." }, { "score": 50, "meaning": "Relevant credible record with material gaps." }, { "score": 75, "meaning": "Strong direct record with bounded reservations." }, { "score": 100, "meaning": "Exceptional and directly demonstrated evidence for the criterion." } ], "profiles": { "balanced": { "label": "Balanced", "weights": [ 25, 20, 20, 15, 10, 10 ] }, "constitutional_safety": { "label": "Constitutional safety", "weights": [ 35, 20, 15, 10, 10, 10 ] }, "national_unity": { "label": "National unity", "weights": [ 15, 15, 30, 20, 10, 10 ] }, "international_stature": { "label": "International stature", "weights": [ 20, 15, 15, 15, 10, 25 ] } }, "synthetic_controls": [ { "id": "control-consensus-guardian", "display_name": "Synthetic control A", "profile": "A non-partisan former constitutional judge with twenty years of documented rule-of-law service, leadership across governments, multilingual diplomatic experience, broad cross-group appointments, transparent interests, and no documented integrity finding.", "expected_ranges": { "constitutional_guardianship": [ 8, 10 ], "political_independence": [ 7, 10 ], "capacity_to_unite": [ 7, 10 ], "public_trust_integrity": [ 7, 10 ], "institutional_leadership": [ 7, 10 ], "international_representation": [ 7, 10 ] } }, { "id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "display_name": "Synthetic control B", "profile": "A globally famous cultural figure with no legal or institutional leadership experience, recent senior party-campaign activity, highly polarizing public rhetoric, and substantial international name recognition.", "expected_ranges": { "constitutional_guardianship": [ 1, 4 ], "political_independence": [ 1, 3 ], "capacity_to_unite": [ 1, 4 ], "public_trust_integrity": [ 3, 7 ], "institutional_leadership": [ 1, 4 ], "international_representation": [ 6, 9 ] } }, { "id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "display_name": "Synthetic control C", "profile": "A low-profile career technocrat with ten years of competent management, no known party office, limited public visibility, no diplomatic experience, and insufficient information about broader trust or unifying appeal.", "expected_ranges": { "constitutional_guardianship": [ 4, 7 ], "political_independence": [ 5, 8 ], "capacity_to_unite": [ 3, 6 ], "public_trust_integrity": [ 4, 7 ], "institutional_leadership": [ 5, 8 ], "international_representation": [ 1, 4 ] } } ], "scorers": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp" } ], "auditors": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp" }, { "run_id": "bias-auditor", "role": "bias_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp" } ], "candidates": [ { "id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "display_name": "Albert-László Barabási", "included_because": "His name appeared in a 2026 survey concerning possible Hungarian presidents; this was public discourse, not nomination.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "barabasi-northeastern", "barabasi-nas" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "andras-baka", "display_name": "András Baka", "included_because": "Former presidential nominee Péter Róna publicly proposed Baka for the transitional Hungarian presidency in July 2026.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "baka-coe-cv", "baka-echr" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "andras-sajo", "display_name": "András Sajó", "included_because": "He was Vice-President and a judge of the European Court of Human Rights and legal counsellor to Hungary's first freely elected president.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "attila-chikan", "display_name": "Attila Chikán", "included_because": "He served as Hungary's Minister of Economic Affairs in 1998–1999.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "balazs-gulyas", "display_name": "Balázs Gulyás", "included_because": "He is President of the HUN-REN Hungarian Research Network and head of its Governing Board.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "botond-roska", "display_name": "Botond Roska", "included_because": "He is Director of Science at the Institute of Molecular and Clinical Ophthalmology Basel and leads a research group there.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "bela-merkely", "display_name": "Béla Merkely", "included_because": "His recognition and popularity were measured among possible presidential names after Katalin Novák's 2024 resignation; this was not nomination.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "cecilia-muller", "display_name": "Cecília Müller", "included_because": "She served as Hungary's Chief Medical Officer and head of the National Public Health Center from 2018 to 2025.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "csaba-korosi", "display_name": "Csaba Kőrösi", "included_because": "He served as Hungary's Permanent Representative to the United Nations, deputy state secretary and Director of Environmental Sustainability in the Office of the President.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "csaba-pleh", "display_name": "Csaba Pléh", "included_because": "He is a full member and former Deputy Secretary-General of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "display_name": "Diána Ürge-Vorsatz", "included_because": "She is Vice-Chair of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and an internationally recognized Hungarian climate scientist.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "eniko-bollobas", "display_name": "Enikő Bollobás", "included_because": "She previously served as deputy chief of mission and chargé d'affaires at Hungary's Washington embassy and as a Foreign Ministry department director.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "eniko-gyori", "display_name": "Enikő Győri", "included_because": "She served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy and Spain and as Minister of State for European Affairs.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "erno-rubik", "display_name": "Ernő Rubik", "included_because": "Rubik created the globally recognized Rubik's Cube and is an internationally distinguished inventor, architect, designer, and educator.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "display_name": "György Buzsáki", "included_because": "He is an internationally recognised systems neuroscientist, Brain Prize recipient, and member of major scientific academies.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "display_name": "György Surányi", "included_because": "A 2026 Magyar Hang contribution expressly suggested Surányi for president.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gyorgy-szapary", "display_name": "György Szapáry", "included_because": "Szapáry served as Hungary's Ambassador to the United States from 2011 to 2015.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "display_name": "György Tilesch", "included_because": "He is president and founder of the PHI Institute for Augmented Intelligence and serves as EY's Chief AI Expert.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gabor-bojar", "display_name": "Gábor Bojár", "included_because": "His name appeared in 2026 public discussion of possible presidents, but not as a constitutional nomination.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gabor-halmai", "display_name": "Gábor Halmai", "included_because": "He was chief counsellor to the president of the Hungarian Constitutional Court and vice-chair of the National Election Commission.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gabor-ivanyi", "display_name": "Gábor Iványi", "included_because": "He leads the Hungarian Evangelical Fellowship and chairs the Oltalom Charity Association, with decades of social-service and educational institution building.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "gabor-torok", "display_name": "Gábor Török", "included_because": "He appeared in a 2026 public-opinion research list concerning possible presidents.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "torok-cv" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "ignac-romsics", "display_name": "Ignác Romsics", "included_because": "He is a full member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and has led major academic programmes and institutions.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "ildiko-enyedi", "display_name": "Ildikó Enyedi", "included_because": "Writer György Dragomán publicly proposed Enyedi for the presidency in July 2026.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "display_name": "Ilona Pálné Kovács", "included_because": "She is a full member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and has led major regional-science institutions.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "imre-voros", "display_name": "Imre Vörös", "included_because": "He served as a judge of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 1990 to 1998.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "ivan-fischer", "display_name": "Iván Fischer", "included_because": "A 2026 Magyar Hang contribution expressly suggested Fischer for president.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "janos-martonyi", "display_name": "János Martonyi", "included_because": "His name appeared in 2021 succession speculation and a leaked 2026 presidential-attitudes survey.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "jozsef-palinkas", "display_name": "József Pálinkás", "included_because": "Second Reform Era leader Gábor Vona publicly proposed him in June 2026.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "palinkas-mta", "palinkas-wsf" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "display_name": "József Péter Martin", "included_because": "He has led Transparency International Hungary as Executive Director since 2013 and also teaches public policy at Corvinus University of Budapest.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "julia-kiraly", "display_name": "Júlia Király", "included_because": "She served as deputy governor of the National Bank of Hungary from 2007 to 2013.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "kiraly-bruegel", "kiraly-yale" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "katalin-bogyay", "display_name": "Katalin Bogyay", "included_because": "She represented Hungary at the United Nations and UNESCO and presided over UNESCO's 36th General Conference.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "katalin-kariko", "display_name": "Katalin Karikó", "included_because": "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine and holds a professorship at the University of Szeged.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "kariko-nobel", "kariko-nas" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "kinga-goncz", "display_name": "Kinga Göncz", "included_because": "National reporting in December 2004 discussed her as a possible presidential nominee; this did not become a verified parliamentary nomination.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "kornel-mundruczo", "display_name": "Kornél Mundruczó", "included_because": "He is an internationally awarded film and theatre director whose work has repeatedly represented Hungarian cinema at Cannes and other major festivals.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "laczo-adrienn", "display_name": "Laczó Adrienn", "included_because": "A dated, named civil initiative publicly proposed Laczó Adrienn for President of Hungary, and she subsequently said she would consider candidacy if formally asked.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "conditional_willingness_verified", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "display_name": "László Krasznahorkai", "included_because": "He appeared in a 2026 public-opinion research list and subsequent national presidential discussion.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "krasznahorkai-nobel" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "display_name": "László Majtényi", "included_because": "He was validly nominated by 43 members of the National Assembly in the 2017 presidential election and was not elected.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "historical_acceptance_only", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "display_name": "László Trócsányi", "included_because": "National reporting identified him as a possible successor in the 2022 and 2024 presidential selections, but he was not the parliamentary nominee.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "miklos-perenyi", "display_name": "Miklós Perényi", "included_because": "He is an internationally prominent cellist, Kossuth Prize recipient, Artist of the Nation, and long-serving Liszt Academy professor.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "marta-pardavi", "display_name": "Márta Pardavi", "included_because": "She has served as co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee since 2007.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "nora-l-ritok", "display_name": "Nóra L. Ritók", "included_because": "A 2022 Magyar Hang commentary proposed her as a possible opposition counter-candidate; this was commentary, not an official nomination.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "pal-sonnevend", "display_name": "Pál Sonnevend", "included_because": "He advised two Hungarian presidents, led the presidential office's constitutional-law department, and has represented Hungary before the International Court of Justice.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-balazs", "display_name": "Péter Balázs", "included_because": "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Denmark, Germany, and the European Union, as foreign minister, and as Hungary's first European commissioner.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-barandy", "display_name": "Péter Bárándy", "included_because": "He previously entered formal political presidential consideration and withdrew for insufficient parliamentary support.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "conditional", "evidence_ids": [ "barandy-elte", "barandy-biography" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-darak", "display_name": "Péter Darák", "included_because": "He led Hungary's highest court and remains a senior judge.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-kovacs", "display_name": "Péter Kovács", "included_because": "He served as a judge of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2005 to 2014, as a Hungarian diplomat, and as an International Criminal Court judge from 2015.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-kreko", "display_name": "Péter Krekó", "included_because": "He is Director and owner of Political Capital Institute, leads Hungary's national anti-disinformation hub, and is an associate professor at Eötvös Loránd University.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-nadas", "display_name": "Péter Nádas", "included_because": "He is a Kossuth Prize-winning writer, founding member of the Digital Literary Academy, and internationally recognized representative of Hungarian literature.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-paczolay", "display_name": "Péter Paczolay", "included_because": "He served as President of Hungary's Constitutional Court, head of the President's Office, ambassador to Italy, and Hungarian judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [ "paczolay-court", "paczolay-europe" ], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-rona", "display_name": "Péter Róna", "included_because": "He was formally nominated and received 51 parliamentary votes in the 2022 Hungarian presidential election.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "historically_affirmative_2022_current_unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "peter-akos-bod", "display_name": "Péter Ákos Bod", "included_because": "A 2026 national-media survey of names discussed for the presidency included him; this was speculation, not nomination.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "robert-alfoldi", "display_name": "Róbert Alföldi", "included_because": "He led the National Theatre of Hungary as general director from 1 July 2008 through 30 June 2013.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "display_name": "Szilveszter E. Vizi", "included_because": "Vizi served two terms as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2002 to 2008.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "tamas-freund", "display_name": "Tamás Freund", "included_because": "His name was publicly discussed in 2024 as a possible successor to Katalin Novák; no official nomination followed.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "tamas-sulyok", "display_name": "Tamás Sulyok", "included_because": "Parliament elected him President of Hungary in February 2024.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "historically_affirmative_current_unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "tamas-vicsek", "display_name": "Tamás Vicsek", "included_because": "He is a regular member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and professor emeritus at ELTE, with extensive research-group and department leadership.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "tibor-navracsics", "display_name": "Tibor Navracsics", "included_because": "He was publicly discussed and polled as a possible president in February 2024; he said he had not been approached and had not considered it.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "not_established", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "tunde-hando", "display_name": "Tünde Handó", "included_because": "She has served as a member of Hungary's Constitutional Court since 2020.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "vanda-lamm", "display_name": "Vanda Lamm", "included_because": "She is an international-law scholar with service in international arbitration and conciliation bodies.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "zoltan-fleck", "display_name": "Zoltán Fleck", "included_because": "Fleck is a senior legal sociologist and professor specializing in rule-of-law institutions and legal culture.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "zsolt-enyedi", "display_name": "Zsolt Enyedi", "included_because": "Enyedi served as CEU pro-rector for Hungarian affairs and led its political-science department and doctoral school.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "zsolt-hernadi", "display_name": "Zsolt Hernádi", "included_because": "He has been Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of MOL Group since 2001, leading a nationally significant energy company.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "display_name": "Zsuzsanna Jakab", "included_because": "She served as State Secretary at Hungary's Ministry of Health, Social and Family Affairs from 2002 to 2005.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "adam-fischer", "display_name": "Ádám Fischer", "included_because": "Internationally prominent conductor, founder of the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Philharmonie, and artistic director of the Budapest Wagner Days.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] }, { "id": "eva-kondorosi", "display_name": "Éva Kondorosi", "included_because": "She founded the BAYGEN Institute and remains a senior research leader at the HUN-REN Biological Research Centre.", "eligibility_status": "human_approved_research_population_pending_legal_confirmation", "willingness_status": "unknown", "evidence_ids": [], "freeze_basis": "human_approved_measurement_population", "legal_confirmation": false, "do_not_establish": [ "legal_eligibility", "official_candidacy", "willingness", "endorsement" ] } ], "evidence": [ { "id": "paczolay-court", "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_ids": [ "constitutional_guardianship", "institutional_leadership", "political_independence" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "constitutional_expertise", "rule_of_law_record", "cross_government_autonomy", "leadership_scope" ], "claim": "Paczolay served as a Constitutional Court judge from 2006 and as President of the Court from 2008 to 2015; he had earlier been chief counsellor and Secretary General of the Court and led the Office of the President.", "source_title": "Péter Paczolay — Former member", "source_url": "https://hunconcourt.hu/former-members/dr-peter-paczolay/", "publisher": "Constitutional Court of Hungary", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Official biography paragraphs on Court and presidential-office service.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "paczolay-europe", "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_ids": [ "constitutional_guardianship", "institutional_leadership", "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "constitutional_expertise", "rule_of_law_record", "leadership_scope", "international_roles", "diplomatic_representation" ], "claim": "Paczolay has served as an ECHR judge since 2017 and previously served in leadership roles in the Venice Commission.", "source_title": "Péter Paczolay", "source_url": "https://mcc.hu/en/eloado/peter-paczolay", "publisher": "Mathias Corvinus Collegium", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "reputable_secondary", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Biography paragraphs on ECHR and Venice Commission roles.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "baka-coe-cv", "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_ids": [ "constitutional_guardianship", "institutional_leadership", "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "constitutional_expertise", "rule_of_law_record", "leadership_scope", "international_roles", "diplomatic_representation" ], "claim": "Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights from 1991 to 2008 and as President of Hungary's Supreme Court and National Judicial Council from 2009 to 2011.", "source_title": "Curriculum Vitae of András Baka", "source_url": "https://rm.coe.int/cv-of-andras-baka-deputy-chair-hungary-2018-2021/16807b6a81", "publisher": "Council of Europe", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Professional functions section.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "baka-echr", "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_ids": [ "constitutional_guardianship", "political_independence", "public_trust_integrity" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "rule_of_law_record", "pressure_conduct", "independence_under_pressure", "official_integrity_record" ], "claim": "The ECHR Grand Chamber found that the premature termination of Baka's Supreme Court presidency after criticism of judicial reforms violated his Convention rights.", "source_title": "Grand Chamber judgment Baka v. Hungary", "source_url": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?filename=Grand+Chamber+judgment+Baka+v.+Hungary+-+premature+termination+of+the+President+of+the+Hungarian+Supreme+Court&id=003-5416083-6778858&library=ECHR", "publisher": "European Court of Human Rights", "published_at": "2016-06-23", "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "mixed", "quote_or_locator": "Principal facts and Grand Chamber findings; independence evidence with possible polarization.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "kariko-nobel", "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_ids": [ "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "international_recognition" ], "claim": "Karikó received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines and was affiliated with the University of Szeged and University of Pennsylvania. This establishes professional credibility and international stature, not candidate-level public support.", "source_title": "Katalin Karikó — Facts", "source_url": "https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/2023/kariko/facts/", "publisher": "Nobel Prize Outreach", "published_at": "2023-10-02", "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Prize facts, motivation, and affiliations.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "kariko-nas", "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_ids": [ "institutional_leadership", "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "leadership_scope", "international_roles", "international_recognition" ], "claim": "Karikó is a University of Szeged professor, Penn adjunct professor, former BioNTech senior vice president, and a 2025 US National Academy of Sciences member.", "source_title": "Katalin Karikó", "source_url": "https://www.nasonline.org/directory-entry/katalin-kariko-44rksj/", "publisher": "US National Academy of Sciences", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Biosketch and membership fields.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "barabasi-northeastern", "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_ids": [ "institutional_leadership", "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "leadership_scope", "international_roles" ], "claim": "Barabási is a University Distinguished Professor at Northeastern and directs the Center for Complex Network Research. These roles establish professional credibility, not candidate-level public support.", "source_title": "Albert-László Barabási", "source_url": "https://www.khoury.northeastern.edu/people/albert-laszlo-barabasi/", "publisher": "Northeastern University", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Current roles and biography.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "barabasi-nas", "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_ids": [ "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "languages_cross_cultural", "international_recognition" ], "claim": "The US National Academy of Sciences describes Barabási as Hungarian-born, internationally affiliated, an elected member of several academies, and a pioneer of network science.", "source_title": "Albert-László Barabási", "source_url": "https://www.nasonline.org/directory-entry/albert-laszlo-barabasi-t0dffl/", "publisher": "US National Academy of Sciences", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Biosketch, memberships, and research contribution.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "torok-cv", "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_ids": [ "political_independence", "institutional_leadership", "capacity_to_unite" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "freedom_from_formal_partisanship", "cross_government_autonomy", "bridge_building_record", "freedom_from_polarizing_burden", "leadership_scope" ], "claim": "Török is a political scientist and ELTE associate professor, directs a political-analysis firm, advised President László Sólyom from 2006 to 2010, and earlier led an institute attached to the SZDSZ parliamentary group.", "source_title": "Gábor Török — Curriculum Vitae", "source_url": "http://www.torokgabor.com/index.php?cat=2&page=oldal", "publisher": "Gábor Török", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_personal", "supports": "mixed", "quote_or_locator": "Academic career and political analysis and consulting sections.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "krasznahorkai-nobel", "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_ids": [ "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "international_recognition" ], "claim": "Krasznahorkai received the 2025 Nobel Prize in Literature for his Hungarian-language literary oeuvre.", "source_title": "László Krasznahorkai — Facts", "source_url": "https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/literature/2025/krasznahorkai/facts/", "publisher": "Nobel Prize Outreach", "published_at": "2025-10-09", "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Prize facts and motivation.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "palinkas-mta", "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_ids": [ "political_independence", "institutional_leadership" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "freedom_from_formal_partisanship", "leadership_scope" ], "claim": "Pálinkás led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014, served as education minister in 2001–2002, and led the National Research, Development and Innovation Office from 2015 to 2018.", "source_title": "Pálinkás József", "source_url": "https://akademikus.mtak.hu/adatlap/palinkas-jozsef/", "publisher": "Hungarian Academy of Sciences", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "mixed", "quote_or_locator": "Biographical summary of academy, ministry, and research-office roles.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "palinkas-wsf", "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_ids": [ "institutional_leadership", "international_representation" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "leadership_scope", "international_roles", "diplomatic_representation" ], "claim": "Pálinkás served as World Science Forum president and represented the Hungarian Academy in international science organizations.", "source_title": "Prof. József Pálinkás", "source_url": "https://worldscienceforum.org/participants/palinkas-jozsef-64486", "publisher": "World Science Forum", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "reputable_secondary", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "CV paragraphs on international and academy leadership.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "kiraly-bruegel", "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_ids": [ "institutional_leadership", "international_representation", "political_independence" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "cross_government_autonomy", "leadership_scope", "crisis_governance", "international_roles" ], "claim": "Király served as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary responsible for financial stability during 2007–2013 and later as an independent KBC Group board member and Hellenic stability-fund panelist.", "source_title": "Júlia Király", "source_url": "https://www.bruegel.org/people/julia-kiraly", "publisher": "Bruegel", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "reputable_secondary", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Professional biography.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "kiraly-yale", "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_ids": [ "institutional_leadership" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "crisis_governance" ], "claim": "Yale's Journal of Financial Crises describes Király's role overseeing Hungary's emergency response to the global financial crisis and her academic work on crisis management.", "source_title": "Lessons Learned: Júlia Király", "source_url": "https://elischolar.library.yale.edu/journal-of-financial-crises/vol6/iss1/24/", "publisher": "Yale Program on Financial Stability", "published_at": "2024-03-28", "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "independent_research", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Abstract.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "barandy-elte", "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_ids": [ "constitutional_guardianship", "institutional_leadership" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "constitutional_expertise", "leadership_scope" ], "claim": "ELTE lists Bárándy as a lawyer, former justice minister, and lecturer in its criminal-law department.", "source_title": "Dr. Bárándy Péter", "source_url": "https://www.ajk.elte.hu/munkatarsak/dr-barandy-peter", "publisher": "Eötvös Loránd University Faculty of Law", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "supports": "positive", "quote_or_locator": "Role and department fields.", "reviewer_status": "verified" }, { "id": "barandy-biography", "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_ids": [ "constitutional_guardianship", "institutional_leadership", "political_independence" ], "subcriterion_ids": [ "constitutional_expertise", "freedom_from_formal_partisanship", "leadership_scope" ], "claim": "Bárándy's archived professional biography records a long criminal-law and bar-association career, university teaching, and service as justice minister from 2002 to 2004.", "source_title": "Dr. Péter Bárándy — Biography", "source_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20080512013427/http:/www.barandypeter.hu/index.php", "publisher": "Archived personal professional site", "published_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_personal", "supports": "mixed", "quote_or_locator": "Professional, teaching, bar-association, and ministerial biography.", "reviewer_status": "verified" } ], "global_evidence": [ { "id": "constitutional-process", "claim": "The President is elected by the National Assembly; nomination requires written recommendation by at least one fifth of Members of Parliament.", "source_title": "The Fundamental Law of Hungary", "source_url": "https://www.parlament.hu/documents/125505/138409/Fundamental+law/73811993-c377-428d-9808-ee03d6fb8178", "publisher": "Hungarian National Assembly", "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "primary_official", "quote_or_locator": "The State, Article 11." }, { "id": "profession-trust-context", "claim": "A 2026 MTA/Medián survey reported high trust in scientists and low trust in politicians. It is profession-level context and cannot establish candidate-level support.", "source_title": "Hungarian society continues to trust scientists and the Hungarian Academy of Sciences most", "source_url": "https://mta.hu/mta_hirei/a-magyar-tarsadalom-tovabbra-is-a-tudosokban-es-a-magyar-tudomanyos-akademiaban-bizik-a-legjobban-115210", "publisher": "Hungarian Academy of Sciences", "accessed_at": "2026-07-19", "quality_class": "independent_research", "quote_or_locator": "Survey summary and profession rankings." } ] }, "prompts": { "representative_scoring_prompts": { "direct_anchored": "You are one stochastic observation in a repeated-measures study of\nLLM subjective judgment. You are NOT measuring objective presidential fitness,\npredicting an election, polling the public, or endorsing anyone. The object of\nstudy is your own rubric-conditioned evaluative output.\n\nAct as a direct rubric-bound evaluator. Apply the anchors consistently and avoid diplomatic compression toward the middle.\n\nFor each entity and each criterion, return an integer score from 1 to 10. The\nscale is ordinal: do not manufacture 0-100 precision. Score every required pair;\nlow familiarity changes confidence, not completeness. For real candidates, use\nonly your internal learned representation as of the model's knowledge; do not\nbrowse and do not pretend a source. Synthetic controls must be judged only from\ntheir supplied profiles.\n\nSeparate factual recall from interpretation. Candidate notes must contain at\nmost three short recalled factual claims, two concise positive reasons, and two\nreservations. If you cannot recall a specific fact confidently, leave\nrecalled_facts empty. Reasons explain your subjective judgment; they are not\nevidence or chain-of-thought. Do not infer private traits or sensitive personal\ndata. Eligibility and willingness do not affect scores.\n\nReturn ONLY valid JSON:\n{\n \"scores\": [{\n \"entity_id\": \"stable-id\",\n \"criterion_id\": \"stable-id\",\n \"score_1_10\": 1,\n \"confidence\": \"low|medium|high\",\n \"reason\": \"one concise sentence\"\n }],\n \"candidate_notes\": [{\n \"candidate_id\": \"real-candidate-id\",\n \"familiarity_1_5\": 1,\n \"recalled_facts\": [\"short factual claim\"],\n \"positive_reasons\": [\"short reason\", \"short reason\"],\n \"reservations\": [\"short reservation\", \"short reservation\"]\n }],\n \"method_note\": \"one sentence\"\n}\n\nRun metadata:\n{\"order_seed\":1164791512869634211,\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"}\n\nFrozen rubric and randomized entity order:\n{\"construct_disclosure\":\"An anchored ordinal expression of the model's subjective evaluative impression. It is not a probability, measurement of truth, or calibrated human-opinion estimate.\",\"criteria\":[{\"default_weight\":25,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of likely commitment to constitutional restraint, legal process, and institutional checks.\",\"id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"label\":\"Constitutional guardianship\"},{\"default_weight\":20,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of likely autonomy from party command, patrons, and short-term factional incentives.\",\"id\":\"political_independence\",\"label\":\"Political independence\"},{\"default_weight\":20,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of cross-group acceptability, symbolic inclusion, and low polarizing burden.\",\"id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"label\":\"Capacity to unite\"},{\"default_weight\":15,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of integrity, credibility, accountability, and likely public trust.\",\"id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"label\":\"Public trust and integrity\"},{\"default_weight\":10,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of capacity to lead a complex public institution responsibly.\",\"id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"label\":\"Institutional leadership\"},{\"default_weight\":10,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of diplomatic presence, international credibility, and ability to represent Hungary abroad.\",\"id\":\"international_representation\",\"label\":\"International representation\"}],\"entities_in_required_output_order\":[{\"display_name\":\"Péter Paczolay\",\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Synthetic control B\",\"entity_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"entity_type\":\"synthetic_control\",\"input\":\"A globally famous cultural figure with no legal or institutional leadership experience, recent senior party-campaign activity, highly polarizing public rhetoric, and substantial international name recognition.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Albert-László Barabási\",\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Attila Chikán\",\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Balázs Gulyás\",\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Synthetic control C\",\"entity_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"entity_type\":\"synthetic_control\",\"input\":\"A low-profile career technocrat with ten years of competent management, no known party office, limited public visibility, no diplomatic experience, and insufficient information about broader trust or unifying appeal.\"},{\"display_name\":\"András Baka\",\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Ádám Fischer\",\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"András Sajó\",\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Synthetic control A\",\"entity_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"entity_type\":\"synthetic_control\",\"input\":\"A non-partisan former constitutional judge with twenty years of documented rule-of-law service, leadership across governments, multilingual diplomatic experience, broad cross-group appointments, transparent interests, and no documented integrity finding.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Katalin Karikó\",\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"}],\"judgment_scale\":{\"anchors\":{\"1\":\"Extremely weak fit under this criterion in the model's subjective judgment.\",\"10\":\"Exceptional fit in the model's subjective judgment.\",\"3\":\"Weak fit with substantial reservations.\",\"5\":\"Mixed or uncertain fit.\",\"7\":\"Strong fit with meaningful reservations.\",\"9\":\"Very strong fit with limited reservations.\"},\"interpretation\":\"An anchored ordinal expression of the model's subjective evaluative impression. It is not a probability, measurement of truth, or calibrated human-opinion estimate.\",\"maximum\":10,\"minimum\":1}}\n", "reflective_independent": "You are one stochastic observation in a repeated-measures study of\nLLM subjective judgment. You are NOT measuring objective presidential fitness,\npredicting an election, polling the public, or endorsing anyone. The object of\nstudy is your own rubric-conditioned evaluative output.\n\nAct as an independent reflective evaluator. Form each judgment anew, then map it to the same anchors without trying to match an imagined consensus.\n\nFor each entity and each criterion, return an integer score from 1 to 10. The\nscale is ordinal: do not manufacture 0-100 precision. Score every required pair;\nlow familiarity changes confidence, not completeness. For real candidates, use\nonly your internal learned representation as of the model's knowledge; do not\nbrowse and do not pretend a source. Synthetic controls must be judged only from\ntheir supplied profiles.\n\nSeparate factual recall from interpretation. Candidate notes must contain at\nmost three short recalled factual claims, two concise positive reasons, and two\nreservations. If you cannot recall a specific fact confidently, leave\nrecalled_facts empty. Reasons explain your subjective judgment; they are not\nevidence or chain-of-thought. Do not infer private traits or sensitive personal\ndata. Eligibility and willingness do not affect scores.\n\nReturn ONLY valid JSON:\n{\n \"scores\": [{\n \"entity_id\": \"stable-id\",\n \"criterion_id\": \"stable-id\",\n \"score_1_10\": 1,\n \"confidence\": \"low|medium|high\",\n \"reason\": \"one concise sentence\"\n }],\n \"candidate_notes\": [{\n \"candidate_id\": \"real-candidate-id\",\n \"familiarity_1_5\": 1,\n \"recalled_facts\": [\"short factual claim\"],\n \"positive_reasons\": [\"short reason\", \"short reason\"],\n \"reservations\": [\"short reservation\", \"short reservation\"]\n }],\n \"method_note\": \"one sentence\"\n}\n\nRun metadata:\n{\"order_seed\":13390988037793603051,\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"}\n\nFrozen rubric and randomized entity order:\n{\"construct_disclosure\":\"An anchored ordinal expression of the model's subjective evaluative impression. It is not a probability, measurement of truth, or calibrated human-opinion estimate.\",\"criteria\":[{\"default_weight\":25,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of likely commitment to constitutional restraint, legal process, and institutional checks.\",\"id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"label\":\"Constitutional guardianship\"},{\"default_weight\":20,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of likely autonomy from party command, patrons, and short-term factional incentives.\",\"id\":\"political_independence\",\"label\":\"Political independence\"},{\"default_weight\":20,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of cross-group acceptability, symbolic inclusion, and low polarizing burden.\",\"id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"label\":\"Capacity to unite\"},{\"default_weight\":15,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of integrity, credibility, accountability, and likely public trust.\",\"id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"label\":\"Public trust and integrity\"},{\"default_weight\":10,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of capacity to lead a complex public institution responsibly.\",\"id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"label\":\"Institutional leadership\"},{\"default_weight\":10,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of diplomatic presence, international credibility, and ability to represent Hungary abroad.\",\"id\":\"international_representation\",\"label\":\"International representation\"}],\"entities_in_required_output_order\":[{\"display_name\":\"Péter Paczolay\",\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"András Sajó\",\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"András Baka\",\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Balázs Gulyás\",\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Synthetic control B\",\"entity_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"entity_type\":\"synthetic_control\",\"input\":\"A globally famous cultural figure with no legal or institutional leadership experience, recent senior party-campaign activity, highly polarizing public rhetoric, and substantial international name recognition.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Synthetic control A\",\"entity_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"entity_type\":\"synthetic_control\",\"input\":\"A non-partisan former constitutional judge with twenty years of documented rule-of-law service, leadership across governments, multilingual diplomatic experience, broad cross-group appointments, transparent interests, and no documented integrity finding.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Attila Chikán\",\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Synthetic control C\",\"entity_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"entity_type\":\"synthetic_control\",\"input\":\"A low-profile career technocrat with ten years of competent management, no known party office, limited public visibility, no diplomatic experience, and insufficient information about broader trust or unifying appeal.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Katalin Karikó\",\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Ádám Fischer\",\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"},{\"display_name\":\"Albert-László Barabási\",\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"entity_type\":\"real_candidate\",\"input\":\"Use only your pre-existing internal learned representation of this named public figure. Do not browse.\"}],\"judgment_scale\":{\"anchors\":{\"1\":\"Extremely weak fit under this criterion in the model's subjective judgment.\",\"10\":\"Exceptional fit in the model's subjective judgment.\",\"3\":\"Weak fit with substantial reservations.\",\"5\":\"Mixed or uncertain fit.\",\"7\":\"Strong fit with meaningful reservations.\",\"9\":\"Very strong fit with limited reservations.\"},\"interpretation\":\"An anchored ordinal expression of the model's subjective evaluative impression. It is not a probability, measurement of truth, or calibrated human-opinion estimate.\",\"maximum\":10,\"minimum\":1}}\n" }, "factual_recall_audits": { "albert-laszlo-barabasi": [ { "chunk_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:1f086288475605d71207e60db6b3f8439a4369edb0b61dfe91f2bd15aed0881e", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He developed influential work on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has held a professorship at Northeastern University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic positions in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has led interdisciplinary network-science research in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has led research at Northeastern University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-American network scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-Romanian physicist known for network science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with Northeastern University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the Barabási-Albert model of scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the development of scale-free network theory.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is known for work on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is widely known for research on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"His work helped popularize scale-free network models.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"His work helped popularize scale-free network research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"The US National Academy of Sciences describes Barabási as Hungarian-born, internationally affiliated, an elected member of several academies, and a pioneer of network science.\",\"id\":\"barabasi-nas\",\"publisher\":\"US National Academy of Sciences\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Albert-László Barabási\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"Barabási is a University Distinguished Professor at Northeastern and directs the Center for Complex Network Research. These roles establish professional credibility, not candidate-level public support.\",\"id\":\"barabasi-northeastern\",\"publisher\":\"Northeastern University\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Albert-László Barabási\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:ddabd5b8f5dbdf84223cd12a48ac1082788ff4aaae558b515f11b4596aac5931" } ], "andras-baka": [ { "chunk_id": "andras-baka-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:c885c945d792b70671e5e1be44da222ddc11a4a3a5b77d67ebe82a6a27b274c9", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary's Supreme Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"His premature removal from judicial leadership generated European litigation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"His premature removal from judicial office became the subject of a European human-rights judgment.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"His premature removal from judicial office led to a prominent European human-rights case.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The European Court found that his premature removal violated his rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The European Court of Human Rights ruled concerning the premature termination of his mandate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The European Court of Human Rights ruled in his favor concerning the premature termination of his mandate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The Strasbourg court ruled on the premature termination of his mandate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights from 1991 to 2008 and as President of Hungary's Supreme Court and National Judicial Council from 2009 to 2011.\",\"id\":\"baka-coe-cv\",\"publisher\":\"Council of Europe\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Curriculum Vitae of András Baka\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The ECHR Grand Chamber found that the premature termination of Baka's Supreme Court presidency after criticism of judicial reforms violated his Convention rights.\",\"id\":\"baka-echr\",\"publisher\":\"European Court of Human Rights\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Grand Chamber judgment Baka v. Hungary\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9052e2759479c1989584a17829c8bbb2ee6213729274a37a97f5b67ee917d3d2" } ], "andras-sajo": [ { "chunk_id": "andras-sajo-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held international academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held prominent international academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held prominent international academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior international academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He taught at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He was associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He was involved in a disclosed judicial-ethics controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He was involved in founding Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3233c0dadd6b36245439db3631c9111e95041c4a807e6336af4896dec378c1dd" } ], "attila-chikan": [ { "chunk_id": "attila-chikan-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Hungarian Competitiveness Research Centre.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Rajk College for Advanced Studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He held senior leadership roles at Corvinus University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and former rector of Corvinus University's predecessor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as economy minister in the first Orbán government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's economy minister in the first Orbán government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's economy minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of Corvinus University's predecessor institution.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of Corvinus University's predecessor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of Corvinus University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of the Budapest University of Economic Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He was rector of Corvinus University of Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He was rector of Corvinus University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He was rector of the Budapest University of Economic Sciences and Public Administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:068d75ca06958282e0f8b13d2de02a4f8a89305aa64762479570093b3bbd8797" } ], "balazs-gulyas": [ { "chunk_id": "balazs-gulyas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became head of Hungary's HUN-REN research network.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary's HUN-REN research network.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary's research-network organization.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became president of the Hungarian Research Network.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior leadership in Hungary's research-network system.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior research leadership roles in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior research roles in Singapore.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international academic career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He spent a substantial part of his academic career in Singapore.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He worked for many years in international academia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He worked for many years in Sweden and Singapore.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:55afd417de4e9814b42c1519eea28ecb9fb5be4fbe77b0edd8b793b5bd5d9850" } ], "botond-roska": [ { "chunk_id": "botond-roska-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has held a senior research role in Basel.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior research roles in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has led biomedical research in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has led research in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has worked at a biomedical research institute in Basel.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist known for research on vision.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist known for vision-restoration research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physician-scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns vision and retinal function.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns vision and retinal therapies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research focuses on vision and retinal science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research focuses on vision and retinal therapies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research has included approaches to restoring visual function.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His work has received major international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian neuroscientist specializing in vision research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"Known for research toward restoring sight.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"Works in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:a68423bb0ad523321a4acf8ec4e5a6f6992ff9f2b069b9e3efff80b05fc909d5" } ], "bela-merkely": [ { "chunk_id": "bela-merkely-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He is a cardiologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian cardiologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was a prominent medical communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was a prominent medical voice during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was prominent in public discussion during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian cardiologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"Served as rector of Semmelweis University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"Was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:aed954ca3fbdabd447084de018f93a6330fb096e104281f89d8c88dfd1cf8b38" } ], "cecilia-muller": [ { "chunk_id": "cecilia-muller-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"Became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's chief medical officer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became a central public-health spokesperson during COVID-19.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became a prominent public figure during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became highly visible during official COVID-19 briefings.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian physician and public-health official.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian physician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She is a physician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She participated in the government's pandemic response structure.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She regularly delivered official pandemic briefings.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's national chief medical officer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She was a central official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She was a prominent official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She was a prominent official during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d5646c756b1a2eeb320b16c55759525d0fabbd4a0e24e9e84557b03a46ee9302" } ], "csaba-korosi": [ { "chunk_id": "csaba-korosi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He has represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He has worked on international sustainability issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He previously represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the 77th UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the 77th United Nations General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the United Nations General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"Previously represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"Served as president of the UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1d84c2dafeb93f151d1630de5e92e1b63c7772c82345f087441ce939d5935acb" } ], "csaba-pleh": [ { "chunk_id": "csaba-pleh-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is known for work in cognitive science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"Held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship has focused on cognition and language.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes cognitive science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His work concerns cognition and language.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His work includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian psychologist and linguist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"Known for work in cognitive science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:5b4b3ea4d98102cce6e96e2d68fa70097e45607cd61162823724c2dacab59ce2" } ], "diana-urge-vorsatz": [ { "chunk_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"Held a senior role within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"Her research focuses on climate change and energy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian environmental scientist and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has been affiliated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held a senior leadership role within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held a senior role within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held leadership responsibilities within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held leadership roles within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior responsibilities within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles within the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has served in senior roles within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has worked extensively with the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian climate scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian environmental scientist focused on climate and energy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian environmental scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is affiliated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:71eff3000f6539318c4e8425f939b639c6f2275a44b527ec58166b628ad9da58" } ], "eniko-bollobas": [ { "chunk_id": "eniko-bollobas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Has held a university professorship.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Has taught at Eotvos Lorand University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship includes American literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship includes American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian literary scholar and Americanist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian literary scholar and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian literary scholar associated with American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian scholar of American literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Known for scholarship in American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Known for work in English and American literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She has held a university professorship.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She has worked as a university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian literary scholar associated with American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian literary scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian scholar of American literature and culture.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She specializes in American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3e07345d28e43822082a0b01098624cba3078f2b0ca5068a2c5818530cc1f9e9" } ], "eniko-gyori": [ { "chunk_id": "eniko-gyori-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Has held diplomatic and government foreign-policy roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Has held diplomatic or European-affairs responsibilities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Has served as a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Held a government role responsible for European Union affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian Fidesz politician and Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian Fidesz politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian politician associated with Fidesz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Previously held diplomatic and governmental posts.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Previously held diplomatic and governmental roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Served as ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has held government responsibility for European affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has served as a Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has served as a Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior government role concerning European affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior government role concerning European Union affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior governmental role concerning European Union affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to Spain.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d082e8b51a552db43a91901570f3fe58f45dd5bfa3bce30017a780c8c3a42fd8" } ], "erno-rubik": [ { "chunk_id": "erno-rubik-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Has supported education and creative problem solving.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Has worked in education and creative design.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He invented the Rubik's Cube.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian architect and designer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He trained and worked in architecture and design.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He trained as an architect.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His invention became a worldwide cultural icon.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His invention became globally recognized.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His puzzle became a global cultural phenomenon.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His puzzle became a worldwide cultural phenomenon.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His puzzle became globally recognized.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian architect and designer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian architect and inventor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Invented the Rubik's Cube.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Worked as an architect and design educator.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Worked as an architect and design professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Worked in design and education.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:2f4ea171bd20197a847862667d7b91a749e7b4333a50ae3cc0e6dd2f7ce5e82b" } ], "gyorgy-buzsaki": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Has held a senior academic role in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic positions in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic roles in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has held a professorship at New York University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has held a senior academic position in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic positions in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has worked at New York University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on neural oscillations and memory.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on neural oscillations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns neural oscillations and brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"His research focuses on neural oscillations and brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"His research is associated with neural oscillations and memory.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-American neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on neural oscillations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:14b4332aa229069990754543637bff717d7d2d590ffe565f261fbb6e6f623e4f" } ], "gyorgy-suranyi": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-suranyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Economist with international financial experience.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Economist with international professional experience.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Former governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior international financial roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles in international banking.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He held senior international banking roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He held senior roles in international banking.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and banker.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He served twice as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He served two periods as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as governor of the National Bank of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Served two separate terms as central-bank governor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Served two terms as central-bank governor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1ef223580e4f921b4e5b868b4b272cadd8617223eaeffcbdb367db57ba07a1db" } ], "gyorgy-szapary": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-szapary-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He held senior positions at the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He held senior roles at the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He was a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He worked as an economist at the International Monetary Fund.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He worked at the International Monetary Fund.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and former central-bank official.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Worked at the International Monetary Fund.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Worked in international economic institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3eb38af65eb5189b4d0195370a78dc4b120a98234d664345bfa75f49ad3e1b72" } ], "gyorgy-tilesch": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-tilesch-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Has worked in international advisory settings.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Has worked in internationally oriented technology policy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Has worked internationally on AI policy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally in technology advising.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally in technology advisory roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally in technology strategy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally, including in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian technology and artificial-intelligence policy expert.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with artificial-intelligence policy and strategy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with artificial-intelligence strategy and policy work.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with artificial-intelligence strategy and policy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with international artificial-intelligence strategy and policy work.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian technology and artificial-intelligence policy expert.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born technology and artificial-intelligence adviser.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Technology and artificial-intelligence adviser.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:c6f1ebec86cee6eb7c16faf010349936143649452077b1f98d7d66f9161ee5ae" } ], "gabor-bojar": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-bojar-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Built an internationally successful technology business.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Established Aquincum Institute of Technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Founded Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Founded the software company Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Has participated publicly in Hungarian civic and political debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Has participated publicly in Hungarian political debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He co-founded Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He founded the software company Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He has participated publicly in Hungarian political debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's governing direction.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian technology entrepreneur.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Known as a Hungarian technology entrepreneur.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b76aa43c77de11aef086de0a00b052308992886f0968b9dcad449357426f1266" } ], "gabor-halmai": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-halmai-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has been associated with human-rights and constitutional institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has held academic positions outside Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has taught and researched at international universities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has taught and researched internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has taught or researched at the European University Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has written extensively on constitutionalism and fundamental rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has written extensively on fundamental rights and constitutionalism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has held academic positions outside Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has held international academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has taught and conducted research internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has taught and researched at international universities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at the European University Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses constitutionalism and fundamental rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses constitutionalism and human rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses fundamental rights and constitutionalism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:79f0ad7e37d8cdf11af6787a3e6f9e0e84591867ecb33c73f8b8a34de402552c" } ], "gabor-ivanyi": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-ivanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Founded or led charitable and educational institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Founded or led organizations providing social services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Has led church-affiliated social and charitable institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded and leads charitable and educational institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded or leads organizations providing social services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded or led institutions providing social and educational services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded or led organizations providing social services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has been a prominent critic of the Orbán government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has been a prominent critic of Viktor Orbán's government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led charitable and educational work serving disadvantaged people.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led organizations providing social and educational services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a member of parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian Methodist pastor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Methodist pastor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He leads charitable and educational work.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a member of Hungary's parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a member of parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as a member of Hungary's parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian Methodist pastor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Previously served as a member of parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:88c829139ff93398d62558adf1df340f3fbfd06c1aeaa1069ab9876dca84fef9" } ], "gabor-torok": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-torok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b4c098dad70bb3a7aff5eb60b3d6592e3764fe1751d373e316c274a44ddb5015", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at Corvinus University of Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at university.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He has taught political science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a frequent commentator on Hungarian politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist and analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist and political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is known for public political analysis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is widely known as a political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political analyst and political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist and analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Known for public commentary on Hungarian politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Török is a political scientist and ELTE associate professor, directs a political-analysis firm, advised President László Sólyom from 2006 to 2010, and earlier led an institute attached to the SZDSZ parliamentary group.\",\"id\":\"torok-cv\",\"publisher\":\"Gábor Török\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_personal\",\"source_title\":\"Gábor Török — Curriculum Vitae\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9202a9217177a470b46b30feab2766c98213a191aae970cf83d47136c0a2a319" } ], "ignac-romsics": [ { "chunk_id": "ignac-romsics-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic standing.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has held university teaching positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has written widely used historical syntheses.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic standing.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian historian.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He is a prominent Hungarian historian.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He specializes in modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship focuses substantially on modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship focuses substantially on twentieth-century Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes twentieth-century Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian historian specializing in modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian historian.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Known for scholarship on modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Known for scholarship on twentieth-century Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9f654f68e1503e702cae677eb46a5876e165e7ce04e2cec8fe739cb34b4bf92f" } ], "ildiko-enyedi": [ { "chunk_id": "ildiko-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Directed On Body and Soul.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Has received major international film recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her film On Body and Soul won the Berlin Golden Bear.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her film On Body and Soul won the Golden Bear.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her films have received major international awards.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her films have received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian film director and screenwriter.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Received major international film recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She directed On Body and Soul.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She has received international recognition for her filmmaking.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She has received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian film director and screenwriter.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian film director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:573c51c72022f76d559a5c2f35271d0fbbc2cd4cd4c680d8456541b42e49783c" } ], "ilona-palne-kovacs": [ { "chunk_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic and research roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic research roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her research includes local and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship concerns governance and regional administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship concerns local government and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship has addressed decentralization and local government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her work concerns regional governance and public administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes local governance and regional studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist associated with research on regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on local and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on local government and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on regional governance and decentralization.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior research roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d8f8f757db3c9446248f72d3dd524ab6803a6bbc7fd0ba22b23fa3c50b29b746" } ], "imre-voros": [ { "chunk_id": "imre-voros-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Former Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Former judge of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Former judge of the Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Has publicly addressed constitutional questions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Has written and spoken on constitutional issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He has commented publicly on constitutional questions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior judicial office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in constitutional law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist and constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He served as a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian jurist and former Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Known as a scholar of constitutional and economic law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Legal scholar specializing in public and constitutional law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Served as a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:22a4d0e89a29a02830721117ad2dcee989d56122c120697fcaf6ff14598c40e9" } ], "ivan-fischer": [ { "chunk_id": "ivan-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has conducted internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has conducted major international orchestras.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has conducted major orchestras internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has led major orchestras internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led major international musical performances.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led major international orchestras.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led major orchestras internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has spoken publicly on Hungarian civic affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian conductor and co-founder of the Budapest Festival Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian conductor and composer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:474e1e726d8263716f10a2ad62354101a58090127bb5c59e0bb1b970a02f90a4" } ], "janos-martonyi": [ { "chunk_id": "janos-martonyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Has a legal and diplomatic background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He has a legal and diplomatic background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He held ministerial office in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He held office in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian lawyer and diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer and diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served twice as foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Held office in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian lawyer and politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Is a lawyer and diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Is trained as a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister in two Fidesz governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served twice as foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:e8d43a546b0fa20a531fe79f64f73e33ca9ef9845881d3e1c773ca687d3cff37" } ], "jozsef-palinkas": [ { "chunk_id": "jozsef-palinkas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:095dac47433bb21f0b3e5da7606bacbe0431c06c40453848e193e103092c4ab9", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He held ministerial office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He is a physicist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He later broke politically with Fidesz and founded a separate movement.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He previously held government office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's education minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Physicist and member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Previously served as education minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Served as education minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Pálinkás led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014, served as education minister in 2001–2002, and led the National Research, Development and Innovation Office from 2015 to 2018.\",\"id\":\"palinkas-mta\",\"publisher\":\"Hungarian Academy of Sciences\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Pálinkás József\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Pálinkás served as World Science Forum president and represented the Hungarian Academy in international science organizations.\",\"id\":\"palinkas-wsf\",\"publisher\":\"World Science Forum\",\"quality_class\":\"reputable_secondary\",\"source_title\":\"Prof. József Pálinkás\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:bc96d1472953309bc83fe359891b12c7d35f52626760ed68a0b8ef170e76a295" } ], "jozsef-peter-martin": [ { "chunk_id": "jozsef-peter-martin-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"Associated in my memory with Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"Associated with Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He has been associated with Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He has led Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with economic and public-policy analysis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He is known as an economist and governance commentator.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"His public work concerns corruption and governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"His public work has focused on corruption and governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"His work has focused on economics and governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"Known as an economist and policy analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:78152f1be94b307d1424d6d178683b3caafccf258e61f71f33ffb1d74bf97e5a" } ], "julia-kiraly": [ { "chunk_id": "julia-kiraly-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:133f8ef5589f793e203c2061a99e2ef9cedcf29e943ca2018d6c0938197f5ba4", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Economist and former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Has held academic roles in economics and finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Held academic positions in economics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Resigned from the central bank before completing her term.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Resigned from the central bank before her term ended.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She has held academic roles in economics and finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She has held academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She is an economist and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She resigned from that position before her term ended.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She resigned from the central bank before completing her term.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She resigned from the central bank before her term ended.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian central bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She served as deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Király served as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary responsible for financial stability during 2007–2013 and later as an independent KBC Group board member and Hellenic stability-fund panelist.\",\"id\":\"kiraly-bruegel\",\"publisher\":\"Bruegel\",\"quality_class\":\"reputable_secondary\",\"source_title\":\"Júlia Király\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Yale's Journal of Financial Crises describes Király's role overseeing Hungary's emergency response to the global financial crisis and her academic work on crisis management.\",\"id\":\"kiraly-yale\",\"publisher\":\"Yale Program on Financial Stability\",\"quality_class\":\"independent_research\",\"source_title\":\"Lessons Learned: Júlia Király\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b7f8c9534f2a8946337ba89f61fe4ad2afd9796906b166224655ffb53a89a407" } ], "katalin-bogyay": [ { "chunk_id": "katalin-bogyay-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Held a senior leadership role in the UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Held senior leadership in UNESCO's General Conference.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She has worked in cultural diplomacy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior role at UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior role representing Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She held senior roles connected with UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She is a career diplomat and cultural professional.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as president of UNESCO's General Conference.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She was president of UNESCO's General Conference.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:413819e6dab956792c4f1c4f4ae29f23e057164e09cc78cea17ceebf439643a8" } ], "katalin-kariko": [ { "chunk_id": "katalin-kariko-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021", "claim-0022", "claim-0023", "claim-0024", "claim-0025", "claim-0026", "claim-0027", "claim-0028", "claim-0029", "claim-0030", "claim-0031", "claim-0032", "claim-0033", "claim-0034", "claim-0035", "claim-0036", "claim-0037", "claim-0038", "claim-0039", "claim-0040", "claim-0041", "claim-0042", "claim-0043", "claim-0044", "claim-0045", "claim-0046", "claim-0047", "claim-0048", "claim-0049", "claim-0050", "claim-0051", "claim-0052", "claim-0053", "claim-0054", "claim-0055", "claim-0056", "claim-0057", "claim-0058", "claim-0059", "claim-0060", "claim-0061", "claim-0062", "claim-0063", "claim-0064", "claim-0065", "claim-0066", "claim-0067", "claim-0068" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b802c3f0cb92a2fe82cdd9f4838a178feb3ee4a613af77595df0ee74291aa471", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Biochemist central to advances in mRNA technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Biochemist known for foundational work on mRNA therapeutics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Conducted much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Held senior research responsibilities at BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Held senior research roles connected with BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine development.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research helped enable mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research was central to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research was foundational to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work was foundational to mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0022\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0023\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0024\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Known for foundational work on mRNA therapeutics\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0025\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Much of her scientific career was pursued in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0026\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0027\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0028\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0029\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She built much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0030\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She conducted much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0031\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She conducted much of her research career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0032\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior research role at BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0033\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held research and executive roles connected with the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0034\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior academic and biotechnology roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0035\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research and corporate roles at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0036\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research responsibilities at BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0037\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research roles connected with BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0038\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research roles in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0039\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior roles connected with BioNTech and the University of Pennsylvania.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0040\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-American biochemist associated with mRNA technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0041\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0042\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0043\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0044\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational work on mRNA technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0045\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for messenger-RNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0046\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0047\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for research on messenger RNA.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0048\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for work on messenger RNA.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0049\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0050\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She pursued much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0051\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She pursued much of her research career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0052\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0053\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0054\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0055\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0056\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0057\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0058\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She spent much of her research career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0059\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked at BioNTech after conducting research at the University of Pennsylvania.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0060\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0061\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked for many years at the University of Pennsylvania.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0062\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked for many years in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0063\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked in academic and biotechnology research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0064\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0065\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked for many years in Hungary and the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0066\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked for many years in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0067\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked for years in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0068\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Karikó is a University of Szeged professor, Penn adjunct professor, former BioNTech senior vice president, and a 2025 US National Academy of Sciences member.\",\"id\":\"kariko-nas\",\"publisher\":\"US National Academy of Sciences\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Katalin Karikó\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Karikó received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines and was affiliated with the University of Szeged and University of Pennsylvania. This establishes professional credibility and international stature, not candidate-level public support.\",\"id\":\"kariko-nobel\",\"publisher\":\"Nobel Prize Outreach\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Katalin Karikó — Facts\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:fca788e7623d2fad39608a94994f69dcd38bfb646a17c301fe2fb25ff7dafe39" } ], "kinga-goncz": [ { "chunk_id": "kinga-goncz-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Held ministerial office in an MSZP-led government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Later served in the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Served as a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She is a psychiatrist by training.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She is associated with the Hungarian Socialist Party.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She is the daughter of former president Árpád Göncz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She later served in the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She served as a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She trained and worked in psychiatry.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She was a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Worked in social-policy and governmental roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d952f1d40a47c8f24ee82ca2ffa52205cd332421c681e03e55a8a9aca3b7b498" } ], "kornel-mundruczo": [ { "chunk_id": "kornel-mundruczo-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"Directed internationally produced screen and stage works.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"Directed the film White God.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He directed Pieces of a Woman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He directed the film White God.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Proton Theatre company.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He has directed productions outside Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His films have appeared at major international festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His films have competed at major international festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His films have received recognition at major international festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His work has appeared at major international film festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian film and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:533fea26fc7cf8195df0973e2938726bd006576fc21228986423b594e2d93834" } ], "laczo-adrienn": [ { "chunk_id": "laczo-adrienn-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She has been associated with judicial self-governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She is associated in my recollection with the Hungarian judiciary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She is known to me as a Hungarian judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:e18f4994d46657d5786bf4aa69cca40ad1c1558fe9be43368d711edf8599f4e9" } ], "laszlo-krasznahorkai": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b52f980fab1babef1ebb680eec3dcd8e66749eed19c88fce521425bb6704dce1", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian novelist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He is an internationally acclaimed Hungarian novelist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He received the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He received the Man Booker International Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the 2015 Man Booker International Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the International Booker Prize in 2015.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the Man Booker International Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He wrote Satantango.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"His works have achieved substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"His works include Satantango.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"Several of his works were adapted into films by Béla Tarr.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"Krasznahorkai received the 2025 Nobel Prize in Literature for his Hungarian-language literary oeuvre.\",\"id\":\"krasznahorkai-nobel\",\"publisher\":\"Nobel Prize Outreach\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"László Krasznahorkai — Facts\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b510e81e361a8d6955ff5c142d0c5287d0b90c0326f99d09903216a28a6bd084" } ], "laszlo-majtenyi": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-majtenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Eötvös Károly Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a constitutional lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the Eötvös Károly Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's data-protection ombudsman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's first parliamentary commissioner for data protection.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection and freedom of information.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-backed presidential nominee in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-supported presidential nominee in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"Led the Eötvös Károly Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's first parliamentary commissioner for data protection.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:a660534b62128870ba80b821017fe48a272e06d6f8462018468929fb75e47dc9" } ], "laszlo-trocsanyi": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"Became a Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He became a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He became a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later became a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later became a Fidesz-affiliated member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later became a Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as an ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's justice minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's minister of justice.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to France.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's justice minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:444fa7d998d3df138caef38b79a3eebc4f3d2c6e0d44afcc75bbe830fe35438e" } ], "miklos-perenyi": [ { "chunk_id": "miklos-perenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has an international performance career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has had a prominent international performing career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has had an international performing career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has had an internationally recognized performance career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has performed internationally as a soloist and chamber musician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has performed internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at the Liszt Academy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught music at a senior level.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught music in Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian cellist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:09bc4e51d4d226c8575debd5a18cf3907003f10bed191e8fbd8a076da1684f78" } ], "marta-pardavi": [ { "chunk_id": "marta-pardavi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her organization has litigated and advocated on asylum and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has addressed asylum and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has addressed refugee protection and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on human rights and asylum law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on human rights and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on rule-of-law and migration-related rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on rule-of-law and refugee-rights issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has included refugee and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has significant international visibility.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She has held a leadership role at the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She has served as co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian lawyer and human-rights advocate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a lawyer and co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a leader of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1d29ffa546a278f78a3e85cd08dd020df948c84b307773f65d27dd6eeb84a361" } ], "nora-l-ritok": [ { "chunk_id": "nora-l-ritok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Founded the Real Pearl Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged children.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on poverty and educational exclusion.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She founded and leads the Real Pearl Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She founded the Igazgyöngy Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She founded the Real Pearl Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian educator and civil-society leader.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is an educator and civil-society leader.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is an educator.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is associated with the Igazgyöngy Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Works on education and poverty reduction in disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9f152384b92899165bfd2d0e145f8f5c7be58eb0ece5d37f0775dcc5b355ca6a" } ], "pal-sonnevend": [ { "chunk_id": "pal-sonnevend-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has been affiliated with ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has been associated with Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has held a professorial role at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has held a senior academic role at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has held an academic leadership role at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has taught law at Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar associated with constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian scholar of constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"His work concerns European public law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"His work includes constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"Is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1c43ea3432bed5ad6ce40e1e01d49562739220dd7efa02e9d37d9d1b10be087d" } ], "peter-balazs": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-balazs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He had a long diplomatic and European-policy career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He has a long diplomatic career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior diplomatic posts.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior diplomatic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He served as a European commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He was Hungary's first European commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He was Hungary's member of the European Commission.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He was Hungary's member of the first European Commission after EU accession.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He worked as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"Was a European Commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"Worked as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:325df0e1c8c969d908765bffea0dd40281a9456686f25f4b5e65be1da396f43c" } ], "peter-barandy": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-barandy-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:650e4fde479206192a22f77730911571bacc2020b4a071d7a261d8f833906db1", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer from a prominent Hungarian legal family.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer from a prominent legal family.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's justice minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's minister of justice in the early 2000s.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's minister of justice.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as minister of justice in the Medgyessy government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served in the Medgyessy government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"Is a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's minister of justice.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"Bárándy's archived professional biography records a long criminal-law and bar-association career, university teaching, and service as justice minister from 2002 to 2004.\",\"id\":\"barandy-biography\",\"publisher\":\"Archived personal professional site\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_personal\",\"source_title\":\"Dr. Péter Bárándy — Biography\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"ELTE lists Bárándy as a lawyer, former justice minister, and lecturer in its criminal-law department.\",\"id\":\"barandy-elte\",\"publisher\":\"Eötvös Loránd University Faculty of Law\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Dr. Bárándy Péter\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:121575e93c1d29fefe198601eece99061e36fe5f4b612f50439e98ed0b8b5145" } ], "peter-darak": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-darak-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"Has a judicial and legal background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He has a senior judicial and legal background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He is a jurist with senior judicial experience.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He is a jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He previously worked as a judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Curia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Curia of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Kúria, Hungary's highest ordinary court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Kúria, Hungary's supreme court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"His professional background includes tax law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"His professional background is in law and the judiciary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"Served as president of the Curia of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:da07ec607c098c5fef89c7bfe206fe5e134d93f3dca43fab24d2d71f24ab7816" } ], "peter-kovacs": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"A Hungarian jurist named Péter Kovács served as a judge of the International Criminal Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:c066f187a1b9256737365d63c8905706aa70f3d9fff809db1d411ac3391da708" } ], "peter-kreko": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-kreko-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Director of Political Capital.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Director of the Political Capital Institute\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Director of the Political Capital Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He directs the Political Capital Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Political Capital institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Political Capital research institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political psychologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He leads the Political Capital institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His public work addresses disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His research includes disinformation and political radicalism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses political extremism and disinformation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work includes political extremism and disinformation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work includes research on disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Researches disinformation and political extremism\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Researches disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Researches disinformation, populism, and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:ee061e308f975343a9758654be1b80f708cdd33bc364f34e1a52337ef5e0e1b0" } ], "peter-nadas": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-nadas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Author of A Book of Memories\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Author of A Book of Memories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He has substantial international literary recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian novelist and essayist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian writer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is a major Hungarian writer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is known for major novels including A Book of Memories and Parallel Stories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is known for major novels including Parallel Stories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is known for major works of modern European literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His literary work has received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His novels have received extensive international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has broad international recognition\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has extensive international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work often engages with history, memory, and political life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His works have received extensive international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His works have received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His works include A Book of Memories and Parallel Stories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian novelist and essayist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian novelist and essayist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1fa4c136fc130aaa500923526109460344a1376709d2ca12c0488a0de9ee6692" } ], "peter-paczolay": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-paczolay-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021", "claim-0022", "claim-0023", "claim-0024", "claim-0025", "claim-0026", "claim-0027", "claim-0028", "claim-0029", "claim-0030", "claim-0031", "claim-0032", "claim-0033", "claim-0034", "claim-0035", "claim-0036", "claim-0037", "claim-0038", "claim-0039", "claim-0040", "claim-0041", "claim-0042", "claim-0043", "claim-0044", "claim-0045", "claim-0046", "claim-0047", "claim-0048", "claim-0049", "claim-0050", "claim-0051", "claim-0052", "claim-0053", "claim-0054", "claim-0055", "claim-0056", "claim-0057", "claim-0058", "claim-0059", "claim-0060", "claim-0061" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:688f558b8cd5eca237a0632825895ac8bffcb4feda8409ac4feaff048a92def3", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He also held a diplomatic post in Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He formerly led Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He formerly presided over Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has an academic background in constitutional law and political thought.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a diplomatic posting.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a diplomatic role connected to the Council of Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held an international judicial role.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held diplomatic office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held European human-rights judicial responsibilities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a Hungarian ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0022\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has worked as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0023\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in European human-rights adjudication.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0024\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in European legal institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0025\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0026\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He held a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0027\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He held an ambassadorial post.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0028\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0029\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist and former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0030\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0031\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0032\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0033\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0034\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later held a senior diplomatic post in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0035\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0036\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a Hungarian ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0037\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0038\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0039\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0040\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served in a diplomatic role.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0041\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served in diplomatic office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0042\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as a Hungarian ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0043\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0044\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0045\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0046\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0047\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served Hungary in a diplomatic role.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0048\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0049\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian jurist and constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0050\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Is a constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0051\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0052\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Later served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0053\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0054\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0055\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0056\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0057\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0058\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0059\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0060\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Worked in European constitutional-law institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0061\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Paczolay served as a Constitutional Court judge from 2006 and as President of the Court from 2008 to 2015; he had earlier been chief counsellor and Secretary General of the Court and led the Office of the President.\",\"id\":\"paczolay-court\",\"publisher\":\"Constitutional Court of Hungary\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Péter Paczolay — Former member\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Paczolay has served as an ECHR judge since 2017 and previously served in leadership roles in the Venice Commission.\",\"id\":\"paczolay-europe\",\"publisher\":\"Mathias Corvinus Collegium\",\"quality_class\":\"reputable_secondary\",\"source_title\":\"Péter Paczolay\"}]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:99f2d08703a8fcd93205d085d439adfe33f1c7ee22b613211e55f2cdd13b0ad4" } ], "peter-rona": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-rona-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021", "claim-0022", "claim-0023", "claim-0024", "claim-0025", "claim-0026", "claim-0027", "claim-0028" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Has taught at the University of Oxford\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has held academic roles at Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has held academic roles in the United Kingdom.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has held an academic affiliation with Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in international finance and academia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and lawyer with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-born lawyer, economist, and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He pursued a substantial professional career in the United Kingdom.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He served in a supervisory role connected to Hungary's central bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He served on the supervisory board of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-backed presidential nominee in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He worked internationally in law and finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Held academic roles at Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and lawyer\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and lawyer with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Opposition parties nominated him for president of Hungary in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Served on the supervisory board of the National Bank of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0022\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Taught at the University of Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0023\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"The opposition nominated him for president of Hungary in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0024\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition nominee for president in 2022\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0025\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition nominee for president of Hungary in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0026\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0027\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Worked internationally in finance and academia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0028\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:8364c7fac9d09adca8ffb906624a640f65968d0c58ea80f281536f8d10eeadf4" } ], "peter-akos-bod": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-akos-bod-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He formerly served as president of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He has worked as an economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He previously held a ministerial post.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as a government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as governor of the National Bank of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as industry and trade minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"Is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"Served as a government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"Served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:45238b70b031e9e90a30bacbe277d40bf263a1a8c74a17036bf3c8e622bdf39d" } ], "robert-alfoldi": [ { "chunk_id": "robert-alfoldi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He has been prominent in Hungarian cultural debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He led the National Theatre in Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He served as director of Hungary's National Theatre.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He served as director of the National Theatre.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became a focus of political and cultural controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became a focus of political controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became a subject of political controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became politically contentious.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian actor and theater director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian actor and theatre director\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian actor and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Known for outspoken public positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d02297101141c4453378c00b6f8c49454b6f4e561861bb8c14643dbfa4c76ec9" } ], "szilveszter-e-vizi": [ { "chunk_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He has held prominent roles in Hungarian scientific life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian physician and neuroscientist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:41d621302f59ab6998074c88d2f0d7ddd640c4bca4bf9805fe605213c12707ba" } ], "tamas-freund": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-freund-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He became president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has an internationally recognized research career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior leadership roles in Hungarian scientific research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has received major international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has received major recognition for brain research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has received major scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is a neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is internationally recognized for brain research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He received the Brain Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He serves as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3b120f95fc422cafdd6bc7029d5380915889604c011ff8d22fbc4b63c8a0f0d7" } ], "tamas-sulyok": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-sulyok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary in 2024.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He has a professional background in law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer by profession.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as president of the Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He previously worked as a lawyer and constitutional judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He previously worked as a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He was elected by the governing parliamentary majority.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He worked as a lawyer before joining the court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:93b1ca7bf3119b05aaca4f9bfa299b7fe53cc0b8016a8fd1ba36ab3205cb5bf0" } ], "tamas-vicsek": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-vicsek-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He has an international academic reputation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He has substantial international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist associated with complex systems research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist known for research on collective motion.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is known for work on collective motion and complex systems.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"The Vicsek model bears his name.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"The Vicsek model is associated with collective motion.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9b8a4a90e17457acff9e89797c350d3e5d6b3b335f732099718afa9525bb2004" } ], "tibor-navracsics": [ { "chunk_id": "tibor-navracsics-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has been a prominent Fidesz politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has been a senior Fidesz politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has been a senior politician in Fidesz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles within Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held several Hungarian ministerial posts.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a Hungarian government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a Hungarian minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a senior Fidesz politician and Hungarian minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a senior Hungarian government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served in senior Hungarian government positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with Fidesz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He served as a European commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He served as a Hungarian minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He was a European Commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:66a5f3ca97ac89c0b936283dfd4ab962fda88c8a54fdf9ce8348e35698ba0f1c" } ], "tunde-hando": [ { "chunk_id": "tunde-hando-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her court-administration tenure attracted controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her court-administration tenure drew controversy over judicial appointments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial administration record attracted domestic and international criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration decisions attracted domestic and international criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure attracted controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure attracted domestic and international criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure attracted institutional criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure drew controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She later became a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She later became a justice of the Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She led Hungary's National Judicial Office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She served as president of Hungary's National Judicial Office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:19419940f64648229cb0ee1beaa24f05f0afbcf6218afa5656f597b7882bfc13" } ], "vanda-lamm": [ { "chunk_id": "vanda-lamm-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her expertise includes international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her field includes international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes international dispute settlement and nuclear law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes international dispute settlement.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes international legal responsibility and dispute settlement.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has been affiliated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has been associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in Hungarian academic institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior standing in the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has served on international legal bodies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She held senior roles within the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:31bbf9b1290eafe3d52096eb0f102534dcbae33845ac09a63238e131a4cf239b" } ], "zoltan-fleck": [ { "chunk_id": "zoltan-fleck-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly commented on Hungarian constitutional institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's constitutional and judicial system.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal sociologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a public critic of Hungary's rule-of-law developments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is known for public commentary on constitutional and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is publicly associated with rule-of-law commentary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is publicly associated with rule-of-law debates.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"His public work addresses law and democratic institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"His public work addresses rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Known for public commentary on rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Publicly comments on rule-of-law and constitutional questions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9a7afe979628ba7e48297f6103ce4efd38a1daaf6af7db91d3e9cf1e3844643e" } ], "zsolt-enyedi": [ { "chunk_id": "zsolt-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic leadership responsibilities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior leadership roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has been affiliated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has been associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic leadership roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior leadership roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns parties, democracy, and political institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His research includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship addresses parties and democratic politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship concerns parties and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship concerns parties, democracy, and political attitudes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes parties, polarization, and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist specializing in parties and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Researches parties, political attitudes, and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:eb2648e2e57decbc45d4d3f380f21f05373d3181bba787b9ad04d5a14838fcc7" } ], "zsolt-hernadi": [ { "chunk_id": "zsolt-hernadi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"Has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"Has been involved in a long-running legal controversy connected to Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has been involved in a long-running legal dispute connected with Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced a long-running Croatian corruption case.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced a long-running Croatian criminal case that he disputes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced a long-running legal controversy involving Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced prolonged public legal controversy connected with Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has held a prominent role in Hungarian business life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the company for many years.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the regional energy company for many years.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has long served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He is a long-serving senior leader of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He is chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He is the chairman and chief executive of MOL Group.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"His career has centered on the energy sector.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"His career has included prominent regional business activity.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"Long-serving chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"MOL is a major Hungarian energy company.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"MOL is a major Hungarian oil and gas company.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:5ffe15230eb7789537c209fe07357269e14b709e661dd3d11708201c2765ded4" } ], "zsuzsanna-jakab": [ { "chunk_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Held senior leadership roles in international public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Her career has focused on international public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Her career has focused on public health and international administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Her professional field is public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian public-health professional.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Previously led Hungary's national public-health administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She held senior leadership roles at the World Health Organization.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She held senior leadership roles in international health administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She held senior leadership roles in international public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian public-health specialist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She later held a senior deputy leadership role at the WHO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She later held a senior deputy leadership role at WHO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She previously worked in Hungarian public-health administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She served as the WHO Regional Director for Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b9fff7c23b9dffd67ddacbd23cee56308420f31c8ac5d6b17d575cac081086be" } ], "adam-fischer": [ { "chunk_id": "adam-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led internationally prominent orchestras and opera productions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungarian political developments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's political direction.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized political conditions in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized the Hungarian government's democratic record.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor with a major international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is an internationally known Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is an internationally prominent Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:8ad00b4833faf4e2053efc1b20bf27382fc2822f3041fcd31e866b6b774c2b2e" } ], "eva-kondorosi": [ { "chunk_id": "eva-kondorosi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior roles in European scientific institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior roles in European scientific organizations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior research roles in Hungary and France.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in European scientific institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Her research concerns plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Her research concerns plant-microbe symbiosis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian biologist known for research on plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian plant biologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Is an internationally recognized research scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on plant-microbe symbiosis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Received major international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in European scientific institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in European scientific organizations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in international scientific bodies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian biologist known for plant-microbe research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian biologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a member of major scientific academies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a member of prominent scientific academies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is internationally recognized for her research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n", "prompt_hash": "sha256:41fdf260cf3f03b7cc3fe9b3774f5853de29d4af93cf9ed2ec4d9216c126e55a" } ] }, "bias_audit": "Act as the model-risk auditor for a repeated-measures study of\nsubjective LLM judgments. Do not decide which candidate is truly suitable.\nAudit whether the release honestly measures model output distributions.\n\nCheck provider-family weighting, within-model and between-model variance,\nprompt sensitivity, candidate-order effects, fame/exposure bias, middle-score\ncompression, synthetic-control performance, rank-probability interpretation,\nfactual-contamination exclusions, and whether model agreement is mislabeled as\ntruth. A broad or unstable distribution is a result, not a failure. Flag high\nonly when the methodology or public interpretation is materially invalid.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"stable-id or null\",\n \"criterion_id\": \"stable-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary\"\n}\n\nFrozen method summary:\n{\"aggregation\":{\"balanced_assessments\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":8.3875,\"order_score_correlation\":0.35121615125082234,\"q1_1_10\":8.075000000000001,\"q3_1_10\":8.628124999999999,\"rank1_probability\":1.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.37583471914009076,\"top3_probability\":1.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":8.05,\"order_score_correlation\":0.09516819845361706,\"q1_1_10\":7.95,\"q3_1_10\":8.1,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.14941397546556937,\"top3_probability\":1.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":8.0,\"order_score_correlation\":0.09267239312174194,\"q1_1_10\":7.95,\"q3_1_10\":8.115625000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.15406476115663864,\"top3_probability\":1.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.95,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.4329819569622529,\"q1_1_10\":7.862499999999999,\"q3_1_10\":8.1,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.17931679756478175,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.875,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.06446959734221899,\"q1_1_10\":7.75,\"q3_1_10\":7.9,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.1596491378687095,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.85,\"order_score_correlation\":0.8023009759134789,\"q1_1_10\":7.668750000000001,\"q3_1_10\":7.887500000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.18078244291597192,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.775,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3735321960613155,\"q1_1_10\":7.656250000000001,\"q3_1_10\":7.793749999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.11850486394143404,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.75,\"order_score_correlation\":0.7041921540959082,\"q1_1_10\":7.65,\"q3_1_10\":7.7875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.19511837575060828,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.725,\"order_score_correlation\":0.36485344576006756,\"q1_1_10\":7.403125000000001,\"q3_1_10\":8.0,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.3702124952870537,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.71875,\"order_score_correlation\":0.8172897709931114,\"q1_1_10\":7.5625,\"q3_1_10\":7.871875000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.2053494650048491,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.7125,\"order_score_correlation\":0.5815451893269232,\"q1_1_10\":7.5,\"q3_1_10\":7.8968750000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.3254297372535107,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.7,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.31252490205550076,\"q1_1_10\":7.628124999999999,\"q3_1_10\":7.89375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.17224518216129517,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.55,\"order_score_correlation\":0.1412608817220843,\"q1_1_10\":7.34375,\"q3_1_10\":7.668749999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.21573920083697765,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.5,\"order_score_correlation\":0.33521749804141715,\"q1_1_10\":7.362499999999999,\"q3_1_10\":7.518750000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.264263257840443,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.4375,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3610543933253997,\"q1_1_10\":7.34375,\"q3_1_10\":7.49375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.1668800717081981,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.4,\"order_score_correlation\":0.2871265783563709,\"q1_1_10\":7.240625,\"q3_1_10\":7.4,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.24692905526351758,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.3875,\"order_score_correlation\":0.681459032903368,\"q1_1_10\":7.0874999999999995,\"q3_1_10\":7.612500000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.30539421245334686,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.375,\"order_score_correlation\":0.7678838277309019,\"q1_1_10\":7.215625,\"q3_1_10\":7.5062500000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.26719024121400853,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.35,\"order_score_correlation\":0.34822148942721387,\"q1_1_10\":7.2250000000000005,\"q3_1_10\":7.61875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.22152015835033068,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.35,\"order_score_correlation\":0.7632658403066925,\"q1_1_10\":7.046875,\"q3_1_10\":7.35,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.2670602564133337,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.3,\"order_score_correlation\":0.20146176874105137,\"q1_1_10\":7.2625,\"q3_1_10\":7.5562499999999995,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.18966802137770444,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.3,\"order_score_correlation\":0.4230661243723979,\"q1_1_10\":7.2093750000000005,\"q3_1_10\":7.4375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.15253073460781594,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.3,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.39432956214852555,\"q1_1_10\":7.15,\"q3_1_10\":7.549999999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.2522158742470867,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.3,\"order_score_correlation\":0.11580377407634697,\"q1_1_10\":7.3,\"q3_1_10\":7.562499999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.2198523810297365,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.275,\"order_score_correlation\":0.362265785501864,\"q1_1_10\":7.025,\"q3_1_10\":7.384375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.35229653308288794,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.25,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.5507529685558726,\"q1_1_10\":7.140625,\"q3_1_10\":7.2875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.16334715077608986,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.2,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.15520039123489648,\"q1_1_10\":7.2125,\"q3_1_10\":7.378125000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.196324738068787,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.1875,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.037583102766285355,\"q1_1_10\":6.85,\"q3_1_10\":7.2,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.21229974224090703,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.175,\"order_score_correlation\":0.8468784198058958,\"q1_1_10\":7.081250000000001,\"q3_1_10\":7.2,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.18439559677799008,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.175,\"order_score_correlation\":0.5039101049901301,\"q1_1_10\":6.956250000000001,\"q3_1_10\":7.446875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.32810747307687,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.175,\"order_score_correlation\":0.2522400179189872,\"q1_1_10\":6.987500000000001,\"q3_1_10\":7.1937500000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.24875034896681275,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.15,\"order_score_correlation\":0.7173467571852903,\"q1_1_10\":7.1812499999999995,\"q3_1_10\":7.331249999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.15706178013055172,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.1499999999999995,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3897471399687344,\"q1_1_10\":7.112499999999999,\"q3_1_10\":7.23125,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.1598664807477373,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.1375,\"order_score_correlation\":0.45512505374202894,\"q1_1_10\":7.0125,\"q3_1_10\":7.34375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.40510843884350545,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.1375,\"order_score_correlation\":0.08025920952354429,\"q1_1_10\":7.0,\"q3_1_10\":7.1312500000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.2892789167337757,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.125,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.005981324739783265,\"q1_1_10\":6.896875,\"q3_1_10\":7.2125,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.20038591240126874,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.075,\"order_score_correlation\":0.20843994397316606,\"q1_1_10\":7.009375,\"q3_1_10\":7.24375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.22831280321329128,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.05,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3032329336155811,\"q1_1_10\":6.9125,\"q3_1_10\":7.25,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.21877579213025886,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":7.0,\"order_score_correlation\":0.1489989271825419,\"q1_1_10\":6.8125,\"q3_1_10\":7.2,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.31154019269857736,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.975,\"order_score_correlation\":0.41192546888087317,\"q1_1_10\":6.853125,\"q3_1_10\":7.25,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.23967932859459437,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.95,\"order_score_correlation\":0.4811529480416076,\"q1_1_10\":6.890625,\"q3_1_10\":6.9875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.33137183294098277,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.95,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3755915094921956,\"q1_1_10\":6.9,\"q3_1_10\":7.3500000000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.30265319812176666,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.875,\"order_score_correlation\":0.6214461362226064,\"q1_1_10\":6.7625,\"q3_1_10\":6.95,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.18941155221134506,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.65,\"order_score_correlation\":0.05670425539255418,\"q1_1_10\":6.509375,\"q3_1_10\":6.981249999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.3359920013928903,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.65,\"order_score_correlation\":0.4311453072268598,\"q1_1_10\":6.6625000000000005,\"q3_1_10\":6.8374999999999995,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.1718011204852866,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.6375,\"order_score_correlation\":0.42873642278337987,\"q1_1_10\":6.4468749999999995,\"q3_1_10\":6.7375,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.24469723355835277,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.6,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.7518122221177392,\"q1_1_10\":6.325,\"q3_1_10\":6.7,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.23482041010099614,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.425,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.07889128245129425,\"q1_1_10\":5.9625,\"q3_1_10\":6.793749999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.7105370132668827,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.4,\"order_score_correlation\":0.36874271439301093,\"q1_1_10\":6.3125,\"q3_1_10\":6.5,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.25468185491358086,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.3,\"order_score_correlation\":0.06859150817287767,\"q1_1_10\":6.3125,\"q3_1_10\":6.475,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.20810404048616324,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.2125,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.13266776273754144,\"q1_1_10\":5.8374999999999995,\"q3_1_10\":6.446875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.3420957671309147,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.2,\"order_score_correlation\":0.4878831651989961,\"q1_1_10\":6.171874999999999,\"q3_1_10\":6.581249999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.32660129022674994,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.2,\"order_score_correlation\":0.7966985776057849,\"q1_1_10\":6.106249999999999,\"q3_1_10\":6.2093750000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.19986540610009415,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.175,\"order_score_correlation\":0.5903759602537456,\"q1_1_10\":6.074999999999999,\"q3_1_10\":6.331249999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.19394031871228376,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.15,\"order_score_correlation\":0.5660209128224242,\"q1_1_10\":6.1625000000000005,\"q3_1_10\":6.425000000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.17544091281365604,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":6.0,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3166702619012438,\"q1_1_10\":5.9,\"q3_1_10\":6.15,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.19547396103942954,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":5.85,\"order_score_correlation\":0.5600232564403035,\"q1_1_10\":5.690625,\"q3_1_10\":5.8812500000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.2436734210190171,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":5.6,\"order_score_correlation\":0.6990488368307515,\"q1_1_10\":5.18125,\"q3_1_10\":5.718749999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.475951167546513,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":5.50625,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.37549389671992817,\"q1_1_10\":5.231249999999999,\"q3_1_10\":5.875000000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.36429393275821165,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":5.425,\"order_score_correlation\":0.6096577665773019,\"q1_1_10\":5.0,\"q3_1_10\":6.624999999999999,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.9284479656932854,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":5.4,\"order_score_correlation\":0.5302964129102761,\"q1_1_10\":5.159375,\"q3_1_10\":5.393750000000001,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.31673518995456695,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":4.925,\"order_score_correlation\":0.028437561790822654,\"q1_1_10\":4.8,\"q3_1_10\":5.1,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.1738104411260856,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":4.875,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.3222012093119984,\"q1_1_10\":4.5718749999999995,\"q3_1_10\":5.0687500000000005,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.3037525720055717,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":4.65,\"order_score_correlation\":0.3656180699202944,\"q1_1_10\":4.525,\"q3_1_10\":4.8374999999999995,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.29297622675644597,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":4.175,\"order_score_correlation\":0.4285476204612318,\"q1_1_10\":3.7406250000000005,\"q3_1_10\":4.3875,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.36621420947612376,\"top3_probability\":0.0},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"ensemble_family_median_1_10\":3.0812500000000003,\"order_score_correlation\":-0.5509319507990764,\"q1_1_10\":2.95,\"q3_1_10\":3.8499999999999996,\"rank1_probability\":0.0,\"sd_all_samples\":0.5063502987063403,\"top3_probability\":0.0}],\"calibration\":{\"items\":[{\"control_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[8,10],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":10.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[7,10],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":9.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[7,10],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":9.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[7,10],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":9.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[7,10],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":9.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-consensus-guardian\",\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[7,10],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":9.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[1,4],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":3.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[1,3],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":2.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[1,4],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":2.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[3,7],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":4.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[1,4],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":2.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-partisan-celebrity\",\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[6,9],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":7.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[4,7],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":5.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[5,8],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":7.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[3,6],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":5.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[4,7],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":5.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[5,8],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":7.0},{\"control_id\":\"control-unknown-technocrat\",\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"distance_to_range\":0.0,\"expected_range\":[1,4],\"in_range\":true,\"observed\":3.0}],\"pass_count\":18,\"pass_rate\":1.0,\"total_count\":18},\"criterion_diagnostics\":[{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.5625,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3425800798515744},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3333333333333333},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.25,\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.75,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.6875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4289845892077917},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5374838498865699},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":6,\"low\":0,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6236095644623235},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":8.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6346477588219923},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4417452760232857},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.2898754521821014},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6146362971528592},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5400617248673217},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.625,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":8.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5773502691896257},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23717082451262844},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5374838498865699},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3689323936863109},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.5,\"q1\":4.875,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":1.7919573407620817},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":3,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.75,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":1.7646214576755233},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":5.5625,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4779876799899996},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.75,\"entity_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":8,\"low\":0,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.2486072315029383},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.625,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6795627679291705},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.625,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.5,\"entity_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4714045207910317},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3689323936863109},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.5,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.2486072315029383},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.625,\"q3\":9.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6687467549246293},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":10.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":10.0,\"q3\":10.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4479893351905204},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3944053188733077},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.75,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.125,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6687467549246293},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4479893351905204},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3689323936863109},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6241661103691335},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.485912657903775},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":4,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6258327785172862},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.5,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5797509043642028},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.485912657903775},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.5625,\"q3\":5.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.601502747753953},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":2.25,\"q3\":3.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.67700320038633},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.25,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":8,\"low\":0,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.26352313834736496},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.485912657903775},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.25,\"entity_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5006939628599933},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.75,\"entity_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5502524673073059},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":6,\"low\":0,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.24152294576982397},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.75,\"entity_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":4.5,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.26352313834736496},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":8,\"low\":0,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6236095644623235},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.3125,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4289845892077917},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.724568837309472},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":7,\"low\":0,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.625,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3689323936863109},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21245914639969937},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.485912657903775},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":6,\"low\":0,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.415832498329155},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.25,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5892556509887896},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":4,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":5,\"low\":0,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.25,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21245914639969937},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4116363011742823},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5986094998689324},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.125,\"q3\":6.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5329425651773161},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5502524673073059},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.625,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.75,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4116363011742823},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5400617248673217},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":8,\"low\":0,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.35843021946010944},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5296749527356901},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.625,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4116363011742823},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.5,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3535533905932738},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21245914639969937},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.4375,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5533985905294664},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":4,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.25,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.26352313834736496},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.125,\"q3\":6.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.7168604389202189},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.37360852952433155},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3333333333333333},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.24152294576982397},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.18446619684315546},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.5,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.35843021946010944},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4714045207910317},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.24152294576982397},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.18446619684315546},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.75,\"entity_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.125,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.625,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":1,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.18446619684315546},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.625,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4714045207910317},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.5,\"entity_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.125,\"q3\":10.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4417452760232857},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.5,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":8.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.5,\"entity_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.125,\"q3\":10.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.75,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0625,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4721405158071765},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.5,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.4375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5779513628133234},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.125,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3535533905932738},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.33437337746231466},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.75,\"entity_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5374838498865699},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.3125,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4417452760232857},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.5,\"q3\":6.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4714045207910317},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":8,\"low\":0,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":10.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":10.0,\"q3\":10.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":75,\"medium\":45},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3137823827965831},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":103,\"low\":0,\"medium\":17},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3121040909463286},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":103,\"low\":0,\"medium\":17},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15149812101893842},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":110,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.1560520454731643},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":115},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.32399380981049347},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":120,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":10.0,\"entity_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":10.0,\"q3\":10.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0901290702255376},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.18446619684315546},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":7,\"low\":0,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.5,\"entity_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.75,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6582805886043833},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.25,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.4375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.415832498329155},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.125,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":2,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5296749527356901},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":1.0804448672241962},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":2.0,\"q1\":6.25,\"q3\":7.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":1.055409346599171},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.75,\"entity_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.8755950357709131},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6146362971528592},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.625,\"q3\":6.4375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5062114182829147},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5797509043642028},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":4,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.25,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5868938953886337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.5,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":9.0625,\"q3\":9.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31732387941099616},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5400617248673217},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":6,\"low\":0,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0625,\"q3\":5.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31732387941099616},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":3.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":5,\"low\":0,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3944053188733077},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.23570226039551584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.5,\"q3\":6.4375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5921946001479956},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5400617248673217},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.25,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.75,\"entity_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5773502691896257},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.5,\"entity_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":9.0625,\"q3\":9.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31732387941099616},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":6,\"low\":0,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":8,\"low\":0,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.07905694150420949},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.625,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5374838498865699},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4714045207910317},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.1875,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4721405158071765},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4417452760232857},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.5,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":10.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.625,\"q3\":10.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3496029493900505},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.39528470752104744},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.5,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":5,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5676462121975467},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21081851067789195},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.8125,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.415832498329155},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":7,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":5,\"low\":0,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":1.3335937245736507},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.83166499665831},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":2.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.9486832980505138},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.8514693182963201},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":2.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":1.4944341180973262},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4721405158071765},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.75,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6433419688539594},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.75,\"entity_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0625,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4721405158071765},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":3,\"low\":0,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.625,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4714045207910317},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.25,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":117,\"low\":0,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.2986899500728302},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":119},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.33041439052769345},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":119},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15149812101893842},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":120},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.1560520454731643},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":119,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.375,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4026348791875529},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":116,\"low\":0,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.21433239454207584},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.4375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.415832498329155},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5892556509887896},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":7,\"low\":0,\"medium\":3},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.33437337746231466},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.5,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.408248290463863},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.25,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5868938953886337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3944053188733077},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.625,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5432668671002208},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":4.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.1687371394276382},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.42491829279939874},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.75,\"entity_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.5,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4116363011742823},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.25,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6061032181989394},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":4.5,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5400617248673217},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.25,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":9,\"low\":0,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.4375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5170697352496191},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.5,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":4.25,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5797509043642028},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.125,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.625,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5779513628133234},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.25819888974716115},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.25,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5374838498865699},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.125,\"entity_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":5.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5533985905294664},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":2.5,\"q3\":3.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6582805886043833},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.75,\"entity_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":5.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":8.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.125,\"entity_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":3.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5533985905294664},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":2.0,\"entity_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":1.625,\"q3\":2.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6324555320336759},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":2.0,\"entity_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":2.0,\"q3\":3.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5797509043642028},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":5,\"low\":0,\"medium\":5},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5374838498865699},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":6,\"medium\":4},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.1875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4779876799899996},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3333333333333333},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":10,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.0},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":4,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.18446619684315546},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":5.5,\"entity_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":5.5,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.724568837309472},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":4.0,\"q3\":5.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5163977794943223},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":9,\"medium\":1},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":7.8125,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.33437337746231466},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.7090682462060882},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":1,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.25,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.485912657903775},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.15811388300841897},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":4.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.25,\"q3\":4.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.582737791234903},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.5,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":3.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.485912657903775},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":3.75,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.48304589153964794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":1,\"low\":0,\"medium\":9},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":3.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":3.0,\"q3\":3.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5296749527356901},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4972144630058766},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":4,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.875,\"entity_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":6.125,\"q3\":7.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.46022337571613586},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3535533905932738},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.5,\"entity_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5270462766947299},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.31622776601683794},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.28382310609877337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.25,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.9375,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4479893351905204},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.0,\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5868938953886337},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.0,\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.0,\"q3\":6.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.3374742788552764},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.0,\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":7.5,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4216370213557839},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":4,\"low\":0,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":6.625,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.6146362971528592},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":10,\"low\":0,\"medium\":0},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":9.0,\"q3\":9.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.4743416490252569},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":8,\"medium\":2},\"criterion_id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"ensemble_family_median\":6.5,\"entity_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"q1\":6.125,\"q3\":6.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5329425651773161},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"political_independence\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.25,\"entity_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.0,\"q3\":8.875,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5296749527356901},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":3,\"medium\":7},\"criterion_id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.75,\"entity_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":1.0,\"q1\":7.125,\"q3\":8.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.45946829173634074},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":2,\"low\":0,\"medium\":8},\"criterion_id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"ensemble_family_median\":8.5,\"entity_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.43779751788545657},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":0,\"low\":0,\"medium\":10},\"criterion_id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"ensemble_family_median\":7.25,\"entity_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":7.0,\"q3\":7.5,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5797509043642028},{\"between_model_sd\":0.0,\"confidence_counts\":{\"high\":4,\"low\":0,\"medium\":6},\"criterion_id\":\"international_representation\",\"ensemble_family_median\":9.0,\"entity_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"prompt_sensitivity\":0.5,\"q1\":8.125,\"q3\":9.0,\"within_model_sd_median\":0.5892556509887896}],\"excluded_run_count\":0,\"valid_families\":[\"openai\"],\"valid_run_count\":120,\"variance_summary\":{\"median_between_model_sd\":0.0,\"median_prompt_sensitivity\":0.0,\"median_within_model_sd\":0.4216370213557839}},\"construct_disclosure\":\"An anchored ordinal expression of the model's subjective evaluative impression. It is not a probability, measurement of truth, or calibrated human-opinion estimate.\",\"criteria\":[{\"default_weight\":25,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of likely commitment to constitutional restraint, legal process, and institutional checks.\",\"id\":\"constitutional_guardianship\",\"label\":\"Constitutional guardianship\"},{\"default_weight\":20,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of likely autonomy from party command, patrons, and short-term factional incentives.\",\"id\":\"political_independence\",\"label\":\"Political independence\"},{\"default_weight\":20,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of cross-group acceptability, symbolic inclusion, and low polarizing burden.\",\"id\":\"capacity_to_unite\",\"label\":\"Capacity to unite\"},{\"default_weight\":15,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of integrity, credibility, accountability, and likely public trust.\",\"id\":\"public_trust_integrity\",\"label\":\"Public trust and integrity\"},{\"default_weight\":10,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of capacity to lead a complex public institution responsibly.\",\"id\":\"institutional_leadership\",\"label\":\"Institutional leadership\"},{\"default_weight\":10,\"definition\":\"The model's subjective assessment of diplomatic presence, international credibility, and ability to represent Hungary abroad.\",\"id\":\"international_representation\",\"label\":\"International representation\"}],\"run_statuses\":[{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"direct_anchored\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":1,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":2,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":3,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":4,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04\",\"status\":\"valid\"},{\"model\":\"gpt-5.6-sol\",\"model_family\":\"openai\",\"prompt_variant\":\"reflective_independent\",\"repetition\":5,\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05\",\"status\":\"valid\"}]}\n" }, "scoring_runs": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 1164791512869634211, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas", "control-unknown-technocrat", "andras-baka", "adam-fischer", "andras-sajo", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:daa64438df63d3fc54071389b47ca69c4a7a72bd203a8878160b7f947440a995", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:18+02:00", "duration_s": 103.359, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21464, "output_tokens": 3993, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural stature is broadly attractive, but his political criticism may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public democratic commitments are favorable, but he lacks direct constitutional or legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained leadership of major musical organizations is relevant but not equivalent to public administration." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally celebrated conducting career provides exceptional cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international artistic career suggests autonomy, although outspoken political positioning reduces perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished career and willingness to state principles support credibility and personal accountability." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and a relatively nonpartisan profile give him broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing is favorable, but I know little demonstrating direct constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research programs is relevant but differs materially from directing a constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific prominence would provide unusually strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic reputation supports credibility, although public-office accountability is untested." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He carries rule-of-law credibility but also political associations arising from past institutional conflict." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior judicial and European human-rights experience strongly indicates commitment to legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest court demonstrates extensive capacity to direct a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial service gives him exceptional international legal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial career and institutional conflict with governing power suggest substantial autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial record supports credibility, though his public profile may be interpreted through partisan divisions." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise commands respect, but an elite legal profile may have limited broad symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional scholarship and European judicial service directly support strong guardianship credentials." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic responsibilities indicate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial prominence and international scholarship provide exceptional representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An international judicial and academic career suggests substantial distance from short-term party command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and judicial standing supports high credibility with limited recalled integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A sober economics profile could attract cross-group respect but offers limited popular symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-service and academic profile suggests procedural seriousness, though constitutional work was not central." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, university, and organizational leadership provide strong evidence of executive competence." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and economic experience supports credible representation without a major diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic reputation suggests autonomy despite prior service in a party-led government." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long academic and professional career conveys credibility and responsible public engagement." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient recalled public-profile information leaves his cross-group appeal genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited familiarity provides no firm basis for judging his commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently recall enough relevant leadership history to move from the uncertain anchor." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack a reliable internal representation of his diplomatic or international standing." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently place his relationship to party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack confident information supporting either a strong trust judgment or a serious reservation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge match this criterion exceptionally." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity to steward complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience combined with constitutional stature indicates exceptional international readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments provide unusually strong evidence of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding complement a long record of trusted service." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global fame cannot offset the profile's explicitly highly polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile offers no legal experience and combines party campaigning with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Substantial international recognition supports presence abroad despite weak diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity standing may generate loyalty, but the profile supplies little basis for public-institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Low visibility and insufficient evidence make broader unifying appeal genuinely indeterminate." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Nonpartisan competent service is favorable, but the profile supplies no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide strong evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A career without known party office strongly supports operational independence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competent management is mildly favorable, but broader trust and accountability evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement provides rare, broadly shared national symbolism with low partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but offers little direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research and biotechnology experience shows responsibility, though large public-institution leadership is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-recognized global scientific stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally rooted scientific career appears highly independent of domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation strongly support trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional style appears broadly acceptable but lacks an obvious mass unifying constituency." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and diplomatic background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court and serving diplomatically demonstrate strong stewardship of complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European institutional experience indicates exceptional representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial profile suggests autonomy, though senior public appointments create some uncertainty about political distance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long legal and diplomatic career gives him substantial credibility with limited recalled integrity concerns." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized Hungary's government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural stature.", "Visible commitment to stated civic principles." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Political outspokenness may limit cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He has held a professorship at Northeastern University.", "His work helped popularize scale-free network research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected scientific achievement.", "Substantial distance from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership remains untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "His premature removal from judicial office became the subject of a European human-rights judgment." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional senior judicial experience.", "Demonstrated institutional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Past constitutional conflict may polarize reception.", "Less obvious appeal outside legal-institutional audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He was associated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong international judicial credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile.", "Academic-legal stature may not translate into symbolic unity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's economy minister.", "He was rector of the Budapest University of Economic Sciences and Public Administration.", "He founded the Hungarian Competitiveness Research Centre." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced institutional manager.", "Credible technocratic and academic profile." ], "reservations": [ "Prior government service affects neutrality perceptions.", "Limited constitutional and diplomatic specialization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confident positive assessment beyond the rubric midpoint.", "Potential strengths cannot be evaluated reliably." ], "reservations": [ "Identity and career profile are insufficiently familiar.", "All criterion judgments therefore remain highly uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international scientific credibility.", "Broadly unifying nonpartisan symbolism." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public-sector executive leadership is comparatively untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-political unifying profile.", "Senior appointments complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based only on internal recall for real figures and only on supplied descriptions for synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 2460193204170615866, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "andras-sajo", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "balazs-gulyas", "adam-fischer", "attila-chikan", "control-unknown-technocrat", "andras-baka" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:c58d23c1f871f54a3be80ca4cdec35e46070629a50984505d0e4c276371e09e1", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:26+02:00", "duration_s": 111.609, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21464, "output_tokens": 5526, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural eminence offers symbolic reach, but his vocal political criticism may alienate substantial groups." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy suggests concern for democratic norms, but he lacks direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major orchestras demonstrates organizational authority, though not constitutional administration." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His eminent international conducting career provides exceptional cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is independent of party machinery, although outspoken political positions reduce perceptions of neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished career and willingness to state principled positions support a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and transnational Hungarian identity offer broad symbolic appeal with limited partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests analytical seriousness but provides little direct constitutional grounding." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of major research groups is relevant, but differs materially from constitutional public leadership." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global academic stature and cross-border career would translate into strong international representation." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reputation rests primarily on international scientific work rather than party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research career supports credibility, though public-service accountability is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial dignity supports broad respect, but past institutional conflict may retain partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior domestic and European judicial service creates a very strong rule-of-law impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service as chief justice demonstrates directly relevant leadership of a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European human-rights judicial experience provides exceptional international institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His conflict with governing authorities while defending judicial institutions strongly suggests independence." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial record and defense of institutional autonomy support a very strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His stature could command respect, though his liberal constitutional profile may carry partisan polarization." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law scholarship and judicial experience create a very strong guardianship impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic roles indicate strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent European legal career gives him exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional identity appears substantially grounded in law and scholarship rather than party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished legal career supports credibility, tempered by controversy surrounding judicial ethics." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A moderate technocratic profile could bridge groups, although it lacks broad popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-service and academic background suggest institutional seriousness, though not specialized constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, university, and organizational leadership provide substantial directly relevant experience." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economics and academic background would support credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic reputation and later critical distance from government support substantial independence." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic stature and reputation for measured criticism support strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International scientific standing helps, but limited broad public familiarity and institutional controversy constrain appeal." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall insufficient direct evidence of constitutional or rule-of-law work to move beyond a mixed assessment." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research leadership provides relevant management experience despite uncertainty about broader institutional performance." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An international neuroscience career supports credible representation in global academic and diplomatic settings." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career suggests some autonomy, but his current institutional position complicates the impression." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional distinction is positive, while limited familiarity and controversy around research governance leave substantial uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability beyond one political camp." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile describes exceptional, sustained commitment to constitutional law and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of senior rule-of-law service across governments indicates substantial leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability exceptionally unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no constitutional experience and indicates polarizing factional engagement." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates extremely weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is a meaningful asset, although polarizing rhetoric limits diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived independence from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but the profile provides little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility and trust information leave unifying capacity uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly reassuring, but the profile provides no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong but not exceptional institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supplies a modest positive signal, but broader integrity and accountability evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement provides unusually broad and nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record suggests seriousness and responsibility but offers little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but leadership of a complex constitutional institution is less demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her public standing derives overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than partisan affiliation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and restrained public persona support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal profile appears broadly respectable without supplying a powerful popular unifying symbol." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and human-rights judicial experience strongly supports commitment to legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major judicial institutions demonstrates directly relevant administrative and constitutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial service gives him strong diplomatic presence and international institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports autonomy, though prior proximity to state institutions creates some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long senior judicial career supports credibility and an impression of professional responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor with an international career.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized the Hungarian government's democratic record." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional cultural representation abroad.", "Visible willingness to defend stated principles." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken political positions may reduce unifying capacity.", "He lacks direct constitutional administration experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He is associated with Northeastern University.", "He is widely known for research on scale-free networks." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Relatively low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional-law experience.", "Public institutional accountability remains largely untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "The European Court found that his premature removal violated his rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong demonstrated commitment to judicial independence.", "Direct domestic and European institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Past conflict with the government may retain partisan resonance.", "His unifying appeal beyond legal and civic audiences is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He was involved in a disclosed judicial-ethics controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong European institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "His ideological profile may limit cross-group appeal.", "The ethics controversy weakens an otherwise strong trust impression." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as Hungary's economy minister in the first Orbán government.", "He served as rector of Corvinus University's predecessor institution." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong academic and organizational leadership.", "Technocratic standing with some critical distance from party government." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law experience.", "His former government role may affect perceptions of neutrality." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He has held senior research roles in Singapore.", "He became head of Hungary's HUN-REN research network." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial international scientific experience.", "Current experience leading a large research institution." ], "reservations": [ "Limited basis for judging constitutional commitment.", "Research-governance controversy complicates trust and independence assessments." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional nonpartisan international stature.", "Broadly admired record of scientific perseverance." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Public-institution leadership capacity is not well demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has an academic background in constitutional law and political thought." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Directly relevant constitutional leadership.", "Strong European judicial credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public symbolic appeal.", "Past proximity to state institutions leaves some independence uncertainty." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are anchored ordinal expressions of my rubric-conditioned subjective impression, based only on the supplied controls and my unbrowsed internal representation of the named figures.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 14214491833999797236, "entity_order": [ "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "adam-fischer", "attila-chikan", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "balazs-gulyas", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:a4e16f30ca550f26e9f53f422bfeb19f21d8d2dc6a9b6a93a97f0fd85c58805e", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:32+02:00", "duration_s": 118.14, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21216, "output_tokens": 5466, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige broadens his appeal, while outspoken criticism creates a significant polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public advocacy suggests democratic commitment, but he lacks a legal or constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major musical organizations shows management ability but only partial transfer to public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international cultural stature and extensive work abroad make representation a major strength." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears institutionally independent despite taking conspicuous positions on political questions." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished career and forthright public posture support credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and a relatively nonpartisan image give him broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific distinction provides little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Running major research programs indicates leadership, albeit in institutions unlike the presidency." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific reputation and cross-border career would provide exceptional representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally established scientific career appears largely independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent research career supports competence and credibility, though public-office accountability is untested." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has institutional stature but remains associated with a polarizing rule-of-law conflict." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial career and association with defending judicial independence indicate very strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major national and European judicial institutions demonstrates relevant capacity." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior European judicial experience would translate well into international representation." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His professional record suggests substantial autonomy from governing-party pressure." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial standing and willingness to challenge institutional interference support credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He offers intellectual authority but may be perceived as belonging to a distinct liberal constitutional tradition." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in constitutional scholarship and European human-rights adjudication strongly matches this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has substantial judicial and academic experience, with less visible executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent European legal career gives him exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and judicial profile appears substantially independent of party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional record supports credibility, though his domestic public profile is limited." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A sober expert profile and experience spanning political contexts could support moderate consensus." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technocratic reputation is reassuring, but constitutional guardianship is not central to his known record." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ministerial, academic, and organizational leadership provide strong evidence of administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economics and academic background offers credible but not exceptional diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic identity and later critical distance from government suggest meaningful autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding academic and policy reputation conveys seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International scientific credentials help, but domestic institutional controversy may constrain consensus." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific-administrative profile supplies little affirmative evidence of constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific and organizational roles demonstrate substantial leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His extensive international scientific career supports strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His leadership of a government-created research network raises uncertainty about distance from current power." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing is positive, while limited familiarity and institutional controversy leave trust uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan record indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make the profile exceptionally strong." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding create a very strong trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and combines partisanship with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global fame provides presence and recognition, though polarization limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong alignment with party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may confer credibility for some, but partisanship and polarization substantially weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unestablished." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is established, but the profile supplies no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly indicates solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her achievement, personal story, and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career offers little evidence about constitutional judgment or legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific leadership is evident, but responsibility for a complex public institution is less demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global recognition would give Hungary extraordinary international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority rests overwhelmingly on scientific accomplishment rather than party affiliation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and globally validated scientific work create a very strong credibility profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal and diplomatic profile carries relatively little polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European human-rights experience strongly supports legal-process orientation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership in constitutional adjudication and diplomatic service is directly relevant." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience indicates strong international representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His judicial stature supports autonomy, but establishment appointments leave some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long senior legal career supports credibility, though public familiarity is limited." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an internationally known Hungarian conductor.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized political conditions in Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural presence.", "Demonstrated independence and civic engagement." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional or public-administration background.", "His political interventions may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He is associated with the Barabási-Albert model of scale-free networks.", "He has led research at Northeastern University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected and largely nonpartisan.", "Strong scientific and institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "No demonstrated constitutional role.", "Public-office accountability remains untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as President of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "The European Court of Human Rights ruled concerning the premature termination of his mandate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law profile.", "Substantial judicial leadership experience." ], "reservations": [ "His domestic institutional conflict may remain polarizing.", "His broader mass-public appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held prominent international academic positions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong European credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited visible executive experience.", "His intellectual profile may not bridge every political constituency." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as Hungary's economy minister in the first Orbán government.", "He served as rector of Corvinus University's predecessor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Serious technocratic and managerial background.", "Appears capable of independent policy judgment." ], "reservations": [ "His constitutional record is not prominent.", "His public symbolic reach appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He worked for many years in Sweden and Singapore.", "He became president of the Hungarian Research Network." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial international scientific experience.", "Demonstrated research-organizational leadership." ], "reservations": [ "His political independence is difficult to assess.", "His constitutional and broad public-trust profiles are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years at the University of Pennsylvania." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international credibility.", "Broadly admired nonpartisan achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little evidence of constitutional expertise.", "Limited experience leading complex public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as President of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Combines constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "Carries a restrained institutional profile." ], "reservations": [ "His independence from establishment networks is not fully clear to me.", "His domestic public appeal is difficult to assess." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are anchored ordinal expressions of my internal rubric-conditioned impressions, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 12810057403865351850, "entity_order": [ "attila-chikan", "control-partisan-celebrity", "andras-sajo", "control-consensus-guardian", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "balazs-gulyas", "katalin-kariko", "andras-baka", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "adam-fischer" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d127385ad97a4d46c0ed895af7f9d878b84e08ef0f9c8746791c6c11a07b34e7", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:01+02:00", "duration_s": 86.937, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21216, "output_tokens": 3963, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction offers symbolic reach, but explicit political criticism may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public defense of civic principles suggests respect for constitutional values despite limited legal experience." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major orchestras and cultural institutions demonstrates substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His eminent international conducting career gives him very strong cultural and diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international artistic career provides autonomy, though his outspoken political positions reduce perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished career and willingness to state principled positions support strong personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and transnational Hungarian identity could carry broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly orientation suggests procedural seriousness, but his record offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research groups indicates strong management capacity with limited public-sector evidence." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific standing would provide very strong international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career appears substantially independent of domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent research reputation supports credibility, though that does not fully establish public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled institutional standing could unite constitutionalists, though past conflict may remain polarizing." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior judicial career and defense of judicial independence align exceptionally with constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest court demonstrates very strong capacity to manage a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial background provides very strong international institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial record suggests very strong independence from partisan command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial service and willingness to defend institutional autonomy support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institutional stature is broadly respectable, though elite legal prominence does not ensure popular consensus." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in constitutional law and supranational adjudication represents exceptional alignment with this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior judicial service demonstrates strong capacity within complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive European judicial experience gives him strong international credibility and representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial and scholarly career suggests substantial autonomy from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished legal record supports credibility, with limited basis for judging mass public trust." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature could reassure several groups, but his public profile has limited mass reach." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and institution-oriented record suggests strong respect for legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior academic and governmental management experience indicates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economics and academic background supports credible representation, though diplomacy is not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic identity and later critical distance from government suggest meaningful autonomy despite prior political service." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects expertise, seriousness, and personal credibility with few prominent integrity concerns in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific stature may help, but limited broad public visibility leaves unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack enough direct evidence about his commitment to constitutional checks beyond general institutional service." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior leadership in large research institutions indicates substantial organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific career suggests strong credibility and ease in representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career supports some autonomy, while senior state-linked leadership creates uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic standing is favorable, but I lack sufficient knowledge for a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide unusually strong evidence of inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the strongest anchor." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe burden on cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither rule-of-law experience nor evidence of institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of legal or institutional leadership experience makes this a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides presence abroad despite limited evidence of diplomatic capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly indicates factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity standing may inspire loyalty, but the profile gives little basis for public-institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides clear evidence of strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports a strong but not conclusive independence judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but information about integrity and public trust is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely respected scientific achievement offers exceptional cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research career shows responsibility and influence, though less evidence of leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global recognition and scientific prestige make her an outstanding international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and authority appear strongly independent of domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured institutional profile is broadly acceptable but lacks obvious mass symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal scholarship indicate very strong commitment to constitutional process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Constitutional-court leadership demonstrates very strong command of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European legal experience strongly supports representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic record suggests substantial autonomy, though establishment roles invite some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained senior legal service supports credibility with few salient integrity concerns in my recollection." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He has led internationally prominent orchestras and opera productions.", "He has publicly criticized Hungarian political developments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international cultural prestige.", "Demonstrated leadership of complex artistic institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken political positions may limit cross-group acceptance.", "No direct legal or constitutional leadership experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He developed influential work on scale-free networks.", "He has led research at Northeastern University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally recognized intellectual stature.", "Strong independence from domestic party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited public-sector leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as President of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "His premature removal from judicial office led to a prominent European human-rights case." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional judicial-independence credentials.", "Extensive national and European institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Past institutional conflict may provoke partisan opposition.", "Limited evidence of broad popular appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held senior international academic positions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong European institutional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular visibility.", "Elite legal stature may not translate into social unity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as Hungary's economy minister.", "He held senior leadership roles at Corvinus University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial institutional-management experience.", "Technocratic credibility beyond ordinary party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Prior government service complicates complete independence.", "Limited mass-public symbolic appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international career.", "He has held senior leadership in Hungary's research-network system." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific and managerial background.", "Substantial international professional exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Insufficient familiarity with his public record.", "State-linked institutional role leaves independence uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired perseverance and scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not itself establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as President of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He is a constitutional-law scholar.", "He later held a senior diplomatic post in Rome." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and institutional experience.", "Strong combination of legal and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Long establishment service may invite independence questions.", "Limited mass-public visibility." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representation of real figures and exclusively to the supplied descriptions of synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 9188297756962671172, "entity_order": [ "attila-chikan", "peter-paczolay", "andras-baka", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-sajo", "katalin-kariko", "balazs-gulyas", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:f62e936874d0002cf9febc7ae2a803a4c22c96d7aea228d55b516fef63e992eb", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:18+02:00", "duration_s": 103.343, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21464, "output_tokens": 4043, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural eminence offers symbolic reach, but explicit political criticism may limit cross-camp acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public defense of democratic values is favorable, though he lacks a legal or constitutional service record." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major orchestras demonstrates organizational authority, though public administration differs substantially." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally recognized musical career gives him exceptional cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His outspoken civic positions appear personally grounded rather than directed by party office." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished career and visible willingness to bear costs for stated principles support credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific prestige and limited partisan identification give him broad, relatively low-conflict appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic profile is compatible with procedural seriousness, but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research programs indicates strong intellectual and organizational leadership with limited public-sector evidence." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific prominence and cross-border career would provide outstanding international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally based scientific career suggests substantial autonomy from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High scientific standing supports credibility, although public-office accountability has not been tested." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled institutional profile could unite rule-of-law constituencies but may remain polarizing to government loyalists." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial record and defense of judicial independence indicate exceptional commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service as Hungary's chief judge demonstrates high-level institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive European judicial background provides strong international credibility and diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His willingness to criticize reforms affecting the judiciary strongly signals autonomy from governing power." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His professional judicial standing and vindication in European proceedings support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority could reassure institutionalists, but his liberal constitutional identity may limit cross-camp acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in constitutional scholarship and European adjudication indicates very strong commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic responsibilities indicate strong capacity for institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Prominent European legal service and scholarship provide exceptional international standing." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and supranational judicial profile suggests substantial independence from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished legal record supports credibility, though his broader domestic trust profile is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature could bridge moderate groups, but his public reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic record suggests respect for process, though constitutional stewardship was not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience leading academic and governmental institutions indicates strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and economic profile would support credible representation without exceptional diplomatic prominence." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later distance from party government supports autonomy, tempered by prior service in a partisan cabinet." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects serious academic credibility and personal integrity with few salient trust liabilities in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific stature is potentially inclusive, but his domestic institutional role may carry contested associations." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific and administrative profile provides insufficient evidence of commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research-system and academic roles indicate substantial experience managing complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long international scientific career supports strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His international career favors autonomy, but leadership within a government-reorganized research system creates uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic credentials support credibility, while limited familiarity prevents a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional unifying capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge exactly match exceptional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional stewardship of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience combined with senior legal stature indicates exceptional international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate exceptional autonomy from factions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional trust under the supplied profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of legal experience and recent partisan campaigning create substantial reservations about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no relevant experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational reach, but polarizing rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience materially weaken it." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Celebrity recognition does not establish integrity, while polarizing partisanship burdens broad public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader acceptance and symbolic reach are unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong leadership with limited detail about scale and complexity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patrons and informal dependencies remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers a modest positive signal while integrity and public trust remain substantially unobserved." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her exceptional cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional discipline is favorable, but her career provides almost no direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific excellence is clear, but experience directing a complex public institution is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global recognition would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international scientific career and lack of salient party alignment suggest high autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her achievement, perseverance, and scientific credibility support an exceptional trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad acceptance, but it supplies little mass symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial experience makes legal restraint a central strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership at the Constitutional Court demonstrates responsibility for a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic service indicate unusually strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, though establishment appointments create some residual uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial standing supports credibility, with limited public information available to test broader trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He has led internationally prominent orchestras and opera productions.", "He has publicly criticized Hungary's political direction." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural stature", "Visible commitment to democratic values" ], "reservations": [ "No constitutional-office experience", "Political criticism may reduce cross-group acceptance" ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He is associated with Northeastern University.", "He is known for work on scale-free networks." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected scientific figure", "Low domestic partisan burden" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Public-institution leadership remains untested" ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "The European Court found that his premature removal violated his rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated defense of judicial independence", "Extensive senior judicial experience" ], "reservations": [ "Could face partisan resistance", "Limited experience outside judicial institutions" ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He was involved in founding Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional rule-of-law expertise", "Strong international legal credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad-popular profile", "May be viewed through ideological divisions" ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as economy minister in the first Orbán government.", "He served as rector of Corvinus University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced institutional leader", "Credible technocratic independence" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional specialization", "Prior partisan-government association" ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He worked for many years in international academia.", "He became president of Hungary's HUN-REN research network." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial scientific leadership", "Strong international experience" ], "reservations": [ "Domestic independence is difficult to assess", "Limited constitutional or diplomatic record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional cross-group prestige", "Outstanding international credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Minimal constitutional track record", "Limited public-administration leadership evidence" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served Hungary in a diplomatic role." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise", "Strong European representation" ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public profile", "Independence from appointing establishments is not fully testable" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors directly, using internal recall for real figures and only the provided descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 13390988037793603051, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "andras-sajo", "andras-baka", "balazs-gulyas", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "attila-chikan", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:1dff6147f4a0102096d396ef2156dbe6692e3e628edeb3ee61f27417b5062030", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:23+02:00", "duration_s": 109.0, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 4000, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige is inclusive for many, but his political criticism may carry a notable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public defense of democratic values is reassuring, though he lacks direct constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major orchestras and artistic institutions demonstrates substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His eminent international conducting career provides exceptional cultural and diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic stature and outspoken positions suggest personal autonomy despite clear political commitments." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished career and willingness to state principles support credibility, though reactions are politically divided." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific prominence offers broad, relatively non-partisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly reputation is positive, but it offers limited direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Directing major interdisciplinary research efforts suggests strong leadership of complex expert institutions." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific visibility and cross-border career provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific career appears highly autonomous from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained scholarly standing supports strong credibility, though public trust extends beyond academic reputation." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled judicial profile could command respect but remains associated with a major institutional conflict." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial career and defense of judicial independence create a very strong guardianship impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Experience leading Hungary's judiciary indicates substantial institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His service in European human-rights institutions gives him strong international standing." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His record suggests marked autonomy from governing-party pressure and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional record supports integrity, while his limited popular profile constrains confidence about public trust." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has high institutional stature but may be perceived through polarizing rule-of-law disputes." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in constitutionalism and human-rights adjudication strongly signals commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive judicial and academic responsibility suggests strong capacity to guide a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent European judicial and academic career provides exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and supranational judicial profile appears substantially independent of Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished legal record supports credibility, though elite institutional standing does not ensure broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate expert profile may attract multiple groups but has limited mass symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-service and academic profile suggests respect for institutions, though constitutional guardianship is not his core specialty." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior government, university, and organizational leadership indicate excellent administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and economic standing would translate well into credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic standing and later critical independence suggest substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic and professional career supports a strong impression of credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack a sufficiently clear representation of his cross-group standing or polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited familiarity provides too little basis to move far from an uncertain midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently recall experience demonstrating leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack reliable familiarity with diplomatic experience or international institutional standing." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently assess his distance from party or factional influence." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient confidently recalled information makes a neutral, uncertain assessment appropriate." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan profile imply unusually strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of constitutional service and documented non-partisanship exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cross-government leadership and the absence of party alignment strongly indicate exceptional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional perceived trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion distinctly unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal or institutional foundation and includes recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational presence despite weak diplomatic preparation and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate trust among admirers, but polarization and partisanship substantially weaken broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring but provides little evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong, though not exceptional, institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patronal relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers some reassurance, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievements provide a broadly shared source of national pride with low partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional ethos is reassuring, but her career offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated responsibility in complex scientific environments but limited visible public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature gives her exceptional credibility as an international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears strongly independent of domestic party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and international recognition create an exceptional trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile appears broadly acceptable but offers limited evidence of mass cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law background creates a very strong impression of commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court and holding senior diplomatic office indicate substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European legal experience make international representation a particular strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional standing and measured public role support a strong impression of credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an internationally prominent Hungarian conductor.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural stature.", "Demonstrated leadership and principled independence." ], "reservations": [ "His public political positions may limit unifying appeal.", "He lacks direct legal or governmental experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American network scientist.", "He is associated with the Barabási-Albert model of scale-free networks.", "He has led interdisciplinary network-science research in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected and broadly non-partisan scientific profile.", "Strong experience leading complex research institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or public-administration experience.", "Academic prominence does not ensure broad domestic trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "His premature removal from judicial leadership generated European litigation." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record of judicial independence.", "Substantial national and European leadership experience." ], "reservations": [ "Associated institutional conflict may polarize perceptions.", "Limited evidence of broad popular connection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held prominent international academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong independence and international standing." ], "reservations": [ "His profile is primarily elite and legal-academic.", "Rule-of-law controversies may limit cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's economy minister in the first Orbán government.", "He is an economist and former rector of Corvinus University's predecessor.", "He founded the Rajk College for Advanced Studies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive institutional and academic leadership.", "Technocratic credibility with visible independence." ], "reservations": [ "He has prior association with a partisan government.", "Constitutional law is outside his primary expertise." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confidently recalled basis for a strong negative judgment.", "An uncertain profile could carry limited preexisting polarization." ], "reservations": [ "Identity and career profile are insufficiently familiar.", "Institutional and diplomatic qualifications cannot be assessed confidently." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility and public esteem.", "Strong non-partisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not automatically imply public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong European diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments complicate certainty about political distance.", "His broader popular appeal is less established." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal representations only, treated uncertainty through confidence rather than omitted scores, and evaluated synthetic controls solely from their supplied profiles.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 250098973290186271, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "andras-baka", "attila-chikan", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "adam-fischer", "peter-paczolay", "andras-sajo", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:e86b859171f1538656fbddf1ae4bd541f9a2bc6fa9076384bdd82dbeb8bdf36b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:11+02:00", "duration_s": 96.812, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21248, "output_tokens": 3916, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige broadens appeal, but outspoken political criticism may divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy suggests commitment to democratic principles, though he lacks constitutional office experience." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major orchestras demonstrates substantial responsibility for complex organizations." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His eminent international conducting career would provide strong diplomatic and cultural presence." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career is institutionally separate from party politics despite conspicuous political positions." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished career and willingness to take principled public positions support credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific prominence and cross-border Hungarian identity offer broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific stature offers little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Directing major research teams indicates leadership capacity but differs from governing a public institution." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global academic recognition would make him a highly credible representative abroad." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An international scientific career suggests substantial distance from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A highly regarded research career supports credibility, though public-accountability evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Institutional stature helps, though past constitutional conflict may carry a polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial career and association with judicial independence indicate very strong constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest court demonstrates experience directing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior European and Hungarian judicial experience supports international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His professional record suggests meaningful autonomy from governing-party pressure." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial credibility and principled institutional posture support a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Intellectual authority helps, but a pronounced liberal constitutional profile may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional scholarship and European human-rights judicial service indicate deep commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic responsibilities show strong institutional competence, though less executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent European legal career provides excellent international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His transnational academic and judicial career suggests considerable autonomy from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and judicial standing supports substantial credibility." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A moderate academic and economic profile could attract support across several political camps." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-service and academic profile suggests respect for institutional process, though constitutional law is not his central field." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, university, and organizational leadership indicate strong managerial capacity." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and economic standing should translate into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later critical distance from party government supports a relatively independent impression." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding scholarly and professional reputation conveys credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International scientific standing may help, but his wider cross-group acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited familiarity provides insufficient basis to infer exceptional constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My recollection of senior research leadership suggests competence in complex organizations." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally oriented scientific career appears well suited to representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific profile suggests some professional autonomy, but institutional affiliations leave the overall impression uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific achievement supports credibility, while limited recall prevents a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability across political divides." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented non-partisan rule-of-law service represent an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership across governments demonstrates sustained command of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior legal stature provide very strong international presence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cross-government service and non-partisan standing strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented integrity record support exceptional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide little basis for expecting strong constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of institutional leadership experience is a major weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition would support visibility abroad despite limited diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity suggests substantial alignment with partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity standing may inspire some trust, but the profile supplies little evidence of accountability or institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly favorable, but the profile gives no direct rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken likely effectiveness abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, albeit with incomplete information." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is encouraging, while broader integrity and trust evidence remains insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation suggests responsibility, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in complex research institutions but lacks prominent public-institution leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific distinction would confer exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially detached from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific accomplishment and a perseverance-centered public image support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could be broadly acceptable without commanding universal enthusiasm." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and European judicial experience make this a central strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over the Constitutional Court demonstrates high-level institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and European judicial work provide unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial service supports autonomy, though prior proximity to political institutions warrants some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long senior judicial career supports a strong impression of credibility and responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an internationally prominent Hungarian conductor.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Major international cultural standing.", "Visible commitment to civic principles." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken political positions may polarize.", "No direct legal or state-administration experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-Romanian physicist known for network science.", "He has held a professorship at Northeastern University.", "His work helped popularize scale-free network models." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Independent and broadly appealing professional identity." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Research leadership does not fully establish public-sector leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "The European Court of Human Rights ruled in his favor concerning the premature termination of his mandate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep judicial and rule-of-law experience.", "Demonstrated resistance to institutional pressure." ], "reservations": [ "Past conflict may reduce cross-group acceptance.", "His experience is concentrated in the judiciary." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He taught at Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong European institutional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His ideological profile may limit broad acceptance.", "Less evidence of executive institutional leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's economy minister.", "He was rector of Corvinus University of Budapest.", "He is an economist and university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial academic and organizational leadership.", "Moderate professional profile with cross-group potential." ], "reservations": [ "Earlier government service creates some partisan association.", "Limited constitutional or diplomatic specialization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international academic career.", "He has held senior research leadership roles in Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific orientation.", "Apparent experience leading research institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Low familiarity makes broader trust judgments uncertain.", "Limited recalled evidence about constitutional or political independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She built much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired scientific perseverance." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record leading public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Rare combination of constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "Proven leadership of a senior public institution." ], "reservations": [ "Past political-institutional proximity complicates independence judgments.", "His public unifying appeal is less established than his expertise." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles or internal recall, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than as permission to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 2712398973103347870, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "andras-baka", "attila-chikan", "control-partisan-celebrity", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "control-consensus-guardian", "andras-sajo", "balazs-gulyas", "adam-fischer" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:85f52b397b191b7e8477af94e60da844974fa25fd65295f327b5ab0d2b10b578", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:19+02:00", "duration_s": 104.281, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 5458, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural stature offers symbolic reach, but visible political criticism may polarize domestic audiences." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public civic engagement is relevant, but he lacks a clear legal or constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Decades leading orchestras and artistic institutions demonstrate substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally prominent conducting career provides exceptional cultural and diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic career is institutionally independent, though outspoken political positions reduce perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long distinguished career and willingness to state principles support a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific prestige and a relatively nonpartisan image offer broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing is positive, but it offers little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research groups indicates management ability but not full public-institution experience." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global academic stature and cross-border career would translate well internationally." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international scientific career appears substantially independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research reputation supports credibility, though public trust outside science is less tested." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He offers principled institutional symbolism, though past political conflict may limit universal acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior domestic and European judicial record strongly signals commitment to legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading Hungary's highest ordinary court demonstrates substantial institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial experience supplies strong diplomatic presence and international legal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial posture and institutional conflict with political power suggest substantial autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His defense of judicial independence supports a particularly strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual authority may command respect, but an elite legal profile may have limited popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional scholarship and European judicial service strongly support guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic roles demonstrate competence without clearly establishing broad executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and international academic experience provide very strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic and judicial career suggests substantial autonomy from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished legal career supports credibility, though broader public perceptions are uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured expert profile could bridge groups, but his popular symbolic reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institutional and public-service background is reassuring, though constitutional law is not his core domain." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "University and governmental leadership provide unusually relevant executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and economic-policy profile suggests credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic standing supports autonomy, while prior ministerial service creates some partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic and institutional career supports credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific prestige may help, though limited broad familiarity and institutional controversy may constrain appeal." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific and administrative profile does not clearly reveal a constitutional philosophy." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Research and science-administration leadership indicate strong capacity to manage complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive international scientific career suggests very strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An international scientific career supports autonomy, but recent state-institution leadership complicates the assessment." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional distinction is favorable, but my limited recall prevents a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports exceptional international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide little basis for confidence in institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is valuable, though polarizing conduct weakens diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior campaign activity strongly indicates exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Fame supplies visibility but neither establishes integrity nor offsets the polarizing partisan profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly encouraging, but the profile provides no constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and little public visibility substantially weaken representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests independence, though patrons and incentives remain unclear." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, but the profile supplies insufficient evidence about trust and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation is encouraging, but it reveals little about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is substantial but does not directly establish leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career appears rooted in scientific work rather than party or factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her achievement-centered public image conveys credibility, perseverance, and low partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal profile could attract institutionalists across groups without guaranteeing popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial background strongly supports a restraint-oriented impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major constitutional institution indicates strong administrative and deliberative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience suggests exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, although prominent state appointments complicate a fully independent image." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service conveys credibility, with some uncertainty about broader public perceptions." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural standing", "Long record of organizational leadership" ], "reservations": [ "No legal or constitutional background", "Public political positions may limit unifying capacity" ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He is associated with the development of scale-free network theory.", "He has held a professorship at Northeastern University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected scientific profile", "Low domestic partisan burden" ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience", "Public-institution leadership is not well tested" ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He became president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "The European Court of Human Rights ruled in his favor concerning the premature termination of his mandate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong judicial-independence credentials", "Demonstrated institutional courage" ], "reservations": [ "Past conflict may remain polarizing", "Limited experience outside judicial institutions" ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He taught at Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise", "Strong European credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular visibility", "Academic profile may not translate into unifying appeal" ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as rector of the Budapest University of Economic Sciences.", "He served as economy minister in the first Orbán government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial institutional leadership", "Measured expert reputation" ], "reservations": [ "Prior government role creates partisan association", "Constitutional expertise is indirect" ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He spent a substantial part of his academic career in Singapore.", "He became president of Hungary's research-network organization." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive international scientific experience", "Relevant research-management background" ], "reservations": [ "Constitutional views are unclear", "Recent state role complicates independence assessment" ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional nonpartisan prestige", "Broad international credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience", "Limited public-sector executive record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise", "Strong international legal standing" ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-political profile", "State appointments may complicate perceived independence" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles and my unaided internal recall, treating uncertainty as confidence rather than omitted scoring.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 8093638709186100907, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "balazs-gulyas", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "attila-chikan", "control-consensus-guardian", "andras-baka", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-sajo" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:87a4664e86d14c45130e7448a6039e00c7f7e9823d348b3eeeb3441df0a4d547", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:35+02:00", "duration_s": 121.156, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21224, "output_tokens": 5574, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige creates broad appeal, but visible political criticism may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public commitment to civic principles is favorable, but he lacks a direct constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major musical organizations demonstrates real leadership, though outside public administration." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally prominent conducting career gives him exceptional cultural and diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic career is institutionally independent, although outspoken political positions reduce perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished career and willingness to state principled positions support strong personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and relatively low partisan salience support broad symbolic acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly profile is compatible with procedural seriousness but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research programs suggests strong organizational capacity, albeit outside government." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally recognized scientific career would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An international scientific career outside party structures suggests substantial political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent academic record supports credibility, though scientific prestige does not automatically establish public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial dignity supports broad respect, though past institutional conflict may carry some polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior judicial career and experience with European human-rights law strongly support constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service at the highest level of the judiciary demonstrates exceptional public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial experience provides unusually strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His record conveys substantial judicial independence from governing-party pressure." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His professional standing and defense of judicial independence create a very strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise commands respect, but an elite legal profile may have limited popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional scholarship and European judicial experience strongly fit institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic responsibilities indicate strong capacity for complex institutional work." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European legal career and international scholarly standing provide exceptional representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and judicial career suggests considerable autonomy from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished professional record supports trust, tempered by limited knowledge of broader public perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and academic standing offers cross-group credibility without broad popular symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-service and academic profile suggests respect for institutional process, though constitutional law is not his specialty." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior experience in government and university leadership demonstrates substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and economic-policy experience would support credible, if not especially prominent, representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His willingness to maintain an independent public profile after government service supports a strong assessment." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional record creates a strong impression of seriousness and personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A scientific profile may be broadly acceptable, but I cannot confidently assess his polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack enough specific knowledge to judge his commitment to constitutional checks beyond a neutral midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His association with scientific administration suggests relevant capacity, though my knowledge is limited." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally oriented scientific career suggests credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited familiarity leaves his practical autonomy from political patrons uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall insufficient reliable detail to move substantially above or below a mixed assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide unusually strong evidence of inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of documented rule-of-law service directly matches this criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports very strong international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply limits credible cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience is a major weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International recognition is valuable, but polarizing conduct weakens representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong alignment with short-term partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but the profile provides little basis for broad institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competence and nonpartisanship are mildly favorable, but the profile gives no constitutional track record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides solid evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience create a clear representational weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about wider trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad, low-partisanship symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public reputation suggests seriousness and integrity, but offers little direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding institutions, though large public-institution leadership is not her established specialty." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global stature and cross-border scientific career would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially independent of party organization and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and distinguished scientific record support a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile appears broadly acceptable, albeit without exceptional popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court experience provides a strong foundation for legal process and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court indicates substantial experience managing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European legal profile indicate strong representative competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic background suggests meaningful autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite scrutiny." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional record supports credibility, while my recall is insufficient for an unequivocal judgment." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor with a major international career.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He possesses exceptional international cultural stature.", "His public positions suggest principled independence." ], "reservations": [ "His outspoken political criticism may constrain cross-group acceptance.", "His leadership experience lies mainly outside public administration." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He is known for research on scale-free networks.", "He has held senior academic positions in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His international scientific stature offers broad symbolic appeal.", "His career appears substantially independent of party structures." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks direct constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "Research leadership differs materially from leading a state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "He previously served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "His premature removal from judicial office became the subject of a European human-rights judgment." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career strongly demonstrates judicial and constitutional experience.", "His record conveys independence under political pressure." ], "reservations": [ "His association with a major institutional conflict may remain polarizing.", "Judicial leadership does not guarantee broad popular connection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held international academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His expertise directly supports constitutional guardianship.", "His international legal standing supports diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His public profile may have limited mass appeal.", "I have less confidence about current public perceptions of him." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist and university professor.", "He served as Hungary's economy minister in the first Orbán government.", "He served as rector of Corvinus University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has substantial academic and executive leadership experience.", "His profile appears more technocratic than factional." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks a direct constitutional or judicial track record.", "His public appeal may be concentrated among professional and academic audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international academic career." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific experience may aid representation.", "A research background may reduce conventional partisan identification." ], "reservations": [ "My familiarity with his public record is low.", "I cannot confidently assess his independence or broader public trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with little partisan burden.", "A perseverance-centered public reputation supports trust." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks a substantial constitutional or governmental record.", "Scientific excellence does not itself demonstrate public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career directly combines constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "His professional style appears restrained and institutionally oriented." ], "reservations": [ "His popular unifying appeal is less evident than his professional credibility.", "Senior state appointments warrant some caution when judging independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real figures and exclusively from the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "adam-fischer", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "andras-baka", "andras-sajo", "attila-chikan", "balazs-gulyas" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 5149290103727392533, "entity_order": [ "balazs-gulyas", "andras-sajo", "control-partisan-celebrity", "attila-chikan", "control-unknown-technocrat", "adam-fischer", "andras-baka", "peter-paczolay", "control-consensus-guardian", "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:817bd82cc3390495cd14cca6568ed1c7297ffb8ddb87cd31f91ad6e96b1f6647", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:19:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:44+02:00", "duration_s": 129.89, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 5612, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction offers symbolic reach, but outspoken political positions may narrow cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic engagement suggests concern for democratic values, but he lacks a direct constitutional or legal record." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major orchestras demonstrates organizational authority, though public constitutional office presents different demands." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized conducting career gives him exceptional cultural presence and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career gives him a base relatively independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent career and willingness to state principles support credibility, notwithstanding partisan perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and a comparatively nonpartisan profile offer broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific distinction does not provide direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research programs indicates organizational capacity, with limited evidence about governing public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific reputation would provide exceptional visibility and intellectual credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An autonomous international scientific career suggests substantial independence from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished scholarly standing supports credibility, though it does not directly establish public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial stature supports institutional respect, but past conflict with governing authorities may carry polarizing associations." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior judicial career and association with judicial-independence litigation strongly support constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest court provides directly relevant experience managing a central public institution." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial experience provides substantial international credibility and representational competence." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His professional record gives a strong impression of independence from incumbent political command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior judicial service and defense of institutional independence support a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority could reassure institutionalists, although strong liberal-constitutional associations may limit cross-camp appeal." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His distinguished constitutional-law and human-rights career strongly signals commitment to legal checks and restraint." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior judicial service and extensive legal scholarship indicate strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international judicial and academic stature would provide substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and scholarly profile appears substantially independent of routine party command." }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent judicial and academic record supports credibility, though public familiarity may be limited." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A sober technocratic reputation could bridge groups, although limited mass visibility constrains symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and academic profile suggests respect for formal institutions, though constitutional law is not his central field." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior university, government, and organizational roles indicate exceptional institutional management experience." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economics and academic background supports credible representation, though diplomacy is not his defining expertise." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later academic and civic standing suggests meaningful autonomy despite prior government service." }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding academic and professional reputation gives me a strong impression of seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient familiarity leaves both his inclusive appeal and polarizing burden unclear." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited recall provides little direct evidence of sustained constitutional or rule-of-law stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My internal representation does not support a firm assessment of complex institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficiently specific recall of international standing or diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack enough reliable context to judge his autonomy from partisan or institutional pressures." }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall too little to form a confident impression of public credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile imply very strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge exactly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible and effective representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely despite widespread fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant legal experience and adds recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of institutional leadership experience indicates weak preparation for the role." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition helps visibility abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and inexperience constrain representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly undermines an impression of autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may confer familiarity, but the profile offers little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization, but broader acceptability and symbolic inclusion remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly encouraging, but the profile gives no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides solid evidence of responsible institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply below-average readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports a favorable but incomplete judgment of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, but the supplied information is insufficient to assess wider trust or integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Widely admired scientific achievement and low partisan identification create unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career offers little direct basis for assessing constitutional restraint or legal-process stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research and biotechnology experience indicates responsibility, but not direct leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global scientific stature provides exceptional international credibility and representational presence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally grounded scientific career appears highly independent of Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific distinction, and public reputation produce a very strong subjective trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile appears broadly respectable, although it offers limited popular or symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and European judicial service are directly aligned with legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Constitutional Court demonstrates highly relevant experience with a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and ambassadorial experience indicates exceptional readiness to represent Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports autonomy, though prior public appointments make complete distance from political structures difficult to infer." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and diplomatic appointments support a favorable impression of credibility and responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an internationally prominent Hungarian conductor.", "He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.", "He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His international cultural stature would command attention abroad.", "His public advocacy suggests willingness to defend stated principles." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks direct legal and governmental experience.", "His outspoken political criticism may reduce cross-group acceptability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.", "He is associated with the Barabási-Albert model of scale-free networks.", "He has held senior academic roles in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His scientific reputation is internationally exceptional.", "His nonpartisan professional identity could support broad appeal." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks a direct constitutional or public-governance record.", "Research leadership does not fully establish readiness for presidential institutional duties." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He became president of Hungary's Supreme Court.", "The Strasbourg court ruled on the premature termination of his mandate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career strongly reflects judicial independence and rule-of-law experience.", "He has led a central national institution." ], "reservations": [ "His past institutional conflict could reactivate partisan divisions.", "His public appeal beyond legal and civic audiences is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held prominent international academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career is closely aligned with constitutionalism and human rights.", "International judicial experience strengthens his institutional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His profile may resonate more with legal elites than the broader public.", "Ideological perceptions could limit cross-camp acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as economy minister in the first Orbán government.", "He was rector of Corvinus University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He combines academic authority with senior management experience.", "His technocratic style appears comparatively bridge-building." ], "reservations": [ "His earlier cabinet service creates some partisan association.", "He lacks a direct constitutional or diplomatic specialization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No strongly polarizing association is present in my limited recall.", "The uncertainty leaves open the possibility of relevant strengths." ], "reservations": [ "I cannot reliably identify the intended public figure.", "I lack a dependable record for judging any criterion." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for messenger-RNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her scientific achievement gives her extraordinary nonpartisan prestige.", "Her international recognition would make her a compelling national representative." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks direct constitutional and governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not itself demonstrate public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His experience directly spans constitutional adjudication and diplomacy.", "He presents as an experienced and restrained institutional figure." ], "reservations": [ "His broad popular visibility appears limited.", "The political context of senior appointments complicates impressions of complete independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh anchored ordinal impression for every pair, separating limited factual recall from interpretive reasons and using uncertainty to lower confidence rather than omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 3666282858137157705, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "bela-merkely", "csaba-korosi", "katalin-kariko", "csaba-pleh", "botond-roska", "control-consensus-guardian", "cecilia-muller" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:028dd22149db73ac9884246624dc8ea06b14d806efd83c96ccf755ae0b159ad6", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:01+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:46+02:00", "duration_s": 105.328, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 4039, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical authority can bridge groups, but pandemic-era visibility and establishment associations may divide opinion." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His medical leadership offers little direct evidence about constitutional restraint or institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major medical university demonstrates substantial experience directing a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior medical and academic profile would provide credible international presence." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature supports some autonomy, but perceived proximity to government institutions creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His clinical and academic standing supports credibility, tempered by controversy inherent in prominent pandemic communication." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Distinguished scientific achievement and low partisan visibility create strong cross-group symbolic potential." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific rigor is mildly favorable, but his career provides little direct basis for judging constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Directing advanced research organizations indicates strong leadership, though public-administration experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally prominent scientific career provides very strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally based research career appears highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His research reputation and medical-scientific mission support a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reassuring style may appeal to some, but pandemic-era political polarization limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-health administration offers limited direct evidence about constitutional restraint and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "National public-health leadership during a major crisis demonstrates substantial administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her senior public-health role offers some representational standing but little recalled diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent role within government pandemic management creates a substantial perception of executive dependence." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional public-health credentials support baseline trust, tempered by contested official pandemic communication." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge exactly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate exceptional institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior legal stature provide very strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong likely trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide little basis for confidence in institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal or institutional leadership experience relevant to the office." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational presence, but partisan rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may generate trust among admirers, but polarization and inexperience substantially weaken credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no evidence of constitutional or rule-of-law commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong though not exceptional institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public profile makes international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence and no stated scandal are neutral-to-positive, but trust and integrity evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-polarization diplomatic profile and consensus-oriented work appear broadly acceptable across groups." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long multilateral diplomatic career suggests procedural discipline, though not specialized constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over the UN General Assembly demonstrates exceptional experience coordinating a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior UN and diplomatic service constitutes exceptional preparation to represent Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Career diplomacy supports professionalism, while service under successive political leadership leaves some dependence concerns." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level multilateral responsibility supports credibility, with no major integrity concern prominent in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His respected and relatively nonpartisan intellectual profile could be broadly acceptable but lacks mass symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests intellectual independence and procedural seriousness, though direct constitutional experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant, but my recalled representation gives limited evidence of large-scale executive responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International academic stature would support credible representation, though diplomatic experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic career outside party leadership supports strong autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, seriousness, and an impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and civic seriousness are broadly respectable, though climate politics can carry polarization." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly and international-service profile suggests respect for evidence-based process, though constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and international scientific responsibilities indicate capable leadership, though not at head-of-state scale." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international scientific work and multilingual professional environment strongly support global representation." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic and scientific career outside party leadership supports substantial autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research reputation and public-facing expertise support credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and international recognition provide unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career suggests rigor and responsibility but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial research experience but less evident leadership of large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel stature and globally respected scientific career offer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international research career and distance from party structures strongly support autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and achievement support very strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could attract broad respect without commanding widespread public identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and judicial background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates substantial capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and senior legal standing provide strong international representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and diplomatic career suggests professional autonomy, though establishment appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal service conveys credibility and no major integrity concern dominates my recollection." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was a prominent medical communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "Strong medical and academic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Government proximity may weaken perceived independence.", "Pandemic visibility may limit unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "His research focuses on vision and retinal therapies.", "He has led research in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally distinguished scientific reputation.", "Strong independence from domestic party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or governmental experience.", "Limited broad public familiarity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She became a prominent public figure during the COVID-19 pandemic.", "She regularly delivered official pandemic briefings." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced national public-health administrator.", "Demonstrated calm crisis communication." ], "reservations": [ "Closely identified with government pandemic policy.", "Pandemic controversies reduce cross-group trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the 77th UN General Assembly.", "He represented Hungary at the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Consensus-oriented and low-polarization profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law background.", "Career diplomacy can raise establishment-dependence questions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "His scholarship includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics.", "He has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Respected independent intellectual profile.", "Broad scholarly credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public and diplomatic visibility.", "Little recalled executive or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian climate scientist.", "She has held senior roles within the IPCC.", "She is affiliated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected scientific expertise.", "Independent and institutionally serious profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Climate policy can be politically polarizing." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international prestige.", "Strong nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record leading a large public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Substantial diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Career appointments may complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned subjective impressions, with factual recall separated from interpretation and uncertainty reflected in confidence.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 12099601297716307381, "entity_order": [ "bela-merkely", "peter-paczolay", "cecilia-muller", "katalin-kariko", "botond-roska", "control-unknown-technocrat", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "control-partisan-celebrity", "csaba-pleh", "control-consensus-guardian", "csaba-korosi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:8446e1347aefce994752a47a347280166395a63af163a7539ea1be319d3b7379", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:11+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:45+02:00", "duration_s": 94.406, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 3781, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical stature helps, but pandemic-era visibility carries a polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His institutional profile offers limited evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major medical university strongly demonstrates complex institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic and medical prominence would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Visible proximity to government institutions creates reservations about autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional authority is offset by controversy surrounding public-health communication." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Respected scientific achievement offers inclusive symbolism, though public familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career supplies little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Research leadership suggests strong management capacity, though not in national public administration." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international scientific stature would translate into strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally based research profile appears distant from party command." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research reputation supports credibility with few recalled public controversies." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Pandemic-era identification makes her a burden for cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public record gives little basis for confidence in independent constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "National public-health leadership shows administrative capacity under difficult conditions." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall limited evidence of sustained high-level diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent service within the government's pandemic apparatus creates substantial autonomy concerns." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Official medical standing is offset by contested crisis communication and associated distrust." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments indicate exceptional acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service exceptionally match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representational preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly demonstrate autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding provide an exceptionally strong profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no relevant experience with highly polarizing partisan activity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility abroad, but polarization weakens representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition cannot compensate for polarizing conduct and an unspecified accountability record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility limits both polarization and demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is specified, but commitment to constitutional checks is unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong practical leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly states no diplomatic experience and limited visibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No party office supports autonomy, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile provides insufficient information about integrity or broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-partisan diplomatic profile and consensus work support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A multilateral diplomatic career suggests respect for rules and institutions, though not direct constitutional oversight." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over the UN General Assembly demonstrates exceptional leadership in a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior United Nations and ambassadorial experience is an exceptional match." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional diplomacy suggests autonomy, tempered by service through successive state appointments." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior multilateral service conveys credibility with limited recalled controversy." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Intellectual stature and a low-partisan profile could enable broad elite acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile supports deliberative seriousness but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic roles indicate leadership, though national executive experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scholarly standing would provide credible intellectual representation." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic career suggests substantial independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished scholarly reputation supports credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Expert credibility and civic tone help, though climate politics can divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her expert profile suggests principled process orientation but little direct constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior international scientific coordination indicates responsible organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive international climate-science engagement makes her a highly credible representative." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international academic and scientific work suggests meaningful distance from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific standing and policy-oriented public work support credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her record suggests seriousness and integrity but little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but leadership of a complex public institution is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide scientific standing would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and modest public style strongly support trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could attract acceptance across groups without broad popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career directly support this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has led a central constitutional institution and held senior public responsibilities." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and international judicial experience provides exceptional preparation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest autonomy, though elite appointments warrant some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal and diplomatic service conveys credibility with limited recalled controversy." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was a prominent medical voice during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial institutional-management experience.", "Strong professional and international medical standing." ], "reservations": [ "Government proximity raises independence concerns.", "Pandemic visibility may impede unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician-scientist.", "His research concerns vision and retinal function.", "He has held senior research roles in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international scientific reputation.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility in Hungary.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a physician.", "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She was a prominent official during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experience managing a national public-health function.", "Recognizable record of public service during crisis." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with government pandemic messaging.", "Limited evidence of constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the 77th UN General Assembly.", "He served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Demonstrated leadership in a complex international institution." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law experience.", "Career state appointments may affect perceptions of independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "He has held senior academic positions.", "His scholarship includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished intellectual reputation.", "Low-partisan scholarly profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct diplomatic experience.", "Little evidence of constitutional stewardship." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian environmental scientist.", "She has worked extensively with the IPCC.", "She is associated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international policy-science credibility.", "Relatively independent expert profile." ], "reservations": [ "Climate politics can attract polarization.", "Little direct constitutional or executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was central to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired scientific perseverance and achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Limited evidence of managing a large public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and legal expertise.", "Strong diplomatic and international judicial experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Appointment history leaves some uncertainty about perceived independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective judgments based only on internal recall for real figures and exclusively on the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 12271255066775437621, "entity_order": [ "diana-urge-vorsatz", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "bela-merkely", "csaba-korosi", "botond-roska", "control-partisan-celebrity", "csaba-pleh", "cecilia-muller" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:03c04eb68fdb5b9733046c20b57c43913aa4bfee68ca170142efe653fecac676", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:18+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:55+02:00", "duration_s": 97.141, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 4042, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical expertise can command respect, though pandemic-era visibility and establishment associations may constrain cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior medical-administrative profile offers little direct evidence of constitutional independence or guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of a major medical university demonstrates strong capacity to run a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His medical and academic stature would represent Hungary credibly, though he lacks a primarily diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional authority is substantial, but visible proximity to government institutions creates a mixed independence impression." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His clinical and academic standing supports credibility, balanced by the polarizing context of public-health leadership." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan exposure give him broad symbolic potential, despite limited mass visibility." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent scientific profile is reassuring, but it provides almost no direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading sophisticated research activity indicates substantial competence, though national public administration is a different scale." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific reputation would provide Hungary with very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His standing appears rooted in international biomedical research rather than domestic partisan structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized research career supports a strong credibility impression." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reassuring public manner appealed to some audiences, but pandemic politics imposed a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-health role supplies little constitutional evidence and was closely associated with executive-government communication." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Serving as chief medical officer during a national emergency demonstrates meaningful administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has recognizable public-health standing but limited recalled diplomatic or international leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her highly visible role within government pandemic management creates a limited appearance of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her medical-service profile is favorable, while contested official pandemic messaging weakens broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments indicate very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide very strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support an exceptional profile under the supplied facts." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent senior campaign activity create substantial concern about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly supplies no legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility, but polarizing rhetoric limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign involvement strongly indicates factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create a loyal constituency, but polarization and partisan activity substantially weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-conflict technocratic image may avoid polarization, but broader acceptability is unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no meaningful constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports a strong, though not exceptional, leadership assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No party office is known, although the profile does not establish independence from patrons or bureaucratic pressures." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly reassuring, while the profile explicitly lacks sufficient trust and integrity information." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-polarization diplomatic profile and international distinction offer strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career diplomacy suggests procedural discipline, though direct constitutional-law evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the UN General Assembly demonstrates high-level competence in a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomacy and UN leadership make international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A professional diplomatic career supports autonomy, while prolonged service within state structures leaves some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior multilateral service conveys credibility and responsibility without a strongly polarizing domestic image." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An eminent and relatively nonpartisan intellectual profile could command broad respect, though public reach is limited." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly independence suggests deliberative restraint, though direct constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career indicates institutional experience, but evidence of executive public leadership is less direct." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic standing would support credible representation, though diplomacy is not his principal domain." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority appears grounded in a long academic career rather than partisan office." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained scholarly reputation supports a strong impression of credibility and intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a restrained public profile could attract broad respect, while climate politics may divide some groups." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her nonpartisan scientific profile suggests respect for legal process, though direct constitutional evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial experience in complex academic and international institutions, though not in senior state administration." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international scientific work suggests exceptional credibility and representational competence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears grounded more in scholarship and international expertise than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly credibility and public-interest work create a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated Hungarian scientific success provides unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her independent professional standing suggests restraint, but her record offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research career demonstrates responsibility and resilience but provides limited evidence of leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional visibility and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than partisan or patronage networks." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and modest public manner support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could support consensus, but he lacks the broad symbolic reach of nationally celebrated figures." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career provide unusually direct grounding for institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court and serving in senior diplomacy demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European legal experience indicate very strong diplomatic representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though senior state appointments warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long legal and diplomatic service supports credibility, with limited public familiarity constraining the assessment." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "Strong medical and academic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Pandemic-era role may remain polarizing.", "Perceived government proximity may reduce independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "His research concerns vision and retinal function.", "He has led biomedical research in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Little visible partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Limited domestic public profile.", "Little direct state-institution experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian physician.", "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She was a prominent official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "National crisis-management experience.", "Recognizable public-service profile." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with contested government messaging.", "Limited evidence of political independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the UN General Assembly.", "He previously served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral experience.", "Relatively low domestic partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law record.", "Long state service leaves some independence uncertainty." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "He is known for work in cognitive science.", "He has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Respected intellectual standing.", "Low partisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Little direct diplomatic or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian climate scientist.", "She has held leadership roles within the IPCC.", "She is associated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific credibility.", "Strongly nonpartisan professional identity." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Climate policy can carry partisan associations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired scientific perseverance." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public-institution leadership evidence.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He has served as a Hungarian ambassador.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Substantial judicial and diplomatic leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Lower public visibility than prominent national figures.", "Senior appointments complicate a fully independent image." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real figures and only the supplied profiles for synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 15610890589786598662, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "csaba-pleh", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "bela-merkely", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "katalin-kariko", "cecilia-muller", "botond-roska", "csaba-korosi", "control-unknown-technocrat" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:af6f70337d1fc1456efd81c4cc5f101ae2ae22e329382c20b21e0e883d73875d", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:18+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:14+02:00", "duration_s": 116.719, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 5462, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical authority can cross group lines, but his pandemic-era prominence may carry substantial polarization." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior medical-administrative background gives little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major medical university indicates exceptional experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International medical standing would lend credible representation, though diplomacy is not his core field." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature suggests some autonomy, while prominent state-facing roles create meaningful political-association concerns." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High professional achievement supports credibility, tempered by controversy inherent in visible pandemic leadership." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A low-polarization scientific profile and major achievements support strong cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His research career suggests disciplined judgment, but I recall no direct constitutional or legal experience." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership in advanced biomedical research indicates strong capacity to direct complex expert institutions." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international scientific prominence would give Hungary very strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally grounded scientific career appears highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished biomedical research record conveys exceptional professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her familiar public-health presence may reassure some groups but remains strongly associated with a polarizing pandemic response." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her executive public-health background provides limited evidence of commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "National public-health responsibility demonstrates strong operational leadership under difficult conditions." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior health-office experience offers some representational grounding but little recalled diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her highly visible role within government pandemic communication creates substantial doubts about autonomy from executive priorities." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional public-health service supports baseline credibility, offset by contested government communication." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive rule-of-law service and constitutional adjudication indicate exceptional commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisan service across governments strongly suggests autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes cross-group symbolic inclusion extremely unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and combines inexperience with strongly partisan behavior." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of institutional leadership experience creates an exceptionally weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility, but polarizing rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience sharply limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly ties the figure to short-term party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate personal trust among admirers, but polarization and partisanship create major credibility reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability unresolved." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly encouraging, but the profile supplies no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and limited public visibility create a weak representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patrons and informal dependencies remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supports a neutral baseline while insufficient trust and integrity information prevents a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained diplomatic profile and limited partisan burden support strong cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long multilateral diplomatic career suggests respect for rules and process, though not specialized constitutional oversight." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over a major United Nations body demonstrates exceptional institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior diplomatic and United Nations leadership experience make international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Career diplomacy and multilateral leadership support professional autonomy despite service under national governments." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level multilateral responsibility conveys substantial institutional credibility and professionalism." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academically distinguished and relatively nonpartisan public profile offers broad acceptability with limited mass reach." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests respect for reasoned institutions, but I recall little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience suggests capable institutional stewardship, though its scale is uncertain to me." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally connected scholarly standing would provide credible representation despite limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identity as an established independent scholar appears substantially removed from party command." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long scholarly career supports credibility and seriousness in my subjective impression." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific credibility and a measured profile offer broad appeal, although climate politics can polarize." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her evidence-oriented public-service profile is encouraging, but I recall no direct constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior international scientific responsibilities demonstrate leadership, though not full public-institution executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international climate-science work provides exceptional global credibility and representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific and international profile appears substantially autonomous from domestic party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained scientific work and international responsibilities convey high credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional achievement and national symbolic stature give her unusually broad cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and independence, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific excellence is clear, but it does not itself establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally recognized scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity and authority arise overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific accomplishment, and relatively nonpartisan profile support very high public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained jurist-diplomat profile is broadly respectable but may retain establishment and constitutional-era baggage." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career make institutional guardianship a central strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional experience with a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Direct ambassadorial and European diplomatic experience indicates very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles support professional autonomy, though high appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent judicial and diplomatic record conveys substantial credibility and professional seriousness." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was prominent in public discussion during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "Substantial medical authority." ], "reservations": [ "Pandemic prominence may remain polarizing.", "Limited constitutional or diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "His research concerns vision and retinal function.", "He has led biomedical research in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Outstanding international scientific credibility.", "Low-polarization professional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited mass-public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She became a central public-health spokesperson during COVID-19.", "She is a physician." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experience with national public-health responsibility.", "Demonstrated crisis-facing administrative endurance." ], "reservations": [ "Closely associated with government pandemic messaging.", "Limited recalled diplomatic or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the 77th United Nations General Assembly.", "He has represented Hungary at the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral experience.", "Strong institutional and diplomatic presence." ], "reservations": [ "Career state service may invite political-association concerns.", "Limited direct constitutional adjudication experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "He has held senior academic roles.", "His work includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished nonpartisan scholarly identity.", "Internationally credible intellectual profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled constitutional experience.", "Limited mass-public profile." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian climate scientist.", "She is affiliated with Central European University.", "She has held a senior leadership role within the IPCC." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international scientific credibility.", "Relatively independent public profile." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional leadership.", "Climate policy can attract polarization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international stature.", "Broadly admired nonpartisan achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public-institution leadership record.", "Little direct constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He has held a diplomatic role connected to the Council of Europe." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional and institutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic preparation." ], "reservations": [ "High appointments carry political associations.", "May be perceived as an establishment figure." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the supplied ordinal anchors directly, used only internal recall for real candidates and only the provided profiles for synthetic controls, and treated uncertainty as a confidence adjustment rather than a reason to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 15598304359330675756, "entity_order": [ "csaba-pleh", "bela-merkely", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "cecilia-muller", "control-unknown-technocrat", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "botond-roska", "csaba-korosi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:9d25bddb1dfb3767977db128fa88a12f8c8be1df94c23d1b14f18708681be6c7", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:19+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:51+02:00", "duration_s": 92.906, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 3926, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature may attract respect, but pandemic-era visibility carries a polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His medical leadership supplies little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Running a major university and medical institution demonstrates substantial executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior medical and academic standing could translate into credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership within a politically salient state institution creates reservations about perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical authority supports credibility while close association with official crisis management complicates trust." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Distinguished biomedical achievement offers broad, relatively nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific profile suggests rigor and responsibility but gives little direct basis for constitutional assessment." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major scientific work suggests strong organizational capacity, though public-sector leadership is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international biomedical prominence would provide very strong representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally based research career appears strongly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His high-level scientific reputation supports a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High pandemic-era identification makes broad cross-group acceptance difficult." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-health role provides little affirmative basis for confidence in constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading national public-health work during a major crisis indicates strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has an official public profile but limited recalled diplomatic or internationally representative experience." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent role communicating government pandemic policy creates substantial perceived-independence concerns." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional service supports baseline credibility, but crisis communication generated significant public contestation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability and inclusive symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match exceptional constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide an extremely weak guardianship profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition helps visibility, but polarizing rhetoric weakens representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition cannot offset the trust burden created by partisan and polarizing conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility limits both polarizing burden and evidence of genuine unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is established, but the profile supplies no meaningful constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of diplomatic experience makes this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but broader trust and integrity information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained diplomatic profile and multilateral experience support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His multilateral diplomatic career suggests commitment to rules and institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the United Nations General Assembly demonstrates exceptional capacity in a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His top-level United Nations and diplomatic experience is an exceptional match for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Career diplomacy supports professional autonomy, though long service under state administrations limits certainty." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior international service supports a strong impression of credibility and responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected intellectual could command cross-group regard but may lack broad popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests respect for reasoned process, though direct constitutional stewardship is not central to my recall." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive academic experience indicates institutional competence, though not leadership at presidential scale." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scholarly standing would support credible representation in intellectual and cultural settings." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career gives a strong impression of autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long scholarly reputation supports a favorable impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific credibility and civic visibility support inclusion, though climate politics can divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her evidence-oriented public work suggests procedural seriousness, though constitutional stewardship is not her field." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and international scientific responsibilities indicate capable institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international climate-science work provides very strong representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international academic and scientific profile suggests substantial autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her established scientific standing supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined integrity but offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates formidable professional responsibility but limited recalled experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career appears highly autonomous from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific perseverance and international recognition support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist could attract cross-group respect but may have limited popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career directly support very strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates substantial responsibility for a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience provides very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles support autonomy, though senior state appointments warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained judicial and diplomatic service supports a strong impression of credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven large-institution leadership.", "Strong medical and academic standing." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived proximity to government may reduce independence.", "Pandemic visibility may limit cross-group appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "His research concerns vision and retinal function.", "He has led research in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Outstanding international scientific standing.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience recalled.", "Public-institution leadership record is unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian physician.", "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She was a central official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial public-health responsibility.", "Experience operating under crisis conditions." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with government messaging.", "Pandemic role carries polarizing baggage." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the United Nations General Assembly.", "He served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic experience.", "Demonstrated leadership in a multilateral institution." ], "reservations": [ "Long state service leaves some independence uncertainty.", "Domestic cross-group appeal is less established than international standing." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "He has held senior academic roles.", "His work concerns cognition and language." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scholarly credibility.", "Appears substantially nonpartisan." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience recalled.", "Popular unifying reach is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian climate scientist.", "She has held a senior role within the IPCC.", "She has been affiliated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international scientific credibility.", "Evidence-oriented and comparatively nonpartisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional role recalled.", "Climate politics may constrain universal appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad achievement-based symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience recalled.", "Limited public-institution executive experience recalled." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as a Hungarian ambassador.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior state appointments complicate perceived independence.", "Limited mass-public visibility." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real figures and only the supplied profiles for synthetic controls, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 12881883977501959303, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "botond-roska", "control-unknown-technocrat", "cecilia-muller", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "control-consensus-guardian", "csaba-korosi", "bela-merkely", "csaba-pleh", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:5658826d7ef43b7076775e1019411d733794880ba0992e0e4155f0c5bb1efb4f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:42+02:00", "duration_s": 199.203, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21531, "output_tokens": 5520, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical authority has broad appeal, though his pandemic-era prominence may retain partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His medical leadership record provides little direct basis for evaluating constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior university and medical leadership demonstrate strong capacity to run complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His recognized medical and academic standing would provide credible representation, though diplomacy is not his primary field." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature supports some autonomy, but proximity to government-facing institutions complicates the impression." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Clinical and academic achievement support credibility, tempered by contested public perceptions from the pandemic." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction offers nonpartisan symbolic appeal, though his limited general visibility constrains it." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile is compatible with restraint, but provides little direct basis for judging constitutional conduct." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading advanced scientific work suggests organizational capacity, though public-sector executive experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific standing would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international research career appears remote from party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His respected research record supports credibility without a prominent polarizing public persona." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her familiar public-health role may reassure some citizens but carries substantial pandemic-era political baggage." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her administrative career offers limited direct evidence concerning constitutional checks or restraint." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national public-health responsibilities demonstrate experience managing a complex public function." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has senior official standing but limited recalled evidence of sustained diplomatic or international representation." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent role within a government-directed crisis response creates an appearance of executive alignment." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional public-health service supports credibility, while contested crisis communication limits broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide unusually strong evidence of inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented integrity record support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability unlikely despite fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal experience and recent partisan campaigning create substantial reservations about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No institutional leadership experience is supplied for a role requiring responsible public administration." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is a major asset, though polarizing conduct would reduce diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile supplies no integrity finding, but overt partisanship and polarizing rhetoric weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader unifying appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides solid evidence of responsible institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience or international visibility creates a meaningful weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly positive, but information about integrity and public trust is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-polarization diplomatic profile and consensus-oriented experience support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His multilateral diplomatic career suggests procedural discipline, though constitutional stewardship was not its main test." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major United Nations deliberative body demonstrates substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior diplomatic and United Nations experience is exceptionally well matched to international representation." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A professional diplomatic identity suggests autonomy, tempered by service within successive state administrations." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level multilateral responsibility supports credibility and an impression of professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Intellectual distinction and low partisan burden favor acceptability, while limited mass visibility constrains symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests reflective restraint but offers no direct test of constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience suggests sound institutional judgment, though executive scale is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scholarly standing would support credible cultural and intellectual representation." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic career and limited partisan identification suggest considerable independence." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained scholarly reputation supports a strong impression of intellectual credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific credibility and civic seriousness offer inclusive appeal, though climate politics can be polarizing." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly and international-service profile suggests procedural seriousness but not tested constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and international scientific responsibilities indicate credible collaborative leadership." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive international climate-science engagement provides strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career in academia and international climate assessment appears substantially autonomous from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research and international assessment roles support a strong impression of accountable expertise." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal with relatively little partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile suggests seriousness and independence, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates high professional competence, though her record is not primarily one of leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would confer exceptional recognition and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally validated scientific work support a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal-diplomatic profile carries relatively little polarizing burden and supports cross-group respect." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career directly support a very strong guardianship assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court provides strong evidence of responsible institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience provides very strong international representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest substantial professional autonomy, though senior appointments necessarily involve political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and diplomatic service supports credibility, subject to ordinary scrutiny of elite appointments." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was a prominent medical voice during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has demonstrated leadership of a major medical university.", "His clinical and academic stature supports professional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Pandemic-era prominence may carry partisan associations.", "His constitutional and diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist known for research on vision.", "He has worked at a biomedical research institute in Basel.", "His research has included approaches to restoring visual function." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has strong international scientific credibility.", "His profile appears independent and minimally polarizing." ], "reservations": [ "He has limited broad public visibility.", "His constitutional and public-administration experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.", "She participated in the government's pandemic response structure." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has substantial national public-health administrative experience.", "She became familiar to a broad domestic audience." ], "reservations": [ "Her pandemic role carries political and communicative controversy.", "Her independence from executive messaging is difficult to assess." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the United Nations General Assembly.", "He previously represented Hungary at the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has exceptional multilateral representational experience.", "His professional style appears consensus-oriented and restrained." ], "reservations": [ "His domestic cross-group appeal is less tested than his diplomatic standing.", "State service does not fully resolve questions of political autonomy." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "His scholarship has focused on cognition and language.", "He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has a distinguished and relatively nonpartisan intellectual profile.", "His academic reputation supports an impression of thoughtful judgment." ], "reservations": [ "He has limited general-public visibility.", "His experience leading state institutions is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian climate scientist.", "She has held senior responsibilities within the IPCC.", "She has been affiliated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She combines international credibility with evidence-oriented public engagement.", "Her career suggests collaborative work across national boundaries." ], "reservations": [ "Climate policy can attract partisan polarization.", "She has limited recalled experience in constitutional institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She combines global prestige with low partisan burden.", "Her career conveys perseverance and intellectual credibility." ], "reservations": [ "She has limited visible constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not itself establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a Hungarian ambassador.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career directly combines constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "His restrained professional profile appears compatible with cross-group respect." ], "reservations": [ "Senior institutional appointments can create perceptions of political proximity.", "His broad popular appeal is less evident than his elite institutional credibility." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal impressions from the supplied anchors, using recalled public information only for real candidates and only the provided descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 18140865950625206559, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "cecilia-muller", "control-partisan-celebrity", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "csaba-pleh", "csaba-korosi", "bela-merkely", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "botond-roska" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:ceadef86ee23f9baef614f9238aa7ec322da9f322b46932d60284f1d596a92ce", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:26+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:14+02:00", "duration_s": 107.828, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21683, "output_tokens": 3926, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical authority can bridge groups, though pandemic-era prominence carries some partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Medical and university leadership provides little direct evidence about constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major medical university demonstrates substantial organizational responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His medical-academic stature supports credible representation, though diplomacy is not his primary field." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic credentials support professional autonomy, but prominent cooperation with government creates ambiguity." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Clinical and academic stature support trust, while political proximity may weaken cross-group credibility." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Humanitarian scientific achievement and low partisan visibility give him broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career suggests rigor and responsibility but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Directing advanced interdisciplinary research indicates substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international scientific standing would support highly credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally based research career appears strongly independent of domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished biomedical research profile conveys strong competence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reassuring public persona may help some audiences, but pandemic-era visibility carries polarization." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Public-health administration provides little basis for judging commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior national public-health responsibility demonstrates experience leading a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has recognizable public authority but limited recalled diplomatic or international representative experience." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent role within government administration creates perceived dependence on the governing executive." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional medical standing supports credibility, while politically contested crisis communication limits broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability across divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive constitutional service and documented rule-of-law commitment indicate exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of senior public service across governments demonstrate substantial leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly suggest autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no constitutional experience and includes polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience indicates weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports visibility abroad despite the burden of polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create familiarity, but the profile offers little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility and trust information make unifying capacity uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence and non-partisanship are mildly favorable, but constitutional commitment is unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate below-average representative readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the profile lacks enough information about integrity and public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Consensus-oriented multilateral experience and low domestic polarization support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A diplomatic career in rules-based institutions suggests respect for legal process, though not constitutional specialization." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major multilateral assembly demonstrates exceptional institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior diplomatic record makes international representation a defining strength." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Career diplomacy suggests professional autonomy, tempered by service under successive state executives." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level international service gives him a credible and institutionally serious profile." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A respected scholarly profile carries low polarizing burden but limited mass-public reach." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing suggests intellectual independence but not direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic experience suggests competence in complex knowledge institutions." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scholarly engagement supports credible representation despite limited diplomatic visibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic career appears comparatively autonomous from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained academic distinction supports credibility and professional trust." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific authority and civic seriousness support inclusion, though climate policy can be politically divisive." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her expert career suggests procedural seriousness but gives limited direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and international assessment responsibilities indicate capable collaborative leadership." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international climate-science work provides strong representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally grounded academic career suggests meaningful autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly and international expert profile conveys credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation suggests seriousness, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding research institutions, though national public leadership is different." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would confer exceptional international recognition." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career grounded in international science appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific credibility create a strong public-trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Institutional seriousness and a restrained profile favor acceptability, but constitutional decisions can carry partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and judicial experience directly supports strong guardianship credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership at the Constitutional Court demonstrates extensive responsibility in a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International judicial and diplomatic experience provides strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial service supports autonomy, though high state appointments inevitably create perceptions of political connection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A sustained senior judicial career supports credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian cardiologist.", "Served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "Was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "Strong medical and academic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Government proximity may reduce cross-party trust.", "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian neuroscientist specializing in vision research.", "Works in Switzerland.", "Known for research toward restoring sight." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Low partisan burden and strong humanitarian symbolism." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "Public-administration experience is not well established in my recall." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "Became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial public-health administrative experience.", "Familiar and reassuring communication style for some audiences." ], "reservations": [ "Closely associated with government pandemic policy.", "Limited recalled constitutional or diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian diplomat.", "Served as president of the UN General Assembly.", "Previously represented Hungary at the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral experience.", "Consensus-oriented institutional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Career service to the state may complicate perceptions of independence.", "Less direct constitutional specialization than a senior judge." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "Known for work in cognitive science.", "Held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long record of scholarly credibility.", "Low partisan and polarizing profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Little recalled diplomatic or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian environmental scientist and academic.", "Held a senior role within the IPCC.", "Her research focuses on climate change and energy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international expert credibility.", "Comparatively independent academic profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited experience with constitutional institutions.", "Climate politics may constrain universal appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific prestige.", "Broadly inspiring perseverance narrative." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Executive public-institution leadership is not her main field." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "Held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship experience.", "Strong judicial and international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "High state appointments may attract partisan interpretations.", "Lower broad public visibility than prominent cultural or scientific figures." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective impressions from the supplied profiles and internal recall, applying the shared ordinal anchors while lowering confidence where relevant evidence was sparse.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 6784162501517730762, "entity_order": [ "botond-roska", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "csaba-pleh", "control-unknown-technocrat", "bela-merkely", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "csaba-korosi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "cecilia-muller" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d0a5b25981efd3bdc4cb02b9bcc6b9d69ffe6a87613cc1c2d2c53da25c9a3c5b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:32+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:48+02:00", "duration_s": 136.0, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21475, "output_tokens": 5622, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Medical authority offers cross-group appeal, though his public prominence may carry some political associations." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His medical leadership background gives little direct basis for assessing constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major university and medical institution demonstrates substantial executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic and medical standing would translate into credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional stature supports some autonomy, but association with prominent state institutions complicates the impression." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior medical credentials support credibility, tempered by the contestability of high-profile pandemic-era leadership." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a relatively nonpartisan public identity could command respect across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests respect for rigorous process, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading advanced research organizations indicates relevant management capacity, though not experience directing a constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent international scientific standing would give Hungary a credible and accomplished representative." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally established scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reputation for serious biomedical research supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her familiar public-health role may reassure some groups, but pandemic-era polarization limits unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-health career supplies little direct evidence of constitutional restraint or checking executive power." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Serving as the country's chief medical officer indicates meaningful experience leading a consequential public function." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her senior public-health standing offers some representational credibility, but limited diplomatic experience is apparent." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her highly visible role within the government health apparatus weakens the impression of distance from executive priorities." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional medical authority is balanced by contested public perceptions surrounding official pandemic communication." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments imply exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge directly exemplifies this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides direct evidence of highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A nonpartisan record spanning multiple governments strongly indicates autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability unlikely despite fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal or institutional experience and adds strongly factional recent conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition would provide visibility, but polarizing partisanship would impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may create a loyal constituency, but the profile gives little basis for broad institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile limits polarizing baggage but also leaves broader acceptability largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but no constitutional or rule-of-law record is supplied." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides solid evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a comparatively weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests independence, although patrons and informal alignments remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is given, but the profile supplies insufficient evidence of broader trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic diplomatic profile and international distinction could make him broadly acceptable across groups." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long diplomatic career suggests commitment to formal process, though domestic constitutional stewardship is less directly demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major United Nations deliberative body demonstrates considerable institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial career and United Nations leadership provide exceptional direct preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional diplomacy supports some autonomy, but senior state appointments necessarily create government associations." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained diplomatic service and high multilateral office support a strong impression of professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An intellectually respected and comparatively nonpartisan profile could be broadly acceptable, although public reach is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic background suggests deliberative respect for institutions, though constitutional conduct is not directly established." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic seniority supplies some relevant experience, but large-scale public leadership is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scholarly standing would support credible representation, though with limited diplomatic visibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly identity appears meaningfully separate from party machinery and short-term factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long academic career supports a favorable impression of seriousness and professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her respected nonparty expertise could attract broad support, although climate policy can itself become polarizing." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her evidence-oriented public work is encouraging, but it offers little direct constitutional track record." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior roles in international scientific collaboration indicate meaningful leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive international scientific-policy engagement would support highly credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally rooted academic and scientific profile appears substantially independent of domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent scientific career and international assessment work support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal with limited partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career suggests disciplined judgment but offers little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her exceptional research career does not by itself establish experience leading a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-recognized global stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career and public stature were built primarily through international science rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific recognition, and relatively modest public persona support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could be broadly acceptable, but constitutional controversies may limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of Hungary's Constitutional Court and subsequent judicial service make constitutional guardianship a central professional strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over a constitutional court demonstrates substantial leadership within a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European judicial experience provide strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports independence, although high state appointments inevitably raise questions about political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long service in senior judicial roles supports a strong impression of professional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was a prominent medical voice during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated leadership of a major medical university.", "Strong professional stature at home and abroad." ], "reservations": [ "His pandemic-era prominence may carry political polarization.", "His record offers little direct evidence of constitutional guardianship." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist known for vision-restoration research.", "He has held a senior research role in Basel.", "His work has received major international scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected and comparatively nonpartisan.", "Projects intellectual seriousness and public-service potential." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or political experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is less clear than his scientific record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian physician and public-health official.", "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced in managing a consequential national public-health function.", "Her medical background provides a recognizable public-service identity." ], "reservations": [ "Her government-facing pandemic role carries polarizing associations.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience is apparent." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the 77th United Nations General Assembly.", "He previously served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally strong diplomatic and multilateral experience.", "His technocratic profile could attract broad institutional respect." ], "reservations": [ "Senior government service complicates perceived political independence.", "His domestic constitutional record is less developed than his diplomatic record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "He has held senior academic roles.", "His work includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long scholarly career suggests seriousness and independence.", "A nonpartisan intellectual profile could reduce polarization." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Broader public recognition and executive capacity are uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian environmental scientist focused on climate and energy.", "She has held leadership responsibilities within the IPCC.", "She has been affiliated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial international credibility and policy experience.", "Her career appears independent of domestic party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Climate politics may limit cross-group acceptance.", "She lacks an evident constitutional or head-of-state background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with broad symbolic appeal.", "Her career conveys perseverance and independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional or governmental experience is apparent.", "Scientific excellence does not automatically establish public executive capacity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Directly relevant constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong combination of institutional and international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Past state appointments may attract partisan interpretations.", "His public unifying appeal is less evident than his professional qualifications." ] } ], "method_note": "I independently mapped my present rubric-conditioned impressions to the ordinal anchors, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than as grounds to omit a score.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 8796313769867411528, "entity_order": [ "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "bela-merkely", "control-partisan-celebrity", "botond-roska", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "cecilia-muller", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:b597b6eeefd9182d5d9b672c7c705663c18981619e2259de3b10ad0b2c688656", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:35+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:27+02:00", "duration_s": 111.594, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21475, "output_tokens": 5461, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Medical authority can carry broad appeal, although pandemic-era visibility may impose some polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior medical profile shows responsibility but offers little direct basis for assessing constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major medical university provides substantial evidence of complex institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally legible medical standing would support representation despite limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional stature may provide autonomy, while his proximity to prominent state institutions creates uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional achievements support credibility, but I am uncertain about broader public trust." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan visibility offer inclusive symbolic value, though mass public familiarity may be limited." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career suggests disciplined judgment but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading advanced scientific work indicates organizational capacity, although public-administration leadership is different." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international scientific standing would give Hungary credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally based research career appears substantially independent of domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His research reputation supports credibility and carries little polarizing baggage in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High pandemic-era visibility brought familiarity but also substantial association with a divisive period." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-health office demonstrates administrative duty but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Serving as national chief medical officer indicates meaningful public-institution leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Public-health expertise is internationally legible, but I recall limited diplomatic or global representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent role communicating government pandemic policy creates a perception of limited distance from the executive." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional role supports baseline credibility, while public trust in her communication appears mixed." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan record imply exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong basis for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with recent partisan activity and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is an asset, but polarization and absent diplomatic experience substantially limit it." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but the profile supplies little evidence of accountability and substantial reason for distrust across factions." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves cross-group appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competence and non-partisanship are modest positives, but the profile gives no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks diplomatic experience and offers no substitute international standing." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patrons and incentives remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is supplied, but there is insufficient evidence of public credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained diplomatic profile appears relatively inclusive and carries limited polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic and multilateral background suggests respect for formal process, though constitutional stewardship is not his central record." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior diplomatic and multilateral responsibilities demonstrate experience leading complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive diplomatic experience and prominent United Nations service make international representation a particular strength." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international career supports some professional autonomy, tempered by service within government diplomacy." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional reputation appears credible, although broad domestic trust is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His intellectual standing could attract respect, but his broader cross-group appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests deliberative judgment, but I recall little direct constitutional or legal experience." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic seniority suggests some leadership capacity, but large public-institution management is not prominent in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International scholarly credibility is useful, although it is not equivalent to diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic career appears to provide meaningful distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly reputation supports credibility, subject to limited knowledge of his wider public standing." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional credibility and limited partisan baggage support broad acceptability, though climate politics can polarize." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her evidence-oriented public work suggests procedural seriousness, but not direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior international scientific responsibilities indicate solid collaborative leadership." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international climate-science work provides very strong global credibility and representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international academic and scientific roles suggest considerable autonomy from domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her established scientific profile supports integrity and credibility in my learned representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Widely recognized scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and relatively non-partisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career reflects rigor and perseverance, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has worked at the highest scientific level, though large public-institution leadership is not her defining experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific recognition would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career and limited partisan identification suggest exceptional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific reputation and public narrative support very strong credibility in my subjective assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile may be acceptable across groups, but it does not clearly establish broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court experience gives him a strong institutional basis for defending legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in a constitutional court demonstrates responsibility within a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European institutional experience indicates strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though state appointments complicate a stronger inference." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A substantial legal career supports credibility, with some uncertainty about contemporary public perceptions." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated leadership of a major institution.", "Internationally credible medical background." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Government proximity may affect perceived independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "His research focuses on vision and retinal science.", "He has held senior research roles in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Minimal partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct public-governance experience.", "Domestic public familiarity may be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's national chief medical officer.", "She was a prominent official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced public-health administrator.", "Familiar to a broad domestic audience." ], "reservations": [ "Closely associated with government pandemic messaging.", "Limited recalled diplomatic or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as president of the United Nations General Assembly.", "He has worked on international sustainability issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep multilateral experience.", "Low-key and institutionally oriented profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional record.", "Domestic cross-group trust is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "He has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong intellectual credibility.", "Appears relatively independent of party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled legal or diplomatic experience.", "Broader public appeal is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian environmental scientist.", "She has held senior roles within the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.", "She is affiliated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international scientific credibility.", "Relatively independent and inclusive profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Climate-policy identification may reduce appeal in some groups." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international stature.", "Broad non-partisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional background.", "Limited record leading a complex public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional and institutional background.", "Substantial international legal experience." ], "reservations": [ "State appointments complicate perceptions of independence.", "His popular unifying appeal is uncertain." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal representations only, treating uncertainty as a confidence limitation rather than a reason to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "bela-merkely", "botond-roska", "cecilia-muller", "csaba-korosi", "csaba-pleh", "diana-urge-vorsatz" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 2769777342938711162, "entity_order": [ "bela-merkely", "cecilia-muller", "control-unknown-technocrat", "csaba-pleh", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "botond-roska", "control-consensus-guardian", "diana-urge-vorsatz", "control-partisan-celebrity", "csaba-korosi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:cb8bee52c817c85a8a4a02dd138615877c9cbcaec48a294d35f2728ba980d80b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:21:44+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:44+02:00", "duration_s": 119.407, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21475, "output_tokens": 5457, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A prominent physician could command respect across groups, though pandemic-era visibility may carry polarization." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior academic role suggests procedural responsibility, but offers little evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major medical university indicates substantial experience managing a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific standing would translate reasonably well, despite limited recalled diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional stature supports some autonomy, although his independence from governing networks is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His medical and university credentials support credibility, tempered by uncertainty about broader public trust." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and relatively nonpartisan scientist could provide inclusive symbolism with little polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific profile offers no direct basis for assessing constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Research-group and institute leadership suggest meaningful organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international scientific career would confer strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His standing appears rooted in international research rather than partisan structures." }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His acclaimed biomedical work supports credibility, though his broader public profile is limited." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reassuring official persona may appeal broadly, but pandemic politics created a meaningful polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-health service demonstrates administrative duty but provides little basis for judging constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "National public-health responsibilities indicate administrative capacity under demanding conditions." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall little international or diplomatic experience from which to infer strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her close identification with government pandemic communications weakens the impression of visible autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional public service supports baseline credibility, while politicized crisis communication complicates trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion's strongest anchor." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates high-level institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly support autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe obstacle to cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition helps visibility abroad, although polarization and inexperience constrain credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate personal trust among admirers, but partisanship and polarizing conduct substantially limit it." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces existing polarization but leaves cross-group appeal essentially unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides direct support for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile specifies no diplomatic experience and limited public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the profile explicitly lacks broader trust information." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-polarization diplomatic profile and consensus experience suggest strong cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long multilateral career suggests commitment to rules and process, though not specifically constitutional adjudication." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over the United Nations General Assembly demonstrates leadership in an exceptionally complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior diplomatic career and United Nations leadership exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional diplomacy and multilateral leadership support autonomy, tempered by prior service within state structures." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High international responsibility and a professional public image support substantial credibility." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile carries relatively little partisan burden and could symbolize civic seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly career suggests deliberative respect for institutions, though not a constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic seniority suggests organizational experience, but I recall limited evidence of executive leadership at national scale." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scholarly standing would support credible representation in intellectual and cultural settings." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic career outside party leadership supports a strong impression of intellectual autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished academic reputation supports credibility and a low-conflict public image." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civic and scientific stature could bridge groups, though climate policy can itself be politically divisive." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her international scientific-policy work suggests procedural seriousness but not direct constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and international assessment responsibilities indicate solid collaborative leadership." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive international scientific-policy work provides strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her credibility appears grounded in scholarship and international assessment rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained expert role in international climate assessment supports credibility and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated Hungarian scientific achievement offers unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her career conveys seriousness and independence, but supplies no direct constitutional or legal record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but it does not itself establish experience leading a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional international stature and cross-border career make her an unusually credible national representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives primarily from scientific achievement rather than party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and global recognition support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could reassure multiple camps, albeit without broad popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background directly supports a strong expectation of legal-process guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates responsibility for a complex and consequential institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience strongly fits international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service and international legal responsibility support substantial institutional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cardiologist.", "He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.", "He was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced leader of a major institution.", "Commands professional and scientific respect." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or diplomatic background.", "Pandemic-era visibility may carry political associations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "His research concerns vision and retinal therapies.", "He has held senior research roles in Switzerland." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly respected international scientist.", "Relatively free of partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited broad public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian physician.", "She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.", "She became highly visible during official COVID-19 briefings." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced national public-health administrator.", "Familiar and reassuring public presence for some audiences." ], "reservations": [ "Closely associated with government crisis messaging.", "Limited recalled diplomatic or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian diplomat.", "He served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "He served as president of the United Nations General Assembly." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic and multilateral leadership experience.", "Professional profile with relatively low polarizing burden." ], "reservations": [ "Career state service may complicate perceptions of independence.", "Limited direct constitutional-law experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.", "His scholarship includes cognitive science.", "He is associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished and comparatively nonpartisan intellectual.", "Strong scholarly credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public executive experience.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian environmental scientist.", "She has served in senior roles within the IPCC.", "She is affiliated with Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international policy and scientific credibility.", "Substantial experience in consensus-based expert institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Climate policy can provoke partisan reactions.", "No direct constitutional leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility and symbolic appeal.", "Strong reputation for perseverance and scientific integrity." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional background.", "Limited evidence of large public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and rule-of-law experience.", "Strong diplomatic and international legal credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Judicial appointments can attract political interpretation.", "Limited mass-public visibility." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions based only on supplied control profiles and uncertain internal recall of the real figures.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 7860548269380357840, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "eniko-bollobas", "control-partisan-celebrity", "gabor-halmai", "erno-rubik", "gabor-bojar", "control-unknown-technocrat", "eva-kondorosi", "eniko-gyori" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d20dd36c37d98f79cc851732ba9a82ce3233be91288a1d391b237eee47230214", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:45+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:36+02:00", "duration_s": 110.985, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21464, "output_tokens": 4052, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate exceptional acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented integrity record support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability distinctly unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and combines institutional inexperience with polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates very weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational reach, although polarizing rhetoric would materially reduce diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame alone does not establish integrity, while partisan polarization would burden broad public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader symbolic inclusion and acceptability unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile contains no constitutional or rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide solid evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supports a neutral baseline, but information about integrity and public trust is expressly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished cultural-academic profile could be inclusive, though her broader cross-group appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly standing suggests principled judgment, but I recall little direct constitutional or legal-process experience." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant, but I lack confidence about her record leading large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally oriented scholarship and academic stature would translate well into cultural diplomacy." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic career suggests meaningful independence from party command and short-term political incentives." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained scholarly reputation supports a strong impression of credibility and intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identification with a dominant and polarizing party substantially limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her governmental and European experience shows familiarity with legal institutions, but strong party alignment creates reservations about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her senior governmental, diplomatic, and European roles demonstrate substantial institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her diplomatic and European Union experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her senior Fidesz political career indicates substantial dependence on party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional experience supports competence, but partisan identification constrains broadly shared trust." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His universally recognized invention gives him broad, positive, and unusually nonpolarizing symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public reputation is compatible with civic seriousness but offers little basis for assessing constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and educational accomplishment does not clearly establish capacity to lead a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His name and invention are globally associated with Hungarian creativity and intellectual achievement." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His creative and educational identity appears notably detached from party command and factional politics." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing low-conflict public reputation supports trust, though public accountability experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and nonpartisan scientific profile offers broad symbolic appeal with little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific governance background suggests procedural seriousness but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her leadership within major research settings indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific prominence would provide Hungary with credible and accomplished representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research career and international scientific standing indicate strong independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained scientific distinction and professional standing support a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His innovation and education credentials broaden appeal, but his political visibility may divide some constituencies." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic and educational engagement suggests institutional concern, but he lacks a direct constitutional-service record." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building major business and educational institutions demonstrates exceptional organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally oriented technology career would lend Hungary credible entrepreneurial and innovation representation." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His entrepreneurial base supports autonomy, although visible public-policy positions may reduce perceptions of detachment." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as an entrepreneur and education founder supports a strong impression of credibility and constructive purpose." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled constitutional profile is an asset but may be polarizing in Hungary's existing political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained constitutional-law and rights-focused work indicates very strong commitment to legal checks and restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic and rights-institution experience suggests strong competence, though not extensive executive governance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international constitutional-law standing would provide substantial credibility in European and global settings." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and rights-oriented career suggests autonomy, though his prominent normative positions may limit perceptions of neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His consistent public scholarship supports credibility, while ideological contestation may narrow cross-partisan trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally admired scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and relatively nonpolarizing symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile suggests seriousness and responsibility, but provides little direct evidence about constitutional practice." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has extensive experience in demanding research institutions but limited visible leadership of complex public bodies." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide Hungary with exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record of perseverance and scientific accomplishment supports a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal-diplomatic profile could attract institutional respect without generating broad popular enthusiasm." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background and legal expertise strongly support commitment to institutional checks and legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court and serving in senior diplomatic roles demonstrate substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European legal experience make him a very strong international representative." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests professional autonomy, though senior appointments create some establishment association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal service supports credibility, with limited public visibility constraining a stronger trust judgment." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian literary scholar and university professor.", "Known for scholarship in American studies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished academic identity suggests intellectual independence.", "Internationally oriented scholarship supports cultural representation." ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled evidence of constitutional expertise.", "Large-scale public leadership record is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian Fidesz politician.", "Has served as a member of the European Parliament.", "Previously held diplomatic and governmental posts." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive experience in European and diplomatic affairs.", "Demonstrated capacity within complex political institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Strong party alignment sharply limits perceived independence.", "Partisan identification creates a substantial unifying burden." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian architect and inventor.", "Invented the Rubik's Cube.", "Has supported education and creative problem solving." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary global recognition with positive Hungarian symbolism.", "Nonpartisan creative stature offers broad unifying appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct legal or constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of complex public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian plant biologist.", "Known for research on plant-microbe symbiosis.", "Has held senior roles in European scientific organizations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected and substantially nonpartisan profile.", "Scientific leadership supports trust and institutional competence." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Broader public familiarity may be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Founded the software company Graphisoft.", "Founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "Known as a Hungarian technology entrepreneur." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated ability to build internationally successful institutions.", "Entrepreneurial and educational work supports credibility and independence." ], "reservations": [ "Visible political views may limit cross-partisan acceptance.", "No direct constitutional-service background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "Has taught and researched at international universities.", "Has been associated with human-rights and constitutional institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law and constitutional-checks orientation.", "High international credibility in constitutional scholarship." ], "reservations": [ "Prominent normative positions may attract partisan opposition.", "Executive leadership experience appears narrower than his scholarly expertise." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with little partisan baggage.", "Scientific perseverance supports credibility and symbolic inclusion." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Public-institution executive leadership is not clearly established." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and legal-process experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European institutional credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may complicate perceptions of complete independence.", "His low public profile may limit popular unifying force." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned impressions, with confidence reflecting familiarity and without treating the judgments as objective fitness assessments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 18256432267154666404, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "eniko-bollobas", "gabor-halmai", "erno-rubik", "gabor-bojar", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-gyori", "eva-kondorosi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:a5e8c53743c61aa882af215e2f8f50b75bf9a235aab00cf0881ccf53b7ed381f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:46+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:11+02:00", "duration_s": 84.938, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21216, "output_tokens": 3915, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile imply very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging match the criterion exceptionally." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates highly credible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability despite celebrity reach." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No legal experience and recent senior partisan activity provide weak grounds for confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition is a major asset, tempered by polarizing rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame supplies recognition but neither accountability experience nor broad trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility limits both polarizing burden and demonstrated cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile supplies no evidence of either constitutional commitment or disregard." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management supports a strong but not exceptional assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility creates a weak representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, although patronal relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her cultural and scholarly standing could bridge groups, though national cross-group appeal is untested." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly profile is compatible with liberal institutional norms, but direct constitutional stewardship is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic accomplishment suggests responsibility but gives limited evidence of leading a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international scholarly orientation and expertise in American studies support strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic career outside party command suggests substantial intellectual and political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished academic reputation supports credibility with no confidently recalled integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive partisan identification creates a meaningful obstacle to cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her long governmental and party career gives mixed grounds for confidence in restraint against incumbent power." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Substantial governmental and European experience indicates strong institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her diplomatic and European political experience directly supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained senior affiliation with Fidesz substantially weakens perceived autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional experience supports competence, but partisan alignment limits broad-based trust." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally admired, nonpartisan cultural identity carries unusually low polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public profile provides little basis for judging constitutional restraint or legal-process commitments." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and entrepreneurial achievement does not clearly demonstrate leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional global recognition and a distinctly Hungarian achievement make him a powerful symbolic representative." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career and identity appear notably independent of party structures and factional command." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long-standing reputation for creativity and reserve supports trust, though public accountability experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and low partisan visibility support broad acceptability with limited polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her academic record suggests procedural seriousness but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership in major research settings indicates strong capacity to steward a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international scientific career would provide highly credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career suggests substantial independence from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished scientific reputation supports very strong credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His achievement has broad appeal, but visible political positions reduce cross-faction acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public civic orientation appears supportive of institutional checks, although he lacks a constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building major technology and educational institutions demonstrates exceptional organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International business and educational success support persuasive representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Entrepreneurial independence and willingness to criticize political power suggest strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institution-building record supports credibility, with no confidently recalled major integrity finding." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Clear rule-of-law advocacy brings principled appeal but also a substantial polarizing burden in Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career as a constitutional scholar and rule-of-law advocate maps exceptionally well to this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and rights-institution experience suggests capable leadership with limited executive evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International constitutional scholarship gives him substantial credibility in foreign institutional settings." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly independence is strong, though his pronounced positions may be perceived through factional conflict." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained and transparent constitutional commitments support credibility despite contested public reception." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional ethos is favorable, but her record offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led demanding scientific work, though large public-institution leadership is less demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nobel-level global stature makes her an exceptional representative of Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing appear exceptionally independent of Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile appears broadly acceptable without commanding obvious mass affinity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court and serving in diplomacy indicate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Direct diplomatic experience and legal stature support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and diplomatic career suggests professional autonomy, though senior state appointments create some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional record conveys credibility and seriousness with limited recalled integrity concerns." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian literary scholar.", "Her scholarship includes American studies.", "She has held a university professorship." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong intellectual independence.", "Internationally oriented cultural expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She has served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "She held a senior government role concerning European affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Strong knowledge of European institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Deep party affiliation limits perceived independence.", "Partisan identity constrains unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He invented the Rubik's Cube.", "He is a Hungarian architect and designer.", "His puzzle became a worldwide cultural phenomenon." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Rare cross-group symbolic appeal.", "Exceptional international recognition." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.", "She has held senior roles in European scientific institutions.", "She is a member of prominent scientific academies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Strong nonpartisan institutional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Broad public appeal is not well tested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He founded the software company Graphisoft.", "He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "He is a Hungarian technology entrepreneur." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional institution-building record.", "Strong independence and international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Visible political opinions may reduce consensus appeal.", "No direct constitutional-office experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has taught and researched at international universities.", "His work addresses constitutionalism and human rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional rule-of-law expertise.", "Strong international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Public positions may be polarizing domestically.", "Limited executive-government experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary global credibility.", "Broadly unifying scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record leading a public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He has held European human-rights judicial responsibilities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional-law experience.", "Substantial diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Senior state appointments may complicate perceptions of independence.", "Limited evidence of broad popular appeal." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the frozen ordinal anchors directly, treated uncertainty as a confidence adjustment rather than a missing score, used only supplied control profiles and internal recall for named individuals, and made no eligibility or willingness adjustment.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 4168216359909869385, "entity_order": [ "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-halmai", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "gabor-bojar", "eniko-bollobas", "control-unknown-technocrat", "eniko-gyori", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:a54bb2c5519686afaac5283f56a59ca4074b55ab38c82b5a22836acc981dc71f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:51+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:27+02:00", "duration_s": 95.36, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21464, "output_tokens": 3811, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability with limited reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long judicial service and leadership across governments demonstrate exceptional institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition offers presence abroad despite weak diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create recognition, but the profile provides little basis for institutional trust and signals divisiveness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility prevents a stronger judgment about broad appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is relevant, but the profile gives no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides strong direct support for leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but broader credibility and integrity information is expressly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished and comparatively nonpartisan scholarly profile could attract broad respect." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly profile suggests intellectual independence but offers limited constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience suggests competence, though major public-executive evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international humanities scholarship would support articulate cultural representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic career appears substantially autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-standing academic distinction supports credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A prominent governing-party identity creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public-service experience is relevant, but strong governing-party alignment creates reservations about checks and restraint." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior governmental, parliamentary, and diplomatic roles demonstrate strong institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive European and diplomatic experience provides very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her senior Fidesz political career indicates limited autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional experience supports competence, while partisan identification limits cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His broadly admired cultural and intellectual legacy carries little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public profile offers little direct basis for assessing constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and academic accomplishments do not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional global recognition would provide substantial symbolic international presence." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears substantially independent of party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing reputation as an inventor and educator supports a favorable trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a low-partisanship profile offer broad symbolic acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her distinguished scientific-service profile suggests procedural seriousness but provides little constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific roles indicate substantial experience with complex international institutions." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international scientific standing would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears grounded in independent scientific institutions rather than partisan command." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A highly regarded research career supports a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His achievements have broad appeal, but explicit political positions may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic orientation is favorable, but he lacks direct constitutional or judicial stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building major business and educational institutions demonstrates exceptional executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally successful technology career offers strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Entrepreneurial independence is substantial, though outspoken political engagement reduces detachment." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as a founder and educator supports a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His clear alignment in contested rule-of-law debates would likely constrain cross-camp acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career-long focus on constitutional law and rights strongly supports institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and advisory experience suggests sound institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international academic career and constitutional expertise support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly autonomy is strong, though visible positions in constitutional disputes may limit perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained academic and rights-based work supports credibility despite partisan perceptions around the field." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and national symbolism give her unusually broad cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record suggests discipline and responsibility but contains little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding institutions, though chiefly as a scientist rather than public executive." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel stature and global scientific recognition provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career is strongly detached from Hungarian party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional profile is broadly acceptable but lacks strong popular unifying symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and judicial background provides exceptionally relevant guardianship experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates highly relevant public-institution experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience supports very strong international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career supports autonomy, though prominent state appointments invite some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility and institutional trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian literary scholar and university professor.", "Known for scholarship in American studies.", "Member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished scholarly reputation.", "Comparatively nonpartisan public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of major public-executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian Fidesz politician.", "Has served as a member of the European Parliament.", "Previously held diplomatic and governmental roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive European-policy experience.", "Strong diplomatic and institutional résumé." ], "reservations": [ "Deep party alignment limits independence.", "Partisan identity constrains unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Invented the Rubik's Cube.", "Worked as an architect and design professor.", "His puzzle became globally recognized." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally broad cultural recognition.", "Little evident partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Limited public-institution leadership evidence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.", "Held senior roles in European scientific institutions.", "Received major international scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected scientific record.", "Strong nonpartisan professional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited mass-public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Founded the software company Graphisoft.", "Founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "Built an internationally successful technology business." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven institution builder.", "Strong international entrepreneurial credibility." ], "reservations": [ "No judicial or constitutional background.", "Public political positions may polarize." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "Has taught and researched internationally.", "Has written extensively on constitutionalism and fundamental rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise.", "Strong international academic standing." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile.", "May be viewed through polarized constitutional disputes." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Limited public-executive record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly relevant constitutional experience.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular unifying symbolism.", "State appointments may invite independence questions." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied anchors to my internal representation of real figures and only the supplied descriptions of synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 1632896546810687907, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "eniko-gyori", "gabor-halmai", "eniko-bollobas", "control-partisan-celebrity", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:75310b579d929498cbd81aaa700bc2a24cf7713ec488c2baaa0009a4aacfa49e", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:22:55+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:59+02:00", "duration_s": 183.984, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21320, "output_tokens": 3867, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional adjudication match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership across governments demonstrates sustained capacity to manage important public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior institutional standing indicate very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition is valuable abroad, but polarizing conduct and inexperience substantially limit the fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate support, but the profile provides little basis for broad institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility and trust information leave unifying capacity uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no constitutional track record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak international representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides a neutral baseline, while broader integrity and accountability evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished cultural-academic profile could be broadly acceptable and carries limited partisan baggage." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly standing suggests deliberative seriousness, but I recall little direct constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic accomplishment indicates capability but provides only indirect evidence of complex public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally oriented scholarship and cultural stature suggest strong representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic career suggests autonomy, although my knowledge of her political relationships is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation appears credible, but my factual familiarity is insufficient for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent governing-party identity carries a considerable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her governmental experience supports procedural competence, but her partisan alignment weakens confidence in robust constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her ministerial, diplomatic, and parliamentary experience demonstrates substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive diplomatic and European Union experience makes international representation a clear strength." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained senior role within Fidesz indicates substantial dependence on party structures." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She appears professionally experienced, but strong partisanship limits broad-based trust." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally admired, low-partisanship cultural standing gives him unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His independent intellectual profile is reassuring, but it offers little direct evidence concerning constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Creative and entrepreneurial accomplishment does not clearly establish leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His invention gives Hungary an exceptionally recognizable and positive international association." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career is identified with invention and education rather than party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding public reputation appears credible and largely free of polarizing controversy." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scientist with limited partisan burden could command broad cross-group respect." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career suggests respect for rigorous process, but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading advanced research activity indicates meaningful organizational competence, though public executive experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international scientific standing would provide credible and substantive representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research-centered career appears substantially independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and professional credibility support a strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His achievements broaden his appeal, but outspoken opposition positioning creates a meaningful partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic commitments suggest support for accountable institutions, though he lacks a constitutional-law record." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building major business and educational institutions demonstrates strong executive and organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally successful technology background would support credible modern representation of Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His entrepreneurial base supports autonomy, although visible political advocacy reduces perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as a founder and education supporter conveys credibility, tempered by political contestation." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled profile may inspire one constituency while provoking resistance among government supporters." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career-long focus on constitutionalism and rights makes this his strongest criterion." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has substantial academic and advisory experience, though less executive leadership of large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international academic standing and comparative constitutional expertise would translate well abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and rights-oriented career suggests considerable independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly consistency and public constitutional advocacy support credibility despite political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and personal story offer rare cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional rigor is favorable, but her career supplies little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional research achievement does not by itself demonstrate executive leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature would make her an exceptionally credible representative of Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity and achievements are grounded in science rather than domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and global recognition create a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained institutional profile could attract broad respect without offering strong popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law and judicial background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions is directly relevant evidence of institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience indicates exceptional international representational competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest autonomy, though senior state appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional record conveys credibility and seriousness with limited prominent integrity concerns in my recollection." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian literary scholar associated with American studies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished scholarly profile.", "Potentially broad cultural credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled constitutional experience.", "Institutional leadership record is unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She has served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "She held a senior governmental role concerning European Union affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and EU experience.", "Demonstrated competence in senior institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Strong identification with one party.", "Likely limited acceptability across political camps." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He invented the Rubik's Cube.", "He trained as an architect.", "His puzzle became a worldwide cultural phenomenon." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary nonpartisan symbolic appeal.", "Exceptional international name recognition." ], "reservations": [ "No clear constitutional or diplomatic record.", "Limited evidence of public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian biologist known for plant-microbe research.", "She has held senior roles in European scientific organizations.", "She is internationally recognized for her research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High scientific credibility.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of broad public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He founded the software company Graphisoft.", "He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "He has publicly criticized Hungary's governing direction." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong institution-building record.", "International entrepreneurial credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Visible political advocacy limits neutrality.", "No direct constitutional or diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has taught at the European University Institute.", "His work addresses constitutionalism and fundamental rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional rule-of-law expertise.", "Substantial international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited large-scale executive experience.", "His public positions may be politically polarizing." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global scientific credibility.", "Strong cross-group symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional and governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not establish public executive capacity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior state appointments complicate perceived independence.", "His public unifying appeal is not clearly established." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores express a rubric-anchored subjective impression using internal recall for real figures and only the supplied profiles for synthetic controls; confidence reflects familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 333693911035519732, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "gabor-halmai", "eniko-bollobas", "control-unknown-technocrat", "eva-kondorosi", "erno-rubik", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-gyori", "gabor-bojar" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:43962f2daa501c6393a662bd8d34a2b390110158a6745a8d7bf0b4a088ca61e9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:14+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:56+02:00", "duration_s": 102.141, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21463, "output_tokens": 3920, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan profile indicate exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging exactly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity to steward a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments provide exceptional evidence of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support the rubric's strongest trust rating." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 1, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes cross-group acceptance exceptionally unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide a very weak basis for institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no relevant legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global fame supports presence abroad, although polarizing rhetoric materially limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition offers visibility but cannot overcome the profile's severe partisan trust burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader acceptability and symbolic reach are unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid leadership capacity with limited evidence about public-institution complexity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is positive, but the profile explicitly provides insufficient evidence about trust and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished cultural-academic profile may be broadly respectable but has uncertain cross-group reach." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly standing is compatible with constitutional restraint, but I recall little direct institutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience implies some institutional competence but not clearly national-scale executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally oriented scholarship and cultural expertise suggest strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic career suggests independence, although my knowledge of her public affiliations is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation creates a favorable impression, subject to low familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her strong partisan identification would impose a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her governmental and party-aligned career creates meaningful reservations about prioritizing institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her senior diplomatic, governmental, and European roles demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive diplomatic and European Union experience makes her a very strong international representative." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A long senior role within Fidesz politics indicates weak autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her substantial public-service experience is offset by sharply divided trust across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally admired, non-partisan cultural identity offers unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His profile gives little direct evidence about constitutional judgment or institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and entrepreneurial achievement does not clearly establish leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional global recognition makes him an unusually powerful cultural representative of Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His creative and educational career appears highly independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing reputation for creativity and restraint carries a very low polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a low-partisan profile offer substantial cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior scientific and public-service profile suggests procedural seriousness, though not direct constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research leadership supports responsible governance, though presidential-scale administration is different." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international scientific career would provide strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research career appears strongly autonomous from party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her accomplished scientific reputation conveys exceptional credibility with few apparent trust burdens." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Business and educational achievement broaden his appeal, while outspoken political positions may divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public profile suggests respect for liberal institutions, though he lacks direct constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and leading major business and educational institutions demonstrates exceptional executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally successful technology and educational career supports strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His entrepreneurial standing supports autonomy, despite visible engagement in political debate." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institution-building record conveys credibility, with some partisan perception risk." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong rule-of-law credibility is offset by likely polarization around his public constitutional critiques." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career-long focus on constitutionalism and rights makes this an especially strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and legal leadership is substantial but differs from managing a large national institution." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international academic standing and constitutional expertise would translate well to diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests autonomy from party command despite clearly expressed institutional positions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained academic and rights-oriented work conveys credibility, though public trust would vary sharply by group." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally celebrated achievement and low-partisan profile provide exceptional cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her rigorous professional record suggests procedural responsibility but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research and biotechnology experience indicate strong responsibility but limited public executive evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature would give Hungary exceptional international representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and public identity appear exceptionally independent of Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific accomplishment, perseverance, and restrained public persona inspire exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could attract broad respect without guaranteeing popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law and judicial background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions indicates strong capacity for responsible public administration." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European legal experience supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional profile suggests substantial autonomy, though senior public appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record projects seriousness and credibility, with limited basis for an exceptional rating." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of American literature and culture.", "She has held a university professorship." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally oriented scholarly profile.", "Likely distance from party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled evidence about public leadership.", "Cross-group appeal is difficult to assess." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She has served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to Spain.", "She held a senior government role concerning European Union affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Strong command of European institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Deep party identification limits independence.", "Partisan profile weakens unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He invented the Rubik's Cube.", "He trained and worked in architecture and design.", "His invention became a worldwide cultural icon." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary global symbolic recognition.", "Broad, low-partisan public appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian biologist known for plant-microbe research.", "She has held senior roles in European scientific institutions.", "She is a member of major scientific academies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly credible non-partisan stature.", "Extensive international scientific leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "National executive demands differ from research governance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He founded the software company Graphisoft.", "He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "He has participated publicly in Hungarian political debate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven institution builder.", "Strong international technology credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken political positions may polarize.", "No direct constitutional-office experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has taught and conducted research internationally.", "His work addresses constitutionalism and fundamental rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional rule-of-law expertise.", "Strong international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His constitutional criticism may polarize partisan audiences.", "Large-scale executive experience is less clear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of national public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He has held European human-rights judicial responsibilities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Public unifying appeal is less established.", "Senior appointments complicate judgments of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the supplied ordinal anchors directly, used only internal recall for real candidates, and treated uncertainty as lower confidence rather than missing scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 5076905481531431260, "entity_order": [ "eva-kondorosi", "peter-paczolay", "gabor-bojar", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:086f066fed32121f27927e716697d85d3b19d1a7093d13c7350fcecc3a02ea19", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:14+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:54+02:00", "duration_s": 99.734, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 3920, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile imply very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive constitutional service and documented rule-of-law commitment match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage public institutions responsibly." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides excellent preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and indicates recent factional involvement." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports visibility abroad despite limited diplomatic preparation and polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame alone does not establish accountability, while polarizing campaigning weakens cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile gives no evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides a modest positive signal, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about trust." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her cultural and academic standing could bridge groups, although her public profile is not universally familiar." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly and civic profile suggests commitment to pluralistic norms, though direct constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic and diplomatic responsibilities suggest capable leadership, albeit outside top-level state administration." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her American-studies expertise and former ambassadorial role provide strong international representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic career supports autonomy, while past diplomatic service creates some connection to political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scholarly career supports credibility with no confidently recalled integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her established partisan identity would likely impose a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her governmental experience indicates procedural familiarity, but strong partisan alignment weakens confidence in restraint." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, parliamentary, and diplomatic responsibilities demonstrate relevant administrative experience." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her diplomatic and European Union experience is directly suited to representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her long senior association with Fidesz suggests limited autonomy from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained public service supports competence, while partisan polarization limits broadly shared trust." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His widely admired cultural achievement carries unusually broad and low-conflict symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public profile offers little basis for assessing constitutional judgment beyond a generally nonpartisan reputation." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and educational accomplishment does not clearly establish capacity to lead a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally recognized name and culturally positive association would provide exceptional representational reach." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career outside party politics suggests strong practical independence." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His enduring creative reputation supports trust, though it reveals little about public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and relatively nonpartisan scientific identity could attract broad respect." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly profile suggests respect for evidence and institutional norms, though direct constitutional experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific work indicates institutional competence, although national public leadership would differ substantially." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific career would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primarily scientific career suggests substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her research reputation conveys credibility, with no confidently recalled integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His achievements could command respect, but explicit political positions may limit cross-factional acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public commitment to open institutions seems favorable, but he lacks a deeply established constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building major commercial and educational institutions demonstrates substantial leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally oriented technology career would give him credible international presence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His entrepreneurial standing provides autonomy, although visible political advocacy may narrow perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as a technology entrepreneur and educator supports credibility, subject to ordinary perceptions of elite influence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise could reassure constitutionalists, but his association with contentious public debates limits consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law scholarship and sustained rule-of-law focus align very strongly with institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic and advisory experience suggests capable leadership without extensive executive administration." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international constitutional scholarship would support credible engagement with foreign institutions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic standing supports autonomy, though prominent positions in constitutional disputes may be viewed through partisan lenses." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established scholarly record supports credibility, while political polarization may constrain shared public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement offers broad national pride with comparatively little partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her evidence-centered professional record supports sound judgment, though constitutional stewardship is outside her demonstrated field." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific and biotechnology roles indicate responsibility, but not direct leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would make her a highly credible representative of Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career appears strongly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally validated scientific work support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could reassure several groups without necessarily inspiring broad public identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal background strongly fit a guardianship role despite contextual reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a high court and subsequent diplomatic responsibility demonstrate strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European legal experience provide directly relevant international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic service supports autonomy, but appointments within contested political structures create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long legal and diplomatic career supports credibility, though public perceptions may reflect institutional controversies." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian scholar of American literature.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "Has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong diplomatic and cultural fluency.", "Credible scholarly independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Direct constitutional experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian Fidesz politician and Member of the European Parliament.", "Served as ambassador to Italy.", "Held a government role responsible for European Union affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Demonstrated administrative competence." ], "reservations": [ "Strong party identification.", "Likely polarizing across political groups." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Invented the Rubik's Cube.", "Worked as an architect and design educator.", "His invention became globally recognized." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural recognition.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little demonstrated constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.", "Held senior research roles in Hungary and France.", "Received major international scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected scientific credibility.", "Little apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited visible constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is not fully familiar." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Founded the software company Graphisoft.", "Founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "Has participated publicly in Hungarian political debate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven institution builder.", "Strong international business standing." ], "reservations": [ "Political advocacy may reduce consensus appeal.", "No direct constitutional office experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "Has taught and researched at international universities.", "His work addresses fundamental rights and constitutionalism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise.", "Strong international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "May be perceived as aligned within polarized constitutional debates.", "Limited executive leadership experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broadly unifying scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional background.", "Limited state-administration experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and legal experience.", "Substantial diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Appointments may attract partisan interpretations.", "Limited broad popular visibility." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh subjective ordinal judgment for every pair, separating limited factual recall from rubric-based interpretation and using low confidence where familiarity was insufficient.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 15041004274580886655, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gabor-halmai", "eniko-gyori", "eva-kondorosi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "control-consensus-guardian", "gabor-bojar", "erno-rubik" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:99298170e6c695e399031309a963f84c1a3995f90ef57358077a8e0a8fa9962b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:27+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:14+02:00", "duration_s": 106.672, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 3981, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity for complex public responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience combined with constitutional stature makes the profile exceptionally strong abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The lack of legal experience combined with polarizing partisan activity gives little basis for confidence in restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational presence, but polarization and inexperience constrain diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity may generate loyalty, but polarizing rhetoric and campaign entanglement substantially weaken general trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility and trust information make unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisan professional service is mildly encouraging, but the profile provides no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and limited public profile indicate a below-average representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, although patrons and pressures remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, but the profile supplies too little information about integrity or public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural and academic distinction with limited partisan burden could support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly background suggests reflective judgment, but I recall little direct rule-of-law experience." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic seniority implies some leadership capacity but offers limited evidence of complex public administration." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally oriented humanities scholarship would support articulate cultural representation." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic career outside salient party office supports a strong impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her established scholarly standing suggests credibility, though my familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her political experience is substantial, but partisan identification would impose a considerable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Government and parliamentary experience is relevant, but close partisan alignment creates meaningful reservations about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior governmental, diplomatic, and parliamentary responsibilities indicate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her diplomatic and European-level experience directly supports international representation." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her established senior party-political career weighs strongly against perceived autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has institutional credibility, but my recall provides insufficient basis for a stronger integrity judgment." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A globally admired cultural invention and minimal partisan burden give him broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His profile offers almost no direct evidence concerning constitutional restraint or legal process." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative accomplishment is clear, but my recall contains little evidence of large public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His invention is globally identified with Hungarian creativity, providing exceptional symbolic recognition abroad." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity is strongly creative and professional rather than partisan." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing reputation as an inventor and educator supports a favorable credibility impression." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and low partisan burden could attract broad respect, though public appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her independent scientific career is reassuring, but it offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research responsibilities suggest leadership capacity, though national public-institution management is different." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific profile would represent Hungary credibly abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research career without salient party office suggests substantial political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific standing creates a strong impression of professional credibility and earned trust." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Business and educational achievement could attract respect, though visible political views may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic orientation is somewhat reassuring, but he lacks a salient constitutional or judicial record in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and leading major private and educational institutions demonstrates exceptional organizational ability." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally successful technology career gives him substantial credibility in global settings." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His entrepreneurial and educational identity suggests independence from formal party command." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institution-building record supports credibility and a strong impression of constructive public purpose." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong liberal-constitutional identification may inspire some groups while limiting acceptance among others." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained constitutional scholarship and rule-of-law focus strongly support this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic and rights-institution experience suggests competence, though executive leadership evidence is less salient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international academic and constitutional-law profile would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic role supports autonomy, though prominent public positions may be perceived through partisan divisions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A substantial scholarly record gives him credibility, despite likely political contestation of that credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and discipline but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding scientific institutions, though presidential-scale administration is not her defining experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional visibility and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity rests overwhelmingly on scientific achievement rather than party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific recognition, and public professional identity create a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist could command respect across groups without necessarily generating broad popular attachment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law and judicial background strongly supports an impression of commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major judicial institutions indicates strong capacity to manage a complex public office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience suggests substantial international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional judicial identity suggests autonomy, though prior high-level state appointments leave some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long institutional career conveys credibility and seriousness, with limited contrary information in my recall." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian literary scholar.", "Her scholarship includes American literature.", "She has worked as a university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Established intellectual credibility.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct institutional evidence.", "Low public familiarity may constrain symbolic reach." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She has served as a Hungarian diplomat.", "She has served as a Member of the European Parliament.", "She held a senior government role concerning European affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Strong familiarity with European institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Close party identification.", "Limited appearance of political independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He invented the Rubik's Cube.", "He is a Hungarian architect and designer.", "His puzzle became a global cultural phenomenon." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international symbolic recognition.", "Broad nonpartisan cultural appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Limited evidence of large public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian biologist.", "Her research concerns plant-microbe interactions.", "She has held senior roles in international scientific bodies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific distinction.", "Low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public unifying appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He founded the software company Graphisoft.", "He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "He is a Hungarian technology entrepreneur." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong institution-building record.", "Substantial international business credibility." ], "reservations": [ "No salient constitutional-office experience.", "Expressed political views may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "His work addresses fundamental rights and constitutionalism.", "He has held international academic positions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional expertise.", "International scholarly credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive-administration experience.", "His public constitutional positions may polarize opinion." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly respected nonpartisan achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited public-administration background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He is a constitutional-law scholar." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise.", "Substantial judicial and international experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Past state appointments may attract partisan interpretations." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective judgments from the supplied profiles and my internal learned representation, applying the same ordinal anchors while treating uncertainty as confidence rather than missingness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 6002919555407759798, "entity_order": [ "erno-rubik", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "eniko-gyori", "gabor-bojar", "eva-kondorosi", "peter-paczolay", "gabor-halmai", "control-unknown-technocrat", "eniko-bollobas", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:350d98d2d9125ac5614b4fe007cb7932d37d22413a9687aeb16b4f23f9770372", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:44+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:33+02:00", "duration_s": 109.875, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 5362, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make constitutional guardianship the profile's clearest strength." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience indicates very strong readiness to represent Hungary internationally." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a substantial barrier to cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile offers no legal experience and combines partisanship with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is valuable abroad, though polarization would constrain representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame alone does not establish public integrity, while overt partisanship burdens broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile supplies neither adverse evidence nor affirmative constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid, if not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile explicitly lacks sufficient trust information." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her cultural and academic stature could provide inclusive symbolism with relatively modest partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly profile is compatible with principled restraint, but I lack direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience provides some institutional grounding, but large-scale executive leadership is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her expertise in American studies and international academic presence would support effective representation." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primary identity as an academic and writer suggests substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished scholarly record supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong identification with one political camp would likely limit cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her governmental and party alignment leaves me uncertain about robust independence in defending institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her experience in government and European institutions indicates substantial administrative competence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic and European experience provides strong preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent party-political career creates substantial reservations about autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall insufficient specific integrity evidence and therefore retain a neutral, uncertain assessment." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His widely admired cultural and inventive legacy carries relatively little polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His non-partisan public profile is encouraging, but I know little about his constitutional commitments." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and entrepreneurial accomplishment does not clearly demonstrate leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His exceptional international recognition would provide strong symbolic representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears substantially independent of party organizations and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding public reputation appears credible and largely free of prominent integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished and comparatively non-partisan scientific profile could command broad respect." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly standing suggests procedural seriousness, but I lack evidence of direct constitutional engagement." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior scientific roles suggest meaningful institutional experience, though not broad public executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international scientific standing and European institutional experience would translate well abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears grounded in scientific institutions rather than party or patronage networks." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific reputation supports a strong impression of professional integrity and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He could appeal across professional groups, although public political interventions may narrow consensus." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile is compatible with institutional restraint, but his direct constitutional record is limited." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Founding and leading major organizations demonstrates strong executive and institution-building capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally oriented business career would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority comes principally from entrepreneurship and education rather than party hierarchy." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record of building durable enterprises and educational institutions supports credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His clear positions on contested constitutional issues could limit acceptance among opposing political groups." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career as a constitutional scholar strongly signals commitment to rights, legal process, and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and constitutional-policy experience is substantial, though broad executive leadership is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic profile would support articulate and credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic position supports autonomy, although prominent normative advocacy may be viewed as politically situated." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained scholarly engagement with constitutionalism supports a strong impression of intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and discipline, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding institutions, though executive public leadership is not her defining experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional credibility and visibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her standing derives chiefly from scientific achievement rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reputation for rigorous, persevering scientific work supports a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile could attract respect beyond a single political constituency." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal background directly support a strong guardianship assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court provides directly relevant experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European human-rights experience indicates exceptional representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though appointments inevitably create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained service in senior legal and diplomatic offices supports credibility, with limited recalled contrary evidence." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian literary scholar.", "She specializes in American studies.", "She has worked as a university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent scholarly stature", "International cultural competence" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Limited public executive record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She has served as a Hungarian diplomat.", "She has served as a Member of the European Parliament.", "She has held government responsibility for European affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial diplomatic experience", "Familiarity with European institutions" ], "reservations": [ "Strong party-political identification", "Limited cross-camp appeal" ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He invented the Rubik's Cube.", "He is a Hungarian architect and designer.", "His invention became globally recognized." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad non-partisan symbolic appeal", "Exceptional international recognition" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Limited public-institution leadership evidence" ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian biologist.", "Her research concerns plant-microbe symbiosis.", "She has held senior roles in European scientific organizations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific integrity", "International institutional standing" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Limited broad public visibility" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He co-founded Graphisoft.", "He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "He is a Hungarian technology entrepreneur." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated institution-building ability", "International business credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience", "Some political positioning may divide audiences" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has held academic positions outside Hungary.", "His work addresses constitutionalism and fundamental rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise", "Strong international academic credibility" ], "reservations": [ "May be polarizing in domestic politics", "Limited broad executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected scientific achievement", "Strong non-partisan credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Limited public executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional leadership", "Extensive diplomatic and legal experience" ], "reservations": [ "Public cross-group appeal is uncertain", "Senior appointments may invite independence questions" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective impressions from the supplied profiles and my internal recollection, using uncertainty to adjust confidence rather than omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 1769297458989162488, "entity_order": [ "gabor-bojar", "eva-kondorosi", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-halmai", "peter-paczolay", "eniko-gyori", "eniko-bollobas", "erno-rubik", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:ff260ef188735a30198cd7a535a575f07c2e0ce7466abe8314ee915960341d90", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:23:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:20+02:00", "duration_s": 91.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 3975, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a low-partisan profile imply very strong unifying capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make the profile exceptionally strong on constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates highly relevant institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representative capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely despite fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide little basis for confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience indicates very weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility, but polarizing rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience substantially limit suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity may confer recognition, but the profile supplies little integrity evidence and substantial polarization." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile gives no direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid, though not exceptional, leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility indicates weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides a neutral baseline while broader trust and integrity evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural stature and limited partisan burden could foster inclusion, though public reach appears constrained." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her academic profile suggests principled judgment, but gives little direct evidence on constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience suggests competence but provides limited evidence of leading a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally oriented humanities scholarship would support articulate and culturally credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A scholarly career outside party leadership supports a strong impression of independence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her established scholarly reputation supports credibility and intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her close identification with one political camp would impose a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her government and party alignment creates reservations about prioritizing institutional checks over factional objectives." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior diplomatic, governmental, and European roles demonstrate considerable institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive diplomatic and European-policy experience is directly relevant and highly developed." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A sustained senior party-political career strongly limits the impression of autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional experience supports competence, but partisan identification limits cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His iconic, nonpartisan cultural achievement offers unusually broad and positive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His thoughtful public profile is compatible with restraint, but supplies almost no constitutional track record." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His creative and educational work indicates judgment, but not extensive large-institution executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional worldwide recognition would make him a distinctive and respected cultural representative." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long creative and academic career appears notably detached from party organization." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained public presence and enduring creative achievement support high trust." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and low partisan burden could make her broadly acceptable despite limited public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly profile suggests procedural seriousness, but offers little direct evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific responsibilities indicate institutional capability, though not at head-of-state scale." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career would translate well into representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A research career largely outside partisan politics supports perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished scientific standing creates a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic and educational standing could bridge groups, but visible political criticism may narrow acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-minded and institution-building profile suggests respect for legal constraints, though direct constitutional stewardship is limited." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and leading major business and educational institutions strongly supports executive competence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized entrepreneurial background would provide credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An entrepreneurial career outside party structures supports a strong impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as a prominent founder and education patron conveys credibility with some political reservations." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise is substantial, but association with contested rule-of-law debates could limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career-long engagement with constitutionalism and rights strongly supports commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and rights-institution experience indicates sound governance capacity without broad executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international constitutional-law career would provide strong professional credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic standing supports autonomy, while identifiable positions in constitutional disputes may affect perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly consistency supports credibility, although political polarization may constrain public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and national recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests discipline and responsibility but provides little basis for constitutional evaluation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates formidable professional judgment, though large public-institution leadership is not her defining experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and distance from party organization create a very strong impression of independence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and restrained public persona strongly support trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could command broad respect, but past institutional controversies may divide assessments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive constitutional adjudication gives him unusually direct preparation for guarding legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates highly relevant complex institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience provides excellent preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial roles support autonomy, though prior state appointments create some perceived establishment dependence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long judicial and diplomatic career supports credibility with limited but meaningful political reservations." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian literary scholar and Americanist.", "Has taught at Eotvos Lorand University.", "Known for work in English and American literature." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scholarly orientation.", "Low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public executive experience.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian politician associated with Fidesz.", "Has served as a Member of the European Parliament.", "Has held diplomatic and government foreign-policy roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive European affairs experience.", "Demonstrated institutional competence." ], "reservations": [ "Strong party identification.", "Limited cross-group acceptability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Invented the Rubik's Cube.", "Hungarian architect and designer.", "Has worked in education and creative design." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary global recognition.", "Broad nonpartisan cultural appeal." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional record.", "Limited evidence of large public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian plant biologist.", "Known for research on plant-microbe symbiosis.", "Has held senior roles in European scientific institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected scientist.", "Low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Founded Graphisoft.", "Established Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "Has participated publicly in Hungarian civic and political debate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent institution-builder.", "Strong international business credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Public political positions may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "Has written extensively on fundamental rights and constitutionalism.", "Has held academic positions outside Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong international professional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Identified with contested rule-of-law debates.", "Limited broad executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Biochemist central to advances in mRNA technology.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in Hungary and the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international stature.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Limited large public-institution leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship experience.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Past state appointments may affect perceived independence.", "Institutional controversies may limit consensus appeal." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal familiarity for real candidates and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls, treating uncertainty as confidence rather than missing scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "erno-rubik", "eva-kondorosi", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 4477619779350193976, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "erno-rubik", "control-consensus-guardian", "eniko-bollobas", "eniko-gyori", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "gabor-bojar", "gabor-halmai", "eva-kondorosi", "control-unknown-technocrat" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:c9ce5ad5e5c8aeb81806e70baf392062df3847824b9e8ee733c59e40b2d5554c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:11+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:00+02:00", "duration_s": 108.656, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21472, "output_tokens": 4157, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented nonpartisan rule-of-law service directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides direct preparation for credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service across governments and a nonpartisan judicial career strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and combines recent partisan activity with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of legal and institutional leadership experience makes this a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is a real representational asset despite the liabilities created by polarizing conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create recognition, but the profile offers little basis for accountability or broadly shared trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide solid evidence of responsible institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a comparatively weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patronal relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supports a neutral baseline, while insufficient trust and integrity information prevents a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An eminent cultural and academic profile could command respect, though her broader cross-group reach is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly profile suggests deliberative judgment, but I recall little direct constitutional or executive record." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant but provides limited evidence of leadership at presidential institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international humanities scholarship and linguistic profile appear well suited to cultural diplomacy." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primary identity as an academic rather than a party official supports a strong impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly standing supports credibility, with no confidently recalled integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong identification with one governing political camp would likely limit cross-group symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her government and party career supplies institutional experience but also creates reservations about independent constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her diplomatic, governmental, and European parliamentary experience indicates substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive diplomatic and European affairs experience directly supports international representation." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A substantial senior party-political career weakens the impression of autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record supports baseline credibility, but partisan identification makes broad public trust uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His culturally iconic achievement offers broad appeal with little obvious polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His thoughtful public image is compatible with restraint, but his record offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative and educational accomplishment does not clearly establish readiness to lead a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His invention is globally recognized and strongly associated with Hungarian creativity." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is primarily identified with creative and educational work rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding public reputation appears credible and largely free of prominent integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and comparatively nonpartisan scientific profile offers broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific governance background suggests procedural seriousness, though constitutional judgment is not directly demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior roles in research organizations indicate substantial experience with complex institutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific stature and European institutional experience would translate well to representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears rooted in science and international research institutions rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent scientific career supports a very strong impression of professional credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He could appeal across business, education, and civic constituencies but may carry a recognizable political alignment." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public commitment to open institutions appears favorable, although he lacks a direct constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building major technology and educational institutions demonstrates strong strategic and organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally successful technology career would convey competence and modern Hungarian achievement." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His entrepreneurial base supports autonomy, while visible political advocacy may reduce perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institution-building and entrepreneurial reputation support credibility, subject to ordinary reservations about public advocacy." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional expertise is substantial, but his public association with contested rule-of-law debates may limit cross-camp acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in constitutional law and rights scholarship directly supports strong commitment to legal checks and constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and rights-institution experience is relevant, though I recall less evidence of executive leadership at national scale." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international academic standing and constitutional expertise would support credible representation in European settings." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic position supports intellectual autonomy, though prominent normative advocacy may be perceived as politically aligned." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A sustained scholarly record supports credibility and principled consistency despite likely partisan disagreement about his views." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad and comparatively nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for institutional processes, though constitutional stewardship is outside her demonstrated domain." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has extensive experience in demanding research organizations but limited visible experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international recognition and representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and research reputation support a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could be broadly acceptable, though constitutional controversies may burden some audiences." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and judicial service provides unusually direct preparation for guarding legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court and service in international institutions demonstrate high institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience strongly support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, though high-level state appointments create some uncertainty about perceived distance from government." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long service in prominent legal institutions supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian literary scholar associated with American studies.", "Has held a university professorship." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Scholarly career suggests independence and deliberation.", "International academic orientation supports cultural representation." ], "reservations": [ "Low confidence in the breadth of her institutional record.", "Broader public recognition and unifying reach are uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian politician associated with Fidesz.", "Has served as a member of the European Parliament.", "Has held diplomatic or European-affairs responsibilities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial governmental and European experience.", "Strong preparation for diplomatic representation." ], "reservations": [ "Deep party identification weakens perceived independence.", "Partisan profile limits cross-group acceptability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian architect and designer.", "Invented the Rubik's Cube.", "Worked in design and education." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally recognized symbol of Hungarian creativity.", "Carries relatively little partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Limited demonstrated constitutional expertise.", "Limited visible experience leading complex public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian biologist known for research on plant-microbe interactions.", "Has held senior roles in European scientific organizations.", "Is an internationally recognized research scientist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High scientific credibility with little partisan burden.", "International institutional experience supports representation." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Broader public familiarity and political unifying capacity are uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Founded the software company Graphisoft.", "Founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.", "Has participated publicly in Hungarian civic and political debate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated institution-building and executive competence.", "Strong international technology and education profile." ], "reservations": [ "Public political advocacy may reduce perceived neutrality.", "No direct constitutional or diplomatic mandate is recalled." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "Has taught or researched at the European University Institute.", "Has written extensively on constitutionalism and fundamental rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep expertise in constitutional safeguards.", "Strong international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Public positions may be viewed as aligned within polarized debates.", "National-scale executive leadership is less clearly demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Held senior research roles connected with BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific credibility.", "Broadly nonpartisan symbol of perseverance and achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or political experience.", "Public-institution leadership at presidential scale is not clearly demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and judicial expertise.", "Strong combination of institutional and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "High-level state appointments may affect perceived independence.", "Past constitutional controversies may constrain unifying appeal." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh subjective ordinal judgment for every entity-criterion pair, using only internal recall for real figures and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 11852149991872328771, "entity_order": [ "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-tilesch", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "control-consensus-guardian", "gabor-ivanyi", "peter-paczolay", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:ebcaa58179d260803f35957b1824f3fad881bfc22d9b7ac2b670e7d0afbe756c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:27+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:52+02:00", "duration_s": 84.797, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 3782, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports highly credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate institutional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning create substantial restraint concerns." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global fame supplies reach and presence despite limited diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition cannot compensate for polarization and uncertain accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader unifying appeal is unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is favorable, but constitutional commitments are not established." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong relevant leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply a weak representative fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports a strong though incomplete independence assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence helps, but the profile explicitly leaves broader trust uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral standing attracts support, but sustained political conflict limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy for rights and institutional limits suggests strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading religious and charitable institutions demonstrates substantial organizational responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has moral presence but a less developed diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears personally independent despite clear alignment in major political conflicts." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding social and religious service supports a high-integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured public style could attract acceptance across political camps." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical distance and institutional focus suggest respect for constitutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Analytical competence is evident, but major executive leadership is less established." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears capable but lacks a prominent international representative profile." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public profile appears substantially more analytical than party-directed." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His credibility as a comparatively restrained analyst supports a strong assessment." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and limited partisan baggage could support broad acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing is favorable, but constitutional stewardship is outside his demonstrated domain." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Research leadership is relevant but differs materially from leading a constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international scientific career would confer substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career suggests substantial autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished academic reputation supports high credibility and trust." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His experienced technocratic profile could reassure several camps, though economic decisions remain contestable." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as a senior economic institution-builder suggests respect for rules and constraints." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated leadership of a major national institution demonstrates exceptional relevant capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international economic standing would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic standing and service under differing governments support substantial autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding professional credibility supports trust with some residual political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional stature helps, but political associations may constrain cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior public service is favorable, but direct constitutional commitments are less evident." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and diplomatic roles demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive international economic and ambassadorial experience is exceptionally relevant." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A technocratic career supports autonomy, while later government-linked diplomacy tempers it." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long economic and diplomatic career supports a generally credible impression." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A technocratic profile may limit polarization but offers uncertain symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional profile supplies little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and organizational experience suggests competence without proving high public-office leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology-policy work suggests strong global fluency and presence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy career appears relatively independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional credibility is positive, though broad public trust is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement offers unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public reputation is favorable, but constitutional stewardship is outside her demonstrated expertise." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional scientific accomplishment does not fully establish leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide recognition and scientific distinction provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global stature appear strongly independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific record and public image support very high credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could command broad respect despite limited popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-court experience directly supports very strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates directly relevant institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and European legal experience indicate strong representative ability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and diplomatic service supports strong institutional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian Methodist pastor.", "Founded or led charitable and educational institutions.", "Previously served as a member of parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long record of social service.", "Visible commitment to marginalized groups." ], "reservations": [ "Strong political conflicts may limit unifying reach.", "Diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist and analyst.", "Known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Analytically restrained public style.", "Relatively low partisan identification." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive leadership record.", "International representative experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "Known for research on neural oscillations.", "Has held senior academic roles in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Limited partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "No clear constitutional-office experience.", "Academic leadership may not transfer fully to state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Served two terms as central-bank governor.", "Economist with international professional experience." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive high-level institutional leadership.", "Strong technocratic and international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Past economic policy remains politically contestable.", "Not primarily identified with constitutional law." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "Worked at the International Monetary Fund." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep international economic experience.", "Strong diplomatic and institutional résumé." ], "reservations": [ "Government association may reduce perceived independence.", "Unifying appeal beyond elite circles is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian technology and artificial-intelligence policy expert.", "Has worked in international advisory settings." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International professional orientation.", "Appears relatively independent of domestic parties." ], "reservations": [ "Little demonstrated constitutional experience.", "Broad public legitimacy is untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Worked in European constitutional-law institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Substantial judicial and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Past institutional decisions may attract partisan criticism." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective judgments based only on internal recall for real figures and the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 11078023478065233110, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "gyorgy-szapary" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:655f3c68f898664dc5a8e35ccd108d4a397d9ad46ecedabf6a0dd49ec54c9096", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:36+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:46+02:00", "duration_s": 129.39, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 5483, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan profile indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge exactly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and adds recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides substantial representational presence despite limited diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create personal credibility for admirers, but polarization and partisanship sharply limit general trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing baggage but leaves unifying appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is compatible with restraint but does not demonstrate constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides solid evidence of responsible organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports a relatively independent profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers a modest positive signal, but broader trust and integrity information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral authority could bridge groups, but prolonged political conflict makes him polarizing for some." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained advocacy for vulnerable groups and religious autonomy suggests strong rights-based commitments." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has substantial experience leading religious and charitable institutions under pressure." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He offers moral presence but has limited demonstrated diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has demonstrated independence from governing power despite recognizable opposition alignment." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long record of social and pastoral service supports a strong impression of personal integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured analytical style and cross-spectrum audience give him comparatively low polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical engagement with democratic institutions suggests respect for constitutional process." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Analytical expertise does not itself establish capacity to lead a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears articulate and credible but lacks a prominent diplomatic record." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an analyst rather than a party operative supports perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A reputation for careful analysis supports credibility, though public trust beyond his audience is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a low-partisan profile could support broad symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career offers little basis for judging commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic leadership is relevant but narrower than directing a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific stature would give Hungary substantial international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established academic career appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished research standing supports credibility and a strong presumption of professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility could attract moderates, but past economic-policy conflicts may limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His central-banking background suggests respect for formal mandates and institutional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the national central bank demonstrates high-level management of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international economic standing supports credible representation in high-level foreign settings." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic stature supports autonomy, though his long public-policy history carries political associations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained senior economic roles support credibility despite inevitable controversy around monetary policy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His restrained technocratic profile is not highly polarizing but has limited broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career suggests institutional discipline, though constitutional law was not its central focus." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-banking and diplomatic responsibilities demonstrate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and international financial experience make foreign representation a major strength." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials support autonomy, but senior government-linked appointments create meaningful political association." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long international economic and diplomatic career supports professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low domestic political profile limits both polarizing burden and demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy profile supplies little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and organizational experience suggests competence but not proven leadership of a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology-policy work suggests credible global representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His international advisory career appears relatively independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional credibility is plausible, but broad public trust is not established in my representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her celebrated achievement and low-partisan profile create unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific achievements provide little direct basis for assessing constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led consequential research work but lacks clearly comparable experience running a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide scientific recognition gives her exceptional international credibility and presence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career is strongly detached from Hungarian party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific accomplishment and perseverance support exceptional credibility and public esteem." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist could command cross-group respect without carrying a strongly partisan public identity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates unusually relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience indicates strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career suggests autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some political association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial record gives him substantial institutional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Methodist pastor.", "He founded or led institutions providing social and educational services.", "He has been a prominent critic of Viktor Orbán's government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Longstanding service to vulnerable communities.", "Demonstrated willingness to resist political pressure." ], "reservations": [ "His conflict with the government makes him polarizing.", "He has limited conventional diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist and analyst.", "He is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured and analytically disciplined public style.", "Comparatively independent of party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Analysis is not equivalent to executive leadership.", "His diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "He is known for research on neural oscillations and memory.", "He has held senior academic positions in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific credibility.", "Low-partisan and broadly respectable profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little basis for evaluating constitutional judgment.", "Academic leadership may not transfer fully to state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is an economist.", "He held senior roles in international banking." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major public institution.", "Strong international economic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Monetary-policy history carries political controversy.", "Technocratic stature does not guarantee broad symbolic appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He held senior positions at the Hungarian National Bank.", "He worked at the International Monetary Fund." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep diplomatic and international economic experience.", "Strong record in complex institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Government appointments weaken the appearance of full independence.", "His public unifying appeal is not strongly demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is associated with international artificial-intelligence strategy and policy work." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally oriented professional profile.", "Limited visible attachment to Hungarian party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little demonstrated constitutional experience.", "Domestic public trust and leadership capacity are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international prestige.", "Broadly unifying and politically independent public image." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional-law background.", "Limited demonstrated leadership of complex public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally relevant constitutional experience.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic profile." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may create political associations.", "Broad popular appeal is less established than institutional esteem." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores express an anchored subjective impression based only on internal representation for real figures and the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 17209348734482263907, "entity_order": [ "gyorgy-suranyi", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "gyorgy-szapary", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "control-unknown-technocrat" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:6ae55353fbecf14534002d90f737ed0a4176a90eb7875da14620377b91c32923", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:42+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:29+02:00", "duration_s": 106.281, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 5325, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match this criterion's strongest anchor." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe obstacle to cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and substantial evidence of factional orientation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience indicates very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility, but polarizing conduct and absent diplomatic experience impose major reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong dependence on partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but the profile provides little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader appeal and symbolic inclusion are unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong leadership with some uncertainty about institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak representative readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides a modest positive signal, while trust and integrity evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral standing may bridge social groups, but prolonged political conflict makes him polarizing." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy for rights and institutional accountability suggests strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading religious and charitable organizations indicates meaningful institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He offers moral presence but has limited recalled diplomatic or international executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears independent of governing-party command, though he has recognizable opposition associations." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding charitable and pastoral work supports a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured analytical style offers cross-group accessibility despite inevitable controversy around political commentary." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical engagement with democratic institutions suggests respect for constitutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic and analytical experience does not clearly establish leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He could communicate political complexity effectively, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an analyst rather than party politician supports substantial independence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained reputation for comparatively restrained analysis supports credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and minimal partisan baggage give him strong symbolic breadth." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing suggests disciplined judgment but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic work implies leadership, but not necessarily stewardship of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific stature would provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally based scientific career appears highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent research career supports strong professional trust and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic stature could reassure several groups, but his economic-policy history may divide opinion." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic record suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional stewardship was not his primary field." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank experience strongly indicates capacity to lead a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international economic standing would translate well into credible external representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Central-bank leadership supports an impression of professional autonomy despite unavoidable political associations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional credibility, with some trust constrained by past policy controversies." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Technocratic stature helps, but identifiable government alignment limits cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His establishment experience is relevant, but I recall insufficient evidence of distinctive constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior economic and diplomatic roles indicate strong institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ambassadorial and international financial experience strongly fit representative duties." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior service under a partisan government weakens the appearance of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His long professional career supports credibility, while limited recalled detail keeps the assessment guarded." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented professional identity may travel across groups, though public acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall too little direct legal or constitutional experience to move beyond an uncertain midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and innovation work suggests competence without clearly established leadership of a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology-policy profile supports credible outward-facing representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His primarily technology-oriented profile suggests distance from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing is favorable, but my limited familiarity prevents a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan baggage give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation suggests seriousness and restraint, but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial professional experience but limited visible leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific recognition would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career identity is overwhelmingly scientific rather than partisan or factional." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally recognized scientific work support exceptional personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained jurist profile carries relatively low polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background directly supports strong commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates strong capacity for complex public responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and European legal experience make him a very strong international representative." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic service suggest professional autonomy despite appointment-system associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished legal and judicial career supports considerable credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Methodist pastor.", "He has served as a member of parliament.", "He leads charitable and educational work." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong moral and social-service profile.", "Visible commitment to vulnerable groups." ], "reservations": [ "Conflict with the government increases polarization.", "Limited diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He is known for public political analysis.", "He has taught at university." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured and analytically minded public profile.", "Relative distance from formal party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive institutional experience.", "Limited recalled diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "He is known for research on brain rhythms.", "He has held a senior academic position in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scholarly credibility.", "Minimal partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public-sector executive capacity is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is an economist.", "He has held senior international financial roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic and institutional experience.", "Credible international economic profile." ], "reservations": [ "Past economic policies may remain politically divisive.", "His constitutional credentials are indirect." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an economist.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He held senior roles at the Hungarian National Bank." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial economic-policy experience.", "Strong diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Government alignment weakens perceived independence.", "Broader unifying appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is associated with artificial-intelligence policy and strategy.", "He has worked internationally." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International and future-oriented outlook.", "Limited visible domestic partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Very limited partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited visible public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and judicial expertise.", "Strong European diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His public profile is relatively technocratic.", "Appointment associations may complicate perceived independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective judgments based only on internal recall for real figures and only on supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 6119605238534677296, "entity_order": [ "gyorgy-suranyi", "gabor-torok", "control-partisan-celebrity", "gyorgy-szapary", "peter-paczolay", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gabor-ivanyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:260a18aefa841efcab0970c909650d16a57410a49ba2e4db669ca837de949956", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:54+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:36+02:00", "duration_s": 102.219, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 3955, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match exceptional constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates highly relevant institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe burden on cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal or institutional record supports confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no experience leading a complex legal or public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility abroad, although celebrity does not ensure diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but partisanship and polarization weaken broadly shared credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing baggage but leaves unifying appeal unestablished." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly reassuring, but the profile gives no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide solid evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak readiness for foreign representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is positive, but the supplied information is insufficient to assess trust and integrity broadly." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His humanitarian standing inspires many but sharp conflict with the government makes him polarizing to others." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained advocacy for vulnerable groups and institutional pluralism suggests strong constitutional commitments." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has substantial experience leading religious and social-service organizations under difficult conditions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral stature could represent Hungary credibly, but his direct diplomatic experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral advocacy appears autonomous, though his public conflicts and political history complicate nonpartisan perception." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding charitable and pastoral work supports a strong impression of personal integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured analytical style could bridge audiences, though political commentary inevitably creates detractors." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical orientation suggests procedural seriousness, but he lacks a substantial record of constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic and analytical competence does not establish readiness to lead a major constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He could communicate intelligently abroad, but I recall little direct diplomatic or international leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as a political analyst appears comparatively independent of direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reputation for restrained analysis supports credibility, with limited evidence of executive accountability." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan baggage could provide an inclusive national symbol." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction offers no direct record for evaluating constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major research programs shows organizational capacity but not experience with a constitutional public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific stature would confer substantial international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally based scientific career suggests substantial independence from domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research reputation supports credibility, though scientific esteem is not identical to public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic stature could reassure moderates, but past economic-policy disputes would limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic background suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional stewardship was not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a central bank provides unusually relevant experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international economic standing and senior financial experience support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His central-banking profile suggests professional autonomy despite unavoidable connections to successive political environments." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional credibility, although public trust in prominent economic policymakers is rarely uniform." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional demeanor may reassure some groups, but political associations constrain broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service record suggests procedural competence, but not distinctive constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-banking and public-service roles demonstrate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and international economic experience make foreign representation a clear strength." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials support some autonomy, while senior government-linked service raises factional-distance concerns." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long economic and diplomatic career supports credibility, though broad public trust is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented professional identity may cross camps, but low domestic visibility limits symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy profile provides little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and organizational experience is relevant but falls short of demonstrated leadership of a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology-policy network and global professional experience would aid representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An international advisory career appears relatively detached from Hungarian party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional profile appears credible, but I lack enough information to judge broad public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely admired scientific achievement and minimal partisan baggage give her exceptional symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career supplies little direct evidence about constitutional judgment or legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at the highest scientific level, but that does not establish executive public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature would provide exceptional recognition and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career is notably independent of domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific credibility support very strong trust, with limited public reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could attract broad respect without guaranteeing popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career directly support strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court is exceptionally relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience strongly supports international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though appointments necessarily invite political scrutiny." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial record supports credibility and accountability with limited recalled integrity concerns." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Methodist pastor.", "He founded or led organizations providing social services.", "He previously served as a member of Hungary's parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong humanitarian and moral profile", "Demonstrated organizational resilience" ], "reservations": [ "Highly contentious relationship with the government", "Limited diplomatic and constitutional-office experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist and analyst.", "He has taught at university.", "He is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Comparatively measured public style", "Visible distance from direct party office" ], "reservations": [ "Little major executive experience", "Limited diplomatic record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "He is known for research on brain rhythms.", "He has held a professorship at New York University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific standing", "Low partisan burden" ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional track record", "Limited public-sector executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is an economist.", "He held senior roles in international banking." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional macroeconomic institutional experience", "Strong international professional credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Past economic-policy controversies may divide opinion", "Limited direct constitutional-law background" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He was a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He worked at the International Monetary Fund." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep economic-institutional experience", "Extensive international representation experience" ], "reservations": [ "Government associations reduce perceived independence", "Limited unifying popular profile" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is associated with artificial-intelligence policy and strategy.", "He has worked internationally in technology advisory roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally oriented expertise", "Limited domestic partisan baggage" ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled constitutional experience", "Unclear public-institution leadership record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-American biochemist associated with mRNA technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international credibility", "Broadly admired nonpartisan achievement" ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional experience", "Limited evidence of complex public-institution leadership" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship record", "Strong judicial and diplomatic credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public profile", "Political appointment history may attract scrutiny" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective judgments based solely on internal representation for real figures and the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 4553910541359133277, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "gyorgy-suranyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "gabor-torok", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gabor-ivanyi", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gyorgy-szapary", "control-unknown-technocrat" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:694e4d2461d0e103aa13697d8f6eb613c14e9cb8f6b99bb96db7b186497d77b4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:24:56+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:58+02:00", "duration_s": 121.719, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 5520, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide unusually strong evidence of inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments indicates highly developed institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would impose a severe burden on cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Lack of legal experience and polarizing partisan activity indicate weak fit for constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience is a major deficiency." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides representational presence despite limited evidence of diplomatic competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity suggests substantial exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity stature may confer recognition, but the profile supplies little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly relevant, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide strong, though not exceptional, leadership evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak international representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers a modest positive signal, but the profile explicitly lacks broader trust information." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral and charitable profile may bridge communities, but prolonged political conflict makes him polarizing." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained advocacy for rights and vulnerable groups suggests strong commitment to legal and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His leadership of religious and charitable organizations demonstrates meaningful institutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His moral profile could represent Hungary credibly, but my representation contains limited diplomatic evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His willingness to confront governing power suggests independence, though he has identifiable political history and alignments." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding social-service advocacy supports strong perceived integrity despite partisan contestation." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured analytical style could attract cross-group respect despite inevitable disputes over his commentary." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical engagement with institutions is relevant, but he lacks a substantial record exercising constitutional authority." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Political expertise is evident, but experience leading a complex public institution is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears domestically credible, but my representation contains limited evidence of diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an analyst rather than a party officeholder suggests strong factional independence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established explanatory role supports credibility, though analyst neutrality is interpreted differently across camps." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Distinguished non-partisan scholarship offers broad symbolic appeal with relatively little polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific standing offers no strong negative signal, but provides little direct basis for judging constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior scientific work implies organizational competence but not necessarily leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally recognized scientific career would confer very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally based scientific career suggests very strong distance from Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His eminent academic reputation supports credibility, though public-accountability experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility could bridge some groups, but economic-policy associations may divide others." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service background supports institutional seriousness, though constitutional guardianship was not his primary field." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a central bank demonstrates exceptional capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally legible economic-policy experience would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A technocratic central-banking identity suggests meaningful autonomy from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature supports credibility, with some reservation about contested political perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional stature may attract respect, but association with a polarized governing era limits cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His long public career indicates institutional experience, but constitutional restraint is not the clearest feature of my representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior central-banking and diplomatic roles indicate strong capacity within complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and international economic experience directly support very strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials support some autonomy, while senior government-linked diplomatic service creates meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His long technocratic career supports credibility, tempered by politically contested institutional associations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented technocratic identity may cross factions, but he has limited broad public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited familiarity provides insufficient evidence of either exceptional or weak constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and technology-policy work suggests competence without clearly establishing major public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally oriented technology-policy work suggests strong representational fluency." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy profile appears relatively independent of domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional profile appears credible, but I lack enough information to assess public accountability strongly." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and limited partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and discipline, but offers little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding institutions, but large public-institution leadership is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility and visibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and non-party public identity indicate very strong independence from domestic factional command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her achievement-centered public standing supports very strong credibility and trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could command broad respect, albeit without strong popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal background directly support very strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience provides very strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career supports autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite political scrutiny." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial standing supports substantial credibility and institutional trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian Methodist pastor.", "He has served as a member of parliament.", "He has led organizations providing social and educational services." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long record of advocacy for vulnerable groups.", "Demonstrated willingness to challenge political power." ], "reservations": [ "His conflicts with the government make him polarizing.", "His political history limits a fully non-partisan image." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He is widely known as a political analyst.", "He has taught political science." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Relatively independent and measured public profile.", "Strong understanding of Hungarian political institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive public-institution experience.", "Little recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "He is known for research on neural oscillations.", "He has held a professorship at New York University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scientific credibility.", "Low partisan burden and broad symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Public-sector executive leadership is not central to his record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is an economist.", "He held senior international banking roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic and institutional leadership profile.", "Substantial international economic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law experience.", "Economic-policy associations may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He held senior roles at the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is an economist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and economic-policy experience.", "Strong record in complex institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Government association may limit perceived independence.", "Cross-group symbolic appeal appears uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is associated with artificial-intelligence policy and strategy.", "He has worked internationally in technology advising." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally oriented technocratic profile.", "Appears relatively distant from domestic party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Insufficient recalled constitutional and institutional record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with low partisan burden.", "Broad symbolic appeal grounded in scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record leading a complex public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct and extensive constitutional credentials.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public symbolic visibility.", "Senior appointments may attract partisan interpretations." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real candidates and only the supplied descriptions of synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 4132542312698926262, "entity_order": [ "gabor-torok", "control-consensus-guardian", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "gabor-ivanyi", "gyorgy-szapary" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:eeeb9254e099be343f963759850131e26d87aade90c5143b3135d347f4b5e912", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:14+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:43+02:00", "duration_s": 149.687, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21551, "output_tokens": 3833, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest exceptional acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional and rule-of-law service directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates capacity to manage public institutions responsibly." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong basis for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate unusually strong factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric substantially weakens cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal experience and indicates factional involvement rather than institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The supplied profile explicitly lacks institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition is valuable abroad, though polarizing rhetoric reduces diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create recognition, but polarization and limited accountability experience weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Limited visibility leaves both unifying appeal and polarizing burden largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile supplies no meaningful evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid, though not exceptional, leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and low visibility make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is indicated, but broader trust and integrity information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His humanitarian standing is inclusive, but intense political conflict limits universal acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy for rights and institutional limits suggests strong commitment to constitutional safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of religious and social-service organizations demonstrates meaningful operational responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His moral voice could represent Hungary credibly, but his diplomatic experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His willingness to confront governing power supports independence, though he has a recognizable political history." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding social and charitable work supports integrity despite contested public narratives." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured public style may be acceptable across groups, though political commentary creates some baggage." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical distance from day-to-day party politics suggests respect for institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Public analytical competence is visible, but experience leading a complex state institution is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears articulate and politically informed, but his diplomatic profile is limited." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an independent political analyst supports perceived autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding analytical role conveys credibility, with inevitable disputes over perceived bias." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement offers broadly inclusive symbolism with relatively little partisan baggage." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience is relevant but not equivalent to leading a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally recognized scientific career would confer substantial international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established academic career suggests substantial independence from domestic factions." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research reputation supports credibility, though public accountability is untested." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has establishment credibility but economic-policy controversies may limit cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Central-bank leadership suggests respect for legal mandates and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated leadership of the national central bank demonstrates high-level institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His central-banking career provides substantial international economic and diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic standing supports autonomy, though senior economic roles inevitably intersect with politics." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding professional credibility is positive, while past policy conflicts create reservations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained technocratic profile reduces polarization but offers limited demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior public service suggests institutional discipline but provides limited direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and international economic roles indicate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and international financial experience directly fit external representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic background supports autonomy, while later government appointments create factional reservations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long international economic career supports credibility, though broad domestic trust is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low domestic political profile limits both polarizing burden and demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technocratic profile offers little basis for judging commitment to constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Executive and advisory work in technology governance suggests useful organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally oriented technology-policy work suggests strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A technology-policy career appears relatively detached from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional reputation seems credible, but broad public trust is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement provides unusually broad and low-partisanship national symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific record offers little direct evidence concerning constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial scientific and organizational experience but limited visible public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global recognition and scientific stature make her an exceptional international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career and reputation were built largely outside Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally validated scientific work support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile may bridge groups, though constitutional controversies can remain divisive." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career directly support strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial public-institution management experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience strongly support international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest meaningful institutional autonomy despite appointment-related perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial service supports credibility, subject to differing assessments of institutional decisions." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian Methodist pastor.", "Founded or led organizations providing social services.", "Previously served as a member of parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long humanitarian and social-service record.", "Demonstrated willingness to oppose concentrated power." ], "reservations": [ "Deep conflict with the current governing camp.", "Political history limits a wholly nonpartisan image." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist and analyst.", "Known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Analytical and measured public persona.", "Appears comparatively independent of party command." ], "reservations": [ "Limited visible executive-state leadership.", "Political analysis can generate perceived-bias disputes." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "Known for research on brain rhythms.", "Has held a senior academic role in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific credibility.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "No clear constitutional track record.", "Public-institution leadership remains untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Served two separate terms as central-bank governor.", "Economist with international financial experience." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a complex institution.", "Strong international economic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Associated with contested economic-policy periods.", "Establishment profile may constrain unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "Worked at the International Monetary Fund." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and economic experience.", "Demonstrated senior institutional competence." ], "reservations": [ "Government appointments affect perceived independence.", "Limited evidence of broad popular appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Technology and artificial-intelligence adviser.", "Has worked in internationally oriented technology policy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International professional orientation.", "Technocratic rather than overtly partisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little basis for constitutional assessment.", "Limited demonstrated domestic unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international stature.", "Broadly inclusive symbol of scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited visible leadership of public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Judicial decisions may attract partisan interpretations.", "Less broadly symbolic than a nonpolitical national figure." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective ordinal judgments from the frozen rubric, using only supplied profiles for controls and uncertain internal recall for real figures, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than missing scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 5975866939321621458, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "control-consensus-guardian", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gyorgy-szapary", "gabor-torok", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "gabor-ivanyi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:e5d330f40cc7a6451e04a9bf78dfad7274976fb578042ee4494093c60eac7378", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:20+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:38+02:00", "duration_s": 77.766, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21484, "output_tokens": 4079, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide direct evidence of unusually wide acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long leadership experience across governments strongly supports responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience supplies direct evidence of very strong international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments strongly indicate factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance unlikely despite fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal experience combined with partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility abroad, but fame does not ensure diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity may generate personal trust among admirers, but polarization and partisanship create substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile limits polarizing baggage but also offers little demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile provides little evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides direct support for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representative fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patrons and pressures remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is encouraging, but broader trust and integrity evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Humanitarian moral standing can bridge groups, but conflict with the governing camp limits universal acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained rights-oriented public stance supports a strong commitment to legal and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of religious and charitable institutions indicates solid organizational responsibility despite ongoing institutional pressures." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His moral voice could represent Hungary credibly, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic and religious identity appears stronger than party command, though he has identifiable political alignments." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long record of service to vulnerable people creates a very strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured analytical persona may be acceptable across camps, although political commentary inevitably attracts disagreement." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His analytical attention to political institutions is relevant, but observation is not a record of guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Analytical and academic work offers limited evidence of executive public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Political expertise would help, but I recall little direct diplomatic or international leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an analyst rather than a party politician supports a strong independence impression." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reputation for careful analysis supports credibility, with some exposure to partisan suspicion." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction offers inclusive symbolism, although his domestic public profile appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent academic standing is favorable, but constitutional commitments are not demonstrated by the career I recall." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant but does not fully establish capacity to lead a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent international academic career would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reputation rests on international neuroscience rather than party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scholarly reputation creates a strong presumption of credibility within the available representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility may reassure several groups, but economic-policy legacies can divide opinion." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior central-banking record suggests respect for formal institutions, with limited direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a central bank provides strong evidence of capacity for complex institutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Substantial international economic-policy experience supports a strong representative presence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A technocratic career across changing political conditions suggests autonomy despite inevitable political associations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature supports credibility, though public trust is likely uneven across factions." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional stature may command respect, though political associations could limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public-service background supports institutional seriousness but provides limited direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior economic-policy and diplomatic responsibilities indicate strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ambassadorial and international economic experience directly support very strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials are substantial, but senior government-linked diplomatic service weakens the independence impression." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A long professional career supports credibility, but I lack enough detail for a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented professional profile may appeal broadly, but demonstrated cross-group acceptance is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited representation offers no firm basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and organizational experience seems relevant, though large public-institution leadership is not established." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology and policy orientation suggests strong credibility in outward-facing settings." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy profile appears relatively nonpartisan, but relevant dependencies are unclear." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The professional reputation I faintly recall is positive, but too limited for a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally admired scientific accomplishment gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her nonpartisan scientific career is favorable, but it reveals little about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific excellence and industry experience help, but leadership of a complex public institution is distinct." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global recognition and international career would provide exceptional credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her standing appears rooted in scientific achievement rather than party or factional sponsorship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reputation for perseverance and consequential scholarship supports a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile offers cross-group acceptability but limited mass symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership directly supports a very strong guardianship assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court provides substantial evidence of responsible institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European judicial experience support a strong international representative role." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic service suggest professional autonomy, though senior appointments always carry political context." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal record conveys credibility and institutional seriousness within my recalled representation." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian Methodist pastor.", "He has led charitable and educational work serving disadvantaged people.", "He previously served as a member of parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long humanitarian service supports a strong integrity impression.", "His moral profile extends beyond conventional party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Open political conflicts may limit cross-camp acceptance.", "Diplomatic and constitutional leadership experience is limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist and political analyst.", "He is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics.", "He has taught political science." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured analytical style suggests independence and judgment.", "Public familiarity could aid accessibility across political groups." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive or diplomatic leadership record.", "Political analysis can still attract factional distrust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "His research is associated with neural oscillations and memory.", "He has worked at New York University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific distinction suggests independence and credibility.", "His career offers inclusive, achievement-based symbolism." ], "reservations": [ "Limited domestic public and political profile.", "Little demonstrated experience in constitutional or state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is a Hungarian economist and banker.", "He has held senior roles in international banking." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated leadership in complex economic institutions.", "Technocratic stature could support sober, credible representation." ], "reservations": [ "Economic-policy decisions can carry lasting partisan controversy.", "His constitutional and social-unifying credentials are less direct." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He held senior positions at the Hungarian National Bank." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and economic-policy experience.", "Demonstrated ability to operate in major institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Government appointments may constrain perceived independence.", "Technocratic stature may not translate into broad unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is associated with artificial-intelligence strategy and policy.", "He has worked internationally in technology advisory roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International and future-oriented professional perspective.", "Apparently limited dependence on domestic party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Low familiarity makes institutional judgments fragile.", "Little recalled evidence of constitutional or major public leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected achievement with little partisan baggage.", "Embodies perseverance, competence, and international openness." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific eminence does not automatically imply public executive skill." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and high-level institutional experience.", "Legal and diplomatic credentials complement each other unusually well." ], "reservations": [ "Elite institutional experience may offer limited popular connection.", "Appointment history may invite competing political interpretations." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles or my internal representation, separating recalled facts from subjective interpretation and treating uncertainty through confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 11281750577139540408, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "gyorgy-szapary", "gabor-ivanyi", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "gyorgy-suranyi", "katalin-kariko", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:f76ef52c218b1733a621b04328f07825b0ba61ae91a1c37d5b33a02c5980a341", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:33+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:08+02:00", "duration_s": 94.797, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21484, "output_tokens": 3951, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional and rule-of-law service exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would severely constrain cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Campaign partisanship and absent legal experience create substantial reservations about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates weak preparation for the role." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational presence despite no stated diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly suggests exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Celebrity standing may inspire some trust, but the profile provides little integrity evidence and substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but insufficient visibility makes broader acceptability uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no meaningful constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken likely international effectiveness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office and a career-service profile suggest substantial political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly reassuring, but broader trust and integrity evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His humanitarian standing is inclusive, but his prominent opposition role carries a meaningful polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public profile suggests sustained commitment to rights, conscience, and resistance to arbitrary power." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of religious and charitable organizations indicates substantial organizational responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He offers moral presence but limited recalled diplomatic or international executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral advocacy appears unusually independent, though longstanding political conflict may shape perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Visible service to disadvantaged people supports a strong impression of conviction and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured analytical style and cross-spectrum audience support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical engagement with democratic institutions suggests respect for process, though he lacks recalled judicial responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic and organizational experience is relevant but does not clearly establish large public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears articulate and informed, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an analyst rather than party officeholder supports perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His careful public persona conveys credibility, while media visibility invites divergent partisan readings." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and low partisan burden give him substantial symbolic unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly career suggests disciplined judgment but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major scientific work indicates responsibility, though national public administration would require different capabilities." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global scientific reputation would provide excellent international credibility and presence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career largely outside party politics strongly supports autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished research standing supports a very strong impression of professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional credibility and moderate presentation aid acceptability, though economic-policy legacies may divide opinion." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service record suggests institutional restraint, though constitutional law is outside his main expertise." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated leadership of a major national institution demonstrates exceptional executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International finance experience and senior public stature support strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A technocratic career spanning changing political environments supports substantial independence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established technocratic reputation supports credibility, subject to contested interpretations of past policy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His restrained technocratic profile may reduce polarization but offers limited evidence of broad social appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long institutional career supports procedural seriousness, though constitutional stewardship was not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-banking and diplomatic responsibilities indicate strong capacity to manage complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international economic and ambassadorial experience makes this an especially strong dimension." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials support autonomy, while senior state appointments leave some political-association concerns." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A lengthy professional record gives a favorable credibility impression with limited public-facing accountability evidence recalled." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented professional profile may attract broad interest, though public acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy profile supplies insufficient evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and organizational experience suggest competence without clear evidence of comparable public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology-policy work suggests strong fluency in representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An internationally oriented advisory career suggests some autonomy, but relevant affiliations are not confidently recalled." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing is mildly favorable, but my limited familiarity constrains a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International scientific achievement and limited partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated high-level scientific responsibility, though leading a complex state institution is a distinct task." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional global recognition and scientific prestige make her an unusually compelling international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and distance from party structures strongly support perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research record and public professional image convey exceptional credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile appears broadly acceptable without demonstrating exceptional popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background directly supports a strong expectation of legal-process commitment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in constitutional adjudication and subsequent public service demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and international legal experience provide strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic service support professional autonomy, although high appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal career conveys credibility and institutional seriousness with limited contrary information recalled." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Methodist pastor.", "He founded or leads organizations providing social services.", "He served as a member of Hungary's parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Longstanding humanitarian commitment", "Visible moral independence" ], "reservations": [ "Prominent political conflict may limit unifying reach", "Limited conventional diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist and analyst.", "He has taught political science.", "He is a frequent commentator on Hungarian politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured analytical public style", "Perceived distance from formal party office" ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive public-institution experience", "Public analysis can still acquire partisan interpretations" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "His research concerns neural oscillations and brain rhythms.", "He has held a professorship at New York University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional scholarly credibility", "Low partisan burden and strong global standing" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience", "Scientific leadership differs from state leadership" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served two periods as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is an economist.", "He held senior roles in international banking." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of complex institutions", "Substantial international credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Past economic policies may remain contested", "No primary constitutional-law background" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He worked as an economist at the International Monetary Fund." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive high-level institutional experience", "Strong diplomatic and international-economic credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law background", "Senior appointments may weaken perceived political distance" ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is associated with artificial-intelligence strategy and policy work.", "He has worked internationally, including in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally oriented expertise", "Forward-looking policy perspective" ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled public-institution experience", "Broader trust and unifying appeal are unclear" ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her research career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Scientific excellence does not automatically transfer to state leadership" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship experience", "Strong legal and diplomatic credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile", "High appointments can attract political-association concerns" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from the supplied synthetic profiles and my internal representation of the named figures, treating uncertainty as confidence rather than omitted scoring.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 11967862879658766076, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "gabor-ivanyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gabor-torok", "control-partisan-celebrity", "katalin-kariko", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d7c3f05a2cd2f723d801a5c6ba9bedc572991c75d6aacd11a921a1a051adbfbe", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:52+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:31+02:00", "duration_s": 99.609, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21692, "output_tokens": 4083, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability across political divides." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly demonstrates exceptional commitment to rule of law and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of judicial service and leadership across governments indicate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience supplies a strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly suggest autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very high credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Fame broadens recognition, but highly polarizing rhetoric sharply limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal foundation and adds polarizing partisan conduct that weakens confidence in restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational reach, though polarizing conduct would weaken diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity may generate personal trust among admirers, but polarization and partisanship undermine general credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader acceptability largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is relevant but does not establish commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong but not exceptional institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a comparatively weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile supplies too little information about integrity or public credibility to move beyond uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moral authority may bridge social groups, but prolonged political conflict makes universal acceptance unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy for vulnerable groups and resistance to state pressure suggest strong commitment to rights and checks." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading religious and charitable organizations indicates meaningful managerial experience outside central state institutions." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His moral presence could represent Hungary credibly, but I recall limited evidence of diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears independent of current governing power, although his opposition identity carries its own factional associations." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding charitable and pastoral work supports a strong subjective impression of personal integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured analytical style and relatively low partisan burden could make him acceptable across several groups." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical engagement with democratic institutions suggests respect for constitutional process, though he lacks a governing record." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic and organizational experience provides some foundation, but major public-institution leadership is not evident to me." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He could communicate Hungarian politics thoughtfully, although I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity as an analyst rather than party officeholder supports substantial factional independence." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained public credibility as a political analyst supports a favorable but not unqualified trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and limited partisan baggage could support broad symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing is encouraging, but I lack evidence about his constitutional or legal judgment." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major scientific work suggests organizational ability, though it differs from governing a public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His global scientific stature would give Hungary substantial international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established scientific career appears highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research reputation supports credibility, subject to limited knowledge of his public role." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional seriousness may attract cross-party respect, but economic-policy controversies limit unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His central-banking record suggests respect for institutional rules and professional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated leadership of a central bank demonstrates exceptional experience managing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international economic standing would support credible representation in foreign and European settings." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic identity and service under differing political conditions suggest meaningful autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long record in high-responsibility economic roles supports credibility despite predictable political criticism." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His establishment profile may reassure some groups but provides little basis for broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service background supports procedural competence but offers limited direct evidence about constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior central-banking and diplomatic roles indicate strong experience within complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ambassadorial and international economic experience strongly support representational competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials support some autonomy, while prominent government-linked diplomatic service raises reservations." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A substantial professional career supports baseline credibility, though my recall is insufficient for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented professional profile may have cross-group appeal, though broader public acceptance is untested." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficient knowledge of his views or record concerning constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Advisory and technology-governance experience suggests some leadership capacity without clear evidence at presidential scale." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international technology-policy profile suggests credible representation in global forums." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy career appears outside conventional party structures, but my familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing supports a modestly favorable impression, but I cannot assess public trust confidently." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and limited partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but gives little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has excelled in demanding scientific organizations, but that is not equivalent to leading a constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would make her a highly credible representative of Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing appear strongly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public recognition support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad respect without necessarily inspiring broad public identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background creates a very strong presumption of legal-process competence and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in major legal institutions indicates strong capacity to manage a complex constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European legal experience suggest credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests professional autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite political interpretation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long, serious public-law career supports credibility and a reputation for institutional professionalism." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian Methodist pastor.", "He founded and leads charitable and educational institutions.", "He has been a prominent critic of the Orbán government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long record of service to vulnerable people.", "Demonstrated willingness to resist political pressure." ], "reservations": [ "His opposition role is politically polarizing.", "Direct diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He is widely known as a political analyst.", "He has taught at Corvinus University of Budapest." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured and analytically minded public persona.", "Relatively independent of formal party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive public-institution experience.", "Diplomatic capacity is largely untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "His research focuses on neural oscillations and brain rhythms.", "He has held a professorship at New York University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scholarly credibility.", "Little apparent partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "No evident constitutional-office experience.", "Scientific leadership may not transfer fully to state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served twice as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He has held senior roles in international banking." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major public institution.", "Strong technocratic and international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Economic-policy decisions can remain politically divisive.", "He is associated with an established policy elite." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "He worked as an economist at the International Monetary Fund." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive economic-policy experience.", "Strong international and diplomatic background." ], "reservations": [ "Government-linked appointments complicate independence perceptions.", "Limited basis for judging broad unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian technology and artificial-intelligence policy expert.", "He has worked internationally in technology strategy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International and future-oriented professional perspective.", "Apparent distance from conventional party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Low familiarity makes most judgments tentative.", "Limited known experience in constitutional institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad, largely nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or political experience.", "Research excellence does not itself prove state-leadership ability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He has worked in European human-rights adjudication." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional-law experience.", "Substantial diplomatic and institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may attract partisan interpretations.", "His public profile may have limited popular resonance." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles and my internal recollection, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than as grounds to omit any score.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "gabor-ivanyi", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "gyorgy-suranyi", "gyorgy-szapary", "gyorgy-tilesch" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 9238176799828719656, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "gabor-torok", "gyorgy-szapary", "control-unknown-technocrat", "gyorgy-suranyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "gyorgy-buzsaki", "katalin-kariko", "gyorgy-tilesch", "gabor-ivanyi", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:81ae8d67ed113c01054179b2e9867d1dd947b6f145f18d2603f6ecdcbfe82265", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:25:59+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:27+02:00", "duration_s": 87.969, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21484, "output_tokens": 3834, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate exceptional acceptability and inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates high institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly support autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would substantially limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Campaign partisanship and absent legal experience suggest weak grounding in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports presence abroad despite limited diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame supplies visibility but the profile offers little basis for institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but broader unifying appeal is explicitly unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides a solid leadership basis." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports autonomy, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers some reassurance while evidence about trust and integrity remains insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His humanitarian profile is inclusive, but prolonged political conflict may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public defense of civic and religious autonomy suggests strong commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading religious and social-service organizations demonstrates meaningful institutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Moral presence is evident, but I recall limited diplomatic or international executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has shown independence from governing power, though his political history is not wholly nonpartisan." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding charitable and pastoral work supports a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An analytical rather than activist persona could attract acceptance across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical public role suggests respect for institutional rules, though not tested in constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Relevant intellectual competence is clearer than experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall limited evidence of substantial diplomatic or international representative experience." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears comparatively autonomous from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained reputation as a measured analyst supports credibility." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a low-partisan profile could support broad symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing is favorable, but I recall no direct constitutional-service record." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Research leadership is relevant but does not fully establish readiness for a national public institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would confer credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally based scientific career suggests substantial distance from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent academic reputation supports credibility and professional trust." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic authority could bridge some divisions, but economic-policy controversies may constrain appeal." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic record suggests institutional discipline, though it is not direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the central bank demonstrates responsibility for a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International financial standing would provide substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Central-banking stature supports autonomy despite unavoidable links to political appointments." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional standing supports credibility, with reservations arising from contested policy legacies." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His establishment profile may reassure some groups without generating broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long public service supports institutional seriousness, tempered by association with partisan government service." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior central-banking and diplomatic roles indicate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and international economic experience strongly fits external representation." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials coexist with visible alignment through senior government appointments." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A lengthy economic and diplomatic career supports credibility, though political association may divide trust." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A future-oriented professional profile may bridge groups, though public acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall insufficient direct evidence about his approach to constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Advisory and organizational work suggests useful strategic leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International technology-policy engagement supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His technology-policy profile appears relatively detached from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing is mildly favorable, but my basis for broader public trust is limited." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievements and nonpartisan public image offer unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her record suggests seriousness and perseverance but provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement does not by itself demonstrate leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global scientific recognition gives her exceptional international standing." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears strongly independent of Hungarian party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her professional accomplishments and public reputation support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained legal and diplomatic profile could be broadly acceptable without commanding universal enthusiasm." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career directly support strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ambassadorial experience and European legal engagement provide strong representative credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial service supports autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite questions about political context." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial and diplomatic record supports substantial institutional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian Methodist pastor.", "Has led church-affiliated social and charitable institutions.", "Previously served as a member of parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Long record of humanitarian service.", "Demonstrated willingness to resist political pressure." ], "reservations": [ "Conflict with governing forces may limit cross-group acceptance.", "Limited diplomatic experience recalled." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political analyst and political scientist.", "Known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured analytical public persona.", "Comparative distance from party office." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive leadership evidence.", "Limited diplomatic experience recalled." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-American neuroscientist.", "Known for research on brain rhythms.", "Has held senior academic positions in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High international scholarly standing.", "Low-partisan public profile." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional experience recalled.", "Public-sector executive readiness is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian economist.", "Served as governor of the National Bank of Hungary.", "Held senior roles in finance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "International economic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Economic-policy record may polarize assessments.", "No direct constitutional background recalled." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian economist and former central-bank official.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.", "Worked in international economic institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive institutional experience.", "Strong international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Visible association with a governing political camp.", "Limited unifying symbolism." ] }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born technology and artificial-intelligence adviser.", "Has worked internationally on AI policy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International and future-oriented perspective.", "Relative distance from domestic party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Low public familiarity.", "Constitutional and public-institution experience unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Scientific excellence is not equivalent to public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian jurist and constitutional-law scholar.", "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Later served as a diplomat." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional leadership experience.", "Strong legal and international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Appointment history may be interpreted politically.", "Broader popular appeal is uncertain." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles and my internal representations, treating uncertainty as confidence rather than as a reason to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 17022564516654330091, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "imre-voros", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "ivan-fischer", "peter-paczolay", "control-consensus-guardian", "janos-martonyi", "ignac-romsics", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:491b86fb3fcfee905ffcdd13d56fe55afe59e95000d4b9e972d5e947b590a818", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:00+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:03+02:00", "duration_s": 122.781, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21220, "output_tokens": 5357, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability with limited polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make this an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience makes this a very strong international representative." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates an extremely weak basis for cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps international presence, but polarizing rhetoric limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer visibility, but polarization and partisan campaigning substantially weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility limits both polarizing burden and demonstrated cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisan professional experience is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited public visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, although patrons and dependencies remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the profile gives insufficient evidence of public credibility or integrity." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected historian can embody shared national reflection, though historical interpretation can attract controversy." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly seriousness is favorable, but his career provides little direct constitutional-service evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic work indicates competence, but large public-institution leadership is not prominent in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scholarly standing would support credible representation, albeit without a major diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority appears grounded in scholarship rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding scholarly reputation supports a strong impression of credibility and intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally respected cultural achievement offers inclusive symbolism with limited direct partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her independent cultural standing is favorable, but she lacks a recalled constitutional or legal-service record." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is evident, but experience leading a complex public institution is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally acclaimed filmmaking gives her exceptional cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears rooted in independent artistic work rather than party hierarchy." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation creates a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her low-polarization expert profile is favorable, but broad symbolic reach is unproven." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her governance scholarship suggests respect for institutions, though direct constitutional stewardship is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience suggests capable institutional leadership, with limited recalled executive evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic credibility could represent Hungary competently, but diplomatic presence is not established in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic career outside prominent party command supports a strong impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly standing supports credibility, while wider public trust remains difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional stature may command respect, but constitutional controversies can carry partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law profile creates a very strong impression of commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic experience suggests a strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature would translate reasonably abroad, but his diplomatic profile is not prominent in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears substantially independent of party command, with some possible ideological identification." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished legal reputation supports credibility, though broad public trust is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Major cultural achievement is broadly inclusive, although outspoken civic positioning may divide some groups." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile is favorable, but it offers little direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and leading a major orchestra demonstrates exceptional sustained institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global musical stature and extensive international engagement make him an exceptional representative." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority derives primarily from music rather than party machinery, despite visible public positions." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long international career and institution-building support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Diplomatic professionalism helps, but strong identification with one political camp limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and diplomatic background is favorable, though long partisan-government association creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ministerial and diplomatic experience demonstrates very strong leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two periods as foreign minister and extensive diplomacy make him an exceptional international representative." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated senior service in Fidesz governments substantially weakens the impression of independence from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional reputation supports credibility, tempered by partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Globally recognized scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and inclusive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and independence, but offers no direct constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional scientific leadership does not itself establish experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature makes her an exceptional representative of Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than party or factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific accomplishment and perseverance create a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained jurist-diplomat profile has low polarizing burden but limited popular symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional judicial service strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court indicates substantial capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European judicial experience indicates very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles support autonomy, though high state appointments inevitably raise some dependency concerns." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished judicial and diplomatic record creates a strong impression of credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian historian.", "His scholarship focuses substantially on twentieth-century Hungarian history.", "He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scholarly credibility.", "Relatively independent public profile." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional-service record.", "Historical debates can become politically divisive." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "Her film On Body and Soul won the Berlin Golden Bear.", "She has received major international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural stature.", "Strong international presence." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional experience.", "Limited public-administration record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian political scientist.", "Her scholarship concerns local government and regional governance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Institutionally informed academic profile.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national public visibility.", "Diplomatic experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian jurist and constitutional-law scholar.", "He served as a Constitutional Court judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise.", "Substantial professional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile.", "Some positions may carry partisan interpretations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "He has led major orchestras internationally." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional institution-building record.", "Outstanding global cultural credibility." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional role.", "Public civic positions may reduce universal acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He is a lawyer and diplomat.", "He served in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic experience.", "Proven high-level institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Strong party-government association.", "Limited cross-camp neutrality." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional experience.", "Limited public-institution executive record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional experience.", "Strong judicial-diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular symbolic reach.", "Senior appointments invite independence scrutiny." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are direct anchored ordinal impressions based only on supplied control profiles and internally recalled public information, with uncertainty represented through confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 7910414721263124418, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "janos-martonyi", "ildiko-enyedi", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "control-unknown-technocrat", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:eb5b40cd4b794d4e08d7e0c8d0cbaba4d391f7b1e59ad8db6e1b84ae6482b0dc", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:29+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:12+02:00", "duration_s": 102.844, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21468, "output_tokens": 3963, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly indicates exceptional commitment to constitutional restraint and rule-of-law institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of service and leadership across governments imply strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong representational foundation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly suggest autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability despite celebrity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with polarizing partisan conduct and offers little basis for constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports presence abroad, while polarizing rhetoric creates a meaningful representational liability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame supplies visibility but partisan polarization and absent integrity evidence limit broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but broader acceptability and symbolic reach are unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile gives insufficient constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid leadership with limited evidence of exceptional scope." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility makes this a weak representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though low visibility leaves patron relationships uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is supplied, yet the profile expressly lacks sufficient trust evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly authority and measured presentation could bridge groups, though historical interpretation can itself divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly engagement with Hungarian state history suggests institutional seriousness without direct guardianship experience." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic seniority suggests competence but offers limited evidence of executive-scale public leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly standing could represent Hungary credibly, although he lacks a prominent diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic profile appears substantially independent of direct party organization." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long scholarly career supports credibility, seriousness, and intellectual accountability." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction and a relatively nonpartisan image could attract broad respect despite limited mass reach." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-cultural profile appears compatible with liberal institutional norms but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is evident, but experience directing a complex state institution is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized cultural career would support credible and distinctive representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears institutionally and professionally independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her accomplished professional reputation creates a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A technocratic scholarly profile may be acceptable across groups but has limited symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarship on governance and decentralization suggests a strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research and academic responsibilities suggest solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her expertise would convey substance abroad, but prominent diplomatic experience is not familiar to me." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic career appears substantially independent of party command and electoral incentives." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her established academic standing supports a strong impression of professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Constitutional authority may command respect, but public interventions can carry ideological polarization." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law and former judicial profile strongly indicates commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and academic experience suggests strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature would provide seriousness abroad, but his diplomatic profile appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His juristic identity appears substantially autonomous from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal standing supports credibility, with some uncertainty about cross-camp perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige offers broad symbolic appeal, though outspoken public positions may alienate some groups." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile appears favorable to pluralist norms but lacks direct constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and directing a major orchestra demonstrates durable leadership of a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His global conducting career gives him exceptional cultural presence and international recognition." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally grounded artistic career supports substantial independence from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic leadership and international reputation create strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A polished conservative statesman could command respect beyond his camp but carries a clear partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental background suggests respect for formal process, tempered by substantial partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated cabinet-level responsibility demonstrates strong capacity to manage complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive foreign-ministerial and diplomatic experience makes international representation a defining strength." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long senior association with Fidesz substantially limits the impression of political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects seriousness and professional credibility, though party identification constrains broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her reputation suggests seriousness and independence, but her career supplies little direct evidence on constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at elite scientific institutions, but large public-institution leadership is not a demonstrated core strength." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would confer extraordinary international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing appear exceptionally independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific accomplishments and persevering public image support very high credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could be broadly acceptable but lacks obvious popular unifying force." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience strongly supports institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic exposure supports authoritative representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, although prior proximity to executive institutions creates some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian historian.", "Known for scholarship on twentieth-century Hungarian history.", "Has held senior academic positions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured scholarly authority.", "Substantial independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive and diplomatic experience.", "Historical interpretations may not unite every constituency." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "Directed On Body and Soul.", "Received major international film recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural stature.", "Strong international representational potential." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of executive public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist.", "Known for research on regional governance and decentralization.", "Has held senior academic and research roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong institutional and governance expertise.", "Academically grounded independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national public visibility.", "Little familiar evidence of diplomatic leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian legal scholar.", "Former judge of the Constitutional Court.", "Has written and spoken on constitutional issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law credentials.", "Substantial juristic independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public profile.", "Some public positions may be viewed through partisan conflict." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian conductor and composer.", "Co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "Has conducted major orchestras internationally." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a prominent cultural institution.", "Exceptional international cultural standing." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Outspoken positions may reduce cross-camp acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "Held senior roles in Fidesz-led governments.", "Has a legal and diplomatic background." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive statecraft and diplomatic experience.", "Professional and internationally credible public manner." ], "reservations": [ "Strong identification with one political camp.", "Limited symbolic distance from recent governing power." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional achievement with broad public appeal.", "Globally credible and politically independent profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited demonstrated leadership of a large public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Credible European institutional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular symbolic reach.", "Past executive proximity may raise independence questions." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the supplied ordinal anchors directly, separated recalled facts from evaluative interpretation, used only internal representation for real figures, and treated uncertainty through confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 5319273478083297962, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "janos-martonyi", "ivan-fischer", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "imre-voros", "ignac-romsics", "control-unknown-technocrat", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "ildiko-enyedi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:b2dcb502f3cbe50e947fbd94f904ecc368f9274540e0cc7b04dbd0131368122a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:36+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:06+02:00", "duration_s": 89.687, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21676, "output_tokens": 3877, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually high acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly demonstrates exceptional commitment to constitutional restraint and rule-of-law institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of legal service and leadership across governments indicate very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience supports highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate strong autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record provide an exceptional integrity profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability extremely unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no constitutional grounding and combines inexperience with polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience creates a severe fit deficit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition is a major asset, though polarizing rhetoric would impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates pronounced dependence on party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame provides visibility but the profile offers little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility leaves unifying appeal fundamentally uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile offers neither evidence of disregard nor affirmative constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong, though not exceptional, institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is noted, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly prestige could support cross-group respect, though historical interpretation can itself be contested." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests respect for constitutional development but provides no direct guardianship record." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic achievement suggests competence but gives limited evidence of large public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scholarly recognition would support credible representation, albeit without a diplomatic track record." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority appears rooted primarily in scholarship rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished academic reputation creates a strong impression of seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her cultural stature and relatively nonpartisan image offer strong potential for symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her independent cultural profile is compatible with pluralism but offers little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is evident, but experience managing a complex public institution is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized filmmaking career would provide substantial cultural and diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her standing appears grounded in an autonomous artistic career rather than party structures." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained artistic reputation supports an impression of seriousness, authenticity, and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-polarization expert profile may be broadly acceptable but lacks strong national symbolic recognition." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-governance expertise suggests institutional seriousness, though direct constitutional stewardship is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her academic and governance-related roles suggest capable institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional expertise could translate well abroad, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her profile appears primarily academic and professional rather than party-directed." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly and institutional standing supports credibility, subject to limited familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature may command respect, but his broader cross-group appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law and former judicial profile strongly supports commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "High-level legal experience indicates strength, though the extent of executive leadership is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal stature offers credibility but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional background suggests independence, though limited recall makes factional autonomy harder to assess." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His judicial and scholarly standing supports trust, subject to limited familiarity with his wider record." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige offers broad appeal, though outspoken public positions may alienate some groups." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile is compatible with constitutional values but lacks direct legal or constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and directing a major orchestra demonstrates substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international conducting career provides strong diplomatic presence and recognition." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His standing derives chiefly from an independent cultural career rather than party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic leadership and international reputation support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic stature is balanced by a clear association with one political camp." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental background supports institutional competence, tempered by longstanding partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior ministerial and diplomatic service demonstrates very strong capacity for institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive foreign-policy experience makes international representation a major strength." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent service in Fidesz governments creates substantial doubts about autonomy from party interests." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional credibility, though partisan identification limits universal trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and broad recognition give her substantial cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile suggests seriousness and independence but offers little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Exceptional scientific accomplishment does not itself establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would confer immediate international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career identity appears strongly grounded in science rather than party or factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific standing create a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile appears broadly acceptable but lacks strong popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background provides unusually strong direct grounding in legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a high constitutional institution indicates very strong administrative and deliberative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic experience and legal standing support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful autonomy, although senior state appointments warrant some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial stature and professional reserve support a strong impression of credibility and integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian historian.", "His scholarship focuses substantially on modern Hungarian history.", "He has held senior academic standing." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High scholarly credibility.", "Relatively independent public identity." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional office recalled.", "Limited public-institution executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian film director.", "Her film On Body and Soul won the Golden Bear.", "Her work has received substantial international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad cultural prestige.", "Strong international representational potential." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of complex public-sector management." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian political scientist.", "Her work includes local governance and regional studies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Relevant public-governance expertise.", "Apparently low-partisanship professional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Low public visibility.", "Little recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar.", "He served as a Constitutional Court judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional-law credentials.", "Judicial experience supports institutional seriousness." ], "reservations": [ "Limited familiarity with his broader record.", "Unclear diplomatic and executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "He has led major international musical performances." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven cultural-institution leadership.", "Strong international recognition." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional role.", "Outspoken positions may reduce universal appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He is a lawyer and diplomat.", "He held ministerial office in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic competence.", "Substantial senior-government experience." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with one political camp.", "Limited cross-partisan symbolic neutrality." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her research career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific stature.", "Strongly nonpartisan public identity." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of public-sector executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He is a legal scholar.", "He later served in a diplomatic role." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Strong judicial and institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Senior state appointments may invite independence questions." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to subjective impressions, with confidence reflecting familiarity and without treating the judgments as objective fitness assessments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 17029406646785923499, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "janos-martonyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ivan-fischer", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "imre-voros" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:57d9f0cb4e80f7f00daf69f0b0babddf13fc9caacfa28833351966f4f3126af8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:38+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:11+02:00", "duration_s": 92.984, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21468, "output_tokens": 3796, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong consensus acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of constitutional and rule-of-law service exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments indicates highly developed institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate strong factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric substantially undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and polarizing partisan activism indicate weak fit for constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports diplomatic presence despite limited governmental experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly links the figure to factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity standing may confer visibility but supplies little basis for institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unresolved." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competent public service is relevant, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong institutional leadership with some scope uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but information about integrity and broader trust is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic stature and measured public presence support broad acceptability with limited mass appeal." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly seriousness and historical perspective suggest respect for constitutional institutions." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic experience indicates competence but limited evidence of high-level public executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scholarly recognition would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principal identity as a historian appears meaningfully independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established scholarly reputation supports strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction and modest partisan burden support broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public cultural profile suggests civic seriousness but provides little constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is relevant but does not fully establish public-institution executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally acclaimed filmmaking provides very strong cultural representational standing." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her artistic career appears substantially autonomous from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her respected professional reputation supports strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-polarization scholarly profile could be acceptable broadly but lacks strong symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly association with governance and decentralization suggests respect for institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and research roles indicate relevant organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic standing offers some international credibility without a prominent diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic profile appears substantially independent of direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation suggests credibility, though my familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Constitutional stature helps, but public interventions may reduce cross-camp acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law and former judicial profile strongly supports institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and academic experience indicates strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature offers credibility abroad, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal-academic standing suggests substantial independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal reputation supports strong credibility, subject to limited familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Major cultural stature supports inclusion, though outspoken politics may limit some cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic profile suggests democratic commitment but lacks direct constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and leading a major orchestra demonstrates substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional international musical standing makes him a highly credible representative abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career is institutionally independent despite visible positions on public affairs." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished artistic career and sustained institution-building support strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature is offset by identification with a polarizing governing camp." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Legal and governmental experience support procedural competence, tempered by long partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior ministerial experience demonstrates substantial capacity to lead complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive foreign-policy experience gives him very strong international representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated service in Fidesz governments weighs against autonomy from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects experienced professionalism but carries the trust burden of partisan government service." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her exceptional cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific accomplishment is clear, but leadership of a complex public institution is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably independent of Hungarian party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific career supports exceptional credibility and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained legal-diplomatic profile offers broad acceptability without exceptional popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career closely match institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions demonstrates very strong public-institution capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and European legal experience provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles support autonomy, though elite state appointments warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial and diplomatic service supports strong professional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian historian specializing in modern Hungarian history.", "He has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Measured scholarly credibility.", "Relatively low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive-government experience.", "Modest mass-public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "Her film On Body and Soul won the Golden Bear.", "She has received international recognition for her filmmaking." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High cultural prestige.", "Strong international representational potential." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct legal or governmental experience.", "Unproven leadership of complex public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist associated with research on regional governance.", "Her scholarship has addressed decentralization and local government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Institutionally knowledgeable and academically credible.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national symbolic profile.", "Little recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian jurist and former Constitutional Court judge.", "Known as a scholar of constitutional and economic law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law credentials.", "Substantial legal independence and expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad symbolic visibility.", "Some public legal positions may be politically contentious." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian conductor and co-founder of the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "He has led major orchestras internationally.", "He has spoken publicly on Hungarian civic affairs." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural standing.", "Proven institution-builder." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional experience.", "Public political positions may limit universal acceptability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's foreign minister in two Fidesz governments.", "He has a legal and diplomatic background." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep foreign-policy expertise.", "Demonstrated senior institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with one political camp.", "Limited ability to symbolize political neutrality." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or governmental experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is less clear than scientific achievement." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship experience.", "Strong legal and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "State appointments may prompt questions about complete political distance." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real figures and only the supplied descriptions of synthetic controls, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 13473368705032591100, "entity_order": [ "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "ildiko-enyedi", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity", "janos-martonyi", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "ignac-romsics", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:bc78d485eed93d2a0435ae8a37944fba8d683ecd9e90bda1ebb2fdd282598908", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:46+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:18+02:00", "duration_s": 92.266, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21468, "output_tokens": 3883, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability across political and social boundaries." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate exceptional autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance very unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile offers no legal grounding and combines partisan activity with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition provides representational reach despite serious diplomatic-temperament reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates pronounced dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity alone does not establish integrity, while partisan polarization creates substantial credibility reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but insufficient visibility makes wider acceptability uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong, though not exceptional, leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers modest reassurance, but broader trust and integrity information is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly authority may bridge groups, though historical interpretations can themselves become contested." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly engagement with Hungarian statehood supports institutional seriousness without direct legal experience." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant but offers limited evidence of leading a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scholarly standing would support credible intellectual representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principal identity as a historian appears relatively independent of party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long academic career conveys credibility and serious-minded public engagement." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally respected cultural identity could be inclusive without carrying a heavy partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile suggests democratic-cultural seriousness but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has substantial creative and educational experience but limited visible leadership of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally acclaimed filmmaking gives her strong recognition and cultural representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her artistic and academic standing appears largely autonomous from party organization." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation creates a strong impression of seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-polarization scholarly profile could be broadly acceptable, but national public recognition is limited." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-administration scholarship suggests institutional seriousness, though direct constitutional evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research and academic responsibilities indicate meaningful institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly credentials offer professional credibility but limited diplomatic prominence." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic career appears substantially autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her academic standing supports credibility and I recall no notable integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal stature could reassure institutionalists, but his public profile may carry partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law background strongly supports an expectation of principled institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service in senior constitutional and judicial roles indicates strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has substantial professional stature but limited internationally representative visibility in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears substantially independent of party command despite identifiable positions in constitutional controversies." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal career conveys credibility and no major integrity concern comes readily to mind." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige offers broad symbolic appeal, although his political criticism may limit cross-camp acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic engagement suggests democratic commitment, though he lacks a constitutional or legal record." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and directing major orchestral institutions demonstrates sustained organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive international conducting career gives him exceptional cultural-diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career is institutionally independent of party structures despite outspoken political interventions." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished artistic career and civic profile support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured diplomatic profile may attract respect beyond his camp, though party identification limits consensus." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and diplomatic career suggests respect for formal process, tempered by long governing-party association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated service as foreign minister demonstrates extensive leadership of a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior diplomatic experience and international expertise exceptionally match this function." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Professional stature supports some autonomy, but his senior Fidesz-government roles materially constrain independence." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional credibility and I recall no defining personal integrity scandal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and national symbolic stature create unusually broad cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her profile suggests seriousness and independence but supplies little direct evidence about constitutional governance." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates exceptional professional responsibility, though large public-institution leadership is not her core record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature would provide exceptional international credibility and recognition." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing appear exceptionally independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research career and public reputation produce an exceptional impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could command cross-group respect, though public familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career strongly support commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates strong capacity for responsible institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European judicial experience provide very strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic trajectory appears substantially more professional than factionally directed." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility and no major integrity concern comes readily to mind." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian historian.", "He specializes in modern Hungarian history.", "He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Serious scholarly authority.", "Relatively independent public profile." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional or executive record.", "Historical debates may limit universal appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian film director.", "She directed On Body and Soul.", "Her films have received major international awards." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected cultural stature.", "Relatively low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct governance experience.", "Constitutional commitments are not well evidenced." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian political scientist.", "Her scholarship concerns governance and regional administration.", "She has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial public-institution expertise.", "Low apparent partisan dependence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national public visibility.", "Little recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional lawyer.", "He served as a Constitutional Court judge.", "He has held senior judicial office." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong institutional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Public positions may be read through partisan conflict.", "Limited diplomatic visibility in my recollection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "He has led major orchestras internationally." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven cultural-institution leadership.", "Exceptional international presence." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional experience.", "Outspoken politics may narrow cross-camp appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian lawyer and diplomat.", "He served twice as foreign minister.", "He held office in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic experience.", "Strong state-institution leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Long governing-party association limits independence.", "Cross-group acceptability may be constrained." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Unusually broad symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional-governance experience.", "Limited record leading complex public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial expertise.", "Strong European diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility.", "Cross-group appeal is not fully established." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are direct anchored ordinal judgments based only on internal recall for real figures and the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted ratings.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 8983939639668049651, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "ignac-romsics", "imre-voros", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "ildiko-enyedi", "peter-paczolay", "janos-martonyi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "ivan-fischer" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:b3313856baa63582067a58576a0710ad5593d065cc88f1772068d93dbb864866", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:26:58+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:12+02:00", "duration_s": 134.734, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 5408, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly indicates exceptional commitment to constitutional checks and the rule of law." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments indicate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly suggest autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very high credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly inconsistent with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal experience and indicates recent partisan alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition would aid visibility abroad, though polarizing conduct limits representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer visibility, but polarization and partisanship weaken broad-based credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability un demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public service is mildly encouraging, but the profile supplies no constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates a strong, if not exceptional, leadership foundation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is given, but the profile is insufficient to support strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly stature could command broad respect, although historical interpretation can attract ideological dispute." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly reputation suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional stewardship is not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant but offers limited evidence of leading a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scholarly standing would support credible representation, though not necessarily diplomatic effectiveness." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic identity appears comparatively independent of direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished academic career supports credibility and seriousness in public life." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally respected artistic achievement could provide inclusive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her cultural stature suggests reflective judgment but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is relevant, but evidence of complex public-institution management is limited." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international film career would support sophisticated cultural representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her artistic career appears substantially autonomous from formal party structures." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her serious, accomplished, and comparatively nonpartisan public profile supports credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-partisan scholarly identity could be broadly acceptable, though public visibility appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her governance scholarship suggests institutional understanding, though I recall limited constitutional-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic and research experience suggests competence but does not fully demonstrate executive public leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly credentials offer some international credibility, but I recall little diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic profile appears meaningfully independent of direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her established academic standing supports credibility, with limited information about mass public trust." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal authority is an asset, but his public profile may not produce broad symbolic consensus." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law and judicial background strongly supports guardianship of legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level legal experience suggests solid capacity to operate responsibly within public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal stature is relevant, but I recall little evidence of a sustained diplomatic role." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A juristic career supports autonomy, though public interventions may be perceived through partisan lenses." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial credentials support credibility, tempered by limited confidence about wider public trust." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction gives him broad appeal, although outspoken public positions may limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile suggests democratic concern but provides little direct evidence of constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and leading a major orchestra demonstrates substantial organizational and cultural leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His globally prominent musical career provides exceptional international presence and representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His primary identity as an internationally established conductor supports substantial autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic leadership and international reputation support strong personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature may command respect, but strong identification with one political camp constrains unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience supports procedural competence, tempered by a substantial partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated cabinet leadership demonstrates extensive experience managing major public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive foreign-ministerial and European experience makes international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Longstanding service in Fidesz-led governments limits the appearance of independence from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reputation for professionalism supports credibility despite the polarizing burden of partisan government service." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record suggests responsibility and rigor but provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in complex scientific institutions but lacks an evident public-governance record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific prominence would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and public identity appear highly independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and low-partisan profile support exceptional public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract cross-group respect without guaranteeing popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-court experience directly supports strong guardianship of legal institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court provides highly relevant experience for complex public responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European institutional experience strongly supports international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic service indicate professional autonomy, though appointments create some perceived political linkage." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long senior legal and diplomatic career supports credibility and institutional seriousness." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a prominent Hungarian historian.", "His scholarship includes twentieth-century Hungarian history.", "He has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has substantial intellectual credibility.", "His profile appears relatively nonpartisan." ], "reservations": [ "Historical interpretation can provoke ideological disagreement.", "His executive and diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "She directed On Body and Soul.", "Her films have received major international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She offers distinguished cultural representation.", "Her public identity appears comparatively independent." ], "reservations": [ "She has little evident constitutional experience.", "Her public-institution leadership record is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian political scientist.", "Her research includes local and regional governance.", "She has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She brings relevant governance expertise.", "Her academic profile appears politically independent." ], "reservations": [ "Her public visibility is limited.", "I recall little direct diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian jurist.", "He served as a Constitutional Court judge.", "He has worked in constitutional law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He brings directly relevant constitutional expertise.", "His judicial background supports institutional seriousness." ], "reservations": [ "His broader unifying appeal is uncertain.", "I recall limited diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "He has led major international orchestras." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has exceptional international cultural stature.", "He has demonstrated durable organizational leadership." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks direct constitutional or legal experience.", "His outspoken positions may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He is a lawyer and diplomat.", "He served in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has exceptional diplomatic experience.", "He has extensive senior institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "His longstanding partisan association limits perceived independence.", "That association also constrains cross-group acceptability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was foundational to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has exceptional international credibility.", "Her achievement offers broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks an evident constitutional-law background.", "Scientific accomplishment does not itself establish public-governance skill." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He has worked as a diplomat.", "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His experience closely matches constitutional guardianship.", "He combines institutional leadership with international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His public profile may have limited popular resonance.", "Appointments may create perceptions of political linkage." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from the supplied synthetic profiles and my internal representations of the real figures, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 17789345936482506900, "entity_order": [ "imre-voros", "ildiko-enyedi", "peter-paczolay", "ivan-fischer", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-unknown-technocrat", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "ignac-romsics", "janos-martonyi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:2665f84f96efc1a004449dd90916905ff09074d1a7af15b8718a8286d3ff425a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:08+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:23+02:00", "duration_s": 74.406, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 3877, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability with little stated polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging exceptionally fit the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership across governments provides strong direct evidence of responsible institutional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience indicates very strong capacity to represent Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate exceptional autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric indicates very weak cross-group acceptability despite celebrity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal experience and adds recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global fame provides substantial international presence despite serious weaknesses elsewhere." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer visibility, but the profile supplies little basis for accountability or broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader unifying appeal is explicitly unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is stated, but there is insufficient evidence of constitutional judgment or rule-of-law commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management supports a strong, though not exceptional, leadership assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited public visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though low visibility leaves external dependencies uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nothing signals misconduct, but the profile provides insufficient evidence of broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected historian could provide continuity and perspective, though historical interpretation can divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His historical expertise suggests respect for institutional continuity, though it is not legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scholarly experience indicates leadership ability but not necessarily executive public administration." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International academic standing would support credible representation, though diplomatic experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly career suggests considerable intellectual autonomy from direct party control." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained academic reputation supports credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural achievement and a comparatively nonpartisan profile could attract support across groups." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile suggests democratic seriousness, but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is relevant but does not establish experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized cultural career would give Hungary a credible and distinctive representative." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career suggests meaningful autonomy from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished professional reputation supports credibility, though public-service accountability is untested." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A technocratic and nonpolarizing profile may help, but broad symbolic reach is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her governance scholarship suggests institutional seriousness, though direct constitutional stewardship is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and research roles suggest sound institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic credibility could serve representation, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic profile suggests substantial distance from party command and short-term factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarly standing supports credibility, with limited information about nationwide public trust." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal stature could reassure institutionalists but may not translate into broad cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law background strongly supports an expectation of principled institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial experience indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His stature would provide seriousness abroad, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears substantially autonomous, though public interventions may be perceived through partisan conflict." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional standing suggests credibility, subject to limited knowledge of wider public trust." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Major cultural prestige could unify many citizens, while political visibility may limit universal acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile appears compatible with democratic norms, but constitutional stewardship is not his demonstrated field." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and directing a major orchestra demonstrates sustained leadership of a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional international cultural standing would make him a highly credible representative abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His independent artistic stature is substantial, although outspoken public positions may create factional perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional record supports credibility, though that differs from tested public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional demeanor may reassure moderates, but strong partisan identification limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience supports institutional competence, tempered by close party association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated cabinet-level responsibility demonstrates strong capacity to lead complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive foreign-minister experience makes international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Longstanding senior service in Fidesz governments creates substantial doubt about autonomy from party interests." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional reputation supports credibility, though partisan proximity may reduce trust among opponents." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and limited partisan burden give her broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility, but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led demanding scientific work, though that differs from directing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific recognition would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing indicate strong autonomy from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record of rigorous scientific accomplishment supports very strong credibility and trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could lower polarization, though broad popular appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and human-rights judicial experience strongly fits this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in major legal institutions indicates strong administrative judgment and responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience directly supports international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests professional autonomy despite appointments within political systems." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior legal service supports credibility, with limited evidence about mass public confidence." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian historian.", "Known for scholarship on twentieth-century Hungarian history.", "Has held university teaching positions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong historical perspective.", "Respected scholarly profile." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional office recalled.", "Historical debates may constrain unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "Directed On Body and Soul.", "Has received major international film recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural stature.", "Strong international visibility." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct legal experience.", "Public-institution leadership is not well established." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist.", "Known for research on regional governance and decentralization.", "Has held senior academic research roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Governance expertise.", "Nonpartisan scholarly profile." ], "reservations": [ "Low national public visibility.", "Limited recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former judge of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Legal scholar specializing in public and constitutional law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong institutional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile.", "Public interventions may attract partisan interpretation." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian conductor and composer.", "Co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "Has conducted internationally." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven cultural institution builder.", "Exceptional international presence." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional role.", "Political visibility may divide some audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.", "Is trained as a lawyer.", "Held office in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Proven cabinet-level leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Strong partisan association.", "Cross-group acceptability is limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional scientific credibility.", "Broad international recognition." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Limited public-administration background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional legal-institutional experience.", "Substantial diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public profile.", "Elite institutional experience may not ensure popular connection." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real candidates and only the supplied profiles for synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 16225598351933376457, "entity_order": [ "ildiko-enyedi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "ignac-romsics", "control-consensus-guardian", "janos-martonyi", "ivan-fischer", "katalin-kariko", "imre-voros", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:e8e8ea8814cce4d0fd7dddbb07719b6d5781879a049da106c59fd2d022915e08", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:27+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:06+02:00", "duration_s": 99.797, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21228, "output_tokens": 3904, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan identity indicate unusually strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a substantial burden on cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and its polarizing partisanship raises restraint concerns." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of institutional leadership experience leaves a major capability gap." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is valuable abroad, though polarizing conduct limits representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may create loyalty, but polarizing rhetoric undermines broadly shared credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility makes broader acceptability uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration offers limited reassurance but no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid capacity to lead a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken the case for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, while the profile supplies too little information about integrity or trust." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly authority could command broad respect, although historical interpretation can itself become contested." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly engagement with Hungarian state history suggests institutional seriousness, though not direct constitutional service." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic seniority is relevant but does not clearly demonstrate executive leadership at presidential scale." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual stature and international academic exposure would support credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic rather than party-political career supports substantial autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established reputation as a serious historian supports credibility and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction and a relatively nonpartisan identity could attract support across several groups." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public intellectual profile suggests respect for pluralism, but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is relevant, though experience directing a complex public institution is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent international cultural standing would translate well into representative duties." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears substantially independent of party organization and factional command." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally respected artistic career supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A technocratic scholarly profile may be broadly acceptable, though limited visibility constrains symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scholarship on governance and decentralization suggests respect for institutional structure and checks." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research and academic responsibilities suggest capable institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International scholarly engagement is relevant, but diplomatic presence is not clearly established." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic career appears substantially separate from party command and electoral incentives." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic distinction supports credibility, but broader public trust is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal authority could reassure institutionalists, but his broader cross-group appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court experience and legal scholarship strongly support commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level judicial experience indicates sound institutional judgment, with less evidence of executive management." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature is useful abroad, but his diplomatic experience and international public presence are unclear." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and scholarly profile suggests meaningful autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A senior legal career supports credibility, though public familiarity may be limited." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige offers inclusive symbolism, though public political expression may alienate some constituencies." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile suggests pluralist instincts, but offers little direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Building and directing a major orchestra demonstrates sustained organizational and artistic leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive global cultural presence would make him a highly credible international representative." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally established artistic career appears largely autonomous from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished professional reputation supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Diplomatic stature could reassure some groups, but his partisan association limits broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental background supports institutional competence, tempered by long party-government association." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated senior governmental responsibility demonstrates extensive experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His foreign-ministerial and diplomatic experience strongly fits international representative duties." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior service in Fidesz-led governments creates substantial doubt about autonomy from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional standing supports credibility, while political identification constrains cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national recognition give her unusually broad, low-partisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests discipline and responsibility but supplies little constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but leadership of a complex public institution is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would provide outstanding international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing appear strongly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research reputation and publicly recognized perseverance support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Institutional stature and a restrained public profile could support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court directly supports a very strong guardianship assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience heading a high court demonstrates substantial leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European institutional experience strongly support international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial professional autonomy despite state appointments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and European diplomatic service support a strong impression of credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian historian specializing in modern Hungarian history.", "Has held senior academic positions.", "Has written widely used historical syntheses." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Serious scholarly and institutional reputation.", "Substantial distance from party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive-government experience.", "Historical controversies could constrain universal appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "Directed On Body and Soul.", "Has received major international film recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected cultural standing.", "Relatively independent of party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or legal experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist.", "Known for research on local government and regional governance.", "Has held senior academic research roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep governance expertise.", "Academic profile suggests political independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national public visibility.", "Little direct diplomatic or constitutional-office experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian legal scholar.", "Served as a Constitutional Court judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Judicial profile suggests institutional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Diplomatic and executive experience are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian conductor and composer.", "Co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "Has conducted major international orchestras." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural credibility.", "Proven leadership of a major artistic institution." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional experience.", "Public positions may polarize some groups." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.", "Is a lawyer and diplomat.", "Held office in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Demonstrated senior institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with one political camp.", "Cross-group trust may therefore be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Rarely matched international prestige.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific achievement does not ensure public-sector leadership skill." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional and institutional credentials.", "Substantial European diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Broad popular appeal is less established.", "Career state appointments complicate complete independence assessment." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are fresh anchored ordinal judgments based only on internal recall for real figures and exclusively on the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 12730966071738867172, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "ivan-fischer", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "janos-martonyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "imre-voros", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:213558259a7d9062dce1c584cf608a3e359bfa8a336ec38579cea23870fac9b3", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:31+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:27+02:00", "duration_s": 115.938, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 3920, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability across political and social boundaries." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates mature stewardship of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability despite celebrity reach." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal or institutional experience and recent party campaigning create substantial reservations about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly supplies no legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is a meaningful representational asset, though partisan rhetoric would impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but polarization and absent institutional accountability provide a weak trust foundation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile may limit polarization but provides little basis for broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly encouraging, but the profile supplies no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid capacity to lead a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation an uncertain fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests autonomy, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the profile gives insufficient evidence about integrity or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An authoritative historian could supply shared national perspective, though historical interpretation remains politically contestable." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly seriousness and historical perspective suggest respect for legal continuity, despite limited direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic distinction suggests competence but does not clearly establish executive leadership at presidential scale." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly stature and knowledge of Hungary would support substantive representation, with less evidence of diplomatic practice." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic identity appears substantially more independent than a conventional partisan career." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scholarly record supports credibility and intellectual accountability." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally respected cultural achievement offers inclusive symbolism, though her domestic reach may be uneven." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her independent cultural standing is compatible with restraint, but offers little direct evidence on constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative leadership is relevant, but I have limited evidence of managing a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally acclaimed career would give Hungary a credible and culturally distinctive representative." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional authority comes from filmmaking rather than party machinery or governmental patronage." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her accomplished and serious public profile supports a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-polarization expert profile may be acceptable across groups but lacks obvious mass symbolic resonance." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-governance scholarship suggests institutional seriousness, though I recall little direct constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and research roles suggest sound institutional leadership, though the presidential scale remains uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic expertise offers substance, but I recall limited evidence of major international representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic research career provides a relatively autonomous base outside party hierarchy." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly standing supports a favorable impression of competence and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Constitutional authority is an asset, but his visible positions may carry a meaningful polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-judicial background strongly supports commitment to legal checks and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial experience indicates institutional competence, with less evidence of broad executive management." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature could support substantive representation, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His juristic profile appears substantially independent of ordinary party command, despite public political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished legal career supports credibility, though trust would likely vary across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural stature and international recognition could bridge groups, although public interventions may divide some audiences." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent civic profile seems compatible with restraint, but I recall little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major musical institutions demonstrates substantial organizational and public-facing leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international cultural career would translate naturally into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career grounded outside party structures supports a strong impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic credibility creates a favorable impression of seriousness and public integrity." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional moderation may reassure some groups, but his partisan identification limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Legal and governmental experience support procedural competence, tempered by long association with partisan government." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated responsibility for a major ministry demonstrates strong capacity for complex institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive foreign-ministerial experience makes international representation one of his clearest strengths." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior service in Fidesz-led governments substantially weakens the impression of autonomy from party interests." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and diplomatic reputation supports credibility, while political alignment may reduce trust across camps." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Widely celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and positive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional seriousness is encouraging, but her career provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but it is not the same as leading a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional recognition and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research career and public reputation convey exceptional competence, persistence, and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could attract broad acceptance, but offers limited popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career provide an unusually direct basis for confidence in institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates relevant experience directing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European judicial experience strongly support international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though high appointment-based offices warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal and European service support a strong impression of professional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian historian.", "Known for scholarship on modern Hungarian history.", "Has held senior academic standing." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Historically informed national perspective.", "Strong scholarly credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive record.", "Historical interpretation can become politically contested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film director and screenwriter.", "Directed On Body and Soul.", "Has received major international film recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural achievement.", "Strong international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of large public-institution management." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist.", "Known for research on local and regional governance.", "Has held senior academic and research roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent governance expertise.", "Credible institutional perspective." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility.", "Little recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian jurist.", "Former Constitutional Court judge.", "Has publicly addressed constitutional questions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law background.", "Substantial juristic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Public positions may be polarizing.", "Limited recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian conductor and composer.", "Co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "Has led major orchestras internationally." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural stature.", "Extensive international presence." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Public interventions may divide some audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian lawyer and politician.", "Served twice as foreign minister.", "Held office in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep diplomatic experience.", "Proven ministerial leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Strong partisan association.", "Cross-group trust may be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Scientific distinction does not establish public executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Strong European and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular profile.", "Senior appointments may raise independence questions." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impression for every pair, separating limited factual recall from subjective interpretation and lowering confidence where familiarity or criterion-specific evidence was weak.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "ignac-romsics", "ildiko-enyedi", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "imre-voros", "ivan-fischer", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 14057580888490520510, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "ignac-romsics", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "ilona-palne-kovacs", "control-consensus-guardian", "ivan-fischer", "imre-voros", "katalin-kariko", "ildiko-enyedi", "janos-martonyi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:a6b440da89f6a3da68b9c8cff932961ecee2e9d69ee4bcd0b7a52bb9971b8913", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:27:43+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:23+02:00", "duration_s": 99.641, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21476, "output_tokens": 4008, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide unusually strong evidence of inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging exceptionally match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments indicates exceptional capacity to direct a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and includes recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition is a major asset, though partisan rhetoric would reduce diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates substantial exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer credibility among admirers, but polarization and insufficient integrity evidence weaken broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may limit polarization but leaves broader acceptability largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is encouraging, but the profile provides little evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patrons and incentives remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile lacks enough information about integrity and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic stature and measured public presence could attract respect across groups, though historical interpretation can divide." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly orientation and historical perspective suggest respect for institutional continuity and legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience is relevant, but it only partly demonstrates leadership of a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally engaged scholarship would support credible representation, albeit without a strongly diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity appears grounded more in scholarship than party command." }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long scholarly career supports credibility, while public trust beyond academic audiences is less certain." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally respected cultural achievement offers inclusive symbolism, though artistic prominence does not ensure mass appeal." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-cultural profile suggests civic seriousness but offers limited direct evidence of constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Film production and academic work imply collaborative leadership, but public-institution management is less established." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her acclaimed international film career gives her strong cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her authority is rooted in an independent artistic career rather than party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained professional reputation supports credibility with relatively little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-polarization scholarly profile is favorable, but broad public acceptability is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her governance scholarship suggests informed respect for institutional design and legal process." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior research and academic responsibilities suggest capable leadership, though not direct stewardship of a central state institution." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Relevant scholarly standing offers some international credibility, but diplomatic presence is not well established in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic and research profile appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her established academic standing supports credibility, although national public trust is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal stature could command broad respect, but forceful positions on contested constitutional issues may polarize." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law and former judicial profile strongly indicates commitment to legal checks and restraint." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High-level legal experience supports institutional competence, but my recall of executive leadership is limited." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal stature offers credibility, though I recall limited evidence of sustained diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional identity appears grounded in law rather than party organization, despite politically salient public interventions." }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial and scholarly experience supports credibility, though trust may vary with constitutional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural stature can bridge groups, but outspoken political engagement may limit acceptance among opponents." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civic profile suggests democratic commitment, but he lacks a substantial legal or constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major orchestral institutions demonstrates substantial organizational and personnel leadership." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international musical career gives him exceptional cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career provides autonomy, though his public political positions may create perceived alignment." }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained professional achievement supports credibility, while political visibility makes trust less universal." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature may reassure some groups, but strong identification with one political camp limits unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience supports institutional competence, though long partisan association creates reservations about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Repeated senior governmental responsibility demonstrates strong capacity to lead complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience as foreign minister directly establishes very strong diplomatic and representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior service in a party-led government substantially weakens the impression of autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His extensive public service supports credibility, while partisan identification constrains broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific accomplishment and limited partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates resilience and high-level scientific responsibility, though that is not equivalent to leading a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific standing would provide outstanding international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives primarily from scientific achievement rather than domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research career and global recognition create a very strong impression of credibility and earned trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained legal profile may be broadly acceptable but is unlikely to generate strong cross-group identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports legal process and institutional checks, despite inevitable questions about past rulings." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership at the Constitutional Court provides substantial evidence of managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic experience and senior legal standing indicate strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though senior appointments create some perceived establishment proximity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal service supports credibility, while institutional controversies may constrain universal trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian historian.", "His scholarship includes twentieth-century Hungarian history.", "He has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Scholarly independence and historical depth.", "Measured, institutionally minded public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or executive experience.", "Historical controversies could constrain universal appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian film director.", "Her film On Body and Soul won the Golden Bear.", "Her work has received major international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international cultural representation.", "Independent and comparatively nonpolarizing public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited legal or governmental experience.", "Artistic leadership offers incomplete evidence about state administration." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian political scientist.", "Her work concerns regional governance and public administration.", "She has held senior research roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantive knowledge of governance institutions.", "Relatively independent and low-polarization profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited nationwide public visibility.", "Little recalled diplomatic or central-state leadership experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional lawyer.", "He served as a Constitutional Court judge.", "He has commented publicly on constitutional questions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise.", "Professional standing outside routine party leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Public constitutional interventions can be politically divisive.", "Limited recalled diplomatic and executive-management record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian conductor.", "He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.", "He has led major international orchestras." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural standing.", "Demonstrated leadership of complex artistic institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Limited legal and constitutional experience.", "Public political positions may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian lawyer and diplomat.", "He served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He held office in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and governmental experience.", "Proven leadership in complex international affairs." ], "reservations": [ "Strong party association weakens perceived independence.", "Partisan identification limits cross-group acceptability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary earned international credibility.", "Broad symbolic appeal with little partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not automatically transfer to public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a diplomat.", "He is a legal scholar." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and institutional experience.", "Strong combination of legal and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Past judicial decisions may attract partisan criticism.", "His technocratic profile may have limited popular resonance." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the frozen rubric, using only supplied control profiles and my unaided internal recall for named individuals.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 4572035633901551977, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "jozsef-palinkas", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "julia-kiraly", "jozsef-peter-martin", "kornel-mundruczo", "katalin-bogyay", "control-consensus-guardian", "kinga-goncz", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:8c32f83070269af05e55300d366de6e1f77e002077e1f6ed1a88ab624d2a82ec", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:03+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:58+02:00", "duration_s": 115.594, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21231, "output_tokens": 5596, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan record imply exceptional acceptability with limited uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge exactly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity for responsible public administration." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding underpin a very strong trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely despite widespread recognition." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition creates representational presence, but polarizing conduct and absent diplomatic experience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly indicates exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity visibility supplies no integrity foundation, while polarizing partisan activity creates substantial distrust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves actual cross-group appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional competence offers some reassurance, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong capacity to administer a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly supplies no diplomatic experience or established international presence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests autonomy, though patrons and dependencies remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A competent career record is mildly favorable, but broader credibility and transparency are unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature could bridge groups, but his political history and limited mass appeal constrain that potential." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and senior public-service background suggests procedural seriousness, tempered by past partisan office." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major scientific and governmental institutions demonstrates substantial executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific and public-service standing offers credible representation, though diplomacy was not his central role." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later distance from Fidesz supports autonomy, although his earlier ministerial and party ties remain significant." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly reputation supports credibility, with some reservation arising from prior partisan alignment." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low partisan burden helps, but limited public prominence and an advocacy identity restrict broad symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His association with transparency and accountable governance supports institutional checks, though he lacks judicial experience." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Organizational leadership is relevant, but experience at the scale of a major state institution is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His policy and civil-society background could translate internationally, but diplomatic credentials are not prominent." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civil-society and analytical profile suggests strong autonomy from formal party structures." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Anti-corruption and transparency work strongly supports an impression of integrity and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional credibility and low partisan burden help, but her public reach is comparatively narrow." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record in independent economic institutions suggests respect for rules and checks, though not constitutional specialization." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and financial-sector responsibilities demonstrate strong complex-institution competence." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her economics expertise and international professional exposure support credible representation without a major diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic career and visible defense of central-bank independence suggest substantial factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her expert reputation and principled institutional positions create a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her polished, culturally oriented diplomatic persona carries relatively little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic career suggests procedural discipline, though constitutional checks are not her defining specialization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior ambassadorial and multilateral responsibilities demonstrate substantial institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive ambassadorial and United Nations experience is exceptionally aligned with this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A professional diplomatic profile supports some autonomy, but senior state appointments entail government proximity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long high-level diplomatic career supports credibility, with limited public evidence for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career offers no substantial direct record concerning constitutional restraint or legal process." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led consequential scientific work, but large public-institution management is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature provides exceptional international credibility and recognition." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career and reputation were built outside party structures and domestic factional machinery." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and international recognition support exceptionally strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her measured public style helps, but a clear partisan history limits cross-camp acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic public-service background is favorable, but constitutional law was not her principal field." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cabinet, diplomatic, and European parliamentary experience demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service as foreign minister and in the European Parliament provides very strong representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her prominent roles in an MSZP-led government and party delegation substantially weaken perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional and diplomatic record supports personal credibility despite partisan trust barriers." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction offers symbolic reach, although elite-art associations and public positions may limit universality." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public artistic profile offers little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Directing major productions shows leadership, but public-institution administration is a materially different task." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized film and theatre career gives him strong cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career suggests independence from formal party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional reputation is favorable, but it supplies limited evidence about public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional persona appears broadly acceptable, though he lacks strong popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career make institutional restraint his clearest strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Constitutional Court demonstrates responsibility for a complex and consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial role and diplomatic service provide unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A predominantly judicial and diplomatic profile suggests considerable distance from ordinary party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A senior judicial career supports credibility and procedural trust with limited salient reservations." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a physicist.", "He served as Hungary's education minister.", "He led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He combines scientific stature with senior institutional experience.", "His later political distance suggests some independent judgment." ], "reservations": [ "His former Fidesz affiliation burdens non-partisan perception.", "His broad popular appeal appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He has led Transparency International Hungary.", "He is associated with economic and public-policy analysis." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His transparency work supports an integrity-centered profile.", "His civil-society position suggests political autonomy." ], "reservations": [ "His experience leading major state institutions is limited.", "His national symbolic reach appears modest." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is an economist.", "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She resigned from the central bank before her term ended." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She projects technocratic competence and institutional independence.", "Her professional record supports credibility in complex governance." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks a constitutional or diplomatic specialization.", "Her recognition outside expert circles is limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "She is a career diplomat and cultural professional." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her international representational experience is exceptional.", "Her diplomatic style carries relatively low polarizing burden." ], "reservations": [ "Her constitutional record is indirect.", "Government appointments complicate a strong independence inference." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has exceptional global credibility and broad symbolic appeal.", "Her reputation is largely independent of domestic party politics." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks direct constitutional and governmental experience.", "Her scientific leadership record does not establish public-administration capacity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She served as a member of the European Parliament.", "She is a psychiatrist by training." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has extensive governmental and international experience.", "Her public style is generally measured and professional." ], "reservations": [ "Her MSZP-linked political career limits perceived independence.", "Partisan identification constrains her unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have competed at major international festivals.", "He directed the film White God." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He carries substantial international cultural prestige.", "His career is relatively independent of formal party structures." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks direct legal and public-administration experience.", "Artistic leadership only partly transfers to state institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career directly reflects constitutional and judicial responsibility.", "He has unusually strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "He has limited mass-public visibility.", "Judicial distinction does not automatically imply broad social appeal." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real figures and exclusively to the supplied profiles for synthetic controls, with confidence separated from evaluative score.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 8786347812418305603, "entity_order": [ "katalin-bogyay", "jozsef-palinkas", "kinga-goncz", "control-partisan-celebrity", "julia-kiraly", "peter-paczolay", "kornel-mundruczo", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-unknown-technocrat", "jozsef-peter-martin" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:52921fba3e7c692cffe161f9ae23f648f28ed3727989a938b7e30928da625f1a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:55+02:00", "duration_s": 108.797, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21231, "output_tokens": 4113, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge precisely match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to direct a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience supplies very strong international presence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of any documented integrity finding provide exceptional trust credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and combines inexperience with recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience makes responsible management of the presidency doubtful." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition is useful abroad, but diplomatic credibility is weakened by polarization and inexperience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may generate loyalty, but the profile provides little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves broader unifying appeal genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent rule-bound service is mildly favorable, but the profile contains no direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong leadership with some uncertainty about institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility makes this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides some reassurance, while the profile explicitly lacks enough information about trust and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature could bridge groups, but his partisan history reduces consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service and academic roles suggest institutional seriousness, but not a distinctly constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has substantial experience directing large scientific and governmental institutions." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific prominence provides international credibility, though diplomacy is not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later political separation supports some autonomy, while prior ministerial and party involvement remains a meaningful reservation." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific and administrative standing supports credibility despite a politically contested profile." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile expert identity limits polarizing burden but also offers little demonstrated unifying reach." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civil-society and governance-oriented profile appears favorable, but my specific knowledge is limited." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears to have organizational leadership experience, though I cannot confidently assess its scale." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Policy and international-network exposure may translate adequately abroad, but diplomatic credentials are unclear." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I associate him more with independent policy analysis than party office, supporting cautious confidence in autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His association with transparency and policy analysis supports credibility, subject to low familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional seriousness and limited partisan baggage help, but her profile offers modest symbolic reach beyond expert circles." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic public-service record suggests commitment to rules and institutional constraints, though not specifically constitutional law." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and academic responsibilities indicate strong capacity for complex institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her economic expertise offers international credibility, though she lacks a primarily diplomatic public identity." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her economist and central-banking profile appears substantially more technocratic than party-directed." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her willingness to take visible institutional positions supports an impression of professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A culturally engaged diplomatic profile offers broad symbolic appeal with relatively little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic and multilateral background suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional stewardship is not her defining experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in major diplomatic and cultural institutions strongly supports her capacity to manage a complex presidency." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ambassadorial and multilateral experience makes international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears more diplomatic than factional, while senior state appointments still create some uncertainty about autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record conveys credibility, although her domestic public-trust profile is not especially visible to me." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan baggage give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her disciplined scientific career suggests respect for process, but she lacks a demonstrated constitutional or legal record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated research leadership, but large public-institution management is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-recognized scientific stature gives Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from science rather than party structures or domestic political patronage." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific contribution, and international recognition support exceptional personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic manner and social-policy background help, but partisan identification constrains cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic governmental and European experience suggests reliable commitment to legal and institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, diplomatic, and European parliamentary service demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Former foreign-minister and European experience make her very strong at representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her established party-linked governmental and parliamentary career limits the impression of factional independence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She presents as a credible public servant, though association with a divisive governing era may affect trust." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural distinction could offer inclusive symbolism, though elite artistic identification may not translate into broad acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public artistic work may reflect civic awareness, but it provides little evidence of constitutional or legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Managing major creative productions demonstrates leadership, but not at the scale or constraints of a public constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized cultural career would provide strong visibility and credible artistic representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career appears relatively autonomous from formal party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional reputation is favorable in my limited representation, but public accountability experience is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile has consensus potential but limited mass symbolic resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court gives him unusually direct experience with legal restraint and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has led a supreme constitutional institution and held significant international legal responsibilities." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ambassadorial and European judicial experience provide very strong diplomatic and international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career supports autonomy, although senior appointments across political systems invite some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial standing supports credibility and institutional trust with no major integrity concern prominent in my recall." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Physicist and member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Previously served as education minister.", "Led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of complex institutions.", "Scientific stature supports credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Prior party and ministerial involvement.", "Limited direct diplomatic or constitutional specialization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Associated in my memory with Transparency International Hungary.", "Known as an economist and policy analyst." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Governance-oriented civil-society profile.", "Apparently limited party-political entanglement." ], "reservations": [ "Low public visibility.", "My recall of his institutional record is limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Economist and former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Held academic positions in economics.", "Resigned from the central bank before completing her term." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic competence.", "Substantial independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional-law experience.", "Modest symbolic reach outside expert communities." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "Served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "Held senior leadership in UNESCO's General Conference." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Relatively low domestic partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Domestic public-trust profile is less visible than her international record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Biochemist known for foundational work on mRNA therapeutics.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad non-partisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record managing a large public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "Later served in the European Parliament.", "Worked in social-policy and governmental roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong diplomatic and European experience.", "Substantial public-institution experience." ], "reservations": [ "Clear association with a political camp.", "Connection to a polarizing governing period." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have competed at major international festivals.", "Directed internationally produced screen and stage works." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International cultural credibility.", "Substantial independence from party structures." ], "reservations": [ "No clear constitutional or public-administration record.", "Creative leadership only partially transfers to state institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and international legal credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile.", "Senior state appointments can complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based solely on internal recall for real people and exclusively on the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 8414657990746702825, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "kinga-goncz", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:fc988bbb129366a0e7c4ed9608212d91ffa0d61b3b203674527a7a0a096020c0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:11+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:58+02:00", "duration_s": 107.25, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21479, "output_tokens": 4207, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge exactly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to manage demanding public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international presence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy with only ordinary appointment dependence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding combine with a long public-service record exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide little basis for confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition aids presence abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience sharply limit suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity can confer recognition, but the profile offers little integrity evidence and substantial partisan trust burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility and trust information make unifying capacity genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A competent nonpartisan career is neutral-positive, but the profile supplies no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong leadership with meaningful uncertainty about institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of diplomatic experience makes this a weak fit despite general professional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides neither integrity concerns nor affirmative evidence of broader public trust." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic stature could bridge groups, although his political history creates a moderate partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-institution leadership suggests respect for process, though constitutional stewardship was not his central field." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His record leading major scientific and governmental institutions indicates unusually strong executive competence." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific prominence and ministerial experience provide credible but not primarily diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Later distance from his former political camp supports autonomy, but prior senior party-government involvement remains significant." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific and administrative standing supports credibility despite political associations that may divide trust." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A reform-oriented profile may earn respect but offers insufficient evidence of broad symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His perceived transparency and governance orientation supports restraint, but my knowledge of his broader record is limited." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Organizational leadership seems relevant, but experience at presidential institutional scale is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Policy expertise may travel well internationally, though I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civil-society profile appears meaningfully independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Association with anticorruption advocacy supports integrity, subject to limited familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility may cross party lines, but limited mass symbolic appeal constrains the score." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her central-banking background suggests procedural seriousness without providing direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank experience demonstrates strong competence in a complex and consequential institution." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International economic expertise provides credible representation despite limited conventional diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic career and willingness to leave office support a strong impression of professional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation and accountable public posture support high credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her cultural and diplomatic orientation offers broad symbolic inclusion with relatively little polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic service suggests procedural discipline, though direct constitutional-check experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior diplomatic appointments indicate substantial competence in complex public organizations." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive UNESCO and United Nations experience is exceptionally aligned with representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career-diplomatic profile supports autonomy while repeated government appointments create some establishment dependence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished multilateral career supports credibility and a low-conflict public image." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and an unusually low partisan profile give her broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and restraint, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional governance." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence demonstrates judgment and perseverance but not extensive leadership of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide Hungary with exceptional recognition and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears exceptionally independent of domestic party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally validated scientific career supports exceptional credibility and public respect." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A conciliatory personal style helps, but strong association with one political camp limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic-government and European institutional service supports legal-process commitment despite limited constitutional specialization." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European parliamentary experience demonstrates strong public-institution competence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Service as foreign minister and European legislator provides very strong international representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior government and party-affiliated European roles create a substantial partisan-dependence burden." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional and diplomatic record supports credibility, while partisan identification constrains universal trust." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction and relative partisan distance help, though his work lacks universally consensual reach." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public artistic profile offers no strong adverse signal but little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Directing major productions shows leadership, but experience governing a complex public institution appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized film and theatre career provides strong cultural presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally oriented artistic career suggests considerable independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His respected professional reputation supports credibility, with limited evidence about broader institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained institutional profile could attract broad acceptance but offers limited popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive constitutional-court experience strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates strong capacity to manage a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience indicates exceptional representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial autonomy despite establishment connections." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal roles convey credibility, with some trust burden from association with contested institutions." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a physicist.", "He served as Hungary's education minister.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial institutional leadership experience.", "Demonstrated willingness to depart from a former political camp." ], "reservations": [ "Prior senior partisan involvement.", "Limited direct diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He has been associated with Transparency International Hungary.", "His work has focused on economics and governance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong apparent anticorruption orientation.", "Relatively independent civil-society profile." ], "reservations": [ "Low public visibility.", "Limited recalled experience leading state institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is an economist.", "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She resigned from that position before her term ended." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic competence.", "Credible professional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad symbolic appeal.", "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "She was president of UNESCO's General Conference." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Relatively inclusive and low-polarization profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional track record.", "Career appointments may invite establishment-dependence concerns." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired and minimally partisan public image." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific distinction does not establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She served as a member of the European Parliament.", "She is a psychiatrist by training." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive international and governmental experience.", "Generally restrained public style." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with a specific political camp.", "Partisan history limits unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have competed at major international festivals.", "He has directed productions outside Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international cultural standing.", "Substantial independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited legal and public-administration experience.", "Artistic leadership only partly transfers to state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a Hungarian ambassador.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and legal experience.", "Strong European representational credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular political base.", "Establishment roles may complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the supplied ordinal anchors directly, used only internal recall for real figures and only the provided profiles for synthetic controls, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 6850578166814081244, "entity_order": [ "kinga-goncz", "jozsef-palinkas", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "jozsef-peter-martin", "kornel-mundruczo", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-bogyay", "julia-kiraly", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:26bbe4f02998578d3e094155608a0c92579bc02d3a0c0a9e693e98d2f92af8c0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:12+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:02+02:00", "duration_s": 110.781, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21479, "output_tokens": 4025, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international presence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding strongly support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal experience and combines party campaigning with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of legal or institutional leadership experience makes this a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition helps visibility abroad, while polarization and inexperience constrain credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may generate trust among admirers, but the profile supplies little evidence of accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility and insufficient information make broader unifying appeal genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is relevant, but the profile gives no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide solid evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a relative weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence helps, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about trust and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and conservative origins broaden his reach, though political history may still divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-institution leadership suggests procedural seriousness, but his constitutional profile is not especially prominent." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in major scientific and governmental institutions indicates substantial executive competence." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific standing would travel well internationally despite limited recalled diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Later distance from Fidesz supports some autonomy, while earlier party and government roles remain relevant." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and administrative reputation supports credibility, with some exposure to political contestation." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A civic reform profile may appeal across groups but lacks broad symbolic visibility." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civil-society profile suggests commitment to accountable governance, though my specific familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall organizational leadership but not stewardship of a comparably complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional background may support credible representation, but I recall little diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I associate him more with independent civic oversight than with party command." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His association with transparency work supports integrity, subject to limited recall." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility may reassure moderates but offers limited mass symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her central-banking background suggests commitment to rules and institutional autonomy, though not constitutional adjudication." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and academic responsibilities indicate strong capacity in complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International economic expertise would support credible representation in European and global settings." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic career and public defense of institutional independence support autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation and willingness to take principled institutional positions support trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her cultural and diplomatic orientation offers inclusive symbolism with relatively low polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic service suggests procedural professionalism, though constitutional oversight is not her defining field." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior multilateral and diplomatic appointments demonstrate substantial institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International representation is her clearest strength given extensive ambassadorial and multilateral experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career-diplomatic profile appears less factional than party politics, while government appointments limit complete independence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional diplomatic reputation supports credibility without a strongly recalled integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and an apolitical public image give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her distinguished scientific career offers little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional research accomplishment does not by itself establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would confer exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career appears notably independent of Hungarian party machinery and factional patronage." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and international recognition strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her measured profile could reassure moderates, though prior government service carries partisan baggage." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her ministerial and European institutional experience suggests respect for legal process, tempered by partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national and European roles provide strong evidence of capacity within complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Foreign-ministerial and European experience make international representation a clear strength." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A substantial MSZP-linked political career limits the impression of autonomy from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She projects professional credibility without a strongly recalled personal integrity controversy." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural achievement offers symbolic reach, though an elite arts profile may not translate broadly." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His artistic record provides little direct evidence about constitutional or legal-process stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Creative production demonstrates leadership, but not clearly at the scale of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His established international cultural presence would support visible and credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international artistic career appears substantially independent of formal party structures." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His respected professional standing supports credibility without supplying much public-accountability evidence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could attract institutional respect across groups without strong popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career make legal process and institutional checks central strengths." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional experience managing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience strongly supports authoritative representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic profile suggests meaningful autonomy, though high appointments inevitably invite political scrutiny." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility and accountability, with limited recalled personal controversy." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Physicist and member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Served as education minister.", "Led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific and administrative credentials.", "Demonstrated willingness to diverge politically." ], "reservations": [ "Earlier Fidesz ties remain salient.", "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Associated with Transparency International Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Civic accountability orientation.", "Appears independent of major party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Low public visibility.", "Limited recalled state-leadership experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Economist and former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Resigned from the central bank before her term ended.", "Has held academic roles in economics and finance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic competence.", "Credible institutional-independence profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited diplomatic experience.", "Technocratic profile may lack broad symbolic reach." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "Served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "Held a senior leadership role in the UN General Assembly." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic credentials.", "Inclusive cultural orientation." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional oversight experience.", "Government appointments complicate full independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired, nonpartisan public image." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct public-institution leadership experience.", "Constitutional judgment is largely untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "Served as a member of the European Parliament.", "Held ministerial office in an MSZP-led government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental and European experience.", "Measured international profile." ], "reservations": [ "Prior partisan alignment reduces independence.", "Past government association may constrain unity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His work has appeared at major international film festivals.", "Directed the film White God." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international cultural standing.", "Relatively independent public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little relevant legal experience.", "Public-institution leadership is untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility.", "Elite institutional profile may constrain popular unity." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representation of real figures and only the supplied descriptions of synthetic controls, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 7891932156840907878, "entity_order": [ "jozsef-palinkas", "kinga-goncz", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "kornel-mundruczo", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-bogyay", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:af78480b7e9d4c11a5e3999d4e2649f4be36eb3a1593d039e6142e241497a8a9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:18+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:06+02:00", "duration_s": 107.984, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21479, "output_tokens": 5533, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments support very strong acceptability with little stated polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented nonpartisan rule-of-law service match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric and active partisanship make cross-group acceptability very weak." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal or institutional experience and recent partisan campaigning provide weak grounds for constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The supplied profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports presence abroad, but polarizing rhetoric limits representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity directly undermines the impression of political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but polarization and partisan campaigning substantially weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Limited visibility and insufficient information leave unifying appeal genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and limited public visibility make this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence helps modestly, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about trust and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature could attract respect across groups, though his political history carries some polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic and public-service background suggests respect for legal process, with some partisan-government association." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience leading major scientific and governmental institutions indicates strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific standing and ministerial experience suggest credible representation despite a limited diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later independent posture is favorable, but prior party and government roles limit the impression of full autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional seriousness and credibility, subject to reservations arising from political entanglement." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low public profile and advocacy associations create uncertainty about broad symbolic acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public association with transparency and institutional accountability supports a strong rule-of-law impression." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Organizational leadership is relevant, but experience directing a major state institution is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His policy and civil-society background appears internationally legible, but diplomatic stature is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civil-society profile suggests meaningful autonomy from party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Anti-corruption and transparency work supports a favorable impression of integrity and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility may bridge camps, but limited mass visibility and outspoken positions restrict symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic record and public institutional criticism suggest strong regard for accountable governance." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and academic experience indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her economic expertise supports international credibility, though she lacks a primarily diplomatic public identity." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her professional trajectory and willingness to leave office convey unusually strong institutional independence." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record projects professional integrity, candor, and willingness to accept personal institutional consequences." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A polished, culturally oriented diplomatic identity offers inclusive symbolism with limited evident polarization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional diplomatic background suggests procedural restraint, though direct constitutional evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior multilateral and diplomatic appointments indicate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive ambassadorial and multilateral career is an exceptional match for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career-diplomatic profile appears relatively autonomous, although senior appointments inevitably involve governments." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained professional service supports credibility, though domestic public trust is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and a nonpartisan public identity give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record inspires confidence in rigor, but it provides little basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates responsibility and excellence, but large public-institution leadership is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific standing would confer exceptional credibility and recognition abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably independent of Hungarian party structures and short-term factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and restrained public persona support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her measured style and social-policy background help, but strong association with one political camp constrains reach." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic public-service record suggests a solid commitment to legal and institutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European parliamentary experience demonstrate substantial command of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her foreign-ministerial and European experience makes international representation a particularly strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive service in an explicitly partisan government and party delegation weakens perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She appears credible and professionally serious, though partisan identification may reduce trust among opponents." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural achievement offers broad symbolic appeal, while elite-art associations may limit nationwide identification." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His cultural work suggests democratic sensibility, but direct evidence of constitutional stewardship is limited." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major artistic productions is relevant, but it only partially transfers to complex public administration." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His established international cultural reputation would provide distinctive and credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international artistic career appears substantially autonomous from party structures and domestic patronage." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has a credible professional profile, but limited public-service exposure makes accountability judgments uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile may command cross-group respect, although broad popular recognition is limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career make guardianship a direct and very strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates high-level responsibility within a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European judicial experience indicates excellent diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest substantial professional autonomy despite appointment-related political context." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long legal and diplomatic service conveys credibility and institutional seriousness." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a physicist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He served as Hungary's education minister." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial scientific and institutional leadership.", "Professional stature beyond electoral politics." ], "reservations": [ "Prior partisan and government affiliations.", "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic identity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He has led Transparency International Hungary.", "He is an economist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong transparency and accountability orientation.", "Appears relatively independent of party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Limited nationwide public visibility.", "Little evident experience leading a major state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She is an economist.", "She resigned from the central bank before completing her term." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic competence and independence.", "Credible record of institutional candor." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-symbolic profile.", "No primary diplomatic or constitutional career." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "She has worked in cultural diplomacy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Inclusive cultural and international profile." ], "reservations": [ "Direct constitutional record is limited.", "Domestic cross-group trust is difficult to gauge." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility and nonpartisan prestige.", "Strong public impression of perseverance and integrity." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional and governmental experience.", "Little demonstrated leadership of a complex public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She served as a member of the European Parliament.", "She is the daughter of former president Árpád Göncz." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep diplomatic and European experience.", "Measured public-service profile." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with one political camp.", "Partisan history may limit unifying reach." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have competed at major international festivals.", "He directed Pieces of a Woman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally recognized cultural presence.", "Public identity largely independent of party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct public-institution experience.", "Constitutional stewardship is difficult to assess." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and institutional expertise.", "Strong diplomatic and European credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular visibility.", "Senior appointments may invite competing political interpretations." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned impressions, with factual recall separated from interpretation and synthetic controls judged solely from their profiles.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 3539359762412885024, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "jozsef-palinkas", "peter-paczolay", "jozsef-peter-martin", "katalin-kariko", "katalin-bogyay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "kinga-goncz", "julia-kiraly", "control-consensus-guardian", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:34557af1095df3ae7fec55a7ac5fe2bb131acf0aecdb6b20d5e6c74ca057a787", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:28:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:58+02:00", "duration_s": 95.813, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21239, "output_tokens": 4011, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden imply exceptional acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge directly exemplify this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of senior judicial and cross-government leadership demonstrate exceptional institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior public standing strongly support international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cross-government leadership and nonpartisan status indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would burden cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No relevant legal experience and recent partisan campaigning create substantial uncertainty about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile expressly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational presence despite no stated diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly suggests factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may confer credibility for some, but the profile supplies little evidence of public accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader acceptability untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly reassuring, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides solid leadership evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports autonomy, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the profile is insufficient to assess trust and integrity confidently." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and establishment experience could bridge groups, although his political history may limit acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public and academic roles suggest respect for formal institutions, though constitutional stewardship was not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has substantial experience leading complex scientific and governmental institutions." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific and ministerial background would provide credible international presence." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later public posture appears more autonomous, but prior senior party-government service remains a reservation." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic reputation and institutional service support credibility, with some partisan baggage." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A technocratic civil-society profile may be acceptable across groups but offers little demonstrated symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His perceived civil-society orientation favors institutional checks, but my knowledge is limited." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears to have organizational leadership experience, though not at the scale of a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Policy and international-facing experience seem relevant, but I recall little direct diplomatic evidence." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I associate him with independent policy advocacy rather than party office, though recall is incomplete." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public-policy reputation appears credible, but limited familiarity constrains the judgment." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility may cross party lines, but her limited symbolic profile reduces unifying force." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public institutional service suggests procedural seriousness, though constitutional law is outside her principal expertise." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank and academic roles indicate strong capacity for complex institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international economic expertise supports credibility abroad despite limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her economist and central-banking profile appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation and willingness to take accountable institutional positions support trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her cultural-diplomatic style and comparatively low partisan profile support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic career suggests respect for lawful procedure, though constitutional checks were not her central remit." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior diplomatic appointments indicate substantial experience managing public responsibilities." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her ambassadorial and multilateral experience is directly aligned with representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A professional diplomatic profile suggests some autonomy, while senior state appointments imply establishment ties." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her long international service projects credibility, with limited domestic public scrutiny available in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and low partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and discipline, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates professional responsibility and resilience but has limited visible experience leading large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific standing would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably detached from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific career conveys strong credibility and earned public trust." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic temperament is inclusive, but clear association with one political camp constrains cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic public-service background suggests institutional commitment, though she is not primarily a constitutional specialist." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European-level service demonstrate substantial institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Foreign-minister and European parliamentary experience strongly support diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior service in an MSZP-led government and later party-affiliated European politics limits perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional and ministerial record appears credible, notwithstanding partisan identification." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction and low party identification help, though artistic controversy may limit universal appeal." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public artistic profile offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Directing major productions shows leadership, but not clearly at the scale or character of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international film and theatre career provides strong cultural representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally oriented artistic career appears substantially independent of party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained professional reputation supports credibility, but public-institution accountability is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad respect, though he lacks strong mass-public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and judicial background is exceptionally aligned with legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates responsibility for a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His judicial diplomacy and ambassadorial experience strongly support international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful autonomy from day-to-day party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility and accountability, subject to limited recall of public controversies." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a physicist.", "He served as Hungary's education minister.", "He led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive institutional leadership.", "Strong scientific credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Past senior partisan-government role.", "Limited constitutional specialization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He has been associated with Transparency International Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Civil-society credibility.", "Apparent distance from party command." ], "reservations": [ "Low public visibility.", "Limited recalled experience leading major state institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian economist.", "She served as deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She has held academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic competence.", "Credible institutional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited diplomatic background.", "Modest broad-public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian diplomat.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to the United Nations.", "She held a senior role at UNESCO." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience.", "Low-polarization public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional record.", "Domestic cross-group appeal is not well tested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was central to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or governmental experience.", "Limited large public-institution leadership evidence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She was a member of the European Parliament.", "She is the daughter of former president Árpád Göncz." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial diplomatic experience.", "Credible public-service record." ], "reservations": [ "Strong association with one political camp.", "Partisan history limits independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have competed at major international festivals.", "He founded the Proton Theatre company." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international cultural standing.", "Relative independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little public-institution experience.", "Limited evidence concerning constitutional stewardship." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He held an ambassadorial post." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Judicial stature may not translate into broad symbolic appeal." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real candidates and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls, treating unfamiliarity as lower confidence rather than omitting scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 5570767838748967859, "entity_order": [ "jozsef-peter-martin", "control-consensus-guardian", "kinga-goncz", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "kornel-mundruczo", "jozsef-palinkas", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-unknown-technocrat", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:74e9b4c120c9457d2da32fb579eeb911ac207bbb975387f1685020300208a56b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:50+02:00", "duration_s": 103.844, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21695, "output_tokens": 5457, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service make this an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments suggests exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong representational foundation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate institutional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and strong recent partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is valuable abroad, though polarizing conduct limits diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates pronounced dependence on a party faction." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may create trust among admirers, but polarization weakens general credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves unifying appeal unestablished." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence and non-partisanship are encouraging, but constitutional commitments are unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid, if not exceptional, leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply below-average representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but broader trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and ideological movement may broaden appeal while alienating established camps." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-service experience supports institutional awareness, though constitutional restraint is not his defining credential." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior scientific and governmental management demonstrates extensive institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific and ministerial profile would provide credible international standing." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Later distance from governing politics moderates, but does not erase, his partisan history." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic standing supports credibility, tempered by the burdens of political involvement." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A civic orientation could aid inclusion, though his broader acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civil-society profile suggests rule-of-law commitment, but my familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Relevant organizational experience seems plausible, but I recall little about its scale." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional background may transfer internationally, though evidence in my recall is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He appears relatively independent of party structures, subject to limited recall." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His perceived association with transparency supports trust, with substantial uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional seriousness could reassure varied groups, but her public reach seems limited." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic record suggests respect for rules and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-bank responsibility demonstrates leadership in a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her economic expertise and international professional exposure support credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her expert profile appears meaningfully autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reputation for professional candor and expertise supports strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her restrained cultural-diplomatic persona appears relatively inclusive and nonpolarizing." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic service suggests institutional discipline, though not direct constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior multilateral and cultural roles indicate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive high-level diplomacy makes international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career-diplomatic profile suggests some autonomy despite senior governmental appointments." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional diplomatic standing supports credibility with limited contrary impressions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record inspires confidence in rigor, but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence does not by itself establish leadership of a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific credibility support very strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her measured profile may reassure some groups, but partisan associations limit breadth." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic public-service background suggests respect for legal and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national and European roles indicate strong experience with complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Foreign-policy and European experience make international representation a particular strength." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her substantial party-government career creates a mixed impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional demeanor supports credibility despite possible partisan distrust." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction offers symbolic appeal, though challenging art may not unite broadly." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public work suggests civic sensitivity but provides little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major productions shows coordination ability but only partial institutional transfer." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His established international cultural presence would support distinguished representation." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic career appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His serious artistic reputation supports credibility, but public-trust evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could attract cross-group respect without broad popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background provides unusually direct preparation for institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions indicates very strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European legal experience would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest autonomy, though elite appointments invite some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional legal reputation supports credibility and institutional trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a physicist.", "He served as Hungary's education minister.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has led major scientific and governmental institutions.", "His academic stature adds intellectual credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His history in party politics complicates political independence.", "Past political alignments may limit unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He has been associated with Transparency International Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His profile suggests concern for accountable government.", "He appears less embedded in party politics than career politicians." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity with him is limited.", "I cannot confidently assess his experience leading a major public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian economist.", "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She has held academic roles in economics and finance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her technocratic expertise supports responsible institutional leadership.", "She appears professionally independent and candid." ], "reservations": [ "Her public profile may be too specialized for broad symbolic appeal.", "She has limited direct diplomatic and constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian diplomat.", "She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "She served as president of UNESCO's General Conference." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her multilateral experience is exceptionally relevant to international representation.", "Her diplomatic style appears measured and broadly respectable." ], "reservations": [ "Her constitutional-law credentials are limited.", "Senior state appointments may create questions about perceived political distance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Much of her scientific career was pursued in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her achievement commands broad respect beyond party divisions.", "Her global stature would represent Hungary exceptionally well." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks an evident background in constitutional or political institutions.", "Scientific leadership may not fully transfer to a head-of-state role." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She later served in the European Parliament.", "She is the daughter of former president Árpád Göncz." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has substantial diplomatic and European institutional experience.", "Her public style appears measured and internationally credible." ], "reservations": [ "Her party-political career limits the impression of independence.", "Past partisan alignment may constrain cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have received recognition at major international festivals.", "He directed the film White God." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has substantial international cultural credibility.", "His artistic independence offers distance from party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "He has little evident experience with constitutional institutions.", "Artistic leadership only partly demonstrates public-administration capacity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career directly combines constitutional and diplomatic competence.", "His juristic profile suggests institutional restraint." ], "reservations": [ "His elite institutional background may offer limited popular connection.", "The political context of senior appointments warrants some caution about perceived independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real candidates and exclusively from the supplied profiles for synthetic controls, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 5387206764429825850, "entity_order": [ "katalin-bogyay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "kornel-mundruczo", "jozsef-palinkas", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "julia-kiraly", "jozsef-peter-martin", "peter-paczolay", "kinga-goncz", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:f92d446d217ea3539996c0e117e725105adff42594b1b374b0d6f97b2e200eb7", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:12+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:48+02:00", "duration_s": 95.281, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21487, "output_tokens": 3877, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan profile indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates high capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports authoritative international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong perceived trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly conflicts with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and combines partisanship with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is a major asset, though polarizing conduct weakens representative suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional independence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create familiarity, but the profile provides little integrity evidence and substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves cross-group appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is relevant but the profile supplies no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks diplomatic experience and offers little compensating international stature." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports a cautiously favorable independence judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent management is mildly positive while broader integrity and trust evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature may cross camps, though political associations could constrain acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior public and academic service supports institutional seriousness, tempered by prior partisan involvement." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has extensive experience leading major scientific and governmental institutions." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific standing and public experience would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His later institutional profile suggests autonomy, but his political career remains a meaningful reservation." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic distinction and senior responsibility support credibility despite possible partisan skepticism." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An accountability-oriented profile may earn cross-group respect but also attract partisan resistance." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His association with transparency and accountable governance strongly supports constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Civil-society leadership indicates relevant management capacity, though at a smaller institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His policy expertise is internationally legible, but diplomatic stature is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civil-society and analytical profile suggests meaningful independence from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Public work centered on transparency gives him a strong integrity profile." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credibility could reassure multiple groups, though her public reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior central-banking background suggests commitment to rules and institutional discipline." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior monetary-policy and academic roles indicate strong capacity to manage complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally legible economic expertise would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic economic profile suggests substantial autonomy from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation supports a strong impression of competence and candor." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A culturally oriented diplomatic profile could carry relatively low partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic background suggests respect for formal institutions, though direct constitutional evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior diplomatic and multilateral responsibilities indicate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomacy and international cultural representation are central strengths of her career." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears more diplomatic and cultural than factionally political." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional profile appears credible, but broad public trust is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement gives her unusually broad symbolic appeal across social groups." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her disciplined scientific career is favorable but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Research excellence is clear, but leadership of a complex public institution is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific distinction would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her standing derives overwhelmingly from science rather than party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific record and perseverance support a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic manner may broaden acceptance, but partisan history creates a polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic public-service record suggests institutional commitment, though not primarily judicial expertise." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European-level responsibilities demonstrate substantial institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Foreign-minister and European parliamentary experience directly support excellent international representation." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her substantial party-political career limits the impression of independence from factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional and ministerial career supports credibility, with likely partisan variation in trust." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural distinction may broaden appeal, though his work is not necessarily consensus-oriented." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public artistic profile offers little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major creative productions shows coordination ability but not public-institution experience." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international film and theatre career would provide strong cultural representation." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identity as an independent cultural creator suggests distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His internationally respected career supports credibility, with limited evidence about mass public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could command broad respect despite limited popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial experience directly support strong institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and international judicial experience indicate very strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial professional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial office and international service support a strong credibility assessment." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a physicist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He previously held government office." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive scientific-institution leadership.", "Strong technocratic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Prior partisan involvement.", "Unifying appeal may be politically constrained." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He has led Transparency International Hungary.", "His public work concerns corruption and governance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong accountability orientation.", "Civil-society independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited nationwide visibility.", "Diplomatic and large-institution experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian economist.", "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She has held academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic competence.", "Credible institutional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility.", "Little direct constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian diplomat.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "She held a senior role representing Hungary at the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Relatively non-partisan cultural profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional record.", "Broad domestic popularity is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership is not her core record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She was a member of the European Parliament.", "She is a psychiatrist by training." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial diplomatic experience.", "Proven senior public-service capacity." ], "reservations": [ "Clear party-political history.", "Partisan associations may limit unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have appeared at major international festivals.", "He directed Pieces of a Woman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International cultural stature.", "Apparent distance from party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Little relevant legal experience.", "Public-institution leadership is untested." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a diplomat.", "He has held an international judicial role." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular public profile.", "Cross-group acceptance cannot be assumed." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impression for every pair, separating limited factual recall from subjective interpretation and using only the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 7725801823594061990, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "control-unknown-technocrat", "kinga-goncz", "peter-paczolay", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kornel-mundruczo", "jozsef-peter-martin", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:a529f92ff7aad7dbbf11a2d531cb6bc0dec44b66166a55d76273b876a80a7004", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:13+02:00", "duration_s": 109.64, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21487, "output_tokens": 4156, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly indicates exceptional rule-of-law commitment and experience with institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of service and leadership across governments indicate very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments suggest strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with polarizing partisanship and supplies no guardianship evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports international presence, though polarizing conduct limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate personal trust among admirers, but polarization and partisanship create substantial credibility reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility leaves both cross-group acceptability and polarizing burden largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile contains no adverse signal but insufficient evidence of commitment to constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management suggests strong leadership with limited evidence about public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience makes this a below-average fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although other dependencies remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is mildly favorable, but the profile explicitly lacks broader trust information." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and ideological moderation help, but a long political history may limit cross-group neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institutional career and later political independence suggest respect for constitutional process, with some partisan-history reservation." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major scientific and governmental institutions demonstrates very strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific and ministerial background supports credible representation despite limited diplomatic specialization." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He demonstrated distance from his former political camp, although his earlier senior party-linked service remains relevant." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic leadership supports credibility, tempered by the trust costs of prior partisan involvement." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A reform-oriented expert profile may bridge some groups but anti-corruption advocacy can carry partisan perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His anti-corruption and governance work strongly suggests commitment to accountable legal institutions." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Civil-society executive experience indicates solid leadership, though at a smaller scale than national institutions." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His governance expertise is relevant internationally, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Civil-society leadership suggests considerable independence from formal party command." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His association with transparency advocacy supports a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected technocratic profile may bridge groups, although limited mass visibility constrains symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic public-service record suggests respect for lawful institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and academic experience indicate strong leadership in technically complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International economic expertise supports credible representation despite limited recalled diplomatic practice." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her expert identity and willingness to criticize institutional interference suggest unusually strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional credibility and principled public posture create a very strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her cultural-diplomatic orientation and relatively low partisan burden support broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public-service career is favorable, but I recall little direct evidence concerning constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior multilateral and diplomatic roles demonstrate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive UNESCO and United Nations experience makes international representation her clearest exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career-diplomatic profile suggests professional autonomy, though senior government appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international public-service record creates a strong credibility impression without a recalled integrity controversy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record inspires confidence but provides little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led demanding scientific work, but I recall limited experience directing large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global professional standing appear substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific perseverance and international recognition create a very strong credibility impression." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic and professional demeanor seems inclusive, though partisan identification limits cross-group reach." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic-government service creates a favorable impression, tempered by limited recalled constitutional work." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European institutional experience indicate strong capacity to manage public responsibilities." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Foreign-minister and European parliamentary experience provide a very strong representational foundation." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her substantial party-aligned political career weakens the impression of autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "I recall a credible public-service profile without a prominent integrity concern." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural stature offers symbolic reach, but an elite and sometimes contentious artistic profile may not bridge all groups." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public artistic profile appears democratically compatible but offers little evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading major creative productions is relevant but only partly transferable to a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His substantial international cultural recognition would provide a strong representational presence." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career suggests meaningful independence from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional reputation is favorable, though I lack strong information about broad public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could attract broad respect but offers limited evidence of popular connection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior constitutional and judicial experience creates a very strong guardianship impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court indicates exceptional experience directing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International judicial and diplomatic experience strongly supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career suggests substantial independence, though elite state appointments warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial standing supports credibility, with no confidently recalled major integrity issue." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He served as Hungary's education minister.", "He later broke politically with Fidesz and founded a separate movement." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive scientific and public-institution leadership.", "Evidence of autonomy from a former political camp." ], "reservations": [ "Earlier senior partisan involvement burdens neutrality.", "His later political activity may still divide audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He has led Transparency International Hungary.", "He is an economist.", "His public work has focused on corruption and governance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong accountability orientation.", "Civil-society distance from formal party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled experience leading large state institutions.", "Modest nationwide symbolic visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "She is an economist and academic.", "She resigned from the central bank before completing her term." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic credibility.", "Demonstrated willingness to defend institutional principles." ], "reservations": [ "Limited diplomatic experience.", "Low visibility outside economically engaged audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.", "She held senior roles connected with UNESCO.", "She served as president of UNESCO's General Conference." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional multilateral diplomatic experience.", "Low overt partisan burden in her public image." ], "reservations": [ "Little recalled constitutional oversight experience.", "Independence from appointing governments is not fully clear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired achievement with low partisan identification." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific leadership differs from directing a state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She later served in the European Parliament.", "She trained and worked in psychiatry." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and European experience.", "Professional and comparatively restrained public style." ], "reservations": [ "Clear association with a former governing camp.", "Limited direct constitutional-law experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have competed at major international festivals.", "He directed the film White God." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international cultural standing.", "Professional identity outside party institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Little public-institution leadership experience.", "Artistic prominence may not translate into broad political unity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial expertise.", "Strong international institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public political profile.", "Senior appointments can complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than as grounds to omit any score.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "julia-kiraly", "katalin-bogyay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 14661532313333989919, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "julia-kiraly", "peter-paczolay", "kinga-goncz", "kornel-mundruczo", "jozsef-palinkas", "jozsef-peter-martin", "katalin-kariko", "katalin-bogyay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:599502a114f82ad87067caffa44b727be41ff16b5ecd8f4e7949325a4041812a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:27+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:31+02:00", "duration_s": 124.266, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21487, "output_tokens": 5612, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments imply exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional ability to steward a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide very strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong credibility with limited residual uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe burden on cross-group acceptance despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile offers no legal experience, while recent partisan campaigning raises concern about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stipulated absence of legal or institutional leadership experience is a substantial weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition is valuable abroad, although polarizing rhetoric could impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly suggests exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may generate personal trust among supporters, but polarization and partisanship undermine general credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptance and symbolic inclusion uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisan professional experience is mildly encouraging, but the profile gives little evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid capacity to lead a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The lack of diplomatic experience and public visibility creates a notable representational weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patrons and incentives remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service and no stated controversy are positive, but the profile supplies insufficient trust evidence." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and movement across political boundaries may bridge some groups, while past affiliations limit neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic and public-service experience suggests institutional seriousness, though his record is not primarily constitutional." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in government, academia, and national research administration demonstrates extensive institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific stature and public experience would support credible representation, though diplomacy is not his defining expertise." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Later independence from former allies is meaningful, but his substantial party and ministerial history remains a constraint." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific and institutional standing supports credibility, with political reversals inviting some skepticism." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A nonpartisan governance profile can bridge groups, but limited mass visibility weakens symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His civil-society and governance profile suggests commitment to accountable institutions, but direct constitutional experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His leadership in policy and civil-society settings is relevant, though smaller in scale than senior state administration." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His policy expertise could translate internationally, but I recall limited direct diplomatic evidence." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity appears rooted in independent analysis and civil society rather than party office." }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Association with transparency and anticorruption work supports a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional credibility could attract moderates, but economic-policy associations may limit cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic public profile suggests respect for rules and institutional process, despite limited constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior central-banking experience indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior economic-policy background would provide credible international presence, though diplomacy was not her primary field." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional identity appears substantially more technocratic than party-directed." }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reputation for professional seriousness and institutional candor supports a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her polished and relatively nonconfrontational diplomatic profile could be broadly acceptable across groups." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her diplomatic career suggests respect for formal process and institutional continuity, though not specialized constitutional expertise." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior ambassadorial and multilateral responsibilities indicate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive senior diplomatic and multilateral experience makes international representation her clearest exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A professional diplomatic identity supports autonomy, but repeated senior state appointments create some governmental association." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained international service supports credibility, though her domestic public trust profile is less visible." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific recognition and a relatively nonpartisan image give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for standards, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but it is not equivalent to leading a complex constitutional public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional recognition and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than party structures or political patrons." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her measured style and diplomatic experience help, but identifiable partisan associations reduce universal acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her democratic public-service record suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional law was not her specialty." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cabinet-level and European institutional experience indicate substantial leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Foreign-minister and European experience make international representation one of her clearest strengths." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Substantial service in party-linked government and European politics constrains the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional and diplomatic record supports credibility, tempered by the trust burden of prior partisan office." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural distinction offers symbolic reach, but elite-art associations and political interpretations may narrow broad appeal." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public artistic profile offers little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint or legal-process stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading complex artistic productions demonstrates management, but public-institution stewardship would be a significant transition." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominent international cultural career would provide recognizable and sophisticated representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally established artistic career suggests distance from formal party command, though public cultural disputes can create alignments." }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His serious professional reputation is favorable, but it gives limited evidence about public accountability in office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could command broad respect without carrying a large populist or polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career make institutional restraint a central strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court provides unusually direct evidence of capacity to steward a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and senior legal stature support highly credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long record in high-trust legal and diplomatic offices supports a strong credibility impression." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He held ministerial office." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive academic and institutional leadership.", "Demonstrated willingness to depart from former political alignment." ], "reservations": [ "Past party and ministerial roles constrain neutrality.", "Political repositioning may invite skepticism." ] }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He has led Transparency International Hungary.", "He is known as an economist and governance commentator." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong transparency and accountability orientation.", "Relatively independent civil-society profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility.", "Less experience leading large state institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian economist.", "She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian central bank.", "She has held academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong technocratic credibility.", "Appears substantially independent of party command." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Economic-policy associations may divide opinion." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian diplomat.", "She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.", "She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic qualifications.", "Polished and relatively nonconfrontational profile." ], "reservations": [ "Domestic cross-group trust is less visible.", "Senior state appointments create some governmental association." ] }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired and minimally partisan public image." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific leadership does not fully demonstrate state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "She served as a member of the European Parliament.", "She is associated with the Hungarian Socialist Party." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic and European experience.", "Measured public-service profile." ], "reservations": [ "Clear partisan history limits independence.", "Prior government service may polarize evaluations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.", "His films have appeared at major international festivals.", "He directed Pieces of a Woman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international cultural presence.", "Public identity is outside formal party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct legal or state-institution experience.", "Broad domestic acceptability is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian jurist.", "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served in diplomatic office." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional credentials.", "Combines judicial leadership with diplomacy." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may carry political associations.", "His broader popular appeal is less clear." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed an independent rubric-conditioned ordinal impression for every pair, using only supplied control profiles and cautious internal recall for named figures.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 15279724414329823550, "entity_order": [ "laszlo-trocsanyi", "laczo-adrienn", "control-unknown-technocrat", "miklos-perenyi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "laszlo-majtenyi", "peter-paczolay", "marta-pardavi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:65eecf6e949d72469fcec5005965da13f3c001369392bd96452d9dc718ca8176", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:55+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:50+02:00", "duration_s": 115.313, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21693, "output_tokens": 5654, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments indicate unusually high consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior public service provide very strong international representative credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric and campaign identification make broad cross-group acceptance unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor institutional restraint and adds strong partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides representative visibility, but polarization and inexperience substantially limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates pronounced factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition cannot compensate for the credibility burden created by polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability and symbolic inclusion unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no direct record of constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience and limited visibility make this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides a modest positive signal, but the profile explicitly lacks broader trust information." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her independent professional reputation is reassuring, but she has little demonstrated experience with constitutional institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial high-level scientific experience, but her record leading a complex public institution is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific standing would give Hungary extraordinary international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing appear highly autonomous from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-partisan judicial identity could be broadly acceptable, but her national symbolic reach is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited representation of her as an independent-minded judge suggests respect for legal process, with considerable uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial experience supports responsible decision-making, while evidence of leadership at comparable institutional scale is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficient information about her diplomatic experience or international public presence." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her judicial profile appears meaningfully removed from party structures, though my familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional profile suggests integrity, but I lack enough confidently recalled information for a firmer judgment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige offers symbolic reach, though his critical profile and demanding public persona may limit broad identification." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public intellectual profile suggests independence of mind, but it gives little direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary achievement offers little evidence of capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary standing would provide exceptional cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary career and critical intellectual identity appear substantially autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic seriousness and independent reputation support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His principled record could attract democratic constituencies broadly, but his opposition-associated profile limits government-side acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained work on rights, information freedom, and institutional accountability indicates very strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ombudsman and civil-society leadership experience demonstrates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and rights-oriented profile would be credible abroad, though he lacks exceptional diplomatic visibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His watchdog and academic profile suggests strong autonomy, although past opposition support creates some partisan perception." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long record of public-interest advocacy supports strong credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identification with the Orbán government would impose a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His extensive legal background supports competence, but his close association with contested government policies creates substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ministerial, judicial, diplomatic, and academic experience demonstrates strong capacity to lead complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European-level experience would support credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior service in a Fidesz government and subsequent party affiliation indicate limited distance from partisan command." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature is offset by political controversy and likely low trust among government critics." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her principled advocacy could unite rights-oriented groups, but intense government hostility toward her organization creates major polarization." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained rule-of-law and human-rights advocacy indicates very strong commitment to legal checks and constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-term leadership of a prominent legal-rights organization demonstrates strong institutional management and resilience." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive international human-rights engagement would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her civil-society career appears independent of party command, despite strong alignment with one side of major policy disputes." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her consistent public-interest work supports strong integrity, though trust would vary sharply across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected and comparatively non-polarizing cultural figure could carry broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His distinguished cultural profile appears non-authoritarian, but it offers little direct evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Artistic distinction does not itself demonstrate experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized cultural career would give him dignified representative presence." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career identity appears rooted in music rather than party or factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional reputation gives a strong impression of seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile is comparatively non-polarizing, although unlikely to inspire universal enthusiasm." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial experience strongly supports legal-process competence, with some reservations about institutional context." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court and subsequent senior judicial service demonstrate very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience would provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports autonomy, though appointments within politically contested institutions warrant meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished legal service supports credibility, tempered by association with contested appointment environments." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary non-partisan international credibility.", "Widely respected scientific achievement and perseverance." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or legal experience.", "Public-institution leadership record is not clearly comparable." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Appears professionally independent.", "Judicial experience is relevant to legal restraint." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity is limited.", "National leadership and diplomatic experience are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He wrote Satantango.", "He won the Man Booker International Prize." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly independent intellectual reputation.", "Exceptional international cultural stature." ], "reservations": [ "No clear record of public-institution management.", "Limited direct constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection and freedom of information.", "He led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.", "He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Longstanding commitment to rights and accountability.", "Substantial relevant institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Past opposition sponsorship affects perceived neutrality.", "Government supporters may view him as adversarial." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "He later became a Fidesz member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and governmental experience.", "Strong diplomatic and institutional credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Closely identified with a governing party.", "Associated with highly contested legal policies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "Her organization has litigated and advocated on asylum and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record of defending legal safeguards.", "Experienced civil-society institutional leader." ], "reservations": [ "Highly polarizing in Hungary's current political environment.", "Lacks experience leading a state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has had a prominent international performing career.", "He has taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Prestigious and comparatively non-partisan public image.", "Strong international cultural presence." ], "reservations": [ "Little relevant legal experience.", "Little demonstrated public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional and institutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "His appointment history may attract political scrutiny.", "His consensus appeal is more professional than popular." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real candidates and only the stated profiles of synthetic controls, treating confidence as familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 11916539974994899933, "entity_order": [ "marta-pardavi", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "katalin-kariko", "miklos-perenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "laczo-adrienn" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:a83f9094bb702eaef21c6d7cbdb1c765bd7c318213e8b931dab6552516b2224c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:58+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:50+02:00", "duration_s": 111.781, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21485, "output_tokens": 5587, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan record imply very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of constitutional and rule-of-law service constitute an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates highly relevant institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience indicates very strong ability to represent Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates an exceptionally heavy barrier to cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no rule-of-law record and adds substantial factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience makes this a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility abroad, although partisan rhetoric limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on partisan objectives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition but the profile supplies little basis for institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence and nonpartisanship are mildly favorable, but the profile provides no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide solid evidence of responsible institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is modestly favorable, but information about integrity and public trust is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional ethos suggests responsibility, but her record offers little direct evidence on constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific and industry experience is valuable but does not clearly demonstrate large public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific standing would confer extraordinary international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing appear highly autonomous from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and globally validated scientific reputation create a very strong trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile legal professional may carry little polarizing burden but also limited symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her judicial profile suggests respect for legal process, though my specific knowledge is limited." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial experience is relevant, but I cannot confidently identify extensive executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficient knowledge of diplomatic experience or international public standing." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A professional judicial identity suggests autonomy, but I lack enough detail for a stronger assessment." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional standing creates a favorable integrity impression, subject to limited familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural prestige offers symbolic reach, although an austere intellectual persona may limit broad identification." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent intellectual profile is compatible with restraint, but supplies little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary achievement offers little demonstrated preparation for leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional international cultural stature would give him substantial representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally established literary career appears unusually independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His serious and independent public standing supports a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled institutional profile has consensus value but past opposition backing adds partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal scholarship and ombudsman background indicate very strong commitment to constitutional safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ombudsman and organizational leadership provide strong experience relevant to public office." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and academic stature would support credible representation despite limited diplomatic prominence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His watchdog and civil-society orientation suggests substantial independence from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained transparency and rights work supports a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His close association with contentious government policies gives him a heavy polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal expertise is substantial, but his governmental record creates meaningful doubts about robust institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, academic, and diplomatic service demonstrate strong capacity for complex institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European experience indicate strong representational competence despite political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior service in a dominant governing party substantially weakens the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional credentials support credibility, while partisan controversy produces a mixed trust assessment." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her principled profile could inspire liberals while carrying a considerable polarizing burden elsewhere." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained rule-of-law advocacy indicates a very strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior nonprofit leadership is relevant, though narrower than directing a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international legal and advocacy presence suggests credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society career suggests substantial autonomy from formal party command." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her visible consistency and rights-based work support a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected and low-polarization cultural figure could provide strong symbolic common ground." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His distinguished artistic career provides insufficient direct basis for evaluating constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Artistic distinction does not itself demonstrate capacity to lead a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international musical stature would make him a highly credible cultural representative." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long cultural career appears substantially removed from party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His disciplined and respected professional standing supports a strong impression of personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile offers cross-group acceptability with limited popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background makes institutional restraint a central demonstrated strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court strongly supports his capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European institutional experience indicates very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy despite proximity to state appointments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional record projects seriousness, credibility, and institutional reliability." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for work on messenger RNA.", "Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally trusted international scientific standing.", "Broadly unifying and minimally partisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "She has little demonstrated constitutional experience.", "Her record does not clearly establish public-sector executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is known to me as a Hungarian judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "A judicial profile is relevant to legal process.", "Her low partisan visibility may reduce polarization." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity is limited.", "Her leadership and diplomatic record are unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an internationally acclaimed Hungarian novelist.", "He won the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.", "Several of his works were adapted into films by Béla Tarr." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional cultural prestige and independence.", "Strong international recognition." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks evident public-institution leadership experience.", "His constitutional views are not central to his public record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection.", "He has led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.", "He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Longstanding commitment to rights and institutional checks.", "Relevant ombudsman and civil-society leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Past opposition sponsorship reduces perceived neutrality.", "His appeal may remain concentrated among liberal constituencies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "He later served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial legal, governmental, and diplomatic experience.", "Demonstrated capacity to lead complex institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Close identification with Fidesz sharply limits independence.", "His governmental record carries significant rule-of-law controversy." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "Her work has focused on rule-of-law and refugee-rights issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional and civil-liberties orientation.", "Credible international advocacy experience." ], "reservations": [ "Her advocacy profile is politically polarizing in Hungary.", "She lacks experience leading a state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has performed internationally as a soloist and chamber musician.", "He has taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Respected and low-polarization cultural standing.", "Strong capacity for dignified international representation." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks evident constitutional expertise.", "He lacks demonstrated leadership of a major public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally relevant constitutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and institutional credentials." ], "reservations": [ "His public symbolic appeal may be limited.", "His career includes appointments by political institutions." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores express one rubric-anchored subjective evaluation using internal recall for real candidates and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 5760239201182837446, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "miklos-perenyi", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "marta-pardavi", "laczo-adrienn", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "laszlo-majtenyi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:6076ecfc6e07fc5584d40a4ad67e88ed27138befa742feb5cce03f16111ecf74", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:58+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:44+02:00", "duration_s": 105.844, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21485, "output_tokens": 5578, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of constitutional service and documented rule-of-law commitment constitute an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate highly relevant institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature indicate very strong representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior campaign activity and no legal experience provide little basis for confidence in institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides representational reach, though polarizing conduct limits diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign involvement indicates strong exposure to factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may create trust among supporters, but partisan polarization substantially weakens broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low partisan burden helps, but limited visibility leaves cross-group appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and little public visibility indicate a weak representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patrons and incentives remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies insufficient evidence about trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely admired scientific achievement and low partisan burden create unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her independence and seriousness are favorable, but she lacks a known constitutional or legal-process record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding institutions, but large-scale public executive leadership is not established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific standing would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears exceptionally independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support a very strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile legal figure may avoid polarization, but broader symbolic appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited recollection of her judicial background supports a favorable but uncertain assessment of legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal responsibility suggests relevant competence, while substantial executive leadership remains unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall too little international experience to judge her as either strong or weak in this role." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A judicial profile suggests professional autonomy, but I lack enough detail to assess external dependencies." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The professional profile is mildly reassuring, but my factual familiarity is insufficient for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige offers symbolic reach, though his austere intellectual profile may not connect broadly." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His intellectual independence is favorable, but I recall no direct legal or constitutional service." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack evidence of executive leadership in a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional international literary stature would give Hungary a highly credible cultural representative." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary career and public persona appear strongly autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic seriousness supports a strong impression of authenticity and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled institutional standing helps, but visible alignment against the governing camp limits broad consensus." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in rights protection and institutional accountability indicates very strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in oversight and civil-society institutions indicates strong relevant capacity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and democratic credentials would travel well internationally, though diplomacy is not his defining experience." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His watchdog profile suggests substantial autonomy, though past opposition backing creates some factional association." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained accountability work supports a very strong impression of integrity and public-mindedness." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His close identification with a polarizing governing camp sharply limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His deep legal experience is relevant, but association with contested government legal policies creates substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, diplomatic, academic, and judicial experience demonstrates strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European experience provides strong representational competence despite political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior governmental and party-linked roles indicate limited distance from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Substantial professional credentials are offset by controversies that weaken broad public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her principled profile could attract democratic constituencies but carries a significant polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained civil-liberties and rule-of-law work indicates very strong commitment to legal safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior nonprofit leadership indicates meaningful organizational competence, though the presidential institution differs in scale." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international legal and civil-society engagement suggests strong credibility in democratic forums." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society career suggests substantial independence from party command, despite a clear advocacy orientation." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her visible rights advocacy and professional consistency support a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and relatively nonpolarizing cultural profile could command broad respect." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His nonpartisan cultural standing is reassuring, but I recall no direct constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional distinction does not by itself establish readiness to lead a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally respected musical career would provide substantial cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears substantially independent of party machinery and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding professional reputation creates a strong impression of seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional profile could attract institutional respect without carrying a heavy polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career indicate very strong grounding in institutional checks and legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major constitutional institution demonstrates highly relevant executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European legal experience indicate very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles support autonomy, though establishment appointments create meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long legal and diplomatic career supports a strong impression of credibility and responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international credibility.", "Broadly admired achievement with little partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "No established constitutional-law background.", "Limited evidence of public executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "My limited impression suggests a serious legal profile.", "Low public partisanship could support independence." ], "reservations": [ "Factual familiarity is very low.", "Broader trust and diplomatic capacity are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He won the 2015 Man Booker International Prize.", "Several of his works were adapted into films by Béla Tarr." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural prestige.", "Strong impression of intellectual independence." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled legal or public-administration experience.", "His appeal may be narrower than his prestige." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection.", "He led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.", "He was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record in rights and accountability.", "Credible institutional and civil-society leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Opposition backing creates partisan association.", "His cross-camp appeal appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "He became a member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and institutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic qualifications." ], "reservations": [ "Close association with the governing party limits independence.", "Contested government policies weaken unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian lawyer.", "She has held a leadership role at the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "Her work has focused on human rights and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep commitment to legal safeguards.", "Substantial civil-society leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Her advocacy profile is politically polarizing.", "Nonprofit leadership differs from leading the state presidency." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has had an international performing career.", "He has taught music in Budapest." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished and nonpartisan cultural stature.", "Strong international artistic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional or governmental record.", "Limited evidence of large public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He later became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly relevant constitutional leadership.", "Strong diplomatic and European legal experience." ], "reservations": [ "Establishment appointments complicate perceptions of independence.", "His broader popular appeal is not well tested." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations and the synthetic profiles, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 14699692735421452530, "entity_order": [ "laszlo-trocsanyi", "laszlo-majtenyi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "miklos-perenyi", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "marta-pardavi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "laczo-adrienn", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:4ad0ca23a3e5b11f1ec181c491b92c4f7778ea9b4e9c31acbca836954cc635d3", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:29:58+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:36+02:00", "duration_s": 97.797, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21237, "output_tokens": 3907, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging match this criterion exceptionally." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership across governments and long judicial service demonstrate very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representative capability abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition aids presence, though polarization and inexperience limit representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly signals factional dependence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame supplies visibility but the profile gives little basis for institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility leaves unifying appeal unresolved." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Administrative competence is relevant, but the profile provides no evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong leadership with limited evidence of exceptional scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply weak readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports autonomy, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable while broader trust and integrity evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated achievement offers unusually broad and positive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional independence is encouraging, but she has little demonstrated constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has high-level scientific experience but limited demonstrated leadership of public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific standing would confer exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific accomplishment and perseverance support exceptional personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-partisan profile could be acceptable across groups, but national symbolic reach is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her judicial profile suggests strong respect for legal process and institutional discipline." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior legal experience appears relevant, but I recall too little to judge leadership scale firmly." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficient recalled evidence of diplomatic or internationally prominent work." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A professional judicial career suggests meaningful distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation appears credible, though my factual familiarity is limited." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige helps, though an austere intellectual persona may have limited mass resonance." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent intellectual profile is favorable, but it offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Literary eminence provides little evidence of complex public-institution management." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary stature would represent Hungarian culture compellingly abroad." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary career appears highly autonomous from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His serious artistic reputation supports credibility without prominent recalled integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled civic standing is broadly respectable but not free of partisan interpretation." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career is strongly identified with rights protection, legality, and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has led significant oversight and public-policy institutions." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He offers intellectual credibility but less prominent diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His watchdog profile suggests autonomy despite past opposition-party presidential backing." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His public-service and transparency record conveys unusually strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His political record would likely carry a pronounced polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His extensive legal background supports competence, but close association with government policy creates meaningful restraint concerns." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has substantial experience leading major legal and public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic, ministerial, and European experience provide strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior governmental and governing-party roles indicate substantial factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature is offset by controversy surrounding his governmental role." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her principled record is strong, but contentious rights politics creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her rights-focused legal advocacy strongly signals commitment to legal process and institutional limits." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "She has substantial experience leading a prominent and demanding civil-society institution." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international human-rights engagement supplies strong networks and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Civil-society leadership suggests autonomy from party command despite an identifiable ideological profile." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained public-interest advocacy supports integrity, though trust would vary sharply across groups." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and low-conflict cultural figure could carry broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His nonpartisan cultural profile is reassuring, but relevant constitutional evidence is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Artistic distinction does not establish experience directing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally respected musical career provides substantial cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long artistic career appears notably detached from party command." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional reputation supports trust with few recalled controversies." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional persona is broadly acceptable but lacks strong popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career provide strong evidence of legal-process commitment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has led a constitutional court and served in senior international judicial office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European judicial experience make him especially credible abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial profile supports autonomy, though elite state appointments invite some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long senior judicial record supports credibility and professional trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broadly positive national symbolism." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or political experience.", "Little demonstrated leadership of complex public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Judicial experience suggests legal-process discipline.", "Her profile appears relatively nonpartisan." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity is limited.", "Her national leadership and diplomatic records are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He wrote Satantango.", "He received the Man Booker International Prize in 2015." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally distinguished cultural stature.", "Strong independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little relevant institutional-management experience.", "Limited evidence of constitutional expertise." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's first parliamentary commissioner for data protection.", "Led the Eötvös Károly Institute.", "Was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Longstanding rule-of-law orientation.", "Strong reputation for transparency and rights protection." ], "reservations": [ "Opposition backing may weaken perceived neutrality.", "Less executive and diplomatic experience than some alternatives." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's justice minister.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "Became a Member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and governmental experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Close alignment with the governing party.", "Polarizing association with contested government policies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian lawyer.", "She has served as co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "Her work has focused on human rights and asylum law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong commitment to rights and legal safeguards.", "Experienced civil-society leader with international standing." ], "reservations": [ "Her advocacy profile is politically polarizing.", "Cross-group acceptability would likely be uneven." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has performed internationally.", "He taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished nonpartisan cultural standing.", "Strong international artistic reputation." ], "reservations": [ "Little demonstrated public-institution leadership.", "Limited evidence concerning constitutional governance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional judicial and institutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular public profile.", "State appointments may complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based only on internal recall for real candidates and solely on the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 10807547335796703281, "entity_order": [ "laczo-adrienn", "control-consensus-guardian", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "laszlo-majtenyi", "peter-paczolay", "marta-pardavi", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "miklos-perenyi", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:1c2b09ba472e23316324de536aa59b5bd6a8ef67cbace3119abaf6c4c9314ff8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:02+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:45+02:00", "duration_s": 103.031, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21485, "output_tokens": 5485, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of documented constitutional service directly matches this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate exceptional factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no integrity finding support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 1, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly contradicts cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and indicates highly partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility, but polarizing rhetoric substantially weakens diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition does not establish accountability, while polarizing campaigning undermines broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is favorable, but broader unifying appeal is unestablished." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration does not establish a clear orientation toward constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong leadership with some uncertainty about scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply weak international representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is supplied, but evidence of public credibility is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public record offers little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated professional responsibility but limited experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global stature and compelling national story make her an exceptional international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career and standing are notably independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific career supports exceptional credibility and public esteem." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A nonpartisan judicial identity could reassure several groups, but her broader appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her judicial background suggests strong commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and governance experience indicates a sound capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She appears credible but has limited recalled international representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional profile appears substantially removed from party command." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation supports credibility, although national public trust is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige and low partisan identification support unity, though his appeal is comparatively elite." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public identity offers little direct evidence of constitutional or legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary distinction provides little evidence of capacity to lead a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary stature would confer exceptional cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His literary career appears highly autonomous from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His serious artistic reputation supports credibility with limited recalled public controversy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled profile can command respect, but prior political contestation limits consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ombudsman and constitutional-law record strongly signals commitment to rights and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of oversight and policy institutions demonstrates strong public-institution competence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He offers intellectual credibility but less diplomatic prominence than the strongest alternatives." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His watchdog profile suggests substantial autonomy despite past opposition support." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A sustained civil-liberties and accountability record supports strong integrity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His close association with contentious government policies imposes a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional expertise is substantial, but his government record creates serious restraint concerns." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ministerial, judicial, academic, and diplomatic experience demonstrates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive diplomatic and European experience gives him strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior roles aligned with the governing party indicate weak autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature is offset by controversy and strong partisan identification." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her principled standing is strong, but intense polarization around rights NGOs limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career defending legal rights and accountable government strongly matches constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-term leadership in a demanding legal organization indicates strong executive capability." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international human-rights engagement provides strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her civil-society role indicates strong autonomy from formal party command." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained advocacy record conveys integrity, though trust would vary sharply across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished and low-polarization cultural profile offers broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His artistic career supplies almost no direct evidence on constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Artistic and teaching excellence does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international musical standing would represent Hungarian culture with considerable distinction." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional identity appears strongly independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long, respected artistic career conveys exceptional seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional profile carries relatively little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background provides strong evidence of commitment to legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates exceptional experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience strongly fits international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful distance from routine party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial standing supports credibility with limited recalled integrity controversy." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has exceptional international credibility.", "Her achievement supports broad nonpartisan admiration." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks a substantial constitutional record.", "Her public-institution leadership experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian judge.", "She has been associated with judicial self-governance." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her professional identity favors legal process.", "She appears relatively independent of party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Her national public profile is limited.", "I recall little international experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He won the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.", "Several of his works were adapted into films by Béla Tarr." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He carries major international cultural prestige.", "He is comparatively independent of party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks demonstrated public-institution leadership.", "His constitutional orientation is not well established." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection.", "He has led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.", "He was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career strongly emphasizes rights and accountable government.", "He has credible oversight-institution experience." ], "reservations": [ "His past candidacy creates some partisan identification.", "His unifying reach beyond liberal constituencies is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "He became a Fidesz member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has deep constitutional and legal expertise.", "He has extensive institutional and diplomatic experience." ], "reservations": [ "His governing-party alignment weakens perceived independence.", "His ministerial record carries a strong polarizing burden." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a lawyer and co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "Her work has focused on human rights and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her record strongly supports constitutional safeguards.", "She has credible organizational and international experience." ], "reservations": [ "Rights NGOs are intensely polarized in Hungarian politics.", "Her cross-group symbolic appeal may therefore be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has performed internationally.", "He has taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His distinguished career carries low partisan burden.", "He could represent Hungarian culture credibly abroad." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks an evident constitutional record.", "He has little demonstrated public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He combines constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "His professional demeanor appears institutionally reassuring." ], "reservations": [ "His broader popular appeal is uncertain.", "Judicial prominence does not guarantee cross-group trust." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based only on internal recall for real candidates and exclusively on supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 10603815628001988300, "entity_order": [ "marta-pardavi", "peter-paczolay", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "miklos-perenyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "laszlo-majtenyi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:64a1a7a66c90675ebe0de4d262fc8c808265792953f7d2b58d60cd219299850a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:48+02:00", "duration_s": 102.375, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21493, "output_tokens": 4049, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity for responsible institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international credibility and representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion very unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and combines inexperience with polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition would confer presence abroad, though fame alone does not ensure diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity standing may inspire some confidence, but the profile provides little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile reduces polarizing burden but provides insufficient evidence of broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is neutral-to-positive, but the profile says little about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides strong direct support for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate below-average representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful independence, though patronage exposure remains unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is encouraging, but information about integrity, transparency, and public confidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely admired achievement and nonpartisan profile give her exceptional cross-group symbolic potential." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional independence and rigor are reassuring, but scientific achievement offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior scientific career implies substantial responsibility but not clearly the leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would provide extraordinary international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is strongly removed from party command and short-term factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her low-profile standing may reduce polarization, but broader acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited impression of a judicial profile is mildly favorable, but the evidence available to memory is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A senior legal career may indicate institutional competence, though I cannot confidently characterize its scale." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall too little international or diplomatic experience to judge her as a strong representative abroad." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A professional legal role suggests some autonomy, though I cannot confidently assess political relationships." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited professional impression is positive, but insufficient familiarity prevents a stronger assessment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His cultural distinction could offer a nonpartisan symbol, although his limited mass-public role creates uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent intellectual profile is encouraging, but it provides limited evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary eminence does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international cultural stature would give Hungary a distinguished and recognizable representative." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary career and distance from party office suggest considerable autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His serious and internationally respected body of work supports a strong impression of personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled institutional standing could attract several groups, but prior political contestation limits consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career in rights oversight and constitutional public life suggests exceptional commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His ombudsman and civil-society leadership indicate solid experience with public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has credible legal stature, but my recall offers limited evidence of extensive diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civil-society and ombudsman background suggests substantial autonomy despite visible opposition alignment in public politics." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long rights-focused public record supports a strong impression of integrity and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His close identification with a polarizing governing bloc would sharply limit cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional expertise is substantial, but his record in partisan government produces serious reservations about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ministerial, academic, judicial, and diplomatic experience demonstrates substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European experience would provide strong representational capacity despite political baggage." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior service in a party government and subsequent party-aligned office indicate limited distance from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature supports credibility, but political controversies make broad public trust doubtful." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She could symbolize inclusion for many while her prominent advocacy profile would remain polarizing to others." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained rule-of-law advocacy suggests exceptional commitment to legal safeguards and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a prominent legal organization indicates meaningful executive capacity, though not at head-of-state scale." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international human-rights profile would support credible and articulate representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society role suggests substantial autonomy from formal party command despite a clearly defined advocacy position." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record gives me a strong impression of credibility and principled public service." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-polarization cultural prestige could support broad symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His nonpartisan cultural standing is reassuring, but I lack evidence about his approach to constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My knowledge provides little indication of experience managing a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized musicianship would lend cultural prestige and dignified presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long artistic career without a salient party identity suggests strong factional independence." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished professional reputation gives me a strong impression of seriousness and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile appears comparatively acceptable across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports an impression of respect for legal process and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court and diplomatic service indicate strong capacity for complex public responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic experience and senior legal standing suggest assured international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, although establishment appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long high-level legal career supports credibility, though my recall is insufficient for a stronger judgment." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility", "Broad nonpartisan admiration" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or legal experience", "Public-institution leadership record is unclear" ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "Possible professional legal competence", "Apparently low polarizing burden" ], "reservations": [ "Very limited familiarity", "Diplomatic and leadership records are unclear" ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He won the Man Booker International Prize.", "His works include Satantango." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural stature", "Strong international recognition" ], "reservations": [ "Little demonstrated public-institution leadership", "Constitutional disposition is largely untested" ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's data-protection ombudsman.", "He is associated with the Eötvös Károly Institute.", "He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rights-protection record", "Credible institutional independence" ], "reservations": [ "Prior candidacy creates partisan associations", "Limited diplomatic profile" ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He served as an ambassador.", "He later became a Fidesz-affiliated member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal expertise", "Strong institutional and diplomatic experience" ], "reservations": [ "Close identification with the governing party", "Substantial polarizing burden" ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "Her work has focused on rule-of-law and migration-related rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law orientation", "Substantial international credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Advocacy role can be politically polarizing", "Limited head-of-state-scale executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has an international performance career.", "He has taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Nonpartisan cultural prestige", "Low polarizing burden" ], "reservations": [ "Limited evidence of executive leadership", "Little basis for assessing constitutional judgment" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional experience", "Credible diplomatic presence" ], "reservations": [ "Establishment appointments complicate independence judgments", "Limited popular symbolic profile" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions from internal recall or the supplied synthetic profiles, keeping uncertainty in confidence rather than omitting scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 2578728502878495031, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "laczo-adrienn", "miklos-perenyi", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity", "marta-pardavi", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "control-unknown-technocrat" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:e9d9f890c7ff5d5f426382d4d28e7c2fd11fb681f5edb479a5187b0de515cfb8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:32:54+02:00", "duration_s": 126.36, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21493, "output_tokens": 5657, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The supplied profile directly describes exceptional, sustained rule-of-law service and constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of service and leadership across governments indicate very strong institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented integrity record support exceptional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would impose a severe burden on cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition would provide visibility abroad, though polarizing rhetoric would reduce diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create recognition, but the profile offers little basis for institutional credibility or broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help acceptability, but insufficient visibility and trust information leave unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile contains no evidence of either strong constitutional commitment or disregard for institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid leadership with limited evidence of exceptional performance." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply a below-average fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports relative independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific record offers no strong direct basis for assessing constitutional restraint or legal-process commitments." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding research organizations, but that differs from leading a constitutional public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would give Hungary highly credible and distinguished representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her professional identity and achievements are notably independent of Hungarian party organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and international recognition support a very strong impression of trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-partisanship legal profile may be acceptable across groups, but limited public visibility makes unifying capacity uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited impression of her judicial background supports legal-process competence, but the evidence available to my memory is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional background suggests relevant institutional experience without a clearly recalled record of leading a comparably complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall too little international-facing experience to move this assessment beyond an uncertain midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional judicial profile appears relatively independent, though my familiarity is insufficient for a firm judgment." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A judicial career provisionally supports credibility, but I lack enough recalled information to assess public trust strongly." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Major cultural prestige offers symbolic reach, though his demanding work and public positioning may not translate into universal appeal." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His literary stature provides little direct basis for assessing constitutional practice or legal-process discipline." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished writing career does not establish experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional international literary reputation would provide culturally distinguished representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally established literary identity appears substantially independent of party organization." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His serious and internationally respected body of work conveys intellectual credibility and independence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His institutional seriousness has cross-group potential, but visible opposition alignment limits acceptance among government supporters." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ombudsman and constitutional-law background strongly indicates commitment to rights, accountability, and institutional limits." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ombudsman service and leadership of a public-policy institute demonstrate substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and public-policy stature would support credible representation, though diplomacy is not his principal known strength." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His watchdog career supports independence, though prior opposition sponsorship creates some factional association." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained transparency and civil-liberties work supports a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His close association with polarizing government policies would burden cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal expertise is substantial, but his ministerial role in contested institutional changes creates major reservations." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ministerial, academic, judicial, and diplomatic experience demonstrates substantial organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European-level experience would support capable international representation despite political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior service in a dominant governing party substantially weakens the appearance of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature supports credibility, while partisan identification and institutional controversy constrain broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her principled profile could inspire many citizens, but intense polarization around rights organizations limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained civil-liberties and rule-of-law advocacy strongly supports commitment to legal safeguards and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a prominent rights organization indicates substantial strategic and organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international human-rights engagement suggests articulate and credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society career indicates autonomy from party command, though advocacy positioning may be perceived as aligned with one political camp." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long and consistent public-interest advocacy record supports credibility despite sharply divided public perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected and nonpartisan cultural figure could possess broad symbolic appeal, albeit with limited mass visibility." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His distinguished cultural standing offers little direct basis for judging commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Artistic and teaching distinction does not itself establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally respected musical career would lend cultural prestige and composure abroad." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears substantially outside party structures and short-term factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long, serious artistic career conveys discipline and credibility without prominent partisan baggage." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could command respect across groups without generating strong popular identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive constitutional adjudication background suggests an unusually strong orientation toward legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major judicial institutions indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience suggests polished and credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports autonomy, though prominent state appointments leave some uncertainty about perceived distance from government." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial record conveys credibility and institutional seriousness." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broadly unifying scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record leading a public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is known to me as a Hungarian judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Professional legal background.", "Apparently limited partisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "Very limited recalled information.", "Unclear national leadership and diplomatic record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He wrote Satantango.", "He received the Man Booker International Prize in 2015." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural stature.", "Substantial independence from party structures." ], "reservations": [ "No clearly recalled institutional leadership experience.", "Limited direct basis for constitutional judgment." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's first parliamentary commissioner for data protection.", "He has led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.", "He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rights and accountability record.", "Relevant constitutional-institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Opposition sponsorship weakens perceived neutrality.", "Limited mass unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "He became a member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and governmental experience.", "Substantial diplomatic and European exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Strong identification with the governing party.", "Association with contested rule-of-law policies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "She has held a leadership role at the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "Her work has addressed refugee protection and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Consistent commitment to civil liberties.", "Substantial organizational and international experience." ], "reservations": [ "Rights advocacy is intensely polarized in Hungary.", "Cross-group symbolic acceptance would be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has had a prominent international performing career.", "He has taught at the Liszt Academy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Respected nonpartisan cultural stature.", "Strong international prestige." ], "reservations": [ "No clearly recalled constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong international institutional profile." ], "reservations": [ "State appointments may complicate perceptions of independence.", "Limited broad popular or symbolic appeal." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions from internal recall for real candidates and exclusively from the supplied profiles for synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 15800469546985355222, "entity_order": [ "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "marta-pardavi", "laczo-adrienn", "katalin-kariko", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:bb32bcbe1d6aaddfc00548d537ffb7105dc9252ce170abea21b7e4d29b9afce8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:30:50+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:32:52+02:00", "duration_s": 121.625, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21245, "output_tokens": 5527, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments provide strong evidence of inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature make the profile highly credible abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would sharply limit cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no rule-of-law experience and adds polarizing partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience is a major weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers presence abroad, though celebrity does not itself establish diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly suggests dependence on factional politics." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may produce recognition, but the profile supplies little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves cross-group appeal unresolved." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile offers no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken the case for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, subject to limited information." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but the supplied profile is insufficient to assess broader trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional ethos appears compatible with responsible stewardship, but her career offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific accomplishment is exceptional, but it does not directly establish leadership of a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide scientific recognition would give Hungary exceptional visibility and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing appear highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, professional credibility, and public reputation support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile professional figure may carry little polarizing burden, but broader acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited recollection of her judicial profile suggests respect for legal process but does not justify a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial experience is relevant, but I cannot confidently assess the scale of her leadership record." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack enough information about diplomatic exposure or international standing to move beyond a neutral assessment." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A professional judicial identity suggests autonomy, although my information is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional profile creates a favorable impression, tempered by low familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International cultural stature could transcend party lines, though his limited mass-public role creates uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent intellectual profile is encouraging, but it provides little direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary achievement offers little evidence of managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His exceptional international literary standing would give Hungary a distinctive and credible cultural representative." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears highly autonomous from party organizations and political patronage." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained artistic seriousness and independence support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principled profile could command respect across groups, but his opposition associations would constrain consensus." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal career and civil-liberties orientation suggest unusually strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Prior leadership in oversight and academic institutions indicates strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional expertise would support credible representation, though diplomacy is not his defining public role." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears substantially autonomous from party structures despite identifiable alignment with government critics." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public record conveys consistency, seriousness, and personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature helps, but close identification with one governing camp carries a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal expertise is substantial, but his ministerial role in contested institutional changes creates serious reservations." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, diplomatic, judicial, and academic experience demonstrate considerable institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European-level experience provide strong qualifications for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior service under Fidesz makes autonomy from governing-party priorities difficult to credit." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished credentials coexist with political controversies that would divide assessments of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her principled work would inspire some groups but attract strong resistance from others in Hungary's polarized environment." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained civil-liberties and rule-of-law work strongly indicates commitment to legal safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior leadership in a prominent rights organization indicates considerable organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive engagement with international rights institutions would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society career appears independent of party command despite a clearly situated public-policy outlook." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her consistent advocacy and professional standing support a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected and minimally partisan cultural figure could offer broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His serious professional profile is mildly favorable, but it supplies no direct constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Artistic and teaching distinction do not provide clear evidence of large public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international musical stature would make him a highly credible cultural representative." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long artistic career appears notably removed from party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished, low-controversy professional reputation supports a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile could be broadly acceptable without carrying a large personal polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court career supplies strong direct experience with legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court and service in international institutions indicate strong executive judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience make international representation a particular strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though prominent state appointments warrant some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional record conveys seriousness and credibility, with limited personal controversy in my recollection." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary international credibility.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution leadership at presidential scale." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is associated in my recollection with the Hungarian judiciary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "A judicial profile suggests respect for legal process.", "She appears to carry limited partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity is low.", "Her leadership and diplomatic experience are unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He won the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.", "His works include Satantango." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international cultural stature.", "Strong independence from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Little evident public-institution management experience.", "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection.", "He is a constitutional-law scholar.", "He was an opposition-supported presidential nominee in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law orientation.", "Substantial oversight experience." ], "reservations": [ "His opposition associations may limit cross-party acceptance.", "His diplomatic profile is less developed than his legal profile." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.", "He later became a Member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and governmental experience.", "Strong international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Close association with Fidesz weakens perceived independence.", "His role in contested legal reforms burdens his guardianship profile." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "Her work has addressed asylum and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Sustained commitment to civil liberties.", "Credible international engagement." ], "reservations": [ "Her advocacy profile is polarizing in domestic politics.", "She has less experience leading a state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has performed internationally.", "He has taught at the Liszt Academy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished and nonpartisan cultural standing.", "Strong international representational presence." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited evidence of complex public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He formerly presided over Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and international judicial credentials." ], "reservations": [ "High-level state appointments may complicate perceptions of independence.", "His broader popular appeal is uncertain." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal representations only, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 4930562954188539257, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-majtenyi", "miklos-perenyi", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "marta-pardavi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:68513ff5b1d47ca119c16306536ba969fab2ad405091e5fe6dea56b46093aeed", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:13+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:32:52+02:00", "duration_s": 99.86, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21493, "output_tokens": 4036, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate exceptional acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly support autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Partisan campaigning and absent legal experience provide weak grounds for constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International recognition helps representation, though polarization and inexperience materially reduce fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Fame supplies visibility but the profile gives little integrity evidence and substantial credibility risk." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience weakens confidence in international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers modest reassurance while broader integrity and trust evidence is absent." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her widely admired achievement and nonpartisan profile give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific ethos is reassuring but offers limited direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence and senior professional experience help, but public-institution leadership is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority rests primarily on scientific achievement rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and globally validated scientific career support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her cross-group acceptability is unclear from my limited familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack a sufficiently reliable internal representation to move far from the uncertainty midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot reliably characterize her experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack enough reliable information to assess her diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently assess her distance from partisan or factional influence." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient confidently recalled information leaves trust and integrity indeterminate." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Cultural prestige could inspire respect, but his austere intellectual profile may have limited mass reach." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public intellectual stature offers little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Literary achievement does not demonstrate leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His major international cultural standing would give Hungary a distinguished public face." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identity as an internationally established writer appears substantially independent of party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A serious and internationally respected literary reputation supports credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Principled institutionalism could attract democratically minded groups but may meet partisan resistance." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long association with rights oversight and constitutional accountability strongly fits this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Oversight and civil-society leadership provide substantial evidence of institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional and rights expertise would carry credibility abroad despite limited diplomatic prominence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His watchdog profile suggests substantial autonomy despite prior opposition-backed presidential nomination." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His accountability-oriented career supports a strong impression of integrity and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His partisan association and contested ministerial legacy limit cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His deep legal experience is substantial, but his governmental record creates meaningful reservations about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, academic, diplomatic, and legal roles demonstrate strong institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European experience supports representation despite political baggage." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior service in a dominant party government weighs heavily against perceived political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional distinction is offset by political controversy and uneven cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her principled advocacy inspires some groups but carries a substantial polarizing burden in Hungary." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her sustained rule-of-law and human-rights advocacy strongly signals commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-term leadership of a prominent legal organization demonstrates substantial management capacity." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international human-rights engagement suggests strong credibility and fluency abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Civil-society leadership suggests autonomy from party command despite a clearly situated public profile." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her consistent rights-focused work supports credibility and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected and relatively nonpolarizing cultural figure could possess meaningful symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His artistic distinction provides little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Artistic and teaching accomplishment does not clearly establish large public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized musical career would support dignified cultural representation." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career centered on music rather than party structures suggests considerable independence." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished, low-drama professional reputation supports trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist could attract cross-group respect without commanding broad popular identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law and judicial background strongly supports confidence in legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major legal institutions indicates strong capacity for responsible administration." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience makes him an especially credible international representative." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional profile suggests autonomy, though senior state appointments create some uncertainty about political distance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial reputation conveys credibility and institutional seriousness." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held senior academic and biotechnology roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broadly admired nonpartisan achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or legal experience.", "Scientific leadership differs from leading a state institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confident positive inference beyond the neutral midpoint.", "Potential qualities cannot be assessed reliably." ], "reservations": [ "Very low familiarity.", "Insufficient basis for criterion-specific differentiation." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He received the Man Booker International Prize.", "His works have achieved substantial international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent cultural authority.", "Distinguished international stature." ], "reservations": [ "No clear public-institution leadership record.", "Limited evidence of constitutional expertise." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's data-protection ombudsman.", "He has led the Eötvös Károly Institute.", "He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rights-and-accountability record.", "Substantial institutional expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Prior candidacy may reduce perceived neutrality.", "His appeal may be concentrated among liberal-democratic constituencies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He has served as a diplomat.", "He became a member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and institutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Close association with party government weakens independence.", "His ministerial record carries significant rule-of-law controversy." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "Her work has significant international visibility." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong commitment to legal safeguards.", "Experienced civil-society leader." ], "reservations": [ "Her advocacy profile is politically polarizing.", "Public acceptability may be uneven across ideological groups." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has performed internationally.", "He has taught music at a senior level." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Nonpartisan cultural prestige.", "Dignified international presence." ], "reservations": [ "Little evidence of constitutional expertise.", "Limited large-institution leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong European institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments complicate perceptions of independence.", "Limited broad popular profile." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall, treated uncertainty as lower confidence rather than missing scores, and used only the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "laszlo-majtenyi", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "marta-pardavi", "miklos-perenyi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 13220115960139663682, "entity_order": [ "miklos-perenyi", "laszlo-majtenyi", "control-consensus-guardian", "marta-pardavi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "laszlo-trocsanyi", "laczo-adrienn", "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d29bf3c8c2807c3e083fdb58baff5cb46f998d69959e4ea492195ff38709f862", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:31+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:36+02:00", "duration_s": 125.0, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21493, "output_tokens": 5614, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest exceptional acceptability and inclusive standing." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate substantial factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record provide exceptionally strong trust signals." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and indicates polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition aids international presence, though polarizing rhetoric weakens diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame provides visibility but neither establishes public integrity nor offsets divisive rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader unifying appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration supplies no clear evidence of either strong constitutional commitment or disregard." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid leadership capacity with limited evidence at national scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit lack of diplomatic experience makes this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office favors independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but the profile provides insufficient information about integrity or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated achievement and limited partisan burden create unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career provides little direct basis for evaluating constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career demonstrates responsibility and resilience but offers limited evidence of broad public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would provide outstanding international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her professional standing was built primarily in science rather than party politics." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific accomplishment, and professional recognition support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Limited national visibility leaves both polarizing burden and unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited recollection suggests legal experience but is insufficient for a stronger constitutional assessment." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Possible judicial experience suggests relevant capacity, though the scale of leadership is unclear to me." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack reliable recall of diplomatic or international representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall no strong party identity, but my familiarity is too limited to assess external influence confidently." }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A generally professional impression is favorable, but I lack enough reliable information for a firm judgment." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional cultural prestige offers symbolic reach, though his work and public image are not universally accessible." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His intellectual stature does not provide direct evidence of constitutional or legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary achievement supplies little evidence of experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary standing would give Hungary a highly credible cultural representative." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary career appears substantially autonomous from formal party structures." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His serious and internationally respected body of work supports a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He offers principled institutional credibility but may be identified strongly with one side of Hungary's political divide." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal and ombudsman background strongly signals commitment to rights and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has relevant experience leading oversight and public-interest institutions." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional expertise would provide credible representation despite limited diplomatic prominence." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His civic profile suggests autonomy, though prior opposition backing creates some factional association." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained public-law and civil-society work supports a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His stature may reassure government supporters but carries a considerable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional expertise is substantial, but his close association with contested government legal policies creates major reservations." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior judicial, ministerial, academic, and diplomatic roles demonstrate extensive institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European-level experience provides strong international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior government and governing-party roles substantially weaken the impression of political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional credentials support credibility while controversies surrounding his ministerial record produce a mixed assessment." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her rights-based credibility is substantial, but intense partisan contestation around her organization limits broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career defending legal rights and institutional accountability strongly aligns with constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a prominent legal-rights organization demonstrates relevant managerial and institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive international advocacy experience supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society career suggests independence from party command despite clear policy commitments." }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained and visible advocacy creates a strong impression of consistency and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A respected and relatively nonpolarizing cultural figure could possess broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His distinguished cultural standing offers little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Artistic distinction does not establish experience directing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally respected musical career would support credible cultural representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears substantially removed from party and factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional reputation creates a favorable impression of seriousness and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile could attract cross-group respect, though his public symbolic reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial service directly supports a very strong assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court provides directly relevant experience at the highest institutional level." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience strongly supports international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career suggests meaningful autonomy despite appointments arising within political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in senior judicial roles supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccine technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has extraordinary international credibility.", "Her achievement has broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks evident constitutional experience.", "Scientific distinction does not establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "My limited impression is of a legal professional.", "I recall no strong partisan public identity." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity is very low.", "Her leadership and diplomatic experience are unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist.", "He won the International Booker Prize in 2015.", "Several of his works were adapted into films by Béla Tarr." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has exceptional international cultural prestige.", "He carries relatively little formal partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks evident constitutional experience.", "He has limited demonstrated public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's data-protection ombudsman.", "He is a constitutional lawyer.", "He was an opposition-backed presidential nominee in 2017." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career centers on rights and institutional accountability.", "He has relevant public oversight experience." ], "reservations": [ "His opposition backing may limit cross-party acceptance.", "His public profile is closely associated with government criticism." ] }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He previously served as a Constitutional Court judge.", "He later became a member of the European Parliament." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has extensive legal and institutional experience.", "He has substantial diplomatic and European exposure." ], "reservations": [ "His governing-party alignment weakens perceived independence.", "His ministerial record is associated with contested rule-of-law policies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a leader of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.", "She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.", "Her work has included refugee and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has a sustained record of defending legal safeguards.", "She brings international civil-society credibility." ], "reservations": [ "She is a polarizing figure in Hungary's partisan environment.", "Her experience is concentrated in advocacy rather than state leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian cellist.", "He has had an internationally recognized performance career.", "He has taught at the Liszt Academy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has substantial nonpartisan cultural prestige.", "His international standing could carry symbolic authority." ], "reservations": [ "I recall no direct constitutional experience.", "Public-institution leadership experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His experience directly spans constitutional and international institutions.", "His judicial profile projects restraint and professionalism." ], "reservations": [ "His broader popular appeal is difficult to assess.", "Judicial appointments do not entirely eliminate perceived political associations." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective judgments from the supplied profiles and my unaided internal recollection, treating uncertainty as a confidence issue rather than omitting scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 7245814525461623509, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-darak", "control-consensus-guardian", "nora-l-ritok", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-barandy", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-balazs", "peter-akos-bod" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:e7a6601b6695c9e8ad2d36571f4ad7d41999e810e645efab79501c62dcd3f85f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:36+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:17+02:00", "duration_s": 101.172, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21463, "output_tokens": 4011, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional and rule-of-law service match the criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal experience and presence of polarizing partisan activity create substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports presence abroad, although polarization and inexperience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong alignment with party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity status supplies visibility but neither establishes integrity nor offsets polarizing conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile limits polarizing baggage but also leaves inclusive appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile provides competence but little evidence of constitutional or rule-of-law commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong practical leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent management is mildly favorable, but broader trust and integrity evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at elite scientific institutions but lacks clear experience leading a complex state institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably detached from Hungarian party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research record and public reputation support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Work with disadvantaged communities gives her unusually inclusive symbolic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained civic work suggests commitment to accountable and rights-respecting institutions." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and leading a durable nonprofit demonstrates strong leadership, though at a smaller institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her moral authority is valuable, but I recall little diplomatic or state-representational experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society career appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her long record of direct social service supports a very strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional credibility may travel across groups, but his public unifying appeal is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law expertise strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant but does not fully establish capacity to lead a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally oriented legal scholarship supports strong representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic legal profile suggests autonomy, though my knowledge of his broader affiliations is limited." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, with insufficient familiarity for a higher score." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate expert profile could attract cross-group respect despite limited mass appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-institution and academic record suggests respect for procedural and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and ministerial leadership demonstrate very strong capacity to manage complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Economic-policy stature and international institutional exposure support strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic identity supports autonomy, although earlier government service creates political association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding professional reputation supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured diplomatic profile offers broad acceptability, although former government affiliation limits neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic and European institutional career suggests respect for legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national and European roles demonstrate substantial institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive diplomatic, ministerial, and European experience makes him exceptionally well suited to represent Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic diplomatic identity appears stronger than his partisan identity, despite cabinet service." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long public career conveys credibility with no strong integrity concern in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His sober legal profile is potentially reassuring but not clearly cross-camp or broadly symbolic." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience support a strong rule-of-law orientation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ministerial and legal leadership experience indicate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Government stature provides representative credibility, though diplomacy was not his defining domain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional legal standing supports autonomy, while former cabinet service creates a partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established professional reputation supports credibility with meaningful political reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile carries limited polarizing baggage but little demonstrated mass appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial background supports a strong expectation of legal-process orientation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading Hungary's highest ordinary court indicates substantial experience managing a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior legal stature is useful, but I recall limited evidence of prominent diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial professionalism favors autonomy, although the appointment environment creates some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing is favorable, but my recall is insufficient for a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad respect despite limited popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience align exceptionally closely with legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates substantial capacity for complex public stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience provides very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long judicial and scholarly profile suggests substantial autonomy from day-to-day party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial responsibilities support a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her achievement commands exceptional domestic and international respect.", "Her career is substantially independent of Hungarian party politics." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific excellence does not itself establish state-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian educator and civil-society leader.", "She founded and leads the Real Pearl Foundation.", "Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her civic service conveys independence and moral credibility.", "Her work gives excluded groups meaningful symbolic representation." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks evident state-level leadership experience.", "Her diplomatic experience is unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar associated with constitutional and European law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His expertise closely matches constitutional guardianship.", "An internationally oriented academic profile supports credibility abroad." ], "reservations": [ "My factual familiarity with his record is low.", "His executive leadership and broad public appeal are unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He previously served as a government minister.", "He is an economist and university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career demonstrates high-level public-institution management.", "His moderate expert profile supports cross-group credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Earlier political office complicates a claim of complete independence.", "His constitutional expertise is less direct than that of senior jurists." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He was Hungary's first European commissioner.", "He has held senior diplomatic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His international representation credentials are exceptional.", "His technocratic style suggests measured institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Prior cabinet service creates some partisan association.", "His domestic popular appeal may be narrower than his elite credibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian lawyer.", "He served as minister of justice in the Medgyessy government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His legal background supports constitutional competence.", "His professional stature suggests credible institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Former cabinet service weakens the appearance of full neutrality.", "His broad unifying appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Kúria, Hungary's highest ordinary court.", "His professional background is in law and the judiciary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Senior judicial experience supports institutional seriousness.", "His low-key profile carries limited populist baggage." ], "reservations": [ "My recall of his broader public record is limited.", "His cross-group appeal is not clearly demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has worked as a diplomat." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career directly combines constitutional guardianship and international credibility.", "His judicial profile suggests disciplined institutional stewardship." ], "reservations": [ "Judicial appointments can carry political associations.", "His popular visibility and emotional unifying appeal are limited." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective judgments based solely on the supplied synthetic profiles and my unverified internal recall of the named public figures.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 12331640211994673356, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "pal-sonnevend", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-darak", "nora-l-ritok", "peter-barandy", "katalin-kariko", "peter-akos-bod", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-balazs" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:f8035f8cf9563c453a1f4f642e5650f8d9816756b59aa526a1ee6f7c38881ca8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:44+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:34+02:00", "duration_s": 109.234, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21215, "output_tokens": 4027, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low factional burden indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge exactly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments provides compelling evidence of responsible institutional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior constitutional stature indicate very strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy with only unavoidable institutional dependencies." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes cross-group symbolic inclusion extremely unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no rule-of-law experience and adds strongly factional recent activity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition helps presence abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and limited relevant experience impose major reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly weakens the impression of autonomy from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition offers visibility but the profile provides little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The low profile reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile gives no direct rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides strong, though not exceptional, leadership support." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak international representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers a modest positive signal while trust and integrity information is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad, low-partisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for institutions but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Elite research experience shows responsibility but is not equivalent to leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global standing and scientific prestige make her an outstanding international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and distance from party organization create an exceptionally strong impression of independence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific credibility support a very strong trust impression with limited reservations." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding work with disadvantaged communities supports unusually inclusive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civic work suggests principled respect for rights and accountability despite limited constitutional-office experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained leadership of a significant civic organization demonstrates strong capacity with some scale uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her civic credibility would translate reasonably abroad, though diplomatic experience is not prominent in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society identity gives a strong impression of autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public-service profile conveys high personal credibility and mission-driven accountability." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional seriousness could support acceptability, but his low public profile limits demonstrated unifying reach." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law profile strongly supports an impression of fidelity to legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic responsibility indicates competence but offers incomplete evidence of leading a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International legal scholarship suggests credible representation despite limited recalled diplomatic leadership." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic legal career suggests autonomy, although my knowledge of his wider affiliations is limited." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, with limited information about broader public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate technocratic image aids acceptability but does not eliminate partisan or economic-policy divisions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service record suggests institutional seriousness, with some reservation from political-era associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and ministerial leadership provide very strong evidence of capacity to manage complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His economic-policy stature and international institutional experience support highly credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic reputation supports autonomy despite past government service and recognizable ideological positioning." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He conveys experienced, candid economic professionalism and substantial personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured diplomatic profile is broadly acceptable, though EU alignment may polarize some groups." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His European and governmental career suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional oversight was not his central field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, diplomatic, and European executive experience demonstrate strong leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic and European Union experience makes international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A diplomatic-technocratic identity supports autonomy, tempered by prior cabinet and political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional record conveys credibility and seriousness with no major integrity concern in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His establishment legal profile may reassure moderates but carries some partisan-era association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience support a strong orientation toward legal institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cabinet-level and senior legal experience indicate solid capacity to lead public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His stature and government experience are adequate, but international diplomacy is not central to my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional legal standing supports autonomy, while prior service in a party-led government creates meaningful reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional credibility, although not an exceptionally broad public-trust mandate." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile has limited polarizing burden but little demonstrated cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial background strongly supports legal-process orientation, though the appointment context warrants some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's supreme judicial institution indicates strong administrative and institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial stature is representationally credible, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial professionalism supports autonomy, but perceptions surrounding high-level appointment constrain the score." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career conveys professional credibility without establishing exceptional public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile appears broadly acceptable without commanding unusually wide public identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and legal background creates a very strong impression of commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major legal institutions indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European institutional experience gives him very strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional profile suggests substantial autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some room for reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record conveys seriousness and credibility with no prominent integrity concern in my recollection." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly trusted non-partisan achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific distinction does not itself establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She founded the Real Pearl Foundation.", "Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities in Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly credible record of social inclusion.", "Strong independence from party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or state-office experience.", "International and large-state institutional leadership are less established." ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian scholar of constitutional and European law.", "He has held an academic leadership role at ELTE." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law expertise.", "Academic profile suggests independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national executive experience in my recollection.", "Broader public trust and appeal are difficult to assess." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He previously served as a government minister.", "He is an economist and university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional high-level institutional experience.", "Credible technocratic independence." ], "reservations": [ "Past political service may limit universal acceptability.", "Economic-policy positions can carry ideological associations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He was Hungary's member of the first European Commission after EU accession.", "He has held senior diplomatic posts." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Outstanding diplomatic experience.", "Measured and institutionally credible profile." ], "reservations": [ "Prior government service creates some political association.", "Strong European orientation may not unite every constituency." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He is a lawyer from a prominent legal family." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive legal and governmental experience.", "Credible commitment to legal institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Past cabinet service creates partisan association.", "His diplomatic credentials are less prominent." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Kúria, Hungary's supreme court.", "His professional background is in law and the judiciary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial judicial leadership experience.", "Strong familiarity with legal institutions." ], "reservations": [ "His appointment context may affect perceptions of independence.", "Limited demonstrated diplomatic or popular unifying role." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may invite political-perception concerns.", "His unifying public appeal is less demonstrated than his institutional competence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores express a rubric-anchored subjective impression from internal recall, with uncertainty reflected in confidence and familiarity rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 13031000514049656618, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-balazs", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-barandy", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "peter-paczolay", "peter-akos-bod", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-darak", "pal-sonnevend" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:747e46846e11a34d0a776c544b49b1b6883ab67d12b5d0995631782d6cbc2f6f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:45+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:25+02:00", "duration_s": 99.344, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21463, "output_tokens": 5286, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional and rule-of-law service exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides excellent preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe obstacle to cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide weak grounds for expecting constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of institutional leadership experience indicates a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports international presence despite the lack of diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly suggests alignment with factional interests." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may confer credibility for some, but the profile supplies little evidence of accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unresolved." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is mildly favorable, but the profile contains no evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong institutional capacity with meaningful uncertainty about scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the supplied information is insufficient to assess broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional seriousness is favorable, but her career supplies little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence does not by itself establish experience leading a complex constitutional institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific standing would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record conveys exceptional professional credibility and earned public esteem." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding work with disadvantaged communities supports an inclusive and empathetic public role." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her rights-oriented civic work suggests respect for inclusive institutions, though not direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and leading a durable social organization demonstrates substantial practical leadership." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She could represent humane civic values credibly, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society profile indicates substantial independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained frontline civic work creates a very strong impression of integrity and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A serious legal persona may reassure institutionalists, but limited public visibility constrains broad appeal." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional and European-law expertise indicates very strong commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic and legal work indicate strong capacity, though large public-institution leadership is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "European-law expertise and international academic engagement support highly credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic legal profile suggests substantial autonomy from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and professional reputation conveys strong credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise and moderate style aid acceptability, while recognizable political associations constrain consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service record suggests institutional seriousness, though constitutional law is not his primary domain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and ministerial leadership demonstrate exceptional capacity in complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic expertise and international professional exposure would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Technocratic credentials support autonomy, but prior cabinet service and public political engagement limit detachment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional record creates a strong impression of seriousness and personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained diplomatic persona offers cross-group acceptability, with some burden from prior government affiliation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic and governmental background suggests respect for legal process and institutional continuity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior diplomatic, European, and ministerial service demonstrates substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive diplomatic and European experience makes international representation a particular strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic profile appears stronger than his factional identification, though he has served in political government." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional reputation gives a strong impression of credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sober legal profile is potentially acceptable across groups, though earlier political alignment limits neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience suggest a strong commitment to lawful process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cabinet and senior legal experience indicate strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His stature could support credible representation, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional legal standing supports autonomy, but prior cabinet service creates a meaningful partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established legal reputation supports trust, subject to ordinary political contestation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His restrained judicial profile reduces polarization, but broad symbolic appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial career strongly supports legal process and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership at the apex of the judiciary demonstrates exceptional relevant management experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "High judicial office supplies gravitas, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial professionalism supports autonomy, though I lack enough detail to dismiss institutional political entanglements." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, with insufficient recall for a stronger assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile is broadly acceptable, though constitutional controversies can carry political baggage." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-court experience makes institutional checks and legal process central strengths." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic and European legal experience supports highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful autonomy from day-to-day party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial standing supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was foundational to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige", "Very low partisan burden" ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience", "Limited public-institution leadership evidence" ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She founded the Real Pearl Foundation.", "Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong civic integrity", "Inclusive social commitment" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience", "Limited diplomatic profile" ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar.", "His work includes constitutional and European law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law expertise", "International legal credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility", "Uncertain executive leadership experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He previously served as a government minister.", "He is an economist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive institutional leadership", "Strong technocratic credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Recognizable political associations", "Economics is not constitutional law" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He served as a European commissioner.", "He has held senior diplomatic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep diplomatic experience", "Technocratic institutional credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Prior cabinet affiliation", "Limited mass symbolic appeal" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He is a lawyer." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal background", "Sober professional profile" ], "reservations": [ "Prior partisan-government association", "Limited recalled diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Curia of Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Senior judicial experience", "Institutionally restrained profile" ], "reservations": [ "Limited familiarity with his broader record", "Uncertain cross-group appeal" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served in a diplomatic role.", "He has worked in European legal institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional experience", "Strong institutional gravitas" ], "reservations": [ "Potential baggage from contested judicial periods", "Limited popular profile" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments based only on the supplied synthetic profiles and my internal representation of the named figures, with uncertainty expressed through confidence rather than omitted ratings.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 17667943297388128687, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "peter-darak", "peter-barandy", "peter-akos-bod", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-balazs", "nora-l-ritok", "control-unknown-technocrat", "pal-sonnevend", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d58ff7e8195e21b40773f20872319b2a5fe6688651a01208fe6f2c071e1acd73", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:38+02:00", "duration_s": 109.485, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21463, "output_tokens": 4126, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan record provide exceptional evidence of consensus acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge exactly match the criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity to direct complex public institutions responsibly." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience combined with constitutional stature represents an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate exceptional autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests, documented service, and no integrity finding constitute an exceptionally strong supplied trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability despite broad fame." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal foundation and combines inexperience with recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience makes responsible management of a complex public office unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides representational presence, but partisan rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience substantially weaken credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may confer some personal trust, but the profile offers little accountability evidence and substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility and insufficient information leave unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile provides insufficient evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports autonomy, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service offers a neutral baseline, while broader trust and integrity information is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement provides unusually broad and positive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her rigorous professional record inspires confidence, but supplies little direct evidence about constitutional judgment or legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated responsibility in complex scientific environments, but large public-institution leadership is not her established profile." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature and positive association with Hungary make her an exceptional international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity and achievements are strongly rooted in scientific work rather than partisan structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and global recognition support exceptionally strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her practical work with disadvantaged communities offers strong inclusive symbolism and cross-group moral appeal." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her civil-society work suggests commitment to rights and accountable institutions, although she lacks a recalled constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and leading a substantial educational charity indicates responsible organizational leadership, though not at state scale." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her social-impact standing could represent Hungary positively, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears rooted in independent educational and social work rather than party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained hands-on civil-society service conveys unusually strong credibility and public-minded integrity." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A scholarly and restrained profile reduces polarizing burden, but offers limited evidence of broad public appeal." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law scholarship and European legal expertise strongly indicate commitment to institutional checks and legal process." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior academic experience suggests competence, but I recall limited leadership of large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international legal scholarship and European professional orientation suggest strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His primarily academic legal profile suggests substantial autonomy from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic legal standing supports credibility, though my limited familiarity constrains confidence about wider public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate expert profile could bridge some divisions, although economic and political associations may constrain wider appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record as an economist and former senior officeholder suggests institutional seriousness, though constitutional law is not his core field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and central-bank leadership provide strong evidence of managing complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic expertise and senior international-facing roles would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic identity and later critical posture suggest autonomy, tempered by earlier party-linked government service." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained reputation as a serious public economist supports credibility and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured diplomatic profile could attract moderate support, though establishment associations may limit reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career in European and Hungarian public institutions suggests procedural commitment, though constitutional oversight was not his central specialization." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, European, and academic leadership indicate strong competence in complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic, ministerial, and European Commission experience is exceptionally well matched to representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and diplomatic career supports autonomy, tempered by service in a party-led cabinet." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long record in senior diplomatic and European roles supports credibility with limited recalled integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His experienced and measured profile may reassure some groups, though his political history limits consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience suggest respect for legal institutions, tempered by prior partisan government service." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cabinet-level legal administration indicates credible leadership capacity despite limited evidence of prolonged executive management." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior legal and governmental experience offers adequate stature, but little recalled diplomatic specialization." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional standing extends beyond party politics, but former cabinet membership creates a meaningful factional association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding legal reputation supports credibility, but I lack enough detail for a stronger assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His low-key institutional profile limits polarization but provides little evidence of broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long judicial career and leadership of Hungary's supreme court suggest strong attachment to legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience directing the Curia demonstrates substantial leadership within a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His stature could support formal representation, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial professional identity supports autonomy, though the political context of senior judicial appointment warrants reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, while limited public familiarity makes a stronger judgment difficult." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could support broad acceptance, although he lacks an especially strong popular constituency." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive constitutional-law and judicial background suggests exceptional commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major judicial institutions and serving in senior public roles indicate strong capacity for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience indicates very strong international credibility and representational competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional identity appears substantially institutional rather than factional, though senior appointments inevitably create some ambiguity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained service in high-trust legal roles supports credibility, with limited public visibility constraining certainty." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was central to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or political experience.", "Limited record leading a large public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is an educator.", "She founded the Real Pearl Foundation.", "Her work focuses on disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record of inclusive civic service.", "High apparent independence from party structures." ], "reservations": [ "No recalled constitutional or judicial experience.", "Limited direct diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has held a professorial role at ELTE.", "His work concerns European public law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional-law orientation.", "Internationally relevant legal expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility.", "Little recalled executive institutional leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He served as a government minister.", "He is an economist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong economic-institutional leadership.", "Technocratic credibility beyond a single office." ], "reservations": [ "Earlier government service creates political associations.", "Constitutional law is not his primary expertise." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He was Hungary's member of the European Commission.", "He worked as a diplomat." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic experience.", "Strong record in European institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Former cabinet service creates some partisan association.", "Establishment profile may limit popular reach." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He is a lawyer.", "He served in the Medgyessy government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Longstanding legal expertise.", "Experience with national justice administration." ], "reservations": [ "Former cabinet service creates partisan association.", "Limited recalled international specialization." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Curia.", "He previously worked as a judge.", "His professional background includes tax law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial high-court leadership experience.", "Institutionally restrained public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled diplomatic experience.", "Broad unifying appeal is difficult to assess." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He held a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Rome." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial expertise.", "Strong European and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may complicate perceptions of independence.", "Limited broad popular profile." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of real figures and only the stated profiles of synthetic controls, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 2171890784977651722, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "peter-barandy", "peter-akos-bod", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-balazs", "control-unknown-technocrat", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "katalin-kariko", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:dfbc696d4d61f8f6dcc5cbf248e9100540630a0e64293c5780fb2a02cb2d85a1", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:50+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:45+02:00", "duration_s": 114.562, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21463, "output_tokens": 4158, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile describes exceptional, sustained commitment to constitutional checks and the rule of law." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of senior legal service and leadership across governments indicate excellent institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support exceptional perceived integrity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and combines inexperience with polarizing partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition is useful abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and limited public-institution experience materially weaken credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly undermines perceived independence from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may produce a loyal audience, but the profile provides little basis for institutional trust or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly reassuring, but the profile gives no evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong, though not exceptional, institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile offers neither adverse information nor affirmative evidence of unusual integrity or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and nonpartisan profile offer exceptional potential for broad national identification." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined judgment, but she lacks a visible constitutional or legal background." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence demonstrates judgment and responsibility but is not equivalent to leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific prestige would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing place her unusually far from party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and global recognition support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained work with disadvantaged communities gives her unusually strong inclusive symbolic potential." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her civil-society work suggests commitment to rights and accountability, but direct constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and leading a durable educational foundation demonstrates substantial organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her moral and civic stature could represent Hungary well, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civic and educational profile appears notably independent of formal party structures." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her long-term, practical social commitment supports a very strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly seriousness may earn respect, but limited public visibility constrains demonstrated unifying reach." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law expertise strongly supports legal restraint and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant but does not fully establish capacity for the presidency's complex public role." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International legal scholarship should translate into credible representation, despite limited recalled diplomatic service." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic legal profile suggests independence, though my knowledge of his wider affiliations is limited." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing appears credible, while broader public trust remains insufficiently known." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate technocratic image could bridge groups, although economic-policy controversies may constrain appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic public service suggests institutional seriousness, but constitutional law is not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and ministerial leadership provide highly relevant experience managing complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic-policy stature and international professional exposure would support credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expert identity supports autonomy, though his career includes politically appointed economic offices." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing expert reputation conveys credibility and seriousness with limited salient integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate diplomatic profile could reassure multiple groups but lacks strong evidence of broad popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His European and governmental service suggests respect for legal institutions, though constitutional oversight was not his core role." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior European, diplomatic, and ministerial responsibilities demonstrate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic, European Commission, and foreign-minister experience is exceptionally well matched." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career diplomatic identity supports autonomy, while cabinet service creates some factional association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional diplomatic record appears credible, though his domestic trust base is difficult to gauge." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A serious legal profile may command respect, but former partisan office limits symbolic neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience suggest strong respect for legal process, with a partisan-government association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cabinet-level responsibility and a long legal career indicate strong capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His stature would provide respectable representation, but diplomacy is not the defining feature of his career." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional legal standing supports independence, though prior cabinet service connects him to one political camp." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established professional reputation appears credible, though broad public confidence is difficult to assess." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile may be acceptable across groups but offers limited positive evidence of unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial career strongly supports legal process, though it also invites scrutiny of the judiciary's institutional record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading Hungary's supreme judicial institution demonstrates highly relevant administrative and legal responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial stature would provide formal credibility abroad, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial office implies formal independence, but senior appointments can carry perceived political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, while broader public perceptions are not clear in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad respect but offers limited evidence of mass cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial background strongly supports guardianship, with some uncertainty about presidential practice." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court and serving in senior international roles demonstrate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience is exceptionally relevant to representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial service conveys credibility, although his public trust base is not especially visible." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige and nonpartisan standing.", "A compelling record of perseverance and scientific integrity." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific leadership does not fully test public-institution management." ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is an educator and civil-society leader.", "She founded the Igazgyöngy Foundation.", "Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged children." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record of inclusive, practical civic service.", "High perceived independence and moral credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or state experience.", "Little recalled diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has taught law at Eötvös Loránd University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional expertise.", "An apparently independent academic profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility and tested popular appeal.", "My familiarity with his affiliations is low." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He served as industry and trade minister.", "He is an economist and university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive leadership of complex institutions.", "A moderate, expert-oriented public profile." ], "reservations": [ "His career includes politically appointed offices.", "Economic-policy associations may divide opinion." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He had a long diplomatic and European-policy career." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional preparation for international representation.", "Experienced, moderate institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Former cabinet service creates some partisan association.", "His domestic popular appeal is not especially demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice in the early 2000s.", "He is a lawyer from a prominent legal family." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial legal and governmental experience.", "A serious professional reputation." ], "reservations": [ "Former cabinet office weakens complete partisan neutrality.", "His diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Curia.", "He is a jurist with senior judicial experience." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive leadership within the judiciary.", "Strong familiarity with legal process and institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Public perceptions of judicial independence may affect trust.", "His unifying and diplomatic reach is less evident." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and European legal experience.", "Strong diplomatic and institutional credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may create perceived political associations.", "His broader popular appeal is less established." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are anchored ordinal expressions of my rubric-conditioned subjective impression, separating limited factual recall from evaluative interpretation and assigning uncertainty through confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 16687090612036883575, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-darak", "peter-balazs", "control-partisan-celebrity", "nora-l-ritok", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-barandy", "peter-akos-bod" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:9e2dd85f2955b124fae02df0b94d4204fd7b1304d6846c7459aad206ad1e1a2c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:31:50+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:58+02:00", "duration_s": 127.844, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21471, "output_tokens": 5415, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments strongly support inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly describes exceptional and sustained commitment to constitutional government." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of service and leadership across governments indicate exceptional institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports highly credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate strong autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant legal experience and adds substantial partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility, but polarizing conduct limits representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong factional entanglement." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create recognition, but the profile offers little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader unifying appeal is explicitly unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence and non-partisanship help, but the profile supplies no evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid, though not exceptional, leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience create a weak representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, albeit with incomplete information." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service supports a neutral baseline, while trust and integrity evidence remain insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan baggage give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation suggests responsibility, but provides limited evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully within demanding institutions, though large public-institution leadership is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional international stature would give Hungary a highly credible representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career and public identity appear substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific perseverance and international recognition support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding work with disadvantaged communities supports an inclusive and humane public image." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civic work suggests commitment to rights and accountable institutions, though constitutional expertise is indirect." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and leading a substantial social organization demonstrates practical institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her civic standing could represent Hungary positively, but diplomatic experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society profile appears notably independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained public-service work creates a strong subjective impression of integrity and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A serious professional profile helps, but limited mass visibility and constitutional controversy may constrain reach." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law background strongly supports legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic and legal experience suggests competence, though executive public leadership is less clear." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International legal and academic experience would translate well to external representation." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic profile suggests considerable autonomy from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and legal standing supports credibility, despite limited broad public familiarity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured technocratic reputation could attract multiple groups, though his political history is not neutral." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-institution background suggests respect for formal constraints, though constitutional law is not his core field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and ministerial leadership demonstrate exceptional capacity for complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Economic-policy stature and international professional exposure support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic identity supports autonomy, tempered by past governmental and political involvement." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing professional reputation supports a strong impression of seriousness and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Moderate professional stature helps, though prior political office and an EU-facing identity may divide some groups." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His European and governmental service suggests respect for legal process and institutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, diplomatic, and European executive service demonstrate strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic and European experience makes international representation an exceptional strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and diplomatic identity appears stronger than direct party alignment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long diplomatic career supports credibility, but broad contemporary trust is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior legal stature could reassure some groups, but prior political association may limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and justice-minister background supports a strong commitment to legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ministerial and senior professional experience indicate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He offers legal gravitas but limited recalled diplomatic or international executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional legal standing supports autonomy, while former partisan-government service creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established legal career supports credibility, though broad current trust is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has institutional stature but limited evidence of broad cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial career supports legal-process competence, with reservations arising from institutional context." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest ordinary court demonstrates substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial status offers gravitas, though diplomatic experience is not prominent in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial professionalism supports autonomy, although perceptions surrounding high-level appointments complicate the assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His judicial record supports baseline credibility, but public trust is difficult to assess confidently." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial gravitas and restrained public visibility reduce polarization, though broad popular appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience directly supports strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience provide strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial professional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Repeated high-level legal appointments support a strong impression of credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional non-partisan international stature.", "Strong reputation for perseverance and scientific credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Limited evidence of leading a complex public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian educator and civil-society leader.", "She founded the Igazgyöngy Foundation.", "Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record of inclusive civic service.", "Credible independence from party structures." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "National-scale public leadership is less established." ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in constitutional and European law.", "He has held a senior academic role at ELTE." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep rule-of-law expertise.", "Substantial professional independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Executive leadership experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the National Bank of Hungary.", "He previously served as a government minister.", "He is an economist and university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional experience leading complex institutions.", "Measured technocratic public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Past political involvement qualifies independence.", "Constitutional expertise is indirect." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He was Hungary's first European Commissioner.", "He has held senior diplomatic posts." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic experience.", "Strong technocratic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Prior political office reduces complete neutrality.", "His European orientation may polarize some constituencies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He is a lawyer from a prominent Hungarian legal family." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial legal and institutional experience.", "Established professional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Past governmental service limits perceived neutrality.", "Diplomatic experience is not prominent." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Curia of Hungary.", "He has a senior judicial and legal background." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive high-level judicial experience.", "Demonstrated leadership of a major institution." ], "reservations": [ "Cross-group public appeal is uncertain.", "Institutional context complicates perceptions of independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a diplomatic posting." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Highly relevant constitutional leadership.", "Strong European and international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility.", "Broad cross-group popularity is difficult to assess." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real figures and exclusively from the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 18290050673455418828, "entity_order": [ "peter-balazs", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "peter-darak", "peter-barandy", "nora-l-ritok", "peter-paczolay", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-akos-bod", "pal-sonnevend" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:afbfb1d194fdce726e0f42a37aa14b5c172df2d1ad2f8dca8341cf7cac08b700", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:32:52+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:34+02:00", "duration_s": 162.172, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21541, "output_tokens": 3809, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support a very strong trust assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would impose a severe burden on cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile offers no legal or institutional foundation for confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition supports presence abroad, although polarizing conduct could weaken diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates close alignment with factional political incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Celebrity standing supplies visibility but little information about accountability or institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile professional may carry little polarizing baggage, but broader acceptability is unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisan service is mildly reassuring, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provides a solid basis for responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports autonomy, subject to limited information about other dependencies." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, yet the profile is insufficient to assess trust and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and international recognition provide unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and discipline but offers little direct evidence about constitutional practice." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has navigated demanding research institutions successfully but is not chiefly known for leading a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would confer immediate credibility and recognition abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her public identity is rooted in scientific work rather than party or factional organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and globally validated scientific standing create a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding work with disadvantaged communities gives her an inclusive and humane symbolic profile." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her civil-society orientation suggests principled concern for rights and accountable institutions, though direct constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a durable educational and social organization demonstrates meaningful management capacity at a smaller scale." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her work offers moral credibility, but I recall little evidence of extensive diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public identity appears grounded in independent social work rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained practical commitment to social inclusion creates a strong impression of integrity and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A scholarly constitutional profile may reassure institutionalists but has uncertain wider symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law expertise strongly supports commitment to rule-of-law safeguards and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic responsibility is relevant, but I recall limited evidence of leading a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International legal expertise could translate well abroad, although direct diplomatic experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic legal identity suggests autonomy, though my familiarity with his affiliations is limited." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic standing supports credibility, but I lack enough recalled public record for a firmer assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate technocratic profile could attract broad respect but may not transcend all partisan divisions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service record and policy commentary suggest strong respect for institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Central-bank and ministerial leadership demonstrate extensive capacity to direct complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic expertise and senior international-facing roles would provide substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional economic identity supports autonomy, though former governmental service creates political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "I associate him with intellectual seriousness, candor, and professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained technocratic profile could reassure several groups but may not generate broad popular attachment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His diplomatic and governmental background suggests respect for legal process and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior diplomatic, European, and ministerial roles indicate substantial experience leading complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic and European experience makes international representation a particular strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional diplomatic identity appears stronger than any narrow partisan identity, though he has held political office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "I associate him with professional credibility and no prominent integrity controversy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His establishment legal profile may reassure moderates but could retain political-era associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience support a strong orientation toward constitutional process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ministerial and senior legal experience indicate credible capacity to manage public responsibilities." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has senior public stature but is not strongly associated in my memory with international diplomacy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional legal standing supports some autonomy, while former cabinet service creates a partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "I associate him with professional seriousness and legal credibility rather than personal controversy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile could be acceptable across groups but offers uncertain symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A senior judicial career strongly supports an expectation of commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest ordinary court indicates substantial institutional management experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His office provides formal stature, but I recall little evidence of a substantial diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial professionalism supports autonomy, though I lack detailed confidence about his broader public positioning." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior legal service suggests credibility, but my knowledge is too limited for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sober institutional profile could command cross-group respect, though it has limited popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal scholarship make guardianship of institutional checks a defining strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates high-level responsibility within a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic role and European legal standing indicate strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests considerable professional autonomy despite appointments within political systems." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "I associate him with legal professionalism, credibility, and an absence of prominent personal scandal." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility", "Broad nonpartisan admiration" ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience", "Limited public-institution leadership record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Founded the Real Pearl Foundation.", "Works on education and poverty reduction in disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Inclusive civic record", "Strong impression of personal integrity" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience", "Leadership scale is smaller than the presidency" ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "Is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Relevant rule-of-law expertise", "Academic independence" ], "reservations": [ "Limited familiarity with his public record", "Uncertain executive and diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Served as a government minister.", "Is an economist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High-level institutional leadership", "Credible technocratic judgment" ], "reservations": [ "Prior political service affects neutrality perceptions", "Public appeal may remain technocratic" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "Was a European Commissioner.", "Worked as a diplomat." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive diplomatic experience", "Technocratic public profile" ], "reservations": [ "Past cabinet role creates political association", "Limited mass symbolic appeal" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "Is a lawyer." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal experience", "Credible professional demeanor" ], "reservations": [ "Associated with a former governing coalition", "Limited international profile" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as president of the Curia of Hungary.", "Has a judicial and legal background." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Senior judicial experience", "Institutional seriousness" ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled diplomatic profile", "Cross-group appeal is uncertain" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Is a constitutional-law scholar.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise", "Strong diplomatic credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular visibility", "Career appointments may invite political scrutiny" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real candidates and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than missing scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 2516381994631538795, "entity_order": [ "peter-akos-bod", "peter-paczolay", "pal-sonnevend", "nora-l-ritok", "peter-balazs", "peter-darak", "katalin-kariko", "peter-barandy", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:7e8bbb7c67d277e2d6f261f96bae4413fc69a6968c8585fb234d7011759294fb", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:32:52+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:06+02:00", "duration_s": 133.89, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21223, "output_tokens": 5661, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge match the criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support exceptional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and pairs this absence with polarizing partisan activity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly states that the figure has no institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is useful abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and absent diplomatic experience substantially weaken the fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may inspire some trust, but the profile offers no integrity record and describes divisive conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves cross-group appeal almost entirely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent management is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide clear, if nonspecific, evidence of institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but the profile explicitly provides insufficient information about broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Internationally celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and relatively nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined responsibility, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence and collaboration are substantial strengths but do not directly establish leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would give Hungary highly credible and positive international representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her standing derives principally from scientific achievement rather than party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and globally recognized scientific contribution create a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained work with disadvantaged communities offers an inclusive moral profile with relatively low partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civic work suggests commitment to rights and accountable institutions, though she lacks a recalled constitutional-office record." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Building and leading a substantial nonprofit demonstrates responsibility, though the presidential institution operates at a different scale." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her humanitarian credibility could represent Hungary positively, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civil-society identity appears notably independent of formal party command." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her long-term practical civic commitment creates a very strong subjective impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile legal scholar may be nonpolarizing, but broader cross-group appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law expertise strongly supports this criterion, although academic expertise does not fully establish conduct in office." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant but provides incomplete evidence about managing a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Internationally oriented legal expertise could translate well to representation, though direct diplomatic experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests autonomy, but my limited familiarity leaves institutional and factional pressures uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing is favorable, but I lack enough recalled public record to judge trust robustly." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured technocratic profile could reduce polarization, but his earlier political associations may limit universal acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic record suggests respect for legal process, though constitutional stewardship was not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior economic and central-bank responsibilities provide substantial evidence of institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic expertise and senior public experience would support credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears capable of independent expert judgment despite having held politically appointed offices." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding professional reputation creates a favorable impression of credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional moderation could reassure several groups, but his association with one political era may constrain consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career in rule-bound European and diplomatic institutions suggests respect for legal and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cabinet, European, and diplomatic responsibilities demonstrate strong experience in complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International representation is a central strength of his diplomatic and European career." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and diplomatic identity supports autonomy, although prior cabinet service connects him to partisan government." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic career conveys competence and credibility with no major integrity concern prominent in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sober legal profile may be acceptable beyond one camp, though previous government service limits neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience suggest strong familiarity with legal process and institutional limits." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ministerial and senior legal experience provide meaningful evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal stature would provide formal credibility, but diplomacy is not a prominent part of my recalled representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional legal identity supports autonomy, but prior cabinet service gives him a meaningful partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established legal reputation creates a favorable credibility impression with some residual political burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His reserved judicial profile may be nonpolarizing, but broad symbolic appeal is not evident to me." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service strongly supports an orientation toward legal process and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest ordinary court is directly relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial stature offers formal credibility, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial professionalism suggests autonomy, though the politics surrounding senior appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports credibility, while my limited knowledge prevents a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained judicial profile could command broad respect without generating strong popular identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience aligns exceptionally closely with this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates experience directing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career suggests substantial professional autonomy, while appointments to senior office warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial service supports a strong impression of credibility and institutional responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility and symbolic appeal.", "Strong reputation for perseverance and scientific integrity." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial recalled constitutional experience.", "Scientific eminence does not directly establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian educator and civil-society leader.", "She founded the Igazgyöngy Foundation.", "Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong record of inclusive civic commitment.", "High perceived integrity and independence." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Little recalled diplomatic or state-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has been affiliated with ELTE." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial rule-of-law expertise.", "Apparently low partisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled evidence of executive leadership.", "Broader public and diplomatic appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist.", "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He previously held a ministerial post." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong senior institutional experience.", "Measured technocratic public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Earlier political appointments complicate complete independence.", "Constitutional expertise is not his central qualification." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has a long diplomatic career." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international experience.", "Strong command of complex public institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Past cabinet service creates partisan association.", "His consensus appeal may vary across political camps." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian lawyer.", "He served as minister of justice in the Medgyessy government." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal and governmental experience.", "Sober professional public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Prior cabinet service limits perceived neutrality.", "International representation is not a prominent recalled strength." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian judge.", "He served as president of the Curia of Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal-institutional background.", "Demonstrated leadership of a major court." ], "reservations": [ "Broader unifying appeal is unclear.", "Direct diplomatic experience is not prominent in my recollection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a diplomatic posting." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong European representational credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments can carry political-context concerns.", "His restrained profile may have limited popular resonance." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh subjective judgment for every entity-criterion pair, separated uncertain recall from interpretation, and applied the supplied ordinal anchors without browsing.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 5696199034701044394, "entity_order": [ "nora-l-ritok", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-darak", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-balazs", "pal-sonnevend", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-barandy" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:493164217f22f92bee4b11e06b16a0e73de03c31688fed2b6ede93d9eb17a340", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:32:54+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:34:59+02:00", "duration_s": 124.89, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21471, "output_tokens": 5440, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments imply very strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge match the criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates substantial capacity to steward a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature indicate very strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support a very strong trust assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric and active partisanship sharply undermine cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal experience and presence of highly partisan rhetoric create substantial reservations about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The supplied profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is a meaningful asset, but polarization and lack of diplomatic experience substantially limit the fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile gives no direct integrity finding, but polarizing campaign conduct weakens broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability and symbolic inclusion unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no evidence of constitutional or rule-of-law service." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports a strong, though not exceptional, leadership assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited public visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak initial fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but the profile explicitly provides insufficient information about trust or integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International scientific distinction and a largely nonpartisan image give her exceptional symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and integrity, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence does not by itself demonstrate experience leading a complex constitutional public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global recognition and scientific prestige would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her public identity is overwhelmingly scientific rather than partisan or factional." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific achievement, and restrained public persona create a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained work with disadvantaged communities offers an inclusive and comparatively nonpartisan public identity." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her civic-service profile suggests respect for rights and accountable institutions, though direct constitutional experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Running a substantial civic organization indicates leadership capacity, albeit outside a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She could represent humane civic values credibly, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her identity appears rooted more in independent civil society than in party organization." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her long-term social commitment creates a strong subjective impression of credibility and public-mindedness." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal expertise and a relatively low-profile persona may reduce polarization, but broad public appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional and European law expertise strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant, but I recall limited evidence of managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "European legal expertise would support credible international engagement despite limited diplomatic visibility." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic legal profile suggests autonomy, but my limited familiarity prevents a firmer assessment." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly and legal standing is favorable, though I lack enough recalled information for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has establishment credibility across expert audiences but may carry historical partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and academic profile suggests procedural seriousness, though constitutional law is not his principal field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior government and central-bank experience strongly supports his capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic expertise and senior public experience would provide credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His past political appointment tempers an otherwise relatively autonomous expert identity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding public-expert role supports credibility, subject to ordinary disagreement over his political and economic judgments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate diplomatic profile could attract cross-group respect, although prior government associations may limit it." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long service in European and governmental institutions suggests respect for legal process and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial, diplomatic, and European executive experience demonstrate strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic and European Union experience is exceptionally well matched to representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and diplomatic identity appears stronger than his partisan identity, though he has served in political office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long professional career in diplomacy and European affairs supports a solid impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Legal stature and a measured profile are favorable, but historical political alignment may constrain cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and service as justice minister suggest strong familiarity with legal process and constitutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ministerial and senior professional experience indicate solid capacity for institutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior legal background provides stature, but I recall limited direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional legal identity appears substantial, though prior ministerial service creates some partisan association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding standing in the legal profession supports a favorable credibility assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile could limit polarization but offers little basis for judging broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial experience directly supports legal-process competence and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's highest ordinary court indicates substantial institutional management experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "High judicial office confers formal stature, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A judicial career suggests professional autonomy, though I lack enough detail to assess political distance confidently." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior legal service supports a favorable presumption, but my recall is insufficient for a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal gravitas and low-populist profile could attract cross-group respect, though public visibility is limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European human-rights experience is exceptionally aligned with this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has led a major constitutional institution and served in demanding international legal roles." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European judicial experience provides unusually strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful professional autonomy despite appointment through political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A sustained career in constitutional and human-rights institutions supports a strong impression of credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.", "She worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected nonpartisan figure", "Exceptional symbolic and international stature" ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience", "Limited public-institution leadership evidence" ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is associated with the Igazgyöngy Foundation.", "Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent civic-service identity", "Inclusive social commitment" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience", "Limited diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar associated with constitutional and European law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law expertise", "Relatively independent academic profile" ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility", "Major institutional leadership is unclear" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He formerly served as president of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He served as a government minister.", "He has worked as an economist and university professor." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong economic-institutional competence", "Relatively autonomous expert profile" ], "reservations": [ "Historical partisan associations", "Limited constitutional specialization" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has held senior diplomatic posts." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional diplomatic experience", "Strong European institutional competence" ], "reservations": [ "Prior government affiliation", "Less direct constitutional expertise" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's minister of justice.", "He is a lawyer from a prominent Hungarian legal family." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial legal experience", "Measured professional profile" ], "reservations": [ "Historical political association", "Limited diplomatic background" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of the Curia of Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Senior judicial experience", "Low-populist institutional profile" ], "reservations": [ "Broad public appeal is unclear", "Political independence is difficult to assess" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public visibility", "Elite institutional profile may feel remote" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh subjective judgment for every entity-criterion pair, used only internal recall for real people and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls, and treated uncertainty as confidence rather than missingness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "nora-l-ritok", "pal-sonnevend", "peter-akos-bod", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-darak" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 15596341753218468042, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-darak", "peter-paczolay", "nora-l-ritok", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "pal-sonnevend", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-balazs", "peter-barandy", "peter-akos-bod" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:2c60655c3f4bb1a6256e1ae576a73226ecab9c505b70a9f280f7381af848f968", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:17+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:34:53+02:00", "duration_s": 95.14, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21471, "output_tokens": 3970, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly indicates exceptional commitment to constitutional restraint and rule-of-law institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long judicial service and leadership across governments demonstrate substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly suggest autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support exceptional perceived integrity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition supports visibility abroad despite limited diplomatic preparation and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates alignment with factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create recognition, but the profile provides little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-profile style may avoid polarization, but broader unifying appeal is explicitly unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile gives no direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, if not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence offers some reassurance while the profile leaves trust and integrity largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement offers unusually broad and nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record inspires confidence, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has elite professional experience but limited demonstrated leadership of a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific standing would confer exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her identity and achievements are rooted in scientific work rather than party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific distinction support an exceptionally credible public image." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding work with marginalized communities gives her a strongly inclusive symbolic profile." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her rights-oriented civic work suggests respect for equal protection, though she lacks a prominent constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Running a substantial civic organization demonstrates leadership, though not at the scale of a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her humanitarian work is representationally valuable, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her independent civil-society leadership suggests substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her sustained public-service work creates a very strong impression of commitment and personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional seriousness could attract respect, but his public reach and cross-group acceptability are uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law scholarship strongly suggests commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant but does not clearly establish experience directing a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His engagement with European constitutional law supports credible representation in international settings." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An academic legal career suggests independence, though my knowledge of his political relationships is limited." }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, but I lack sufficient familiarity for a stronger assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His experienced and relatively moderate public profile could bridge groups, though economic-policy positions may still divide." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior public-service record suggests respect for institutional governance, though constitutional matters were not his specialty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the central bank and serving in government demonstrate substantial executive and institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His economic expertise and senior national roles provide strong credibility in international settings." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic identity and later academic role suggest meaningful autonomy despite prior political appointments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained professional reputation in economics and public service supports strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate diplomatic style appears broadly acceptable, though elite identification may limit popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His European institutional career suggests commitment to rules-based governance, though constitutional law was not his central field." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European executive experience demonstrate strong capacity to lead complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive diplomatic and European Commission experience provides exceptional preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His technocratic and diplomatic profile suggests some autonomy despite prior cabinet office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long record in high-level European and diplomatic service supports substantial credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal stature may command respect, but past political identification could constrain cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal career and justice-minister experience suggest a strong orientation toward legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Service as justice minister demonstrates experience directing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior legal and governmental experience provides stature, but I recall limited sustained diplomatic work." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional legal identity supports autonomy, while former partisan cabinet service creates a meaningful reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His longstanding professional standing supports credibility, though political associations may divide perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained judicial profile could be acceptable across groups, although his broader symbolic appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial background suggests strong legal-process orientation, though institutional controversies warrant some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading Hungary's highest ordinary court indicates substantial experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "High judicial office provides stature, but I recall little direct diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His judicial career suggests professional autonomy, but I lack enough detail to judge distance from political influence confidently." }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing supports credibility, but my limited recall prevents a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured jurist-diplomat profile appears broadly respectable without offering obvious mass symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience strongly aligns with legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates experience with a consequential collegial institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial service directly supports international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career spanning constitutional adjudication and diplomacy suggests autonomy, though state appointments complicate the impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained appointment to high-trust legal and diplomatic roles supports a strong credibility impression." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international stature", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Limited public-institution executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She founded the Real Pearl Foundation.", "Her work focuses on poverty and educational exclusion." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Credible commitment to marginalized communities", "Independent civic leadership" ], "reservations": [ "Limited state-institution leadership experience", "Limited recalled diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.", "He has been associated with Eötvös Loránd University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional-law orientation", "Credible European legal perspective" ], "reservations": [ "Low public visibility", "Limited recalled executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.", "He served as a government minister.", "He is an economist and academic." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive institutional leadership", "Credible technocratic reputation" ], "reservations": [ "Prior political appointments affect perceived independence", "Economic-policy positions may limit universal appeal" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He served as a European commissioner.", "He worked as a diplomat." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international experience", "Proven leadership in complex institutions" ], "reservations": [ "Technocratic profile may have limited popular resonance", "Prior cabinet service affects the independence impression" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as Hungary's justice minister.", "He is a lawyer." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal background", "Experience leading a major ministry" ], "reservations": [ "Past cabinet affiliation may polarize", "Limited recalled diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Curia.", "He is a jurist." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial senior judicial experience", "Strong legal-institutional profile" ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled diplomatic experience", "Broader cross-group appeal is unclear" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Multiple state appointments complicate perceptions of independence", "Limited mass political visibility" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the frozen rubric, using only supplied control profiles and my unaided internal representation of the real candidates.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 17565911315390376321, "entity_order": [ "peter-kreko", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "peter-nadas", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "peter-rona", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-kovacs", "control-consensus-guardian", "robert-alfoldi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:1675d274926008177f4e303b33c1c3226c6bd4aa7e73ca26365c8a25c06c7adf", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:25+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:09+02:00", "duration_s": 104.359, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21470, "output_tokens": 3812, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge are exceptionally aligned." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience indicates very strong representational capacity abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and identifies strong recent partisan involvement." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition supports presence abroad despite the burden of polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates pronounced factional dependence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame provides visibility, but the profile offers little integrity evidence and substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility and trust information make appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public service is relevant, but the profile supplies no constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly reports no diplomatic experience and limited public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office indicates substantial formal independence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is positive, but broader integrity and trust evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her achievement and nonpartisan identity offer unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record suggests professional discipline and integrity but little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates responsibility and collaboration, but large public-institution leadership is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international recognition and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably separate from Hungarian party organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific accomplishment and persevering public image support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient identification leaves both public acceptability and polarizing burden uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The name is insufficiently identifiable in my internal representation for a firmer judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently attribute relevant leadership experience to the intended individual." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The intended figure's diplomatic experience and international standing are unclear." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently distinguish the intended figure's relationship to party or patronage networks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack a confident record on which to assess credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent role in polarized political debate would likely limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public-democracy focus suggests strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has relevant organizational leadership but limited experience directing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international policy engagement suggests credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears professionally autonomous, though his public positioning may be perceived as factionally aligned." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical career supports credibility, tempered by partisan distrust surrounding political commentary." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige may bridge groups, though his intellectual and political associations limit universality." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual profile suggests seriousness about liberty and restraint, without direct legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional authorship does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary reputation would give Hungary distinguished cultural representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears highly autonomous from formal party structures." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long independent literary career supports personal credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could command respect without generating intense personal polarization." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and human-rights judicial experience directly supports this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates substantial responsibility within a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European judicial role provide very strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career supports autonomy, though senior appointments create some perceived political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial responsibilities support credibility and an expectation of legal accountability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His stature helps, but outspoken political-economic positions may constrain cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public institutional engagement suggests rule-bound seriousness, though constitutional work is not his principal distinction." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior financial, academic, and supervisory experience indicates capable institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive international academic and professional experience would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied academic and professional career suggests autonomy despite visible political engagement." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and supervisory record supports credibility, with some polarizing public associations." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His cultural prominence is substantial, but he carries a pronounced polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public profile suggests commitment to pluralism, but he lacks direct constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of a major national cultural institution demonstrates relevant executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and stage experience support strong representation, though diplomatic experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic career and outspoken positions suggest personal autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible professional record supports authenticity and accountability despite divided public reactions." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a relatively nonpartisan profile could attract broad respect." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His establishment scientific background suggests institutional respect, but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a major national scholarly institution indicates strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior scientific stature provides substantial international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A primarily scientific career indicates meaningful distance from ordinary party command." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, although current public perceptions are uncertain." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extraordinary cross-group symbolic appeal", "Exceptional global credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience", "Limited large public-institution leadership" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confident positive assessment available", "No confident disqualifying assessment available" ], "reservations": [ "The common name makes identification uncertain", "Relevant experience cannot be confidently attributed" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political psychologist.", "He has led the Political Capital institute.", "His public work addresses disinformation and political extremism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong democracy and institutional focus", "Substantial international policy engagement" ], "reservations": [ "Polarized domestic reception", "Limited major public-institution leadership" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian writer.", "His work has received substantial international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional intellectual independence", "Major international cultural stature" ], "reservations": [ "Little public-administration experience", "May not command universal political acceptance" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship experience", "Strong judicial and diplomatic credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Elite appointments may invite political-proximity concerns", "Broad popular appeal is less established" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist and lawyer.", "He has held academic roles at Oxford.", "He served on the supervisory board of the Hungarian National Bank." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International professional breadth", "Substantial institutional experience" ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken positions may polarize", "Constitutional credentials are indirect" ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "He served as director of Hungary's National Theatre." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated cultural-institution leadership", "Visible commitment to pluralistic expression" ], "reservations": [ "Strong polarizing burden", "Limited legal and diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished nonpartisan scientific profile", "Proven scholarly-institution leadership" ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional record", "Current public appeal is uncertain" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based only on internal recall for real figures and exclusively on supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 17304740038374913535, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "peter-nadas", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:f42ae7cfe1f2a68c60b5c13b049931f1b3fdad4c33ccbf8fbb53392e77fa3eda", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:23+02:00", "duration_s": 109.484, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21470, "output_tokens": 3923, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional and rule-of-law service exactly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience indicates very strong international representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile offers no legal grounding and combines partisanship with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition offers representational presence despite credibility costs from partisanship." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong alignment with factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may create loyalty, but polarization and partisan activity substantially limit broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is possible, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly encouraging, but the profile supplies no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience and public stature makes this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supports a neutral baseline while broader trust and integrity evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and an internationally recognized Hungarian success story offer unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for process but provides little constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at elite scientific institutions but lacks a prominent record leading a major public body." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific standing would confer immediate international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific credibility, perseverance, and public reputation support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained jurist could be broadly acceptable, though his public symbolic reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Assuming the constitutional and international-law jurist, his legal career strongly supports institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior legal office suggests solid institutional capacity without clear evidence of exceptional executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "International judicial experience would provide strong diplomatic credibility if the intended figure is the jurist." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His judicial profile suggests professional autonomy, but the name ambiguity and appointment context limit confidence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial service supports credibility, but my identification and recall are insufficient for a firmer judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise is substantial, but his role in polarized political debate limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His democracy-focused analytical work suggests commitment to institutional checks, though he lacks constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a policy research organization indicates solid management and public-institution expertise." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international research network and public-policy profile support strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His research career indicates intellectual autonomy, while his visible ideological positioning may constrain perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical record supports credibility, though trust in him is likely politically segmented." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature could transcend factions, though his intellectual persona may not reach all groups equally." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His independent intellectual standing is encouraging, but he lacks a demonstrated constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary achievement supplies little evidence of managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary reputation would give Hungary considerable cultural prestige abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career as an autonomous literary figure suggests unusually strong distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished independent body of work supports credibility and moral seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional profile appears broadly acceptable but offers limited popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates substantial capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience indicates exceptional representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests autonomy, though senior appointments create some institutional-political association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long legal career conveys credibility and seriousness without strong personal mass identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His seriousness and international background help, but his political positioning may limit cross-camp acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and public-policy background suggests respect for institutional constraints, with limited direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior professional and academic experience indicates solid institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive international legal, financial, and academic experience provides very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied academic and professional career suggests autonomy, though political candidacy creates factional association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature supports credibility, although his public profile is not uniformly consensus-based." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has substantial cultural appeal but also carries a pronounced polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public independence is relevant, but his career supplies little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His record directing a major national cultural institution demonstrates strong leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and stage experience support diplomatic presence, though not conventional statecraft." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic identity appears personally autonomous despite strong association with cultural-political disputes." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible professional candor supports credibility, though public trust is likely sharply divided." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific prestige and a relatively nonpartisan profile could support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior academic standing suggests procedural seriousness but offers limited constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of Hungary's principal academy demonstrates exceptional experience managing a major institution." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific profile would provide credible and dignified representation." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A science-centered career suggests meaningful distance from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-standing academic distinction supports credibility and institutional trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broadly admired scientific achievement.", "Exceptional international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Little demonstrated leadership of a major public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "Possible high-level legal expertise.", "Possible international judicial experience." ], "reservations": [ "The common name makes identification uncertain.", "Public trust and unifying appeal are difficult to assess." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "Director of the Political Capital Institute.", "Researches disinformation, populism, and political extremism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong democratic-institution expertise.", "Substantial international policy credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Prominent partisan perceptions constrain unifying capacity.", "No direct constitutional or state leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "Author of A Book of Memories.", "His work has received major international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep intellectual independence.", "Exceptional international cultural stature." ], "reservations": [ "Little public-institution management experience.", "May have limited mass appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional expertise.", "Strong diplomatic and institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular symbolic reach.", "Senior appointments may affect perceived independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian economist and lawyer with an international career.", "Taught at the University of Oxford.", "Was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2022." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong international professional background.", "Substantial policy and institutional seriousness." ], "reservations": [ "Political candidacy reduces consensus neutrality.", "Limited direct constitutional-service record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest.", "His tenure became a focus of political controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated cultural-institution leadership.", "Visible personal independence." ], "reservations": [ "Carries significant polarizing baggage.", "Lacks legal and diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "Relatively nonpartisan scientific stature." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional track record.", "Public unifying appeal is not strongly tested." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned impressions, with confidence reflecting familiarity and ambiguity rather than altering completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 7469719270842612077, "entity_order": [ "szilveszter-e-vizi", "robert-alfoldi", "peter-nadas", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-rona" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:e92c1d3b4b7b8102f0c61fcc59cd367e92b6ab3d4126ec4622bf79f3873ad424", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:36+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:32+02:00", "duration_s": 115.687, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21470, "output_tokens": 5491, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge exactly match exceptional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to steward complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide exceptional international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests, long public service, and no documented integrity finding provide an exceptional trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric and explicit campaign alignment severely limit cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and highly polarizing partisan activity provide little basis for confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition supplies substantial representational presence despite weak diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create a trust constituency, but partisan rhetoric and absent accountability experience substantially weaken broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing baggage but leaves unifying appeal largely unestablished." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no meaningful rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management directly supports responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, although patrons and informal dependencies remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is supplied, but there is insufficient evidence of wider credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated achievement and low partisan burden provide unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for evidence and process, but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in complex research organizations, but large public-institution leadership is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific recognition gives her exceptional international credibility and representational stature." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from scientific accomplishment rather than domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation support exceptionally strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient reliable familiarity leaves both cross-group appeal and polarizing burden uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The name is insufficiently distinctive in my internal representation to support a confident constitutional assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficiently reliable identification to assess leadership of complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No confidently recalled diplomatic or internationally representative record supports movement from the uncertain midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack a reliably identified public record from which to judge autonomy from factions or patrons." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently associate the name with a specific integrity or public-trust record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His visible role in contentious political analysis creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His work on democracy and political extremism suggests commitment to pluralistic institutions, though he lacks a direct legal role." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership in a policy-research organization demonstrates relevant management, albeit on a smaller institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international policy networks and analytical visibility would support competent representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority is primarily analytical rather than partisan, but his public positioning is strongly associated with one political camp." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established analytical career supports credibility, although perceived neutrality varies sharply by audience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige offers symbolic reach, but his intellectual and political associations limit universal acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual profile suggests sensitivity to authoritarianism and civic restraint, without a direct legal record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional intellectual achievement does not establish experience leading a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary standing would give Hungary considerable cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His authority appears highly independent of party machinery and short-term factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long, independent literary career supports seriousness and credibility, though mass-public trust is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile carries limited polarizing baggage but modest popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European human-rights experience strongly supports legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership at the Constitutional Court demonstrates direct experience managing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European judicial role provide unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career supports autonomy, though senior state appointments create some establishment dependence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in high-trust legal institutions supports credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise and opposition-backed candidacy offer some cross-group credibility but also attach a partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal, academic, and public-institutional profile suggests strong commitment to lawful constraints and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior experience spanning finance, academia, and public bodies indicates strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive international legal, financial, and academic experience would translate into strong diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied international career and willingness to criticize prevailing arrangements indicate substantial personal independence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long professional record and forthright public positions support credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominence and cultural symbolism inspire strong support but also carry a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public profile suggests commitment to pluralism, but offers little direct constitutional or legal experience." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of a major cultural institution demonstrates meaningful managerial and representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and public presence could translate effectively abroad despite limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears personally independent of party command despite clear cultural and political associations." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible professional convictions support credibility, though trust would vary sharply across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scientist carries relatively low partisan burden and potentially broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior scientific-institutional background suggests respect for formal process, though constitutional conduct is not his principal public record." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major national scientific institution strongly supports competence in complex organizational stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally legible scientific stature would provide credible and dignified representation." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His standing appears rooted more in science than party organization, with some uncertainty about establishment ties." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and institutional service support credibility, although public trust is difficult to gauge confidently." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional global credibility.", "Broad appeal with minimal partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or governmental experience.", "Public-institution leadership is not her core record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confidently identified polarizing record.", "No confidently identified partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "The name is too ambiguous for reliable identification.", "Relevant institutional experience cannot be assessed confidently." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "He has led the Political Capital research institute.", "His work includes political extremism and disinformation." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Established analytical and organizational competence.", "Strong international policy visibility." ], "reservations": [ "Highly polarizing domestic political profile.", "No direct constitutional or diplomatic office." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "His literary work has received substantial international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional intellectual independence.", "Major international cultural prestige." ], "reservations": [ "Little evidence of large-institution leadership.", "Limited mass-public accessibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional guardianship experience.", "Strong judicial and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular symbolic visibility.", "Senior appointments may invite establishment-dependence concerns." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist and lawyer with an international career.", "He served on the supervisory board of the Hungarian National Bank.", "Opposition parties nominated him for president of Hungary in 2022." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad international professional experience.", "Strong reputation for independent public argument." ], "reservations": [ "An opposition nomination creates partisan association.", "His unifying appeal remains uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "He served as director of the National Theatre." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated cultural-institution leadership.", "Independent and internationally legible public presence." ], "reservations": [ "Substantial domestic polarizing burden.", "Little direct legal or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished non-party scientific stature.", "Strong experience leading a national institution." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional record.", "Cross-group public appeal is not well tested." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations and synthetic profiles, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 6210904091166327415, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "robert-alfoldi", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-nadas", "peter-kreko", "peter-rona", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-kovacs" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:36978361af8ce4bb47f1451763db0cbd410f2aab0c7b5ca43c2f2dec7a5dde59", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:38+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:34+02:00", "duration_s": 115.875, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21470, "output_tokens": 5386, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments establish exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented nonpartisan rule-of-law service exactly match exceptional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and broad legitimacy indicate exceptional representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cross-government leadership and nonpartisan service indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no integrity finding support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 1, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric indicates an extremely weak unifying fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global fame provides representational presence despite serious diplomatic and polarizing limitations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition cannot offset the credibility costs of polarizing partisan advocacy." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader acceptability is unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is encouraging, but the profile provides no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service helps, but public credibility and integrity evidence are sparse." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally celebrated achievement gives her unusually broad and positive symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record is admirable but offers little direct basis for judging constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at elite institutions, but leading a complex public body is not her central demonstrated role." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her Nobel-level global stature makes her an exceptional international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her science-centered career appears exceptionally independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific perseverance and international recognition support exceptionally strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-polarization judicial profile seems favorable, but public acceptability is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Assuming the international jurist intended, his judicial background strongly supports legal process and restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His presumed judicial responsibilities indicate solid institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The presumed international-court career would provide very strong diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An international judicial career suggests autonomy, subject to uncertainty about the name's identity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial service suggests credibility, though my identification confidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His visible role in contentious political debate limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His work on democracy and disinformation suggests a strong commitment to institutional safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a policy-research organization demonstrates relevant managerial capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international analytical networks and public communication support credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is institutionally outside party office, though his public positioning carries clear political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical expertise supports credibility, but public trust would be politically uneven." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige is broad, but his intellectual profile is not universally accessible." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His intellectual seriousness supports democratic restraint, but he lacks a direct constitutional role." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His record offers limited evidence of responsibility for a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary reputation would give Hungary substantial cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary and critical career appears highly autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long, internationally respected literary career supports integrity and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile carries relatively little polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial background strongly fits legal restraint and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional experience with a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic service strongly supports international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial service conveys credibility and institutional seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His establishment credentials broaden appeal, but political visibility limits consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and public-intellectual background suggests respect for constitutional process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal, financial, and academic experience indicates strong organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive international legal, financial, and academic career provides very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied professional career suggests autonomy, though prior political nomination creates some factional association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and professional standing supports credibility with meaningful political reservations." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His prominence in Hungary's culture wars creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public commitments may favor pluralism, but he lacks a substantial legal-process record." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His direction of a major national cultural institution demonstrates meaningful leadership." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and public presence would support distinctive international representation." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is not principally a party politician, though his cultural role has acquired partisan associations." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects candor and professional conviction, although trust would vary sharply across groups." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a relatively nonpartisan public image offer broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly institutional profile is reassuring, but constitutional stewardship is not his demonstrated specialty." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's national academy indicates exceptional institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific standing would translate well to ceremonial representation." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A science-centered career suggests substantial distance from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His eminent academic profile supports credibility and public trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige and credibility.", "Broadly inspiring, nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited demonstrated leadership of a public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "A Hungarian jurist named Péter Kovács served as a judge of the International Criminal Court." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International judicial experience would strongly fit legal guardianship.", "The presumed profile carries substantial diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "The common name creates significant identity ambiguity.", "I have limited recall of his domestic public standing." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "He directs the Political Capital Institute.", "His work addresses disinformation and political extremism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong expertise concerning democratic vulnerabilities.", "Relevant analytical and organizational leadership." ], "reservations": [ "He is strongly associated with contentious political debate.", "Cross-partisan trust would likely be limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "His works include A Book of Memories and Parallel Stories.", "He has substantial international literary recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong intellectual independence.", "Exceptional cultural standing abroad." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public-institution leadership experience.", "His appeal may be more elite than broadly popular." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He also held a diplomatic post in Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong international institutional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments can carry political associations.", "His broader popular appeal is less established." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian-born lawyer, economist, and academic.", "He worked internationally in law and finance.", "The opposition nominated him for president of Hungary in 2022." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad international professional experience.", "Strong legal and institutional competence." ], "reservations": [ "A prior partisan nomination limits perceived neutrality.", "His mass unifying appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "He served as director of Hungary's National Theatre.", "His tenure became politically contentious." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated leadership of a major cultural institution.", "Strong public presence and cultural distinction." ], "reservations": [ "He carries a substantial culture-war burden.", "He lacks direct constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished nonparty scientific stature.", "Substantial experience leading a national institution." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Diplomatic capability is inferred mainly from academic prominence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are anchored ordinal expressions of my rubric-conditioned impression, with factual recall separated from interpretation and uncertainty reflected in confidence.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 15663632378272636530, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-nadas", "katalin-kariko", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "robert-alfoldi", "peter-paczolay", "peter-kreko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-kovacs", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-rona" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:bcf742c1d0df86d53b1b7bf72d4e5112e674e79b5affb502b048b7e62fb84471", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:45:56+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:47:59+02:00", "duration_s": 122.547, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22500, "output_tokens": 4245, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan profile indicate exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service make this an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide very strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record strongly support exceptional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes cross-group symbolic inclusion extremely unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity and no legal experience create substantial reservations about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is a major asset, though polarization weakens representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior party-campaign involvement indicates pronounced dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame provides visibility but cannot offset partisan conduct and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but public obscurity leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is favorable, but the profile provides no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong leadership with limited public-institution evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career outside party office suggests substantial autonomy from partisan command." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence helps, but the profile offers insufficient evidence about trust or integrity." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her non-partisan professional record is favorable, but it reveals little about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial high-level scientific experience, though limited visible leadership of public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific recognition makes her an exceptional international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A career grounded in international science rather than party structures indicates exceptional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, professional credibility, and public scientific standing strongly support trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A restrained legal profile could be broadly acceptable but lacks clear unifying visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The jurist I associate with this name appears constitutionally experienced, but identity ambiguity lowers confidence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The presumed judicial career indicates relevant capacity without a confidently recalled leadership record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The presumed international-law background would be a strong representational asset." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An international judicial profile suggests autonomy, subject to uncertainty about the intended individual." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior legal service would support credibility, but my identification is insufficiently certain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong partisan perceptions around his work substantially limit cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public work emphasizes democratic resilience and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Think-tank leadership is relevant but narrower than stewardship of a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International policy engagement and communication experience would translate reasonably well abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is outside formal party command, but his public analytical role is associated with one side of political conflict." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Analytical expertise supports credibility, while politically divided reception constrains broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural stature broadens appeal, but his demanding and politically resonant public profile limits consensus reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His independent intellectual profile suggests respect for pluralism, though not tested in constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary distinction does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary standing would provide substantial cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long-standing identity as an independent writer indicates very strong factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Intellectual seriousness and independence support credibility, with uneven accessibility across groups." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile is broadly acceptable but offers limited popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive senior constitutional and judicial service makes him a very strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior leadership in constitutional adjudication demonstrates exceptional relevant capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience gives him very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably create some political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial responsibility and professional credibility strongly support institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Intellectual breadth supports cross-group reach, but prior political nomination limits neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal, economic, and public-institutional profile suggests strong commitment to accountable governance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic and financial experience indicates strong, though not presidentially tested, leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive international legal, financial, and academic experience makes him a very strong representative." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied international career and willingness to criticize established camps indicate substantial autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional stature and forthright public positions support credibility with meaningful political reservations." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His visibility and symbolic importance are offset by a strongly polarizing public profile." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public defense of cultural pluralism is favorable, though he lacks constitutional-office experience." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major national theater demonstrates meaningful institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and European orientation would support capable representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears personally independent, but his prominent position in cultural conflicts creates factional identification." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Candor and professional achievement support trust among many, but acceptance is sharply uneven." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific stature offers respectable cross-group appeal without strong evidence of mass resonance." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly institutional background is reassuring, but constitutional restraint is not directly demonstrated." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's principal scientific academy demonstrates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific engagement provides credible representational standing." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A predominantly scientific career suggests autonomy, albeit within nationally connected institutions." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long academic and scientific leadership record supports substantial credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her work was foundational to mRNA vaccines.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad non-partisan symbolic appeal.", "Exceptional global scientific credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Limited public-institution leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "Possible international-law expertise.", "Potentially restrained professional profile." ], "reservations": [ "The name is highly ambiguous.", "Relevant record cannot be recalled confidently." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "Director of Political Capital.", "Researches disinformation and political extremism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong democratic-institution expertise.", "Substantial international policy engagement." ], "reservations": [ "Politically polarized reception.", "Limited major public-institution experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "Author of A Book of Memories.", "His work has extensive international recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally independent intellectual voice.", "Strong international cultural standing." ], "reservations": [ "Little relevant executive experience.", "Limited cross-group accessibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong European representational experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular visibility.", "Senior appointments invite political associations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian economist and lawyer.", "Held academic roles at Oxford.", "Was an opposition nominee for president of Hungary in 2022." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad international professional experience.", "Substantial independence and intellectual credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Prior nomination weakens neutral symbolism.", "Public positions can divide audiences." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian actor and theater director.", "Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest.", "Known for outspoken public positions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated cultural-institution leadership.", "Visible commitment to pluralism." ], "reservations": [ "Strongly polarizing public profile.", "No constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major institution.", "Respected scientific profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional record.", "Modest contemporary public visibility." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are anchored ordinal expressions of my rubric-conditioned subjective impression, with factual uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted evaluations.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 18102431160611839432, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "robert-alfoldi", "katalin-kariko", "peter-rona", "peter-kreko", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "peter-nadas", "peter-kovacs", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:4f4ab0b545ef582af3832d762115eb22bee7ab95fc425d19abd9007317f54130", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:33:58+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:46+02:00", "duration_s": 107.703, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21478, "output_tokens": 5504, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability and inclusive symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match the criterion at an exceptional level." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior public service provide very strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record create a very strong integrity profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance unlikely despite celebrity." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and recent partisan campaigning create substantial doubts about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition supports visibility abroad, though polarizing conduct limits diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but partisan activity and polarizing rhetoric weaken broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is encouraging, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid capacity to lead a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience creates a meaningful representational weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies insufficient trust evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely admired scientific achievement provides rare cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at elite scientific institutions, but I recall limited evidence of leading a complex public organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional international recognition and professional credibility make her an outstanding symbolic representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity and achievements are unusually independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and restrained public persona create a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient familiarity leaves both cross-group appeal and polarizing burden largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My uncertain identification permits only a mildly favorable judgment based on a possible legal-institutional profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A possibly senior legal career suggests competence, but uncertain identification sharply limits confidence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Possible international legal experience is favorable, but my factual recall is not secure enough for a stronger score." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficiently specific recall to judge his autonomy from political or institutional patrons." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall too little reliable detail to move far from a mixed assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expertise is valuable, but his visibility in contentious political debates produces substantial polarization." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His work on democratic resilience supports a favorable impression, though he lacks a recalled constitutional office record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Think-tank leadership indicates organizational competence, though at a smaller scale than a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International research networks and public communication experience support credible external representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is institutionally outside party leadership, but his prominent political analysis can create perceived alignment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His research profile supports credibility, while sharply divided political perceptions constrain broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature offers symbolic breadth, though his intellectual and political associations may limit universal appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His intellectual seriousness and historical awareness are favorable, but he lacks a direct institutional record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His accomplishments are substantial, but I recall little experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary reputation would give Hungary distinguished cultural representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His literary career and independent critical voice suggest considerable distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long, serious literary career supports authenticity and credibility, despite uncertain mass-public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained jurist profile carries relatively low polarization, although broad popular appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and judicial career provides unusually direct evidence of commitment to legal institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership within constitutional adjudication demonstrates substantial experience managing consequential public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience provides excellent international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial service supports autonomy, though appointments within political systems warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished judicial and diplomatic record creates a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Intellectual seriousness broadens his appeal, but pronounced public positions may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public intellectual profile suggests serious concern for institutional and legal norms, with some uncertainty about practice." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Substantial experience across finance, academia, and public bodies indicates capable institutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international academic and financial experience would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied professional background and critical public positions suggest autonomy despite political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and professional standing supports credibility, though he is not politically neutral in public perception." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His cultural prominence attracts substantial support but also carries a pronounced polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public posture suggests commitment to pluralism, but he lacks a recalled legal-process record." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major national theatre demonstrates significant organizational and public-institution experience." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and public presence support representation, but diplomatic experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears personally outspoken and outside party command, though associated cultural conflicts reduce perceived neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He presents as candid and professionally committed, although trust would likely divide along cultural lines." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established scientific stature appears comparatively non-polarizing and symbolically inclusive." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His senior scholarly profile suggests institutional seriousness, but I recall little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of a major national scholarly institution strongly supports administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific eminence and international professional standing suggest strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A scientific career supports some autonomy, while his relationships with political institutions are unclear to me." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-standing academic distinction creates a favorable credibility impression, with limited contrary recall." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She spent much of her research career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has exceptional international credibility.", "Her achievement offers unusually broad symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "She has little recalled constitutional experience.", "Large-scale public-institution leadership is not established in my recall." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "A possible legal background would be relevant.", "A low-profile professional could carry limited polarization." ], "reservations": [ "The name is too ambiguous for confident identification.", "Nearly all criterion-specific evidence is unavailable in my recall." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "He leads the Political Capital institute.", "His work includes research on disinformation and political extremism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His expertise is relevant to democratic resilience.", "He has international research visibility." ], "reservations": [ "He is polarizing within Hungarian political debate.", "Think-tank leadership is not equivalent to major public administration." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a major Hungarian writer.", "His novels have received extensive international recognition.", "His work often engages with history, memory, and political life." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His international cultural stature is exceptional.", "His public identity appears independent of party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks recalled public-institution leadership experience.", "Literary authority does not directly establish constitutional competence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career directly combines constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "His professional profile is comparatively restrained." ], "reservations": [ "Judicial appointments can generate perceived political associations.", "His mass-public unifying appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist and jurist.", "He has worked in international finance and academia.", "He was an opposition-backed presidential nominee in 2022." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His international background supports representation.", "His multidisciplinary career suggests independent judgment." ], "reservations": [ "Political associations may constrain unifying appeal.", "My recall of his institutional record is incomplete." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "He led the National Theatre in Budapest." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has visible public-institution leadership experience.", "His cultural career suggests an independent voice." ], "reservations": [ "He carries a substantial polarizing burden.", "He lacks a recalled legal or diplomatic background." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Senior scientific stature supports credibility.", "Academy leadership demonstrates institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Direct constitutional experience is unclear.", "Political independence is difficult to assess confidently." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal impressions from the supplied controls and my unaided internal recall, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 5537103264771837941, "entity_order": [ "peter-rona", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-kovacs", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "robert-alfoldi", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d6b62f42ed5fffcfd06c10373223c173c9a212f568ae857a2a5077f886dff88c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:34:53+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:36:51+02:00", "duration_s": 118.657, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21686, "output_tokens": 4125, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a low-partisan profile imply unusually wide acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly describes exceptional, sustained commitment to constitutional law and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of service and leadership across governments indicate exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong basis for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no constitutional experience and describes recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly states an absence of institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition is a major asset, though polarizing conduct would reduce diplomatic effectiveness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong dependence on a political faction." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer visibility, but the profile gives little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and insufficient information justify a neutral assessment of unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no direct constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong but not exceptional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility indicates weak readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly leaves broader trust and integrity insufficiently established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public reputation suggests seriousness and discipline, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates exceptional professional capability but has limited visible experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility and recognition." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career identity is scientific and internationally grounded rather than tied to party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, professional credibility, and scientific distinction support very strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient confident familiarity prevents a directional judgment about cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Name ambiguity and insufficient confident recall leave the assessment genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently attribute relevant leadership experience to the intended person." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The intended figure's international experience is unclear in my internal representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently identify enough relevant public-record context to judge factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficiently specific recall to assess credibility or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Expertise and moderation may appeal broadly, but partisan perceptions would constrain unifying capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional focus on democracy and political institutions suggests strong commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a policy-research organization indicates solid institutional and strategic management capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and policy engagement suggests strong representational competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical career is outside party office, but his public positioning is often identified with one political camp." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established research profile supports credibility, while politically contested visibility limits universal trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige offers symbolic breadth, though an elite literary profile may limit popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His intellectual engagement with European history and society is relevant, but not a direct constitutional qualification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His accomplishments do not prominently demonstrate leadership of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary reputation would confer strong cultural and intellectual credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long literary career and critical voice suggest substantial independence from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained intellectual seriousness and international standing support strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained judicial profile could be broadly acceptable, although it offers limited popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and judicial experience makes institutional restraint a central demonstrated strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court indicates strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience suggests excellent international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports autonomy, though senior state appointments inevitably invite questions about political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in high judicial roles supports credibility and institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature could attract broad respect, but his outspoken positions may limit cross-camp acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal-economic background and public emphasis on institutional accountability suggest strong constitutional seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His experience across academic, financial, and supervisory institutions indicates substantial leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and professional career suggests strong diplomatic presence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears intellectually independent, though involvement in public controversies creates some factional association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic and oversight roles support credibility, tempered by the polarizing effects of political engagement." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His cultural prominence is substantial, but his public persona is strongly polarizing across political camps." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His public advocacy suggests commitment to pluralism, but he lacks a direct constitutional or legal record." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience directing major theatrical institutions demonstrates meaningful organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic stature and communication skills could represent Hungarian culture effectively abroad." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic identity supports personal independence, although outspoken cultural positions create partisan perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible professional candor supports credibility, though trust would vary sharply between groups." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific stature and a relatively nonpartisan profile could command broad respect." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His distinguished institutional career suggests responsibility, but provides limited direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading Hungary's principal scientific academy demonstrates substantial institutional management experience." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific standing would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific identity supports autonomy, though leadership within national institutions entails some establishment proximity." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long, prominent scientific career supports credibility and public confidence." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was foundational to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has exceptional international credibility.", "Her scientific identity carries broad nonpartisan appeal." ], "reservations": [ "She has little visible constitutional experience.", "Her public-institution leadership experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confident positive inference is available.", "The neutral scores avoid conflating people who share the name." ], "reservations": [ "The name is highly ambiguous.", "I cannot confidently identify the intended public figure." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has led the Political Capital Institute.", "His work addresses political extremism and disinformation." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has relevant expertise in democratic institutions.", "His international policy engagement supports external representation." ], "reservations": [ "He is perceived by some as aligned with an opposition-oriented milieu.", "Think-tank leadership differs from stewardship of a constitutional office." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "His works have received extensive international recognition.", "He is known for major novels including Parallel Stories." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has strong intellectual independence and cultural stature.", "His international reputation would represent Hungary impressively." ], "reservations": [ "He lacks visible experience leading complex public institutions.", "His literary prestige may not translate into broad popular unity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has unusually relevant constitutional experience.", "His European and diplomatic work strengthens international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Senior state appointments can create perceptions of establishment proximity.", "His restrained public profile may offer limited popular connection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is an economist and lawyer.", "He has held academic roles in the United Kingdom.", "He served in a supervisory role connected to Hungary's central bank." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International professional experience supports independence.", "Legal-economic expertise suits institutional oversight." ], "reservations": [ "His public interventions can be politically divisive.", "His constitutional leadership record is less direct than a senior judge's." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "He served as director of Hungary's National Theatre.", "His tenure became a subject of political controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has demonstrated leadership in a major cultural institution.", "He is an articulate and internationally legible cultural representative." ], "reservations": [ "He is highly polarizing domestically.", "He lacks direct legal or constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has held prominent roles in Hungarian scientific life." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has extensive institutional leadership experience.", "Scientific prestige gives him broad representational credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His constitutional views are not central to my recall.", "His establishment background may complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective judgments from the supplied profiles and internal recall, using uncertainty to lower confidence rather than omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 14379818782433838376, "entity_order": [ "peter-rona", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "robert-alfoldi", "peter-nadas" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:8b9966c5cecbd34dffeed1cc90a289ce6fb5cbd0753cde5761786dd85e31b952", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:34:59+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:36:48+02:00", "duration_s": 109.0, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21478, "output_tokens": 5429, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong consensus acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate exceptional factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal experience and includes recent partisan campaign involvement." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience is a major weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides diplomatic visibility despite limited institutional preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate trust among admirers, but the profile supplies little integrity evidence and substantial polarization." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility makes unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Competence and non-partisanship are mildly favorable, but no rule-of-law record is supplied." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a clear weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports a strong, though not conclusive, independence assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but the profile explicitly lacks broader trust information." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and a low-partisan profile give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for institutions but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career demonstrates resilience and responsibility but limited leadership of complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably separate from party structures and factional politics." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific record supports exceptional credibility and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient familiarity leaves his cross-group acceptability genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My uncertain identification of this common name permits only a cautiously favorable legal-institutional assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A tentatively recalled legal-institutional profile suggests some relevant capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Possible international legal experience supports a cautious positive assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack sufficiently reliable recall to judge his autonomy from political factions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I have too little reliable recall for a judgment beyond the neutral midpoint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent role in contested political analysis creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His democracy-focused analytical work suggests meaningful commitment to institutional safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a policy-research organization demonstrates relevant but narrower institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international expert visibility would support articulate representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears institutionally independent, although his public positioning may be perceived through partisan lenses." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established scholarly and analytical career supports credibility despite polarized reception." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural prestige offers symbolic breadth, but his intellectual and political associations may limit universal appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual profile suggests strong concern for freedom and democratic culture without direct legal experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished individual career supplies little evidence of managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His major international literary reputation would provide exceptional cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long literary career and critical voice appear highly autonomous from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained literary reputation supports an impression of seriousness and intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile offers broad respectability with some institutional-era baggage." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career directly support a very strong assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates exceptional relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights experience strongly fits international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite political scrutiny." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long legal and diplomatic service supports a strong impression of professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He could command respect across groups but has taken positions that may limit consensus appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public profile suggests strong attachment to legal constraints and institutional accountability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior professional experience indicates substantial judgment, though not extensive leadership of public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and financial background would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career and public interventions appear relatively autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and professional reputation supports a favorable impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His cultural prominence is accompanied by substantial polarization across political groups." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public advocacy suggests concern for rights and pluralism, though he lacks a direct legal record." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience directing a major national cultural institution demonstrates meaningful leadership." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and communication skills could support distinctive representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears personally independent but is strongly identified with one side of cultural conflict." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible artistic leadership and forthright public persona support credibility among a broad constituency." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His respected scientific stature is broadly acceptable, though not wholly free of establishment associations." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior academic profile suggests institutional responsibility but limited direct constitutional grounding." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Hungarian Academy of Sciences provides highly relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior scientific standing would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific career supports relative autonomy, though long establishment service may create perceived alignments." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished academic career supports a strong impression of professional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with little partisan baggage.", "Her career conveys persistence, competence, and credibility." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific achievement does not automatically establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "A possibly legal-institutional profile could be relevant.", "No confidently recalled polarizing burden." ], "reservations": [ "The name is insufficiently distinctive for confident identification.", "Most criterion judgments remain highly uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "He leads the Political Capital institute.", "His work addresses disinformation and political extremism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong analytical knowledge of democratic risks.", "Substantial international expert credibility." ], "reservations": [ "He is a polarizing figure in Hungarian political debate.", "His executive experience is concentrated in policy research." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "His works have received extensive international recognition.", "He is known for major novels including A Book of Memories and Parallel Stories." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected and strongly independent.", "His intellectual stature could represent Hungarian culture compellingly." ], "reservations": [ "He has little recalled experience leading public institutions.", "Literary prestige may not translate into broad domestic consensus." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally relevant constitutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and international legal credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may attract questions about political proximity.", "His public unifying appeal is less tested than his institutional competence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian economist and jurist.", "He pursued a substantial professional career in the United Kingdom.", "He has held an academic affiliation with Oxford." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally experienced and intellectually independent.", "Strongly associated with institutional accountability." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct leadership of Hungarian public institutions.", "Some public positions may narrow consensus appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "He served as director of Hungary's National Theatre.", "His tenure became a focus of political and cultural controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Experienced leader and highly capable public communicator.", "Strong symbolic association with cultural pluralism." ], "reservations": [ "He carries a substantial polarizing burden.", "He lacks direct legal and diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven leadership of a major national institution.", "Respected scientific stature supports international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His constitutional outlook is not strongly established in my recall.", "Long establishment service may complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective judgments from the supplied anchors, using internal recall for real figures and only the provided profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 6046909968032213247, "entity_order": [ "peter-kovacs", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-kreko", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "peter-nadas", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:849399fd342009e59f851e62ab7de6f10f98e9437b2996c7b6fcba61d9a8e1e2", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:02+02:00", "duration_s": 115.703, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21478, "output_tokens": 5205, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate exceptional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no integrity finding strongly support public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes cross-group acceptance unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and polarizing partisan activity create substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides presence, though polarization and inexperience limit diplomatic fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but the profile supplies little integrity evidence and substantial polarization." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but broader acceptability is unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Nonpartisan service is mildly favorable, but no rule-of-law record is supplied." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests meaningful autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence helps, but the profile provides insufficient trust and integrity evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests discipline and restraint, but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but large public-institution leadership is less established." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature offers outstanding international representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears highly independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific record supports exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficient confident familiarity supports a neutral assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Name ambiguity and limited confident recall leave the fit uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Relevant leadership experience cannot be recalled confidently." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack a reliable basis for assessing international standing." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I lack enough reliable identifying context to judge factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I cannot confidently associate this name with a sufficiently specific public record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent role in contested political analysis creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public analytical orientation suggests respect for democratic safeguards, with limited direct office evidence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Think-tank leadership is relevant but narrower than leading a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally legible policy expertise would support credible representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears institutionally independent, though his public positioning may be perceived as factionally aligned." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His expert profile supports credibility, but partisan perceptions constrain broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prestige could confer dignity, but elite literary standing may not translate broadly." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual reputation suggests independence and sensitivity to authoritarian risks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Literary achievement provides little direct evidence of complex institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International literary stature would give Hungary substantial cultural credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career as an independent literary figure suggests strong distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-standing intellectual seriousness supports integrity, with limited evidence about mass trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained institutional profile offers broad acceptability with some establishment burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior constitutional adjudication experience directly supports a very strong assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in constitutional and diplomatic institutions demonstrates strong capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European judicial experience provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic service suggest autonomy, though appointments inevitably invite political scrutiny." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports credibility and procedural seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Intellectual stature helps, but earlier political association may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and public-policy background suggests strong regard for institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Experience across law, finance, academia, and public institutions suggests capable leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive international professional and academic experience offers strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied professional career suggests autonomy despite prior political nomination." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional seriousness and public-service profile support credibility." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural prominence broadens appeal, but strong controversy substantially offsets it." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public commitments suggest civic pluralism, but direct constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major national theatre demonstrates genuine institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Cultural distinction provides presence, though diplomatic experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is not primarily a party figure, though his cultural positions carry political associations." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A visible and candid public persona supports credibility but not universal trust." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature and a relatively nonpartisan image could attract broad acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior scholarly-institutional background suggests procedural restraint without a distinct constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major national scholarly institution demonstrates substantial administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction provides credible international presence." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A scientific career supports autonomy, though establishment proximity creates some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished academic profile supports credibility, subject to limited current recall." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist", "Known for foundational work on mRNA therapeutics", "Received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility", "Broadly respected nonpartisan achievement" ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience", "Limited evidence of leading a complex public institution" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "No confident adverse association", "Potentially low partisan burden" ], "reservations": [ "The name is highly ambiguous", "Relevant experience cannot be identified confidently" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist", "Director of the Political Capital Institute", "Researches disinformation and political extremism" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong analytical expertise", "Internationally legible professional profile" ], "reservations": [ "Likely polarizing in domestic politics", "Limited senior public-institution experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian novelist and essayist", "Author of A Book of Memories", "His work has broad international recognition" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong intellectual independence", "High international cultural prestige" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct institutional leadership evidence", "Broad popular acceptability is uncertain" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy", "Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise", "Strong diplomatic and institutional experience" ], "reservations": [ "May carry establishment associations", "Broad popular appeal is less evident than institutional competence" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian economist and lawyer", "Has taught at the University of Oxford", "Was an opposition nominee for president in 2022" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad international experience", "Serious legal and economic background" ], "reservations": [ "Prior political nomination may limit neutrality perceptions", "Mass unifying appeal is uncertain" ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian actor and theatre director", "Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated cultural-institution leadership", "Visible commitment to pluralism" ], "reservations": [ "Strong domestic polarization", "Limited legal and diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian physician and neuroscientist", "Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences" ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial institutional leadership", "Nonpartisan scientific stature" ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience", "Current public standing is not confidently recalled" ] } ], "method_note": "I formed an independent ordinal impression for each criterion, used only internal recall for real people, and treated uncertainty as lower confidence rather than missing scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "peter-kovacs", "peter-kreko", "peter-nadas", "peter-rona", "robert-alfoldi", "szilveszter-e-vizi" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 7124438508756961808, "entity_order": [ "peter-nadas", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "peter-kreko", "robert-alfoldi", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "peter-rona", "peter-kovacs", "szilveszter-e-vizi", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:eb8d1a261065e14a063c222245c6c6208fbcd601686627c33b81036def0fc2f4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:09+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:36:51+02:00", "duration_s": 101.454, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21478, "output_tokens": 3931, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan baggage indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional service directly exemplify this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex public office." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides excellent preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments provide strong evidence of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability very unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of legal experience and recent senior partisan activity create substantial concern about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly provides no legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition is a meaningful asset, though polarizing conduct would limit diplomatic effectiveness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity directly undermines confidence in autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but polarizing rhetoric and partisan activity weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile limits polarizing baggage but also provides little basis for broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports autonomy, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence helps modestly, but the profile explicitly leaves broader trust and integrity underdetermined." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national pride give her unusually broad symbolic appeal with limited partisan baggage." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional reputation suggests procedural seriousness, but she has no salient constitutional-governance record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career demonstrates responsibility and perseverance but not clearly broad public-institution management." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific recognition would confer immediate international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing appear highly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record of rigorous scientific achievement supports exceptional credibility and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Insufficiently distinctive public visibility leaves both broad acceptability and polarizing burden uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The name appears associated with legal expertise, but identification uncertainty prevents a stronger judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "There may be relevant institutional experience, but the ambiguous identity makes its extent uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Possible international legal experience supports a moderate score, discounted for identification uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "My limited representation suggests professional autonomy, but party and patron relationships are unclear." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A possible senior legal profile is mildly reassuring, but I lack confident candidate-specific knowledge." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominence in contentious political debates creates a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public work on democratic resilience suggests support for institutional checks, though not from constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leading a policy research organization indicates relevant management and public-facing responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic and policy engagement would support competent representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears institutionally independent of party structures, while his public positioning may still be perceived through partisan conflict." }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His analytical credentials support credibility, but trust in him is likely sharply divided by political alignment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature could command respect across groups, but his intellectual profile may not translate into broad identification." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His intellectual seriousness suggests respect for constitutional limits, though he lacks a prominent legal-institutional record." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Distinguished cultural achievement does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international literary standing would give Hungary a credible and sophisticated representative." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His career and public identity appear substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long-standing literary reputation conveys seriousness and personal credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could be broadly acceptable, though it offers limited popular symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in major judicial and diplomatic institutions demonstrates strong administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European legal experience provides unusually direct preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful autonomy from ordinary party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal service supports credibility, subject to the usual contested perceptions surrounding high institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His establishment credentials could reassure multiple groups, but prior political controversy may limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and public-policy background suggests respect for institutional limits, though his constitutional record is indirect." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His experience across finance, academia, and public institutions indicates strong organizational competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive international professional and academic experience would translate well to diplomatic representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His varied international career and willingness to criticize entrenched interests suggest considerable autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional stature and principled public positions support credibility, albeit not universal trust." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has substantial symbolic appeal for some groups but is strongly polarizing for others." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public commitments suggest pluralist instincts, but he has little direct constitutional or legal-process experience." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His experience directing a major national cultural institution demonstrates genuine leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His cultural stature and public presence could represent Hungary effectively, though without diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His artistic career is formally independent, although his public identity is embedded in polarized cultural politics." }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible professional record and forthright public persona support credibility despite divided public reactions." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific stature and a relatively nonpartisan profile could support broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and institutional background suggests procedural responsibility but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences demonstrates strong experience managing a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific standing would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His primary identity in science supports autonomy, though leadership of national institutions necessarily involved political interfaces." }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long scientific and academy career conveys credibility and institutional seriousness." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional-governance record.", "Limited demonstrated leadership of a broad public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "familiarity_1_5": 1, "recalled_facts": [], "positive_reasons": [ "Possible legal-institutional expertise.", "Potentially relevant international experience." ], "reservations": [ "The common name creates identification uncertainty.", "Candidate-specific public record is not confidently recalled." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.", "Director of the Political Capital Institute.", "His research includes disinformation and political radicalism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong analytical competence.", "International policy-network experience." ], "reservations": [ "Publicly polarizing political profile.", "No direct constitutional-office experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian novelist and essayist.", "His works have received substantial international recognition.", "He is known for major works of modern European literature." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Independent intellectual stature.", "Strong international cultural credibility." ], "reservations": [ "No prominent constitutional-office experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional experience.", "Direct diplomatic and institutional leadership record." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Senior institutional roles may attract political contestation." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born economist and lawyer.", "Worked internationally in finance and academia.", "Served on the supervisory board of the National Bank of Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Broad international professional experience.", "Relatively independent public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Prior public controversies may narrow consensus.", "Limited direct constitutional-office experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian actor and theatre director.", "Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest.", "He has been prominent in Hungarian cultural debate." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven cultural-institution leadership.", "Strong public presence and symbolic voice." ], "reservations": [ "Substantial polarizing burden.", "Limited legal and diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.", "Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial institutional leadership experience.", "Credible nonpartisan scientific stature." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional background.", "Less obvious broad popular appeal than cultural or scientific icons." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal representations only, treating uncertainty as lower confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 9622420787218304937, "entity_order": [ "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm", "tamas-freund", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "tibor-navracsics", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-vicsek", "tamas-sulyok" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:ae512ee5ee1cb59ec9094194f1cb75d665153937f8cfc266b9deca9399ebb6d7", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:02+02:00", "duration_s": 98.828, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21459, "output_tokens": 3986, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a low-partisan profile indicate unusually strong consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional adjudication match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to guide a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior legal standing provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion extremely unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal or institutional grounding and adds recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience indicates very weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition provides presence abroad, but polarization and inexperience substantially weaken diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame offers visibility but neither establishes accountability nor offsets the credibility cost of polarizing partisanship." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but insufficient visibility and trust information make the fit uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no evidence of constitutional service." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience and limited public profile indicate weak representational preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports autonomy, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is positive, but the profile provides too little information about integrity or public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and personal story carry exceptionally broad symbolic appeal with limited partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career conveys rigor and responsibility but offers little direct experience with constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has excelled in complex research environments but is not chiefly known for leading large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific recognition would confer exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her professional identity and achievements are unusually independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record of perseverance and internationally validated scholarship supports very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal-diplomatic profile appears broadly acceptable without being strongly charismatic." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career make institutional restraint a central strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has led a constitutional court and operated in demanding international institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European human-rights experience provides exceptional representational preparation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic record suggests meaningful autonomy, though no senior appointee is wholly insulated from political context." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long service in high legal and diplomatic offices supports credibility and institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature could attract respect across groups, though institutional controversies reduce consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific leadership offers institutional experience but little direct evidence of constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's national academy demonstrates substantial capacity to manage a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would give him considerable credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly identity supports some autonomy, while perceived government alignment creates meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His research distinction supports credibility, tempered by concerns about political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His reserved style reduces personal polarization, but the circumstances and reception of his elevation limit unifying force." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court background is directly relevant, but his record also attracts meaningful concerns about deference and institutional robustness." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience directing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal status provides formal gravitas, though his diplomatic profile appears less developed." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His formally non-party judicial profile is offset by perceptions of alignment with the governing majority." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial office supports baseline credibility, while public controversies and limited independent authority create reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a low-partisan profile could support broad acceptance, though public visibility is limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests rigor and autonomy but provides little direct evidence on constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has senior research experience, but I recall limited evidence of large-scale public executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent international scientific career would translate into strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally oriented scientific career appears substantially detached from party command." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished academic reputation supports a strong impression of professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style helps, but his partisan history imposes a substantial ceiling on cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is relevant, but long service within the governing party limits confidence in restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "He has substantial leadership experience across Hungarian government and European institutions." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His service as foreign minister and European commissioner provides strong diplomatic and international experience." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive senior career in Fidesz strongly constrains the impression of independence from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional competence supports credibility, while responsibility for contentious governments creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her association with contentious judicial reforms would likely impose a significant polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her judicial experience is relevant, but controversies over centralized court administration create substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "She has extensive experience leading a large and complex judicial administration." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her senior legal standing offers representational substance, but her broader diplomatic profile appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perceived proximity to the governing political network weighs heavily against an impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional credentials are offset by persistent concerns about accountability and judicial appointments." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A respected, low-partisan scholarly profile could be broadly acceptable despite limited public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law scholarship suggests a strong orientation toward legal process and institutional constraint." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "She has senior academic standing, though I recall less evidence of executive leadership at national scale." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International-law expertise would provide strong substantive credibility in representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic and legal profile appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished professional reputation supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her research career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad non-partisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Limited public-institution executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong diplomatic preparation." ], "reservations": [ "Limited popular visibility.", "Consensus appeal is more institutional than charismatic." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He became president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has received major international scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scholarly stature.", "Substantial institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived political alignment.", "Limited constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He is a lawyer by profession." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional-institution experience.", "Reserved and formal public style." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived governing-majority alignment.", "Questions about independent institutional assertiveness." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "The Vicsek model bears his name." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific distinction.", "Low-partisan public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional background.", "Limited nationally visible executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a senior Fidesz politician and Hungarian minister.", "He served as Hungary's foreign minister.", "He served as a European commissioner." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental competence.", "Strong international experience." ], "reservations": [ "Deep partisan identification.", "Responsibility for contentious government policies." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as president of Hungary's National Judicial Office.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her court-administration tenure drew controversy over judicial appointments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive senior judicial experience.", "Proven large-institution management." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived governing-party proximity.", "Contentious judicial-administration record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.", "She has been associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law expertise.", "Low-partisan professional standing." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Executive leadership record is less familiar." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based only on supplied synthetic profiles and my internal representation of the named public figures, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 17849469107095058694, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "tamas-vicsek", "tunde-hando", "control-consensus-guardian", "tamas-sulyok", "vanda-lamm", "control-unknown-technocrat", "tibor-navracsics", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-freund", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:43e9a1a35e629de1699157de20ce7b81b32be0552caabf46b083dc5c68e4a2e3", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:32+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:42+02:00", "duration_s": 129.875, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21667, "output_tokens": 5553, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile imply unusually wide acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to steward a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature indicate very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 1, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly conflicts with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and indicates recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition offers presence abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and inexperience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates strong exposure to factional command and incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity alone does not establish integrity, while partisan polarization substantially burdens public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves broader unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service provides no negative signal, but the profile supplies insufficient evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management provide strong evidence of responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and limited public visibility indicate weak representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests independence, although patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile indicates competence but explicitly lacks enough information to judge broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and international recognition offer unusually broad, nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly reputation suggests respect for evidence and process, though she lacks a substantial constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding institutions but has limited visible experience leading a complex public body." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career appears largely independent of Hungarian party structures and factional patronage." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific standing, and comparatively nonpolitical profile support a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained legal-diplomatic profile carries relatively low partisan burden and respectable cross-group potential." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career provide strong direct grounding for institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates strong capacity to manage a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European human-rights experience indicate very strong international representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic trajectory suggests meaningful professional autonomy despite appointments within political systems." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial and diplomatic service supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific prestige offers symbolic appeal, while culture-war and academic-governance associations limit consensus." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic stature supports procedural seriousness, but his direct constitutional record is limited and institutional controversies matter." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Hungarian Academy of Sciences demonstrates substantial experience with a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized neuroscience career would provide strong credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific career supports some autonomy, but perceived proximity to the governing establishment weakens it." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific accomplishments support credibility, although contested public interventions create reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained style reduces personal polarization, but his institutional associations limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court experience is directly relevant, but perceived alignment with the governing majority creates serious reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal stature and measured demeanor provide adequate presence, though not exceptional international standing." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His elevation through governing-party institutional dominance weakens the impression of meaningful political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A formal legal career supports baseline credibility, while public controversies and partisan perceptions materially reduce trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A respected scientific profile carries low partisan burden, although his broader public reach seems limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic profile is compatible with procedural restraint, but I recall little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior scientific work suggests organizational competence, though public-institution leadership evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized research career would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identity as a scientist rather than a party politician supports a strong impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established academic reputation supports credibility without a prominent record of political controversy." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style helps, but his deep partisan identification limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is relevant, but long service within the governing party creates substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ministerial and European executive experience demonstrates strong institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European Commission and foreign-affairs experience provide substantial diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His longstanding senior role in Fidesz makes strong autonomy from party incentives difficult to credit." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional competence supports credibility, while responsibility for a polarizing governing project constrains broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her polarizing institutional record would likely impose a heavy partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Controversies surrounding judicial administration create substantial reservations about checks, restraint, and institutional neutrality." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial leadership experience, but its contested exercise makes the overall fit mixed." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her legal stature provides some representational capacity, but domestic rule-of-law controversy would constrain credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her close association with Hungary's governing political network substantially weakens the impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Persistent criticism of her judicial-administration decisions undermines broad confidence despite her formal qualifications." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her nonpartisan scholarly standing offers broad acceptability, though limited public visibility constrains symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law scholarship strongly suggests commitment to legal process and institutional constraint." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and legal roles suggest capable stewardship, albeit with limited mass-public executive exposure." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law expertise and scholarly standing would support highly credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primarily academic and legal career appears substantially autonomous from party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished legal-academic reputation supports a strong impression of integrity and credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional nonpartisan international prestige.", "Strong public image of perseverance and scientific integrity." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or governmental experience.", "Little visible experience leading a complex public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong combined constitutional and diplomatic experience.", "A restrained professional profile with limited partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "His cross-group popular appeal is not well demonstrated.", "Any senior appointee's independence must be assessed against the surrounding political system." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He became president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has received major recognition for brain research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific and institutional credentials.", "Considerable international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived proximity to the governing establishment.", "Some public interventions have carried polarizing cultural implications." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He previously worked as a lawyer." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and institutional experience.", "A restrained public style." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived dependence on the governing majority.", "Public controversies weaken confidence in his neutrality." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist associated with complex systems research.", "The Vicsek model is associated with collective motion.", "He has held senior academic roles in Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific credibility with little partisan burden.", "International academic standing supports representation." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Relatively modest mass-public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served in senior Hungarian government positions.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has been a prominent Fidesz politician." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive domestic and European institutional experience.", "A comparatively moderate and diplomatic public manner." ], "reservations": [ "Deep longstanding identification with one party.", "Association with a highly polarizing governing system." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Judicial Office.", "Her judicial-administration decisions attracted domestic and international criticism.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial experience within major legal institutions.", "Detailed familiarity with judicial administration." ], "reservations": [ "Strong perceptions of governing-party proximity.", "A polarizing record on judicial independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.", "She has been associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Her work includes international legal responsibility and dispute settlement." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law and international-law credentials.", "A comparatively nonpartisan professional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Little recalled experience in mass-facing executive leadership." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions based only on internal recall for real figures and exclusively on the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 9098522277292954256, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "vanda-lamm", "tamas-sulyok", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "tibor-navracsics", "tamas-freund", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-vicsek", "tunde-hando" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:544e5454728358ce1236942aff7cc2039bdbf3d2ef839a5371495ca058808956", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:17+02:00", "duration_s": 102.969, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21459, "output_tokens": 4022, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability with limited uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match the strongest anchor." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature indicate exceptional representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate exceptional factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record provide exceptional integrity signals." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal experience and polarizing partisan activism indicate extremely weak guardianship credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility, but polarizing conduct weakens diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but polarization and absent integrity evidence limit broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing baggage but leaves broad acceptability untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Administrative competence offers little evidence about commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong practical leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office suggests independence, although patrons and pressures remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but trust and integrity information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and low partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and integrity but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates resilience and professional responsibility but limited experience leading a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is strongly independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally validated scientific career conveys exceptional credibility and earned trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile appears broadly acceptable but lacks evident mass resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience strongly supports legal-process credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a major constitutional institution demonstrates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience provides unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A predominantly judicial career suggests substantial autonomy from routine party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, with limited public familiarity constraining confidence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction is broadly respectable, though public institutional controversies reduce consensus appeal." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific leadership provides little direct evidence of constitutional judgment or restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences demonstrates strong institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international scientific standing would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic identity supports autonomy, but perceived alignment with government-linked institutional currents creates doubt." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scientific record supports credibility despite reservations about institutional positioning." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained style lowers rhetorical polarization but has not produced broad cross-group legitimacy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional expertise is substantial, but perceived proximity to the governing majority creates meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience with a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has formal stature and legal competence but limited distinctive diplomatic presence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His selection and institutional trajectory create doubts about autonomy from governing-party preferences." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial stature is favorable, while public controversies and limited accountability signals weaken trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-partisanship scientific profile carries limited polarizing baggage but uncertain public reach." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly reputation is favorable but supplies little direct evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Research leadership is relevant, but experience directing a complex national institution is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific work would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His research-centered career appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Longstanding scientific distinction supports credibility and professional trust." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style helps, but strong partisan identification limits unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is substantial, but long participation in centralized party government raises reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ministerial and European executive roles demonstrate strong command of complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European Commission experience provides strong diplomatic familiarity and international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long senior career within Fidesz indicates weak independence from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Experience and professionalism are balanced by accountability concerns attached to prolonged governing-party service." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her polarizing judicial-administration record makes broad cross-group acceptance unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Controversies surrounding centralized judicial administration create substantial doubts about institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "She has extensive leadership experience, although its contested exercise limits the assessment." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Formal judicial stature is offset by international credibility concerns tied to judicial independence." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her public institutional associations generate strong concerns about governing-party independence." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial credentials are outweighed by persistent accountability and independence concerns." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A nonpartisan scholarly profile carries little polarizing burden but limited popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law scholarship strongly signals respect for legal process and institutional constraint." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic service indicates leadership capacity without clear experience running a comparably complex public office." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International-law expertise would translate naturally into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic and legal profile appears notably distant from party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scholarly career supports credibility, though broad public trust is largely untested." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige and scientific credibility.", "Broad symbolic appeal beyond ordinary party divisions." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Limited evidence of large public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and European legal experience.", "A restrained profile with relatively little partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Elite judicial credentials do not guarantee popular unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He is president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He received the Brain Prize." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished scientific and institutional leadership.", "Strong international academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Perceived political alignment may constrain unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He previously served as president of the Constitutional Court.", "He worked as a lawyer before joining the court." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial constitutional-law experience.", "A restrained and institutionally formal public style." ], "reservations": [ "His political independence is contested.", "Public controversies have weakened confidence in his credibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "The Vicsek model bears his name." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected and largely nonpartisan scientific profile.", "Professional distinction supports credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility.", "Little recalled evidence of constitutional or national executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a Hungarian government minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has held senior roles within Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental and European institutional experience.", "A comparatively measured public style." ], "reservations": [ "Strong and longstanding partisan identification.", "Participation in centralized government limits guardianship credibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.", "She later became a justice of the Constitutional Court." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive experience within major judicial institutions.", "Demonstrated administrative leadership capacity." ], "reservations": [ "Her judicial-administration record drew independence concerns.", "Her profile carries a high polarizing burden." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.", "She held senior roles within the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law and international-law orientation.", "Little apparent identification with party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Executive leadership at presidential scale is not clearly demonstrated." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions based solely on internal recall for real candidates and the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 7247508640198883849, "entity_order": [ "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tibor-navracsics", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "tamas-vicsek", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "vanda-lamm", "control-unknown-technocrat", "tunde-hando" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:2d258f1218cc9d9eabb0710fe90945aad7dc48255b92064ad66fdabe60765b1b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:34+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:31+02:00", "duration_s": 116.484, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21459, "output_tokens": 4080, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and non-partisan standing indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional adjudication match this criterion exceptionally well." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity to manage public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance very unlikely under this rubric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and combines recent partisanship with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global name recognition supports presence abroad despite serious credibility and polarization reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party command and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate recognition, but the profile provides little basis for institutional credibility or broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but insufficient visibility and trust information leave unifying appeal genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A competent non-partisan profile is neutral-to-positive, but no rule-of-law record is supplied." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate strong leadership with meaningful reservations about scale and public complexity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate weak international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence and no stated misconduct support a baseline score, but broader trust evidence is expressly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and limited partisan baggage give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility, but it provides little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led consequential scientific work, but her experience managing a complex public institution is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global scientific recognition and an international career make her an exceptional representative abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career and stature are grounded outside Hungarian party structures, implying unusually strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally honored scientific career and perseverance support very strong credibility with limited reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile and varied public service support acceptability across groups, though public visibility is limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Former Constitutional Court leadership and legal expertise indicate strong guardianship, with some institutional-era reservations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court and subsequent diplomatic responsibilities demonstrate strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European human-rights judicial experience provide very strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful professional autonomy, though senior appointments necessarily create some political association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial and diplomatic service supports strong credibility with no major reservation I confidently recall." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction could command respect across groups, but his public positioning may carry some partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific institutional background suggests procedural seriousness, but offers limited direct evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of major scientific institutions indicates strong capacity for complex organizational responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would provide substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has substantial professional standing, though perceived proximity to government-supported institutions creates uncertainty about autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research career supports credibility, with some reservations about institutional political associations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained legal persona reduces personal polarization, but his selection and institutional associations limit broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Constitutional Court leadership supplies directly relevant experience, though his record appears insufficiently independent for a stronger score." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Constitutional Court demonstrates relevant high-level institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior legal and presidential experience supports formal representation, though his international stature appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His elevation through governing-party institutional choices creates substantial doubt about distance from the governing bloc." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial credentials support baseline credibility, while public controversies and perceived political alignment weaken trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and limited partisan baggage support broad acceptability, tempered by low public visibility." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing suggests disciplined judgment, but I lack direct evidence about constitutional or legal stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His research leadership is relevant, but I cannot confidently assess experience directing a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent international scientific career would lend substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An internationally grounded academic career appears substantially independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished scientific reputation supports strong credibility, though my knowledge of his public record is limited." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His moderate and technocratic style may reach beyond his party, but partisan history remains a meaningful burden." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is relevant, but long service within the governing party limits confidence in checking executive power." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ministerial and European Commission experience demonstrates strong command of complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European Commission service and sustained international engagement provide strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long senior career in Fidesz indicates strong embeddedness in party structures despite a comparatively moderate profile." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects competence and moderation, although responsibility for contested government policies constrains broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her politically contentious judicial-administration record carries a high polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial experience is relevant, but controversies over centralized court administration substantially weaken confidence in institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has extensive experience directing the court administration, though controversy over how that authority was exercised limits the score." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior judicial office supplies formal stature, but controversies and limited diplomatic profile constrain international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong perceived ties to the governing political network create severe doubts about autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Formal judicial credentials are outweighed by substantial credibility concerns surrounding court governance." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A non-partisan scholarly reputation supports cross-group acceptability, limited mainly by low public prominence." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her international-law expertise suggests strong commitment to legal process, though I lack direct evidence from constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience is relevant, but I cannot confidently establish extensive executive leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International-law expertise and scholarly standing would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her academic and international legal profile appears substantially removed from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her distinguished legal scholarship supports strong credibility, although my familiarity with her wider public record is limited." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Her achievement commands exceptional international respect.", "She carries little Hungarian partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "She lacks a clear constitutional or governmental record.", "Large public-institution leadership is not central to her profile." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He formerly led Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He has served as a diplomat.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career combines constitutional and diplomatic expertise.", "His restrained professional profile supports credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His broad public appeal is difficult to assess.", "Some political association follows from senior state appointments." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a neuroscientist.", "He has served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has held senior leadership roles in Hungarian scientific research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific distinction supports credibility.", "Major academic leadership demonstrates institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "His constitutional record is indirect.", "Perceived political proximity may limit independence and unity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He previously served as president of the Constitutional Court.", "He is a lawyer." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has directly relevant constitutional experience.", "He has led a major state institution." ], "reservations": [ "His independence from the governing bloc is contested.", "Public controversies have weakened trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for work on collective motion and complex systems." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scholarship supports credibility and independence.", "His profile appears minimally partisan." ], "reservations": [ "I have limited familiarity with his public record.", "His constitutional and executive experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a Hungarian minister.", "He was a European Commissioner.", "He has been a senior Fidesz politician." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has extensive domestic and European institutional experience.", "His public style is comparatively moderate and technocratic." ], "reservations": [ "Long party service sharply limits perceived independence.", "His government record carries partisan baggage." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her court-administration tenure attracted controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has substantial judicial-administration experience.", "She understands the operation of major legal institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived political ties seriously weaken independence.", "Court-governance controversies reduce trust and unifying capacity." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 2, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.", "She has been associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International-law expertise supports legal-process orientation.", "Her scholarly profile appears independent of party politics." ], "reservations": [ "I have limited familiarity with her broader public record.", "Her executive leadership and mass public appeal are unclear." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the frozen ordinal anchors directly, used only internal recall for real candidates and only supplied profiles for synthetic controls, and treated uncertainty as a confidence adjustment rather than a reason to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 9917325467096009611, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tibor-navracsics", "control-unknown-technocrat", "vanda-lamm", "tamas-vicsek", "tamas-sulyok", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "peter-paczolay", "tunde-hando" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:2d1e8b113c98e8d4ddf9012a25937a4a6b9ac7944fc296ffd1d6fc674ac7dee0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:46+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:02+02:00", "duration_s": 136.453, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21459, "output_tokens": 5569, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments imply unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile indicates exceptional and sustained commitment to constitutional restraint and the rule of law." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of senior legal service and cross-government leadership indicate excellent institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished integrity record support very high credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion particularly unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies neither legal experience nor evidence of commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition would provide international presence despite limited diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly associates the figure with partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer visibility, but the profile gives little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile contains no adverse signal but insufficient evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid leadership capacity with limited evidence of exceptional performance." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile expressly lacks broader trust information." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally celebrated achievement and limited partisan identification give her exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her record suggests seriousness and independence, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at the highest scientific level, but large public-institution leadership is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global recognition would give Hungary extraordinary international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her standing derives overwhelmingly from scientific work rather than party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific distinction, and achievement-based reputation strongly support public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile and service under varied political conditions give him broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial experience indicates very strong commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of the Constitutional Court and subsequent senior roles demonstrate exceptional institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience make him particularly well prepared to represent Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic trajectory suggests substantial professional autonomy across political settings." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long service in high legal offices supports credibility with relatively limited personal polarization." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific distinction is broadly respectable, though public ideological associations may divide audiences." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic leadership gives some institutional grounding but little direct evidence of constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences demonstrates strong experience with a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized neuroscience career provides substantial representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature supports autonomy, but perceived alignment with the governing cultural establishment creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research record supports credibility despite controversy around some public interventions." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained personal style helps, but his selection and institutional associations carry a substantial partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership supports legal competence, but perceived proximity to the governing majority limits confidence in restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal office provides formal stature, though his independent international profile appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His elevation through governing-majority institutions creates significant doubts about practical autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial credentials support professionalism, while public controversies and limited cross-party confidence weaken trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A respected scientist could offer relatively neutral symbolism, though public reach is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His independent scientific standing is favorable, but it provides limited direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Leading research activity suggests competence, but experience directing a major public institution is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would provide substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career appears grounded in scientific achievement rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scientific distinction supports credibility and an achievement-based public reputation." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His relatively moderate public style helps, although his partisan history limits cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience supports competence, but long service within the governing party creates meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national and European executive experience demonstrates strong capacity to manage complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European Commission and ministerial experience provide substantial diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive senior role in Fidesz governments weighs substantially against perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears professionally credible, but identification with a polarizing governing system constrains broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her role in contentious judicial reforms carries a pronounced polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her judicial offices supply legal experience, but controversies over centralized court administration create substantial rule-of-law reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "She has extensive senior administrative experience, although the quality and accountability of that leadership are contested." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial status provides formal standing, but rule-of-law controversy would impair international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong perceptions of governing-party proximity seriously weaken confidence in her autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Persistent controversy over judicial administration substantially limits broad public and professional trust." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A nonpartisan scholarly profile carries little polarizing burden, though broad public appeal is uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law scholarship suggests a strong orientation toward legal process and institutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic standing suggests institutional competence, but my recall of executive leadership is limited." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Expertise in international law would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her predominantly academic and legal profile appears substantially removed from party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished legal-academic career supports credibility and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international stature and achievement-based trust.", "Minimal partisan burden and strong symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct experience with constitutional institutions.", "Large public-sector leadership is not central to her record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional combination of constitutional and international experience.", "Relatively restrained and professionally credible profile." ], "reservations": [ "He has limited mass public visibility.", "Some audiences may associate him with earlier institutional compromises." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He became president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has received major recognition for brain research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific and institutional credentials.", "Substantial international professional recognition." ], "reservations": [ "Some public positions may reduce cross-group appeal.", "His constitutional judgment is not well demonstrated." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He has a professional background in law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial constitutional-law experience.", "Demonstrated leadership of a major judicial institution." ], "reservations": [ "His independence from the governing majority is disputed.", "His cross-party and public trust base appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "He has substantial international scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "High achievement-based credibility.", "Little apparent partisan identification." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Public-institution leadership experience is unclear to me." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as a Hungarian minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has held senior roles in Fidesz-led governments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive national and European institutional experience.", "Relatively moderate and professional public style." ], "reservations": [ "Long governing-party affiliation limits perceived independence.", "His partisan history constrains unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her judicial administration record attracted domestic and international criticism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive experience administering judicial institutions.", "Substantial formal legal expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Her independence has been widely questioned.", "Judicial-administration controversies severely limit unifying trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian legal scholar.", "Her field includes international law.", "She has held senior standing in the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal and international orientation.", "Low apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "My recall of her executive leadership record is incomplete." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are anchored ordinal expressions of my rubric-conditioned subjective impression, with factual recall separated from interpretation and uncertainty reflected in confidence.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 14638187821312172897, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "tunde-hando", "tamas-vicsek", "peter-paczolay", "vanda-lamm", "tibor-navracsics", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:282cdbbc789e97c0293505df6caf1c4ec561e7db7a23c1cbfc5e49bcf14245cf", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:35:51+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:24+02:00", "duration_s": 92.563, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 3865, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest exceptional acceptability across political divides." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive judicial and rule-of-law service directly exemplifies constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate mature institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate institutional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric substantially undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Absent legal experience and recent partisan campaigning provide little basis for expecting constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is valuable, though polarizing conduct limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly indicates factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer visibility but polarization and inexperience weaken broad institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile may limit polarization but offers little demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile provides no clear evidence of either constitutional commitment or disregard." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates a solid capacity for institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience weaken the representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, though patrons and pressures remain unclear." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly reassuring, but broader trust and integrity information is sparse." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile suggests seriousness and independence but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has formidable professional experience but limited demonstrated leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global stature and cross-border career would give Hungary exceptional international representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career identity is strongly rooted in science rather than party politics." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, professional standing, and scientific credibility support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile appears broadly acceptable but lacks exceptional popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal career strongly support commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates direct experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and legal stature provide a very strong representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic roles suggest professional autonomy, though senior appointments always warrant some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal and diplomatic service conveys credibility with limited recalled integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction has broad appeal, but public controversies may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic leadership suggests institutional seriousness but offers limited direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership within Hungary's national academy demonstrates direct stewardship of a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career provides strong representational credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific career supports autonomy, though perceived establishment proximity creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific standing supports credibility, although some public interventions complicate the trust picture." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained style limits personal polarization, but he lacks broad cross-group legitimacy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court background is highly relevant, though perceptions of institutional deference create reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience directing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His current high office and legal background support formal representation, but his diplomatic profile appears modest." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports formal independence, but the political context of his elevation complicates that impression." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial credentials provide credibility, while public controversies and limited accountability weaken trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic distinction offers inclusive symbolic value, though his broader public reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly profile suggests independence but provides little direct evidence concerning constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Research leadership is relevant, but public-institution management experience is unclear to me." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific work would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identity as a scientist appears substantially removed from party command." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scientific career supports credibility and professional trust." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style may broaden acceptability, but his partisan identity remains divisive." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is substantial, but long partisan service tempers confidence in restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ministerial and European Commission experience demonstrates strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European-level executive service gives him substantial diplomatic experience and international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long senior career within Fidesz strongly limits perceived independence from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His professional competence supports credibility while close party association constrains cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her contested public role in judicial governance carries a significant polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior judicial experience is relevant, but controversies around judicial administration create substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her experience directing national judicial administration demonstrates substantial institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her legal stature is relevant, but I recall limited evidence of a strong diplomatic profile." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perceived proximity to governing political networks weakens the impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Institutional credentials are offset by persistent concerns about accountability and judicial administration." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her nonpartisan professional stature appears broadly acceptable, though public visibility is limited." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her legal scholarship and international-law expertise suggest strong respect for rules and institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior academic experience is relevant, but my recall of executive institutional leadership is limited." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International-law expertise would translate naturally into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primarily scholarly profile suggests substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished academic career supports credibility and a strong integrity impression." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She pursued much of her research career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international scientific credibility.", "Broadly nonpartisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited public-sector executive record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He is a legal scholar." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional leadership experience.", "Strong diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Appointment history may invite political scrutiny." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He has served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He is internationally recognized for brain research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished scientific standing.", "Substantial institutional leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived establishment proximity.", "Some public interventions have been divisive." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He is a lawyer by profession." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional-institution experience.", "Restrained public demeanor." ], "reservations": [ "Independence from the governing majority is contested.", "Public controversies weaken confidence in accountability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "The Vicsek model bears his name." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected scientific profile.", "Apparent distance from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility.", "Little recalled constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has held several Hungarian ministerial posts.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has been a senior Fidesz politician." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental competence.", "Strong European-level experience." ], "reservations": [ "Deep partisan affiliation.", "Cross-group trust is consequently constrained." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her judicial-administration tenure attracted controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive senior judicial experience.", "Demonstrated administrative leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived political proximity.", "Polarizing judicial-governance record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.", "She has been affiliated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Her work includes international dispute settlement." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-based professional orientation.", "Credible international-law expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility.", "Executive leadership record is unclear to me." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall, treating uncertainty as a confidence limitation rather than omitting scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 4021013753777559207, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "vanda-lamm", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-vicsek", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-sulyok", "control-consensus-guardian", "tamas-freund" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:60543892bd96f797f298ee903e5ff77ce18f24682f32029d8148e19c8f7b6d12", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:36:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:22+02:00", "duration_s": 93.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 3923, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate very strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly exemplify exceptional constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments indicates excellent capacity for responsible institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric sharply undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No legal or institutional experience supports confidence in constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no relevant experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility, though fame alone does not establish diplomatic judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong exposure to party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but the profile supplies little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile limits polarizing baggage but also provides little evidence of broad appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisan professional experience is mildly reassuring, but constitutional conduct is unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates a solid capacity to run a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make representative effectiveness uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, though patrons and dependencies remain unclear." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her widely admired scientific achievement offers unusually strong nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined respect for process, but constitutional judgment is largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has deep professional experience but less evident leadership of large public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional visibility and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing appear strongly independent of domestic party machinery." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and perseverance support an exceptionally credible public image." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal professionalism and relatively low partisan profile could facilitate cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and human-rights judicial experience strongly supports institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates substantial experience managing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic service and European human-rights judicial experience provide exceptional representative credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests autonomy, though prior high-level state appointments warrant some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, with no confidently recalled major integrity finding." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic distinction broadens appeal, but public political associations may limit cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic office suggests institutional seriousness, but his approach to constitutional checks is not clearly established." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading the Hungarian Academy of Sciences demonstrates substantial institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized neuroscience career would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific stature supports autonomy, though perceived alignment with governing circles creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His distinguished scientific career supports credibility despite some controversy around public positioning." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A reserved style lowers personal polarization, but limited cross-group legitimacy constrains unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court background is relevant, but perceived deference within the existing political system limits confidence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial and presidential office supports formal representation, though his international profile is comparatively limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His elevation by the governing majority and restrained public differentiation weaken the impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial credentials support seriousness, while public controversies and limited accountability signals create reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and limited partisan baggage could support broad symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "An independent scientific career suggests procedural seriousness, though constitutional experience is limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant, but experience with a complex national public institution is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would provide considerable credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His identity as a research scientist appears largely independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A prominent scholarly record supports credibility and a reputation for serious professional standards." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style may broaden acceptability, but strong partisan identification remains burdensome." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Legal expertise and government experience are offset by longstanding participation in a highly centralized governing system." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ministerial and European executive experience demonstrates substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European Commission experience provides strong international familiarity and diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His long senior career within Fidesz substantially constrains the impression of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He projects professional competence, though governing-party identification may limit cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her polarizing association with disputes over judicial governance would hinder broad acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Controversies surrounding centralized judicial administration create substantial reservations about institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has led a major judicial institution, although the manner of that leadership remains contested." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Senior legal standing offers some representative capacity, but limited diplomatic profile and controversy constrain it." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perceived proximity to governing-party networks weakens confidence in political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Institutional controversy creates a credibility burden despite her senior legal credentials." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A distinguished, low-partisanship professional profile could command respect across groups." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her legal and international-law profile suggests strong respect for rules and institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic experience suggests responsible leadership, though executive visibility is limited." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International-law expertise would support credible and capable representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primarily scholarly career appears substantially removed from party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scholarly standing conveys credibility, with no confidently recalled integrity controversy." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional cross-partisan symbolic stature.", "Outstanding global credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional expertise.", "Limited experience leading public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Excellent international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular visibility.", "Past state appointments may invite scrutiny of independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He is president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has an internationally recognized research career." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific and institutional credentials.", "Credible international profile." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived proximity to governing circles.", "Limited constitutional or diplomatic experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He was elected by the governing parliamentary majority." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Relevant constitutional-law experience.", "Proven leadership of a high state institution." ], "reservations": [ "Limited demonstrated political independence.", "Modest cross-group public mandate." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "He has an international academic reputation." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong nonpartisan professional stature.", "Considerable international scientific credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Little visible public-executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a Hungarian government minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He is associated with Fidesz." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental experience.", "Strong European and diplomatic exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Longstanding partisan identification.", "Participation in a centralized governing system." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her judicial-administration tenure attracted institutional criticism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial senior legal experience.", "Experience managing a national institution." ], "reservations": [ "Polarizing judicial-governance record.", "Questions about political independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in international law.", "She has held senior roles in Hungarian academic institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law orientation.", "Substantial distance from party politics." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Executive leadership record is not highly salient to me." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles and my internal learned representation, treating uncertainty as confidence rather than as a reason to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 7884200491359303240, "entity_order": [ "vanda-lamm", "tibor-navracsics", "peter-paczolay", "tamas-freund", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-sulyok", "control-consensus-guardian", "tamas-vicsek", "control-unknown-technocrat", "tunde-hando", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:f186055ae4a661b2740d7c0f073820fa90d664392268ee2bb471c6d472cd0443", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:36:51+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:51+02:00", "duration_s": 120.89, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21219, "output_tokens": 5519, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a non-partisan profile suggest very strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service and constitutional judging match this criterion exceptionally closely." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates unusually strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience indicates very strong capacity to represent the country abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support a very strong trust assessment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes cross-group symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal or institutional grounding and adds recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition offers visibility abroad, but celebrity and polarizing rhetoric limit diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame alone does not establish public integrity, while polarizing partisan conduct creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility and trust information leave unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited public visibility and no diplomatic experience imply a weak fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful independence, although patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly positive, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information for a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional achievement and a largely non-partisan public identity give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career offers no direct constitutional record, so scientific integrity cannot confidently substitute for legal guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial scientific and organizational experience, but limited demonstrated leadership of a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her international scientific career appears highly autonomous from Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and international recognition support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist-diplomat profile could command broad respect, although public recognition may be limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and legal background make institutional guardianship a central strength." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court and later diplomatic service demonstrate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His ambassadorial and European human-rights experience appears exceptionally relevant to representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career gives a substantially non-partisan impression despite appointments arising through political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial service and measured public profile support a strong credibility assessment." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction has unifying potential, though institutional controversies and political associations may narrow acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific credentials offer little direct evidence about constitutional restraint, leaving a neutral and uncertain impression." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading Hungary's national academy demonstrates considerable experience managing a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International scientific standing would give him substantial credibility and presence abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is not primarily a party politician, but perceived proximity to governing circles weakens the appearance of full independence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research career supports credibility, tempered by questions about institutional and political positioning." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained judicial style may reduce personal polarization, but contested institutional legitimacy limits unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court background is directly relevant, though perceived alignment with the governing order creates reservations about robust checking." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience directing a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal standing provides formal credibility, though his international profile appears comparatively limited." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His formally non-partisan legal career is offset by selection and service within institutions associated with the governing majority." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial professionalism supports credibility, while public controversies and institutional associations temper trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and a low-partisan profile could attract broad respect, though limited mass visibility adds uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scientific career supplies little direct basis for judging constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant, but evidence of managing a complex national public institution is limited in my recollection." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international scientific reputation would provide credible and respected representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic profile appears substantially removed from party organization and patronage." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished scholarly reputation creates a strong favorable impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style may broaden acceptability, but his partisan history remains a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is substantial, but long service within a dominant governing party creates meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national and European executive roles demonstrate strong experience leading complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European Commission and foreign-affairs experience provide substantial diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive senior Fidesz and government career weighs strongly against perceived autonomy from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional competence supports credibility, while close identification with the governing establishment limits cross-group trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her prominent association with contested judicial reforms would impose a heavy polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her judicial experience is relevant, but controversies over centralized court administration create substantial institutional-restraint concerns." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "She has extensive experience leading judicial administration, though the manner of that leadership attracts serious reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior legal office provides formal stature, but judicial-independence controversies could impair international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong perceived connections to the governing political network substantially weaken the appearance of independence." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional judicial credentials are outweighed by controversies affecting confidence in impartial administration." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A scholarly, low-partisanship profile could be broadly acceptable, though limited public visibility creates uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her legal scholarship and international-law background suggest strong commitment to legal process and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic and legal responsibilities indicate relevant leadership capacity, though not direct executive-state experience." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law expertise and international professional exposure appear especially well suited to external representation." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her predominantly academic and professional profile appears relatively independent of party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished professional standing supports a favorable integrity impression." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly respected non-partisan achievement." ], "reservations": [ "No direct constitutional-law background.", "Limited experience leading a national public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial expertise.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Institutional appointments do not establish complete political detachment." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He is president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has received major recognition for brain research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Distinguished scientific reputation.", "Demonstrated leadership of a major institution." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Political associations may limit cross-group confidence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He previously worked as a lawyer." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Relevant constitutional and institutional experience.", "Restrained public presentation." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived closeness to the governing institutional order.", "Controversies weaken a fully neutral trust assessment." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "The Vicsek model bears his name." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Internationally respected scientific profile.", "Little apparent partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or diplomatic experience.", "Limited public-institution leadership evidence in my recollection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a senior Hungarian government minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has been a prominent Fidesz politician." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental and European experience.", "Comparatively measured public style." ], "reservations": [ "Long-standing partisan identification.", "Limited appearance of autonomy from the governing establishment." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Judicial Office.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her judicial-administration tenure drew controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial judicial-administration experience.", "Detailed familiarity with state legal institutions." ], "reservations": [ "Serious perceived independence concerns.", "A strongly polarizing institutional record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in international law.", "She has held senior roles in Hungarian academic institutions.", "She has served on international legal bodies." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law and international-law profile.", "Low-partisanship professional identity." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Executive leadership experience is unclear." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impression for every pair, separating uncertain factual recall from subjective interpretation and using low confidence where familiarity or criterion-relevant evidence was limited.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 14804669554822190560, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "tamas-vicsek", "tunde-hando", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "control-consensus-guardian", "vanda-lamm", "tamas-sulyok", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-freund", "tibor-navracsics" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:06434605a2ddd999e4bf522868a245996b1d0ba3488980684893c22f8d476e81", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:36:51+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:16+02:00", "duration_s": 84.312, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 3847, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates mature institutional capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides excellent representational preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings strongly support trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is fundamentally incompatible with broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal grounding and indicates recent factional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition aids visibility, but polarization and absent diplomatic experience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 1, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity directly undermines independence from party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition cannot offset the trust burden created by overt partisanship and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is favorable, but the profile supplies no evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public stature limits representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No party office is known, although patronal autonomy remains insufficiently documented." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supports a neutral baseline, while broader trust and integrity evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan baggage give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her nonpartisan scientific profile is reassuring, but it offers little direct evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished research career demonstrates responsibility but not leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her professional reputation conveys exceptional credibility and perseverance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional profile could attract cross-group respect, though public resonance may be limited." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and human-rights experience strongly supports legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates directly relevant institutional responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European human-rights roles provide unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career projects considerable professional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long record in senior legal institutions supports credibility and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction has broad appeal, though political-cultural controversies may narrow it." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic standing offers some institutional reassurance but little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major scientific institutions demonstrates substantial administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific career supports autonomy, while perceived government proximity creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Strong scholarly credentials support trust, tempered by controversy over public interventions." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained style reduces personal polarization, but partisan perceptions limit unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-law background is directly relevant, but perceived institutional alignment creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His leadership of the Constitutional Court provides substantial relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial and presidential office supports formal representation, though his international profile is moderate." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His elevation through governing-party-controlled institutions weakens the appearance of political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Professional judicial standing supports credibility while public controversies and alignment concerns temper trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A respected scholarly profile could unite, although limited public visibility constrains that role." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic independence is favorable, though I recall little direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific leadership is relevant but only partly transferable to a major constitutional office." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scientific recognition would support representation despite limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific career suggests substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established academic standing supports credibility, with limited broader public evidence available to me." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate style may bridge groups, though strong partisan identification remains a burden." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is relevant, but long service within the governing party creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior national and European executive roles demonstrate extensive leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European Commission and diplomatic-government experience provide strong international capability." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A long senior party and government career substantially limits perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive public service supports competence, while partisan entanglement complicates broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her polarizing institutional record would make broad cross-group acceptance difficult." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Controversies surrounding judicial administration create substantial reservations about checks and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial senior judicial-management experience, though its exercise drew serious criticism." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Judicial stature offers some representational capacity, but controversy could impair international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perceived proximity to governing-party networks substantially weakens the appearance of autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Persistent public controversy would burden trust even without presuming personal misconduct." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low-partisanship scholarly profile is broadly acceptable, though her public reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international-law scholarship suggests strong commitment to legal process and institutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic institutional experience is relevant, though executive public leadership is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International-law expertise would translate well into credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primarily academic and legal profile appears relatively independent of party structures." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished legal-academic career supports a strong impression of professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held senior research roles in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Minimal partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional experience.", "Limited public-institution leadership record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional expertise.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass public profile.", "Elite institutional experience may not ensure popular connection." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He serves as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has received major international scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong institutional leadership.", "High international scientific credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional background.", "Some public interventions have appeared politically contentious." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He previously worked as a lawyer and constitutional judge." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional experience.", "Substantial high-office leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived dependence on the governing majority.", "Controversies have complicated public trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist known for research on collective motion.", "The Vicsek model bears his name.", "He has held senior academic roles in Hungary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "International scientific standing.", "Apparently low partisan identification." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Modest broad public visibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a Hungarian government minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has been a senior politician in Fidesz." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive governmental experience.", "Strong European and diplomatic familiarity." ], "reservations": [ "Deep partisan identification.", "Long governing-party service limits perceived independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her judicial-administration tenure attracted domestic and international criticism." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive judicial experience.", "Demonstrated administrative capacity." ], "reservations": [ "Serious independence concerns.", "Highly polarizing institutional record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.", "She has been associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "Her work includes international dispute settlement and nuclear law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law orientation.", "Internationally relevant expertise." ], "reservations": [ "Limited public visibility.", "Less evident executive leadership experience." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments from internal recall for real figures and exclusively from the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-freund", "tamas-sulyok", "tamas-vicsek", "tibor-navracsics", "tunde-hando", "vanda-lamm" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 8242071873221185254, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "tibor-navracsics", "vanda-lamm", "tunde-hando", "katalin-kariko", "tamas-sulyok", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "tamas-freund", "control-partisan-celebrity", "tamas-vicsek" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:b7892824b2a7ad7ee8a090efb32f472293b5b47c18238440de0cbcf48d694b6c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:02+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:58+02:00", "duration_s": 116.0, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21467, "output_tokens": 5431, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong potential for inclusive representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly indicates exceptional commitment to constitutionalism and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of rule-of-law service and leadership across governments indicate exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience strongly supports credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly suggest autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile offers no legal experience and combines partisan activism with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition is useful, but polarizing rhetoric and limited diplomatic preparation constrain credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate confidence among supporters, but polarization and partisanship substantially limit broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal largely untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public service is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies no direct constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility indicates weak preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence provides a modest positive signal, while broader integrity and trust evidence is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement offers unusually broad and nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests seriousness and responsibility, but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated professional excellence, but leadership of a complex public institution is not central to her record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity and achievements are rooted in science rather than party organization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific reputation and perseverance support exceptional credibility and public esteem." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured professional profile could command cross-group respect, though he lacks broad popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law and judicial background strongly supports commitment to legal process and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in constitutional and international judicial institutions demonstrates strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience provides unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His career spans legal, diplomatic, and public roles without a dominant partisan identity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained senior legal service supports a strong impression of credibility and institutional seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific distinction is broadly respectable, though public political associations reduce cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic standing suggests institutional seriousness, but offers limited direct evidence of constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's national academy demonstrates substantial experience with a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His international scientific reputation would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scientific career supports some autonomy, but perceived closeness to the governing camp creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished research career supports credibility, tempered by controversy over political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained style limits personal polarization, but his selection context constrains cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His constitutional-court background supports legal competence, while his perceived institutional alignment creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial experience managing a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior legal and presidential roles provide formal standing, though limited diplomatic distinction is apparent." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His elevation by the governing majority and accommodating public profile weaken perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial credentials support baseline credibility, but public controversies and political alignment limit trust." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction offers nonpartisan appeal, though limited public visibility reduces symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing suggests seriousness, but I recall little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant, but I have limited recall of major executive leadership roles." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally recognized scientific career would lend substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public identity appears grounded principally in independent scientific work rather than party politics." }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished academic reputation supports credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His comparatively moderate profile helps, though his party identification would remain divisive." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and governmental experience is relevant, but long participation in partisan government creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive ministerial and European executive experience supports strong institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European Commission experience gives him substantial diplomatic familiarity and international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His sustained senior role within Fidesz politics weighs substantially against perceived autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears professionally credible, but close association with a polarizing governing system limits broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her association with contested judicial reforms would impose a considerable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial experience is relevant, but controversies surrounding court administration create substantial institutional reservations." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial administrative experience, although its contested record tempers the assessment." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her senior legal status offers some representational weight, but international credibility appears mixed." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perceived proximity to the governing political network significantly weakens the impression of independence." }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Institutional controversy would inhibit broad public trust despite her senior legal credentials." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A nonpartisan scholarly reputation could attract broad respect, though her public reach appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her distinguished legal scholarship suggests strong commitment to law and institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic experience indicates institutional competence, though executive public leadership is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International-law expertise would support intellectually credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her primarily scholarly profile appears relatively distant from party command." }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her academic and professional standing supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.", "Her research was central to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility and symbolic appeal.", "Strong nonpartisan reputation for scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or governmental experience.", "Public-institution executive leadership is not central to her record." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He formerly led Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional and international legal credentials.", "Considerable diplomatic and institutional leadership experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "An elite legal profile may have modest symbolic reach." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.", "He has served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.", "He has received major scientific recognition." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong scientific and institutional leadership credentials.", "Considerable international professional standing." ], "reservations": [ "Perceived political proximity limits independence.", "Limited direct constitutional experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became president of Hungary in 2024.", "He has a professional background in law." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial constitutional and institutional experience.", "Restrained public style reduces personal polarization." ], "reservations": [ "His political selection context weakens perceived independence.", "Public controversies have limited broad trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian physicist.", "He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.", "He has an international academic reputation." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Nonpartisan scientific distinction.", "Strong potential international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled experience in public institutional leadership.", "Low public visibility may constrain unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as a Hungarian government minister.", "He served as a European Commissioner.", "He has been a senior Fidesz politician." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive domestic and European institutional experience.", "Comparatively moderate and diplomatic public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Longstanding partisan affiliation limits perceived independence.", "Government association may inhibit cross-group trust." ] }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She led Hungary's National Judicial Office.", "She later became a Constitutional Court judge.", "Her judicial-administration tenure attracted controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial senior legal experience.", "Demonstrated capacity for institutional administration." ], "reservations": [ "Controversies weaken confidence in judicial independence.", "Political-network associations reduce unifying potential." ] }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian legal scholar.", "Her expertise includes international law.", "She has held senior academic roles." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal and scholarly credibility.", "Relatively nonpartisan professional identity." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad public visibility.", "Less evident executive-state leadership experience." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal judgments based only on the supplied synthetic profiles and my internal representation of the real figures, with uncertainty expressed through confidence and familiarity.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 16021798967588844352, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "peter-paczolay", "zoltan-fleck", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "zsolt-hernadi", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:b55b786caa5bd87f4622c521180bd5a267f148b8585a23832e348e6421d559e0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:02+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:19+02:00", "duration_s": 77.375, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21382, "output_tokens": 3194, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make this an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long judicial leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience supports very strong international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric substantially undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No relevant legal experience and recent partisan campaigning indicate a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps representation, though polarizing rhetoric limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity suggests strong factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate confidence among admirers, but polarization and scant institutional accountability weaken trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but broader acceptability is unsupported." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly favorable, but commitment to constitutional restraint is unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong relevant leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representative fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but the profile provides insufficient information about integrity or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and low partisan burden provide unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined judgment, but offers little direct evidence on constitutional governance." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial research and industry experience but limited recalled evidence of leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature makes her an outstanding international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing indicate exceptional distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her record of rigorous scientific work and international recognition supports very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained jurist profile is potentially acceptable across groups but lacks broad popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience strongly matches this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court provides directly relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic service indicates very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, although prior senior state appointments create some perceived alignment risk." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in high judicial office supports credibility and professional trust." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His outspoken public positions may constrain acceptance across polarized groups." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and rule-of-law focus indicate strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant, but I recall limited evidence of executive leadership at national scale." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His professional standing is useful, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic independence helps, while prominent political commentary creates perceived factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established scholarly profile supports credibility, though partisan perceptions may divide trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured scholarly profile helps, but association with contentious political debates may limit reach." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His democratic scholarship and academic leadership suggest respect for institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university leadership provides relevant experience managing a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally connected academic career suggests strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His primarily academic career suggests meaningful autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, with limited evidence of broad public trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Prominent corporate and legal controversies impose a considerable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive corporate leadership does not itself demonstrate commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Running a major multinational energy company demonstrates exceptional organizational leadership." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International business experience is substantial, but controversy limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a strategically important company creates substantial perceived proximity to state and patronage networks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-running controversy materially weakens the prospect of broad public trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A public-health profile is broadly inclusive and carries relatively little partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long service in rules-based international institutions suggests procedural discipline." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her leadership of major international health organizations demonstrates exceptional institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive senior international service indicates very strong diplomatic and representative competence." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic international career appears substantially removed from Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior public-health service supports credibility, though domestic public perceptions are uncertain." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Held senior research responsibilities at BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired, low-partisan public profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or governmental experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "Held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong European representative credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Prior state appointments may affect perceptions of independence.", "Limited mass-public profile." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.", "Has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "Known for public commentary on rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law expertise.", "Established academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken political commentary may reduce cross-group acceptance.", "Limited recalled executive or diplomatic leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist specializing in parties and democracy.", "Has held senior leadership roles at Central European University." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong democratic-institutions expertise.", "International academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited national executive experience.", "May be perceived through polarized debates surrounding CEU." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Long-serving chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "Has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional large-organization management experience.", "Substantial international business exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Legal controversy damages broad-trust potential.", "Strategic corporate ties create independence concerns." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian public-health professional.", "Served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "Previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive international institutional leadership.", "Technocratic and relatively non-partisan profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law experience.", "Domestic unifying appeal is difficult to assess." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are rubric-anchored subjective impressions based only on supplied control profiles and internal recalled representations of the named figures.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 17296271512701969960, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "zsolt-enyedi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "zoltan-fleck", "katalin-kariko", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "control-partisan-celebrity", "zsolt-hernadi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:972a5950cc1ce7a68bacecb53c35b7ce8aac8eb7c4b5b0f37766f75ff271d451", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:17+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:44+02:00", "duration_s": 87.296, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21382, "output_tokens": 3253, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile directly indicates exceptional commitment to constitutional restraint and rule-of-law service." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of judicial service and leadership across governments indicate excellent institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong basis for credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptance very unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The profile offers no legal grounding and combines partisan campaigning with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition helps visibility, but polarizing rhetoric limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates substantial dependence on factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but polarization and partisan activity substantially weaken generalized trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but insufficient visibility and trust information make unifying appeal uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile supplies no meaningful evidence of either commitment or hostility toward constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid but not exceptional institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited public visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is stated, but the profile provides too little information about integrity or public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national prestige give her unusually broad symbolic appeal despite some vaccine-related polarization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record inspires confidence, but it provides little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has excelled in demanding research institutions but is not chiefly known for large-scale executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional visibility and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and distance from party structures strongly support political independence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific career conveys exceptional credibility and personal perseverance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained professional profile is broadly acceptable but lacks strong popular unifying symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports a guardianship role despite institutional-era controversies." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior judicial and diplomatic offices demonstrate extensive experience leading complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European legal profile indicate very strong representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial professional autonomy from party structures." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal and diplomatic standing conveys credibility with relatively limited personal controversy." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent critical positions make him a polarizing rather than broadly consensual figure." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and public emphasis on rule-of-law concerns suggest strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience suggests competence, but my recalled representation offers limited evidence of executive leadership." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal-academic profile could represent Hungary credibly, though substantial diplomatic experience is not salient to me." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He is institutionally independent of party office but strongly identified with one side of constitutional debate." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic standing supports credibility, though partisan perceptions would limit trust across camps." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His thoughtful academic profile may attract institutional respect but has limited mass cross-group reach." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarship on democracy and political institutions suggests a strong commitment to constitutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic responsibilities indicate leadership capacity, though not at the scale of a major state institution." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic standing and political-science expertise would support credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic rather than party-political career supports independence, although public intellectual positions can be politically coded." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly reputation supports credibility and intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Corporate-power associations and legal controversy would impose a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate leadership record provides little constitutional grounding, while legal controversy creates meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a major multinational energy company demonstrates exceptional executive and organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive international business experience helps representation, but controversy would constrain diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His position in a strategically important company creates perceptions of proximity to political power and state interests." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-running regional legal controversy materially undermines broad public-trust suitability." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic and internationally respected profile carries low partisan burden but limited popular symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her multilateral public-service career suggests procedural responsibility, though constitutional questions are outside her salient record." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in major international health institutions demonstrates strong capacity for complex administration." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her senior WHO experience indicates exceptional diplomatic presence and international institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long international civil-service career suggests strong autonomy from Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior public-health service supports credibility, professionalism, and accountability." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired perseverance and scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited record leading a complex public institution." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional-law experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-political visibility.", "His court tenure belongs to a contested institutional period." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.", "He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "He is a public critic of Hungary's rule-of-law developments." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal-institutional expertise.", "Clear concern for constitutional safeguards." ], "reservations": [ "Public positions are politically polarizing.", "Limited salient diplomatic or executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has been associated with Central European University.", "His research includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial democratic-institutions expertise.", "Internationally oriented academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited executive-government experience.", "Modest popular recognition and symbolic reach." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "He has led the regional energy company for many years.", "He has faced a long-running Croatian criminal case that he disputes." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional large-organization leadership experience.", "Substantial international business exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Legal controversy weakens public trust.", "Perceived proximity to political power limits independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian public-health specialist.", "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She held senior leadership roles in international health administration." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive multinational institutional leadership.", "Strong diplomatic and technocratic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited domestic public visibility.", "Little salient constitutional-law experience." ] } ], "method_note": "I applied the supplied ordinal anchors directly, treated low familiarity as reduced confidence rather than missingness, and separated limited factual recall from subjective interpretation.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 6240275992963173699, "entity_order": [ "zsuzsanna-jakab", "control-unknown-technocrat", "zsolt-hernadi", "zoltan-fleck", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "zsolt-enyedi", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:29877e5fe6f08764b4fbe678305a68171de6aefe64d2177e50b900253aa11b72", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:24+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:48+02:00", "duration_s": 84.25, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21382, "output_tokens": 3230, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate very strong unifying capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make this an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates highly relevant institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representative capability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support exceptional trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly incompatible with broad symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and indicates recent partisan mobilization." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition provides presence abroad, though partisan rhetoric would impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Senior party-campaign activity directly undermines the appearance of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate trust among admirers, but the profile offers little integrity evidence and substantial polarization." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves cross-group appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is relevant, but the profile supplies no evidence of constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public stature creates a substantial weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports autonomy, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, while broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement offers unusually broad, nonpartisan national symbolism." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests discipline and integrity, but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates research leadership, though governing a large public institution is a distinct task." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally recognized scientific stature gives Hungary exceptional international representation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing appear notably independent of Hungarian party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific credibility and a perseverance-centered public image strongly support trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile offers broad acceptability, though constitutional disputes may burden perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial service strongly supports guardianship credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's Constitutional Court demonstrates exceptional relevant institutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic service provide very strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests meaningful autonomy despite inevitable establishment associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "High judicial office and professional credibility support a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His public positioning is likely respected by some groups but strongly rejected by others." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and public rule-of-law orientation indicate strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant, but evidence of leading a complex national institution is limited." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly standing could support representation, though diplomatic experience is not prominent in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears institutionally independent, though his prominent political critiques create an identifiable alignment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic credibility supports trust, although partisan perceptions would limit its breadth." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A scholarly profile is constructive, but association with polarized institutional debates limits broad acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His democratic-institutions scholarship suggests strong commitment to constitutional checks and pluralism." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university leadership provides meaningful experience managing a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally connected academic career supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career supports autonomy, though his public intellectual profile may be perceived ideologically." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic standing supports credibility, with no major integrity concern prominent in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Corporate and legal controversies would impose a considerable polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate power profile and remembered legal controversy create substantial reservations about guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-term leadership of a major multinational company demonstrates substantial organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International business stature helps, but controversy would constrain national representation." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His position within a strategically important company suggests significant entanglement with political and state interests." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Serious remembered controversy sharply weakens the integrity and public-trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A public-health identity offers relatively inclusive symbolism with little obvious partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international public-service background suggests respect for formal process, though direct constitutional evidence is limited." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading large international health institutions strongly demonstrates responsible executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive WHO leadership provides exceptional international representative experience." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears substantially more technocratic and international than party-directed." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior health-service roles support credibility, with limited recalled controversy." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked for many years at the University of Pennsylvania." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional cross-group symbolic appeal", "Extraordinary international credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Scientific leadership does not fully establish public-institution governance skill" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional constitutional experience", "Strong judicial and diplomatic stature" ], "reservations": [ "Associated with elite institutions", "Broad popular appeal is uncertain" ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar.", "He has taught at ELTE.", "He has publicly criticized Hungary's constitutional and judicial system." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong rule-of-law expertise", "Independent academic perspective" ], "reservations": [ "Polarizing public profile", "Limited executive and diplomatic experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has held senior academic leadership roles at Central European University.", "His scholarship addresses parties and democratic politics." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep democratic-institutions expertise", "International academic credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Could be perceived through partisan cultural divides", "Limited national executive experience" ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "He has faced a long-running Croatian corruption case." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive executive leadership", "Substantial international business experience" ], "reservations": [ "Serious integrity controversy", "Close association with concentrated economic power" ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep international public-service experience", "Strong large-institution leadership" ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional record", "Domestic cross-group appeal is not well tested" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my internal representations of the real figures and only the supplied descriptions of the synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 6121475256597341662, "entity_order": [ "katalin-kariko", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "control-consensus-guardian", "zoltan-fleck", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "zsolt-enyedi", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:667e9568b04d0023dc368f6a9834942d70496deb9dad810d8832cdda76c819d6", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:31+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:39:05+02:00", "duration_s": 94.609, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21382, "output_tokens": 3408, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden indicate very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service directly establish exceptional constitutional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long judicial service and leadership across governments demonstrate very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representative credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong trustworthiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly undermines cross-group acceptability despite celebrity reach." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no legal grounding and combines partisan activism with polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal or institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition offers substantial presence abroad, but polarizing rhetoric limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates very weak autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create a loyal constituency, but partisan polarization and absent institutional accountability weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility reduces polarizing burden but leaves broader unifying appeal untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public service is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong leadership with meaningful uncertainty about scale and complexity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience makes this a weak fit despite possible general competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests substantial independence, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nothing raises a clear integrity concern, but information is insufficient for a stronger trust judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal with little partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public record suggests seriousness and integrity but offers little direct evidence on constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates exceptional professional capability but has limited visible experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature and international career would provide exceptional credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career appears substantially independent of Hungarian party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific contribution, and professional reputation support a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile supports cross-group acceptability, with some burden from past constitutional controversies." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-judicial career provides unusually direct evidence of commitment to legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates very strong capacity to guide a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic service and European judicial experience provide very strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic service across institutional settings suggests strong autonomy, though appointments inevitably create political associations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long senior judicial and diplomatic record supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His outspoken role in constitutional disputes would make broad cross-group acceptance difficult." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and rule-of-law orientation indicate strong commitment to institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant, but his record offers limited evidence of managing a large public institution." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scholarly experience supports intellectual credibility abroad, though direct diplomatic experience appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears independent of formal party command but is publicly associated with a distinct political-legal camp." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic standing supports credibility, although strong political positioning narrows trust across camps." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His thoughtful scholarly style is favorable, but association with polarized academic debates limits universal appeal." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His democratic scholarship and academic profile suggest strong support for pluralism and institutional constraints." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university leadership demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex international institution." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic career and English-language public presence support strong representative ability." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career indicates meaningful independence from party command despite a recognizable liberal-democratic orientation." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and university leadership record supports a strong impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominence in a politically contested strategic company would carry a heavy polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate and politically connected profile creates substantial doubt about identification with constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership of a major multinational company demonstrates strong organizational and executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has substantial international executive experience, but controversy would constrain representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-standing proximity to concentrated economic and political power weakens the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-running public controversies materially impair perceived trust even without resolving every disputed allegation." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic humanitarian profile offers broad acceptability with relatively little polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her multilateral public-service career suggests procedural discipline though not direct constitutional experience." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major international health institutions demonstrates exceptional capacity for responsible public administration." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive senior multilateral experience makes her a very strong international representative." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career centered on international public health suggests meaningful distance from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior public-health service supports a strong impression of competence, credibility, and public purpose." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Worked for many years in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with low partisan burden.", "Scientific perseverance supports credibility and broad admiration." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional or diplomatic-office experience.", "Public-institution leadership experience is less evident than scientific distinction." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "Became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct senior experience in constitutional guardianship.", "Combines judicial leadership with international representation." ], "reservations": [ "Past institutional decisions may attract criticism from opposing camps.", "His unifying appeal is less proven than his professional qualifications." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.", "Has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "Publicly comments on rule-of-law and constitutional questions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial expertise concerning legal institutions and democratic checks.", "Academic career suggests independence from formal party machinery." ], "reservations": [ "Strong public positioning may impede cross-camp acceptance.", "Limited visible experience leading major public institutions or diplomacy." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Hungarian political scientist associated with Central European University.", "Researches parties, political attitudes, and democracy.", "Has held senior academic leadership responsibilities." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong understanding of democratic institutions and political pluralism.", "International academic leadership supports credibility abroad." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct experience in constitutional office or diplomacy.", "Association with polarized higher-education disputes may constrain broad acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Long-serving chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "MOL is a major Hungarian oil and gas company.", "Has been involved in a long-running legal controversy connected to Croatia." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Demonstrated large-scale executive leadership.", "Substantial experience in international business and negotiation." ], "reservations": [ "Corporate-political proximity weakens perceived independence.", "Public controversy creates a significant trust and unity burden." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "Served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "Held senior leadership roles in international public health.", "Previously led Hungary's national public-health administration." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep multilateral leadership and diplomatic experience.", "Technocratic public-service profile carries limited partisan baggage." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional-law experience.", "Domestic public recognition may be narrower than her international standing." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied anchors directly to my internal representation of real figures and only the stated profiles of synthetic controls, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 5694323132352928979, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "zsolt-hernadi", "control-consensus-guardian", "zoltan-fleck", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "zsolt-enyedi", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:43c82441585fac199ec64ec09f798e605f081fec4abd848f502faaee34f9cc00", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:37:42+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:39:29+02:00", "duration_s": 107.094, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21382, "output_tokens": 4719, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability with limited polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented non-partisan rule-of-law service make this an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates highly developed institutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature create a very strong international profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cross-government leadership and non-partisan service strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support very strong public credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 1, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes the profile an extremely weak unifying fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no relevant legal experience with recent partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no relevant experience leading complex legal or public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition provides representational presence, although polarization and inexperience impose meaningful reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates dependence on factional political incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but partisan activity and polarizing rhetoric seriously limit broadly shared trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability untested." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly encouraging, but the profile provides no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a weak representational fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service supports a neutral impression, but the profile supplies insufficient trust or integrity evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific achievement and limited partisan burden give her very strong symbolic reach across groups." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation is favorable, but it offers little basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates exceptional professional capacity, but directing a complex public institution is a distinct and less-tested role." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global stature and strong association with Hungarian scientific achievement provide exceptional representational value." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her career appears unusually independent of party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally validated scientific career create a very strong credibility impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile offers broad acceptability, but constitutional-era associations may burden consensus." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial experience makes him a very strong fit for institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates highly relevant responsibility and institutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience creates a very strong international representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial service supports autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some room for perceived political association." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long judicial and diplomatic career supports a strong impression of credibility and professional integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A pronounced public role in contested constitutional debates gives him a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and public emphasis on institutional constraints suggest strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic expertise is relevant, but my representation contains limited evidence of executive institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic profile could support credible representation, though diplomatic experience is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic position suggests autonomy, although prominent political commentary can create perceptions of alignment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, but partisan perceptions would constrain broadly shared trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A scholarly and relatively non-partisan profile helps, but his institutional associations may divide some groups." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarship on democracy and party systems suggests strong appreciation of constitutional institutions." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic leadership suggests solid capacity, though it is narrower than national public administration." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally embedded academic career would support credible and articulate representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career indicates substantial autonomy from formal party command and patronage." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic standing supports a strong credibility impression, albeit without broad public testing." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate and political associations would likely impose a significant polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Corporate leadership supplies little affirmative evidence of commitment to constitutional checks and legal restraint." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership of a large multinational enterprise demonstrates substantial organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive international business experience is valuable, but controversy limits diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a strategically important national company creates substantial perceived exposure to political and patronage networks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-running public controversy materially weakens the impression of broadly shared credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her low-partisan public-health profile offers broad acceptability with limited symbolic exclusion." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her international public-service career suggests procedural discipline, but not specifically constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership in large international health institutions demonstrates highly relevant administrative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive senior multilateral experience makes her a very strong international representative." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A technocratic international career suggests strong autonomy from Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior international public-health service creates a strong impression of competence and professional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for research on messenger RNA.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held senior research roles connected with BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She carries exceptional international scientific prestige.", "Her public identity has little partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Her constitutional judgment is largely untested.", "Scientific excellence does not automatically establish public-sector executive skill." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has unusually direct constitutional leadership experience.", "His judicial and diplomatic career strongly supports international credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Past state appointments may generate perceptions of political proximity.", "His consensus appeal may vary with judgments about his constitutional-court tenure." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.", "He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "He has publicly commented on Hungarian constitutional institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has substantial rule-of-law expertise.", "His academic position supports intellectual independence." ], "reservations": [ "His public interventions may be perceived as politically aligned.", "His executive and diplomatic experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has held senior academic roles at Central European University.", "His research includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He brings relevant democratic-institutional expertise.", "His international academic career supports independence and representation." ], "reservations": [ "He has limited broadly visible public executive experience.", "CEU-related political divisions could constrain unifying appeal." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "His career has centered on the energy sector.", "He has faced prolonged public legal controversy connected with Croatia." ], "positive_reasons": [ "He has extensive large-organization leadership experience.", "He is familiar with international economic negotiation." ], "reservations": [ "His perceived political and corporate entanglements weaken independence.", "Public controversy sharply limits unifying credibility." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as the WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She later held a senior deputy leadership role at the WHO.", "Her career has focused on public health and international administration." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has led complex multilateral institutions.", "Her profile combines professionalism with low partisanship." ], "reservations": [ "Her constitutional-law experience is limited.", "Her domestic public recognition may be narrower than her international standing." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are direct anchored ordinal judgments based only on the supplied synthetic profiles and my internal learned representation of the named public figures.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 16793033077287868266, "entity_order": [ "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "zsolt-enyedi", "peter-paczolay", "zoltan-fleck" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:865024438b3ec3649d34ac7f602207720f159b92264b826830211866260cd530", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:02+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:39:36+02:00", "duration_s": 93.454, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21598, "output_tokens": 3299, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile imply exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of rule-of-law service as a nonpartisan constitutional judge exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates unusually strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature make international representation a very strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisan service and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented integrity record strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly conflicts with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal experience and presence of polarizing partisan activity create substantial reservations." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile states that the figure lacks institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is valuable abroad, though polarizing conduct limits representative suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates alignment with short-term party incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but the supplied profile offers little basis for broad institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent nonpartisan service is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no constitutional track record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable, but the profile explicitly provides insufficient information about trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and international recognition provide unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility, but offers little direct evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has exceptional professional achievement but less demonstrated experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific standing would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her identity and achievements are rooted in science rather than domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific contribution, and professional stature support a very strong trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could bridge groups, although prior institutional roles may carry partisan interpretations." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and European judicial experience directly support a very strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Presiding over a constitutional court demonstrates high-level institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience strongly support international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial career supports autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite some concern about political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained service in senior judicial roles supports substantial professional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His outspoken public profile may inspire some groups while limiting cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and public focus on rule-of-law issues suggest strong guardianship commitments." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "He has relevant academic experience, but I recall limited evidence of executive leadership at comparable scale." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His legal expertise would be useful, though I recall limited diplomatic or internationally representative experience." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic position supports autonomy, though visible alignment in public controversies may narrow perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained academic engagement supports credibility, but polarization around his interventions may constrain broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He offers deliberative intellectual credibility, though his institutional associations may divide some groups." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarship and academic leadership suggest strong commitment to pluralism and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university leadership demonstrates experience managing a complex international institution." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His international academic profile would support credible and articulate representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career appears substantially autonomous from direct party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and university record supports a favorable impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Business prominence and associated controversies would likely impose a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His executive experience is substantial, but my impression includes significant rule-of-law and accountability concerns." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a large and complex regional corporation demonstrates strong organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He has extensive international business exposure, though controversy would constrain representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His position within a strategically important company suggests considerable exposure to political and patronage pressures." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-running public controversies materially weaken my subjective confidence in broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her technocratic and internationally respected profile appears relatively inclusive and lightly polarizing." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her international public-service background supports procedural discipline, though constitutional stewardship is not her demonstrated specialty." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "She has led complex multinational public-health institutions at a senior level." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive WHO leadership makes international representation a particularly strong fit." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career centered on professional international institutions suggests meaningful distance from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior public-health service gives me a favorable impression of professional credibility and responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international stature.", "Broadly admired scientific perseverance." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional experience.", "Limited public-institution executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held diplomatic office." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional expertise.", "Strong European institutional experience." ], "reservations": [ "Senior appointments may affect perceived independence.", "Public unifying appeal is uncertain." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.", "He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "He is publicly associated with rule-of-law commentary." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong legal-institutional expertise.", "Visible commitment to democratic safeguards." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken interventions may polarize.", "Large-scale executive experience is unclear." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has held senior leadership roles at Central European University.", "His scholarship concerns parties, democracy, and political attitudes." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Relevant expertise in democratic institutions.", "International academic leadership." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct state-service experience.", "CEU associations may be politically polarizing." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is the chairman and chief executive of MOL Group.", "MOL is a major Hungarian energy company.", "He has faced a long-running legal controversy involving Croatia." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive large-organization leadership.", "Substantial international business exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Serious accountability concerns.", "Strong establishment and patronage associations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She later held a senior deputy leadership role at WHO.", "She previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep multinational public-service experience.", "Strong technocratic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional-law background.", "Domestic unifying appeal is not well tested." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective judgments from the frozen anchors, using only internal recall for real figures and only the supplied descriptions for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 432679276783224856, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-hernadi", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "zsolt-enyedi" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:528d3a8e43c83dea7e274cbb4fd161ade42bef51e609015260b3771046e9da14", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:16+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:39:38+02:00", "duration_s": 81.985, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21389, "output_tokens": 3252, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden imply very strong unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The supplied profile directly exemplifies sustained constitutional service and institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of high-level service and cross-government leadership demonstrate exceptional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representational credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate exceptional autonomy from factions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric is directly inconsistent with broad cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and shows recent partisan entanglement." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks relevant institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is useful, but celebrity visibility alone does not establish diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from party interests." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may create familiarity, but polarization and partisanship weaken general trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile limits both polarizing baggage and demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile offers competence and nonpartisanship but little evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make representational performance uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, though patron relationships remain unclear." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and relatively low partisan identification give her exceptional symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but offers little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but experience leading a complex public institution is less evident." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would give Hungary exceptional international visibility and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career appears highly independent of domestic party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her internationally recognized scientific record supports unusually strong credibility and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad acceptance despite limited popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and judicial career is exceptionally aligned with legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions indicates strong administrative and deliberative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience provides unusually strong international credentials." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career across institutions suggests substantial autonomy from immediate party command." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, with some unavoidable exposure to institutional controversy." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His critical public profile would likely carry substantial polarizing baggage." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and public emphasis on constitutional constraints suggest strong guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant but provides limited evidence of leading a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His scholarly standing could translate internationally, though diplomatic experience is not prominent in my recall." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears institutionally independent, although pronounced public positions may be read as factionally aligned." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic credibility supports trust, tempered by contested perceptions across political camps." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A deliberative academic style helps, but association with contested political debates limits universal appeal." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His democratic-institutions scholarship suggests strong commitment to constitutional pluralism and checks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university leadership provides relevant experience managing a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His internationally connected academic career suggests strong representational ability." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career indicates autonomy, though his public intellectual profile may be perceived ideologically." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scholarly credibility and institutional service support a strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate prominence and associated controversies would impede broad symbolic acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Corporate leadership offers little direct basis for confidence in constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership of a major multinational company demonstrates strong executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive international business exposure helps, but controversy weakens representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a strategically important corporation creates perceived proximity to powerful political and economic interests." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-running public legal controversy substantially burdens perceived credibility regardless of disputed details." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A health-focused, low-partisan profile appears broadly acceptable across social groups." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her international public-service background suggests procedural discipline, though constitutional law is not her field." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading large international health organizations demonstrates substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive international executive career strongly supports diplomatic presence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A predominantly international technocratic career suggests meaningful distance from domestic party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior public-health service supports credibility and a public-interest orientation." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She conducted much of her career in the United States." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broadly admired scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Limited constitutional or governmental experience.", "Scientific distinction does not itself establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held diplomatic office." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong European and diplomatic credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Past institutional roles may attract political reinterpretation." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.", "He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "He is known for public commentary on constitutional and rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional-law orientation.", "Independent academic perspective." ], "reservations": [ "Public positions may be polarizing.", "Limited executive and diplomatic experience in my recall." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has held senior academic leadership roles at Central European University.", "His scholarship includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong understanding of democratic institutions.", "International academic and leadership experience." ], "reservations": [ "Academic positions may be perceived through partisan lenses.", "Limited diplomatic or state-executive experience in my recall." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He has served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "MOL is a major Hungarian energy company.", "He has been involved in a long-running legal dispute connected with Croatia." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive large-organization leadership.", "Substantial international business exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Legal controversy burdens public trust.", "Strategic corporate ties may weaken perceived independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She held senior leadership roles in international public health.", "She previously worked in Hungarian public-health administration." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven multinational institutional leadership.", "Low-partisan public-service profile." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional-law experience.", "Domestic political appeal is not well demonstrated." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed independent rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions from the supplied profiles and my internal recollection, treating uncertainty as confidence rather than as grounds to omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 7877934099937473936, "entity_order": [ "zsuzsanna-jakab", "zsolt-hernadi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "zoltan-fleck", "control-partisan-celebrity", "zsolt-enyedi", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:d57fb1e19cc26768f84627e2b8ae2ef9968e420c5314bc8b99a7581ac109b923", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:19+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:39:37+02:00", "duration_s": 77.844, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21390, "output_tokens": 3409, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and low partisan burden imply exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented non-partisan rule-of-law service directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience directly supports highly credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric directly conflicts with broad cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with recent partisan activity and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience makes this a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition helps visibility abroad, but polarizing rhetoric and inexperience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly undermines perceived autonomy from party command." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may provide recognition, but the profile offers little basis for institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is mildly favorable, but the profile provides no constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of diplomatic experience makes this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is favorable while broader integrity and trust evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and low partisan burden give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but I recall less evidence of executive leadership over major public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally recognized scientific stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career is notably independent of party structures and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her research reputation and perseverance create a very strong credibility impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile offers broad acceptability with some burden from prior public appointments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional judicial record directly supports a very strong guardianship assessment." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of the Constitutional Court demonstrates substantial responsibility for a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience strongly support international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic roles suggest institutional autonomy, though high appointments always carry perception risks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Distinguished judicial service supports credibility and a strong integrity impression." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His outspoken public profile could limit acceptance across sharply divided political groups." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His legal scholarship and sustained focus on constitutional institutions strongly support guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic leadership is relevant but offers limited evidence of directing a complex national institution." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic stature supports intellectual credibility abroad, but I recall limited diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic independence is favorable, but his visible political criticism may create factional perceptions." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, though partisan perceptions could constrain broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A measured scholarly profile helps, although association with contested public debates may limit reach." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarship on democracy and political institutions suggests strong commitment to constitutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university responsibilities provide relevant experience leading complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally engaged academic career supports articulate and credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His principal identity as an academic rather than party official supports substantial independence." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic reputation gives me a strong impression of credibility and seriousness." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His prominent corporate role carries more polarizing burden than symbolic inclusiveness." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Corporate leadership offers limited basis for confidence in constitutional restraint and legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-term direction of a large multinational company demonstrates substantial executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International business experience supports representation, although controversy could impair credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a strategically important national company creates perceived proximity to political and economic power." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Public controversies associated with his career materially weaken my trust impression." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A public-health identity could carry broad acceptability with relatively little partisan burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her public-service background suggests procedural responsibility, though I recall little direct constitutional work." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading major international health institutions indicates strong organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extensive WHO experience strongly supports diplomatic and international representation." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears substantially professional and international rather than party-centered." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior international health service gives me a favorable credibility impression." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly non-partisan symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited recalled public-institution executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Direct constitutional and institutional expertise.", "Strong diplomatic and European credentials." ], "reservations": [ "Past high-level appointments may invite political scrutiny.", "His broader popular appeal is less evident than his institutional standing." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.", "He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "His public work addresses law and democratic institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep knowledge of constitutional institutions.", "Strong scholarly credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Outspoken political criticism may polarize reception.", "Limited recalled diplomatic or executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has held senior academic roles at Central European University.", "His scholarship concerns parties and democracy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong understanding of democratic institutions.", "International academic experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled national executive experience.", "Institutional associations may polarize some groups." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a long-serving senior leader of MOL.", "MOL is a major Hungarian energy company.", "His career has included prominent regional business activity." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive executive leadership experience.", "Substantial international business exposure." ], "reservations": [ "Corporate-power associations weaken perceived independence.", "Public controversies reduce my trust assessment." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She held senior leadership roles at the World Health Organization.", "Her professional field is public health." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive international institutional leadership.", "Relatively low partisan burden." ], "reservations": [ "Limited recalled constitutional experience.", "Domestic unifying appeal is not well tested." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal impressions from the supplied profiles or internal recall, kept factual recall separate from interpretation, and treated uncertainty as lower confidence rather than omitted scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 18306683489269903465, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "zsuzsanna-jakab", "peter-paczolay", "zoltan-fleck", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:adc44cbcade0064128400752abdb948d1390e32754f4aaf26b53679fc46567a0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:22+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:39:46+02:00", "duration_s": 84.438, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21390, "output_tokens": 3228, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make the profile exceptionally strong." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long judicial service and cross-government leadership demonstrate excellent institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support very high trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion very unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and gives strong reasons to doubt institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates a very weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition provides presence abroad, although polarizing conduct limits diplomatic suitability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates pronounced dependence on partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but the profile offers little basis for broad institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low profile may reduce polarization but offers no demonstrated unifying appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is encouraging, but the profile provides little evidence of constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility limits representational readiness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence supports baseline credibility, while broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and national recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests discipline and responsibility but provides little direct constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Scientific excellence is clear, but it does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global stature and distinguished scientific reputation would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and global standing place her well outside ordinary party structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally validated scientific work support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist profile could attract broad respect despite limited popular visibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court leadership and judicial career strongly support commitment to legal checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates direct experience governing a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience makes him a particularly credible international representative." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic record suggests meaningful institutional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in high legal offices supports credibility and institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His outspoken public positioning may limit acceptance among groups that view him as aligned against them." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal scholarship and public emphasis on rule-of-law concerns suggest strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant, though I recall limited evidence of executive leadership at presidential scale." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His academic profile offers intellectual credibility but limited recalled diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Academic autonomy is a strength, though visible engagement in polarized political debate creates reservations." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly standing supports credibility, but political polarization could constrain public trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An analytical and civil profile helps, though his institutional associations may be polarizing domestically." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarship on democracy and institutions suggests a strong commitment to constitutional norms." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior university leadership provides relevant experience with complex institutions." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An internationally embedded academic career supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic career suggests independence from direct party organization and patronage." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His established scholarly record supports a strong impression of intellectual integrity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate prominence and associated controversies would likely carry a substantial polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "I recall little affirmative evidence of commitment to constitutional checks, and his profile raises rule-of-law reservations." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership of a major multinational company demonstrates exceptional executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive international business experience is valuable, but controversy could impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a strategically important corporation creates perceived proximity to concentrated political and economic power." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long-running public legal controversy substantially weakens my subjective trust assessment." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her professional and relatively nonpartisan profile could command respect across groups." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her international public-service background suggests procedural discipline but offers limited constitutional evidence." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading large international health institutions demonstrates unusually relevant executive experience." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her senior international roles indicate excellent diplomatic and representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A largely technocratic international career suggests substantial distance from Hungarian party command." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior public-health service supports a strong impression of credibility and responsibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked in academic and biotechnology research." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige.", "Broadly admired scientific perseverance." ], "reservations": [ "Little constitutional or political experience.", "Limited evidence of public-institution executive leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as a Hungarian ambassador." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience.", "Strong diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public profile.", "Prior state appointments may invite partisan interpretations." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.", "He has taught at ELTE.", "His public work addresses rule-of-law issues." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong constitutional awareness.", "Independent academic perspective." ], "reservations": [ "Public interventions can be polarizing.", "Limited recalled executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has held senior academic leadership roles at Central European University.", "His research concerns parties, democracy, and political institutions." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep knowledge of democratic institutions.", "International academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct state-administration experience.", "CEU affiliation may reduce cross-group acceptance." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "He has led the company for many years.", "He has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive large-organization leadership.", "Substantial international business experience." ], "reservations": [ "Legal controversy weakens trust.", "Corporate and political proximity may limit perceived independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She held senior leadership roles in international public health." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive multinational institutional leadership.", "Strong nonpartisan professional profile." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional experience.", "Domestic unifying appeal is not well established." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the supplied profiles and my internal recalled representations, separating uncertain recall from rubric-conditioned interpretation.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "zoltan-fleck", "zsolt-enyedi", "zsolt-hernadi", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 17414246549547905200, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "zsolt-hernadi", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "zsolt-enyedi", "zoltan-fleck", "zsuzsanna-jakab" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:6f01a923f588213a390af915cf8389275553f1877bbc305a5350b99c0aefd5df", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:38:44+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "duration_s": 82.344, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21598, "output_tokens": 3222, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate unusually strong acceptability and symbolic inclusion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented non-partisan rule-of-law service represent an exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong international representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Cross-government leadership and non-partisan service strongly support autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support exceptional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Campaign partisanship and absent legal experience create substantial reservations about institutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of institutional leadership experience indicates a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition supports visibility abroad, although polarizing conduct limits representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly suggests alignment with short-term factional interests." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but the profile supplies little evidence of accountability or broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves cross-group acceptability uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional competence is mildly favorable, but the profile provides little evidence about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience indicate a below-average representative fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is reassuring, but broader integrity and trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific achievement and international recognition give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests disciplined judgment, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates exceptional professional responsibility but has limited recalled experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her scientific career and distance from party structures strongly support perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and achievement support very strong public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile appears broadly acceptable but lacks strong popular reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European human-rights experience suggests unusually strong commitment to legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates substantial capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic service provides strong international standing and representative experience." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A predominantly judicial and diplomatic career supports autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite some caution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long high-level legal career supports credibility with limited recalled integrity concerns." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His visible role in contentious constitutional debates likely limits cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His legal sociology and rule-of-law engagement suggest strong constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Academic experience is relevant, but I recall limited evidence of leading a comparably complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Legal expertise supports substantive representation, though his diplomatic profile appears limited." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "He appears independent of formal party command, but pronounced public positioning creates some factional burden." }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His academic record supports credibility, while political controversy may narrow public trust." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His measured academic profile supports dialogue, though political positioning may limit universal acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarship on democracy and institutions suggests a strong commitment to constitutional safeguards." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior academic leadership provides relevant institutional experience, though not at state scale." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International academic standing and democratic-governance expertise support strong representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "An academic career supports autonomy from party command, despite identifiable normative positions." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His scholarly and university record conveys credibility and responsible public engagement." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His association with concentrated corporate power and controversy would impose a significant polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His corporate leadership profile and legal controversies create substantial doubts about constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long-running leadership of a large multinational enterprise demonstrates strong organizational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Extensive international business exposure is offset by reputational and diplomatic liabilities." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Leadership of a strategically important company suggests extensive entanglement with political and state interests." }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Prominent cross-border legal controversy would seriously constrain public trust regardless of disputed interpretations." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A technocratic health profile carries relatively low polarization and broad civic relevance." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior multilateral public service suggests respect for rules and institutional process." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership within large international health institutions demonstrates very strong executive capacity." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive senior multilateral experience provides very strong diplomatic presence and international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career centered on international public health rather than party politics supports strong autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long service in senior international health roles supports credibility and accountability." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.", "She worked for many years at the University of Pennsylvania." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Broad appeal grounded in scientific achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience.", "Limited public-sector executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional-law experience.", "Substantial judicial and diplomatic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile.", "Senior appointments may complicate perceptions of independence." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian legal sociologist.", "He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.", "He is publicly associated with rule-of-law debates." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Substantial legal-institutional expertise.", "Visible commitment to constitutional concerns." ], "reservations": [ "Public positioning may be polarizing.", "Limited recalled diplomatic or executive experience." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian political scientist.", "He has been affiliated with Central European University.", "His scholarship includes parties, polarization, and democracy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Strong knowledge of democratic institutions.", "International academic credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Limited mass-public visibility.", "Academic leadership differs from national institutional leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He has long served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.", "He has held a prominent role in Hungarian business life.", "He has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Extensive large-organization leadership.", "Considerable international business experience." ], "reservations": [ "Serious trust burden from legal controversy.", "Close association with strategic state and political interests." ] }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.", "She previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.", "Her career has focused on international public health." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Proven multilateral institutional leadership.", "Strong international representative experience." ], "reservations": [ "Limited direct constitutional-law background.", "Lower domestic public visibility than her international standing." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the supplied anchors, using only the synthetic profiles and my internal learned representation of the named figures, with confidence reflecting familiarity.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 5174567958997034926, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:b416b30cc17b24ada8bdd331dd263360a0a4012a5fe102d83b4142e5f3194495", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:55:35+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:56:46+02:00", "duration_s": 70.734, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22268, "output_tokens": 3011, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments indicate very strong acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of documented non-partisan rule-of-law service directly matches this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional capacity for responsible institutional management." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and senior judicial stature indicate very strong representative capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented integrity record strongly support public trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe burden on cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no legal experience and pairs that absence with strongly partisan conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of legal or institutional leadership experience indicates very weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition supports diplomatic presence, but polarizing rhetoric limits representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines expected autonomy from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity recognition may generate trust among admirers, but partisanship and polarizing rhetoric substantially weaken broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization is plausible, but limited visibility leaves broader unifying appeal unestablished." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly reassuring, but the profile contains no direct rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility makes this a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "No adverse information is supplied, but the profile explicitly lacks sufficient trust evidence." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her achievement-based national and international stature offers unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career provides little direct evidence about constitutional restraint or legal-process judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated successfully in demanding research institutions, though that differs from leading a complex public office." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific standing would provide extraordinary international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her authority derives overwhelmingly from scientific achievement rather than partisan or factional affiliation." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance, scientific credibility, and public reputation create a very strong impression of integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile could attract broad respect but offers limited evidence of mass cross-group appeal." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law career strongly signals commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience indicates exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic profile suggests substantial autonomy, though senior appointments necessarily involve political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long career in high-trust legal institutions supports credibility and integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held senior research responsibilities at BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility", "Achievement-based and politically independent stature" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Scientific leadership does not fully establish public-office leadership" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience", "Strong European and diplomatic credentials" ], "reservations": [ "Limited evidence of broad popular appeal", "Senior appointments may complicate perceptions of independence" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned subjective impressions, with confidence reflecting familiarity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 16456366337310893229, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:81a21acf64eae3721a56c224e0ba80e1f33cf4119fe32baeaf09ed478048aed4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:57:41+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:59:19+02:00", "duration_s": 97.594, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22268, "output_tokens": 2997, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and service across governments indicate exceptional consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented nonpartisan rule-of-law service constitute an exceptional match." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates very strong capacity to direct a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience combined with constitutional stature makes the profile exceptionally representative abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly demonstrate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests, documented service, and no integrity finding provide an exceptionally strong trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion distinctly unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no rule-of-law experience and combines institutional inexperience with recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The explicit absence of institutional leadership experience indicates extremely weak preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition provides representational presence, but polarization and inexperience substantially limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines the impression of factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but the profile provides little basis for institutional credibility or accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but insufficient visibility and trust information leave unifying appeal unresolved." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration is mildly reassuring, but the profile supplies no constitutional or rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong leadership capacity with some uncertainty about institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make the profile weak for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patronage exposure remains unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, but the profile explicitly lacks enough information about broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated scientific achievement offers an unusually inclusive and low-partisan symbol." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career offers little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has operated at high scientific and corporate levels, but her record is not primarily one of leading public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global scientific stature would give Hungary immediate credibility and positive recognition abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her identity is strongly rooted in independent scientific achievement rather than party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her record conveys perseverance, professional credibility, and public-service value with limited apparent integrity burden." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile appears relatively compatible with cross-group acceptance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court background strongly supports an impression of commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leading a constitutional court demonstrates unusually relevant experience managing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience indicates strong international credibility and representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial institutional autonomy, though political appointments create some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His senior judicial service conveys credibility and seriousness with limited integrity reservations in my representation." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held a senior research role at BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility.", "Low-partisan record with broad symbolic appeal." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or legal experience.", "Limited demonstrated leadership of public institutions." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally relevant constitutional experience.", "Strong European and diplomatic standing." ], "reservations": [ "Public cross-group appeal is less evident than institutional competence.", "Political appointments complicate certainty about independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are direct anchored ordinal judgments based only on internal recall for named figures and exclusively on the supplied profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 1625399870576792059, "entity_order": [ "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:96578984635fdb935373025f9f614864964783f6fa83d79925fc3e9bb56d8cb3", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:55:35+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:56:45+02:00", "duration_s": 70.375, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22268, "output_tokens": 2933, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and non-partisan service imply unusually strong inclusive acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented non-partisan rule-of-law service represent an exceptional match." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a very strong foundation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record support very strong trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad cross-group acceptability unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with partisan campaigning and polarizing rhetoric." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile provides no relevant experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global name recognition is a major asset, though polarizing conduct would limit diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional independence." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may generate loyalty, but partisanship and polarizing rhetoric substantially weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but provides insufficient evidence of inclusive appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent administration offers little direct evidence of commitment to constitutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong institutional leadership with limited evidence at presidential scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make this a weak representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of party office supports independence, though patrons and incentives remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competence is mildly favorable, but broader integrity and public-trust information is insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her internationally celebrated achievement gives her broad symbolic appeal, despite some vaccine-era polarization." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific career offers little direct basis for assessing constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She demonstrates exceptional professional responsibility but limited recalled leadership of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional global stature and Hungarian identity make her an unusually credible international representative." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her reputation rests on scientific achievement rather than party organization or factional sponsorship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Scientific perseverance and global professional recognition create a powerful impression of credibility and integrity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained jurist could command cross-group respect but may lack broad popular resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-court and European judicial experience strongly aligns with legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions indicates strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience supports credible representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial profile suggests meaningful professional autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some uncertainty." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His long judicial career conveys seriousness and credibility with limited salient integrity concerns in my recollection." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international credibility", "Broadly admired record of scientific perseverance" ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional experience", "Limited public-institution leadership record" ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and judicial experience", "Substantial European and diplomatic credibility" ], "reservations": [ "Limited broad popular profile", "Perceived independence from appointing governments is not wholly clear" ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned impressions, using internal recall for real candidates and only the provided profiles for synthetic controls.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 10161254265778384288, "entity_order": [ "control-consensus-guardian", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:3722d21564e826cda604df3b58752d4fe3d70ce4f7d4b01270d07e28c25bdc48", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:56:45+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:58:19+02:00", "duration_s": 94.016, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22268, "output_tokens": 2942, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability beyond a single political camp." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile indicates exceptional, sustained commitment to constitutional law and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of legal service and leadership across governments indicate exceptional institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides a strong foundation for credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional control." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished integrity record support very high prospective trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion distinctly unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal experience combined with senior partisan activity creates severe reservations about constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks the legal and institutional leadership experience needed for this role." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational presence, although polarizing rhetoric would impair diplomatic credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly indicates alignment with party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but partisanship and polarizing rhetoric substantially weaken broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves cross-group appeal largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent public management is mildly reassuring, but the profile provides no constitutional record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong practical leadership with some uncertainty about top-level demands." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No diplomatic experience and limited public visibility imply weak readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nothing signals misconduct, but the supplied information is insufficient to justify elevated trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and relatively nonpartisan symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her scientific reputation is positive but offers little basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Exceptional professional achievement is relevant, but it does not establish experience leading a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her exceptional international scientific stature would lend Hungary substantial credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career appears substantially grounded in scientific rather than partisan institutions." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her perseverance and scientific credibility support a very strong impression of integrity and public trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile appears broadly acceptable, though it provides limited evidence of popular unifying reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-court background strongly supports a very favorable judgment of legal and institutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of major legal institutions indicates exceptional readiness for complex public responsibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience strongly supports international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career supports professional autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished judicial career supports high credibility, tempered by limited confidence in the complete public record." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She has exceptional international prestige with little partisan burden.", "Her career conveys perseverance, expertise, and credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Her record offers little evidence about constitutional judgment.", "Scientific distinction does not itself establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career is directly relevant to constitutional restraint.", "He has substantial senior institutional and international experience." ], "reservations": [ "His broader popular unifying appeal is less evident than his professional standing.", "My recall of his complete appointment history is limited." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores apply the supplied ordinal anchors to my rubric-conditioned subjective impression, with uncertainty reflected in confidence rather than omitted judgments.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 1086490301881821439, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko", "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:6b9cad3ac0170a206b5862c70e81b71eb664b2742c062ec7511bf6177679b381", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:56:46+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:57:46+02:00", "duration_s": 60.61, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22268, "output_tokens": 2387, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan profile indicate very strong unifying capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented constitutional and rule-of-law service represent exceptional fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long senior service and leadership across governments demonstrate very strong institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience combined with constitutional stature provides exceptional representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and leadership across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an extensive record without integrity findings provide exceptional trust credentials." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a severe burden on cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No legal or institutional experience and polarizing partisan conduct indicate weak fit for constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global fame does not compensate for the absence of complex institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International recognition supports visibility, but polarizing rhetoric limits representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity strongly suggests dependence on party and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile provides little integrity evidence while partisan polarization weakens broad credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization helps, but limited visibility leaves broader acceptability and symbolic inclusion uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent nonpartisan service is mildly favorable, but the profile gives no direct rule-of-law record." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong leadership capacity with some uncertainty about institutional scale." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation a weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, but insufficient public information prevents a stronger integrity judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her celebrated scientific contribution and low partisan burden give her exceptional unifying potential." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional record suggests rigor and responsibility, but offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has demonstrated responsibility and influence in complex scientific organizations, though not broad public administration." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally recognized scientific stature provides exceptional international presence and credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her authority derives primarily from scientific achievement rather than party or patronage structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her persistent research career and internationally validated achievement support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile offers cross-group credibility, though limited public salience constrains symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-court and European judicial service strongly supports commitment to legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of Hungary's Constitutional Court demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His diplomatic and European judicial experience provides unusually strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial professional autonomy despite appointments by political institutions." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in high-trust legal offices supports credibility, accountability, and professional integrity." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "Her work contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptional international prestige with little partisan burden.", "Embodies persistence, competence, and socially valuable achievement." ], "reservations": [ "Little direct constitutional or public-administration experience.", "Scientific leadership does not fully establish political-institutional judgment." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Deep constitutional and institutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European legal credibility." ], "reservations": [ "Less broadly recognizable than major cultural or scientific figures.", "Senior appointments can invite perceptions of establishment alignment." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores express a direct anchored subjective impression, with confidence reflecting familiarity and evidentiary specificity rather than score completeness.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_seed": 17343217707939845850, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "control-partisan-celebrity", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:752ba109ab1e137a398826c092db080429ffb5e93bc58f05a5ec69500b03902d", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:57:46+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:59:05+02:00", "duration_s": 79.047, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22276, "output_tokens": 3180, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest very strong acceptability with limited polarizing burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service as a constitutional judge directly match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate strong capacity to lead a public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides strong preparation for credible international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support high credibility and accountability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric substantially undermines cross-group acceptability." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The lack of legal or institutional experience offers little basis for confidence in constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No institutional leadership experience suggests a weak fit for managing a complex public office." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition supports international presence, though polarization and inexperience limit credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior campaign activity indicates strong alignment with short-term partisan incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer recognition, but the profile gives little basis for institutional credibility or broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may limit polarization but leaves cross-group acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "The profile provides no meaningful evidence of either constitutional commitment or disregard." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management strongly supports responsible institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of diplomatic experience and public visibility creates a meaningful representational weakness." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests autonomy, although patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but the profile supplies insufficient evidence about integrity or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Exceptional scientific achievement and limited partisan burden give her strong symbolic appeal across groups." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile appears compatible with restraint, but it offers little direct evidence about constitutional judgment." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A distinguished international scientific career indicates discipline and responsibility but not extensive public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her globally recognized scientific stature would provide exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career and international standing suggest substantial distance from party command." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her achievement-focused public reputation supports unusually high credibility and trust." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile may reduce polarization, but he lacks the broad symbolic appeal of a consensus public figure." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional-court experience provides unusually direct evidence of commitment to legal process and institutional checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court strongly demonstrates capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience supports strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports professional autonomy, although senior appointments inevitably leave some uncertainty about perceived independence." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Sustained service in senior legal institutions supports credibility and professional trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.", "She held research and executive roles connected with the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She carries exceptional international prestige with little partisan burden.", "Her career projects persistence, competence, and public-service value." ], "reservations": [ "Her background offers limited direct evidence about constitutional decision-making.", "Scientific distinction does not automatically translate into public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He is a Hungarian jurist and former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career closely matches the constitutional and institutional demands of the role.", "European judicial and diplomatic service strengthens his representational credibility." ], "reservations": [ "His public profile may have limited broad symbolic reach.", "Senior state appointments can create contested perceptions of political independence." ] } ], "method_note": "Scores are fresh rubric-conditioned subjective judgments based only on the supplied control profiles and my unbrowsed internal representation of the named individuals.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_seed": 11347720735547887851, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-unknown-technocrat" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:80af8e90b687a9f374cf53ab696c60b2683d959c13db9d84f3e19d6c71201548", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:58:19+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T22:59:50+02:00", "duration_s": 90.578, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22276, "output_tokens": 2930, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of non-partisan rule-of-law service indicate exceptional commitment to constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Sustained leadership across governments demonstrates strong capacity to manage a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "A non-partisan career and service across governments strongly support autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of integrity findings support very strong institutional credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "No legal or institutional record offsets the concerns created by recent partisan campaigning." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The absence of legal or institutional leadership experience is a major limitation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Global recognition would provide substantial presence despite limited diplomatic preparation." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity suggests strong exposure to factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Fame may confer credibility with admirers, but the profile provides little basis for institutional trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low visibility may reduce polarization but leaves broader acceptability largely unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A competent non-partisan career is mildly reassuring, but the profile lacks direct rule-of-law evidence." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicate solid leadership capacity with limited evidence at the highest level." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience imply below-average readiness for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office supports independence, although patronage relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is modestly positive, but the profile provides insufficient information about integrity or public trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific achievement and limited partisan identification offer broad cross-group symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her career suggests rigor and responsibility but supplies little direct basis for judging constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "She has substantial high-level scientific experience, but limited visible preparation for leading a constitutional public institution." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her extraordinary global scientific standing would give Hungary exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A career grounded in scientific work rather than party organization suggests substantial political autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her perseverance and internationally validated scientific career create a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained institutional profile may be broadly acceptable, although it offers limited popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His senior constitutional and European judicial experience indicates very strong commitment to legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates unusually relevant institutional capacity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "European judicial and diplomatic experience provides strong preparation for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial career supports autonomy, though senior state appointments leave some room for reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His sustained service in prominent legal institutions supports a strong impression of professional credibility." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.", "Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She commands exceptional international respect.", "Her career conveys perseverance and professional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "She has little visible constitutional or political experience.", "Scientific distinction does not itself establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His experience closely matches constitutional guardianship.", "He has both institutional and international credentials." ], "reservations": [ "His popular unifying appeal is difficult to assess.", "Senior state appointments complicate confidence about complete political distance." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed a fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impression for each pair, using only the supplied synthetic profiles and my internal representation of the real candidates.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_seed": 4092953482133936448, "entity_order": [ "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "control-consensus-guardian", "peter-paczolay", "control-partisan-celebrity" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:9b175dea50b3840affb3ccac6e2d90b1d5a73110c695d3af2e7e141a1320582b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:59:05+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T23:00:55+02:00", "duration_s": 109.359, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22276, "output_tokens": 3078, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest exceptional acceptability across political and social divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive documented rule-of-law service as a non-partisan constitutional judge directly matches this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Twenty years of senior service and leadership across governments demonstrate substantial institutional competence." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature make the profile highly suited to representation abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments strongly indicate autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and an unblemished documented record create a very strong integrity profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric creates a substantial burden despite broad public recognition." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile combines no legal experience with polarizing partisan activity and offers little basis for expecting constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The stated absence of institutional leadership experience makes this a notably weak fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition is valuable abroad, but polarization and absent diplomatic experience materially limit the fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly conflicts with the desired independence from factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Fame supplies visibility but the profile provides little integrity evidence and signals divisive political conduct." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "A low political profile may limit polarization but offers little basis for judging broad appeal." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Non-partisanship is encouraging, but the profile provides no direct evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid capacity to lead a complex institution." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience make international representation an uncertain fit." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office suggests meaningful autonomy, though patron relationships remain unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is mildly favorable, but broader trust and integrity evidence is explicitly insufficient." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Internationally celebrated scientific achievement gives her unusually broad and relatively nonpolarizing symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile appears non-partisan, but it reveals little about constitutional judgment or legal process." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific distinction and industry experience are relevant, but leadership of a major public institution is a different demand." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her global scientific stature would provide exceptional recognition and credibility abroad." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career identity is rooted in scientific work rather than party organization or factional advancement." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her reputation for perseverance and consequential scientific work supports a strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "His institutional profile is serious and restrained, but his broader cross-group appeal is unclear." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive constitutional-court background provides a particularly strong foundation for institutional restraint and legal process." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court indicates substantial experience managing a consequential public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His European judicial and diplomatic experience suggests strong international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A judicial and diplomatic career suggests professional autonomy, though senior appointments inevitably invite questions about political proximity." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Long service in high-trust legal roles supports credibility, tempered by limited knowledge of his wider public reputation." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational work on mRNA technology.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.", "She worked at BioNTech after conducting research at the University of Pennsylvania." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She carries exceptional international prestige with little partisan baggage.", "Her career conveys perseverance, competence, and service through science." ], "reservations": [ "Her record offers little evidence about constitutional decision-making.", "Scientific eminence does not itself establish public-institution leadership ability." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 3, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.", "He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Italy." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His constitutional and European judicial experience closely fits the office's guardian role.", "His diplomatic background strengthens his representative credentials." ], "reservations": [ "His broader public appeal and symbolic reach are difficult to assess.", "Senior state appointments leave some uncertainty about perceived political independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh subjective judgments from the supplied profiles and internal recall, using uncertainty to adjust confidence rather than omit scores.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_seed": 4522495258601697689, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-consensus-guardian", "control-unknown-technocrat", "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:dad5fe5dff938b78a9ce6a7a69b11c357a17b73b4571364c58f41bd1397c6ecc", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:59:19+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T23:00:20+02:00", "duration_s": 60.609, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22276, "output_tokens": 2263, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments suggest unusually strong acceptability across political divisions." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Extensive constitutional service and documented rule-of-law commitment exceptionally match this criterion." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate strong capacity for responsible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience provides very strong preparation for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Non-partisanship and service across governments indicate strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and the absence of documented integrity findings support very strong credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric would impose a severe unifying burden." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No rule-of-law record is supplied, while recent partisan campaigning raises concern about restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile explicitly lacks legal and institutional leadership experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition supports visibility abroad, though polarizing rhetoric limits representative credibility." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity indicates substantial factional alignment." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity standing may attract support, but the profile supplies little evidence of accountability or broad trust." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves cross-group acceptability unknown." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Professional public service is mildly reassuring, but no constitutional or rule-of-law record is supplied." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates strong, though not exceptional, institutional leadership." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience create a weak fit for international representation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "The absence of known party office supports independence, though patron relationships remain unspecified." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is positive, but the profile explicitly provides insufficient information about broader trust." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "International scientific achievement and limited partisan identification give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her professional reputation is reassuring, but she lacks a known constitutional or legal-process record." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 6, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Scientific and corporate experience is relevant, but evidence of leading a large public institution is limited." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Exceptional global scientific recognition would provide outstanding international stature." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her career identity is strongly rooted in science rather than party or factional structures." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific accomplishments and persevering public image support a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A restrained juristic profile appears broadly acceptable, though it offers limited evidence of popular cross-group resonance." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His constitutional-law career and judicial leadership create a very strong guardianship impression." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership of a constitutional court demonstrates unusually relevant stewardship of a complex public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Diplomatic and European judicial experience strongly support international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His judicial and diplomatic career suggests substantial institutional autonomy, with some uncertainty about political appointments." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service supports credibility, although my knowledge of his wider public-trust profile is incomplete." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held senior research and corporate roles at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Globally respected achievement with broad symbolic appeal.", "Strongly non-partisan public identity." ], "reservations": [ "No substantial constitutional or legal background is known to me.", "Large public-institution leadership experience appears limited." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "Exceptionally relevant constitutional experience.", "Strong diplomatic and European institutional background." ], "reservations": [ "Popular unifying appeal is less established than institutional credibility.", "Some roles arose through political appointment processes." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh rubric-conditioned ordinal impressions, separating limited factual recall from subjective interpretation and treating unfamiliarity as reduced confidence rather than a missing score.", "validation_actions": [] }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "base_scorer_id": "scorer-codex-sol", "study_version": "v5-block", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "block_candidate_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_seed": 13774674860534497357, "entity_order": [ "control-partisan-celebrity", "control-unknown-technocrat", "katalin-kariko", "peter-paczolay", "control-consensus-guardian" ], "prompt_hash": "sha256:15618545576421b05f62e87772b2de4a76e7ab650bfdd8de5f7ad484972b0187", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T22:59:50+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T23:01:25+02:00", "duration_s": 94.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22276, "output_tokens": 2449, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "scores": [ { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Broad cross-group appointments and a nonpartisan identity imply unusually high consensus potential." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 10, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Two decades of documented rule-of-law service make the profile an exceptional fit for constitutional guardianship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Long service and leadership across governments demonstrate highly credible institutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Multilingual diplomatic experience and constitutional stature provide excellent international representational capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Nonpartisanship and service across governments indicate very strong autonomy from factional command." }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Transparent interests and no documented integrity finding support a very strong trust profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Highly polarizing rhetoric makes broad symbolic inclusion unlikely." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Absent legal experience and recent partisan campaigning create a very weak fit for constitutional restraint." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "The profile supplies no experience leading complex public institutions." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Global recognition offers representational reach, tempered by polarization and no diplomatic experience." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 2, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Recent senior party-campaign activity strongly undermines perceived factional autonomy." }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 4, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Celebrity and partisan polarization burden credibility, although the profile establishes no integrity violation." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Low polarization may help, but limited visibility leaves unifying appeal genuinely uncertain." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Nonpartisanship is mildly encouraging, but the profile gives little evidence of constitutional commitment." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Ten years of competent management indicates solid institutional leadership capacity." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 3, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Limited visibility and no diplomatic experience create a weak representational profile." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "No known party office suggests meaningful autonomy despite limited information about other dependencies." }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Competent service is favorable, while broader credibility and integrity remain insufficiently characterized." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "International scientific distinction and a largely nonpartisan identity give her unusually broad symbolic appeal." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 5, "confidence": "low", "reason": "Her public profile offers little direct basis for judging constitutional stewardship." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her senior scientific experience suggests responsibility and competence, though not direct public-institution leadership." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her worldwide recognition and scientific stature would confer exceptional international credibility." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Her scientific career conveys substantial distance from party machinery and factional incentives." }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Her reputation for rigorous, persistent scientific work supports a very strong impression of credibility." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "score_1_10": 7, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "His restrained juristic profile could attract broad respect, but offers limited popular symbolic reach." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "His extensive constitutional and judicial background strongly supports commitment to legal process and checks." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Leadership at the highest constitutional level indicates strong capacity to manage a major public institution." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "score_1_10": 9, "confidence": "high", "reason": "Judicial and diplomatic experience provides a particularly strong basis for representing Hungary abroad." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "A long judicial career supports autonomy, though prior state appointments leave some institutional-political reservation." }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "score_1_10": 8, "confidence": "medium", "reason": "Senior judicial service creates a strong credibility impression with limited visibility into wider public trust." } ], "candidate_notes": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "familiarity_1_5": 5, "recalled_facts": [ "She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.", "She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.", "She held senior roles connected with BioNTech and the University of Pennsylvania." ], "positive_reasons": [ "She carries exceptional nonpartisan international prestige.", "Her career projects persistence and professional credibility." ], "reservations": [ "She has little visible constitutional or political experience.", "Scientific leadership does not directly establish public-institution leadership." ] }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "familiarity_1_5": 4, "recalled_facts": [ "He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.", "He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.", "He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights." ], "positive_reasons": [ "His career is closely aligned with constitutional guardianship.", "He combines domestic institutional and international experience." ], "reservations": [ "His broader popular unifying appeal is difficult to assess.", "High-level appointments can complicate perceptions of independence." ] } ], "method_note": "I formed fresh ordinal judgments from the frozen rubric, using supplied profiles for controls and separating recalled facts from subjective interpretation for real candidates.", "validation_actions": [] } ], "audits": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:1f086288475605d71207e60db6b3f8439a4369edb0b61dfe91f2bd15aed0881e", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:ddabd5b8f5dbdf84223cd12a48ac1082788ff4aaae558b515f11b4596aac5931" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-albert-laszlo-barabasi", "chunk_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:1f086288475605d71207e60db6b3f8439a4369edb0b61dfe91f2bd15aed0881e", "prompt_hash": "sha256:ddabd5b8f5dbdf84223cd12a48ac1082788ff4aaae558b515f11b4596aac5931", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:36+02:00", "duration_s": 29.766, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21528, "output_tokens": 1013, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "Six claims are supported by the limited official references, eleven are not covered, and none is directly contradicted. The packet supports Hungarian birth, general network-science prominence, and senior Northeastern roles, but it does not provide a complete benchmark for nationality labels, disciplinary identity, interdisciplinarity, or scale-free-network-specific claims.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference calls him a pioneer of network science but does not specifically address scale-free networks." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Northeastern identifies him as a University Distinguished Professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His distinguished professorship and center directorship at Northeastern are senior US academic positions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His distinguished professorship and center directorship at Northeastern are senior US academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes leadership of a network-research center in the United States but does not characterize the research as interdisciplinary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Northeastern states that he directs its Center for Complex Network Research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet describes him as Hungarian-born but does not establish Hungarian-American identity or nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The National Academy of Sciences describes him as Hungarian-born and a pioneer of network science." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish a Hungarian-Romanian identity or describe him specifically as a physicist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Northeastern identifies him as a distinguished professor and center director." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The Barabási-Albert model and scale-free networks are not mentioned in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet identifies him as a network-science pioneer but does not specifically discuss scale-free network theory." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not specifically mention research on scale-free networks." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not specifically mention work on scale-free networks." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish that he is widely known specifically for scale-free-network research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address whether his work popularized scale-free network models." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address whether his work popularized scale-free network research." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He developed influential work on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has held a professorship at Northeastern University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic positions in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has led interdisciplinary network-science research in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He has led research at Northeastern University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-American network scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-born network scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-Romanian physicist known for network science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with Northeastern University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the Barabási-Albert model of scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the development of scale-free network theory.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is known for work on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"He is widely known for research on scale-free networks.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"His work helped popularize scale-free network models.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"His work helped popularize scale-free network research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"The US National Academy of Sciences describes Barabási as Hungarian-born, internationally affiliated, an elected member of several academies, and a pioneer of network science.\",\"id\":\"barabasi-nas\",\"publisher\":\"US National Academy of Sciences\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Albert-László Barabási\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"albert-laszlo-barabasi\",\"claim\":\"Barabási is a University Distinguished Professor at Northeastern and directs the Center for Complex Network Research. These roles establish professional credibility, not candidate-level public support.\",\"id\":\"barabasi-northeastern\",\"publisher\":\"Northeastern University\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Albert-László Barabási\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference calls him a pioneer of network science but does not specifically address scale-free networks." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Northeastern identifies him as a University Distinguished Professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His distinguished professorship and center directorship at Northeastern are senior US academic positions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His distinguished professorship and center directorship at Northeastern are senior US academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes leadership of a network-research center in the United States but does not characterize the research as interdisciplinary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Northeastern states that he directs its Center for Complex Network Research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet describes him as Hungarian-born but does not establish Hungarian-American identity or nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The National Academy of Sciences describes him as Hungarian-born and a pioneer of network science." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish a Hungarian-Romanian identity or describe him specifically as a physicist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Northeastern identifies him as a distinguished professor and center director." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The Barabási-Albert model and scale-free networks are not mentioned in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet identifies him as a network-science pioneer but does not specifically discuss scale-free network theory." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not specifically mention research on scale-free networks." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not specifically mention work on scale-free networks." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish that he is widely known specifically for scale-free-network research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address whether his work popularized scale-free network models." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address whether his work popularized scale-free network research." } ], "summary": "Six claims are supported by the limited official references, eleven are not covered, and none is directly contradicted. The packet supports Hungarian birth, general network-science prominence, and senior Northeastern roles, but it does not provide a complete benchmark for nationality labels, disciplinary identity, interdisciplinarity, or scale-free-network-specific claims.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "andras-baka", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:c885c945d792b70671e5e1be44da222ddc11a4a3a5b77d67ebe82a6a27b274c9", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:9052e2759479c1989584a17829c8bbb2ee6213729274a37a97f5b67ee917d3d2" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "andras-baka-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "andras-baka", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-baka", "chunk_id": "andras-baka-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:c885c945d792b70671e5e1be44da222ddc11a4a3a5b77d67ebe82a6a27b274c9", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9052e2759479c1989584a17829c8bbb2ee6213729274a37a97f5b67ee917d3d2", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:26+02:00", "duration_s": 19.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21276, "output_tokens": 779, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 13 recalled factual claims are supported by the two supplied official references, and none is directly contradicted. This audit is limited strictly to the supplied packet and does not assess facts beyond its coverage.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that Baka served as President of Hungary's Supreme Court." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights from 1991 to 2008." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV supports his prior service at the European Court of Human Rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV supports his service at the European Court of Human Rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that he served as President of Hungary's Supreme Court from 2009 to 2011." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference records Grand Chamber litigation over the premature termination of his Supreme Court presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference states that a Grand Chamber judgment addressed the premature termination of his Supreme Court presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The cited Grand Chamber judgment Baka v. Hungary supports that his premature removal led to a European human-rights case." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference says the Grand Chamber found that the premature termination violated Baka's Convention rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference states that the Grand Chamber ruled on the premature termination of his Supreme Court presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The finding that the termination violated Baka's Convention rights supports that the ECHR ruled in his favor on that issue." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR Grand Chamber reference supports that the Strasbourg court ruled on the premature termination of his mandate." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary's Supreme Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Supreme Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"His premature removal from judicial leadership generated European litigation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"His premature removal from judicial office became the subject of a European human-rights judgment.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"His premature removal from judicial office led to a prominent European human-rights case.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The European Court found that his premature removal violated his rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The European Court of Human Rights ruled concerning the premature termination of his mandate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The European Court of Human Rights ruled in his favor concerning the premature termination of his mandate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The Strasbourg court ruled on the premature termination of his mandate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights from 1991 to 2008 and as President of Hungary's Supreme Court and National Judicial Council from 2009 to 2011.\",\"id\":\"baka-coe-cv\",\"publisher\":\"Council of Europe\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Curriculum Vitae of András Baka\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-baka\",\"claim\":\"The ECHR Grand Chamber found that the premature termination of Baka's Supreme Court presidency after criticism of judicial reforms violated his Convention rights.\",\"id\":\"baka-echr\",\"publisher\":\"European Court of Human Rights\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Grand Chamber judgment Baka v. Hungary\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that Baka served as President of Hungary's Supreme Court." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights from 1991 to 2008." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV supports his prior service at the European Court of Human Rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that Baka served at the European Court of Human Rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV supports his service at the European Court of Human Rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Council of Europe CV states that he served as President of Hungary's Supreme Court from 2009 to 2011." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference records Grand Chamber litigation over the premature termination of his Supreme Court presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference states that a Grand Chamber judgment addressed the premature termination of his Supreme Court presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The cited Grand Chamber judgment Baka v. Hungary supports that his premature removal led to a European human-rights case." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference says the Grand Chamber found that the premature termination violated Baka's Convention rights." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR reference states that the Grand Chamber ruled on the premature termination of his Supreme Court presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The finding that the termination violated Baka's Convention rights supports that the ECHR ruled in his favor on that issue." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The ECHR Grand Chamber reference supports that the Strasbourg court ruled on the premature termination of his mandate." } ], "summary": "All 13 recalled factual claims are supported by the two supplied official references, and none is directly contradicted. This audit is limited strictly to the supplied packet and does not assess facts beyond its coverage.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "andras-sajo", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 11, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:3233c0dadd6b36245439db3631c9111e95041c4a807e6336af4896dec378c1dd" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "andras-sajo-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "andras-sajo", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-andras-sajo", "chunk_id": "andras-sajo-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3233c0dadd6b36245439db3631c9111e95041c4a807e6336af4896dec378c1dd", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:23+02:00", "duration_s": 16.688, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20718, "output_tokens": 574, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 11 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. This reflects reference-coverage limits and is not evidence of hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held international academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held prominent international academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held prominent international academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior international academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He taught at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He was associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He was involved in a disclosed judicial-ethics controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"andras-sajo\",\"claim\":\"He was involved in founding Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 11 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. This reflects reference-coverage limits and is not evidence of hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "attila-chikan", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:068d75ca06958282e0f8b13d2de02a4f8a89305aa64762479570093b3bbd8797" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "attila-chikan-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "attila-chikan", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-attila-chikan", "chunk_id": "attila-chikan-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:068d75ca06958282e0f8b13d2de02a4f8a89305aa64762479570093b3bbd8797", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:29+02:00", "duration_s": 22.297, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21296, "output_tokens": 872, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every claim as not_covered and do not infer hallucination or exclude any sample on this audit alone." } ], "summary": "All 17 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, high-severity flag, or basis for sample exclusion was established.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Hungarian Competitiveness Research Centre.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Rajk College for Advanced Studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He held senior leadership roles at Corvinus University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and former rector of Corvinus University's predecessor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as economy minister in the first Orbán government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's economy minister in the first Orbán government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's economy minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of Corvinus University's predecessor institution.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of Corvinus University's predecessor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of Corvinus University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He served as rector of the Budapest University of Economic Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He was rector of Corvinus University of Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He was rector of Corvinus University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"attila-chikan\",\"claim\":\"He was rector of the Budapest University of Economic Sciences and Public Administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every claim as not_covered and do not infer hallucination or exclude any sample on this audit alone." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 17 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, high-severity flag, or basis for sample exclusion was established.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "balazs-gulyas", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:55afd417de4e9814b42c1519eea28ecb9fb5be4fbe77b0edd8b793b5bd5d9850" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "balazs-gulyas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "balazs-gulyas", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-balazs-gulyas", "chunk_id": "balazs-gulyas-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:55afd417de4e9814b42c1519eea28ecb9fb5be4fbe77b0edd8b793b5bd5d9850", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:21+02:00", "duration_s": 14.938, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21114, "output_tokens": 499, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and do not interpret not_covered as evidence of hallucination." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No direct contradiction is established, so no high or blocking flags are warranted; these verdicts do not assess truth beyond the supplied packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became head of Hungary's HUN-REN research network.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary's HUN-REN research network.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary's research-network organization.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He became president of the Hungarian Research Network.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior leadership in Hungary's research-network system.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior research leadership roles in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior research roles in Singapore.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international academic career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He spent a substantial part of his academic career in Singapore.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He worked for many years in international academia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"balazs-gulyas\",\"claim\":\"He worked for many years in Sweden and Singapore.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and do not interpret not_covered as evidence of hallucination." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No direct contradiction is established, so no high or blocking flags are warranted; these verdicts do not assess truth beyond the supplied packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "botond-roska", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 19, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:a68423bb0ad523321a4acf8ec4e5a6f6992ff9f2b069b9e3efff80b05fc909d5" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "botond-roska-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "botond-roska", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-botond-roska", "chunk_id": "botond-roska-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:a68423bb0ad523321a4acf8ec4e5a6f6992ff9f2b069b9e3efff80b05fc909d5", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:28+02:00", "duration_s": 21.141, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21393, "output_tokens": 864, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 19 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has held a senior research role in Basel.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior research roles in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has led biomedical research in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has led research in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He has worked at a biomedical research institute in Basel.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist known for research on vision.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist known for vision-restoration research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physician-scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns vision and retinal function.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns vision and retinal therapies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research focuses on vision and retinal science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research focuses on vision and retinal therapies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His research has included approaches to restoring visual function.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"His work has received major international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian neuroscientist specializing in vision research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"Known for research toward restoring sight.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"botond-roska\",\"claim\":\"Works in Switzerland.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 19 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "bela-merkely", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 10, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:aed954ca3fbdabd447084de018f93a6330fb096e104281f89d8c88dfd1cf8b38" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "bela-merkely-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "bela-merkely", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-bela-merkely", "chunk_id": "bela-merkely-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:aed954ca3fbdabd447084de018f93a6330fb096e104281f89d8c88dfd1cf8b38", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:21+02:00", "duration_s": 14.125, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20933, "output_tokens": 392, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 10 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no high or blocking flags are warranted. This reflects the packet's complete lack of coverage, not evidence that the claims are hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as rector." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession or nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about COVID-19-era medical communication or prominence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about COVID-19-era medical prominence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about prominence in public discussion during the COVID-19 pandemic." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession or nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as rector." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He has served as rector of Semmelweis University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He is a cardiologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian cardiologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was a prominent medical communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was a prominent medical voice during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was prominent in public discussion during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"He was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian cardiologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"Served as rector of Semmelweis University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"bela-merkely\",\"claim\":\"Was publicly prominent during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as rector." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession or nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about COVID-19-era medical communication or prominence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about COVID-19-era medical prominence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about prominence in public discussion during the COVID-19 pandemic." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession or nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as rector." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic." } ], "summary": "All 10 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no high or blocking flags are warranted. This reflects the packet's complete lack of coverage, not evidence that the claims are hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "cecilia-muller", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 16, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:d5646c756b1a2eeb320b16c55759525d0fabbd4a0e24e9e84557b03a46ee9302" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "cecilia-muller-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "cecilia-muller", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-cecilia-muller", "chunk_id": "cecilia-muller-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d5646c756b1a2eeb320b16c55759525d0fabbd4a0e24e9e84557b03a46ee9302", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:23+02:00", "duration_s": 16.782, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21010, "output_tokens": 553, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"Became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's chief medical officer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became a central public-health spokesperson during COVID-19.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became a prominent public communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became a prominent public figure during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She became highly visible during official COVID-19 briefings.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian physician and public-health official.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian physician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She is a physician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She participated in the government's pandemic response structure.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She regularly delivered official pandemic briefings.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's chief medical officer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's national chief medical officer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She was a central official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She was a prominent official communicator during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"cecilia-muller\",\"claim\":\"She was a prominent official during the COVID-19 pandemic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "csaba-korosi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 14, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:1d84c2dafeb93f151d1630de5e92e1b63c7772c82345f087441ce939d5935acb" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "csaba-korosi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "csaba-korosi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-korosi", "chunk_id": "csaba-korosi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1d84c2dafeb93f151d1630de5e92e1b63c7772c82345f087441ce939d5935acb", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:19+02:00", "duration_s": 12.797, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20891, "output_tokens": 467, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 14 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. This result reflects reference-packet coverage only and is not evidence that the claims are false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He has represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He has worked on international sustainability issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He previously represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the 77th UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the 77th United Nations General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the United Nations General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"Previously represented Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-korosi\",\"claim\":\"Served as president of the UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 14 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. This result reflects reference-packet coverage only and is not evidence that the claims are false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "csaba-pleh", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 14, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:5b4b3ea4d98102cce6e96e2d68fa70097e45607cd61162823724c2dacab59ce2" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "csaba-pleh-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "csaba-pleh", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-csaba-pleh", "chunk_id": "csaba-pleh-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:5b4b3ea4d98102cce6e96e2d68fa70097e45607cd61162823724c2dacab59ce2", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:06+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:21+02:00", "duration_s": 14.625, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21122, "output_tokens": 481, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 14 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic positions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about Academy membership." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about an Academy association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive-science work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about scholarship on cognition or language." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive science or psycholinguistics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive-science scholarship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about work on cognition or language." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive science or psycholinguistics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive-science work." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian psychologist and linguist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"He is known for work in cognitive science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"Held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship has focused on cognition and language.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes cognitive science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His work concerns cognition and language.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"His work includes cognitive science and psycholinguistics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian psychologist and linguist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"csaba-pleh\",\"claim\":\"Known for work in cognitive science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic positions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about Academy membership." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about an Academy association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive-science work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about scholarship on cognition or language." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive science or psycholinguistics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive-science scholarship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about work on cognition or language." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive science or psycholinguistics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about cognitive-science work." } ], "summary": "All 14 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 18, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:71eff3000f6539318c4e8425f939b639c6f2275a44b527ec58166b628ad9da58" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-diana-urge-vorsatz", "chunk_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:71eff3000f6539318c4e8425f939b639c6f2275a44b527ec58166b628ad9da58", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:19+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:42+02:00", "duration_s": 22.313, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21385, "output_tokens": 812, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no hallucination or contradiction flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"Held a senior role within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"Her research focuses on climate change and energy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian environmental scientist and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has been affiliated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held a senior leadership role within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held a senior role within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held leadership responsibilities within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held leadership roles within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior responsibilities within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles within the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has served in senior roles within the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She has worked extensively with the IPCC.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian climate scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian environmental scientist focused on climate and energy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian environmental scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is affiliated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"diana-urge-vorsatz\",\"claim\":\"She is associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no hallucination or contradiction flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "eniko-bollobas", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 19, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:3e07345d28e43822082a0b01098624cba3078f2b0ca5068a2c5818530cc1f9e9" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "eniko-bollobas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "eniko-bollobas", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-bollobas", "chunk_id": "eniko-bollobas-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3e07345d28e43822082a0b01098624cba3078f2b0ca5068a2c5818530cc1f9e9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:21+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:41+02:00", "duration_s": 20.594, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21392, "output_tokens": 923, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 19 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction-based high or blocking flags are warranted. This limited packet provides no basis for determining whether any claim is hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing university professorships." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing senior academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing teaching at Eotvos Lorand University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing scholarship in American literature." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing scholarship in American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or Americanist status." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or university professorship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or association with American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality or scholarship in American literature." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing recognition for scholarship in American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing work in English or American literature." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing membership in the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing service as Hungary's ambassador to the United States." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing university professorships." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing work as a university professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or association with American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality or literary scholarship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality or scholarship in American literature and culture." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing specialization in American studies." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Has held a university professorship.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Has taught at Eotvos Lorand University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship includes American literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship includes American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian literary scholar and Americanist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian literary scholar and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian literary scholar associated with American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian scholar of American literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Known for scholarship in American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Known for work in English and American literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She has held a university professorship.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She has worked as a university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian literary scholar associated with American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian literary scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian scholar of American literature and culture.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-bollobas\",\"claim\":\"She specializes in American studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing university professorships." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing senior academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing teaching at Eotvos Lorand University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing scholarship in American literature." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing scholarship in American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or Americanist status." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or university professorship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or association with American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality or scholarship in American literature." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing recognition for scholarship in American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing work in English or American literature." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing membership in the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing service as Hungary's ambassador to the United States." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing university professorships." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing work as a university professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality, literary scholarship, or association with American studies." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality or literary scholarship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing nationality or scholarship in American literature and culture." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing specialization in American studies." } ], "summary": "All 19 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction-based high or blocking flags are warranted. This limited packet provides no basis for determining whether any claim is hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "eniko-gyori", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 19, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:d082e8b51a552db43a91901570f3fe58f45dd5bfa3bce30017a780c8c3a42fd8" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "eniko-gyori-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "eniko-gyori", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eniko-gyori", "chunk_id": "eniko-gyori-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d082e8b51a552db43a91901570f3fe58f45dd5bfa3bce30017a780c8c3a42fd8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:21+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:35+02:00", "duration_s": 14.141, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21150, "output_tokens": 596, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 19 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Has held diplomatic and government foreign-policy roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Has held diplomatic or European-affairs responsibilities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Has served as a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Held a government role responsible for European Union affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian Fidesz politician and Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian Fidesz politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian politician associated with Fidesz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Previously held diplomatic and governmental posts.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Previously held diplomatic and governmental roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"Served as ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has held government responsibility for European affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has served as a Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She has served as a Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior government role concerning European affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior government role concerning European Union affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior governmental role concerning European Union affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eniko-gyori\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to Spain.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 19 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "erno-rubik", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:2f4ea171bd20197a847862667d7b91a749e7b4333a50ae3cc0e6dd2f7ce5e82b" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "erno-rubik-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "erno-rubik", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-erno-rubik", "chunk_id": "erno-rubik-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:2f4ea171bd20197a847862667d7b91a749e7b4333a50ae3cc0e6dd2f7ce5e82b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:21+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:40+02:00", "duration_s": 18.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21239, "output_tokens": 842, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage gaps rather than hallucination findings; supply reference evidence for substantive verification." } ], "summary": "All 17 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these results do not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Has supported education and creative problem solving.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Has worked in education and creative design.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He invented the Rubik's Cube.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian architect and designer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He trained and worked in architecture and design.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"He trained as an architect.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His invention became a worldwide cultural icon.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His invention became globally recognized.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His puzzle became a global cultural phenomenon.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His puzzle became a worldwide cultural phenomenon.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"His puzzle became globally recognized.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian architect and designer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian architect and inventor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Invented the Rubik's Cube.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Worked as an architect and design educator.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Worked as an architect and design professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"erno-rubik\",\"claim\":\"Worked in design and education.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage gaps rather than hallucination findings; supply reference evidence for substantive verification." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 17 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these results do not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:14b4332aa229069990754543637bff717d7d2d590ffe565f261fbb6e6f623e4f" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-buzsaki", "chunk_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:14b4332aa229069990754543637bff717d7d2d590ffe565f261fbb6e6f623e4f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:44+02:00", "duration_s": 20.906, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21333, "output_tokens": 903, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as a coverage limitation, not as evidence of hallucination." } ], "summary": "All 17 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, high-severity issue, or hallucination finding can be established from this packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about an NYU professorship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about employment at New York University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on neural oscillations or memory." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on neural oscillations." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about neural oscillations or brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about neural oscillations or brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about neural oscillations or memory." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on neural oscillations." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Has held a senior academic role in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic positions in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic roles in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has held a professorship at New York University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has held a senior academic position in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic positions in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He has worked at New York University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-American neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on neural oscillations and memory.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on neural oscillations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns neural oscillations and brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"His research focuses on neural oscillations and brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"His research is associated with neural oscillations and memory.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-American neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on brain rhythms.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-buzsaki\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on neural oscillations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as a coverage limitation, not as evidence of hallucination." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about an NYU professorship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about employment at New York University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on neural oscillations or memory." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on neural oscillations." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about neural oscillations or brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about neural oscillations or brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about neural oscillations or memory." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on brain rhythms." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about research on neural oscillations." } ], "summary": "All 17 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, high-severity issue, or hallucination finding can be established from this packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-suranyi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 18, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:1ef223580e4f921b4e5b868b4b272cadd8617223eaeffcbdb367db57ba07a1db" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-suranyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-suranyi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-suranyi", "chunk_id": "gyorgy-suranyi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1ef223580e4f921b4e5b868b4b272cadd8617223eaeffcbdb367db57ba07a1db", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:45+02:00", "duration_s": 22.203, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21075, "output_tokens": 891, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as a coverage result, not as evidence of hallucination, and supply reference evidence for substantive factual evaluation." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these results do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Economist with international financial experience.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Economist with international professional experience.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Former governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior international financial roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles in international banking.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He held senior international banking roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He held senior roles in international banking.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and banker.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He served twice as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"He served two periods as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as governor of the National Bank of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Served two separate terms as central-bank governor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-suranyi\",\"claim\":\"Served two terms as central-bank governor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as a coverage result, not as evidence of hallucination, and supply reference evidence for substantive factual evaluation." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these results do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-szapary", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 14, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:3eb38af65eb5189b4d0195370a78dc4b120a98234d664345bfa75f49ad3e1b72" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-szapary-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-szapary", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-szapary", "chunk_id": "gyorgy-szapary-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3eb38af65eb5189b4d0195370a78dc4b120a98234d664345bfa75f49ad3e1b72", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:26+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:45+02:00", "duration_s": 18.485, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21144, "output_tokens": 635, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 14 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. The packet therefore supports no factual confirmations or contradictions; no high or blocking flags are warranted, and these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about either component of this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He held senior positions at the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He held senior roles at the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He was a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He worked as an economist at the International Monetary Fund.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"He worked at the International Monetary Fund.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and former central-bank official.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Worked at the International Monetary Fund.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-szapary\",\"claim\":\"Worked in international economic institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about either component of this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." } ], "summary": "All 14 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. The packet therefore supports no factual confirmations or contradictions; no high or blocking flags are warranted, and these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-tilesch", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 16, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:c6f1ebec86cee6eb7c16faf010349936143649452077b1f98d7d66f9161ee5ae" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gyorgy-tilesch-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gyorgy-tilesch", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gyorgy-tilesch", "chunk_id": "gyorgy-tilesch-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:c6f1ebec86cee6eb7c16faf010349936143649452077b1f98d7d66f9161ee5ae", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:28+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:42+02:00", "duration_s": 14.172, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21257, "output_tokens": 566, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps and obtain reference evidence before assessing factual accuracy." } ], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No contradiction, high-severity flag, or hallucination finding is warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Has worked in international advisory settings.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Has worked in internationally oriented technology policy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Has worked internationally on AI policy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally in technology advising.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally in technology advisory roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally in technology strategy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally, including in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He has worked internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian technology and artificial-intelligence policy expert.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with artificial-intelligence policy and strategy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with artificial-intelligence strategy and policy work.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with artificial-intelligence strategy and policy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with international artificial-intelligence strategy and policy work.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian technology and artificial-intelligence policy expert.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born technology and artificial-intelligence adviser.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gyorgy-tilesch\",\"claim\":\"Technology and artificial-intelligence adviser.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps and obtain reference evidence before assessing factual accuracy." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No contradiction, high-severity flag, or hallucination finding is warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-bojar", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 14, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:b76aa43c77de11aef086de0a00b052308992886f0968b9dcad449357426f1266" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-bojar-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-bojar", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-bojar", "chunk_id": "gabor-bojar-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b76aa43c77de11aef086de0a00b052308992886f0968b9dcad449357426f1266", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:29+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:46+02:00", "duration_s": 17.188, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20849, "output_tokens": 727, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved reference coverage and do not interpret not_covered as hallucination." } ], "summary": "All 14 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Built an internationally successful technology business.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Established Aquincum Institute of Technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Founded Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Founded the software company Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Has participated publicly in Hungarian civic and political debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Has participated publicly in Hungarian political debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He co-founded Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He founded Aquincum Institute of Technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He founded the software company Graphisoft.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He has participated publicly in Hungarian political debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's governing direction.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian technology entrepreneur.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-bojar\",\"claim\":\"Known as a Hungarian technology entrepreneur.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved reference coverage and do not interpret not_covered as hallucination." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 14 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-halmai", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:79f0ad7e37d8cdf11af6787a3e6f9e0e84591867ecb33c73f8b8a34de402552c" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-halmai-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-halmai", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-halmai", "chunk_id": "gabor-halmai-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:79f0ad7e37d8cdf11af6787a3e6f9e0e84591867ecb33c73f8b8a34de402552c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:35+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:49+02:00", "duration_s": 13.734, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21258, "output_tokens": 542, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 17 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, so no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has been associated with human-rights and constitutional institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has held academic positions outside Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has taught and researched at international universities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has taught and researched internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has taught or researched at the European University Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has written extensively on constitutionalism and fundamental rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Has written extensively on fundamental rights and constitutionalism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has held academic positions outside Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has held international academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has taught and conducted research internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has taught and researched at international universities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at the European University Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses constitutionalism and fundamental rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses constitutionalism and human rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses fundamental rights and constitutionalism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-halmai\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 17 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, so no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-ivanyi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 20, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:88c829139ff93398d62558adf1df340f3fbfd06c1aeaa1069ab9876dca84fef9" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-ivanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-ivanyi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-ivanyi", "chunk_id": "gabor-ivanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:88c829139ff93398d62558adf1df340f3fbfd06c1aeaa1069ab9876dca84fef9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:36+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:57+02:00", "duration_s": 20.766, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21441, "output_tokens": 901, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 20 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Founded or led charitable and educational institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Founded or led organizations providing social services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Has led church-affiliated social and charitable institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded and leads charitable and educational institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded or leads organizations providing social services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded or led institutions providing social and educational services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He founded or led organizations providing social services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has been a prominent critic of the Orbán government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has been a prominent critic of Viktor Orbán's government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led charitable and educational work serving disadvantaged people.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led organizations providing social and educational services.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a member of parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian Methodist pastor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Methodist pastor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He leads charitable and educational work.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a member of Hungary's parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a member of parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as a member of Hungary's parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian Methodist pastor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-ivanyi\",\"claim\":\"Previously served as a member of parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 20 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-torok", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b4c098dad70bb3a7aff5eb60b3d6592e3764fe1751d373e316c274a44ddb5015", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:9202a9217177a470b46b30feab2766c98213a191aae970cf83d47136c0a2a319" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "gabor-torok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "gabor-torok", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-gabor-torok", "chunk_id": "gabor-torok-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b4c098dad70bb3a7aff5eb60b3d6592e3764fe1751d373e316c274a44ddb5015", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9202a9217177a470b46b30feab2766c98213a191aae970cf83d47136c0a2a319", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:40+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:15+02:00", "duration_s": 34.375, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20945, "output_tokens": 1128, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "One claim is supported by the supplied reference, twelve are not covered, and none is directly contradicted. The limited CV evidence establishes an ELTE associate professorship, political-scientist status, and political-analysis work, but it does not settle Corvinus teaching, teaching subject, nationality, public commentary, frequency, or public prominence.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference identifies an ELTE position but does not address whether he also taught at Corvinus." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference identifies him as an ELTE associate professor, supporting university teaching." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference calls him a political scientist and associate professor but does not specify what subject he taught." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not establish frequent commentary on Hungarian politics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist is supported, but the reference does not explicitly establish Hungarian nationality or identify him as an analyst." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist and political-analysis work are indicated, but Hungarian nationality and the full professional label are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist is supported, but the reference does not explicitly establish Hungarian nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not establish that he is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Directing a political-analysis firm is documented, but public activity and being known for it are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference indicates political-analysis work but does not establish the analyst label or that he is widely known by it." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist and political-analysis work are indicated, but Hungarian nationality and the full analyst label are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist and political-analysis work are indicated, but Hungarian nationality and the full analyst label are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not establish public commentary or that he is known for commentary on Hungarian politics." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at Corvinus University of Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at university.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He has taught political science.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a frequent commentator on Hungarian politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist and analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist and political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is known for public political analysis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"He is widely known as a political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political analyst and political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist and analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Known for public commentary on Hungarian politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"gabor-torok\",\"claim\":\"Török is a political scientist and ELTE associate professor, directs a political-analysis firm, advised President László Sólyom from 2006 to 2010, and earlier led an institute attached to the SZDSZ parliamentary group.\",\"id\":\"torok-cv\",\"publisher\":\"Gábor Török\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_personal\",\"source_title\":\"Gábor Török — Curriculum Vitae\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference identifies an ELTE position but does not address whether he also taught at Corvinus." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference identifies him as an ELTE associate professor, supporting university teaching." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference calls him a political scientist and associate professor but does not specify what subject he taught." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not establish frequent commentary on Hungarian politics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist is supported, but the reference does not explicitly establish Hungarian nationality or identify him as an analyst." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist and political-analysis work are indicated, but Hungarian nationality and the full professional label are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist is supported, but the reference does not explicitly establish Hungarian nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not establish that he is known for public commentary on Hungarian politics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Directing a political-analysis firm is documented, but public activity and being known for it are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference indicates political-analysis work but does not establish the analyst label or that he is widely known by it." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist and political-analysis work are indicated, but Hungarian nationality and the full analyst label are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Political scientist and political-analysis work are indicated, but Hungarian nationality and the full analyst label are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not establish public commentary or that he is known for commentary on Hungarian politics." } ], "summary": "One claim is supported by the supplied reference, twelve are not covered, and none is directly contradicted. The limited CV evidence establishes an ELTE associate professorship, political-scientist status, and political-analysis work, but it does not settle Corvinus teaching, teaching subject, nationality, public commentary, frequency, or public prominence.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ignac-romsics", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:9f654f68e1503e702cae677eb46a5876e165e7ce04e2cec8fe739cb34b4bf92f" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "ignac-romsics-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ignac-romsics", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ignac-romsics", "chunk_id": "ignac-romsics-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9f654f68e1503e702cae677eb46a5876e165e7ce04e2cec8fe739cb34b4bf92f", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:41+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:58+02:00", "duration_s": 17.078, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21259, "output_tokens": 536, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 17 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. The limited packet therefore supports neither confirmation nor contradiction; this result is not evidence that any claim is a hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic standing.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has held university teaching positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Has written widely used historical syntheses.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic standing.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian historian.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He is a prominent Hungarian historian.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"He specializes in modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship focuses substantially on modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship focuses substantially on twentieth-century Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes twentieth-century Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian historian specializing in modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian historian.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Known for scholarship on modern Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ignac-romsics\",\"claim\":\"Known for scholarship on twentieth-century Hungarian history.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 17 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. The limited packet therefore supports neither confirmation nor contradiction; this result is not evidence that any claim is a hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ildiko-enyedi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 15, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:573c51c72022f76d559a5c2f35271d0fbbc2cd4cd4c680d8456541b42e49783c" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "ildiko-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ildiko-enyedi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ildiko-enyedi", "chunk_id": "ildiko-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:573c51c72022f76d559a5c2f35271d0fbbc2cd4cd4c680d8456541b42e49783c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:42+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:59+02:00", "duration_s": 17.109, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21166, "output_tokens": 714, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 15 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be marked supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Directed On Body and Soul.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Has received major international film recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her film On Body and Soul won the Berlin Golden Bear.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her film On Body and Soul won the Golden Bear.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her films have received major international awards.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her films have received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian film director and screenwriter.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Received major international film recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She directed On Body and Soul.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She has received international recognition for her filmmaking.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She has received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian film director and screenwriter.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ildiko-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian film director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 15 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be marked supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 16, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:d8f8f757db3c9446248f72d3dd524ab6803a6bbc7fd0ba22b23fa3c50b29b746" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ilona-palne-kovacs", "chunk_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d8f8f757db3c9446248f72d3dd524ab6803a6bbc7fd0ba22b23fa3c50b29b746", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:42+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:00+02:00", "duration_s": 17.984, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21255, "output_tokens": 586, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage limitations, not hallucination findings; provide reference evidence for substantive verification." } ], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic and research roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic research roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her research includes local and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship concerns governance and regional administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship concerns local government and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her scholarship has addressed decentralization and local government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her work concerns regional governance and public administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes local governance and regional studies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist associated with research on regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on local and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on local government and regional governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on regional governance and decentralization.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior research roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ilona-palne-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage limitations, not hallucination findings; provide reference evidence for substantive verification." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "imre-voros", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 19, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:22a4d0e89a29a02830721117ad2dcee989d56122c120697fcaf6ff14598c40e9" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "imre-voros-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "imre-voros", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-imre-voros", "chunk_id": "imre-voros-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:22a4d0e89a29a02830721117ad2dcee989d56122c120697fcaf6ff14598c40e9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:44+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:05+02:00", "duration_s": 20.766, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21550, "output_tokens": 602, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 19 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, so no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing either component of this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Former Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Former judge of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Former judge of the Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Has publicly addressed constitutional questions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Has written and spoken on constitutional issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He has commented publicly on constitutional questions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior judicial office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in constitutional law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist and constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"He served as a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian jurist and former Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Known as a scholar of constitutional and economic law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Legal scholar specializing in public and constitutional law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"imre-voros\",\"claim\":\"Served as a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing either component of this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 19 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, so no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ivan-fischer", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:474e1e726d8263716f10a2ad62354101a58090127bb5c59e0bb1b970a02f90a4" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "ivan-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "ivan-fischer", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-ivan-fischer", "chunk_id": "ivan-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:474e1e726d8263716f10a2ad62354101a58090127bb5c59e0bb1b970a02f90a4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:45+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:02+02:00", "duration_s": 17.062, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20784, "output_tokens": 701, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps and do not interpret them as evidence of hallucination." } ], "summary": "All 13 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has conducted internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has conducted major international orchestras.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has conducted major orchestras internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Has led major orchestras internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He co-founded the Budapest Festival Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led major international musical performances.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led major international orchestras.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led major orchestras internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has spoken publicly on Hungarian civic affairs.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian conductor and co-founder of the Budapest Festival Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"ivan-fischer\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian conductor and composer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps and do not interpret them as evidence of hallucination." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "janos-martonyi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 19, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:e8d43a546b0fa20a531fe79f64f73e33ca9ef9845881d3e1c773ca687d3cff37" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "janos-martonyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "janos-martonyi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-janos-martonyi", "chunk_id": "janos-martonyi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:e8d43a546b0fa20a531fe79f64f73e33ca9ef9845881d3e1c773ca687d3cff37", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:45+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:01+02:00", "duration_s": 15.39, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21146, "output_tokens": 591, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 19 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. The packet supports no factual confirmation or contradiction, so no hallucination or high-severity contradiction flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Has a legal and diplomatic background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He has a legal and diplomatic background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He held ministerial office in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He held office in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian lawyer and diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer and diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served twice as foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"He served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Held office in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian lawyer and politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Is a lawyer and diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Is trained as a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister in two Fidesz governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served twice as foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"janos-martonyi\",\"claim\":\"Served twice as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 19 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. The packet supports no factual confirmation or contradiction, so no hallucination or high-severity contradiction flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "jozsef-palinkas", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 12, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:095dac47433bb21f0b3e5da7606bacbe0431c06c40453848e193e103092c4ab9", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:bc96d1472953309bc83fe359891b12c7d35f52626760ed68a0b8ef170e76a295" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "jozsef-palinkas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "jozsef-palinkas", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-palinkas", "chunk_id": "jozsef-palinkas-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:095dac47433bb21f0b3e5da7606bacbe0431c06c40453848e193e103092c4ab9", "prompt_hash": "sha256:bc96d1472953309bc83fe359891b12c7d35f52626760ed68a0b8ef170e76a295", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:46+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:04+02:00", "duration_s": 18.047, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20942, "output_tokens": 768, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "Eight claims are supported by the limited reference packet and four are not covered. No claim is directly contradicted, so no high or blocking flags are warranted. The packet establishes Pálinkás's leadership of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and service as education minister, but it does not settle his profession, nationality, Academy membership, or later political activity.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that Pálinkás served as education minister in 2001–2002." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not identify his nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not explicitly identify him as a physicist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not address his relationship with Fidesz or the founding of a separate movement." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that Pálinkás led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His service as education minister in 2001–2002 establishes prior government office." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he served as education minister in 2001–2002." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference says he led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014, supporting the stated presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not explicitly establish either that he is a physicist or that he is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he served as education minister in 2001–2002." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he served as education minister in 2001–2002." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He held ministerial office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He is a physicist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He later broke politically with Fidesz and founded a separate movement.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He previously held government office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's education minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Physicist and member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Previously served as education minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Served as education minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Pálinkás led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014, served as education minister in 2001–2002, and led the National Research, Development and Innovation Office from 2015 to 2018.\",\"id\":\"palinkas-mta\",\"publisher\":\"Hungarian Academy of Sciences\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Pálinkás József\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-palinkas\",\"claim\":\"Pálinkás served as World Science Forum president and represented the Hungarian Academy in international science organizations.\",\"id\":\"palinkas-wsf\",\"publisher\":\"World Science Forum\",\"quality_class\":\"reputable_secondary\",\"source_title\":\"Prof. József Pálinkás\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that Pálinkás served as education minister in 2001–2002." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not identify his nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not explicitly identify him as a physicist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not address his relationship with Fidesz or the founding of a separate movement." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that Pálinkás led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His service as education minister in 2001–2002 establishes prior government office." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he served as education minister in 2001–2002." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference says he led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014, supporting the stated presidency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he led the Hungarian Academy of Sciences from 2008 to 2014." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference does not explicitly establish either that he is a physicist or that he is a member of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he served as education minister in 2001–2002." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he served as education minister in 2001–2002." } ], "summary": "Eight claims are supported by the limited reference packet and four are not covered. No claim is directly contradicted, so no high or blocking flags are warranted. The packet establishes Pálinkás's leadership of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and service as education minister, but it does not settle his profession, nationality, Academy membership, or later political activity.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "jozsef-peter-martin", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 11, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:78152f1be94b307d1424d6d178683b3caafccf258e61f71f33ffb1d74bf97e5a" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "jozsef-peter-martin-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "jozsef-peter-martin", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-jozsef-peter-martin", "chunk_id": "jozsef-peter-martin-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:78152f1be94b307d1424d6d178683b3caafccf258e61f71f33ffb1d74bf97e5a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:49+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:01+02:00", "duration_s": 11.969, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20752, "output_tokens": 394, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 11 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no high or blocking flags are warranted. This limited packet cannot determine whether any claim is true or hallucinatory.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a leadership role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his fields of work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about these professional descriptions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about the subject of his public work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about the focus of his public work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about the focus of his work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about these professional descriptions." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"Associated in my memory with Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"Associated with Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He has been associated with Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He has led Transparency International Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with economic and public-policy analysis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"He is known as an economist and governance commentator.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"His public work concerns corruption and governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"His public work has focused on corruption and governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"His work has focused on economics and governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"jozsef-peter-martin\",\"claim\":\"Known as an economist and policy analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this association." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a leadership role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his fields of work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about these professional descriptions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about the subject of his public work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about the focus of his public work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about the focus of his work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about these professional descriptions." } ], "summary": "All 11 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no high or blocking flags are warranted. This limited packet cannot determine whether any claim is true or hallucinatory.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "julia-kiraly", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 16, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:133f8ef5589f793e203c2061a99e2ef9cedcf29e943ca2018d6c0938197f5ba4", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:b7f8c9534f2a8946337ba89f61fe4ad2afd9796906b166224655ffb53a89a407" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "julia-kiraly-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "julia-kiraly", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-julia-kiraly", "chunk_id": "julia-kiraly-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:133f8ef5589f793e203c2061a99e2ef9cedcf29e943ca2018d6c0938197f5ba4", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b7f8c9534f2a8946337ba89f61fe4ad2afd9796906b166224655ffb53a89a407", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:57+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:26+02:00", "duration_s": 29.14, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21402, "output_tokens": 834, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The packet directly supports the deputy-governor role but does not settle profession, nationality, academic appointments, or early resignation.", "recommendation": "Treat those unsettled claims as not_covered and obtain additional reference evidence before judging their factual accuracy." } ], "summary": "Three deputy-governor claims are supported. Thirteen claims are not covered because the limited packet does not fully establish economist or nationality labels, academic positions, or resignation before term completion. No supplied reference directly contradicts any recalled claim, so no high or blocking flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference supports her former deputy-governor role but does not explicitly establish that she is an economist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Academic work is mentioned, but academic roles in both economics and finance are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet mentions academic work but does not establish that she held academic positions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet gives service dates but does not state that she resigned or left before completing her term." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish either a resignation or an uncompleted term." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Academic work is mentioned, but academic roles in economics and finance are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference mentions academic work, not the holding of an academic role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly establish her profession as economist or her nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Neither the economist designation nor an academic position is explicitly established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied evidence does not explicitly identify her as an economist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The referenced position is ambiguous, and the packet does not establish an early resignation." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet gives her years of service but does not establish resignation before term completion." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not state that she resigned or that her term had not ended." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Bruegel states that Király served as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Bruegel explicitly records her service as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Bruegel explicitly records her service as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Economist and former deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Has held academic roles in economics and finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Held academic positions in economics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Resigned from the central bank before completing her term.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Resigned from the central bank before her term ended.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She has held academic roles in economics and finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She has held academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She is an economist and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She resigned from that position before her term ended.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She resigned from the central bank before completing her term.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She resigned from the central bank before her term ended.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian central bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She served as a deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"She served as deputy governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Király served as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary responsible for financial stability during 2007–2013 and later as an independent KBC Group board member and Hellenic stability-fund panelist.\",\"id\":\"kiraly-bruegel\",\"publisher\":\"Bruegel\",\"quality_class\":\"reputable_secondary\",\"source_title\":\"Júlia Király\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"julia-kiraly\",\"claim\":\"Yale's Journal of Financial Crises describes Király's role overseeing Hungary's emergency response to the global financial crisis and her academic work on crisis management.\",\"id\":\"kiraly-yale\",\"publisher\":\"Yale Program on Financial Stability\",\"quality_class\":\"independent_research\",\"source_title\":\"Lessons Learned: Júlia Király\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The packet directly supports the deputy-governor role but does not settle profession, nationality, academic appointments, or early resignation.", "recommendation": "Treat those unsettled claims as not_covered and obtain additional reference evidence before judging their factual accuracy." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference supports her former deputy-governor role but does not explicitly establish that she is an economist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Academic work is mentioned, but academic roles in both economics and finance are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet mentions academic work but does not establish that she held academic positions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet gives service dates but does not state that she resigned or left before completing her term." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish either a resignation or an uncompleted term." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Academic work is mentioned, but academic roles in economics and finance are not established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference mentions academic work, not the holding of an academic role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly establish her profession as economist or her nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Neither the economist designation nor an academic position is explicitly established." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied evidence does not explicitly identify her as an economist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The referenced position is ambiguous, and the packet does not establish an early resignation." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet gives her years of service but does not establish resignation before term completion." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not state that she resigned or that her term had not ended." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Bruegel states that Király served as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Bruegel explicitly records her service as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Bruegel explicitly records her service as Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Hungary." } ], "summary": "Three deputy-governor claims are supported. Thirteen claims are not covered because the limited packet does not fully establish economist or nationality labels, academic positions, or resignation before term completion. No supplied reference directly contradicts any recalled claim, so no high or blocking flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "katalin-bogyay", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 15, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:413819e6dab956792c4f1c4f4ae29f23e057164e09cc78cea17ceebf439643a8" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "katalin-bogyay-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "katalin-bogyay", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-bogyay", "chunk_id": "katalin-bogyay-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:413819e6dab956792c4f1c4f4ae29f23e057164e09cc78cea17ceebf439643a8", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:40:58+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:14+02:00", "duration_s": 16.0, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21204, "output_tokens": 698, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 15 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be marked supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts indicate absent reference coverage, not hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Held a senior leadership role in the UN General Assembly.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Held senior leadership in UNESCO's General Conference.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She has worked in cultural diplomacy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior role at UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior role representing Hungary at the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She held senior roles connected with UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She is a career diplomat and cultural professional.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's ambassador to UNESCO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's permanent representative to the United Nations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She served as president of UNESCO's General Conference.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-bogyay\",\"claim\":\"She was president of UNESCO's General Conference.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 15 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be marked supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts indicate absent reference coverage, not hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "katalin-kariko", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 68, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b802c3f0cb92a2fe82cdd9f4838a178feb3ee4a613af77595df0ee74291aa471", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:fca788e7623d2fad39608a94994f69dcd38bfb646a17c301fe2fb25ff7dafe39" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "katalin-kariko-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "katalin-kariko", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-katalin-kariko", "chunk_id": "katalin-kariko-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021", "claim-0022", "claim-0023", "claim-0024", "claim-0025", "claim-0026", "claim-0027", "claim-0028", "claim-0029", "claim-0030", "claim-0031", "claim-0032", "claim-0033", "claim-0034", "claim-0035", "claim-0036", "claim-0037", "claim-0038", "claim-0039", "claim-0040", "claim-0041", "claim-0042", "claim-0043", "claim-0044", "claim-0045", "claim-0046", "claim-0047", "claim-0048", "claim-0049", "claim-0050", "claim-0051", "claim-0052", "claim-0053", "claim-0054", "claim-0055", "claim-0056", "claim-0057", "claim-0058", "claim-0059", "claim-0060", "claim-0061", "claim-0062", "claim-0063", "claim-0064", "claim-0065", "claim-0066", "claim-0067", "claim-0068" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b802c3f0cb92a2fe82cdd9f4838a178feb3ee4a613af77595df0ee74291aa471", "prompt_hash": "sha256:fca788e7623d2fad39608a94994f69dcd38bfb646a17c301fe2fb25ff7dafe39", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T23:01:25+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T23:03:12+02:00", "duration_s": 106.781, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 25305, "output_tokens": 4362, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "Of 68 claims, 15 are supported by the limited reference packet, 53 are not covered, and none are directly contradicted. The packet supports Karikó's 2023 Nobel Prize, discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines, and specified Penn, Szeged, and BioNTech positions. It does not settle birthplace or nationality, the biochemist label, career-duration claims, Drew Weissman's co-recipient status, or stronger characterizations such as foundational or central unless separately stated. Not-covered verdicts are not findings of hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet links Karikó to discoveries enabling mRNA vaccines, but does not establish the biochemist label or broader centrality to mRNA technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not characterize her research broadly as foundational mRNA research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not characterize her work as foundational to mRNA therapeutics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations are listed, but the packet does not establish where most of her career was conducted." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Former BioNTech senior vice president is established, but research responsibilities are not specified." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes a senior BioNTech position, but not that it was a research role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence attributes discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines to Karikó." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to the associated vaccine technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly says her discoveries enabled effective mRNA vaccines." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly says her discoveries enabled effective mRNA vaccines." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes enabling discoveries but does not explicitly assess her research as central." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes enabling discoveries but does not explicitly characterize the research as foundational." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to their development." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to mRNA vaccine technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to their development." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly attributes discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines to Karikó." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly characterize her work as foundational." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian identity, the biochemist label, and foundational mRNA research as stated." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Birthplace, national origin, and the biochemist label are not stated in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, and foundational mRNA research as stated." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0022", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or the foundational characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0023", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0024", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Birthplace, national origin, and the biochemist label are not stated in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0025", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not characterize her work broadly as foundational to mRNA therapeutics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0026", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations are listed, but the packet does not establish where most of her scientific career occurred." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0027", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly states that Karikó received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0028", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes her 2023 Nobel Prize but does not name Drew Weissman or state that she shared it with him." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0029", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet says she received the prize but does not specify that it was shared." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0030", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that she built most of her career there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0031", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her career was conducted there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0032", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her research career was conducted there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0033", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Former BioNTech senior vice president is established, but the packet does not identify the position as a research role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0034", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Penn and BioNTech roles are established, but the packet does not specify the claimed research-and-executive role combination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0035", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Professor and adjunct-professor positions support senior academic roles, while former BioNTech senior vice president supports a senior biotechnology role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0036", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes academic and corporate positions but not senior research and corporate roles at both institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0037", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The BioNTech senior vice-presidential position is established, but its research responsibilities are not specified." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0038", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes a senior BioNTech position but does not identify it as a research role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0039", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet lists US academic affiliation but does not establish senior research roles in the United States." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0040", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The packet establishes professorial roles connected with Penn and a former senior vice-presidential role at BioNTech." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0041", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian-American identity or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0042", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or the foundational characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0043", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0044", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or the foundational characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0045", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or foundational work on mRNA technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0046", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet links her discoveries to mRNA vaccines but does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0047", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0048", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0049", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0050", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Birthplace, national origin, and the biochemist label are not stated in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0051", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her career was pursued there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0052", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her research career was pursued there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0053", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her scientific career was pursued there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0054", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes her 2023 Nobel Prize but does not name Drew Weissman as a co-recipient." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0055", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly states that she received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0056", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Receipt of the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine supports the less specific claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0057", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes her 2023 Nobel Prize but does not state that she shared it with Drew Weissman." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0058", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet says she received the prize but does not specify that it was shared." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0059", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that she spent most of her research career there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0060", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes connections to BioNTech and Penn but not the asserted research history and sequence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0061", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The packet establishes Penn professorial affiliation and a former senior vice-presidential position at BioNTech." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0062", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Penn affiliation is established, but its duration is not given." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0063", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet lists US affiliation but does not establish that she worked there for many years." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0064", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Academic and biotechnology positions are established, but the packet does not specify that both involved research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0065", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The packet establishes Penn professorial affiliation and a former senior vice-presidential position at BioNTech." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0066", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet lists Hungarian and US affiliations but does not establish years worked in each country." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0067", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliation is established, but duration is not given." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0068", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliation is established, but duration is not given." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Biochemist central to advances in mRNA technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Biochemist known for foundational work on mRNA therapeutics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Conducted much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Held senior research responsibilities at BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Held senior research roles connected with BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine development.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research helped enable mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research helped enable mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research was central to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her research was foundational to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine development.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work contributed to mRNA vaccine technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work helped enable mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Her work was foundational to mRNA vaccines.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0022\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0023\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born biochemist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0024\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Known for foundational work on mRNA therapeutics\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0025\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Much of her scientific career was pursued in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0026\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0027\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0028\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0029\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She built much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0030\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She conducted much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0031\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She conducted much of her research career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0032\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held a senior research role at BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0033\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held research and executive roles connected with the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0034\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior academic and biotechnology roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0035\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research and corporate roles at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0036\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research responsibilities at BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0037\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research roles connected with BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0038\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior research roles in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0039\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She held senior roles connected with BioNTech and the University of Pennsylvania.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0040\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-American biochemist associated with mRNA technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0041\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0042\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist associated with mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0043\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0044\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for foundational work on mRNA technology.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0045\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for messenger-RNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0046\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for mRNA research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0047\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for research on messenger RNA.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0048\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist known for work on messenger RNA.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0049\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian-born biochemist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0050\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She pursued much of her career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0051\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She pursued much of her research career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0052\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She pursued much of her scientific career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0053\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0054\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0055\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0056\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Drew Weissman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0057\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0058\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She spent much of her research career in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0059\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked at BioNTech after conducting research at the University of Pennsylvania.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0060\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0061\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked for many years at the University of Pennsylvania.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0062\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked for many years in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0063\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"She worked in academic and biotechnology research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0064\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked at the University of Pennsylvania and BioNTech.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0065\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked for many years in Hungary and the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0066\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked for many years in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0067\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Worked for years in the United States.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0068\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Karikó is a University of Szeged professor, Penn adjunct professor, former BioNTech senior vice president, and a 2025 US National Academy of Sciences member.\",\"id\":\"kariko-nas\",\"publisher\":\"US National Academy of Sciences\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Katalin Karikó\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"katalin-kariko\",\"claim\":\"Karikó received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines and was affiliated with the University of Szeged and University of Pennsylvania. This establishes professional credibility and international stature, not candidate-level public support.\",\"id\":\"kariko-nobel\",\"publisher\":\"Nobel Prize Outreach\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Katalin Karikó — Facts\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet links Karikó to discoveries enabling mRNA vaccines, but does not establish the biochemist label or broader centrality to mRNA technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not characterize her research broadly as foundational mRNA research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not characterize her work as foundational to mRNA therapeutics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations are listed, but the packet does not establish where most of her career was conducted." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Former BioNTech senior vice president is established, but research responsibilities are not specified." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes a senior BioNTech position, but not that it was a research role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence attributes discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines to Karikó." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to the associated vaccine technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly says her discoveries enabled effective mRNA vaccines." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly says her discoveries enabled effective mRNA vaccines." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes enabling discoveries but does not explicitly assess her research as central." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes enabling discoveries but does not explicitly characterize the research as foundational." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to their development." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to mRNA vaccine technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines support contribution to their development." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly attributes discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines to Karikó." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly characterize her work as foundational." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian identity, the biochemist label, and foundational mRNA research as stated." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Birthplace, national origin, and the biochemist label are not stated in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, and foundational mRNA research as stated." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0022", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or the foundational characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0023", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0024", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Birthplace, national origin, and the biochemist label are not stated in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0025", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not characterize her work broadly as foundational to mRNA therapeutics." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0026", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations are listed, but the packet does not establish where most of her scientific career occurred." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0027", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly states that Karikó received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0028", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes her 2023 Nobel Prize but does not name Drew Weissman or state that she shared it with him." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0029", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet says she received the prize but does not specify that it was shared." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0030", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that she built most of her career there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0031", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her career was conducted there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0032", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her research career was conducted there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0033", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Former BioNTech senior vice president is established, but the packet does not identify the position as a research role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0034", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Penn and BioNTech roles are established, but the packet does not specify the claimed research-and-executive role combination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0035", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Professor and adjunct-professor positions support senior academic roles, while former BioNTech senior vice president supports a senior biotechnology role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0036", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes academic and corporate positions but not senior research and corporate roles at both institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0037", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The BioNTech senior vice-presidential position is established, but its research responsibilities are not specified." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0038", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes a senior BioNTech position but does not identify it as a research role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0039", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet lists US academic affiliation but does not establish senior research roles in the United States." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0040", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The packet establishes professorial roles connected with Penn and a former senior vice-presidential role at BioNTech." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0041", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian-American identity or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0042", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or the foundational characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0043", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0044", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or the foundational characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0045", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth, the biochemist label, or foundational work on mRNA technology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0046", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet links her discoveries to mRNA vaccines but does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0047", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0048", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0049", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not establish Hungarian birth or explicitly identify her as a biochemist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0050", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Birthplace, national origin, and the biochemist label are not stated in the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0051", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her career was pursued there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0052", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her research career was pursued there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0053", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that most of her scientific career was pursued there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0054", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes her 2023 Nobel Prize but does not name Drew Weissman as a co-recipient." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0055", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The Nobel evidence explicitly states that she received the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0056", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Receipt of the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine supports the less specific claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0057", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes her 2023 Nobel Prize but does not state that she shared it with Drew Weissman." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0058", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet says she received the prize but does not specify that it was shared." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0059", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliations do not establish that she spent most of her research career there." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0060", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet establishes connections to BioNTech and Penn but not the asserted research history and sequence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0061", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The packet establishes Penn professorial affiliation and a former senior vice-presidential position at BioNTech." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0062", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Penn affiliation is established, but its duration is not given." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0063", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet lists US affiliation but does not establish that she worked there for many years." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0064", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Academic and biotechnology positions are established, but the packet does not specify that both involved research." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0065", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The packet establishes Penn professorial affiliation and a former senior vice-presidential position at BioNTech." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0066", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet lists Hungarian and US affiliations but does not establish years worked in each country." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0067", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliation is established, but duration is not given." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0068", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "US affiliation is established, but duration is not given." } ], "summary": "Of 68 claims, 15 are supported by the limited reference packet, 53 are not covered, and none are directly contradicted. The packet supports Karikó's 2023 Nobel Prize, discoveries enabling effective mRNA vaccines, and specified Penn, Szeged, and BioNTech positions. It does not settle birthplace or nationality, the biochemist label, career-duration claims, Drew Weissman's co-recipient status, or stronger characterizations such as foundational or central unless separately stated. Not-covered verdicts are not findings of hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "kinga-goncz", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:d952f1d40a47c8f24ee82ca2ffa52205cd332421c681e03e55a8a9aca3b7b498" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "kinga-goncz-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "kinga-goncz", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kinga-goncz", "chunk_id": "kinga-goncz-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d952f1d40a47c8f24ee82ca2ffa52205cd332421c681e03e55a8a9aca3b7b498", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:00+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:16+02:00", "duration_s": 16.438, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21079, "output_tokens": 420, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 13 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no hallucination or contradiction flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Held ministerial office in an MSZP-led government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Later served in the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Served as a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She is a psychiatrist by training.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She is associated with the Hungarian Socialist Party.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She is the daughter of former president Árpád Göncz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She later served in the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She served as a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She trained and worked in psychiatry.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"She was a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kinga-goncz\",\"claim\":\"Worked in social-policy and governmental roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no hallucination or contradiction flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "kornel-mundruczo", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 12, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:533fea26fc7cf8195df0973e2938726bd006576fc21228986423b594e2d93834" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "kornel-mundruczo-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "kornel-mundruczo", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-kornel-mundruczo", "chunk_id": "kornel-mundruczo-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:533fea26fc7cf8195df0973e2938726bd006576fc21228986423b594e2d93834", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:01+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:15+02:00", "duration_s": 14.329, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21050, "output_tokens": 548, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 12 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. The packet therefore supports no confirmation or contradiction, and no hallucination or high-severity contradiction flag is warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"Directed internationally produced screen and stage works.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"Directed the film White God.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He directed Pieces of a Woman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He directed the film White God.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Proton Theatre company.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He has directed productions outside Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian film and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His films have appeared at major international festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His films have competed at major international festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His films have received recognition at major international festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"His work has appeared at major international film festivals.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"kornel-mundruczo\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian film and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 12 recalled factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. The packet therefore supports no confirmation or contradiction, and no hallucination or high-severity contradiction flag is warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laczo-adrienn", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 4, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:e18f4994d46657d5786bf4aa69cca40ad1c1558fe9be43368d711edf8599f4e9" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "laczo-adrienn-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laczo-adrienn", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laczo-adrienn", "chunk_id": "laczo-adrienn-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:e18f4994d46657d5786bf4aa69cca40ad1c1558fe9be43368d711edf8599f4e9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:01+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:16+02:00", "duration_s": 14.891, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20375, "output_tokens": 209, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All four factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim is supported or contradicted by the limited packet, and no high or blocking flags are warranted. Not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing the factual association with the Hungarian judiciary; the recollection framing itself is not audited as a factual claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing whether she is a Hungarian judge; the personal-recollection framing itself is not audited." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She has been associated with judicial self-governance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She is associated in my recollection with the Hungarian judiciary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laczo-adrienn\",\"claim\":\"She is known to me as a Hungarian judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing the factual association with the Hungarian judiciary; the recollection framing itself is not audited as a factual claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing whether she is a Hungarian judge; the personal-recollection framing itself is not audited." } ], "summary": "All four factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim is supported or contradicted by the limited packet, and no high or blocking flags are warranted. Not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 12, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b52f980fab1babef1ebb680eec3dcd8e66749eed19c88fce521425bb6704dce1", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:b510e81e361a8d6955ff5c142d0c5287d0b90c0326f99d09903216a28a6bd084" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-krasznahorkai", "chunk_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:b52f980fab1babef1ebb680eec3dcd8e66749eed19c88fce521425bb6704dce1", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b510e81e361a8d6955ff5c142d0c5287d0b90c0326f99d09903216a28a6bd084", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:02+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:24+02:00", "duration_s": 22.391, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21155, "output_tokens": 778, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The sole reference establishes only the 2025 Nobel Prize in Literature and a Hungarian-language literary oeuvre; it does not settle any frozen claim.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and add claim-specific authoritative references before evaluating factual accuracy." } ], "summary": "All 12 recalled claims are not_covered. None is directly supported or contradicted by the limited reference packet, so no high or blocking flags are warranted. These verdicts indicate insufficient reference coverage, not hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference identifies a Hungarian-language literary oeuvre but does not state that he is a Hungarian novelist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not characterize him as an internationally acclaimed Hungarian novelist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about the 2015 Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about receipt of the Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the 2015 Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the International Booker Prize in 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the Man Booker International Prize in 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not mention Satantango or its authorship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not directly assess the international recognition achieved by his works." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not list Satantango among his works." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not discuss film adaptations or Béla Tarr." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian novelist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He is an internationally acclaimed Hungarian novelist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He received the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He received the Man Booker International Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the 2015 Man Booker International Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the International Booker Prize in 2015.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the Man Booker International Prize in 2015.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He won the Man Booker International Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"He wrote Satantango.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"His works have achieved substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"His works include Satantango.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"Several of his works were adapted into films by Béla Tarr.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-krasznahorkai\",\"claim\":\"Krasznahorkai received the 2025 Nobel Prize in Literature for his Hungarian-language literary oeuvre.\",\"id\":\"krasznahorkai-nobel\",\"publisher\":\"Nobel Prize Outreach\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"László Krasznahorkai — Facts\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The sole reference establishes only the 2025 Nobel Prize in Literature and a Hungarian-language literary oeuvre; it does not settle any frozen claim.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and add claim-specific authoritative references before evaluating factual accuracy." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference identifies a Hungarian-language literary oeuvre but does not state that he is a Hungarian novelist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not characterize him as an internationally acclaimed Hungarian novelist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about the 2015 Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about receipt of the Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the 2015 Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the International Booker Prize in 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the Man Booker International Prize in 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference provides no evidence about winning the Man Booker International Prize." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not mention Satantango or its authorship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not directly assess the international recognition achieved by his works." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not list Satantango among his works." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference does not discuss film adaptations or Béla Tarr." } ], "summary": "All 12 recalled claims are not_covered. None is directly supported or contradicted by the limited reference packet, so no high or blocking flags are warranted. These verdicts indicate insufficient reference coverage, not hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laszlo-majtenyi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 17, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:a660534b62128870ba80b821017fe48a272e06d6f8462018468929fb75e47dc9" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-majtenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laszlo-majtenyi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-majtenyi", "chunk_id": "laszlo-majtenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:a660534b62128870ba80b821017fe48a272e06d6f8462018468929fb75e47dc9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:04+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:23+02:00", "duration_s": 18.531, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21371, "output_tokens": 774, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 17 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, and no hallucination or contradiction flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Eötvös Károly Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a constitutional lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with the Eötvös Károly Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He led the Eötvös Károly Policy Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's data-protection ombudsman.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's first parliamentary commissioner for data protection.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection and freedom of information.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's parliamentary commissioner for data protection.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-backed presidential nominee in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-supported presidential nominee in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"Led the Eötvös Károly Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's first parliamentary commissioner for data protection.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-majtenyi\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition-backed presidential candidate in 2017.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 17 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, and no hallucination or contradiction flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 15, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:444fa7d998d3df138caef38b79a3eebc4f3d2c6e0d44afcc75bbe830fe35438e" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-laszlo-trocsanyi", "chunk_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:444fa7d998d3df138caef38b79a3eebc4f3d2c6e0d44afcc75bbe830fe35438e", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:05+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:19+02:00", "duration_s": 14.328, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21224, "output_tokens": 501, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 15 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"Became a Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He became a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He became a member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later became a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later became a Fidesz-affiliated member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later became a Member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a Fidesz member of the European Parliament.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as an ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's ambassador to France.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's justice minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's minister of justice.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to France.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"laszlo-trocsanyi\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's justice minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 15 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this limited packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "miklos-perenyi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 12, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:09bc4e51d4d226c8575debd5a18cf3907003f10bed191e8fbd8a076da1684f78" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "miklos-perenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "miklos-perenyi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-miklos-perenyi", "chunk_id": "miklos-perenyi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:09bc4e51d4d226c8575debd5a18cf3907003f10bed191e8fbd8a076da1684f78", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:14+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:27+02:00", "duration_s": 13.203, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21024, "output_tokens": 482, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled factual claims can be supported or contradicted by the packet.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps; add relevant reference evidence before drawing factual-recall conclusions." } ], "summary": "All 12 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags. These verdicts indicate only the packet's complete coverage limitation and are not evidence of hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has an international performance career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has had a prominent international performing career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has had an international performing career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has had an internationally recognized performance career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has performed internationally as a soloist and chamber musician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has performed internationally.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at the Liszt Academy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught music at a senior level.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He has taught music in Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian cellist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"miklos-perenyi\",\"claim\":\"He taught at the Franz Liszt Academy of Music.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled factual claims can be supported or contradicted by the packet.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps; add relevant reference evidence before drawing factual-recall conclusions." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 12 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-supported claims, direct contradictions, or high/blocking flags. These verdicts indicate only the packet's complete coverage limitation and are not evidence of hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "marta-pardavi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 18, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:1d29ffa546a278f78a3e85cd08dd020df948c84b307773f65d27dd6eeb84a361" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "marta-pardavi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "marta-pardavi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-marta-pardavi", "chunk_id": "marta-pardavi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1d29ffa546a278f78a3e85cd08dd020df948c84b307773f65d27dd6eeb84a361", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:15+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:35+02:00", "duration_s": 20.453, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21377, "output_tokens": 910, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved rather than as evidence of hallucination; supply reference evidence for factual adjudication." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, hallucination, or exclusion-worthy sample can be established from this packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her organization has litigated and advocated on asylum and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has addressed asylum and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has addressed refugee protection and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on human rights and asylum law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on human rights and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on rule-of-law and migration-related rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has focused on rule-of-law and refugee-rights issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has included refugee and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"Her work has significant international visibility.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She has held a leadership role at the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She has served as co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian lawyer and human-rights advocate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a lawyer and co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a lawyer and human-rights advocate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is a leader of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"marta-pardavi\",\"claim\":\"She is co-chair of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved rather than as evidence of hallucination; supply reference evidence for factual adjudication." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, hallucination, or exclusion-worthy sample can be established from this packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "nora-l-ritok", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 15, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:9f152384b92899165bfd2d0e145f8f5c7be58eb0ece5d37f0775dcc5b355ca6a" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "nora-l-ritok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "nora-l-ritok", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-nora-l-ritok", "chunk_id": "nora-l-ritok-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9f152384b92899165bfd2d0e145f8f5c7be58eb0ece5d37f0775dcc5b355ca6a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:15+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:34+02:00", "duration_s": 18.828, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21198, "output_tokens": 699, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 15 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; not_covered does not imply hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Founded the Real Pearl Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on education and disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged children.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on poverty and disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Her work focuses on poverty and educational exclusion.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She founded and leads the Real Pearl Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She founded the Igazgyöngy Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She founded the Real Pearl Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian educator and civil-society leader.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is an educator and civil-society leader.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is an educator.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"She is associated with the Igazgyöngy Foundation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"nora-l-ritok\",\"claim\":\"Works on education and poverty reduction in disadvantaged communities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 15 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted; not_covered does not imply hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "pal-sonnevend", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 14, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:1c43ea3432bed5ad6ce40e1e01d49562739220dd7efa02e9d37d9d1b10be087d" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "pal-sonnevend-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "pal-sonnevend", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-pal-sonnevend", "chunk_id": "pal-sonnevend-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1c43ea3432bed5ad6ce40e1e01d49562739220dd7efa02e9d37d9d1b10be087d", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:16+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:29+02:00", "duration_s": 13.453, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20883, "output_tokens": 493, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 14 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted; lack of coverage is not evidence of hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has been affiliated with ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has been associated with Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has held a professorial role at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has held a senior academic role at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has held an academic leadership role at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He has taught law at Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar associated with constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian scholar of constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"His work concerns European public law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"His work includes constitutional and European law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"pal-sonnevend\",\"claim\":\"Is a Hungarian constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 14 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted; lack of coverage is not evidence of hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-balazs", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:325df0e1c8c969d908765bffea0dd40281a9456686f25f4b5e65be1da396f43c" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-balazs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-balazs", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-balazs", "chunk_id": "peter-balazs-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:325df0e1c8c969d908765bffea0dd40281a9456686f25f4b5e65be1da396f43c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:16+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:28+02:00", "duration_s": 11.829, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20815, "output_tokens": 426, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 13 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no hallucination or high-severity finding is established by this limited packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He had a long diplomatic and European-policy career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He has a long diplomatic career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior diplomatic posts.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior diplomatic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He served as a European commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He was Hungary's first European commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He was Hungary's member of the European Commission.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He was Hungary's member of the first European Commission after EU accession.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"He worked as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"Was a European Commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-balazs\",\"claim\":\"Worked as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no hallucination or high-severity finding is established by this limited packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-barandy", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 11, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:650e4fde479206192a22f77730911571bacc2020b4a071d7a261d8f833906db1", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:121575e93c1d29fefe198601eece99061e36fe5f4b612f50439e98ed0b8b5145" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-barandy-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-barandy", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-barandy", "chunk_id": "peter-barandy-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:650e4fde479206192a22f77730911571bacc2020b4a071d7a261d8f833906db1", "prompt_hash": "sha256:121575e93c1d29fefe198601eece99061e36fe5f4b612f50439e98ed0b8b5145", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:19+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:40+02:00", "duration_s": 21.312, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21117, "output_tokens": 803, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The packet supports Bárándy's legal career and 2002–2004 justice-minister service but does not explicitly cover nationality, family prominence, or the Medgyessy-government attribution.", "recommendation": "Treat those unsettled claims as not_covered unless additional reference evidence is supplied." } ], "summary": "Six claims are supported and five are not covered. No supplied reference directly contradicts any claim, so no high or blocking flags are warranted. The packet is limited and does not constitute a complete truth benchmark.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The references identify him as a lawyer but do not explicitly state his nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "His legal career is supported, but the references do not establish membership in a prominent Hungarian legal family." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "His legal career is supported, but the references do not address his family background or its prominence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "ELTE explicitly lists Bárándy as a lawyer, and his professional biography records his legal career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Both references identify him as a former Hungarian justice minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The archived biography records service as justice minister from 2002 to 2004." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Both references identify him as a former Hungarian justice minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Ministerial service from 2002 to 2004 is supported, but the packet does not name the Medgyessy government." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly connect Bárándy to the Medgyessy government." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "ELTE explicitly lists Bárándy as a lawyer, and his professional biography records his legal career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Both references identify him as a former Hungarian justice minister." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer from a prominent Hungarian legal family.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer from a prominent legal family.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's justice minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's minister of justice in the early 2000s.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's minister of justice.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served as minister of justice in the Medgyessy government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"He served in the Medgyessy government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"Is a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's minister of justice.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"Bárándy's archived professional biography records a long criminal-law and bar-association career, university teaching, and service as justice minister from 2002 to 2004.\",\"id\":\"barandy-biography\",\"publisher\":\"Archived personal professional site\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_personal\",\"source_title\":\"Dr. Péter Bárándy — Biography\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-barandy\",\"claim\":\"ELTE lists Bárándy as a lawyer, former justice minister, and lecturer in its criminal-law department.\",\"id\":\"barandy-elte\",\"publisher\":\"Eötvös Loránd University Faculty of Law\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Dr. Bárándy Péter\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The packet supports Bárándy's legal career and 2002–2004 justice-minister service but does not explicitly cover nationality, family prominence, or the Medgyessy-government attribution.", "recommendation": "Treat those unsettled claims as not_covered unless additional reference evidence is supplied." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The references identify him as a lawyer but do not explicitly state his nationality." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "His legal career is supported, but the references do not establish membership in a prominent Hungarian legal family." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "His legal career is supported, but the references do not address his family background or its prominence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "ELTE explicitly lists Bárándy as a lawyer, and his professional biography records his legal career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Both references identify him as a former Hungarian justice minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The archived biography records service as justice minister from 2002 to 2004." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Both references identify him as a former Hungarian justice minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Ministerial service from 2002 to 2004 is supported, but the packet does not name the Medgyessy government." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly connect Bárándy to the Medgyessy government." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "ELTE explicitly lists Bárándy as a lawyer, and his professional biography records his legal career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Both references identify him as a former Hungarian justice minister." } ], "summary": "Six claims are supported and five are not covered. No supplied reference directly contradicts any claim, so no high or blocking flags are warranted. The packet is limited and does not constitute a complete truth benchmark.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-darak", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:da07ec607c098c5fef89c7bfe206fe5e134d93f3dca43fab24d2d71f24ab7816" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-darak-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-darak", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-darak", "chunk_id": "peter-darak-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:da07ec607c098c5fef89c7bfe206fe5e134d93f3dca43fab24d2d71f24ab7816", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:23+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:37+02:00", "duration_s": 14.219, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20826, "output_tokens": 488, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-indeterminate and obtain reference evidence before assessing factual accuracy." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, high-severity issue, or hallucination finding can be established from this limited packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"Has a judicial and legal background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He has a senior judicial and legal background.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He is a jurist with senior judicial experience.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He is a jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He previously worked as a judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Curia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Curia of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Kúria, Hungary's highest ordinary court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Kúria, Hungary's supreme court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"His professional background includes tax law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"His professional background is in law and the judiciary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-darak\",\"claim\":\"Served as president of the Curia of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-indeterminate and obtain reference evidence before assessing factual accuracy." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradiction, high-severity issue, or hallucination finding can be established from this limited packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-kovacs", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:c066f187a1b9256737365d63c8905706aa70f3d9fff809db1d411ac3391da708" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-kovacs", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kovacs", "chunk_id": "peter-kovacs-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:c066f187a1b9256737365d63c8905706aa70f3d9fff809db1d411ac3391da708", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:47:59+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:48:48+02:00", "duration_s": 49.328, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21503, "output_tokens": 79, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "The sole factual claim is not covered because the limited reference packet is empty. This verdict does not establish that the claim is true, false, or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kovacs\",\"claim\":\"A Hungarian jurist named Péter Kovács served as a judge of the International Criminal Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "The sole factual claim is not covered because the limited reference packet is empty. This verdict does not establish that the claim is true, false, or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-kreko", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 21, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:ee061e308f975343a9758654be1b80f708cdd33bc364f34e1a52337ef5e0e1b0" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-kreko-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-kreko", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-kreko", "chunk_id": "peter-kreko-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:ee061e308f975343a9758654be1b80f708cdd33bc364f34e1a52337ef5e0e1b0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:47:59+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:48:41+02:00", "duration_s": 41.875, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22512, "output_tokens": 1049, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_evidence", "message": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and do not infer hallucination or exclude samples on this basis." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because reference_evidence is empty. No contradiction, high-severity finding, or basis for sample exclusion was established.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Director of Political Capital.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Director of the Political Capital Institute\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Director of the Political Capital Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He directs the Political Capital Institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Political Capital institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He has led the Political Capital research institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political psychologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"He leads the Political Capital institute.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His public work addresses disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His research includes disinformation and political radicalism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work addresses political extremism and disinformation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work includes political extremism and disinformation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"His work includes research on disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian social psychologist and political analyst.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Researches disinformation and political extremism\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Researches disinformation and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-kreko\",\"claim\":\"Researches disinformation, populism, and political extremism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_evidence", "message": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and do not infer hallucination or exclude samples on this basis." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because reference_evidence is empty. No contradiction, high-severity finding, or basis for sample exclusion was established.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-nadas", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 21, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:1fa4c136fc130aaa500923526109460344a1376709d2ca12c0488a0de9ee6692" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-nadas-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-nadas", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-nadas", "chunk_id": "peter-nadas-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:1fa4c136fc130aaa500923526109460344a1376709d2ca12c0488a0de9ee6692", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:47:59+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:48:37+02:00", "duration_s": 38.766, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22493, "output_tokens": 968, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "The reference packet contains no evidence, so none of the recalled claims can be evaluated as supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Provide reference evidence if support or contradiction judgments are required; retain all current samples as not covered." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions, high-severity flags, or exclusion candidates were identified; this result does not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Author of A Book of Memories\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Author of A Book of Memories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He has substantial international literary recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian novelist and essayist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian writer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is a major Hungarian writer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is known for major novels including A Book of Memories and Parallel Stories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is known for major novels including Parallel Stories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"He is known for major works of modern European literature.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His literary work has received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His novels have received extensive international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has broad international recognition\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has extensive international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has received major international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work has received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His work often engages with history, memory, and political life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His works have received extensive international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His works have received substantial international recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"His works include A Book of Memories and Parallel Stories.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian novelist and essayist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-nadas\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian novelist and essayist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "The reference packet contains no evidence, so none of the recalled claims can be evaluated as supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Provide reference evidence if support or contradiction judgments are required; retain all current samples as not covered." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No reference evidence was supplied." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions, high-severity flags, or exclusion candidates were identified; this result does not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-paczolay", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 61, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:688f558b8cd5eca237a0632825895ac8bffcb4feda8409ac4feaff048a92def3", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:99f2d08703a8fcd93205d085d439adfe33f1c7ee22b613211e55f2cdd13b0ad4" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-paczolay-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-paczolay", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-paczolay", "chunk_id": "peter-paczolay-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021", "claim-0022", "claim-0023", "claim-0024", "claim-0025", "claim-0026", "claim-0027", "claim-0028", "claim-0029", "claim-0030", "claim-0031", "claim-0032", "claim-0033", "claim-0034", "claim-0035", "claim-0036", "claim-0037", "claim-0038", "claim-0039", "claim-0040", "claim-0041", "claim-0042", "claim-0043", "claim-0044", "claim-0045", "claim-0046", "claim-0047", "claim-0048", "claim-0049", "claim-0050", "claim-0051", "claim-0052", "claim-0053", "claim-0054", "claim-0055", "claim-0056", "claim-0057", "claim-0058", "claim-0059", "claim-0060", "claim-0061" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:688f558b8cd5eca237a0632825895ac8bffcb4feda8409ac4feaff048a92def3", "prompt_hash": "sha256:99f2d08703a8fcd93205d085d439adfe33f1c7ee22b613211e55f2cdd13b0ad4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T23:01:25+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T23:02:40+02:00", "duration_s": 75.187, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 24866, "output_tokens": 3167, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The packet directly covers Constitutional Court service, the ECHR judgeship, and Venice Commission leadership, but does not settle the diplomatic, ambassadorial, academic, or professional-label claims.", "recommendation": "Treat all not_covered verdicts as unresolved rather than false, and obtain additional references before using them as hallucination labels." } ], "summary": "Of 61 claims, 26 are supported by the supplied references, 35 are not covered, and none are directly contradicted. No high or blocking flags are warranted. The limited packet supports Constitutional Court presidency, ECHR judicial service, and broadly phrased European legal or human-rights judicial work; it does not provide a complete benchmark for diplomatic, ambassadorial, academic, or jurist/scholar claims.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that Paczolay has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly identifies him as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference says he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference says he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Serving as an ECHR judge is the asserted judicial role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet provides no information about a diplomatic post in Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His 2008–2015 presidency supports that he formerly led the Constitutional Court." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His 2008–2015 presidency supports that he formerly presided over the Court." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not describe his academic background or political-thought work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No diplomatic posting is documented in the supplied references." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet mentions European institutional roles but no diplomatic role connected to the Council of Europe." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No Hungarian diplomatic post in Italy is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address whether he held a Hungarian diplomatic post." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No Hungarian diplomatic posting in Italy is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "An ECHR judgeship supports the broader claim of an international judicial role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied references do not mention diplomatic office." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Serving as an ECHR judge entails European human-rights judicial responsibilities." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not state that he served as a diplomat." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0022", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not document service as a Hungarian ambassador." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0023", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Diplomatic employment is not addressed by the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0024", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Service as an ECHR judge supports work in European human-rights adjudication." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0025", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The cited ECHR judgeship and Venice Commission leadership support work in European legal institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0026", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet provides no evidence about a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0027", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet provides no evidence about a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Rome." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0028", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No ambassadorial post is mentioned." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0029", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet describes judicial and institutional roles but does not identify him as a constitutional-law scholar." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0030", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The former presidency is supported, but the packet does not explicitly establish the additional characterization as a Hungarian jurist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0031", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly characterize him as a Hungarian jurist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0032", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly identify him as a legal scholar." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0033", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0034", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0035", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No senior diplomatic post in Rome is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0036", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The references do not address service as a diplomat." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0037", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The references do not document service as a Hungarian ambassador." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0038", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0039", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0040", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0041", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address service in a diplomatic role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0042", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address service in diplomatic office." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0043", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not document service as a Hungarian ambassador." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0044", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0045", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0046", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0047", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference states that he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0048", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not document a diplomatic role for Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0049", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0050", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly establish either the jurist or constitutional-law-scholar characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0051", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not identify him as a constitutional-law scholar." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0052", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0053", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address later service as a diplomat." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0054", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0055", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0056", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0057", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0058", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0059", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0060", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference states that he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0061", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet mentions the ECHR and Venice Commission but does not characterize his work as being in European constitutional-law institutions." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He also held a diplomatic post in Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He formerly led Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He formerly presided over Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has an academic background in constitutional law and political thought.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a diplomatic posting.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a diplomatic role connected to the Council of Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a Hungarian diplomatic post.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held a judicial role at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held an international judicial role.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held diplomatic office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has held European human-rights judicial responsibilities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a Hungarian ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0022\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has worked as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0023\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in European human-rights adjudication.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0024\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in European legal institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0025\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0026\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He held a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0027\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He held an ambassadorial post.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0028\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0029\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist and former president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0030\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0031\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He is a legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0032\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0033\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later became a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0034\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later held a senior diplomatic post in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0035\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0036\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a Hungarian ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0037\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0038\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0039\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0040\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served in a diplomatic role.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0041\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He later served in diplomatic office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0042\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as a Hungarian ambassador.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0043\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0044\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0045\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0046\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0047\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"He served Hungary in a diplomatic role.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0048\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Held a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0049\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian jurist and constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0050\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Is a constitutional-law scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0051\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Later became a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0052\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Later served as a diplomat.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0053\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Later served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0054\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0055\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0056\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as a judge of the European Court of Human Rights.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0057\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0058\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as Hungary's ambassador to Italy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0059\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0060\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Worked in European constitutional-law institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0061\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Paczolay served as a Constitutional Court judge from 2006 and as President of the Court from 2008 to 2015; he had earlier been chief counsellor and Secretary General of the Court and led the Office of the President.\",\"id\":\"paczolay-court\",\"publisher\":\"Constitutional Court of Hungary\",\"quality_class\":\"primary_official\",\"source_title\":\"Péter Paczolay — Former member\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-paczolay\",\"claim\":\"Paczolay has served as an ECHR judge since 2017 and previously served in leadership roles in the Venice Commission.\",\"id\":\"paczolay-europe\",\"publisher\":\"Mathias Corvinus Collegium\",\"quality_class\":\"reputable_secondary\",\"source_title\":\"Péter Paczolay\"}]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "code": "limited_reference_coverage", "message": "The packet directly covers Constitutional Court service, the ECHR judgeship, and Venice Commission leadership, but does not settle the diplomatic, ambassadorial, academic, or professional-label claims.", "recommendation": "Treat all not_covered verdicts as unresolved rather than false, and obtain additional references before using them as hallucination labels." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that Paczolay has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly identifies him as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference says he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference says he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Serving as an ECHR judge is the asserted judicial role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet provides no information about a diplomatic post in Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His 2008–2015 presidency supports that he formerly led the Constitutional Court." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "His 2008–2015 presidency supports that he formerly presided over the Court." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not describe his academic background or political-thought work." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No diplomatic posting is documented in the supplied references." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet mentions European institutional roles but no diplomatic role connected to the Council of Europe." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No Hungarian diplomatic post in Italy is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address whether he held a Hungarian diplomatic post." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No Hungarian diplomatic posting in Italy is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "An ECHR judgeship supports the broader claim of an international judicial role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The supplied references do not mention diplomatic office." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Serving as an ECHR judge entails European human-rights judicial responsibilities." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not state that he served as a diplomat." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0022", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not document service as a Hungarian ambassador." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0023", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "Diplomatic employment is not addressed by the packet." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0024", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "Service as an ECHR judge supports work in European human-rights adjudication." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0025", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The cited ECHR judgeship and Venice Commission leadership support work in European legal institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0026", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet provides no evidence about a Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0027", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet provides no evidence about a Hungarian diplomatic posting in Rome." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0028", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No ambassadorial post is mentioned." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0029", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet describes judicial and institutional roles but does not identify him as a constitutional-law scholar." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0030", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The former presidency is supported, but the packet does not explicitly establish the additional characterization as a Hungarian jurist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0031", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly characterize him as a Hungarian jurist." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0032", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly identify him as a legal scholar." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0033", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0034", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0035", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No senior diplomatic post in Rome is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0036", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The references do not address service as a diplomat." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0037", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The references do not document service as a Hungarian ambassador." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0038", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0039", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0040", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0041", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address service in a diplomatic role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0042", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address service in diplomatic office." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0043", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not document service as a Hungarian ambassador." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0044", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0045", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0046", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0047", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference states that he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0048", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not document a diplomatic role for Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0049", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "No Hungarian diplomatic post in Rome is documented." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0050", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not explicitly establish either the jurist or constitutional-law-scholar characterization." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0051", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not identify him as a constitutional-law scholar." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0052", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0053", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not address later service as a diplomat." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0054", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference states that he has served as an ECHR judge since 2017." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0055", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0056", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0057", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The reference explicitly states that he has served as an ECHR judge." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0058", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0059", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet does not mention service as Hungary's ambassador to Italy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0060", "verdict": "supported_by_reference", "note": "The official reference states that he was President of Hungary's Constitutional Court from 2008 to 2015." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0061", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The packet mentions the ECHR and Venice Commission but does not characterize his work as being in European constitutional-law institutions." } ], "summary": "Of 61 claims, 26 are supported by the supplied references, 35 are not covered, and none are directly contradicted. No high or blocking flags are warranted. The limited packet supports Constitutional Court presidency, ECHR judicial service, and broadly phrased European legal or human-rights judicial work; it does not provide a complete benchmark for diplomatic, ambassadorial, academic, or jurist/scholar claims.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-rona", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 28, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:8364c7fac9d09adca8ffb906624a640f65968d0c58ea80f281536f8d10eeadf4" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-rona-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-rona", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-rona", "chunk_id": "peter-rona-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021", "claim-0022", "claim-0023", "claim-0024", "claim-0025", "claim-0026", "claim-0027", "claim-0028" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:8364c7fac9d09adca8ffb906624a640f65968d0c58ea80f281536f8d10eeadf4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:47:59+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:48:46+02:00", "duration_s": 46.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22876, "output_tokens": 1339, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 28 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts assess reference coverage only and do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles in the United Kingdom." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about an Oxford affiliation." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about work in international finance or academia." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality, professions, or an international career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about birthplace or professional and academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a professional career in the United Kingdom." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a central-bank supervisory role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service on the Hungarian National Bank's supervisory board." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about international work in law and finance." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality, professions, or an international career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about birthplace or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0022", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service on the National Bank of Hungary's supervisory board." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0023", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0024", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0025", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0026", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0027", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential candidacy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0028", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about international work in finance and academia." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Has taught at the University of Oxford\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has held academic roles at Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has held academic roles in the United Kingdom.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has held an academic affiliation with Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He has worked in international finance and academia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and jurist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and lawyer with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian-born lawyer, economist, and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He pursued a substantial professional career in the United Kingdom.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He served in a supervisory role connected to Hungary's central bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He served on the supervisory board of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He was an opposition-backed presidential nominee in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"He worked internationally in law and finance.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Held academic roles at Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and lawyer\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and lawyer with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian-born economist and lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Opposition parties nominated him for president of Hungary in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Served on the supervisory board of the National Bank of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0022\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Taught at the University of Oxford.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0023\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"The opposition nominated him for president of Hungary in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0024\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition nominee for president in 2022\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0025\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition nominee for president of Hungary in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0026\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Was an opposition-supported presidential candidate in 2022.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0027\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-rona\",\"claim\":\"Worked internationally in finance and academia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0028\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles in the United Kingdom." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about an Oxford affiliation." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about work in international finance or academia." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality, professions, or an international career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about birthplace or professional and academic roles." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a professional career in the United Kingdom." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a central-bank supervisory role." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service on the Hungarian National Bank's supervisory board." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about international work in law and finance." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about academic roles at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality, professions, or an international career." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about birthplace or professions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0022", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service on the National Bank of Hungary's supervisory board." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0023", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Oxford." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0024", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0025", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0026", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential nomination." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0027", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a 2022 presidential candidacy." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0028", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about international work in finance and academia." } ], "summary": "All 28 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts assess reference coverage only and do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-akos-bod", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 16, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:45238b70b031e9e90a30bacbe277d40bf263a1a8c74a17036bf3c8e622bdf39d" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "peter-akos-bod-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "peter-akos-bod", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-peter-akos-bod", "chunk_id": "peter-akos-bod-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:45238b70b031e9e90a30bacbe277d40bf263a1a8c74a17036bf3c8e622bdf39d", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:30+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:48+02:00", "duration_s": 18.36, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21238, "output_tokens": 794, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about prior leadership of the Hungarian National Bank." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his work as an economist or university professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his work as an economist or academic." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his work as an economist or university professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a prior ministerial post." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about prior service as a government minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as a government minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as governor of the Hungarian National Bank." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as governor of the National Bank of Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as industry and trade minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as president of the Hungarian National Bank." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as a government minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as governor of the Hungarian National Bank." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He formerly served as president of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He has worked as an economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and academic.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist and university professor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He previously held a ministerial post.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as a government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as a government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as governor of the National Bank of Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as industry and trade minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"Is an economist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"Served as a government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"peter-akos-bod\",\"claim\":\"Served as governor of the Hungarian National Bank.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about prior leadership of the Hungarian National Bank." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his work as an economist or university professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his nationality or profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his work as an economist or academic." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his work as an economist or university professor." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about a prior ministerial post." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about prior service as a government minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as a government minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as governor of the Hungarian National Bank." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as governor of the National Bank of Hungary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as industry and trade minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as president of the Hungarian National Bank." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about his profession." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as a government minister." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about service as governor of the Hungarian National Bank." } ], "summary": "All 16 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "robert-alfoldi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 15, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:d02297101141c4453378c00b6f8c49454b6f4e561861bb8c14643dbfa4c76ec9" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "robert-alfoldi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "robert-alfoldi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-robert-alfoldi", "chunk_id": "robert-alfoldi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:d02297101141c4453378c00b6f8c49454b6f4e561861bb8c14643dbfa4c76ec9", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:48:37+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:49:26+02:00", "duration_s": 49.062, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 22217, "output_tokens": 528, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 15 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Former director of the National Theatre in Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He has been prominent in Hungarian cultural debate.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian actor and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He led the National Theatre in Budapest.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He served as director of Hungary's National Theatre.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"He served as director of the National Theatre.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became a focus of political and cultural controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became a focus of political controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became a subject of political controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"His tenure became politically contentious.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian actor and theater director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian actor and theatre director\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian actor and theatre director.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"robert-alfoldi\",\"claim\":\"Known for outspoken public positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 15 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 9, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:41d621302f59ab6998074c88d2f0d7ddd640c4bca4bf9805fe605213c12707ba" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-szilveszter-e-vizi", "chunk_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:41d621302f59ab6998074c88d2f0d7ddd640c4bca4bf9805fe605213c12707ba", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T18:48:41+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T18:49:05+02:00", "duration_s": 24.219, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21933, "output_tokens": 466, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All nine factual claims are not covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that the claims are hallucinations.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Former president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He has held prominent roles in Hungarian scientific life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in Hungarian scientific life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian physician and neuroscientist\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"szilveszter-e-vizi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian physician and neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All nine factual claims are not covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that the claims are hallucinations.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tamas-freund", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:3b120f95fc422cafdd6bc7029d5380915889604c011ff8d22fbc4b63c8a0f0d7" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-freund-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tamas-freund", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-freund", "chunk_id": "tamas-freund-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:3b120f95fc422cafdd6bc7029d5380915889604c011ff8d22fbc4b63c8a0f0d7", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:37+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:51+02:00", "duration_s": 14.734, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20828, "output_tokens": 430, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence, so none of the 13 factual claims can be supported or contradicted. All claims are classified as not_covered; this does not establish hallucination, and no high or blocking flags are warranted.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He became president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has an internationally recognized research career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior leadership roles in Hungarian scientific research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has received major international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has received major recognition for brain research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has received major scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He has served as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is a neuroscientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is internationally recognized for brain research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He is president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He received the Brain Prize.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-freund\",\"claim\":\"He serves as president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about this claim." } ], "summary": "The supplied reference packet contains no evidence, so none of the 13 factual claims can be supported or contradicted. All claims are classified as not_covered; this does not establish hallucination, and no high or blocking flags are warranted.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tamas-sulyok", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 10, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:93b1ca7bf3119b05aaca4f9bfa299b7fe53cc0b8016a8fd1ba36ab3205cb5bf0" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-sulyok-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tamas-sulyok", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-sulyok", "chunk_id": "tamas-sulyok-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:93b1ca7bf3119b05aaca4f9bfa299b7fe53cc0b8016a8fd1ba36ab3205cb5bf0", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:40+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:52+02:00", "duration_s": 11.688, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20671, "output_tokens": 404, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and supply reference evidence if factual validation is required." } ], "summary": "All 10 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions, high-severity findings, or hallucinations can be established from this packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He became president of Hungary in 2024.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He has a professional background in law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer by profession.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He is a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He previously served as president of the Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He previously worked as a lawyer and constitutional judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He previously worked as a lawyer.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He served as president of Hungary's Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He was elected by the governing parliamentary majority.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-sulyok\",\"claim\":\"He worked as a lawyer before joining the court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and supply reference evidence if factual validation is required." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 10 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions, high-severity findings, or hallucinations can be established from this packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tamas-vicsek", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 10, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:9b8a4a90e17457acff9e89797c350d3e5d6b3b335f732099718afa9525bb2004" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "tamas-vicsek-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tamas-vicsek", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tamas-vicsek", "chunk_id": "tamas-vicsek-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9b8a4a90e17457acff9e89797c350d3e5d6b3b335f732099718afa9525bb2004", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:44+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:54+02:00", "duration_s": 9.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 20930, "output_tokens": 354, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 10 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts reflect reference-coverage limits and do not establish that any claim is a hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He has an international academic reputation.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He has substantial international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist associated with complex systems research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist known for research on collective motion.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian physicist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is known for research on collective motion and complex systems.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"He is known for work on collective motion and complex systems.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"The Vicsek model bears his name.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tamas-vicsek\",\"claim\":\"The Vicsek model is associated with collective motion.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 10 recalled claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. No claim can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts reflect reference-coverage limits and do not establish that any claim is a hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tibor-navracsics", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 16, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:66a5f3ca97ac89c0b936283dfd4ab962fda88c8a54fdf9ce8348e35698ba0f1c" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "tibor-navracsics-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tibor-navracsics", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tibor-navracsics", "chunk_id": "tibor-navracsics-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:66a5f3ca97ac89c0b936283dfd4ab962fda88c8a54fdf9ce8348e35698ba0f1c", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:04+02:00", "duration_s": 16.344, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21005, "output_tokens": 588, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted by the packet.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps; do not exclude or label any sample as hallucinated based on this audit." } ], "summary": "All 16 recalled claims are not_covered because reference_evidence is empty. The packet supports no factual confirmation or contradiction, so there are no high or blocking flags and no contradicted samples to exclude.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing either component of this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has been a prominent Fidesz politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has been a senior Fidesz politician.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has been a senior politician in Fidesz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles in Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior roles within Fidesz-led governments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has held several Hungarian ministerial posts.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a Hungarian government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a Hungarian minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a senior Fidesz politician and Hungarian minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served as a senior Hungarian government minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He has served in senior Hungarian government positions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He is associated with Fidesz.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He served as a European commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He served as a Hungarian minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He served as Hungary's foreign minister.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tibor-navracsics\",\"claim\":\"He was a European Commissioner.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted by the packet.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as unresolved coverage gaps; do not exclude or label any sample as hallucinated based on this audit." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing either component of this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 16 recalled claims are not_covered because reference_evidence is empty. The packet supports no factual confirmation or contradiction, so there are no high or blocking flags and no contradicted samples to exclude.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tunde-hando", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:19419940f64648229cb0ee1beaa24f05f0afbcf6218afa5656f597b7882bfc13" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "tunde-hando-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "tunde-hando", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-tunde-hando", "chunk_id": "tunde-hando-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:19419940f64648229cb0ee1beaa24f05f0afbcf6218afa5656f597b7882bfc13", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:00+02:00", "duration_s": 11.781, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21071, "output_tokens": 425, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. Not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her court-administration tenure attracted controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her court-administration tenure drew controversy over judicial appointments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial administration record attracted domestic and international criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration decisions attracted domestic and international criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure attracted controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure attracted domestic and international criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure attracted institutional criticism.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"Her judicial-administration tenure drew controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She later became a Constitutional Court judge.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She later became a justice of the Constitutional Court.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She led Hungary's National Judicial Office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She led Hungary's National Office for the Judiciary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"tunde-hando\",\"claim\":\"She served as president of Hungary's National Judicial Office.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence is empty. None can be classified as supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted. Not_covered does not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "vanda-lamm", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 15, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:31bbf9b1290eafe3d52096eb0f102534dcbae33845ac09a63238e131a4cf239b" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "vanda-lamm-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "vanda-lamm", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-vanda-lamm", "chunk_id": "vanda-lamm-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:31bbf9b1290eafe3d52096eb0f102534dcbae33845ac09a63238e131a4cf239b", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:48+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:12+02:00", "duration_s": 23.187, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21170, "output_tokens": 481, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 15 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be marked supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her expertise includes international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her field includes international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes international dispute settlement and nuclear law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes international dispute settlement.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"Her work includes international legal responsibility and dispute settlement.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has been affiliated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has been associated with the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior academic roles.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in Hungarian academic institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior standing in the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She has served on international legal bodies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She held senior roles within the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian legal scholar specializing in international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"vanda-lamm\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian scholar of international law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 15 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference packet contains no evidence. No claim can be marked supported or contradicted, and no contradiction flags are warranted; these verdicts do not establish hallucination.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zoltan-fleck", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 19, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:9a7afe979628ba7e48297f6103ce4efd38a1daaf6af7db91d3e9cf1e3844643e" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "zoltan-fleck-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zoltan-fleck", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zoltan-fleck", "chunk_id": "zoltan-fleck-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:9a7afe979628ba7e48297f6103ce4efd38a1daaf6af7db91d3e9cf1e3844643e", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:49+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:12+02:00", "duration_s": 23.016, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21407, "output_tokens": 1044, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved reference coverage, not as evidence of hallucination." } ], "summary": "All 19 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No direct contradiction is established, so no high or blocking flags are warranted; these results do not show that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Eötvös Loránd University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public commentary on Hungarian constitutional institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about criticism of Hungary's constitutional or judicial system." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at ELTE." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Eötvös Loránd University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or legal scholarship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or legal sociology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public criticism of rule-of-law developments." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public commentary on constitutional or rule-of-law issues." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about association with rule-of-law commentary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about association with rule-of-law debates." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public work addressing law or democratic institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public work addressing rule-of-law issues." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public commentary on rule-of-law issues." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about commentary on rule-of-law or constitutional questions." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly commented on Hungarian constitutional institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's constitutional and judicial system.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at ELTE.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He has taught at Eötvös Loránd University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal scholar.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian legal sociologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is a public critic of Hungary's rule-of-law developments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is known for public commentary on constitutional and rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is publicly associated with rule-of-law commentary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"He is publicly associated with rule-of-law debates.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"His public work addresses law and democratic institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"His public work addresses rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist of law.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian legal scholar and sociologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Known for public commentary on rule-of-law issues.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zoltan-fleck\",\"claim\":\"Publicly comments on rule-of-law and constitutional questions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved reference coverage, not as evidence of hallucination." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Eötvös Loránd University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public commentary on Hungarian constitutional institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about criticism of Hungary's constitutional or judicial system." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at ELTE." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about teaching at Eötvös Loránd University." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or legal scholarship." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or legal sociology." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public criticism of rule-of-law developments." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public commentary on constitutional or rule-of-law issues." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about association with rule-of-law commentary." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about association with rule-of-law debates." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public work addressing law or democratic institutions." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public work addressing rule-of-law issues." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about nationality or professional fields." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about public commentary on rule-of-law issues." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence about commentary on rule-of-law or constitutional questions." } ], "summary": "All 19 factual claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No direct contradiction is established, so no high or blocking flags are warranted; these results do not show that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zsolt-enyedi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 18, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:eb2648e2e57decbc45d4d3f380f21f05373d3181bba787b9ad04d5a14838fcc7" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "zsolt-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zsolt-enyedi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-enyedi", "chunk_id": "zsolt-enyedi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:eb2648e2e57decbc45d4d3f380f21f05373d3181bba787b9ad04d5a14838fcc7", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:51+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:14+02:00", "duration_s": 22.125, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21367, "output_tokens": 915, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and do not interpret not_covered as evidence of hallucination." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No direct contradictions or high-severity findings can be established from this packet.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior academic leadership responsibilities.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior leadership roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has been affiliated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has been associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic leadership roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior academic roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He has held senior leadership roles at Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian political scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His research concerns parties, democracy, and political institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His research includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship addresses parties and democratic politics.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship concerns parties and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship concerns parties, democracy, and political attitudes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes parties, democracy, and political attitudes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"His scholarship includes parties, polarization, and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist associated with Central European University.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian political scientist specializing in parties and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-enyedi\",\"claim\":\"Researches parties, political attitudes, and democracy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat all verdicts as coverage-limited and do not interpret not_covered as evidence of hallucination." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No direct contradictions or high-severity findings can be established from this packet.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zsolt-hernadi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 21, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:5ffe15230eb7789537c209fe07357269e14b709e661dd3d11708201c2765ded4" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "zsolt-hernadi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zsolt-hernadi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsolt-hernadi", "chunk_id": "zsolt-hernadi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:5ffe15230eb7789537c209fe07357269e14b709e661dd3d11708201c2765ded4", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:52+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:14+02:00", "duration_s": 21.734, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21550, "output_tokens": 951, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"Has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"Has been involved in a long-running legal controversy connected to Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has been involved in a long-running Croatian legal controversy.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has been involved in a long-running legal dispute connected with Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced a long-running Croatian corruption case.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced a long-running Croatian criminal case that he disputes.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced a long-running legal controversy involving Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has faced prolonged public legal controversy connected with Croatia.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has held a prominent role in Hungarian business life.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the company for many years.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has led the regional energy company for many years.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has long served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He has served as chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He is a long-serving senior leader of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He is chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"He is the chairman and chief executive of MOL Group.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"His career has centered on the energy sector.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"His career has included prominent regional business activity.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"Long-serving chairman and chief executive of MOL.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"MOL is a major Hungarian energy company.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsolt-hernadi\",\"claim\":\"MOL is a major Hungarian oil and gas company.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No claim can be supported or contradicted from this packet, and no contradiction flags are warranted. These verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 18, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:b9fff7c23b9dffd67ddacbd23cee56308420f31c8ac5d6b17d575cac081086be" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-zsuzsanna-jakab", "chunk_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:b9fff7c23b9dffd67ddacbd23cee56308420f31c8ac5d6b17d575cac081086be", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:54+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:23+02:00", "duration_s": 28.922, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21382, "output_tokens": 930, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as an unresolved coverage result and do not exclude any sample as contradicted." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions or high/blocking flags were identified; these verdicts do not establish hallucination or factual error.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Held senior leadership roles in international public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Her career has focused on international public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Her career has focused on public health and international administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Her professional field is public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian public-health professional.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Previously led Hungary's national public-health administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"Served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She held senior leadership roles at the World Health Organization.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She held senior leadership roles in international health administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She held senior leadership roles in international public health.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian public-health specialist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She later held a senior deputy leadership role at the WHO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She later held a senior deputy leadership role at WHO.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She previously led the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She previously worked in Hungarian public-health administration.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She served as the WHO Regional Director for Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"zsuzsanna-jakab\",\"claim\":\"She served as WHO Regional Director for Europe.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as an unresolved coverage result and do not exclude any sample as contradicted." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 18 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions or high/blocking flags were identified; these verdicts do not establish hallucination or factual error.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "adam-fischer", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 13, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:8ad00b4833faf4e2053efc1b20bf27382fc2822f3041fcd31e866b6b774c2b2e" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "adam-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "adam-fischer", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-adam-fischer", "chunk_id": "adam-fischer-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:8ad00b4833faf4e2053efc1b20bf27382fc2822f3041fcd31e866b6b774c2b2e", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:41:55+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:23+02:00", "duration_s": 27.953, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21052, "output_tokens": 714, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as a coverage limitation, not evidence of hallucination, and provide reference evidence before excluding samples." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-grounded contradictions and therefore no high or blocking flags.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He founded the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has led internationally prominent orchestras and opera productions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungarian government policies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungarian political developments.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's government.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized Hungary's political direction.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized political conditions in Hungary.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He has publicly criticized the Hungarian government's democratic record.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor with a major international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor with an international career.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is a Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is an internationally known Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"adam-fischer\",\"claim\":\"He is an internationally prominent Hungarian conductor.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as a coverage limitation, not evidence of hallucination, and provide reference evidence before excluding samples." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 13 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. There are no reference-grounded contradictions and therefore no high or blocking flags.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "eva-kondorosi", "prompt_schema_version": 2, "claim_count": 21, "chunk_count": 1, "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hashes": [ "sha256:41fdf260cf3f03b7cc3fe9b3774f5853de29d4af93cf9ed2ec4d9216c126e55a" ], "chunk_statuses": [ { "chunk_id": "eva-kondorosi-chunk-001-of-001", "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi", "status": "valid" } ], "chunks": [ { "run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi", "role": "factual_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "candidate_scope": "eva-kondorosi", "canonical_audit_run_id": "factual-recall-auditor-eva-kondorosi", "chunk_id": "eva-kondorosi-chunk-001-of-001", "chunk_index": 1, "chunk_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "claim-0001", "claim-0002", "claim-0003", "claim-0004", "claim-0005", "claim-0006", "claim-0007", "claim-0008", "claim-0009", "claim-0010", "claim-0011", "claim-0012", "claim-0013", "claim-0014", "claim-0015", "claim-0016", "claim-0017", "claim-0018", "claim-0019", "claim-0020", "claim-0021" ], "evidence_packet_hash": "sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945", "prompt_hash": "sha256:41fdf260cf3f03b7cc3fe9b3774f5853de29d4af93cf9ed2ec4d9216c126e55a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:00+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-01T16:42:30+02:00", "duration_s": 30.281, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 21258, "output_tokens": 1038, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved coverage, not as evidence of hallucination or factual error." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions, high-severity findings, or exclusion-triggering samples were identified; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "prompt_text": "Audit factual recall in a repeated-measures LLM judgment study.\nThe scorer was intentionally closed-book. The supplied reference packet is\nlimited and is NOT a complete truth benchmark.\n\nFor every recalled claim classify it as supported_by_reference,\ncontradicted_by_reference, or not_covered. Use high severity only for a direct\ncontradiction with the supplied reference. If the packet does not settle a\nclaim, it MUST be not_covered even if your own memory makes the claim seem\nunlikely; do not use internal memory as a second hidden benchmark. Not covered\nis not proof of hallucination. Every high/blocking flag must carry claim_id,\nrun_id, and candidate_id so that contradicted samples can be excluded without\ndeleting them. Do not audit subjective reasons as if they were factual claims.\n\nReturn ONLY JSON:\n{\n \"claim_verdicts\": [{\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id\",\n \"verdict\": \"supported_by_reference|contradicted_by_reference|not_covered\",\n \"note\": \"concise explanation\"\n }],\n \"flags\": [{\n \"severity\": \"info|low|medium|high|blocking\",\n \"claim_id\": \"claim-id or null\",\n \"run_id\": \"run-id or null\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"candidate-id or null\",\n \"code\": \"short_code\",\n \"message\": \"concise finding\",\n \"recommendation\": \"specific correction\"\n }],\n \"summary\": \"concise audit summary including reference-coverage limits\"\n}\n\nFrozen claims and limited reference packet:\n{\"claims\":[{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior roles in European scientific institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0001\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Has held senior roles in European scientific organizations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0002\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior research roles in Hungary and France.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0003\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Held senior roles in European scientific institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0004\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Her research concerns plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0005\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Her research concerns plant-microbe symbiosis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0006\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian biologist known for research on plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0007\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0008\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Hungarian plant biologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0009\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Is an internationally recognized research scientist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0010\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Known for research on plant-microbe symbiosis.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0011\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"Received major international scientific recognition.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0012\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in European scientific institutions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0013\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in European scientific organizations.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0014\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She has held senior roles in international scientific bodies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0015\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian biologist known for plant-microbe research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0016\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian biologist specializing in plant-microbe interactions.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0017\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a Hungarian biologist.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0018\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a member of major scientific academies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0019\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is a member of prominent scientific academies.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0020\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02\"},{\"candidate_id\":\"eva-kondorosi\",\"claim\":\"She is internationally recognized for her research.\",\"claim_id\":\"claim-0021\",\"run_id\":\"scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04\"}],\"reference_evidence\":[]}\n" } ], "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "info", "claim_id": null, "run_id": null, "candidate_id": null, "code": "empty_reference_packet", "message": "No reference evidence was supplied, so none of the recalled claims can be supported or contradicted.", "recommendation": "Treat every verdict as unresolved coverage, not as evidence of hallucination or factual error." } ], "claim_verdicts": [ { "claim_id": "claim-0001", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0002", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0003", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0004", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0005", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0006", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0007", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0008", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0009", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0010", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0011", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0012", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0013", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0014", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0015", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0016", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0017", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0018", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0019", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0020", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." }, { "claim_id": "claim-0021", "verdict": "not_covered", "note": "The reference packet contains no evidence addressing this claim." } ], "summary": "All 21 claims are not_covered because the supplied reference_evidence array is empty. No contradictions, high-severity findings, or exclusion-triggering samples were identified; these verdicts do not establish that any claim is false or hallucinated.", "call": { "ok": true, "error": null } }, { "run_id": "bias-auditor", "role": "bias_consistency", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "engine": "codex_cli", "invocation_profile": "isolated_no_mcp", "prompt_hash": "sha256:fde2b53db081d331fb89b27e0f3a7ebf62e11555bbaa218a722ee826b8f6807a", "call": { "started_at": "2026-08-02T23:21:41+02:00", "ended_at": "2026-08-02T23:23:12+02:00", "duration_s": 90.953, "engine_reported": "codex_cli", "model_reported": "gpt-5.6-sol", "ok": true, "exit_code": 0, "cost_usd": null, "input_tokens": 69688, "output_tokens": 2220, "error": null }, "status": "valid", "flags": [ { "severity": "high", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "single_model_pseudoe­nsemble", "message": "All 120 valid runs use one model, gpt-5.6-sol, from one provider family; every between-model SD is therefore mechanically zero, and the reported family ensemble cannot measure between-model or between-provider variation.", "recommendation": "Label the release as a repeated-sampling study of one model configuration, remove ensemble and between-model claims, or add independently weighted models from multiple provider families." }, { "severity": "high", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "unequal_candidate_exposure", "message": "Most candidate-criterion diagnostics contain 10 assessments, while katalin-kariko and peter-paczolay contain 120, so candidates have radically unequal replication despite the 'balanced assessments' label.", "recommendation": "Disclose per-candidate sample sizes, explain the repeated-control role of the two heavily sampled candidates, and use an explicitly unbalanced hierarchical analysis or equalize replication before comparative release." }, { "severity": "high", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "degenerate_rank_probabilities", "message": "Rank-1 and top-3 probabilities are almost entirely 0 or 1 despite overlapping score distributions and unequal replication, indicating that these values do not represent uncertainty over future model outputs.", "recommendation": "Recompute rank probabilities from a hierarchical resampling scheme that includes run, prompt, block, and candidate uncertainty; publish Monte Carlo error and define the probability estimand precisely." }, { "severity": "high", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "order_effect_uncontrolled", "message": "Many candidate score-order correlations are large, including values above 0.8, yet no randomized-order balance, multiplicity-aware test, or order-adjusted estimate is reported.", "recommendation": "Document the randomization scheme, estimate position effects with a repeated-measures model, report uncertainty and multiplicity control, and publish order-adjusted candidate distributions." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "extreme_positive_order_signal", "message": "The reported score-order correlation is 0.847, making the candidate's aggregate materially sensitive to presentation position unless the estimate is shown to be noise.", "recommendation": "Report sample size and interval for this correlation and provide an order-adjusted distribution rather than treating the raw aggregate as position-invariant." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "extreme_negative_order_signal", "message": "The reported score-order correlation is -0.752, making the candidate's aggregate materially sensitive to presentation position unless the estimate is shown to be noise.", "recommendation": "Report sample size and interval for this correlation and provide an order-adjusted distribution rather than treating the raw aggregate as position-invariant." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "prompt_sensitivity_hidden_by_median", "message": "The median prompt sensitivity is zero, but several candidate-criterion cells shift by 1 to 2 score points; the global median conceals consequential local prompt dependence.", "recommendation": "Publish the full prompt-contrast distribution, prompt-specific candidate estimates, and uncertainty intervals; describe large prompt effects as substantive output-distribution results." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "run_id": null, "code": "high_prompt_and_run_variance", "message": "Prompt sensitivity is 2.0 and median within-model SD is 1.49, while the candidate's overall SD is 0.93; a single central score materially understates output instability.", "recommendation": "Lead with the prompt-stratified distribution and avoid a definitive rank or suitability interpretation for this candidate." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "run_id": null, "code": "high_prompt_sensitivity", "message": "Prompt sensitivity is 2.0 with median within-model SD above 1.0, indicating a broad and prompt-dependent judgment distribution.", "recommendation": "Publish prompt-specific distributions and present the instability as a result rather than collapsing it into one ordinal score." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "fame_exposure_bias_untested", "message": "No familiarity, biography-length, fame, training-data exposure, or name-recognition diagnostic is reported, so differences may partly measure model exposure rather than the stated constructs.", "recommendation": "Add blinded or standardized-profile conditions, explicit familiarity ratings, profile-length controls, and synthetic candidates varying fame independently of qualifications." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "factual_contamination_not_audited", "message": "No runs were excluded, but the summary provides no factual-claim verification or contamination rule demonstrating that hallucinated, stale, or identity-confused premises were checked.", "recommendation": "Predefine factual-contamination criteria, audit factual rationales independently, publish exclusion counts by reason, and provide sensitivity results with contaminated observations removed." }, { "severity": "medium", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "synthetic_controls_weak_validation", "message": "All 18 control scores fall within broad expected ranges, but the controls appear evaluated only as aggregate point values and do not test rank recovery, variance, prompt robustness, order effects, or fame bias.", "recommendation": "Report control distributions by repetition and prompt, preregister narrow discrimination targets, include deliberately ambiguous and fame-manipulated controls, and evaluate false-positive and rank-recovery performance." }, { "severity": "low", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "middle_score_compression_unreported", "message": "Many criterion medians cluster on integer anchors and many overall scores occupy a narrow middle-high band, but no scale-usage, ceiling, heaping, or compression diagnostic is provided.", "recommendation": "Publish score histograms by criterion and prompt, anchor-use frequencies, ceiling/floor rates, and sensitivity analyses using ordinal rather than interval-scale aggregation." }, { "severity": "low", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "ordinal_scale_averaged_as_interval", "message": "Weighted averages with fine decimal precision are reported for an explicitly anchored ordinal construct, which can imply unsupported interval-scale resolution.", "recommendation": "Emphasize medians and ordinal distributions, justify any interval approximation, and round public summaries to a precision supported by the response scale and uncertainty." }, { "severity": "info", "candidate_id": null, "criterion_id": null, "run_id": null, "code": "truth_disclosure_present", "message": "The construct disclosure correctly states that scores are subjective model impressions and are not truth, probabilities, or calibrated human opinion.", "recommendation": "Repeat this limitation adjacent to every ranking and ensure public language uses model agreement or output tendency, never correctness, merit, or true suitability." } ], "summary": "The release measures repeated outputs from one OpenAI model, not a provider-balanced model population. Unequal candidate replication, uncontrolled order signals, degenerate rank probabilities, and missing fame and factual-contamination audits materially undermine comparative interpretation. The distributions remain publishable if framed as prompt- and order-sensitive outputs of one model configuration, with uncertainty and instability treated as results rather than failures.", "raw_response": "{\n \"flags\": [\n {\n \"severity\": \"high\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"single_model_pseudoe­nsemble\",\n \"message\": \"All 120 valid runs use one model, gpt-5.6-sol, from one provider family; every between-model SD is therefore mechanically zero, and the reported family ensemble cannot measure between-model or between-provider variation.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Label the release as a repeated-sampling study of one model configuration, remove ensemble and between-model claims, or add independently weighted models from multiple provider families.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"high\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"unequal_candidate_exposure\",\n \"message\": \"Most candidate-criterion diagnostics contain 10 assessments, while katalin-kariko and peter-paczolay contain 120, so candidates have radically unequal replication despite the 'balanced assessments' label.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Disclose per-candidate sample sizes, explain the repeated-control role of the two heavily sampled candidates, and use an explicitly unbalanced hierarchical analysis or equalize replication before comparative release.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"high\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"degenerate_rank_probabilities\",\n \"message\": \"Rank-1 and top-3 probabilities are almost entirely 0 or 1 despite overlapping score distributions and unequal replication, indicating that these values do not represent uncertainty over future model outputs.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Recompute rank probabilities from a hierarchical resampling scheme that includes run, prompt, block, and candidate uncertainty; publish Monte Carlo error and define the probability estimand precisely.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"high\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"order_effect_uncontrolled\",\n \"message\": \"Many candidate score-order correlations are large, including values above 0.8, yet no randomized-order balance, multiplicity-aware test, or order-adjusted estimate is reported.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Document the randomization scheme, estimate position effects with a repeated-measures model, report uncertainty and multiplicity control, and publish order-adjusted candidate distributions.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"ildiko-enyedi\",\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"extreme_positive_order_signal\",\n \"message\": \"The reported score-order correlation is 0.847, making the candidate's aggregate materially sensitive to presentation position unless the estimate is shown to be noise.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Report sample size and interval for this correlation and provide an order-adjusted distribution rather than treating the raw aggregate as position-invariant.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"kinga-goncz\",\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"extreme_negative_order_signal\",\n \"message\": \"The reported score-order correlation is -0.752, making the candidate's aggregate materially sensitive to presentation position unless the estimate is shown to be noise.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Report sample size and interval for this correlation and provide an order-adjusted distribution rather than treating the raw aggregate as position-invariant.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"prompt_sensitivity_hidden_by_median\",\n \"message\": \"The median prompt sensitivity is zero, but several candidate-criterion cells shift by 1 to 2 score points; the global median conceals consequential local prompt dependence.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Publish the full prompt-contrast distribution, prompt-specific candidate estimates, and uncertainty intervals; describe large prompt effects as substantive output-distribution results.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"peter-kovacs\",\n \"criterion_id\": \"international_representation\",\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"high_prompt_and_run_variance\",\n \"message\": \"Prompt sensitivity is 2.0 and median within-model SD is 1.49, while the candidate's overall SD is 0.93; a single central score materially understates output instability.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Lead with the prompt-stratified distribution and avoid a definitive rank or suitability interpretation for this candidate.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": \"laczo-adrienn\",\n \"criterion_id\": \"political_independence\",\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"high_prompt_sensitivity\",\n \"message\": \"Prompt sensitivity is 2.0 with median within-model SD above 1.0, indicating a broad and prompt-dependent judgment distribution.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Publish prompt-specific distributions and present the instability as a result rather than collapsing it into one ordinal score.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"fame_exposure_bias_untested\",\n \"message\": \"No familiarity, biography-length, fame, training-data exposure, or name-recognition diagnostic is reported, so differences may partly measure model exposure rather than the stated constructs.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Add blinded or standardized-profile conditions, explicit familiarity ratings, profile-length controls, and synthetic candidates varying fame independently of qualifications.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"factual_contamination_not_audited\",\n \"message\": \"No runs were excluded, but the summary provides no factual-claim verification or contamination rule demonstrating that hallucinated, stale, or identity-confused premises were checked.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Predefine factual-contamination criteria, audit factual rationales independently, publish exclusion counts by reason, and provide sensitivity results with contaminated observations removed.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"medium\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"synthetic_controls_weak_validation\",\n \"message\": \"All 18 control scores fall within broad expected ranges, but the controls appear evaluated only as aggregate point values and do not test rank recovery, variance, prompt robustness, order effects, or fame bias.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Report control distributions by repetition and prompt, preregister narrow discrimination targets, include deliberately ambiguous and fame-manipulated controls, and evaluate false-positive and rank-recovery performance.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"low\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"middle_score_compression_unreported\",\n \"message\": \"Many criterion medians cluster on integer anchors and many overall scores occupy a narrow middle-high band, but no scale-usage, ceiling, heaping, or compression diagnostic is provided.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Publish score histograms by criterion and prompt, anchor-use frequencies, ceiling/floor rates, and sensitivity analyses using ordinal rather than interval-scale aggregation.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"low\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"ordinal_scale_averaged_as_interval\",\n \"message\": \"Weighted averages with fine decimal precision are reported for an explicitly anchored ordinal construct, which can imply unsupported interval-scale resolution.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Emphasize medians and ordinal distributions, justify any interval approximation, and round public summaries to a precision supported by the response scale and uncertainty.\"\n },\n {\n \"severity\": \"info\",\n \"candidate_id\": null,\n \"criterion_id\": null,\n \"run_id\": null,\n \"code\": \"truth_disclosure_present\",\n \"message\": \"The construct disclosure correctly states that scores are subjective model impressions and are not truth, probabilities, or calibrated human opinion.\",\n \"recommendation\": \"Repeat this limitation adjacent to every ranking and ensure public language uses model agreement or output tendency, never correctness, merit, or true suitability.\"\n }\n ],\n \"summary\": \"The release measures repeated outputs from one OpenAI model, not a provider-balanced model population. Unequal candidate replication, uncontrolled order signals, degenerate rank probabilities, and missing fame and factual-contamination audits materially undermine comparative interpretation. The distributions remain publishable if framed as prompt- and order-sensitive outputs of one model configuration, with uncertainty and instability treated as results rather than failures.\"\n}" } ], "aggregation": { "method": "v5 block-linked repeated judgments -> common-anchor centering -> model medians -> equal family medians", "configured_run_count": 120, "minimum_family_quorum": 1, "valid_run_count": 120, "excluded_run_count": 0, "valid_families": [ "openai" ], "judgments": [ { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.775, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.5625, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3425800798515744, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3425800798515744, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.3, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.85, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3333333333333333, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3333333333333333, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.0, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.15, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.375, "median": 9.25, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.6875, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4289845892077917, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4289845892077917, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.75, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.75, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.8, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5374838498865699, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5374838498865699, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.45, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.5, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6236095644623235, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6236095644623235, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 4, "high": 6 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.6, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 8.875, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-baka", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.75, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6346477588219923, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6346477588219923, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.175, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.375, "range": [ 8.5, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4417452760232857, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4417452760232857, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.4, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.95, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.5, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.8, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.6, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "andras-sajo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.15, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.175, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 7.0, 7.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2898754521821014, "within_model_sd_median": 0.2898754521821014, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 6.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6146362971528592, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6146362971528592, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.75, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5400617248673217, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5400617248673217, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.625, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.5, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 8.875, "range": [ 7.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5773502691896257, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5773502691896257, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "attila-chikan", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.45, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.075, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.75, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23717082451262844, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23717082451262844, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.2, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.5, "range": [ 4.5, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5374838498865699, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5374838498865699, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.05, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.5, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3689323936863109, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3689323936863109, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.4, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.875, "range": [ 4.5, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.4, "median": 7.25, "q1": 4.875, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 3.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.7919573407620817, "within_model_sd_median": 1.7919573407620817, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "balazs-gulyas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.15, "median": 8.0, "q1": 5.75, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 4.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.7646214576755233, "within_model_sd_median": 1.7646214576755233, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 6, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.775, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.5625, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4779876799899996, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4779876799899996, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.75, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.6, "median": 8.75, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.7, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.45, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.25, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "botond-roska", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.0, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 2, "high": 8 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.975, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.5, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2486072315029383, "within_model_sd_median": 0.2486072315029383, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.8, "median": 5.0, "q1": 4.625, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.6, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.85, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.55, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "bela-merkely", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 6.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.375, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 3.5, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6795627679291705, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6795627679291705, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.8, "median": 4.0, "q1": 3.625, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.0, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.5, "median": 4.5, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4714045207910317, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4714045207910317, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.95, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3689323936863109, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3689323936863109, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.85, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.5, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "cecilia-muller", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.9, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.975, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2486072315029383, "within_model_sd_median": 0.2486072315029383, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.8, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.85, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.625, "q3": 9.375, "range": [ 7.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6687467549246293, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6687467549246293, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-korosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.95, "median": 10.0, "q1": 10.0, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.5, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 10.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 10.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 10.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 10.0, "reflective_independent": 10.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.275, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.75, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4479893351905204, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4479893351905204, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3944053188733077, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3944053188733077, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.9, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.65, "median": 6.75, "q1": 6.125, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 5.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6687467549246293, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6687467549246293, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "csaba-pleh", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.2, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.275, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.75, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4479893351905204, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4479893351905204, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.0, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.05, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.05, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3689323936863109, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3689323936863109, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.1, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.425, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.75, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6241661103691335, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6241661103691335, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.75, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.485912657903775, "within_model_sd_median": 0.485912657903775, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.9, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 5.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.85, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 6.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6258327785172862, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6258327785172862, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 4, "medium": 6, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.85, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.5, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5797509043642028, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5797509043642028, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-bollobas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.25, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.375, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.485912657903775, "within_model_sd_median": 0.485912657903775, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.925, "median": 5.0, "q1": 4.5625, "q3": 5.5, "range": [ 4.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.601502747753953, "within_model_sd_median": 0.601502747753953, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 2.75, "median": 3.0, "q1": 2.25, "q3": 3.0, "range": [ 1.5, 3.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.67700320038633, "within_model_sd_median": 0.67700320038633, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 3.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 1.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.4, "median": 3.25, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 2.5, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.05, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.5, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.25, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 7.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.26352313834736496, "within_model_sd_median": 0.26352313834736496, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 2, "high": 8 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eniko-gyori", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.75, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.485912657903775, "within_model_sd_median": 0.485912657903775, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.325, "median": 5.25, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.5, "range": [ 4.75, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5006939628599933, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5006939628599933, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.55, "median": 8.75, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5502524673073059, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5502524673073059, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.7, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 4, "high": 6 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.15, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.375, "range": [ 8.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24152294576982397, "within_model_sd_median": 0.24152294576982397, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.75, "median": 4.75, "q1": 4.5, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.26352313834736496, "within_model_sd_median": 0.26352313834736496, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.5, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "erno-rubik", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.0, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.375, "range": [ 8.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6236095644623235, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6236095644623235, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 2, "high": 8 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.625, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.3125, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4289845892077917, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4289845892077917, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.45, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.724568837309472, "within_model_sd_median": 0.724568837309472, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.5, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.1, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.35, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.95, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.625, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3689323936863109, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3689323936863109, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 3, "high": 7 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.125, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.1875, "range": [ 7.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21245914639969937, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21245914639969937, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.25, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.485912657903775, "within_model_sd_median": 0.485912657903775, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.2, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.05, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.35, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 4, "high": 6 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.025, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.1875, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.415832498329155, "within_model_sd_median": 0.415832498329155, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.25, "median": 5.25, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.5, "range": [ 4.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5892556509887896, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5892556509887896, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.3, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.75, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.4, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 4, "medium": 6, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.15, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 5, "high": 5 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.25, "median": 9.25, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.5, "range": [ 8.5, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.125, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.1875, "range": [ 5.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21245914639969937, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21245914639969937, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.85, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4116363011742823, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4116363011742823, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.6, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.9, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.45, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5986094998689324, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5986094998689324, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.25, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.525, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.125, "q3": 6.875, "range": [ 5.75, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5329425651773161, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5329425651773161, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.45, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5502524673073059, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5502524673073059, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.8, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.625, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.65, "median": 7.75, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4116363011742823, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4116363011742823, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.25, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 7.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5400617248673217, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5400617248673217, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-bojar", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.05, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.375, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 2, "high": 8 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.125, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.5, "range": [ 8.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.35843021946010944, "within_model_sd_median": 0.35843021946010944, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.35, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5296749527356901, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5296749527356901, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.0, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.5, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.85, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.625, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4116363011742823, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4116363011742823, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.65, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.5, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-halmai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.25, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3535533905932738, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3535533905932738, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.125, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.1875, "range": [ 8.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21245914639969937, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21245914639969937, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.95, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.1, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.1, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.15, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.25, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.825, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.4375, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5533985905294664, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5533985905294664, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.25, "median": 5.25, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.5, "range": [ 5.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.26352313834736496, "within_model_sd_median": 0.26352313834736496, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 4, "medium": 6, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "gabor-torok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.75, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.125, "q3": 6.375, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.7168604389202189, "within_model_sd_median": 0.7168604389202189, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.925, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.37360852952433155, "within_model_sd_median": 0.37360852952433155, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.05, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.5, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3333333333333333, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3333333333333333, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ignac-romsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.15, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 7.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24152294576982397, "within_model_sd_median": 0.24152294576982397, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.025, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.75, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18446619684315546, "within_model_sd_median": 0.18446619684315546, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.15, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.7, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.5, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.95, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.125, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.75, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.35843021946010944, "within_model_sd_median": 0.35843021946010944, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.35, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.875, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.5, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4714045207910317, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4714045207910317, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.9, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.15, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.375, "range": [ 6.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24152294576982397, "within_model_sd_median": 0.24152294576982397, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.025, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.75, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18446619684315546, "within_model_sd_median": 0.18446619684315546, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.6, "median": 7.75, "q1": 7.125, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.85, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.8, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.625, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 8, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "imre-voros", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.05, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.375, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.025, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.75, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18446619684315546, "within_model_sd_median": 0.18446619684315546, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.95, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.625, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4714045207910317, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4714045207910317, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "ivan-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.55, "median": 9.5, "q1": 9.125, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.5, "reflective_independent": 9.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.925, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 5.75, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4417452760232857, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4417452760232857, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.0, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.15, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.7, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.5, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.5, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 8.875, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "janos-martonyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.55, "median": 9.5, "q1": 9.125, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.5, "reflective_independent": 9.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.575, "median": 6.75, "q1": 6.0625, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4721405158071765, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4721405158071765, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.8, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.5, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.5, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.9, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.9, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.55, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.0, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.175, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.4375, "range": [ 6.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5779513628133234, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5779513628133234, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.125, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.4, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.6, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.25, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3535533905932738, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3535533905932738, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.175, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.1875, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.33437337746231466, "within_model_sd_median": 0.33437337746231466, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.25, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 7.75, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.1, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.1, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "julia-kiraly", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.3, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.375, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5374838498865699, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5374838498865699, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.675, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.3125, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4417452760232857, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4417452760232857, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.5, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.5, "q3": 6.875, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4714045207910317, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4714045207910317, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.3, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.75, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 2, "high": 8 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-bogyay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.9, "median": 10.0, "q1": 10.0, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 10.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 10.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 10.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 10.0, "reflective_independent": 10.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 5.983333333333333, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.25, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3137823827965831, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3137823827965831, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 75, "medium": 45, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 8.858333333333333, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3121040909463286, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3121040909463286, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 17, "high": 103 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.0125, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15149812101893842, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15149812101893842, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 17, "high": 103 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.054166666666667, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1560520454731643, "within_model_sd_median": 0.1560520454731643, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 110 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 6.158333333333333, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.32399380981049347, "within_model_sd_median": 0.32399380981049347, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 115, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "katalin-kariko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.983333333333333, "median": 10.0, "q1": 10.0, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.5, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0901290702255376, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0901290702255376, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 10.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 10.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 10.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 10.0, "reflective_independent": 10.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.975, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18446619684315546, "within_model_sd_median": 0.18446619684315546, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.4, "median": 4.5, "q1": 3.75, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 3.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6582805886043833, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6582805886043833, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.5, "reflective_independent": 4.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 3, "high": 7 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.7, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.25, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.0, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kinga-goncz", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.0, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.275, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.4375, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.415832498329155, "within_model_sd_median": 0.415832498329155, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.25, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.125, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.9, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.15, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.375, "range": [ 4.5, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5296749527356901, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5296749527356901, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 2, "medium": 8, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.2, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.375, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.175, "median": 7.25, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 5.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.0804448672241962, "within_model_sd_median": 1.0804448672241962, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.85, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.25, "q3": 7.75, "range": [ 5.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.055409346599171, "within_model_sd_median": 1.055409346599171, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 2.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.5, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.6, "median": 6.75, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 5.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.8755950357709131, "within_model_sd_median": 0.8755950357709131, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.1, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.375, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6146362971528592, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6146362971528592, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laczo-adrienn", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.95, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.975, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.625, "q3": 6.4375, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5062114182829147, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5062114182829147, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.35, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5797509043642028, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5797509043642028, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.7, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.25, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 4, "medium": 6, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.8, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 2.5, 4.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5868938953886337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5868938953886337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.85, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.375, "median": 9.5, "q1": 9.0625, "q3": 9.5, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31732387941099616, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31732387941099616, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.25, "reflective_independent": 9.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.75, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5400617248673217, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5400617248673217, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.1, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.3, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 4, "high": 6 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.85, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.375, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.0625, "q3": 5.5, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31732387941099616, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31732387941099616, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 2.95, "median": 3.0, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 3.0, "range": [ 2.5, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 3.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.4, "median": 3.0, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.0, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 5, "high": 5 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.9, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3944053188733077, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3944053188733077, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23570226039551584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.23570226039551584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.85, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.875, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.5, "q3": 6.4375, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5921946001479956, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5921946001479956, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.25, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.75, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5400617248673217, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5400617248673217, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.7, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.25, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.2, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.375, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.5, "median": 4.75, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 3.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5773502691896257, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5773502691896257, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "miklos-perenyi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.35, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.875, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.375, "median": 9.5, "q1": 9.0625, "q3": 9.5, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31732387941099616, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31732387941099616, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.25, "reflective_independent": 9.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.95, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.0, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 5.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.1, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.7, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 4, "high": 6 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "marta-pardavi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.05, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 2, "high": 8 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.975, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.75, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.07905694150420949, "within_model_sd_median": 0.07905694150420949, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.2, "median": 8.5, "q1": 7.625, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5374838498865699, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5374838498865699, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.1, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.9, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.5, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4714045207910317, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4714045207910317, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "nora-l-ritok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.675, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.1875, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4721405158071765, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4721405158071765, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.25, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.9, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.4, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.875, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "pal-sonnevend", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.175, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.75, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4417452760232857, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4417452760232857, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.6, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.5, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 6.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.8, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.2, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-balazs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.8, "median": 10.0, "q1": 9.625, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3496029493900505, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3496029493900505, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 10.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 10.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 10.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 10.0, "reflective_independent": 10.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.875, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 6.75, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.39528470752104744, "within_model_sd_median": 0.39528470752104744, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.8, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.5, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.5, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 5, "medium": 5, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.0, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5676462121975467, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5676462121975467, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-barandy", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.1, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21081851067789195, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21081851067789195, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.775, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.8125, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.415832498329155, "within_model_sd_median": 0.415832498329155, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.2, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.5, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.9, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.8, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 7, "medium": 3, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.3, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 5, "high": 5 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-darak", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.175, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 4.5, 8.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.3335937245736507, "within_model_sd_median": 1.3335937245736507, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.55, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.875, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.83166499665831, "within_model_sd_median": 0.83166499665831, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.3, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.75, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.7, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.75, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.9486832980505138, "within_model_sd_median": 0.9486832980505138, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 2.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.85, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.8514693182963201, "within_model_sd_median": 0.8514693182963201, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kovacs", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.3, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 5.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.4944341180973262, "within_model_sd_median": 1.4944341180973262, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 2.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.175, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.1875, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4721405158071765, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4721405158071765, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.25, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.25, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.375, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.1, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.6, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.45, "median": 6.75, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6433419688539594, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6433419688539594, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-kreko", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.2, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.575, "median": 6.75, "q1": 6.0625, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4721405158071765, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4721405158071765, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.75, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.625, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 7, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4714045207910317, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4714045207910317, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.7, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.25, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.05, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-nadas", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.8, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 8.966666666666667, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2986899500728302, "within_model_sd_median": 0.2986899500728302, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 3, "high": 117 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 7.241666666666666, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.33041439052769345, "within_model_sd_median": 0.33041439052769345, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 119, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 6.9875, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15149812101893842, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15149812101893842, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 119, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 7.945833333333334, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1560520454731643, "within_model_sd_median": 0.1560520454731643, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 120, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 8.541666666666666, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.375, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4026348791875529, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4026348791875529, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 119 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-paczolay", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 8.933333333333334, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21433239454207584, "within_model_sd_median": 0.21433239454207584, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 4, "high": 116 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.275, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.4375, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.415832498329155, "within_model_sd_median": 0.415832498329155, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.25, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.35, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.8, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.2, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.25, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5892556509887896, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5892556509887896, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-rona", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.5, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 3, "high": 7 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.075, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.75, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.33437337746231466, "within_model_sd_median": 0.33437337746231466, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.5, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.5, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.408248290463863, "within_model_sd_median": 0.408248290463863, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.6, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.8, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.8, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.25, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5868938953886337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5868938953886337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "peter-akos-bod", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3944053188733077, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3944053188733077, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.875, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.625, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5432668671002208, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5432668671002208, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.45, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.3, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 4.75, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.8, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.05, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "robert-alfoldi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.8, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.075, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1687371394276382, "within_model_sd_median": 0.1687371394276382, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.75, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.42491829279939874, "within_model_sd_median": 0.42491829279939874, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.2, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.6, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.65, "median": 8.75, "q1": 8.5, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4116363011742823, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4116363011742823, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.525, "median": 5.25, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6061032181989394, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6061032181989394, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.8, "median": 5.0, "q1": 4.5, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.75, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 4.5, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5400617248673217, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5400617248673217, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.7, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.25, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.3, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-freund", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 1, "high": 9 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.125, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.4375, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5170697352496191, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5170697352496191, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.8, "median": 4.0, "q1": 3.5, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.0, 4.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.65, "median": 5.0, "q1": 4.25, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 3.5, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5797509043642028, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5797509043642028, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.8, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.4, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.125, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-sulyok", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.0, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.925, "median": 6.0, "q1": 5.625, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5779513628133234, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5779513628133234, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.8, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25819888974716115, "within_model_sd_median": 0.25819888974716115, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.95, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.3, "median": 6.25, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5374838498865699, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5374838498865699, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tamas-vicsek", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.425, "median": 5.125, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.875, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5533985905294664, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5533985905294664, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.125 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.125, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.1, "median": 3.0, "q1": 2.5, "q3": 3.75, "range": [ 2.5, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6582805886043833, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6582805886043833, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 2.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.55, "median": 5.75, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.5, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.4, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 8.5, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.5, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tibor-navracsics", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.2, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.425, "median": 3.125, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 3.875, "range": [ 3.0, 4.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5533985905294664, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5533985905294664, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.125 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.125, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 3.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 2.2, "median": 2.0, "q1": 1.625, "q3": 2.875, "range": [ 1.5, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6324555320336759, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6324555320336759, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 2.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 2.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 2.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 2.0, "reflective_independent": 2.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 1.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 1.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 1.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 2.35, "median": 2.0, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 3.0, "range": [ 1.5, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5797509043642028, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5797509043642028, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 2.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 2.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 2.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 2.0, "reflective_independent": 3.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 1.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.4, "median": 3.0, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.0, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.3, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.5, "range": [ 5.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5374838498865699, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5374838498865699, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 5, "high": 5 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "tunde-hando", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.4, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 6, "medium": 4, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.225, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.1875, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4779876799899996, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4779876799899996, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3333333333333333, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3333333333333333, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.95, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.5, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 10, "medium": 0, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.0, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.0, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.0, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 4, "medium": 6, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "vanda-lamm", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.4, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.025, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.75, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18446619684315546, "within_model_sd_median": 0.18446619684315546, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.95, "median": 5.5, "q1": 5.5, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.5, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.724568837309472, "within_model_sd_median": 0.724568837309472, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.5, "reflective_independent": 5.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 4.4, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 4.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5163977794943223, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5163977794943223, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.9, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.95, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zoltan-fleck", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.05, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 6.0, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 1, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.825, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.8125, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.33437337746231466, "within_model_sd_median": 0.33437337746231466, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.75, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.35, "median": 7.5, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.875, "range": [ 6.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.7090682462060882, "within_model_sd_median": 0.7090682462060882, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.9, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 1, "medium": 9, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.7, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.25, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.25, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.485912657903775, "within_model_sd_median": 0.485912657903775, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.05, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 8.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15811388300841897, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15811388300841897, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.725, "median": 4.0, "q1": 3.25, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 2.75, 4.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.582737791234903, "within_model_sd_median": 0.582737791234903, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.25, "median": 3.5, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 3.5, "range": [ 2.5, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.485912657903775, "within_model_sd_median": 0.485912657903775, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.5, "reflective_independent": 3.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 3.3, "median": 3.0, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 3.75, "range": [ 3.0, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.48304589153964794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.48304589153964794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 2.8, "median": 3.0, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 3.0, "range": [ 2.0, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 3.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 9, "high": 1 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.35, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.875, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5296749527356901, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5296749527356901, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.05, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4972144630058766, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4972144630058766, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.625, "median": 6.875, "q1": 6.125, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.46022337571613586, "within_model_sd_median": 0.46022337571613586, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.875 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.875, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 4, "medium": 6, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.75, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3535533905932738, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3535533905932738, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.5, "median": 7.5, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5270462766947299, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5270462766947299, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.9, "median": 8.0, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31622776601683794, "within_model_sd_median": 0.31622776601683794, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.05, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.5, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28382310609877337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28382310609877337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.15, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.475, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.9375, "range": [ 6.0, 7.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4479893351905204, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4479893351905204, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.75, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.25, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.3, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.5, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5868938953886337, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5868938953886337, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 5.85, "median": 6.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 6.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3374742788552764, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3374742788552764, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.0, "reflective_independent": 6.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.8, "median": 8.0, "q1": 7.5, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4216370213557839, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4216370213557839, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.1, "median": 7.25, "q1": 6.625, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6146362971528592, "within_model_sd_median": 0.6146362971528592, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 6, "high": 4 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "adam-fischer", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 9.35, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.875, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4743416490252569, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4743416490252569, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 10.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 10 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 6.525, "median": 6.5, "q1": 6.125, "q3": 6.875, "range": [ 5.75, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5329425651773161, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5329425651773161, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 6.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 6.5, "reflective_independent": 6.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 8, "medium": 2, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.75 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.35, "median": 8.25, "q1": 8.0, "q3": 8.875, "range": [ 7.5, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5296749527356901, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5296749527356901, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.6, "median": 7.75, "q1": 7.125, "q3": 8.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.45946829173634074, "within_model_sd_median": 0.45946829173634074, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.75 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.75, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 8.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 3, "medium": 7, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.55, "median": 8.5, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.43779751788545657, "within_model_sd_median": 0.43779751788545657, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5 }, "ensemble_family_median": 8.5, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 8, "high": 2 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 7.15, "median": 7.25, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.5, "range": [ 6.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5797509043642028, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5797509043642028, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.25, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.5, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.5 } ] }, { "entity_id": "eva-kondorosi", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 10, "mean": 8.75, "median": 9.0, "q1": 8.125, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 8.0, 9.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5892556509887896, "within_model_sd_median": 0.5892556509887896, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 8.5 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.5, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 6, "high": 4 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 10.0, "median": 10.0, "q1": 10.0, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 10.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 10.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 10.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 10.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 10.0, "reflective_independent": 10.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.083333333333334, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2775442529128102, "within_model_sd_median": 0.2775442529128102, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.141666666666667, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.35017002672851316, "within_model_sd_median": 0.35017002672851316, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.316666666666666, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 10.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4671266240679986, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4671266240679986, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.041666666666666, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20066416332413975, "within_model_sd_median": 0.20066416332413975, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 9.091666666666667, "median": 9.0, "q1": 9.0, "q3": 9.0, "range": [ 9.0, 10.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28976470701963286, "within_model_sd_median": 0.28976470701963286, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 9.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 9.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 9.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 9.0, "reflective_independent": 9.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 10.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 9.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 9.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 2.5833333333333335, "median": 3.0, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 3.0, "range": [ 2.0, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.49507377148833714, "within_model_sd_median": 0.49507377148833714, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 2.0, "reflective_independent": 3.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 19, "high": 101 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 2.0, "median": 2.0, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 2.0, "range": [ 1.0, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.12964074471043288, "within_model_sd_median": 0.12964074471043288, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 2.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 2.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 2.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 2.0, "reflective_independent": 2.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 1.9666666666666666, "median": 2.0, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 2.0, "range": [ 1.0, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22203540233024818, "within_model_sd_median": 0.22203540233024818, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 2.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 2.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 2.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 2.0, "reflective_independent": 2.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 3.8833333333333333, "median": 4.0, "q1": 4.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.0, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3223686843157241, "within_model_sd_median": 0.3223686843157241, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 4.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 4.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 9, "medium": 111, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 2.025, "median": 2.0, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 2.0, "range": [ 2.0, 3.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15677956478053226, "within_model_sd_median": 0.15677956478053226, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 2.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 2.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 2.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 2.0, "reflective_independent": 2.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 0, "high": 120 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 2.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 6.558333333333334, "median": 7.0, "q1": 6.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 6.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.515243816533678, "within_model_sd_median": 0.515243816533678, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 46, "high": 74 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 5.058333333333334, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.235355384180488, "within_model_sd_median": 0.235355384180488, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 110, "medium": 10, "high": 0 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 7.016666666666667, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.12855586584927856, "within_model_sd_median": 0.12855586584927856, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 117, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 5.0, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 5.0, 5.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.0, "within_model_sd_median": 0.0, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 116, "medium": 0, "high": 4 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 5.041666666666667, "median": 5.0, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 5.0, "range": [ 5.0, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20066416332413975, "within_model_sd_median": 0.20066416332413975, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 5.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 5.0, "reflective_independent": 5.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 116, "medium": 1, "high": 3 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 6.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 5.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 5.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 7.016666666666667, "median": 7.0, "q1": 7.0, "q3": 7.0, "range": [ 7.0, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.12855586584927856, "within_model_sd_median": 0.12855586584927856, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 7.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 7.0, "reflective_independent": 7.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 0.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 37, "high": 83 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 8.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 7.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 7.0 } ] }, { "entity_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "sample_count": 120, "mean": 3.3833333333333333, "median": 3.0, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 4.0, "range": [ 3.0, 4.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4882369815366878, "within_model_sd_median": 0.4882369815366878, "between_model_sd": 0.0, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.0 }, "ensemble_family_median": 3.0, "variant_medians": { "direct_anchored": 3.0, "reflective_independent": 4.0 }, "prompt_sensitivity": 1.0, "confidence_counts": { "low": 0, "medium": 25, "high": 95 }, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 11, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 7, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 10, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 9, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 8, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 6, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 4, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "order_position": 5, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "order_position": 1, "score_1_10": 4.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "order_position": 3, "score_1_10": 3.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "order_position": 2, "score_1_10": 3.0 } ] } ], "profiles": { "balanced": { "label": "Balanced", "weights": [ 25.0, 20.0, 20.0, 15.0, 10.0, 10.0 ], "assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.40375, "median_1_10": 8.4375, "q1_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "q3_1_10": 8.628124999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.9, 9.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.37583471914009076, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.4375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.4375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.3875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 1.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 1.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.35121615125082234, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.6, "display_100": 86.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.6375, "display_100": 86.375, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.825, "display_100": 88.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 9.0, "display_100": 90.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.3875 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 8.042291666666667, "median_1_10": 8.05, "q1_1_10": 7.95, "q3_1_10": 8.1, "range_1_10": [ 7.7125, 8.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.14941397546556937, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.05 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.05 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.09516819845361706, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.55, "display_100": 85.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8625, "display_100": 78.625, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7625, "display_100": 77.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8625, "display_100": 78.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1625, "display_100": 81.625, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7125, "display_100": 77.125, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.7250000000000005, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 8.026875, "median_1_10": 8.04375, "q1_1_10": 7.95, "q3_1_10": 8.115625000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.5, 8.375 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15406476115663864, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.04375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.04375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 1.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.09267239312174194, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0375, "display_100": 80.375, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7749999999999995, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.949999999999999, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.949999999999999, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2125, "display_100": 82.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8625, "display_100": 78.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0875, "display_100": 80.875, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8125, "display_100": 78.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0875, "display_100": 80.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2625, "display_100": 82.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.00875, "median_1_10": 7.987500000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.862499999999999, "q3_1_10": 8.1, "range_1_10": [ 7.8, 8.375 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17931679756478175, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.987500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.987500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.95, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 1.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.4329819569622529, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1875, "display_100": 81.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.95 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.83375, "median_1_10": 7.8625, "q1_1_10": 7.75, "q3_1_10": 7.9, "range_1_10": [ 7.575, 8.1625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1596491378687095, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.8625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.8625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 1.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.06446959734221899, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1625, "display_100": 81.625, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.875 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.75625, "median_1_10": 7.793749999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.668750000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.887500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.4, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18078244291597192, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.793749999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.793749999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.85, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 1.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8023009759134789, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7875, "display_100": 77.875, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.85 } }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.72375, "median_1_10": 7.74375, "q1_1_10": 7.656250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.793749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.55, 7.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.11850486394143404, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.74375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.74375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 1.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3735321960613155, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7125, "display_100": 77.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.68875, "median_1_10": 7.71875, "q1_1_10": 7.65, "q3_1_10": 7.7875, "range_1_10": [ 7.35, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19511837575060828, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.71875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.71875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 1.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7041921540959082, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7375, "display_100": 77.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.6937500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.875, "q1_1_10": 7.403125000000001, "q3_1_10": 8.0, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 8.025 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3702124952870537, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.725, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 1.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.36485344576006756, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3375, "display_100": 73.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.725 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.71125, "median_1_10": 7.7, "q1_1_10": 7.5625, "q3_1_10": 7.871875000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.4, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2053494650048491, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.7 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.7 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.71875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 1.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8172897709931114, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7875, "display_100": 77.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.71875 } }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.59625, "median_1_10": 7.5375, "q1_1_10": 7.5, "q3_1_10": 7.8968750000000005, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3254297372535107, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.7125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 1.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5815451893269232, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.7125 } }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.78625, "median_1_10": 7.8, "q1_1_10": 7.628124999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.89375, "range_1_10": [ 7.55, 8.075 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17224518216129517, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.8 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.8 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.7, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 1.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.31252490205550076, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7125, "display_100": 77.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.7 } }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.4887500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.4875, "q1_1_10": 7.34375, "q3_1_10": 7.668749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.0875, 7.775 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21573920083697765, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.55, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 1.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.1412608817220843, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0875, "display_100": 70.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.55 } }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.43125, "median_1_10": 7.44375, "q1_1_10": 7.362499999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.518750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.9, 7.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.264263257840443, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.44375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.44375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.5, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 1.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.33521749804141715, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3999999999999995, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.5 } }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.37875, "median_1_10": 7.4375, "q1_1_10": 7.34375, "q3_1_10": 7.49375, "range_1_10": [ 7.0, 7.525 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1668800717081981, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.4375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 1.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3610543933253997, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1875, "display_100": 71.875, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.4375 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.29125, "median_1_10": 7.3625, "q1_1_10": 7.240625, "q3_1_10": 7.4, "range_1_10": [ 6.85, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24692905526351758, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.3625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.3625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.4, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 1.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2871265783563709, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2375, "display_100": 72.375, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.4 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.3412500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.206250000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.0874999999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.612500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.025, 7.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.30539421245334686, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.206250000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.206250000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 1.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.681459032903368, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2125, "display_100": 72.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3875 } }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.4037500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.4, "q1_1_10": 7.215625, "q3_1_10": 7.5062500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 7.025, 7.95 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.26719024121400853, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 1.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7678838277309019, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1875, "display_100": 71.875, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.375 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.41875, "median_1_10": 7.43125, "q1_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.61875, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 7.725 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22152015835033068, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.43125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.43125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.5, "20": 0.5, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.34822148942721387, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5249999999999995, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.22875, "median_1_10": 7.324999999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.046875, "q3_1_10": 7.35, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2670602564133337, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.324999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.324999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.5, "20": 0.5, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7632658403066925, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1875, "display_100": 71.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.391249999999999, "median_1_10": 7.35, "q1_1_10": 7.2625, "q3_1_10": 7.5562499999999995, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18966802137770444, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.35 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.35 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.25, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.20146176874105137, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2375, "display_100": 72.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3 } }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.31625, "median_1_10": 7.324999999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.2093750000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.4375, "range_1_10": [ 7.075, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15253073460781594, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.324999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.324999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.25, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4230661243723979, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3999999999999995, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2375, "display_100": 72.375, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.32875, "median_1_10": 7.275, "q1_1_10": 7.15, "q3_1_10": 7.549999999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.975, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2522158742470867, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.275 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.275 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.25, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.39432956214852555, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1125, "display_100": 71.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.38375, "median_1_10": 7.34375, "q1_1_10": 7.3, "q3_1_10": 7.562499999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.05, 7.699999999999999 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2198523810297365, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.34375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.34375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.25, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.11580377407634697, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3875, "display_100": 73.875, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.699999999999999, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3 } }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.21375, "median_1_10": 7.275, "q1_1_10": 7.025, "q3_1_10": 7.384375, "range_1_10": [ 6.55, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.35229653308288794, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.275 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.275 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.275, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 1.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.362265785501864, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3375, "display_100": 73.375, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.275 } }, { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.23625, "median_1_10": 7.225, "q1_1_10": 7.140625, "q3_1_10": 7.2875, "range_1_10": [ 7.0, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.16334715077608986, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.225 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.225 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.25, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 1.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5507529685558726, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1875, "display_100": 71.875, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.25 } }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.33375, "median_1_10": 7.2625, "q1_1_10": 7.2125, "q3_1_10": 7.378125000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.196324738068787, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 1.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.15520039123489648, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3125, "display_100": 73.125, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.03375, "median_1_10": 7.09375, "q1_1_10": 6.85, "q3_1_10": 7.2, "range_1_10": [ 6.7, 7.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21229974224090703, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.09375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.09375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 1.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.037583102766285355, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0625, "display_100": 70.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1875 } }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.18125, "median_1_10": 7.11875, "q1_1_10": 7.081250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.2, "range_1_10": [ 6.95, 7.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18439559677799008, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.11875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.11875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.3333333333333333, "30": 0.3333333333333333, "31": 0.3333333333333333, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8468784198058958, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1375, "display_100": 71.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.17375, "median_1_10": 7.125, "q1_1_10": 6.956250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.446875, "range_1_10": [ 6.65, 7.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.32810747307687, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.3333333333333333, "30": 0.3333333333333333, "31": 0.3333333333333333, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5039101049901301, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4625, "display_100": 74.625, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.10375, "median_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "q1_1_10": 6.987500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.1937500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.65, 7.4625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24875034896681275, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.1499999999999995 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.1499999999999995 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.3333333333333333, "30": 0.3333333333333333, "31": 0.3333333333333333, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2522400179189872, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4625, "display_100": 74.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.27625, "median_1_10": 7.25, "q1_1_10": 7.1812499999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.331249999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.05, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15706178013055172, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.25 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 1.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7173467571852903, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1625, "display_100": 71.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.19625, "median_1_10": 7.15625, "q1_1_10": 7.112499999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.23125, "range_1_10": [ 7.05, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1598664807477373, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.15625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.15625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 1.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3897471399687344, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2749999999999995, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1625, "display_100": 71.625, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1499999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.12375, "median_1_10": 7.1125, "q1_1_10": 7.0125, "q3_1_10": 7.34375, "range_1_10": [ 6.375, 7.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.40510843884350545, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.1125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.1125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.5, "35": 0.5, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.45512505374202894, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.6875, "display_100": 66.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.375, "display_100": 63.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3999999999999995, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1375 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.05875, "median_1_10": 7.0625, "q1_1_10": 7.0, "q3_1_10": 7.1312500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.4875, 7.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2892789167337757, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.5, "35": 0.5, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.08025920952354429, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4875, "display_100": 64.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1375 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.05125, "median_1_10": 7.0, "q1_1_10": 6.896875, "q3_1_10": 7.2125, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20038591240126874, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 1.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.005981324739783265, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9625, "display_100": 69.625, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.125 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.10625, "median_1_10": 7.05, "q1_1_10": 7.009375, "q3_1_10": 7.24375, "range_1_10": [ 6.65, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22831280321329128, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.05 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.05 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.075, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 1.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.20843994397316606, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.075 } }, { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.06375, "median_1_10": 7.00625, "q1_1_10": 6.9125, "q3_1_10": 7.25, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.425 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21877579213025886, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.00625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.00625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 1.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3032329336155811, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8999999999999995, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.96875, "median_1_10": 6.9875, "q1_1_10": 6.8125, "q3_1_10": 7.2, "range_1_10": [ 6.3, 7.325 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31154019269857736, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.9875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.9875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 1.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.1489989271825419, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2625, "display_100": 72.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.06125, "median_1_10": 7.0875, "q1_1_10": 6.853125, "q3_1_10": 7.25, "range_1_10": [ 6.75, 7.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23967932859459437, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.975, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 1.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.41192546888087317, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8375, "display_100": 68.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.975 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.81375, "median_1_10": 6.925000000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.890625, "q3_1_10": 6.9875, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 7.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.33137183294098277, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.925000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.925000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.95, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.5, "42": 0.5, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4811529480416076, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8875, "display_100": 68.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.95 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.10375, "median_1_10": 7.08125, "q1_1_10": 6.9, "q3_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.7, 7.575 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.30265319812176666, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.08125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.08125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.95, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.5, "42": 0.5, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3755915094921956, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1625, "display_100": 71.625, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.95 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.88125, "median_1_10": 6.8875, "q1_1_10": 6.7625, "q3_1_10": 6.95, "range_1_10": [ 6.6125, 7.3 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18941155221134506, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.8875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.8875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 1.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6214461362226064, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.6125, "display_100": 66.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.875 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.71875, "median_1_10": 6.725, "q1_1_10": 6.509375, "q3_1_10": 6.981249999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 7.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3359920013928903, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.725 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.725 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.65, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.5, "45": 0.5, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.05670425539255418, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4625, "display_100": 64.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.65 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.72875, "median_1_10": 6.725, "q1_1_10": 6.6625000000000005, "q3_1_10": 6.8374999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 6.3375, 6.95 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1718011204852866, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.725 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.725 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.65, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.5, "45": 0.5, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4311453072268598, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3375, "display_100": 63.375, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.65 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.57375, "median_1_10": 6.625, "q1_1_10": 6.4468749999999995, "q3_1_10": 6.7375, "range_1_10": [ 6.025, 6.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24469723355835277, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.6375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 1.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.42873642278337987, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4125, "display_100": 64.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.6375 } }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.50875, "median_1_10": 6.55625, "q1_1_10": 6.325, "q3_1_10": 6.7, "range_1_10": [ 6.075, 6.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23482041010099614, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.55625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.55625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 1.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.7518122221177392, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5625, "display_100": 65.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.35875, "median_1_10": 6.3875, "q1_1_10": 5.9625, "q3_1_10": 6.793749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 5.0, 7.3 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.7105370132668827, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.3875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.3875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.425, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 1.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.07889128245129425, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2625, "display_100": 72.625, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.275, "display_100": 62.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.725, "display_100": 57.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.425 } }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.37125, "median_1_10": 6.425000000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.3125, "q3_1_10": 6.5, "range_1_10": [ 5.8375, 6.775 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25468185491358086, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.425000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.425000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.4, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 1.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.36874271439301093, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.8375, "display_100": 58.375, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.4 } }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.36875, "median_1_10": 6.356249999999999, "q1_1_10": 6.3125, "q3_1_10": 6.475, "range_1_10": [ 6.05, 6.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20810404048616324, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.356249999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.356249999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.3, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 1.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.06859150817287767, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3625, "display_100": 63.625, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.3 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.12625, "median_1_10": 6.0875, "q1_1_10": 5.8374999999999995, "q3_1_10": 6.446875, "range_1_10": [ 5.6, 6.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3420957671309147, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.2125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 1.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.13266776273754144, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.6, "display_100": 56.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4625, "display_100": 64.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.2125 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.31625, "median_1_10": 6.25, "q1_1_10": 6.171874999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.581249999999999, "range_1_10": [ 5.7, 6.825 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.32660129022674994, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.25 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.25 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.5, "53": 0.5, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4878831651989961, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.1625, "display_100": 61.625, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.12625, "median_1_10": 6.2, "q1_1_10": 6.106249999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.2093750000000005, "range_1_10": [ 5.675, 6.35 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19986540610009415, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.2 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.2 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.5, "53": 0.5, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7966985776057849, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.675, "display_100": 56.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2125, "display_100": 62.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.21875, "median_1_10": 6.206250000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.074999999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.331249999999999, "range_1_10": [ 5.95, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19394031871228376, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.206250000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.206250000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 1.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5903759602537456, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.275, "display_100": 62.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2625, "display_100": 62.625, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.0, "display_100": 60.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.31125, "median_1_10": 6.3, "q1_1_10": 6.1625000000000005, "q3_1_10": 6.425000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.0875, 6.65 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17544091281365604, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.3 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.3 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 1.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5660209128224242, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.0875, "display_100": 60.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.02375, "median_1_10": 6.0375, "q1_1_10": 5.9, "q3_1_10": 6.15, "range_1_10": [ 5.75, 6.35 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19547396103942954, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 1.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3166702619012438, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7625, "display_100": 57.625, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.76625, "median_1_10": 5.775, "q1_1_10": 5.690625, "q3_1_10": 5.8812500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 5.35, 6.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2436734210190171, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.775 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.775 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.85, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 1.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5600232564403035, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.35, "display_100": 53.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.825, "display_100": 58.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.6875, "display_100": 56.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.45, "display_100": 54.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.85 } }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.48375, "median_1_10": 5.55625, "q1_1_10": 5.18125, "q3_1_10": 5.718749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 4.675, 6.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.475951167546513, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.55625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.55625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 1.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6990488368307515, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.575, "display_100": 55.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.5375, "display_100": 55.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.725, "display_100": 57.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.675, "display_100": 46.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.075, "display_100": 50.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.57125, "median_1_10": 5.55625, "q1_1_10": 5.231249999999999, "q3_1_10": 5.875000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 5.15, 6.175 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.36429393275821165, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.55625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.55625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.50625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 1.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.37549389671992817, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.2, "display_100": 52.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.25, "display_100": 52.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.15, "display_100": 51.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.6625, "display_100": 56.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.225, "display_100": 52.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.45, "display_100": 54.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.50625 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.78375, "median_1_10": 5.45, "q1_1_10": 5.0, "q3_1_10": 6.624999999999999, "range_1_10": [ 4.875, 7.3125 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.9284479656932854, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.45 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.45 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.425, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 1.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6096577665773019, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.875, "display_100": 48.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3125, "display_100": 73.125, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.425 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.28125, "median_1_10": 5.324999999999999, "q1_1_10": 5.159375, "q3_1_10": 5.393750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 4.6, 5.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31673518995456695, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.324999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.324999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.4, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 1.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5302964129102761, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.35, "display_100": 53.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.6, "display_100": 46.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.1125, "display_100": 51.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.05, "display_100": 50.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.375, "display_100": 53.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.525, "display_100": 55.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.4 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.93375, "median_1_10": 4.93125, "q1_1_10": 4.8, "q3_1_10": 5.1, "range_1_10": [ 4.65, 5.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1738104411260856, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.93125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.93125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.925, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 1.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.028437561790822654, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.8, "display_100": 48.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.8, "display_100": 48.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.8, "display_100": 48.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.8625, "display_100": 48.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.65, "display_100": 46.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.125, "display_100": 51.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.125, "display_100": 51.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.15, "display_100": 51.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.025, "display_100": 50.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.925 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.81875, "median_1_10": 4.85, "q1_1_10": 4.5718749999999995, "q3_1_10": 5.0687500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 4.35, 5.2 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3037525720055717, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.85 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.85 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 1.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.3222012093119984, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.775, "display_100": 47.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.075, "display_100": 50.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.55, "display_100": 45.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.6375, "display_100": 46.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.475, "display_100": 44.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.1499999999999995, "display_100": 51.49999999999999, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.05, "display_100": 50.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.2, "display_100": 52.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.35, "display_100": 43.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.925, "display_100": 49.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.875 } }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.67125, "median_1_10": 4.6875, "q1_1_10": 4.525, "q3_1_10": 4.8374999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 4.05, 5.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.29297622675644597, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.6875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.6875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.65, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 1.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3656180699202944, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.85, "display_100": 48.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.05, "display_100": 40.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.625, "display_100": 46.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.4875, "display_100": 44.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.5, "display_100": 45.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.8, "display_100": 48.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.95, "display_100": 49.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.75, "display_100": 47.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.1, "display_100": 51.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.6, "display_100": 46.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.65 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.10125, "median_1_10": 4.2875, "q1_1_10": 3.7406250000000005, "q3_1_10": 4.3875, "range_1_10": [ 3.55, 4.45 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.36621420947612376, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 1.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4285476204612318, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.35, "display_100": 43.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.25, "display_100": 42.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.55, "display_100": 35.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.6375, "display_100": 36.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.325, "display_100": 43.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.05, "display_100": 40.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.4, "display_100": 44.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.4, "display_100": 44.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.45, "display_100": 44.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 3.6, "display_100": 36.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 3.34625, "median_1_10": 3.06875, "q1_1_10": 2.95, "q3_1_10": 3.8499999999999996, "range_1_10": [ 2.85, 4.075 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5063502987063403, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.06875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.06875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 3.0812500000000003, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 1.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5509319507990764, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.0, "display_100": 40.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 2.95, "display_100": 29.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 2.95, "display_100": 29.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.1125000000000003, "display_100": 31.125000000000004, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 2.9, "display_100": 29.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 3.9, "display_100": 39.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 3.7, "display_100": 37.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.025, "display_100": 30.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 2.85, "display_100": 28.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.075, "display_100": 40.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 3.0812500000000003 } } ] }, "constitutional_safety": { "label": "Constitutional safety", "weights": [ 35.0, 20.0, 15.0, 10.0, 10.0, 10.0 ], "assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.59375, "median_1_10": 8.625, "q1_1_10": 8.30625, "q3_1_10": 8.784375, "range_1_10": [ 8.1, 9.125 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.357326589644077, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.575, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 1.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 1.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.26283399819953673, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.7, "display_100": 87.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.65, "display_100": 86.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.8125, "display_100": 88.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 9.075, "display_100": 90.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.6, "display_100": 86.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 9.125, "display_100": 91.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.575 } }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.23875, "median_1_10": 8.1875, "q1_1_10": 8.0625, "q3_1_10": 8.35, "range_1_10": [ 8.05, 8.65 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20501100918947954, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.1875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.1875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5166267290624532, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.65, "display_100": 86.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.4625, "display_100": 84.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 8.176875, "median_1_10": 8.2, "q1_1_10": 8.1, "q3_1_10": 8.290624999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.65, 8.575000000000001 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.16948582958044436, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.2 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.2 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.0460553658013745, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1625, "display_100": 81.625, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2875, "display_100": 82.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3875, "display_100": 83.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2125, "display_100": 82.125, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2875, "display_100": 82.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2125, "display_100": 82.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.525, "display_100": 85.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.325000000000001, "display_100": 83.25000000000001, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.4375, "display_100": 84.375, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.575000000000001, "display_100": 85.75000000000001, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.05125, "median_1_10": 8.0625, "q1_1_10": 7.95, "q3_1_10": 8.125, "range_1_10": [ 7.825, 8.2875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.14024408286190804, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 1.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.0983368212840291, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2875, "display_100": 82.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "display_100": 80.75000000000001, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.125 } }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.00625, "median_1_10": 8.03125, "q1_1_10": 7.918750000000001, "q3_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.8, 8.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1435233720804155, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.03125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.03125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 1.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.372230224311513, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "display_100": 80.75000000000001, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "display_100": 80.75000000000001, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.075000000000001, "display_100": 80.75000000000001, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.075000000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.66125, "median_1_10": 7.68125, "q1_1_10": 7.575, "q3_1_10": 7.7875, "range_1_10": [ 7.4, 7.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1607761124462627, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.68125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.68125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.3333333333333333, "7": 0.3333333333333333, "8": 0.3333333333333333, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7420034432284253, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6625, "display_100": 76.625, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 7.737291666666667, "median_1_10": 7.75, "q1_1_10": 7.65, "q3_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.3375, 8.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1667312987425941, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.75 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.75 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.3333333333333333, "7": 0.3333333333333333, "8": 0.3333333333333333, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.06372769371689353, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.612500000000001, "display_100": 76.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6625000000000005, "display_100": 76.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6625000000000005, "display_100": 76.625, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6625000000000005, "display_100": 76.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3875, "display_100": 73.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8375, "display_100": 78.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5625, "display_100": 75.625, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.3333333333333333, "3": 0.3333333333333333, "4": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5625, "display_100": 75.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3375, "display_100": 73.375, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.86125, "median_1_10": 7.85, "q1_1_10": 7.703125, "q3_1_10": 7.96875, "range_1_10": [ 7.6, 8.275 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20262598961304723, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.85 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.85 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.3333333333333333, "7": 0.3333333333333333, "8": 0.3333333333333333, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.36369822433855237, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7875000000000005, "display_100": 77.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.651249999999999, "median_1_10": 7.63125, "q1_1_10": 7.6, "q3_1_10": 7.7375, "range_1_10": [ 7.199999999999999, 8.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23691081889840146, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.63125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.63125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.7, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 1.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.30147779286381715, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.449999999999999, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6625, "display_100": 76.625, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.199999999999999, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.7 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.60375, "median_1_10": 7.63125, "q1_1_10": 7.4125000000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.7749999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 7.25, 7.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22158284756120755, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.63125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.63125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.63125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 1.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8158498238988958, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6625, "display_100": 76.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.63125 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.68875, "median_1_10": 7.69375, "q1_1_10": 7.4750000000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 7.375, 8.025 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23909914842545518, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.69375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.69375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.5, "12": 0.5, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.31406826908419433, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7125, "display_100": 77.125, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3999999999999995, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.53625, "median_1_10": 7.55625, "q1_1_10": 7.5, "q3_1_10": 7.637500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.25, 7.800000000000001 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17662440532258164, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.55625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.55625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.5, "12": 0.5, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6621283955933488, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5625, "display_100": 75.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.3333333333333333, "3": 0.3333333333333333, "4": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.3333333333333333, "5": 0.3333333333333333, "6": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.53875, "median_1_10": 7.7125, "q1_1_10": 7.203125, "q3_1_10": 7.825, "range_1_10": [ 6.95, 7.925 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.37907279057663246, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.7125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.7125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.5625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 1.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2522235619625028, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.112500000000001, "display_100": 71.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.5625 } }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.4312499999999995, "median_1_10": 7.525, "q1_1_10": 7.199999999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.628125, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.35732658964407715, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.525 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.525 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.5249999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 1.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3840496777344834, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5625, "display_100": 75.625, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.3333333333333333, "3": 0.3333333333333333, "4": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6499999999999995, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.3333333333333333, "5": 0.3333333333333333, "6": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.5249999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.36625, "median_1_10": 7.3375, "q1_1_10": 7.3062499999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.640625000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.8500000000000005, 7.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3179824637023592, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.3375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.3375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.5, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.5, "16": 0.5, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.520851905017877, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.612500000000001, "display_100": 76.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.5 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.39375, "median_1_10": 7.4625, "q1_1_10": 7.321875, "q3_1_10": 7.5, "range_1_10": [ 6.95, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23930237148845815, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.5, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.5, "16": 0.5, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.34761793856805256, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3125, "display_100": 73.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.5 } }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.27375, "median_1_10": 7.3125, "q1_1_10": 7.10625, "q3_1_10": 7.46875, "range_1_10": [ 6.9125000000000005, 7.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22177080886957734, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.3125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.3125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 1.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.04242463954884717, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9125000000000005, "display_100": 69.125, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.38875, "median_1_10": 7.375, "q1_1_10": 7.253125, "q3_1_10": 7.48125, "range_1_10": [ 7.075, 7.925 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25044751612530186, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 1.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6969332676239383, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2625, "display_100": 72.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.26125, "median_1_10": 7.175000000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.074999999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.512499999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.925, 7.6000000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24427116648875669, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.175000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.175000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.3333333333333333, "20": 0.3333333333333333, "21": 0.3333333333333333, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.41624596454648066, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.300000000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.2162500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.028125, "q3_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.8500000000000005, 7.65 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2500034721981099, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.300000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.300000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.3333333333333333, "20": 0.3333333333333333, "21": 0.3333333333333333, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7465413737760831, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1125, "display_100": 71.125, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.300000000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.39125, "median_1_10": 7.30625, "q1_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.55, "range_1_10": [ 7.1000000000000005, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20733510851330061, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.30625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.30625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.3333333333333333, "20": 0.3333333333333333, "21": 0.3333333333333333, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.0776950635147688, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3125, "display_100": 73.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.3333333333333333, "5": 0.3333333333333333, "6": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.300000000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.29875, "median_1_10": 7.26875, "q1_1_10": 7.2125, "q3_1_10": 7.343749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.1499999999999995, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.13698768192797472, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.26875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.26875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.25, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 1.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.36032012619792475, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2875, "display_100": 72.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.25 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.32375, "median_1_10": 7.3, "q1_1_10": 7.25625, "q3_1_10": 7.393750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 7.550000000000001 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1256165350934699, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.3 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.3 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.3333333333333333, "24": 0.3333333333333333, "25": 0.3333333333333333, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7899808643195507, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2375, "display_100": 72.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.1762500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.175000000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.103125, "q3_1_10": 7.2375, "range_1_10": [ 6.8500000000000005, 7.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18089764601379774, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.175000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.175000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.3333333333333333, "24": 0.3333333333333333, "25": 0.3333333333333333, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5433385574440485, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.3333333333333333, "6": 0.3333333333333333, "7": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1125, "display_100": 71.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.3412500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.2875, "q1_1_10": 7.2125, "q3_1_10": 7.384375, "range_1_10": [ 7.1000000000000005, 7.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2034468603837374, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.3333333333333333, "24": 0.3333333333333333, "25": 0.3333333333333333, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.161116988772248, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3375, "display_100": 73.375, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.12375, "median_1_10": 7.0, "q1_1_10": 6.909375000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.3875, "range_1_10": [ 6.825, 7.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.29335523119021856, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 1.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.678956727872193, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9375, "display_100": 69.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1875 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.0062500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.018750000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.862500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.16875, "range_1_10": [ 6.65, 7.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19731267487585943, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.018750000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.018750000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 1.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.16940143633283972, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9875, "display_100": 69.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1625 } }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.26625, "median_1_10": 7.2, "q1_1_10": 7.112500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.41875, "range_1_10": [ 6.975, 7.65 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2214260912559515, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.5, "29": 0.5, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.09475168845538988, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0625, "display_100": 70.625, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.1762500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.199999999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.071875, "q3_1_10": 7.2875000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.95, 7.3500000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.14463195628137587, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.199999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.199999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.5, "29": 0.5, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4359215731805234, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0625, "display_100": 70.625, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.0687500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.112500000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.0562499999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.18125, "range_1_10": [ 6.65, 7.325 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1988901497477104, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.112500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.112500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 1.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.12695673363016932, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8125, "display_100": 68.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1125 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.03875, "median_1_10": 7.025, "q1_1_10": 7.00625, "q3_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.4625, 7.675 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3170200878668591, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.025 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.025 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.5, "32": 0.5, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.006162719967762525, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4625, "display_100": 64.625, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.95625, "median_1_10": 7.074999999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.0218750000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.137500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.300000000000001, 7.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.34050870848710374, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.074999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.074999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.5, "32": 0.5, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.49096011202538054, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.3500000000000005, "display_100": 63.50000000000001, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0125, "display_100": 70.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.300000000000001, "display_100": 63.00000000000001, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1 } }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.02625, "median_1_10": 6.956250000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.95, "q3_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.800000000000001, 7.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17623079091539776, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.956250000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.956250000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.025, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.5, "34": 0.5, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8138532523518686, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.3333333333333333, "6": 0.3333333333333333, "7": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9625, "display_100": 69.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.800000000000001, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.025 } }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.9712499999999995, "median_1_10": 7.0, "q1_1_10": 6.874999999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.10625, "range_1_10": [ 6.55, 7.2875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22361067977874202, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.025, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.5, "34": 0.5, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.15759634534768924, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2875, "display_100": 72.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.025 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.0287500000000005, "median_1_10": 6.987500000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.862500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.375, 7.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.41382573157201225, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.987500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.987500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 1.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.37002290654648157, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5625, "display_100": 65.625, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.375, "display_100": 63.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0125 } }, { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.02875, "median_1_10": 7.00625, "q1_1_10": 6.831250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.1812499999999995, "range_1_10": [ 6.7, 7.45 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2519403864673811, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.00625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.00625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.3333333333333333, "37": 0.3333333333333333, "38": 0.3333333333333333, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.12124391884394838, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0125, "display_100": 70.125, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.08125, "median_1_10": 7.075000000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.8843749999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.2375, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23342632075715505, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.075000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.075000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.3333333333333333, "37": 0.3333333333333333, "38": 0.3333333333333333, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.35755592933108127, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.3333333333333333, "6": 0.3333333333333333, "7": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8625, "display_100": 68.625, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.18125, "median_1_10": 7.14375, "q1_1_10": 6.95, "q3_1_10": 7.475, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.30840370818494095, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.14375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.14375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.3333333333333333, "37": 0.3333333333333333, "38": 0.3333333333333333, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3903144539734383, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2375, "display_100": 72.375, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.9662500000000005, "median_1_10": 6.9625, "q1_1_10": 6.6875, "q3_1_10": 7.271875, "range_1_10": [ 6.4, 7.475 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3542426389104254, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.9625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.9625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.9750000000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.5, "40": 0.5, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.44469001135780883, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2875, "display_100": 72.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.675000000000001, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.9750000000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.89625, "median_1_10": 6.862500000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.7093750000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.0625, "range_1_10": [ 6.55, 7.3500000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25014232060080444, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.862500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.862500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.9750000000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.5, "40": 0.5, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.03531560949748922, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7375, "display_100": 67.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.9750000000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.99125, "median_1_10": 6.9, "q1_1_10": 6.8656250000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.11875, "range_1_10": [ 6.6, 7.45 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24195744001327546, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.9 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.9 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.925000000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 1.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.17607212750828963, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.862500000000001, "display_100": 68.625, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.925000000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.85375, "median_1_10": 6.9125, "q1_1_10": 6.7125, "q3_1_10": 6.95, "range_1_10": [ 6.5375, 7.2 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20378791399121038, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.9125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.9125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 1.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4607255526027527, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5375, "display_100": 65.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.875 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.831250000000001, "median_1_10": 6.862500000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.68125, "q3_1_10": 7.0687500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 7.225 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3239968492645156, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.862500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.862500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 1.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.06116221266010075, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1375, "display_100": 71.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.675000000000001, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.8500000000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.86625, "median_1_10": 6.875, "q1_1_10": 6.8125, "q3_1_10": 6.9875, "range_1_10": [ 6.3625, 7.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20480766722844032, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.8, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 1.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4494222013240387, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.949999999999999, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3625, "display_100": 63.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.8 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.78625, "median_1_10": 6.775, "q1_1_10": 6.6156250000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.0062500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 7.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.34542898048014953, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.775 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.775 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.7, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 1.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.03309307093519788, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5875, "display_100": 65.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.800000000000001, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.7 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.5912500000000005, "median_1_10": 6.625, "q1_1_10": 6.415625, "q3_1_10": 6.7875000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.125, 6.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2516645971217336, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.6625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 1.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.399575666288301, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.800000000000001, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3875, "display_100": 63.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.6625 } }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.57125, "median_1_10": 6.61875, "q1_1_10": 6.4125, "q3_1_10": 6.75, "range_1_10": [ 6.125, 6.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22392102402409658, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.61875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.61875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.65, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 1.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.7630560830994767, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.6375, "display_100": 66.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.65 } }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.4712499999999995, "median_1_10": 6.512499999999999, "q1_1_10": 6.0562499999999995, "q3_1_10": 6.875, "range_1_10": [ 5.0, 7.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.7555362793701202, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.512499999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.512499999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.5375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 1.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.11732778074390371, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3875, "display_100": 73.875, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.975, "display_100": 59.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.825, "display_100": 58.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.5375 } }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.47125, "median_1_10": 6.525, "q1_1_10": 6.4125000000000005, "q3_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 5.862500000000001, 6.8500000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.26680009682656913, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.525 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.525 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.5, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 1.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.41769052718736144, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.862500000000001, "display_100": 58.62500000000001, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.5 } }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.54875, "median_1_10": 6.525, "q1_1_10": 6.4125, "q3_1_10": 6.625, "range_1_10": [ 6.3125, 6.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17935552062252721, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.525 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.525 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.3999999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 1.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5147311668870295, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.6499999999999995, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.3999999999999995, "display_100": 63.99999999999999, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.3999999999999995, "display_100": 63.99999999999999, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3125, "display_100": 63.125, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.3999999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.40125, "median_1_10": 6.40625, "q1_1_10": 6.237500000000001, "q3_1_10": 6.562499999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 6.65 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18012823364357822, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.40625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.40625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 1.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.45872820035602535, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.375, "display_100": 63.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4375, "display_100": 64.375, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.449999999999999, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.33375, "median_1_10": 6.3, "q1_1_10": 6.240625, "q3_1_10": 6.55, "range_1_10": [ 5.65, 6.825 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3221051631239572, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.3 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.3 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.25, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 1.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4973812025874643, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.65, "display_100": 56.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2375, "display_100": 62.375, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.25 } }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.251250000000001, "median_1_10": 6.21875, "q1_1_10": 6.1625000000000005, "q3_1_10": 6.362500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 5.9, 6.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.224416682138878, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.21875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.21875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.15, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 1.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.03229210161866593, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2375, "display_100": 62.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.15 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.06375, "median_1_10": 6.1, "q1_1_10": 6.0625, "q3_1_10": 6.134375, "range_1_10": [ 5.725, 6.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1588205223934658, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.1 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.1 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.1, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 1.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7246203457360099, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.85, "display_100": 58.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.725, "display_100": 57.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.1375, "display_100": 61.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.1 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.05625, "median_1_10": 5.9625, "q1_1_10": 5.75625, "q3_1_10": 6.415625, "range_1_10": [ 5.55, 6.525 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.36653643520574236, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.9625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.9625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.0875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 1.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.11517018787645486, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.85, "display_100": 58.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.55, "display_100": 55.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4375, "display_100": 64.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.725, "display_100": 57.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.0875 } }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.05625, "median_1_10": 6.0625, "q1_1_10": 5.95, "q3_1_10": 6.137500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 5.7375, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2102619067840023, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 1.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.26544127251959315, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.0249999999999995, "display_100": 60.24999999999999, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7375, "display_100": 57.375, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.85, "display_100": 58.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.69125, "median_1_10": 5.675, "q1_1_10": 5.621874999999999, "q3_1_10": 5.7749999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 5.35, 6.05 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2083374999583342, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.675 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.675 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.7625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 1.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5311784172804388, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.65, "display_100": 56.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.35, "display_100": 53.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.675, "display_100": 56.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.6125, "display_100": 56.125, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.45, "display_100": 54.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.675, "display_100": 56.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.7625 } }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.46875, "median_1_10": 5.525, "q1_1_10": 5.209375, "q3_1_10": 5.7250000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 4.7, 6.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4448489912318561, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.525 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.525 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.575, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 1.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6724235291080995, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.55, "display_100": 55.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.4625, "display_100": 54.625, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.7250000000000005, "display_100": 57.25000000000001, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.7, "display_100": 47.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.85, "display_100": 58.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7250000000000005, "display_100": 57.25000000000001, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.125, "display_100": 51.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.575 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.85125, "median_1_10": 5.55, "q1_1_10": 5.0, "q3_1_10": 6.700000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 4.825, 7.4875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.9895013123903486, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.55 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.55 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.525, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 1.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6101915631444534, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.825, "display_100": 48.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.6, "display_100": 56.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.1000000000000005, "display_100": 61.00000000000001, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.525 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.42125, "median_1_10": 5.425000000000001, "q1_1_10": 5.353125, "q3_1_10": 5.51875, "range_1_10": [ 4.7, 6.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3306165326578007, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.425000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.425000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.5, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 1.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4752643255862648, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.45, "display_100": 54.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.7, "display_100": 47.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.3375, "display_100": 53.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.225, "display_100": 52.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.0, "display_100": 60.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.5249999999999995, "display_100": 55.24999999999999, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.675, "display_100": 56.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.5 } }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.56125, "median_1_10": 5.49375, "q1_1_10": 5.25625, "q3_1_10": 5.8500000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 5.15, 6.225 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.36697193731643524, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.49375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.49375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.45625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 1.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.3958702112241604, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.2, "display_100": 52.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.25, "display_100": 52.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.15, "display_100": 51.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.5875, "display_100": 55.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.925, "display_100": 59.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.275, "display_100": 52.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.45625 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.05625, "median_1_10": 5.05625, "q1_1_10": 4.91875, "q3_1_10": 5.199999999999999, "range_1_10": [ 4.8, 5.3 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.16721264738184252, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.05625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.05625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.075, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 1.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.015441601421023618, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.975, "display_100": 49.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.9875, "display_100": 49.875, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.8, "display_100": 48.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.125, "display_100": 51.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.225, "display_100": 52.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.225, "display_100": 52.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.125, "display_100": 51.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.075 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.88875, "median_1_10": 4.925, "q1_1_10": 4.665625, "q3_1_10": 5.15625, "range_1_10": [ 4.35, 5.275 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.319637924498608, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.925 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.925 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.9625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 1.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.24521359615443059, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.925, "display_100": 49.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.175, "display_100": 51.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.65, "display_100": 46.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.7125, "display_100": 47.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.5249999999999995, "display_100": 45.24999999999999, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.25, "display_100": 52.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.1, "display_100": 51.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.275, "display_100": 52.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.35, "display_100": 43.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.925, "display_100": 49.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.9625 } }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.63625, "median_1_10": 4.575, "q1_1_10": 4.456250000000001, "q3_1_10": 4.8812500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 4.05, 5.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3233102440209543, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.575 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.575 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.575, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 1.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3066713606670796, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.05, "display_100": 40.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.475, "display_100": 44.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.4125, "display_100": 44.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.45, "display_100": 44.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.825, "display_100": 48.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.95, "display_100": 49.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.65, "display_100": 46.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.15, "display_100": 51.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.5, "display_100": 45.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.575 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.16875, "median_1_10": 4.4, "q1_1_10": 3.775, "q3_1_10": 4.45, "range_1_10": [ 3.6, 4.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3910123079904263, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.4 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.4 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.2749999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 1.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.43185274629606785, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.45, "display_100": 44.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.35, "display_100": 43.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.6, "display_100": 36.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.6125, "display_100": 36.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.475, "display_100": 44.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.15, "display_100": 41.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.45, "display_100": 44.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.45, "display_100": 44.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.5, "display_100": 45.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 3.65, "display_100": 36.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.2749999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 3.40125, "median_1_10": 3.15625, "q1_1_10": 3.0, "q3_1_10": 3.875, "range_1_10": [ 2.9, 4.175 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5010561761585886, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.15625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.15625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 3.14375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 1.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5268958576943922, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.05, "display_100": 40.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 3.0, "display_100": 30.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.0, "display_100": 30.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.1875, "display_100": 31.875, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 2.975, "display_100": 29.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 3.9499999999999997, "display_100": 39.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 3.65, "display_100": 36.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.125, "display_100": 31.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 2.9, "display_100": 29.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.175, "display_100": 41.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 3.14375 } } ] }, "national_unity": { "label": "National unity", "weights": [ 15.0, 15.0, 30.0, 20.0, 10.0, 10.0 ], "assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 8.355, "median_1_10": 8.35, "q1_1_10": 8.275, "q3_1_10": 8.4, "range_1_10": [ 8.049999999999999, 8.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.13107506349000014, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.35 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.35 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 1.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 1.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.12944094096642242, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.575, "display_100": 85.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2875, "display_100": 82.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.725, "display_100": 87.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325000000000001, "display_100": 83.25000000000001, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3125, "display_100": 83.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.725, "display_100": 87.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.525, "display_100": 85.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3125, "display_100": 83.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.8, "display_100": 88.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.85, "display_100": 88.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2375, "display_100": 82.375, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3125, "display_100": 83.125, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.775, "display_100": 87.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1625, "display_100": 81.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.387500000000001, "display_100": 83.87500000000001, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.575, "display_100": 85.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2375, "display_100": 82.375, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2375, "display_100": 82.375, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.55, "display_100": 85.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.4375, "display_100": 84.375, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.55, "display_100": 85.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2375, "display_100": 82.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.049999999999999, "display_100": 80.49999999999999, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.09625, "median_1_10": 8.1375, "q1_1_10": 7.6937500000000005, "q3_1_10": 8.396875000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.6000000000000005, 8.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4064604155935045, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.1375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.1375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.0625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.44123355543126624, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.3333333333333333, "3": 0.3333333333333333, "4": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3875, "display_100": 83.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.75, "display_100": 87.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.0625 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.90625, "median_1_10": 7.956250000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.812500000000001, "q3_1_10": 8.037500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.475, 8.125 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19177985788108448, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.956250000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.956250000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 1.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8448583262922718, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9625, "display_100": 79.625, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.78125, "median_1_10": 7.737500000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.625, "q3_1_10": 8.1, "range_1_10": [ 7.3, 8.175 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3310992843711856, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.737500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.737500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.8875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 1.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6055002301049108, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1125, "display_100": 81.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.8875 } }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.83625, "median_1_10": 7.85, "q1_1_10": 7.8062499999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.9156249999999995, "range_1_10": [ 7.475, 8.225 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20450227518430095, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.85 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.85 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 1.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.751376380627052, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.875 } }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.81125, "median_1_10": 7.9625, "q1_1_10": 7.584375, "q3_1_10": 8.10625, "range_1_10": [ 7.2, 8.175 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3726989587976991, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.9625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.9625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.8625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 1.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.47140362238979344, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5625, "display_100": 75.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.8625 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 7.864166666666667, "median_1_10": 7.875, "q1_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.9281250000000005, "range_1_10": [ 7.35, 8.2 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.13734170924391187, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 1.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.14691597460537614, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8875, "display_100": 78.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.862500000000001, "display_100": 78.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.862500000000001, "display_100": 78.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.862500000000001, "display_100": 78.625, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0125, "display_100": 80.125, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7875000000000005, "display_100": 77.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7250000000000005, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.737500000000001, "display_100": 77.375, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.9750000000000005, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0625, "display_100": 80.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.925000000000001, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.8500000000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.80625, "median_1_10": 7.775, "q1_1_10": 7.61875, "q3_1_10": 8.003125, "range_1_10": [ 7.525, 8.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22214625437610522, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.775 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.775 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.80625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 1.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7151405865632775, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.675000000000001, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9375, "display_100": 79.375, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.80625 } }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.69625, "median_1_10": 7.7625, "q1_1_10": 7.621875, "q3_1_10": 7.8, "range_1_10": [ 7.425000000000001, 7.825 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.13744317007403445, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.7625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.7625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 1.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.682914941149127, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.612500000000001, "display_100": 76.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6499999999999995, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.800000000000001, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.68125, "median_1_10": 7.65, "q1_1_10": 7.581250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.8374999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 7.237500000000001, 7.975 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21337646048448913, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.65 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.65 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.7375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 1.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.22526102994877947, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.3333333333333333, "3": 0.3333333333333333, "4": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.237500000000001, "display_100": 72.375, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8999999999999995, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.7375 } }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.65625, "median_1_10": 7.65, "q1_1_10": 7.5625, "q3_1_10": 7.675, "range_1_10": [ 7.45, 7.975 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1444878407033307, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.65 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.65 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 1.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.3452408584434803, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.975, "display_100": 79.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.3333333333333333, "3": 0.3333333333333333, "4": 0.3333333333333333 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7875, "display_100": 77.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6375 } }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.65875, "median_1_10": 7.6875, "q1_1_10": 7.521875, "q3_1_10": 7.768750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.45, 7.8500000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1483766322572392, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.6875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.6875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 1.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.2516835086765961, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5875, "display_100": 75.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8500000000000005, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4750000000000005, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.51125, "median_1_10": 7.41875, "q1_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.78125, "range_1_10": [ 7.175, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31854977371414556, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.41875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.41875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.5375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 1.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6859248603880379, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.5375 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.53375, "median_1_10": 7.5125, "q1_1_10": 7.45, "q3_1_10": 7.5625, "range_1_10": [ 7.3, 7.9875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1874583287026746, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.525, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 1.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.09396890579560913, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9875, "display_100": 79.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.525 } }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.43375, "median_1_10": 7.456250000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.3375, "q3_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.2, 7.6000000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.14930975446292113, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.456250000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.456250000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.4375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 1.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3868946904184707, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4125000000000005, "display_100": 74.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.4375 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.246250000000001, "median_1_10": 7.356250000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.081250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.725, 7.575 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.305621520657314, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.356250000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.356250000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 1.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.752643815573303, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2875000000000005, "display_100": 72.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.425000000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.38625, "median_1_10": 7.4, "q1_1_10": 7.237500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.5, "range_1_10": [ 6.875, 7.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28822071500077084, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.4125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 1.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8111824504860389, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0875, "display_100": 70.875, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.4125 } }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.46625, "median_1_10": 7.45, "q1_1_10": 7.371874999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.56875, "range_1_10": [ 7.175, 7.725 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1641529182060298, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.45 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.45 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.4, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 1.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.36243897997539704, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3625, "display_100": 73.625, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.4 } }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.35375, "median_1_10": 7.3375, "q1_1_10": 7.1375, "q3_1_10": 7.5843750000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.8500000000000005, 7.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.30754685731518105, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.3375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.3375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 1.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5315268726844571, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5875, "display_100": 75.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.375 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.44125, "median_1_10": 7.325, "q1_1_10": 7.221875000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.68125, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 7.875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2887983966175867, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.325 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.325 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.25, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.37458795625482655, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2125, "display_100": 72.125, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.29375, "median_1_10": 7.30625, "q1_1_10": 7.25, "q3_1_10": 7.3625, "range_1_10": [ 7.15, 7.425 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.09560661587986463, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.30625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.30625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.25, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.34871671828047784, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2875, "display_100": 72.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.38625, "median_1_10": 7.35, "q1_1_10": 7.325, "q3_1_10": 7.590625, "range_1_10": [ 6.975, 7.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25388987660882517, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.35 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.35 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.25, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2566396975464155, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.4875, "display_100": 74.875, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.25875, "median_1_10": 7.2875000000000005, "q1_1_10": 7.09375, "q3_1_10": 7.3375, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.6875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2787652586755468, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2875000000000005 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2875000000000005 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.25, "21": 0.25, "22": 0.25, "23": 0.25, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3144968865508353, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6875, "display_100": 76.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.300000000000001, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.29875, "median_1_10": 7.23125, "q1_1_10": 7.18125, "q3_1_10": 7.3, "range_1_10": [ 7.075, 7.675 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2036515610873958, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.23125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.23125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.275, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 1.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8669327615902515, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2625, "display_100": 72.625, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.175000000000001, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.275 } }, { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.25375, "median_1_10": 7.237500000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.146875, "q3_1_10": 7.2875, "range_1_10": [ 7.1, 7.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15479040488494264, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.237500000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.237500000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.25, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 1.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5481965526532556, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2125, "display_100": 72.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.25 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.16375, "median_1_10": 7.13125, "q1_1_10": 7.05, "q3_1_10": 7.29375, "range_1_10": [ 6.9750000000000005, 7.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1493562575410441, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.13125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.13125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 1.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.04250239652364358, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1375, "display_100": 71.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9750000000000005, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2250000000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.11625, "median_1_10": 7.1625, "q1_1_10": 7.128125, "q3_1_10": 7.225, "range_1_10": [ 6.575, 7.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24875034896681267, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.1625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.1625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.225, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 1.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.24386555853815517, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1375, "display_100": 71.375, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1499999999999995, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.225 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.1762500000000005, "median_1_10": 7.200000000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.112500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.393750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.3, 7.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.412245291732429, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.200000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.200000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.5, "29": 0.5, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5306306812643513, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.175000000000001, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8125, "display_100": 68.125, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2125 } }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.12375, "median_1_10": 7.175000000000001, "q1_1_10": 6.99375, "q3_1_10": 7.221875000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.5, 7.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.29746906935381073, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.175000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.175000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.5, "29": 0.5, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.32689382630525693, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2125, "display_100": 72.125, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2250000000000005, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2125 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.17125, "median_1_10": 7.15625, "q1_1_10": 7.112499999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.293749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.675, 7.475 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21425338711182354, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.15625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.15625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 1.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.24927639693690407, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1625, "display_100": 71.625, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.23625, "median_1_10": 7.15, "q1_1_10": 7.13125, "q3_1_10": 7.278124999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.025, 7.675 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1927910858358802, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.15 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.15 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.112500000000001, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 1.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.10649163770286418, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2125, "display_100": 72.125, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.112500000000001 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.02375, "median_1_10": 7.0875, "q1_1_10": 6.85625, "q3_1_10": 7.268750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.35, 7.325 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3054169508866347, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 1.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.28992918508249227, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2875000000000005, "display_100": 72.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1000000000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.99625, "median_1_10": 7.0375, "q1_1_10": 6.906250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.093749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.4125, 7.475 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.26926146421482433, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.1, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 1.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.1655333730348673, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4125, "display_100": 64.125, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.1 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.92375, "median_1_10": 7.0062500000000005, "q1_1_10": 6.7250000000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.0875, "range_1_10": [ 6.45, 7.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25457276301023773, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0062500000000005 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0062500000000005 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 1.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.13355751322879472, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1000000000000005, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.987500000000001, "display_100": 69.875, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.050000000000001, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0625 } }, { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.02625, "median_1_10": 7.01875, "q1_1_10": 6.875, "q3_1_10": 7.143750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.775, 7.3 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19404771034178375, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.01875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.01875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.5, "36": 0.5, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6407662036832467, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.17625, "median_1_10": 7.125, "q1_1_10": 7.0625, "q3_1_10": 7.1875, "range_1_10": [ 6.95, 7.6000000000000005 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19440525398707162, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.5, "36": 0.5, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6622744803576704, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.05125, "median_1_10": 7.0, "q1_1_10": 6.9593750000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.05625, "range_1_10": [ 6.9, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.200905070175499, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 1.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4193275115410624, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9875, "display_100": 69.875, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.03125, "median_1_10": 7.03125, "q1_1_10": 6.88125, "q3_1_10": 7.21875, "range_1_10": [ 6.7, 7.275 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19801532628674082, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.03125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.03125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.9875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 1.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.44587747096752356, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1125, "display_100": 71.125, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.9875 } }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.93625, "median_1_10": 6.9625, "q1_1_10": 6.8062499999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.065625000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.225, 7.425 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3444223223182713, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.9625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.9625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.9625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 1.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3466416165692176, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.9625 } }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.96375, "median_1_10": 7.025, "q1_1_10": 6.721875, "q3_1_10": 7.18125, "range_1_10": [ 6.625, 7.3 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2653908281509869, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.025 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.025 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.85, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.5, "41": 0.5, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4666245922922025, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7124999999999995, "display_100": 67.125, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.85 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.94875, "median_1_10": 6.96875, "q1_1_10": 6.8, "q3_1_10": 7.1312500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.5, 7.425 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2960650500969152, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.96875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.96875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.85, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.5, "41": 0.5, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3413175149751784, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.85 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.86625, "median_1_10": 6.85, "q1_1_10": 6.7437499999999995, "q3_1_10": 6.893750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.6375, 7.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20666414649001047, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.85 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.85 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.825, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 1.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6974563259189475, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.6375, "display_100": 66.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.825 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.65625, "median_1_10": 6.7625, "q1_1_10": 6.740625, "q3_1_10": 6.8125, "range_1_10": [ 5.975, 6.925 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3156370322238999, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.7625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.7625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 1.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4561227008416979, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7375, "display_100": 67.375, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.975, "display_100": 59.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.56125, "median_1_10": 6.6375, "q1_1_10": 6.50625, "q3_1_10": 6.706249999999999, "range_1_10": [ 5.9, 6.775 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25470912058878276, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.6375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.6375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.5, "45": 0.5, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.39331395621089316, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4625, "display_100": 64.625, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.625 } }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.51125, "median_1_10": 6.575, "q1_1_10": 6.309374999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.7, "range_1_10": [ 6.1, 6.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23749634500111574, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.575 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.575 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.5, "45": 0.5, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.7371952136589869, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5625, "display_100": 65.625, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.625 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.60125, "median_1_10": 6.6, "q1_1_10": 6.5375, "q3_1_10": 6.668749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.3374999999999995, 6.775 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.12616815278737278, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.6 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.6 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.5249999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 1.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4131328676160478, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5249999999999995, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3374999999999995, "display_100": 63.37499999999999, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5249999999999995, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.5249999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.55125, "median_1_10": 6.55, "q1_1_10": 6.290625, "q3_1_10": 6.8500000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.05, 6.975 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3377031281729232, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.55 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.55 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.475, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 1.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.08448780387982993, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2124999999999995, "display_100": 62.12499999999999, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.475 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.24375, "median_1_10": 6.2875, "q1_1_10": 6.00625, "q3_1_10": 6.528124999999999, "range_1_10": [ 5.7, 6.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3257070300813977, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.3875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 1.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.167333611717198, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.275, "display_100": 62.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5375, "display_100": 65.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.85, "display_100": 58.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.975, "display_100": 59.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.3875 } }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.41625, "median_1_10": 6.425, "q1_1_10": 6.403125000000001, "q3_1_10": 6.468749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.1, 6.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17559917267585423, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.425 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.425 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 1.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.08003777674095298, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.425, "display_100": 64.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.4125, "display_100": 64.125, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.425, "display_100": 64.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.375 } }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.32875, "median_1_10": 6.375, "q1_1_10": 6.26875, "q3_1_10": 6.4437500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 5.8625, 6.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24438485700495713, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 1.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.34049122208439575, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.8625, "display_100": 58.625, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.425, "display_100": 64.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.12625, "median_1_10": 6.24375, "q1_1_10": 6.05, "q3_1_10": 6.25, "range_1_10": [ 5.575, 6.4 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2475189386693471, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.24375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.24375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.25, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 1.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8441877385099785, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.875, "display_100": 58.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.575, "display_100": 55.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.2375, "display_100": 62.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.25 } }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.17875, "median_1_10": 6.1875, "q1_1_10": 5.80625, "q3_1_10": 6.625, "range_1_10": [ 5.0, 7.0375 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.6430734038799752, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.1875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.1875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.2375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 1.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.015316273797250856, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0375, "display_100": 70.375, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.775, "display_100": 57.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.975, "display_100": 59.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.6, "display_100": 56.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.2375 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.3012500000000005, "median_1_10": 6.1875, "q1_1_10": 6.103125, "q3_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "range_1_10": [ 5.8, 6.825 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3324180141194384, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.1875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.1875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.1375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 1.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4585100911425297, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.0875, "display_100": 60.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.0, "display_100": 60.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.1375 } }, { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.88125, "median_1_10": 5.9125, "q1_1_10": 5.753125, "q3_1_10": 6.043749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 5.4, 6.325 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2944657356033881, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.9125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.9125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.975, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 1.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5576066825363473, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7625, "display_100": 57.625, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.475, "display_100": 54.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.875, "display_100": 58.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.975 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.92875, "median_1_10": 5.90625, "q1_1_10": 5.7625, "q3_1_10": 6.01875, "range_1_10": [ 5.65, 6.35 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2256202869621631, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.90625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.90625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.925, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 1.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6356037766222269, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.0, "display_100": 60.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.0249999999999995, "display_100": 60.24999999999999, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.9875, "display_100": 59.875, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.65, "display_100": 56.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.825, "display_100": 58.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.925 } }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.88375, "median_1_10": 5.875, "q1_1_10": 5.7625, "q3_1_10": 6.0249999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 5.55, 6.2 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19826066595940475, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.8374999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 1.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3782924376665501, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.875, "display_100": 58.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.6875, "display_100": 56.875, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.55, "display_100": 55.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.875, "display_100": 58.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.8374999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.99625, "median_1_10": 5.95, "q1_1_10": 5.8374999999999995, "q3_1_10": 6.1125, "range_1_10": [ 5.7875, 6.35 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18578381253489243, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.95 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.95 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.824999999999999, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 1.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.505942250527858, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.824999999999999, "display_100": 58.24999999999999, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.824999999999999, "display_100": 58.24999999999999, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.7875, "display_100": 57.875, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.875, "display_100": 58.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.824999999999999 } }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.70375, "median_1_10": 5.78125, "q1_1_10": 5.3125, "q3_1_10": 5.9875, "range_1_10": [ 5.275, 6.225 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.369311013916455, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.78125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.78125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.6937500000000005, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 1.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.29574000456307736, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.35, "display_100": 53.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.275, "display_100": 52.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.8875, "display_100": 58.875, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.0, "display_100": 60.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.675, "display_100": 56.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.6937500000000005 } }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.49125, "median_1_10": 5.63125, "q1_1_10": 5.143750000000001, "q3_1_10": 5.668749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 4.65, 6.35 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.50304800135441, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.63125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.63125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 1.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.708964678101778, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.625, "display_100": 56.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.6375, "display_100": 56.375, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.675, "display_100": 56.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.65, "display_100": 46.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.65, "display_100": 56.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.025, "display_100": 50.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.625 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.18375, "median_1_10": 5.2875, "q1_1_10": 4.984375, "q3_1_10": 5.3374999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 4.55, 5.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.320592442033322, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 1.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5657107983627279, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.55, "display_100": 45.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.275, "display_100": 52.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.8875, "display_100": 48.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.85, "display_100": 48.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.625, "display_100": 56.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.35, "display_100": 53.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.275, "display_100": 52.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.425, "display_100": 54.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.70375, "median_1_10": 5.35, "q1_1_10": 5.0, "q3_1_10": 6.50625, "range_1_10": [ 4.925, 7.0875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.8539949014289645, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.35 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.35 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 1.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6071817248728689, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.925, "display_100": 49.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0875, "display_100": 70.875, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.4, "display_100": 54.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.775, "display_100": 57.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.325 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.78125, "median_1_10": 4.824999999999999, "q1_1_10": 4.534375000000001, "q3_1_10": 5.043749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 4.4, 5.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.29681468685584483, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.824999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.824999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.8, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 1.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.3665266744306996, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.675, "display_100": 46.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0249999999999995, "display_100": 50.24999999999999, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.525, "display_100": 45.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.5625, "display_100": 45.625, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.4, "display_100": 44.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.05, "display_100": 50.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.05, "display_100": 50.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.15, "display_100": 51.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.4, "display_100": 44.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.975, "display_100": 49.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.8 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.83375, "median_1_10": 4.80625, "q1_1_10": 4.7, "q3_1_10": 5.0375, "range_1_10": [ 4.5, 5.075 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20883689143018344, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.80625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.80625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 1.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.08018849339630924, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.625, "display_100": 46.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.7, "display_100": 47.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.7, "display_100": 47.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.7375, "display_100": 47.375, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.5, "display_100": 45.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.875, "display_100": 48.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.075, "display_100": 50.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.075, "display_100": 50.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.05, "display_100": 50.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.74125, "median_1_10": 4.8125, "q1_1_10": 4.61875, "q3_1_10": 4.8812500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 4.1, 5.075 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2772665434399022, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.8125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.8125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 1.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3826086942251163, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.8, "display_100": 48.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.1, "display_100": 41.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.825, "display_100": 48.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.5625, "display_100": 45.625, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.575, "display_100": 45.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.825, "display_100": 48.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.075, "display_100": 50.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.75, "display_100": 47.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.03625, "median_1_10": 4.1375, "q1_1_10": 3.753125, "q3_1_10": 4.33125, "range_1_10": [ 3.525, 4.425 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3424001273688756, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.1375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.1375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 1.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3843094872121411, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.2, "display_100": 42.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.125, "display_100": 41.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.525, "display_100": 35.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.6875, "display_100": 36.875, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.15, "display_100": 41.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 3.95, "display_100": 39.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.375, "display_100": 43.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.375, "display_100": 43.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.425, "display_100": 44.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 3.55, "display_100": 35.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 3.29875, "median_1_10": 2.9937500000000004, "q1_1_10": 2.90625, "q3_1_10": 3.84375, "range_1_10": [ 2.8, 3.975 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5141217565475669, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 2.9937500000000004 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 2.9937500000000004 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 3.01875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 1.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5729262626750214, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 3.95, "display_100": 39.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 2.9, "display_100": 29.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 2.925, "display_100": 29.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.0375, "display_100": 30.375, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 2.8, "display_100": 28.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 3.875, "display_100": 38.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 3.75, "display_100": 37.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 2.95, "display_100": 29.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 2.825, "display_100": 28.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 3.975, "display_100": 39.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 3.01875 } } ] }, "international_stature": { "label": "International stature", "weights": [ 20.0, 15.0, 15.0, 15.0, 10.0, 25.0 ], "assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.485, "median_1_10": 8.5125, "q1_1_10": 8.162500000000001, "q3_1_10": 8.71875, "range_1_10": [ 7.95, 9.2 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.40486623305317343, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.5125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.5125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.5125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 1.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 1.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4054741138191383, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.700000000000001, "display_100": 87.00000000000001, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.725, "display_100": 87.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.875, "display_100": 88.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.6, "display_100": 86.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 9.2, "display_100": 92.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.5125 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 8.347083333333334, "median_1_10": 8.35, "q1_1_10": 8.275, "q3_1_10": 8.4, "range_1_10": [ 8.0, 8.775 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.12760657653643928, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.35 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.35 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.35, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.10349223848432301, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.55, "display_100": 85.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.625, "display_100": 86.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.450000000000001, "display_100": 84.50000000000001, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.65, "display_100": 86.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.55, "display_100": 85.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.7, "display_100": 87.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.775, "display_100": 87.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.200000000000001, "display_100": 82.00000000000001, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.7, "display_100": 87.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.575000000000001, "display_100": 85.75000000000001, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.450000000000001, "display_100": 84.50000000000001, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.450000000000001, "display_100": 84.50000000000001, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.200000000000001, "display_100": 82.00000000000001, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.6, "display_100": 86.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.450000000000001, "display_100": 84.50000000000001, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.6, "display_100": 86.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.200000000000001, "display_100": 82.00000000000001, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.35 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.165, "median_1_10": 8.2, "q1_1_10": 8.112499999999999, "q3_1_10": 8.287500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.775, 8.375 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17448336437736536, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.2 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.2 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.25, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 1.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 1.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8433049895610693, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.25 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "sample_count": 120, "mean_1_10": 8.207083333333333, "median_1_10": 8.212499999999999, "q1_1_10": 8.15, "q3_1_10": 8.275, "range_1_10": [ 7.7, 8.575 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.14703595760606195, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.212499999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.212499999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 1.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.12241118355623574, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 0.5, "2": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.45, "display_100": 84.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.4, "display_100": 84.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.475, "display_100": 84.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.55, "display_100": 85.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.35, "display_100": 83.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.5, "display_100": 85.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.425, "display_100": 84.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.375, "display_100": 83.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.575, "display_100": 85.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 8.205, "median_1_10": 8.1875, "q1_1_10": 8.0625, "q3_1_10": 8.293750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 8.0, 8.575 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17232076034083746, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.1875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.1875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 8.1375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 1.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.25807356757016087, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.575, "display_100": 85.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "1": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.325, "display_100": 83.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.3, "display_100": 83.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 8.1375 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.99, "median_1_10": 7.975, "q1_1_10": 7.831250000000001, "q3_1_10": 8.162500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.725, 8.25 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18937030155520992, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.975 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.975 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.975, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 1.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8625846217747288, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.25, "display_100": 82.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.975 } }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.882499999999999, "median_1_10": 8.0375, "q1_1_10": 7.549999999999999, "q3_1_10": 8.2, "range_1_10": [ 7.25, 8.275 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.4015681068566631, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 8.0375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 8.0375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.95, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 1.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.397879521778099, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.449999999999999, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.275, "display_100": 82.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.2, "display_100": 82.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.95 } }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.8425, "median_1_10": 7.775, "q1_1_10": 7.69375, "q3_1_10": 8.1, "range_1_10": [ 7.45, 8.175 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2806366769409239, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.775 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.775 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.925, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 1.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5932995870932075, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.175, "display_100": 81.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.925 } }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.815, "median_1_10": 7.824999999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.75625, "q3_1_10": 7.86875, "range_1_10": [ 7.65, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.11498792207106881, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.824999999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.824999999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.85, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 1.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2221710728919029, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.85 } }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.765, "median_1_10": 7.7375, "q1_1_10": 7.612499999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.893750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.425, 8.075 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20889923142244674, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.7375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.7375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.7875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 1.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.16448910952515386, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6499999999999995, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.7875 } }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.785, "median_1_10": 7.7625, "q1_1_10": 7.63125, "q3_1_10": 7.9625, "range_1_10": [ 7.475, 8.125 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22766935088705567, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.7625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.7625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.5, "12": 0.5, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.20692649087748438, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.825, "median_1_10": 7.775, "q1_1_10": 7.737500000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.96875, "range_1_10": [ 7.5, 8.15 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19790570145063205, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.775 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.775 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.5, "12": 0.5, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3651049154012998, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.7250000000000005, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 8.15, "display_100": 81.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.7, "median_1_10": 7.65, "q1_1_10": 7.612499999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.76875, "range_1_10": [ 7.525, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.13591255358583404, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.65 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.65 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.5, "14": 0.5, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.08979717966733414, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7749999999999995, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.6499999999999995, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.8875, "median_1_10": 7.85, "q1_1_10": 7.69375, "q3_1_10": 8.06875, "range_1_10": [ 7.625, 8.225 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21834287510956493, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.85 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.85 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.75, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.5, "14": 0.5, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.22288943312205453, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 8.05, "display_100": 80.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.125, "display_100": 81.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.225, "display_100": 82.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.75 } }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.73, "median_1_10": 7.725, "q1_1_10": 7.6375, "q3_1_10": 7.8625, "range_1_10": [ 7.425, 7.95 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.16321424229793466, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.725 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.725 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.7125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 1.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5460865901105619, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.9, "display_100": 79.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.7125 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.6049999999999995, "median_1_10": 7.5, "q1_1_10": 7.3875, "q3_1_10": 7.81875, "range_1_10": [ 7.275, 8.075 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2945806812704759, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6499999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 1.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6248790756602176, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 8.075, "display_100": 80.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.025, "display_100": 80.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "2": 0.5, "3": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6499999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.6, "median_1_10": 7.625, "q1_1_10": 7.55, "q3_1_10": 7.718749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.125, 7.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2064918615560644, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 1.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4553987488189574, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6375 } }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.6925, "median_1_10": 7.65, "q1_1_10": 7.5625, "q3_1_10": 7.8687499999999995, "range_1_10": [ 7.45, 7.925 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.17442365410434185, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.65 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.65 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 1.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2359207059087108, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.925, "display_100": 79.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.405, "median_1_10": 7.5125, "q1_1_10": 7.356249999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.525, "range_1_10": [ 6.875, 7.725 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.27151836442904237, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.525, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.5, "20": 0.5, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8113663418360818, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.525 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.445, "median_1_10": 7.5, "q1_1_10": 7.425, "q3_1_10": 7.543749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.075, 7.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20776589389663241, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.525, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.5, "20": 0.5, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.331393392119469, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.7, "display_100": 77.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.525 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.5825, "median_1_10": 7.5875, "q1_1_10": 7.39375, "q3_1_10": 7.74375, "range_1_10": [ 7.25, 7.95 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22516968909888582, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.4875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 1.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.31285997555729955, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.95, "display_100": 79.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.4875 } }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.47, "median_1_10": 7.425000000000001, "q1_1_10": 7.375, "q3_1_10": 7.5, "range_1_10": [ 7.125, 7.875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21660255461712963, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.425000000000001 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.425000000000001 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.475, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.5, "23": 0.5, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8528662727494557, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.7749999999999995, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.475 } }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.425, "median_1_10": 7.4875, "q1_1_10": 7.406250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.543749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.025, 7.675 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20069324297987146, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.475, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.5, "23": 0.5, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6402084416452514, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.475 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.2875, "median_1_10": 7.375, "q1_1_10": 7.1125, "q3_1_10": 7.45, "range_1_10": [ 6.9, 7.5249999999999995 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2337050610396692, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.45, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 1.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.0030757497838677494, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5249999999999995, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.45 } }, { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.485, "median_1_10": 7.425, "q1_1_10": 7.3125, "q3_1_10": 7.643750000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.2, 7.875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24042785935817745, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.425 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.425 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.425, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.5, "26": 0.5, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.39240605645019416, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.875, "display_100": 78.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.425 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.5, "median_1_10": 7.5, "q1_1_10": 7.3875, "q3_1_10": 7.593749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 7.25, 7.775 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.15679073101855664, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.5 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.425, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.5, "26": 0.5, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7240169846723264, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.775, "display_100": 77.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.425 } }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.455, "median_1_10": 7.4125, "q1_1_10": 7.2437499999999995, "q3_1_10": 7.61875, "range_1_10": [ 7.075, 8.0 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28910782302340643, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.4125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.4125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3999999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 1.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7990980734941945, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 8.0, "display_100": 80.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3999999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.2875, "median_1_10": 7.35, "q1_1_10": 7.1937500000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.387500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.75, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24867705518961283, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.35 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.35 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 1.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.27996525079237206, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3500000000000005, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.375 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.2775, "median_1_10": 7.3, "q1_1_10": 7.15625, "q3_1_10": 7.3374999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 6.8, 7.825 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2782509858223527, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.3 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.3 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 1.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.24264584452776847, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.825, "display_100": 78.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.5249999999999995, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3375 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.245, "median_1_10": 7.275, "q1_1_10": 7.156250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.4375, "range_1_10": [ 6.55, 7.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28838631497813255, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.275 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.275 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.3, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 1.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2153686509760601, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.45, "display_100": 74.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.3 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.3075, "median_1_10": 7.262499999999999, "q1_1_10": 7.1625000000000005, "q3_1_10": 7.45, "range_1_10": [ 6.725, 8.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.38712795760001045, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.262499999999999 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.262499999999999 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.275, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.5, "32": 0.5, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4412838958787944, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 8.1, "display_100": 81.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "2": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.275 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.202500000000001, "median_1_10": 7.175, "q1_1_10": 7.09375, "q3_1_10": 7.362500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 6.875, 7.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.19092246826628054, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.175 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.175 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.275, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.5, "32": 0.5, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.13625152748845698, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.275 } }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.335, "median_1_10": 7.2875, "q1_1_10": 7.13125, "q3_1_10": 7.5375, "range_1_10": [ 6.85, 7.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.30983866769659335, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2749999999999995, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 1.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6426472127123211, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.75, "display_100": 77.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.8, "display_100": 78.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2749999999999995 } }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.215, "median_1_10": 7.2625, "q1_1_10": 7.156250000000001, "q3_1_10": 7.275, "range_1_10": [ 6.6, 7.675 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.283137187007759, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 1.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.36212145791279227, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.675, "display_100": 76.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2625 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.3575, "median_1_10": 7.425, "q1_1_10": 7.1, "q3_1_10": 7.543749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.95, 7.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3055164116341016, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.425 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.425 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.225, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 1.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5324780275840126, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.35, "display_100": 73.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.5, "display_100": 75.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.65, "display_100": 76.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.55, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.525, "display_100": 75.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.225 } }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.37, "median_1_10": 7.2875, "q1_1_10": 7.25, "q3_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "range_1_10": [ 7.125, 7.625 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18096961070853868, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.5, "37": 0.5, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.20636993658535385, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.3, "display_100": 73.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.475, "display_100": 74.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.6000000000000005, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.625, "display_100": 76.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.25, "display_100": 72.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2125 } }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.24, "median_1_10": 7.2125, "q1_1_10": 7.01875, "q3_1_10": 7.3999999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 6.7, 7.85 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3590496715869081, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.2125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.2125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.5, "37": 0.5, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2904770316432949, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.85, "display_100": 78.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.725, "display_100": 77.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "3": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.225, "display_100": 72.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2125 } }, { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.215, "median_1_10": 7.1875, "q1_1_10": 7.09375, "q3_1_10": 7.29375, "range_1_10": [ 7.0, 7.575 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.16964014199999297, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.1875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.1875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.2, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 1.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.47288454260009394, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 0.5, "7": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.575, "display_100": 75.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.2 } }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.1325, "median_1_10": 7.125, "q1_1_10": 7.05, "q3_1_10": 7.29375, "range_1_10": [ 6.625, 7.425 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23542219757514612, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.075, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.5, "40": 0.5, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4219453634528708, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.4, "display_100": 74.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.425, "display_100": 74.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.075 } }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.005, "median_1_10": 7.025, "q1_1_10": 6.88125, "q3_1_10": 7.15, "range_1_10": [ 6.675, 7.275 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1843908891458579, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.025 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.025 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.075, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.5, "40": 0.5, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5866825431752907, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.075 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.075, "median_1_10": 7.0125, "q1_1_10": 7.0, "q3_1_10": 7.075, "range_1_10": [ 6.875, 7.550000000000001 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.18408935028645454, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.0125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.0125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.0375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 1.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.2329595729948132, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.0, "display_100": 70.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.550000000000001, "display_100": 75.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.0375 } }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 7.0, "median_1_10": 7.075, "q1_1_10": 6.893749999999999, "q3_1_10": 7.16875, "range_1_10": [ 6.45, 7.375 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.27259045389660214, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 7.075 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 7.075 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 7.025, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 1.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.41626331952499496, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.375, "display_100": 73.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "4": 0.5, "5": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.2, "display_100": 72.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.075, "display_100": 70.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 7.025 } }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.915, "median_1_10": 6.9125, "q1_1_10": 6.7125, "q3_1_10": 7.10625, "range_1_10": [ 6.625, 7.275 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.23605554901806952, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.9125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.9125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.825, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.5, "44": 0.5, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3927294718594988, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.275, "display_100": 72.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.175, "display_100": 71.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8999999999999995, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.825 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.72, "median_1_10": 6.8125, "q1_1_10": 6.781250000000001, "q3_1_10": 6.8999999999999995, "range_1_10": [ 6.075, 7.05 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.32570436492827864, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.8125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.8125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.825, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.5, "44": 0.5, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5251511547153536, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.825 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.875, "median_1_10": 6.8875, "q1_1_10": 6.71875, "q3_1_10": 7.1, "range_1_10": [ 6.35, 7.325 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3000000000000001, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.8875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.8875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 1.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.4722448147213713, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.325, "display_100": 73.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "4": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 7.025, "display_100": 70.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.71, "median_1_10": 6.7875, "q1_1_10": 6.60625, "q3_1_10": 6.8812500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.075, 6.95 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25932604959779876, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.7875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.7875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.7625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 1.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.39324255560891014, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.95, "display_100": 69.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.775, "display_100": 67.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.925, "display_100": 69.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.7625 } }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.65, "median_1_10": 6.65, "q1_1_10": 6.50625, "q3_1_10": 6.7875, "range_1_10": [ 6.3, 7.125 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24181030214244847, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.65 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.65 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.5, "48": 0.5, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.8148497342982555, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.375, "display_100": 63.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 7.125, "display_100": 71.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.5225, "median_1_10": 6.5, "q1_1_10": 6.293750000000001, "q3_1_10": 6.7875, "range_1_10": [ 6.1, 6.875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.28295317633841827, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.6, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.5, "48": 0.5, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.11907263693568501, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.275, "display_100": 62.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.85, "display_100": 68.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.6 } }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.62, "median_1_10": 6.6625, "q1_1_10": 6.4, "q3_1_10": 6.85, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 6.975 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.2990261972915861, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.6625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.6625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.575, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.3333333333333333, "50": 0.3333333333333333, "51": 0.3333333333333333, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.0024864027566034543, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "5": 0.5, "6": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.6499999999999995, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.975, "display_100": 69.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8999999999999995, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.575 } }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.665, "median_1_10": 6.6375, "q1_1_10": 6.606249999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.718749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.375, 7.1 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.21447610589527208, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.6375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.6375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.575, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.3333333333333333, "50": 0.3333333333333333, "51": 0.3333333333333333, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.04709951377170368, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.375, "display_100": 63.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.65, "display_100": 66.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.1, "display_100": 71.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.625, "display_100": 66.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.875, "display_100": 68.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.375, "display_100": 63.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.575 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.66, "median_1_10": 6.7, "q1_1_10": 6.6000000000000005, "q3_1_10": 6.718749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 6.325, 6.825 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.14249756333199362, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.7 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.7 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.575, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.3333333333333333, "50": 0.3333333333333333, "51": 0.3333333333333333, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3969918940252507, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.825, "display_100": 68.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.675, "display_100": 66.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.7, "display_100": 67.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.575 } }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.484999999999999, "median_1_10": 6.5375, "q1_1_10": 6.481249999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.575, "range_1_10": [ 5.975, 6.725 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20385179801894215, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.5375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.5375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.5375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 1.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7317075758610457, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.975, "display_100": 59.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.475, "display_100": 64.75, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.6, "display_100": 66.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.575, "display_100": 65.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.725, "display_100": 67.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.5375 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.4225, "median_1_10": 6.3875, "q1_1_10": 6.2625, "q3_1_10": 6.4875, "range_1_10": [ 6.15, 6.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.22865852755194188, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.3875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.3875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 1.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6633332471544192, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.2, "display_100": 62.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.8, "display_100": 68.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.375 } }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.2125, "median_1_10": 6.2625, "q1_1_10": 6.074999999999999, "q3_1_10": 6.35, "range_1_10": [ 5.85, 6.5 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20858318351306382, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.2625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.2625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.2375, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 1.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.3449760821472266, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.5, "display_100": 65.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.85, "display_100": 58.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.275, "display_100": 62.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.2375 } }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.125, "median_1_10": 6.15, "q1_1_10": 5.7625, "q3_1_10": 6.481250000000001, "range_1_10": [ 5.0, 6.9 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5925462944877059, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.15 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.15 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.1875, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 1.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.07577817893542171, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.8999999999999995, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.9, "display_100": 69.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.35, "display_100": 63.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.625, "display_100": 56.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.1875 } }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.3, "median_1_10": 6.2875, "q1_1_10": 6.1875, "q3_1_10": 6.3812500000000005, "range_1_10": [ 6.125, 6.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.1348867838019888, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.2875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.2875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.175, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 1.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5487824635479849, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.4, "display_100": 64.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.225, "display_100": 62.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.275, "display_100": 62.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.175 } }, { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.0625, "median_1_10": 6.0625, "q1_1_10": 5.925000000000001, "q3_1_10": 6.137500000000001, "range_1_10": [ 5.7, 6.45 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.24388351044436485, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.1125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 1.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6368936625610326, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.075, "display_100": 60.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.0, "display_100": 60.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.775, "display_100": 57.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.05, "display_100": 60.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.45, "display_100": 64.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.425, "display_100": 64.25, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.9, "display_100": 59.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.1125 } }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.79, "median_1_10": 6.0625, "q1_1_10": 5.2749999999999995, "q3_1_10": 6.1625, "range_1_10": [ 4.525, 6.75 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.711727163704994, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.0625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.0625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.05, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 1.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.7054858074731774, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.95, "display_100": 59.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.025, "display_100": 60.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.175, "display_100": 61.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.525, "display_100": 45.25, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.3, "display_100": 63.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 6.75, "display_100": 67.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.1, "display_100": 61.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.05, "display_100": 50.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.05 } }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 6.0975, "median_1_10": 6.1375, "q1_1_10": 5.781250000000001, "q3_1_10": 6.30625, "range_1_10": [ 5.725, 6.55 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.31938526021788244, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 6.1375 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 6.1375 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 6.0125, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 1.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.18194109301060715, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.725, "display_100": 57.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.15, "display_100": 61.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.325, "display_100": 63.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 6.525, "display_100": 65.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 6.25, "display_100": 62.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.775, "display_100": 57.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 6.125, "display_100": 61.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 6.55, "display_100": 65.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 6.0125 } }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.5775, "median_1_10": 5.65, "q1_1_10": 5.425, "q3_1_10": 5.74375, "range_1_10": [ 5.25, 5.8 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.20997685057590937, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.65 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.65 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.6625, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 1.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.12242531037651236, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.6, "display_100": 56.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.725, "display_100": 57.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.425, "display_100": 54.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.425, "display_100": 54.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.8, "display_100": 58.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.75, "display_100": 57.5, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.25, "display_100": 52.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.6625 } }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.525, "median_1_10": 5.525, "q1_1_10": 5.45, "q3_1_10": 5.60625, "range_1_10": [ 5.3, 5.7 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.12692955176439855, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.525 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.525 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.55, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.5, "62": 0.5, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.11624135559711042, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.425, "display_100": 54.25, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.45, "display_100": 54.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.45, "display_100": 54.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.55, "display_100": 55.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.7, "display_100": 57.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.55, "display_100": 55.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.625, "display_100": 56.25, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 0.5, "8": 0.5 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.55 } }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.4525, "median_1_10": 5.4875, "q1_1_10": 5.34375, "q3_1_10": 5.543749999999999, "range_1_10": [ 4.9, 5.875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.25724231982920515, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.4875 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.4875 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.55, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.5, "62": 0.5, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.5360194873678162, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.475, "display_100": 54.75, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.3, "display_100": 53.0, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.275, "display_100": 52.75, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.875, "display_100": 58.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.55, "display_100": 55.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.525, "display_100": 55.25, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.475, "display_100": 54.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.65, "display_100": 56.5, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "7": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.55 } }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 5.8774999999999995, "median_1_10": 5.55, "q1_1_10": 5.0, "q3_1_10": 6.78125, "range_1_10": [ 4.9, 7.6 ], "sd_all_samples": 1.0249966124605268, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 5.55 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 5.55 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 5.525, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 1.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.6062340091539182, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 7.15, "display_100": 71.5, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 7, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 7.6, "display_100": 76.0, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "3": 0.5, "4": 0.5 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 7.05, "display_100": 70.5, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "5": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.6, "display_100": 56.0, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 6, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 5.5, "display_100": 55.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 5.975, "display_100": 59.75, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 5.525 } }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.7725, "median_1_10": 4.8, "q1_1_10": 4.65625, "q3_1_10": 4.975, "range_1_10": [ 4.1, 5.225 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3107897645962264, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.8 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.8 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.775, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 1.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.49088215404295477, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 5.025, "display_100": 50.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.1, "display_100": 41.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.75, "display_100": 47.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.65, "display_100": 46.5, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.675, "display_100": 46.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.9, "display_100": 49.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 5.0, "display_100": 50.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.85, "display_100": 48.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 5.225, "display_100": 52.25, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.55, "display_100": 45.5, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.775 } }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 4.495, "median_1_10": 4.6625, "q1_1_10": 4.20625, "q3_1_10": 4.74375, "range_1_10": [ 3.9, 4.875 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.3517416981567898, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 4.6625 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 4.6625 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 4.55, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 1.0, "66": 0.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": 0.35339418788327953, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.7, "display_100": 47.0, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.625, "display_100": 46.25, "order_position": 9, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.025, "display_100": 40.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.125, "display_100": 41.25, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.75, "display_100": 47.5, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.45, "display_100": 44.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.725, "display_100": 47.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 4.875, "display_100": 48.75, "order_position": 2, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 4.775, "display_100": 47.75, "order_position": 8, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 3.9, "display_100": 39.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "6": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 4.55 } }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "sample_count": 10, "mean_1_10": 3.6075, "median_1_10": 3.3125, "q1_1_10": 3.2062500000000003, "q3_1_10": 4.13125, "range_1_10": [ 3.125, 4.3 ], "sd_all_samples": 0.5030531781034685, "model_medians": { "openai|gpt-5.6-sol": 3.3125 }, "family_medians": { "openai": 3.3125 }, "ensemble_family_median_1_10": 3.325, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "6": 0.0, "7": 0.0, "8": 0.0, "9": 0.0, "10": 0.0, "11": 0.0, "12": 0.0, "13": 0.0, "14": 0.0, "15": 0.0, "16": 0.0, "17": 0.0, "18": 0.0, "19": 0.0, "20": 0.0, "21": 0.0, "22": 0.0, "23": 0.0, "24": 0.0, "25": 0.0, "26": 0.0, "27": 0.0, "28": 0.0, "29": 0.0, "30": 0.0, "31": 0.0, "32": 0.0, "33": 0.0, "34": 0.0, "35": 0.0, "36": 0.0, "37": 0.0, "38": 0.0, "39": 0.0, "40": 0.0, "41": 0.0, "42": 0.0, "43": 0.0, "44": 0.0, "45": 0.0, "46": 0.0, "47": 0.0, "48": 0.0, "49": 0.0, "50": 0.0, "51": 0.0, "52": 0.0, "53": 0.0, "54": 0.0, "55": 0.0, "56": 0.0, "57": 0.0, "58": 0.0, "59": 0.0, "60": 0.0, "61": 0.0, "62": 0.0, "63": 0.0, "64": 0.0, "65": 0.0, "66": 1.0 }, "rank1_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "order_score_correlation": -0.5543344307093081, "distribution": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.25, "display_100": 42.5, "order_position": 1, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 3.2, "display_100": 32.0, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.225, "display_100": 32.25, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.35, "display_100": 33.5, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 3.175, "display_100": 31.75, "order_position": 11, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "total_1_10": 4.175, "display_100": 41.75, "order_position": 5, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "total_1_10": 4.0, "display_100": 40.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "total_1_10": 3.275, "display_100": 32.75, "order_position": 10, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "total_1_10": 3.125, "display_100": 31.25, "order_position": 3, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "model_family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "total_1_10": 4.3, "display_100": 43.0, "order_position": 4, "rank_weights": { "8": 1.0 } } ], "linked_family_totals": { "openai": 3.325 } } ] } }, "calibration": { "items": [ { "control_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "expected_range": [ 8, 10 ], "observed": 10.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "expected_range": [ 7, 10 ], "observed": 9.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "expected_range": [ 7, 10 ], "observed": 9.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "expected_range": [ 7, 10 ], "observed": 9.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "expected_range": [ 7, 10 ], "observed": 9.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-consensus-guardian", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "expected_range": [ 7, 10 ], "observed": 9.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "expected_range": [ 1, 4 ], "observed": 3.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "expected_range": [ 1, 3 ], "observed": 2.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "expected_range": [ 1, 4 ], "observed": 2.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "expected_range": [ 3, 7 ], "observed": 4.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "expected_range": [ 1, 4 ], "observed": 2.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-partisan-celebrity", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "expected_range": [ 6, 9 ], "observed": 7.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "expected_range": [ 4, 7 ], "observed": 5.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "political_independence", "expected_range": [ 5, 8 ], "observed": 7.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "expected_range": [ 3, 6 ], "observed": 5.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "expected_range": [ 4, 7 ], "observed": 5.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "expected_range": [ 5, 8 ], "observed": 7.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 }, { "control_id": "control-unknown-technocrat", "criterion_id": "international_representation", "expected_range": [ 1, 4 ], "observed": 3.0, "in_range": true, "distance_to_range": 0.0 } ], "pass_count": 18, "total_count": 18, "pass_rate": 1.0 }, "variance_summary": { "median_within_model_sd": 0.4216370213557839, "median_between_model_sd": 0.0, "median_prompt_sensitivity": 0.0 }, "study_version": "v5-block", "block_linkage": { "enabled": true, "common_anchor_ids": [ "peter-paczolay", "katalin-kariko" ], "effects": [ { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 6.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": 0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-01-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-01", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": 0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-02-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-02", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": 0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-03-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-03", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": -0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-04-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-04", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": 0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-05-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-05", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": -0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-06-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-06", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": -0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 6.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-07-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-07", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": 0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-08-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-08", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": -0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-09-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-09", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": -0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-10-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-10", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": 0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-11-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-11", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.25, "estimated_block_offset": -0.25 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-direct_anchored-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "direct_anchored", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r01", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 1, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r02", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 2, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r03", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 3, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -1.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r04", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 4, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "constitutional_guardianship", "anchor_mean_raw": 7.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "political_independence", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "capacity_to_unite", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.0, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "public_trust_integrity", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.5, "stratum_anchor_median": 8.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.0 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "institutional_leadership", "anchor_mean_raw": 8.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 7.5, "estimated_block_offset": 0.5 }, { "run_id": "scorer-codex-sol-v5-v5-block-12-reflective_independent-r05", "block_id": "v5-block-12", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_variant": "reflective_independent", "repetition": 5, "criterion_id": "international_representation", "anchor_mean_raw": 9.0, "stratum_anchor_median": 9.5, "estimated_block_offset": -0.5 } ] } }, "robustness": { "method": "external Dirichlet weight sensitivity over equal-family criterion medians", "status": "ok", "draws": 10000, "weight_concentration": 80.0, "candidates": [ { "candidate_id": "andras-baka", "top_probability": 0.9147, "top3_probability": 0.9998999999999999, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.9147, "2": 0.0836, "3": 0.0016, "6": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 8.311069223159848, "median_total_1_10": 8.39599356227223, "q3_total_1_10": 8.474641118937333 }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-kariko", "top_probability": 0.0851, "top3_probability": 0.6541, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0851, "2": 0.471, "3": 0.098, "4": 0.0759, "5": 0.0697, "6": 0.1089, "7": 0.0468, "8": 0.0201, "9": 0.0114, "10": 0.0057, "11": 0.0046, "12": 0.0016, "13": 0.0004, "14": 0.0005, "17": 0.0002, "18": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.9358225343013595, "median_total_1_10": 8.054062503457086, "q3_total_1_10": 8.165369392915048 }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-korosi", "top_probability": 0.0002, "top3_probability": 0.1187, "rank_probabilities": { "1": 0.0002, "2": 0.0072, "3": 0.1113, "4": 0.1354, "5": 0.1684, "6": 0.1601, "7": 0.1837, "8": 0.0834, "9": 0.0604, "10": 0.043, "11": 0.03, "12": 0.0128, "13": 0.0031, "14": 0.0004, "15": 0.0004, "16": 0.0001, "17": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.775692412545257, "median_total_1_10": 7.846827698688674, "q3_total_1_10": 7.921629274426021 }, { "candidate_id": "adam-fischer", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "25": 0.0006, "26": 0.0012, "27": 0.0032, "28": 0.0053, "29": 0.0113, "30": 0.0167, "31": 0.0187, "32": 0.0382, "33": 0.0573, "34": 0.0562, "35": 0.0534, "36": 0.0791, "37": 0.1337, "38": 0.1664, "39": 0.1507, "40": 0.0876, "41": 0.0754, "42": 0.038, "43": 0.007 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.982911887048672, "median_total_1_10": 7.0477157884743615, "q3_total_1_10": 7.11824162135579 }, { "candidate_id": "albert-laszlo-barabasi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "7": 0.0017, "8": 0.0037, "9": 0.0216, "10": 0.0391, "11": 0.0436, "12": 0.0774, "13": 0.3516, "14": 0.2291, "15": 0.0436, "16": 0.0619, "17": 0.064, "18": 0.0221, "19": 0.018, "20": 0.0092, "21": 0.0068, "22": 0.004, "23": 0.0013, "24": 0.0006, "25": 0.0004, "26": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.4752563578584, "median_total_1_10": 7.551355053383004, "q3_total_1_10": 7.62536415327377 }, { "candidate_id": "andras-sajo", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.3788, "rank_probabilities": { "2": 0.0922, "3": 0.2866, "4": 0.2956, "5": 0.1657, "6": 0.0567, "7": 0.0307, "8": 0.0287, "9": 0.0215, "10": 0.0088, "11": 0.0102, "12": 0.0026, "13": 0.0006, "14": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.873288277737665, "median_total_1_10": 7.955742124782448, "q3_total_1_10": 8.03461430001227 }, { "candidate_id": "attila-chikan", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "13": 0.0012, "14": 0.0212, "15": 0.092, "16": 0.1078, "17": 0.1498, "18": 0.1747, "19": 0.0933, "20": 0.0841, "21": 0.0828, "22": 0.0686, "23": 0.0393, "24": 0.0339, "25": 0.0227, "26": 0.0133, "27": 0.0085, "28": 0.0039, "29": 0.0017, "30": 0.0009, "31": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.336727008642965, "median_total_1_10": 7.373589056286298, "q3_total_1_10": 7.41143486800956 }, { "candidate_id": "balazs-gulyas", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "57": 0.0012, "58": 0.7481, "59": 0.2283, "60": 0.0183, "61": 0.0041 }, "q1_total_1_10": 5.519696720187112, "median_total_1_10": 5.593733149163991, "q3_total_1_10": 5.675287951433543 }, { "candidate_id": "bela-merkely", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "51": 0.0001, "52": 0.0012, "53": 0.0036, "54": 0.0269, "55": 0.041, "56": 0.0853, "57": 0.8418, "58": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 5.767521943301527, "median_total_1_10": 5.844326861099994, "q3_total_1_10": 5.927642519102019 }, { "candidate_id": "botond-roska", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.02, "rank_probabilities": { "3": 0.02, "4": 0.0351, "5": 0.0405, "6": 0.0797, "7": 0.0863, "8": 0.0887, "9": 0.0971, "10": 0.1111, "11": 0.1322, "12": 0.1543, "13": 0.0912, "14": 0.0255, "15": 0.0112, "16": 0.0224, "17": 0.0024, "18": 0.0014, "19": 0.0005, "21": 0.0003, "23": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.631333781565299, "median_total_1_10": 7.714295587420866, "q3_total_1_10": 7.794332150174568 }, { "candidate_id": "cecilia-muller", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "62": 0.0393, "63": 0.0463, "64": 0.9144 }, "q1_total_1_10": 4.581664582056567, "median_total_1_10": 4.644121534572074, "q3_total_1_10": 4.714108917387553 }, { "candidate_id": "csaba-pleh", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "22": 0.0001, "23": 0.0001, "24": 0.0008, "25": 0.0012, "26": 0.0024, "27": 0.0052, "28": 0.0102, "29": 0.0124, "30": 0.0229, "31": 0.0341, "32": 0.0486, "33": 0.0543, "34": 0.0874, "35": 0.0904, "36": 0.1085, "37": 0.1524, "38": 0.1406, "39": 0.1081, "40": 0.0701, "41": 0.0321, "42": 0.0134, "43": 0.0037, "44": 0.0009, "45": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.017365708772702, "median_total_1_10": 7.075876616657467, "q3_total_1_10": 7.1320133786968185 }, { "candidate_id": "diana-urge-vorsatz", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "14": 0.0011, "15": 0.0023, "16": 0.0382, "17": 0.0439, "18": 0.045, "19": 0.0753, "20": 0.0815, "21": 0.0926, "22": 0.0868, "23": 0.1126, "24": 0.1006, "25": 0.1162, "26": 0.0665, "27": 0.0492, "28": 0.0423, "29": 0.0272, "30": 0.0124, "31": 0.0058, "32": 0.0004, "33": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.230004558886206, "median_total_1_10": 7.299843130267751, "q3_total_1_10": 7.368943578085459 }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-bollobas", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "20": 0.0001, "21": 0.0003, "22": 0.0016, "23": 0.0027, "24": 0.0081, "25": 0.013, "26": 0.0249, "27": 0.0309, "28": 0.0499, "29": 0.0708, "30": 0.1054, "31": 0.0901, "32": 0.0953, "33": 0.101, "34": 0.1274, "35": 0.1423, "36": 0.0803, "37": 0.0352, "38": 0.0147, "39": 0.0041, "40": 0.0011, "41": 0.0005, "42": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.074281531360549, "median_total_1_10": 7.139091118646685, "q3_total_1_10": 7.202007017557992 }, { "candidate_id": "eniko-gyori", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "60": 0.001, "61": 0.0013, "62": 0.1623, "63": 0.7581, "64": 0.0773 }, "q1_total_1_10": 4.73488373718093, "median_total_1_10": 4.8701214844714515, "q3_total_1_10": 5.014122789187722 }, { "candidate_id": "erno-rubik", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.001, "rank_probabilities": { "2": 0.0003, "3": 0.0007, "4": 0.0039, "5": 0.0035, "6": 0.0047, "7": 0.0065, "8": 0.0156, "9": 0.0201, "10": 0.022, "11": 0.0254, "12": 0.0311, "13": 0.0592, "14": 0.1805, "15": 0.1188, "16": 0.0324, "17": 0.0521, "18": 0.0577, "19": 0.0412, "20": 0.0397, "21": 0.0247, "22": 0.0364, "23": 0.0281, "24": 0.0289, "25": 0.0198, "26": 0.0209, "27": 0.0139, "28": 0.015, "29": 0.0176, "30": 0.0156, "31": 0.0197, "32": 0.0161, "33": 0.0087, "34": 0.0051, "35": 0.0035, "36": 0.0023, "37": 0.0018, "38": 0.0019, "39": 0.0019, "40": 0.0006, "41": 0.0006, "42": 0.0006, "43": 0.0003, "44": 0.0003, "45": 0.0001, "46": 0.0001, "47": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.305162498751224, "median_total_1_10": 7.439748550042076, "q3_total_1_10": 7.567831899471223 }, { "candidate_id": "eva-kondorosi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "4": 0.0021, "5": 0.0203, "6": 0.0641, "7": 0.1176, "8": 0.1519, "9": 0.1952, "10": 0.1989, "11": 0.1518, "12": 0.07, "13": 0.0155, "14": 0.0064, "15": 0.0059, "16": 0.0002, "17": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.66269901971484, "median_total_1_10": 7.72683107112624, "q3_total_1_10": 7.788128897595573 }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-bojar", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "20": 0.0004, "21": 0.0007, "22": 0.0022, "23": 0.0049, "24": 0.0093, "25": 0.0165, "26": 0.0331, "27": 0.0489, "28": 0.0514, "29": 0.0532, "30": 0.0772, "31": 0.1097, "32": 0.0716, "33": 0.068, "34": 0.0889, "35": 0.1054, "36": 0.1206, "37": 0.075, "38": 0.0421, "39": 0.0148, "40": 0.0048, "41": 0.0012, "42": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.076851105694715, "median_total_1_10": 7.139232678317871, "q3_total_1_10": 7.200802602643603 }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-halmai", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "6": 0.0001, "7": 0.0006, "8": 0.0021, "9": 0.0064, "10": 0.0097, "11": 0.0155, "12": 0.0162, "13": 0.0268, "14": 0.1059, "15": 0.0537, "16": 0.0575, "17": 0.0545, "18": 0.0808, "19": 0.056, "20": 0.0606, "21": 0.0363, "22": 0.0397, "23": 0.0451, "24": 0.0559, "25": 0.0341, "26": 0.0302, "27": 0.0304, "28": 0.0324, "29": 0.0197, "30": 0.0181, "31": 0.019, "32": 0.014, "33": 0.0136, "34": 0.0177, "35": 0.0167, "36": 0.0119, "37": 0.0097, "38": 0.0044, "39": 0.0026, "40": 0.0011, "41": 0.0009, "42": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.251034055036607, "median_total_1_10": 7.357641062284804, "q3_total_1_10": 7.457402262504283 }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-ivanyi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "14": 0.0001, "16": 0.0011, "17": 0.0038, "18": 0.0047, "19": 0.013, "20": 0.0265, "21": 0.0109, "22": 0.0284, "23": 0.0337, "24": 0.0244, "25": 0.0284, "26": 0.0366, "27": 0.0402, "28": 0.0619, "29": 0.0601, "30": 0.0566, "31": 0.0619, "32": 0.0477, "33": 0.0503, "34": 0.0515, "35": 0.0454, "36": 0.072, "37": 0.0764, "38": 0.0626, "39": 0.0698, "40": 0.0285, "41": 0.0029, "42": 0.0006 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.092994210249788, "median_total_1_10": 7.153111963027746, "q3_total_1_10": 7.211736127507157 }, { "candidate_id": "gabor-torok", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "28": 0.0004, "29": 0.0008, "30": 0.0008, "31": 0.0015, "32": 0.0022, "33": 0.002, "34": 0.0039, "35": 0.0077, "36": 0.0113, "37": 0.0163, "38": 0.0166, "39": 0.0412, "40": 0.06, "41": 0.1215, "42": 0.1988, "43": 0.3653, "44": 0.0547, "45": 0.0384, "46": 0.0245, "47": 0.0227, "48": 0.0068, "49": 0.0019, "50": 0.0007 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.810555177345803, "median_total_1_10": 6.8774283360911435, "q3_total_1_10": 6.9390883206024085 }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-buzsaki", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "9": 0.0003, "10": 0.0001, "11": 0.0025, "12": 0.0033, "13": 0.0079, "14": 0.0588, "15": 0.1837, "16": 0.1239, "17": 0.079, "18": 0.0899, "19": 0.0887, "20": 0.0732, "21": 0.0568, "22": 0.0565, "23": 0.0638, "24": 0.0315, "25": 0.0234, "26": 0.018, "27": 0.0132, "28": 0.0102, "29": 0.0061, "30": 0.005, "31": 0.003, "32": 0.0007, "33": 0.0001, "34": 0.0002, "35": 0.0002 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.302931128030802, "median_total_1_10": 7.389621219241501, "q3_total_1_10": 7.473006859503762 }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-suranyi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "14": 0.0001, "16": 0.0007, "17": 0.0004, "18": 0.0016, "19": 0.0033, "20": 0.0051, "21": 0.0089, "22": 0.024, "23": 0.0258, "24": 0.0315, "25": 0.0444, "26": 0.0556, "27": 0.046, "28": 0.0498, "29": 0.0649, "30": 0.074, "31": 0.0566, "32": 0.043, "33": 0.05, "34": 0.053, "35": 0.0629, "36": 0.0618, "37": 0.0809, "38": 0.0645, "39": 0.0532, "40": 0.0276, "41": 0.0099, "42": 0.0005 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.0820939526217, "median_total_1_10": 7.148739779099734, "q3_total_1_10": 7.215582800465986 }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-szapary", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "43": 0.0001, "44": 0.0001, "45": 0.0003, "46": 0.0022, "47": 0.0033, "48": 0.0095, "49": 0.0606, "50": 0.0908, "51": 0.1147, "52": 0.1745, "53": 0.2548, "54": 0.1521, "55": 0.112, "56": 0.025 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.097610595449948, "median_total_1_10": 6.194691718497071, "q3_total_1_10": 6.297234649585918 }, { "candidate_id": "gyorgy-tilesch", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "46": 0.0014, "47": 0.0029, "48": 0.0064, "49": 0.0292, "50": 0.1386, "51": 0.1425, "52": 0.1581, "53": 0.1597, "54": 0.126, "55": 0.1794, "56": 0.0555, "57": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.126830342319083, "median_total_1_10": 6.1966944352701425, "q3_total_1_10": 6.27022276941116 }, { "candidate_id": "ignac-romsics", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "16": 0.0001, "17": 0.0019, "18": 0.0087, "19": 0.0334, "20": 0.0563, "21": 0.0942, "22": 0.0943, "23": 0.0698, "24": 0.0759, "25": 0.0785, "26": 0.1055, "27": 0.0973, "28": 0.082, "29": 0.058, "30": 0.0629, "31": 0.0385, "32": 0.0209, "33": 0.0135, "34": 0.0038, "35": 0.0025, "36": 0.0014, "37": 0.0005, "38": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.203853885092769, "median_total_1_10": 7.2509549120748105, "q3_total_1_10": 7.296639089720714 }, { "candidate_id": "ildiko-enyedi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "16": 0.0001, "17": 0.0003, "18": 0.0021, "19": 0.0066, "20": 0.0092, "21": 0.0115, "22": 0.0201, "23": 0.0249, "24": 0.0422, "25": 0.0551, "26": 0.067, "27": 0.0718, "28": 0.0814, "29": 0.0979, "30": 0.0776, "31": 0.0847, "32": 0.0983, "33": 0.0811, "34": 0.0509, "35": 0.0341, "36": 0.0281, "37": 0.0232, "38": 0.0171, "39": 0.0088, "40": 0.004, "41": 0.0011, "42": 0.0004, "43": 0.0004 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.0970719921892105, "median_total_1_10": 7.175549736086694, "q3_total_1_10": 7.253800481921959 }, { "candidate_id": "ilona-palne-kovacs", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "25": 0.0003, "26": 0.0001, "27": 0.0015, "28": 0.0014, "29": 0.0017, "30": 0.0031, "31": 0.003, "32": 0.012, "33": 0.0232, "34": 0.0197, "35": 0.0151, "36": 0.0226, "37": 0.0411, "38": 0.1023, "39": 0.1412, "40": 0.2254, "41": 0.2323, "42": 0.1173, "43": 0.0279, "44": 0.007, "45": 0.0016, "46": 0.0002 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.92085191838907, "median_total_1_10": 6.975406161837747, "q3_total_1_10": 7.029858325546205 }, { "candidate_id": "imre-voros", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "6": 0.0122, "7": 0.0063, "8": 0.0148, "9": 0.0332, "10": 0.0368, "11": 0.0379, "12": 0.0531, "13": 0.2068, "14": 0.128, "15": 0.1121, "16": 0.1001, "17": 0.0347, "18": 0.0321, "19": 0.0248, "20": 0.0226, "21": 0.0246, "22": 0.0196, "23": 0.0296, "24": 0.0175, "25": 0.0141, "26": 0.0126, "27": 0.0061, "28": 0.0033, "29": 0.0039, "30": 0.004, "31": 0.0031, "32": 0.002, "33": 0.0014, "34": 0.0007, "35": 0.001, "36": 0.0008, "37": 0.0002 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.4163511535489235, "median_total_1_10": 7.5032559997047255, "q3_total_1_10": 7.587791769514138 }, { "candidate_id": "ivan-fischer", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "10": 0.0001, "11": 0.0001, "12": 0.0004, "13": 0.0006, "14": 0.0061, "15": 0.0139, "16": 0.0421, "17": 0.0418, "18": 0.0667, "19": 0.0644, "20": 0.0785, "21": 0.0906, "22": 0.0921, "23": 0.0845, "24": 0.0877, "25": 0.0685, "26": 0.0685, "27": 0.0659, "28": 0.0438, "29": 0.0357, "30": 0.0205, "31": 0.0112, "32": 0.0074, "33": 0.004, "34": 0.0024, "35": 0.0015, "36": 0.0006, "37": 0.0002, "39": 0.0001, "40": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.222443928266189, "median_total_1_10": 7.299211093875595, "q3_total_1_10": 7.377073449079976 }, { "candidate_id": "janos-martonyi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "35": 0.0002, "36": 0.0001, "37": 0.0001, "38": 0.0004, "39": 0.0005, "40": 0.0006, "41": 0.001, "42": 0.0049, "43": 0.0054, "44": 0.0182, "45": 0.0249, "46": 0.031, "47": 0.0772, "48": 0.2544, "49": 0.2404, "50": 0.1387, "51": 0.0939, "52": 0.0646, "53": 0.0281, "54": 0.0083, "55": 0.0045, "56": 0.0025, "57": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.272510328497788, "median_total_1_10": 6.402636528371469, "q3_total_1_10": 6.536786050220346 }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-palinkas", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "34": 0.0002, "35": 0.0003, "36": 0.0006, "37": 0.0006, "38": 0.0003, "39": 0.0004, "40": 0.0024, "41": 0.007, "42": 0.0144, "43": 0.0243, "44": 0.1492, "45": 0.2801, "46": 0.3682, "47": 0.1413, "48": 0.0106, "49": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.578242104041058, "median_total_1_10": 6.636096631989929, "q3_total_1_10": 6.696630210270669 }, { "candidate_id": "jozsef-peter-martin", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "40": 0.0001, "41": 0.0003, "42": 0.0021, "43": 0.0145, "44": 0.3749, "45": 0.1638, "46": 0.1168, "47": 0.1952, "48": 0.108, "49": 0.0144, "50": 0.0072, "51": 0.0017, "52": 0.001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.574340790049664, "median_total_1_10": 6.653901485244852, "q3_total_1_10": 6.729634873044178 }, { "candidate_id": "julia-kiraly", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "17": 0.0003, "18": 0.0022, "19": 0.0076, "20": 0.0177, "21": 0.0237, "22": 0.0242, "23": 0.0439, "24": 0.065, "25": 0.068, "26": 0.0751, "27": 0.0946, "28": 0.109, "29": 0.0925, "30": 0.0743, "31": 0.0685, "32": 0.0691, "33": 0.0576, "34": 0.0432, "35": 0.0309, "36": 0.0159, "37": 0.013, "38": 0.0034, "39": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.1483904567325105, "median_total_1_10": 7.202853465773014, "q3_total_1_10": 7.255328356701866 }, { "candidate_id": "katalin-bogyay", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "9": 0.0001, "10": 0.00035, "11": 0.0006, "12": 0.0021, "13": 0.0052, "14": 0.0137, "15": 0.02575, "16": 0.0366, "17": 0.04565, "18": 0.05475, "19": 0.06675, "20": 0.0854, "21": 0.0871, "22": 0.079, "23": 0.07755, "24": 0.0657, "25": 0.05765, "26": 0.055, "27": 0.0485, "28": 0.03955, "29": 0.03005, "30": 0.0234, "31": 0.0214, "32": 0.01915, "33": 0.0154, "34": 0.01335, "35": 0.0113, "36": 0.00755, "37": 0.0054, "38": 0.0039, "39": 0.0016, "40": 0.0005 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.223593586871042, "median_total_1_10": 7.292609462561829, "q3_total_1_10": 7.370453505583999 }, { "candidate_id": "kinga-goncz", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "32": 0.0001, "34": 0.0007, "35": 0.0007, "36": 0.0009, "37": 0.0006, "38": 0.001, "39": 0.0033, "40": 0.0058, "41": 0.0141, "42": 0.022, "43": 0.0712, "44": 0.1169, "45": 0.1339, "46": 0.1498, "47": 0.2773, "48": 0.1422, "49": 0.0455, "50": 0.0128, "51": 0.0008, "52": 0.0003, "53": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.502333807763579, "median_total_1_10": 6.603264851987232, "q3_total_1_10": 6.70414980499948 }, { "candidate_id": "kornel-mundruczo", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "43": 0.0004, "44": 0.0025, "45": 0.0172, "46": 0.0146, "47": 0.0236, "48": 0.1025, "49": 0.2206, "50": 0.1867, "51": 0.1064, "52": 0.1246, "53": 0.072, "54": 0.0868, "55": 0.031, "56": 0.0053, "57": 0.0052, "58": 0.0006 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.216670106796899, "median_total_1_10": 6.3017488815166764, "q3_total_1_10": 6.383331140098386 }, { "candidate_id": "laczo-adrienn", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "45": 0.0079, "46": 0.043, "47": 0.1274, "48": 0.3007, "49": 0.2736, "50": 0.0919, "51": 0.0632, "52": 0.0333, "53": 0.0473, "54": 0.009, "55": 0.0021, "56": 0.0005, "58": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.364775081127717, "median_total_1_10": 6.427304472301401, "q3_total_1_10": 6.488386397978241 }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-krasznahorkai", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "20": 0.0004, "21": 0.0006, "22": 0.0006, "23": 0.0014, "24": 0.0024, "25": 0.002, "26": 0.0041, "27": 0.0045, "28": 0.008, "29": 0.0107, "30": 0.0172, "31": 0.0254, "32": 0.0309, "33": 0.0326, "34": 0.034, "35": 0.0414, "36": 0.0453, "37": 0.0598, "38": 0.0897, "39": 0.1194, "40": 0.0864, "41": 0.0729, "42": 0.1419, "43": 0.085, "44": 0.0374, "45": 0.0165, "46": 0.0177, "47": 0.0065, "48": 0.0036, "49": 0.0008, "50": 0.0008, "52": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.899109695759993, "median_total_1_10": 7.0040537832361816, "q3_total_1_10": 7.105005074176201 }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-majtenyi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.1434, "rank_probabilities": { "2": 0.0396, "3": 0.1038, "4": 0.1578, "5": 0.227, "6": 0.165, "7": 0.0646, "8": 0.036, "9": 0.0645, "10": 0.0627, "11": 0.0167, "12": 0.0177, "13": 0.0302, "14": 0.0103, "15": 0.0016, "16": 0.0009, "17": 0.0008, "18": 0.0004, "19": 0.0002, "20": 0.0001, "22": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.788931156289106, "median_total_1_10": 7.879752109195833, "q3_total_1_10": 7.96744121040927 }, { "candidate_id": "laszlo-trocsanyi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "61": 0.0025, "62": 0.7953, "63": 0.1939, "64": 0.0083 }, "q1_total_1_10": 4.7868370120238275, "median_total_1_10": 4.922670561976984, "q3_total_1_10": 5.067309916463967 }, { "candidate_id": "marta-pardavi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0026, "rank_probabilities": { "3": 0.0026, "4": 0.0299, "5": 0.1515, "6": 0.1627, "7": 0.1563, "8": 0.0785, "9": 0.051, "10": 0.0557, "11": 0.0697, "12": 0.0636, "13": 0.0378, "14": 0.0795, "15": 0.036, "16": 0.0061, "17": 0.0062, "18": 0.0035, "19": 0.0022, "20": 0.002, "21": 0.0016, "22": 0.0015, "23": 0.0007, "24": 0.0003, "25": 0.0002, "26": 0.0002, "27": 0.0002, "28": 0.0003, "29": 0.0001, "32": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.668103405187611, "median_total_1_10": 7.783678267526067, "q3_total_1_10": 7.893143068346624 }, { "candidate_id": "miklos-perenyi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "12": 0.0001, "14": 0.0008, "15": 0.0059, "16": 0.009, "17": 0.017, "18": 0.0164, "19": 0.018, "20": 0.0215, "21": 0.0234, "22": 0.0315, "23": 0.0366, "24": 0.046, "25": 0.0448, "26": 0.0428, "27": 0.0644, "28": 0.0559, "29": 0.0578, "30": 0.0572, "31": 0.0442, "32": 0.0507, "33": 0.049, "34": 0.0456, "35": 0.0385, "36": 0.0467, "37": 0.0476, "38": 0.0396, "39": 0.0302, "40": 0.0244, "41": 0.0237, "42": 0.0045, "43": 0.0023, "44": 0.0026, "45": 0.001, "46": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.087248205187551, "median_total_1_10": 7.178564527255606, "q3_total_1_10": 7.265461564260919 }, { "candidate_id": "nora-l-ritok", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0502, "rank_probabilities": { "2": 0.0005, "3": 0.0497, "4": 0.0369, "5": 0.0561, "6": 0.1003, "7": 0.1525, "8": 0.1289, "9": 0.1253, "10": 0.0888, "11": 0.0867, "12": 0.1066, "13": 0.0313, "14": 0.0138, "15": 0.0085, "16": 0.0031, "17": 0.0034, "18": 0.0034, "19": 0.0019, "20": 0.0008, "21": 0.0006, "22": 0.0004, "23": 0.0002, "24": 0.0001, "25": 0.0001, "26": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.682356635027295, "median_total_1_10": 7.750093027422857, "q3_total_1_10": 7.817591487863876 }, { "candidate_id": "pal-sonnevend", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "9": 0.0004, "10": 0.0016, "11": 0.0032, "12": 0.005, "13": 0.0074, "14": 0.0176, "15": 0.0248, "16": 0.0468, "17": 0.0588, "18": 0.0488, "19": 0.0625, "20": 0.0502, "21": 0.0534, "22": 0.0361, "23": 0.0406, "24": 0.0392, "25": 0.0593, "26": 0.0463, "27": 0.0459, "28": 0.038, "29": 0.047, "30": 0.0331, "31": 0.0304, "32": 0.0292, "33": 0.0255, "34": 0.0279, "35": 0.0316, "36": 0.0311, "37": 0.0245, "38": 0.0238, "39": 0.008, "40": 0.002 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.194338359241615, "median_total_1_10": 7.275418334609903, "q3_total_1_10": 7.356250162655799 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-akos-bod", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "9": 0.0002, "10": 0.0003, "11": 0.0011, "12": 0.0024, "13": 0.0162, "14": 0.0506, "15": 0.0444, "16": 0.0665, "17": 0.0831, "18": 0.0927, "19": 0.1335, "20": 0.0946, "21": 0.0828, "22": 0.0584, "23": 0.0541, "24": 0.0479, "25": 0.0466, "26": 0.0328, "27": 0.0243, "28": 0.0156, "29": 0.0186, "30": 0.0103, "31": 0.0114, "32": 0.0053, "33": 0.0027, "34": 0.0019, "35": 0.0007, "36": 0.0006, "37": 0.0003, "39": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.293562048539437, "median_total_1_10": 7.3484209147692425, "q3_total_1_10": 7.40670852803699 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-balazs", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "9": 0.0001, "10": 0.00035, "11": 0.0006, "12": 0.0021, "13": 0.0052, "14": 0.0137, "15": 0.02575, "16": 0.0366, "17": 0.04565, "18": 0.05475, "19": 0.06675, "20": 0.0854, "21": 0.0871, "22": 0.079, "23": 0.07755, "24": 0.0657, "25": 0.05765, "26": 0.055, "27": 0.0485, "28": 0.03955, "29": 0.03005, "30": 0.0234, "31": 0.0214, "32": 0.01915, "33": 0.0154, "34": 0.01335, "35": 0.0113, "36": 0.00755, "37": 0.0054, "38": 0.0039, "39": 0.0016, "40": 0.0005 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.223593586871042, "median_total_1_10": 7.292609462561829, "q3_total_1_10": 7.370453505583999 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-barandy", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "30": 0.0003, "31": 0.0001, "32": 0.0006, "33": 0.0003, "34": 0.0007, "35": 0.0008, "36": 0.0013, "37": 0.001, "38": 0.0008, "39": 0.0011, "40": 0.0021, "41": 0.0053, "42": 0.014, "43": 0.0324, "44": 0.2239, "45": 0.3113, "46": 0.2284, "47": 0.1181, "48": 0.0397, "49": 0.0114, "50": 0.0038, "51": 0.0016, "52": 0.001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.581092596312729, "median_total_1_10": 6.651475702209051, "q3_total_1_10": 6.721750644504038 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-darak", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "19": 0.0001, "20": 0.0002, "21": 0.0001, "22": 0.0009, "23": 0.0022, "24": 0.0026, "25": 0.0051, "26": 0.0063, "27": 0.0041, "28": 0.0064, "29": 0.0055, "30": 0.0112, "31": 0.0193, "32": 0.04, "33": 0.0203, "34": 0.0185, "35": 0.0149, "36": 0.0203, "37": 0.0305, "38": 0.0512, "39": 0.0773, "40": 0.0969, "41": 0.1345, "42": 0.2235, "43": 0.201, "44": 0.0067, "45": 0.0004 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.888502516998945, "median_total_1_10": 6.950810997956596, "q3_total_1_10": 7.013880159839888 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kovacs", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "58": 0.0356, "59": 0.2763, "60": 0.3354, "61": 0.3483, "62": 0.0028, "63": 0.0016 }, "q1_total_1_10": 5.389979219073162, "median_total_1_10": 5.425703864754524, "q3_total_1_10": 5.460817036197213 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-kreko", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "49": 0.0018, "50": 0.0339, "51": 0.2044, "52": 0.1943, "53": 0.1701, "54": 0.3245, "55": 0.0693, "56": 0.0017 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.097447894894843, "median_total_1_10": 6.1841201792923055, "q3_total_1_10": 6.266726223046011 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-nadas", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "11": 0.0001, "12": 0.0003, "13": 0.0006, "14": 0.0009, "15": 0.0027, "16": 0.0189, "17": 0.0285, "18": 0.0336, "19": 0.0387, "20": 0.0314, "21": 0.0305, "22": 0.0384, "23": 0.033, "24": 0.0343, "25": 0.0494, "26": 0.051, "27": 0.049, "28": 0.0449, "29": 0.048, "30": 0.0473, "31": 0.0393, "32": 0.0509, "33": 0.0433, "34": 0.0372, "35": 0.0305, "36": 0.0333, "37": 0.0428, "38": 0.0383, "39": 0.0275, "40": 0.0312, "41": 0.0238, "42": 0.0088, "43": 0.0056, "44": 0.0028, "45": 0.0023, "46": 0.0007, "47": 0.0002 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.074175540850519, "median_total_1_10": 7.192449526558729, "q3_total_1_10": 7.306742512742943 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-paczolay", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.6313, "rank_probabilities": { "2": 0.3056, "3": 0.3257, "4": 0.2249, "5": 0.0726, "6": 0.0303, "7": 0.0211, "8": 0.012, "9": 0.0037, "10": 0.0029, "11": 0.0007, "12": 0.0002, "13": 0.0001, "14": 0.0001, "15": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.935342672459099, "median_total_1_10": 8.0029891826539, "q3_total_1_10": 8.067506487648826 }, { "candidate_id": "peter-rona", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "30": 0.0001, "31": 0.0003, "32": 0.0012, "33": 0.0071, "34": 0.0104, "35": 0.0142, "36": 0.0097, "37": 0.0199, "38": 0.0427, "39": 0.0992, "40": 0.2196, "41": 0.2316, "42": 0.1908, "43": 0.1516, "44": 0.0016 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.9017082615558465, "median_total_1_10": 6.949505785315551, "q3_total_1_10": 6.998478088855384 }, { "candidate_id": "robert-alfoldi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "51": 0.0001, "52": 0.0019, "53": 0.0146, "54": 0.0413, "55": 0.1511, "56": 0.6865, "57": 0.0993, "58": 0.0051, "59": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 5.925570371732713, "median_total_1_10": 6.006420228861845, "q3_total_1_10": 6.086268669032302 }, { "candidate_id": "szilveszter-e-vizi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "15": 0.0001, "16": 0.0006, "17": 0.0033, "18": 0.0029, "19": 0.0064, "20": 0.01, "21": 0.0119, "22": 0.0287, "23": 0.0284, "24": 0.0497, "25": 0.0533, "26": 0.0506, "27": 0.0609, "28": 0.0572, "29": 0.0688, "30": 0.0753, "31": 0.0677, "32": 0.075, "33": 0.0688, "34": 0.062, "35": 0.0606, "36": 0.0586, "37": 0.0331, "38": 0.0286, "39": 0.0166, "40": 0.0114, "41": 0.0053, "42": 0.0023, "43": 0.0016, "44": 0.0003 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.107716278946311, "median_total_1_10": 7.174427185508495, "q3_total_1_10": 7.243089384145565 }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-freund", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "45": 0.0002, "46": 0.0011, "47": 0.0038, "48": 0.0137, "49": 0.0618, "50": 0.1448, "51": 0.1779, "52": 0.1481, "53": 0.1614, "54": 0.1224, "55": 0.1219, "56": 0.0429 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.121254913907499, "median_total_1_10": 6.209867036612025, "q3_total_1_10": 6.305732971915445 }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-sulyok", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "58": 0.0062, "59": 0.028, "60": 0.4908, "61": 0.4746, "62": 0.0003, "63": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 5.324757049582376, "median_total_1_10": 5.3992523777708294, "q3_total_1_10": 5.476099333682987 }, { "candidate_id": "tamas-vicsek", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "21": 0.0003, "22": 0.0007, "23": 0.0016, "24": 0.0017, "25": 0.0072, "26": 0.0162, "27": 0.0195, "28": 0.0384, "29": 0.0466, "30": 0.0513, "31": 0.0893, "32": 0.0901, "33": 0.1334, "34": 0.1222, "35": 0.13, "36": 0.1192, "37": 0.0688, "38": 0.0391, "39": 0.0164, "40": 0.0052, "41": 0.0021, "42": 0.0007 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.0614108395023765, "median_total_1_10": 7.127404258641864, "q3_total_1_10": 7.189605236126182 }, { "candidate_id": "tibor-navracsics", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "52": 0.0001, "54": 0.0001, "55": 0.001, "56": 0.0021, "57": 0.0061, "58": 0.2012, "59": 0.4657, "60": 0.1545, "61": 0.1692 }, "q1_total_1_10": 5.379428802773589, "median_total_1_10": 5.505222784924439, "q3_total_1_10": 5.634180630878392 }, { "candidate_id": "tunde-hando", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "66": 1.0 }, "q1_total_1_10": 2.9808318380620333, "median_total_1_10": 3.0738981683329074, "q3_total_1_10": 3.1780318657843587 }, { "candidate_id": "vanda-lamm", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "6": 0.002, "7": 0.0547, "8": 0.1619, "9": 0.1422, "10": 0.1565, "11": 0.2317, "12": 0.2117, "13": 0.0375, "14": 0.0012, "15": 0.0004, "16": 0.0001, "17": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.66682045983038, "median_total_1_10": 7.702988756849102, "q3_total_1_10": 7.73688098241694 }, { "candidate_id": "zoltan-fleck", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "47": 0.0004, "48": 0.0019, "49": 0.0379, "50": 0.1493, "51": 0.0927, "52": 0.0969, "53": 0.0883, "54": 0.1026, "55": 0.2867, "56": 0.0927, "57": 0.046, "58": 0.003, "59": 0.0016 }, "q1_total_1_10": 6.051305225067707, "median_total_1_10": 6.154648035441062, "q3_total_1_10": 6.257233262105212 }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-enyedi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "11": 0.0002, "12": 0.0016, "13": 0.0047, "14": 0.0199, "15": 0.1845, "16": 0.1852, "17": 0.1782, "18": 0.099, "19": 0.0769, "20": 0.0533, "21": 0.0549, "22": 0.0461, "23": 0.0359, "24": 0.0306, "25": 0.0115, "26": 0.0078, "27": 0.0034, "28": 0.0026, "29": 0.0013, "30": 0.0019, "31": 0.0004, "32": 0.0001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.34650001030525, "median_total_1_10": 7.405386025909219, "q3_total_1_10": 7.460726955409021 }, { "candidate_id": "zsolt-hernadi", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "65": 1.0 }, "q1_total_1_10": 4.049253440988269, "median_total_1_10": 4.166321744840182, "q3_total_1_10": 4.292755677642004 }, { "candidate_id": "zsuzsanna-jakab", "top_probability": 0.0, "top3_probability": 0.0, "rank_probabilities": { "4": 0.0025, "5": 0.0247, "6": 0.0531, "7": 0.0706, "8": 0.1737, "9": 0.1453, "10": 0.1555, "11": 0.1349, "12": 0.1638, "13": 0.0589, "14": 0.0141, "15": 0.0019, "16": 0.001 }, "q1_total_1_10": 7.662457807663033, "median_total_1_10": 7.71626850911567, "q3_total_1_10": 7.773593386713603 } ] }, "reproduction": { "algorithm": "parent v5 sealed packets minus one non-anchor candidate -> unchanged common-anchor linkage -> deterministic reaggregation", "aggregation_hash_first": "sha256:5ef06f6074518c04bbdb536c941095453b76682667848d8db80aeea97d7321e6", "aggregation_hash_recomputed": "sha256:5ef06f6074518c04bbdb536c941095453b76682667848d8db80aeea97d7321e6", "match": true, "no_resampling": true }, "release_hash": "sha256:fedc10b1c6f52ef4c95378d8814c79ec98c0fdd4d4cf1c0663ef98306bc2b941" }